|
Part IV Should Anyone Be Blamed For The Aberfan Disaster? (cont.) Section A — History 5. The Events of 1958-1963 109. As we have already observed (ante paragraphs 35-41) for about 40 years there have been well-founded complaints of flooding at Aberfan. These complaints became more frequent and vociferous after Tip 7 was begun and, being addressed to the Merthyr Tydfil Borough Council, led to its setting-up in 1959 of a sub-committee to deal with complaints regarding the Aberfan tip complex. Whilst there can be no doubt that, as we have said, it was the flooding problem which inspired such complaints, the manner in which the residents of Aberfan advanced their criticisms and the language in which they were expressed cannot be ignored in considering the question of whether the National Coal Board (and others) ought not to have become alerted into instituting an investigation of the state of affairs on Merthyr Mountain a long time before the disaster. 110. As early as July 29th, 1959, the Merthyr Tydfil Town Clerk wrote to Mr. Stiles, the Board's Area Estates Manager, regarding the "reference made to the potential danger of the above tip at Aberfan" and seeking a meeting. On October 30th, the Merthyr Vale Ward Labour Party informed the Town Clerk that "further grave concern was unanimously expressed at the continued inaction and almost contemptuous disregard by the National Coal Board of the representations made by your Council re matters concerned with the safety and health of the residents of this Ward. We were instructed to draw your attention to:
On November 25th, 1959, these complaints were transmitted by the Town Clerk to the National Coal Board and a meeting requested, but no reply seems to have been sent. On June 17th, 1960, the Town Clerk wrote to Mr. Stiles that a deputation: ". . . wish to discuss with you the potential danger of the above Tip. Concern has been expressed that the Tip could slide after heavy rainfall," and on June 20th the Sub-Committee met Mr. Baker, Mr. Stiles and Mr. Roberts of the National Coal Board. At that meeting, held in Merthyr, the discussion was about the Aberfan tip complex as a whole and it was minuted thus: "The Council side expressed the concern that had been expressed of the potential danger of slipping the Tip after heavy rainfall and that hot clinkers were being tipped by the Board without having previously been sprayed with water. The National Coal Board representatives stated that the Board had tried to move the Tip using a bulldozer but this had been abandoned because of the danger from fire. The Board did not agree that there was a potential danger of the Tip slipping and it was pointed out to the Council side that the Tip which was burning was not being tipped upon. The National Coal Board's representatives agreed however to discuss the problem with a view to seeing what could be done about the burning tip, and what needs to be done with the tip as a whole with regard to the question of it slipping. They would also investigate the position with regard to the spraying of the hot clinkers. They undertook to write to the Council further in the matter." 111. Fears of a tip-slide were thus being expressed as early as July, 1960 and the National Coal Board representatives were contending they were groundless. But Mr. Baker now thinks that no worthwhile view could have been expressed on the matter by Board officials "without a most detailed investigation taking place". The promised investigation never materialised and the promised letter was never sent by the Board. But the next day Mr. Baker told the colliery mechanic "that the Council were very much concerned about the tip slipping" and, despite the fact that he "did not think they (the Merthyr Tydfil authorities) were making a nuisance of themselves by any means", he nevertheless limited his activities to putting a few pegs in the mountainside. Apart from that, no-one appears to have said or done anything to assuage the fears which had been expressed. On the other hand, it is right to point out that, while many letters passed between the National Coal Board and the Merthyr Tydfil Council during the remainder of 1960 and a few during 1961 and 1962, they were all restricted to discussing the flooding problem and they contain no reference to fears of a tip-slide. Indeed, when the National Coal Board and Council Officials met on February 6th, 1962, it was simply in relation to flooding. That was, in another respect, an important month, being that in which Tailings were first produced. These constituted in some respects an important (certainly a time-consuming) aspect of our investigation and we now turn to consider them.
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||