7. Hours Of Work Below Ground.
Though no direct evidence as to the hours of work below ground was taken, there was a considerable amount of incidental evidence that men were allowed to work and did work longer hours than are permitted by the Coal Mines Regulation Act, 1908 — generally known as the Eight Hours Act — as amended by later Acts. In fact, the provisions of that Act were, to all intents and purposes, ignored.
On 24th May, 1933, a complaint of the working of overtime in the North Wales Collieries was received by the Secretary for Mines from the North Wales Miners' Association; the complaint was general and no individual colliery was mentioned.
On 25th May, Mr. Charlton was notified of this complaint and he had it investigated by Mr. Dominy.
When forwarding to the Mines Department Mr. Dominy's report, together with his and Mr. Boydell's comments, Mr. Charlton said that it might be that all the overtime worked was not entered in the Register" and in this connection Mr. Boydell saw the Miners' Secretary (acting) to try to get from him specific instances of overtime. This, however, could not be produced".
During the course of his investigations, Mr. Dominy visited Gresford Colliery on i6th June, 1933, and from the Register kept under the Act took particulars of cases of men who had worked overtime.
He assumed the Register to have been properly kept and did not ask the Manager if any overtime was worked other than that shown by the Register. He, therefore, did not discover that it was the practice for men who had worked the morning or the afternoon shift on a Friday to work also the night-shift on that day each week.
The Manager, in his evidence on this matter, said he knew this practice was a breach of the Act but "many of the men liked it and they asked for it".
I have no doubt that this is correct and years ago, within my own experience, it was usual to work on Friday nights, in order to avoid working on Saturday afternoons.
Men are reluctant to work on Saturday afternoon and yet they wish to earn the wages for six shifts a week if possible. That this is so was shown by an answer by one of the witnesses called by the North Wales Miners' Association when he was asked by me — "What shift do you work on?" and he replied :— "I worked on days and afternoons", and "I have been in on night-shift to get my six in, when I have been on afternoons". The fact was that it was a common, if not a standing, practice to work double shifts and it would seem that there was at least some tacit arrangement between the management and the workmen or their representatives.
It does not, of course, excuse breaches of the law to say that the men were willing to work overtime. But, in such a case, it does not lie with those representing the men to blame only the Management and the Inspectors. And yet in these circumstances and despite the fact that Mr. Boydell's specific request for information had proved fruitless, there was at the Inquiry vehement complaint against Mr. Dominy by the North Wales Miners' Association because he did not find out that such a practice existed.
The question of preventing the working of illegal overtime is one within the power of the men themselves and their Trade Unions and I regret the increasing extent to which, of recent years, it has taken up the time of H.M. Inspectors and encroached on their proper duties of attending to matters directly concerned with health and safety.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.