8. Workmen.
In the sections of this Report dealing with shotfiring and hours of work below ground, I have mentioned certain continuing offences against the law to which, as I consider, numbers of the workmen were parties; and in general it was a distressing feature of the Inquiry that there were so many workmen who, according to their evidence, knew of and were alarmed at conditions which they considered dangerous and yet took no steps to secure for themselves or their fellow workers the protection to which they thought they were entitled.
A few protests, it was said, were made during Mr. Shaw's time, but those ceased with Mr. Dominy's advent and for the reason suggested by Counsel that the workmen considered Mr. Dominy incompetent and inattentive. If that were, indeed, the reason why no complaint was made, it was a deplorable state of things, not incomparable to that in which law-breaking should be allowed to flourish because citizens, whether rightly or wrongly, had lost confidence in some one officer of the Police and had resigned themselves to endure it rather than appeal to his superior officers or make some other effort to help themselves.
The law for the protection of the citizens is largely dependent for its efficacy on their wish and determination to be protected. Those who are mis-used or know of others mis-used take — and indeed have a duty to take — some measures which will invoke the protection of the law by informing and assisting the Police or other executive authority, and if the individual fears to take such measures himself, he can get them taken by some protection association or trade union, or through Parliamentary or other elected representatives.
It was common ground at the Inquiry that for a period of some two years before the explosion no such measures were ever taken by any of the very large number of workers employed at the Colliery. The reasons for this, suggested by Counsel, were that, while "it is technically true to some extent that each man is responsible for not working in unsafe conditions himself," practically speaking, the individual was impotent because of the fear of victimisation in a set of economic and other circumstances which would completely ruin him. I have no doubt that this fear does exist among miners, and it is not the less potent for ill whether it is groundless or well founded, a matter upon which, in this case, I am not in a position to express any opinion.
In the same general connexion it is, I think, of importance that a large proportion of the persons employed at the Colliery were not effective members of the North Wales Mineworkers' Union. That was advanced as a reason why the Union was inactive, and no doubt it was a reason why no inspection of the mine on behalf of the workers had been made for many years, but I fail to appreciate why the Union, with such powerful aid as was ready to hand, should not have been able to act on any information given to it by such members as it had at the Colliery.
However that may be, I hope that I am not exceeding my function in saying now what I have held for many years that miners should be members of some effective trades union. That opinion is based on grounds of safety, with which alone I am concerned, for I believe that a well organised trades union, wisely directed, can be as potent an influence for promoting greater safety in mines as it is already in matters, for example, of wages and conditions of employment.
Lest it might be supposed from what I have said that H.M. Inspectors pay attention only to complaints made through a trades union, I mention here that unsigned complaints are attended to as if they were signed. That fact appeared to come as a surprise to many at the Inquiry, but it has been stated publicly over and over again, and to my personal knowledge has been a standing Instruction to the Inspectors for over 35 years.
It was stated during the Inquiry by many witnesses that they did not know the name and address of the Inspector. That may have been so, but such a statement shows the very small amount of interest which was really taken in the matter by those witnesses and may indicate that they were not, at the time, greatly in earnest in seeking a safe channel for their complaints. At every mine, of course, the name and address of the Inspector in charge of the Division are printed on the copies of the Abstract of the Act and the Regulations which are posted up for all and sundry to see.
The information might well be given more prominence, say, by painting it in bold characters on a separate board, then to be set up in a position where the persons employed could not fail to see it.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.