|
4. Return Airways.Examination and Reports. — The Manager said that the dayshift deputy in each district was appointed to examine the airways at least one a week in accordance with the requirement of Section 66 (d) of the Coal Mines Act, 1911. Of some of these examinations, the reports required by the Section to be made were not made. This omission the Manager said was due to the fact that the deputies concerned examined the particular airways daily and the result of those examinations was included in the reports made daily. This explanation is not valid for all the airways, for example 14's and 29's, and in any case the reports should have been made in the appropriate* book. Condition. — The size of the return airways generally was at the date of the explosion, according to the evidence, greater than it had been for some time. 109's return had been repaired throughout; 14's new return was completed a week before the explosion occurred, and 29's had been repaired as far as the bottom of the drift through the 75 feet fault at the inbye end of the Main Martin Return. But all the return air from 109's, 95's and 14's and 29's had to pass up this drift which, at one part where there were three ladders, was only, according to one witness, 4 feet by 4 feet and, according to another, 5 feet wide by 3 feet high — a very small area for a main return airway. At an earlier date, namely, after the fall on 14's face, on 24th May, this return airway was also of small area where it passed through 14's district, the size then being, according to the evidence of the afternoon-shift deputy, Harold Amos, about 3 feet high by 4 or 5 feet wide. Immediately before the fall on 14's face at the beginning of September, this part of this airway became even smaller, it being then necessary, according to the evidence of Joseph Owens, repairer, to travel a part of it on hands and knees. That this part at that time was very small is shown by the fact that, in order to keep the air on the face, it was necessary to have three cloths and a door across the "old timber road." The new return from 14's district, as previously stated, was completed a week before the explosion occurred. No. 4 North return airway served 20's and 61's districts and Richard Owen, day shift deputy in 20's district, said that on 14th September he travelled it from the workings to the Martin Shaft and back again the same way, and he found during that examination the smallest place to be four feet six inches high and four feet six inches wide. A new connection from 20's workings to the return had been completed three days before the explosion occurred. Josiah Thomas Jones, day shift deputy in 61's district, said he accompanied Richard Owen through this return airway in July and the lowest place then would be four feet six inches to five feet and the narrowest about the same. He did not take particular notice of the width but he knew he could walk all the way comfortably. The airway was pretty well settled for a long, long way. Owen said the distance from the workings to the Martin Shaft would be about 1,400 yards and to travel forth and back would take him an hour and a half or thereabouts. The distance measured on the plan is 1,650 yards each way, and, as 25 minutes per mile is considered to be a good pace underground, I think the time taken by Owen was reasonable and does not point to the airway being in bad condition. There was also evidence in reference to this airway by John Charles Williams, Captain of the Llay Main Colliery, No. 1 Rescue Teams who, with three other rescue men, entered it by way of two doors from the Main Dennis Intake on the day of the explosion, with instructions, according to Williams' evidence, "to ascertain the conditions prevailing in the airway". Williams said he took the lead, and the distance between each man would be approximately 20 yards. The airway to start with would be six feet high and about five or six feet wide; some 120 yards or more further along, it decreased to about three feet high by three feet wide; about 200 yards along it was four feet by four feet and then further on it became so small that it was impossible to get along it. He was on his hands and knees and the road would be "about three feet by three feet, or less. There was not room for me to turn round and get out with the apparatus on. I had to come out backwards...". He did not think the airway was in a condition in which men could travel it with ease and comfort and he did not think the explosion had damaged it. Some eight months later, on 20th May, 1935, Mr. Benson, H.M. Inspector of Mines, took the width and height of this airway at 15 feet intervals for a distance of 690 feet measured from the "Back Dennis". These measurements showed the least width at that time in that length to be four feet six inches which was at a point 625 feet from the" Back Dennis", and the least height two feet two inches at a point 662 feet from the "Back Dennis". At this point, according to Mr. Benson's evidence, water was oozing from the floor. At the point where the least width was measured, the height was measured to be four feet three inches and at the point where the least height was measured the width was measured to be five feet three inches. There was nothing corresponding to the three feet by three feet mentioned by Williams as being the width and height some 120 yards from the doors. Mr. Benson had previously on 9th May made measurements over a length of 600 feet from the "Back Dennis". His measurement at 200 feet on that date was — three feet ten inches high by five feet wide; on the 20th May he did not take a measurement at this point because the roof had all broken down in the interval. At 300 feet, on 9th May, he had measured the height to be four feet three inches and the width six feet five inches: on 20th May he did not take a measurement at the same place because there had been a fall of roof in the interval. In view of the length of time — eight months — which elapsed between the date of the explosion and the date on which Mr. Benson took measurements and of the fact that water had had access to the airway owing to the pump in the shaft lodgement having been idle during that interval, I am surprised that the airway had not closed even more than it did. I saw this part of this airway for myself and noticed the effect of the water; the floor had heaved and was "drummy". I believe the evidence of Richard Owen to be the truth. There is nothing in the Coal Mines Act, 1911, requiring airways to be of any particular size or of not less than any particular size. Proposals have been made that there should be such a requirement; I think there should, though there are difficulties in connection with it, such as the minimum becoming in practice the maximum. Several witnesses during the Inquiry expressed the opinion that it would be well if the men in each district of a mine were required to travel the second means of egress from those districts from time to time. That is a course which has been recommended on many occasions and has been advocated by witnesses appearing before the Royal Commission on Mines now sitting. * M. & Q. Form No. 46.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||