Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

3. Ventilation (cont.).

(g) Ventilation of 29's District. — Apparently 29's district was ventilated by the return air from 109's, 95's and 14's districts but really by that return air together with an unknown quantity which left 142's Deep at 29's Turn and leaked past the three doors placed across 29's haulage road — see Plan 1.

This leakage must have been considerable — one witness referred to it as a split — but its actual amount was not known. Attempts were made during the Inquiry to estimate its value, the results varying from 8,000 to 18,000 cubic feet per minute. The 18,000 was clearly wrong but 8,000 to 10,000 may have been somewhere near the correct figure; calculations are of little value because of the unreliability of the air measurement records.

It was no doubt due to this large leakage of air into 29's district that the witnesses called were able to say that the ventilation in 29's was good or very good and that they had been little troubled with gas. But this adventitious aid to the ventilation of 29's was at the expense of the ventilation of the inbye districts of the mine which was dependent upon the condition of the three doors in 29's haulage road and the steps taken to see that they were not all open at the same time. Their condition was said by David Jones, night shift deputy, to be good, but even when they were closed the air could be heard whistling through.

The Under-manager said that a boy was stationed at the middle door and Harold Platt, who had charge of that door on the afternoon shift of 21st September, explained that attending to the door was his only job and that when he was sent to it he was told to open the door between for the journey to come through, and close it straight away when it went past" and that he never neglected to do that. When he opened the door a lot of wind rushed through.

The Under-manager said the three doors would not all be open at the same time but two of them might, and men who worked in the district said they could feel the variation in the ventilation when the doors were opened.

Whilst the Manager agreed that there would be a considerable scaling of air through these doors, he did not seem to have realised its importance. Two of the deputies — one Harold Thomas in 14's district and the other Sam Matthias in 109's district — on the contrary had done so, as the following examination of Herbert Thomas and David Jones, day shift and night shift deputies respectively in 29's district, shows :—

Herbert Thomas examined by Mr. Charlton:

Q. Have you had the firemen in the other districts ask you if they cannot keep the doors in a bit better condition to get some more air?

A. Well, they may have done. It is not a regular thing, but that brother of mine has been bullying me now and again.

Q. I just wondered.

A. Just casual. Nothing definitely.

Q. We had your namesake, Mr. Thomas, sitting there. Has he complained to you sometimes you might manage — ?

A. Not complained, but a vigorous speech more or less: "You want to see them doors closed". Something like that.

Q. Is the Mr. Thomas we had before your brother?

A. Yes. Sir.

Q. He would soon let you know if he was in trouble?

A. He would that.

Q. And I take it he did let you know?

A. Yes.

Q. How long is it since he ragged you about those doors?

A. I could not say, Sir. It was not a general thing with him.

Q. Has the fireman of 109's ever complained to you?

A. No, I do not think he has, Sir.

Q. You know. Has he or has he not?

A. No. he has not, Sir.

David Jones examined by Mr. Charlton :—

Q. Of course, I suppose on the Friday nights and the Sunday nights when you were coaling in 29's the doors would be opened a great deal more frequently than on an ordinary night?

A. Yes, Sir.

Q. On this particular Friday night, you had a fair amount of coal coming out?

A. Well, at the commencing of the shift there was very little.

Q. At the what?

A. There was none at the commencement of the shift until about 11 o'clock.

Q. Then did it begin to get a bit busy about 11 o'clock?

A. Yes, it commenced then.

Q. And you would be keeping pretty busy until the time you heard the noise?

A. Yes.

(It should be explained here that David Jones when in 29's district heard the sound of the explosion, "the noise" in the question above.)

Q. So that I take it during that period there would be quite a considerable amount of traffic through these doors?

A. Yes.

Q. And that would not take place on a Wednesday or a Thursday night?

A. No. Sir.

Q. It takes place on a Friday night. Have you heard any complaint from the firemen of 14's or 109's that you were getting more than your share of the air?

A. No, Sir, only once I was asked by Sam Matthias to make sure that no door was open there or left.

Q. How long ago will that be?

A. That will be just about June, I expect.

Q. Just after you had started?

A. Yes.

Q. Did you try to do what he requested you to do?

A. Yes, Sir.

In the quotation from the evidence of David Jones just given the answer to the first question is of first importance, especially in view of the answers given by the Under-manager to the following questions put to him by Sir Stafford Cripps —

Q. Did you notice when you were in 109's and 14's or 95's that the amount of ventilation varied considerably according to the amount of haulage that was going on out of 29's?

A. No, I cannot say that I did.

Q. You would expect it to be so, would you not?

A. It is possible that there was a little difference, but I have not noticed. It is quite possible when those doors were opened at 29's.

Q. They might make a very considerable difference?

A. It is possible they would.

Q. And the busier they were in 29's, the more likely it would be to make a difference?

A. Unless they were careful to keep the doors closed.

Q. I suppose in every mine people are sometimes not as careful as they might be in shutting doors every time they go through?

A. We generally teach them to be careful.

Q. On the Friday night of the explosion they were in fact, very busy in 29's?

A. They were coal getting in 29's.

Q. They had more men in there than had ever been in there before. I think?

A. From 29's and 20's all the coal was coming through.

Q. Can you answer me the question whether they had more men in 29's than they had ever had previously?

A. I believe that is so, in my time.

The Under-manager said he had only known gas to be reported in 29's district on one occasion, namely, on 10th September, but, in fact, it was reported on 10th May and on eight subsequent occasions, the last being on 17th June.

Comparing 29's district with 14's, having regard to the fact that the output from 14's was greater than that from 29's and that the ventilation available for 14's was much less in quantity than that available for 29's, it is remarkable to find that gas was reported between April and the date of the explosion only four times in 14's, whereas in 29's it was reported 10 times.

General remarks on ventilation. — Apart from the verbal evidence, examination of the ventilation plan shows:

(1) That No. 4 North District (20's and 61's) got first pull at the ventilation and as it was being coursed in that district on natural lines it was unlikely that any great difficulty would be experienced.

(2) That 109's district was in a somewhat similar position though, in view of the faulted ground in the middle of the district and the bend in the return airway, not so favourable.

(3) That there was no outlet at the rise end of the left side of 95's district.

(4) That the faces of 14's district and of 29's district were going to the rise, and

(5) That the same split of air was being coursed round 95's, 14's and 29's districts and at the return end in 14's and 29's had, in each case, to come a considerable distance downhill.

(6)* That between the point M.1 and the points M.3 and 4 there were likely to be substantial losses of air by leakage — notably into the haulage road from 29's district, this explaining why the ventilation of 29's district was not so bad as, on primary considerations, it should have been.

Because of these leakages and of the prior pull on the air taken by the No. 4 North district there could have been only a comparatively small quantity of air for the ventilation of 109's, 95's and 14's districts, and keeping in mind the lie of these districts, it was to be expected that 109's district would get more of that small quantity than 95's and 14's and less trouble be encountered in that district than in the other two.

In view of the small quantity of air passing M.4 and in consideration of the depth of the workings from the surface, so small a current would in its passage round the workings become very heated and its being hot would add greatly to the difficulty of ventilating workings going to the rise, such as 24's place in 95's district and the whole of 14's face.

For the reason why the scheme of ventilation in the Dennis Section had got into such a position, it is necessary to go back 12 to 15 years to the time when the three main roads — the Dennis Main and the roads parallel to and on either side of it — met the downthrow fault to the North East of the "Clutch".

Apparently it had been the intention to maintain these three parallel roads and, after workings had been opened out, on the dip side of the fault, it was still intended to maintain return airways on either side of 142's Deep. But when a further fault was met — this time an upthrow — only the return on the South side of 142's Deep was put through it. That on the North side was abandoned, and no proper consideration was then given to the problem of ventilating any subsequent workings beyond that upthrow fault.

But even if a return parallel to and on the North side of 142's Deep had been maintained, the method of working 29's district, involving the use of doors across the haulage road into that district would still have resulted in considerable leakage of air at 29's Turn. This difficulty was the result of the failure to drive the Dennis Main road and the roads on either side of it through the downthrow fault North East of the "Clutch", and this failure was the initial cause of the unsatisfactory scheme of ventilation existing at the time of the explosion.

Had these three roads been driven through that fault and the seam then developed to the East and North East, there would have been no difficulty in providing separate splits of ventilation for each district.

It is evident that the mistake of not maintaining the return airway on the North side of 142's Deep had been recognised, for an attempt had been made, though in a desultory fashion, to reopen that airway to the rise and to the dip of 61's main road.

The Manager said the place to the rise (37's) had at the time of the explosion been stopped for nine months but the Undermanager said it was stopped towards the end of May; the place to the dip had reached, and was standing at, the upthrow fault.

The date when 37's was stopped is significant.

The Under-manager started at the colliery towards the end of January, 1934. He saw where the main difficulty lay but was confronted with one more pressing for the moment, namely, the ventilation of the left side of 95's district, and to effect that a drift (105's) was being driven to the dip from 81's road to hole into 24's.

Unfortunately, towards the end of May, the fall which occurred and cut off 47 yards of 14's face created another difficulty, and it was then that the men were taken away from 37's and put to get coal in 95's district.

The position at the time of the explosion was that the bigger scheme had been held up due to the dead work necessary after the fall in 14's face, and, even at that time, due to a lack of vigour in pressing on with 105's drift and the scouring in 14's district, the lesser remedial measures had not been completed.

Whether this lack of vigour was due merely to dilatoriness or to lack of funds, it is not possible to say, but on this point the Manager, in evidence, in answer to Mr. A. T. Miller, said that in the matter of moneys required by him for upkeep and maintenance, there had been no stint whatever and there was no foundation for the suggestion that he was working under undue pressure to produce output.

Be that as it may, work was being carried on in face of excessive leakage of ventilation but, so long as the lie of the workings allowed such air as was available to take a natural course, the workings were kept clear of gas. As soon as an attempt was made to course heated air downhill, however., then trouble began and, in addition to that natural difficulty, there came the falls on 14's face.

So long as 14's face abutted on the return, the ventilation, which in the deeper workings of the mine was most probably due to natural causes alone, was sufficient to carry away the gas but, so soon as the air on that face had to be brought downhill, difficulty arose and, when after the fall on 24th May, the return air had to be brought right away back ‘to within a few yards of the intake, the position became so precarious that drastic remedies were needed and should have been taken.

Work on 14's face should have been stopped altogether until a return aircourse, far removed from the intake, was made.

Work on 95's and 24's faces should have been stopped until the place (105's) being driven to the dip from 81's level had holed, and, in order to get more air into the inbye districts, 29's district should also have been stopped and the leakage of air direct into the return by way of 29's Turn prevented.

These seem drastic remedies but even had they been taken, there would still have remained the initial error, and, until it was repaired, the position would not have been entirely satisfactory.

I think the Under-manager realised the predicament into which he had stepped and that he knew the remedy.

The Manager, on the other hand, appears, if his evidence about ventilation meant anything at all, to have been quite satisfied, as is shown by the following examination of him by Mr. A. T. Miller on the general ventilation of the Dennis Section of the mine :—

Q. Was there anything in the conditions in the Dennis to suggest that there was any trouble with the ventilation?

A. No, nothing whatever.

Q. And the last figures show an improving state of affairs during 1934?

A. Yes.

The figures to which reference was being made were those representing the total quantity of air in the intakes in January to be 127,928, and in July 118,973 cubic feet per minute, that in the Dennis intake in January was 35,353 and in July 43,103 cubic feet per minute.

It was unfortunate, of course, that "the last figures" — those for July — were, to the Manager's knowledge, fictitious, but even when they are substituted by those for June, the answer given by the Manager was merely misleading for, although the quantity of air, according to the figures, in the Dennis intake had increased from 35,353 cubic feet per minute in January to 43,065 in June, the proportion of those quantities which arrived at the place where the first split was taken off was, again according to the figures, 90 per cent. in January and only 51 per cent. in June.

As I have already said I can place no real reliance on these figures but it was on them that the Manager said an improving state of affairs was shown, whereas they showed exactly the contrary.

In any case, no one can say whether the ventilation of a mine is adequate by reference to the quantity of air in each split and the quantities passing along the different faces, and in fact such measurements give no indication of the adequacy of the ventilation as defined in Section 29 of the Coal Mines Act, 1911. It is true that Section 29 requires certain air measurements to be taken monthly, but to no defined purpose or obligation on the part of either the management or the Inspectors. The Section judges ventilation entirely by results, that is to say, by the quality of the air. The ventilation must be adequate at all times in the ordinary course of working "to dilute and render harmless inflammable and noxious gases"; but, that condition satisfied, the present law does not concern itself with any question whether the system and method of ventilation are workmanlike and efficient or, indeed, whether there is any method or any system at all.

It leaves the adequacy of ventilation to be judged solely by the quality of the air and this has to be determined by tests made with a flame safety lamp and by analyses of samples.

The question of instituting a regular check on the frequent tests made with a flame safety lamp by the officials by requiring the taking of air samples in the faces at stated intervals by the managements of all collieries and the posting of the results where the workers may see them, is one which has been raised by witnesses before the Royal Commission now sitting.

To return to the ventilation of the Dennis Section, the initial errors indicated were made years before the explosion and at a time when there was an agent in authority, but the Manager, satisfied as he professed to be with the ventilation, yet described himself as mystified by the leakages of air and as unable to find where they were taking place, notwithstanding that the air could be heard whistling through the doors in 29's haulage road. It would seem that he was not really attending to the matter at all, and, as he said, had latterly devoted most of his time to the Slant district. The Under-manager would thus appear to have been left to solve the difficulties of ventilating the Dennis Section — difficulties which, as has been indicated, could only be solved satisfactorily, in my opinion, by stopping work in 95's, 14's and 29's districts. That would have been a drastic remedy for a new Under-manager to suggest, and Mr. Williams did not suggest it.

Brushing or Wafting out Gas. — General Regulation No. 11 of the General Regulations reads :— "No person shall brush or waft out gas".

It was indicated by questions put to witnesses by Counsel for the North Wales Miners' Association that to use compressed air to dilute gas constituted "brushing or wafting out gas". I do not think it does.

The word waft was used in its proper sense in my opinion by several witnesses during the Inquiry; for example, by David Jones, the night-shift deputy in 29's district, in giving an account of the escape of himself and others after the explosion when he said :— "Fisher, Tom Fisher, said: ‘ Let us take the chance, lads. If we fail, we have tried.' Then he went in front wafting his shirt"; by John Edward Samuel, speaking of the same episode, when he said:—" We kept wafting these bits of rag and our caps and things round our faces." By Walter Pritchard, collier, in 14's district, when asked by Mr. Frowen "Did you notice any effect on the lamp with the gas?", he answered :— No. There was only the waft from the shovels that kept the lamp that was in, in." And by Thomas Maynard, also a collier in 14's district, who was asked by Mr. Henderson "After Thomas had stemmed the hole what did he do?", when he answered :— "He walked away about six yards from the hole, him and two of the strappers, and one stood in front of the hole. I couldn't tell whether it was a piece of brattice or an old shirt, and they were doing like this, wafting the gas away, I suppose."

By "wafting" no fresh air is introduced. When a jet of compressed air is allowed, to blow off in a working, fresh air is introduced.

Particulars of ventilation in Annual Returns. — Counsel for the North Wales Miners' Association when examining Mr. Charlton asked him what his practice was with regard to the Annual Return Forms — rendered for every mine as required by Section 18 of the Coal Mines Act, 1911. Mr. Charlton said that after the receipt of these Returns in his office had been noted and any information he had asked his office staff to extract had been extracted, it was the practice to send them straight to the Mines Department to collate the statistics and that it was a fair assumption that these forms were used there purely for statistical purposes and not for control purposes.

Counsel, as he explained later, had in mind, particularly, the information which used to be collected in these Returns about the number of splits of air and the quantity of air in them; and he criticized strongly what he thought to be the neglect of the Mines Department and the Inspectors to make proper use of these "vital control documents as regards measurements." I regret it was not made plain to Counsel at the time that the particulars required to be furnished in the Annual Return forms now differ greatly from those set out in the First Schedule to the Coal Mines Act, 1911.

Power is given under Section 18 of that Act to alter these particulars. They have been altered and added to from time to time and, over-all, much more information is collected now than the Act of 1911 prescribed, but since 1928 no demand has been made in these returns for particulars of ventilation.

Experience had shown that the few particulars which used to be furnished in regard to ventilation in the Annual Returns were really of no value to H.M. Inspectors as a check on the adequacy of the ventilation of any mine, having regard to their powers under the Act, and no doubt that was the reason why the collection of the information was discontinued.


* The air measurement records, for what they are worth, indicate that almost one-half the air passing M.1 was lost by leakage between that point and M.3 and M.4.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z