|
3. Ventilation (cont.).(e) Ventilation of 95's District. — The ventilating current for this district entered at the point marked M7 on Plan 1 and left by the road which, at its upper end, joined 14's level. Two or three yards on the inbye side of the point M7, according to the evidence of some witnesses and as shown on Plans 1 and 2, the latter being provided for ease in reference, the current was split, one part continuing down 142's Deep whilst the other turned into a road on the left (North-West) known as 24's airway. In view particularly of the fact that shots were fired on 142's Deep (a) close to and (b) immediately above the mouth of 24's airway it is important to consider whether in fact 95's district was ventilated in this way and whether the ventilation was adequate. The evidence on the first point — as on so many others — was contradictory. During the first day of the Inquiry when examining the Manager, Mr. Charlton threw doubt on there being, in fact, any such splitting of the air current. Mr. Bonsall agreed that in order to drive the air along 24's airway a sheet or door, placed across 142's Deep below the entrance to that airway, would be necessary. He said he knew sheets had been there at one time; he could not say whether they were there at the time of the explosion but he assumed, erroneously as will be seen later, that, as the sheets which had been so placed were not shown on the Plan, they had been omitted from the Plan by mistake. On the sixth day of the Inquiry, when examining the Undermanager, Mr. Charlton returned to the same point as follows :— Q. Will you cast your mind back to Mr. Bonsall's evidence about that 95's face? You were in Court all the time. He said it would be difficult to get the air to 95's face, and it would be necessary to put sheets on 142's to force it that way. You heard that? A. I have heard it, but I have not found it necessary to do it. Q. You have found that the air — ? A. Gravitates. Q. I am putting it to you, you know, that it never did anything of the sort? A. Well, Sir, I am also going to state that when a brattice cloth was put there it was worse. It was no good. Q. Of course it was worse. I can imagine it would be worse, because I am going to put it to you that that face was ventilated entirely by natural ventilation, by self-current, that the air as a fact went down on the straight, passed the entrance of 24's and that it went to the left there and split itself there and went to 95's and up 95's face? A. I cannot agree with that. Q. I will be a most astonished man if I do not find evidence from somebody that that happened, and I do not see what else could happen. And if you put a sheet on the straight you would of course interfere with that self-ventilation, and I can well imagine it. I put it to you it is just what you would expect if you put a sheet there. You would interfere with the natural ventilation, and you found by experience that it did do so, and you took the sheet away. That is what I put to you, Mr. Williams. You do not agree? A. I don't, Sir. The Under-manager said that he was last in 95's district prior to the explosion on 17th September, and that on that visit,. accompanied by the fireman, he went into 95's face — the longwall face to the left of 142's Deep — by way of 95's road — the road next below 24's airway — and that when he was travelling up 95's face the air was coming to meet him. He agreed that if the air was circulating in the reverse direction, it would have a dangerous effect but, he added, "we have not got that." The day shift deputy, Norman Parry, said he was positive the air circulated as shown on the plan, that is, it was split? part going into 24's airway and part straight down 142's Deep; there had been a sheet across 142's Deep at one time but it got torn off "a good while ago" and he found the ventilation was better with it off than on. He said it was "a lot" cooler in 142's Deep than in 95's face and that 24's heading was the hottest place in the district. He had fired one shot in 95's face a few months before the explosion from a position on 95's road and the smoke from that shot came straight down the face towards him. The afternoon shift deputy, Robert Thomas Edwards, was not asked which way the air circulated in the district but a repairer and spare deputy, Edward William Williams, who from time to time had taken the place of one of the regular deputies, said there was a little air going into 24's airway, "not a rush, but there was air going through." He said :— "I've been thinking it over many a time myself — how was it going, how was it getting there. But there was air there, and how it was going it is beyond me to explain." Although he was puzzled, he was quite certain the air did travel and "was never nervous about going up there, because I knew there was air there." When he was in the district he travelled from 142's Deep, down 95's road, then up 24's road, through a brattice, and so "I go into this hole then, but I would not go through," that is into 24's airway, which he said was about four feet high and about four or five feet wide. "I just go into this air road, just to feel if there is any air coming through." And he said he did feel air coming through. David Peters, repairer, said that, about three weeks before the explosion, he was sent to clean out 24's airway and at that time the air was going in. Robert Edwards, who with Bert Wynne and Leonard Williams, was repairing in the return airway (147's) leading to 14's level, said they used to have a rest or have their food on the top side of 95's junction because it was cooler there than below it — the inference intended to be drawn being that hot air was coming out of 95's road. But Wynne at first said, as Edwards had done, that when he had his food, or when he had a rest, he went to the top side of 95's because it was a lot cooler "on the top side than below," but later said he had his food in 147's road and that he used to sit at the top side of 95's "for about ten minutes after we came out." Leonard Williams seemed to sum up the position when he said "we used to stop top side of 95's, by 37's old road, when we were coming out. It was cooler there." He also said, when asked if his working place was so warm that when he had finished he went to the top side of 95's for ten minutes rest, "No, we used to finish early, and we used to go and sit there because it was too early to go up to the top." Such in brief was the effect of the evidence that the current was split at 24's airway and that this was accordingly an intake airway. Other witnesses gave evidence that the air was moving in the reverse direction and that 24's airway was a return. John Taylor, ripper and contractor, who for five years had been engaged on repair work on 142's Deep and was always on the night shift, said that the air came out of 24's airway on to 142's Deep and that the opening from 142's Deep into the airway by the raising of the floor had become restricted to about a yard long and about nine inches high. Some three weeks before the explosion, with the nightshift deputy, Matthias, he went round by way of 95's and 24's roads into 24's airway to see if there was any room to pack the rubbish made in the course of blowing down the roof of the airway with a view to keeping a connection to 142's Deep. Apparently there was room but, according to Taylor, it was no part of his job to clear away the rubbish he got down and, that rubbish not being cleared away, the mouth of the airway in consequence got blocked up about a fortnight before the explosion and remained so until the early hours of Wednesday, 19th September. John Hughes, collier, gave evidence which was somewhat contradictory in that he said that what air there was, was coming through 24's airway into 142's Deep but that during the last few weeks prior to the explosion there was no air travelling at all. He was always under the impression that what air was coming, came up 95's face and into his place — 24's. He thought the air went into 95's road, up that face and then through the old (24's) airway. Edward Ponton, haulage-hand, said he thought the air went into 95's road and up the face and down 24's road. Stephen Lewis, collier, who worked in 95's face, said the only air they used to get was down 95's road and up 95's face. He was present when the shot referred to by the deputy, Norman Parry, was fired and in contradiction to Parry's evidence, he said the smoke from that shot came uphill towards where he was. He also said that the mouth of 24's airway "was practically covered over almost every morning when we went down, with timber and one thing and another". It had been hotter in 95's face during the fortnight before the explosion than previously — it was "red hot". Bert Jones said he did not see the shot fired in 95's face but he heard it and later he smelled the reek where he was working at the top end of the face. Ralph Roberts, roadman, said he went through 24's airway about three weeks before the explosion. The entrance to that road off 142's Deep was at that time about 2 feet 6 inches high and about feet wide. The air was coming out of 24's airway — it was a slight current. Henry Tomlinson, rope splicer, said he was in 95's road about two months before the explosion and he could feel the "draught coming in at that road". I have no difficulty in making up my mind which of these two bodies of evidence is correct. The temperature of the air passing on 95's face was much higher than the temperature on 142's Deep; there was no positive means of any kind to reverse the flow according to natural laws, and there is no doubt in my mind that such air as did circulate on this side of the district left 142's Deep at 95's road, passed down that road to 95's. face, up that face and out along 24's airway on to 142's Deep again. In other words, there was a local circulation due entirely to natural causes as Mr. Charlton had suggested, the main air current simply passing down 142's Deep and out by the return to 14's level. Such, being in my judgment, the course. of the ventilation on this side of the district, the evidence as to its quality falls to be considered and, as an examination of the plan would cause one to think, the place where gas was most likely to be found, namely, 24's heading, was the one to which this evidence was, for the most part, directed. The Manager said in reference to 24's heading that "they had a little gas there on the head end as they were working. It probably would be 1 per cent." but he denied that the driving of this heading was stopped and the heading fenced off because of the presence of gas. The Under-manager said 24's heading had not been worked whilst he had been at the colliery, that is since 21st January, 1934, but he had known gas to be in it some months prior to the explosion. He also said that he "would expect to find a little there when it was a heading for a few yards in front of the face, and being that it was coming to the rise". The night shift overman, Frederick John Davies, was, according to his evidence, last in 95's district, prior to the explosion, sometime about the month of March when, he said, he "went round the face and found it free from gas with the exception of a little bit in 24's top end. It was standing at the time and was a narrow place; just a short length — 3 or 4 yards". There were, at that time, bits of sheets hanging on 142's Deep; they were "not much use The deputies, Parry, Edwards and Matthias, had reported gas in 24's heading and the heading fenced off from 23rd January to 3rd February, and Edwards on 2nd May and Matthias on 3rd May had reported to the same effect, these being the last statutory reports of gas in the heading. It is impossible to reconcile the evidence of these several witnesses, namely, the Under-manager's that the heading had not been worked at least since 21st January; the Manager's that there was a little gas in this heading when it was worked; the deputies' reports of gas in it only from 23rd January to 3rd February and on 2nd and 3rd May; the night shift Overman's statement that he found a "little bit" in the top end of the heading in March and that the heading, although shown on Plan 1 to be about 35 yards long, was then only 3 or 4 yards in length. Again, when later during the Inquiry, the Manager was being questioned in regard to the stoppings shown on the plan towards the bottom end of this district and he was asked if he had had any trouble with gas in that area, he replied "Never". Further asked "Not even in the headings?" he answered "No". This last evidence is in direct conflict with that of Mr. J. T. Shaw, Sub-Inspector of Mines, who had made inspection in this district on 31st May, 1932, more than two years before the explosion, and reported in reference to the presence of gas" The firemen are reporting a little in 24 and 37 and 81 and 147 headings fenced off. In 24, 37 and 109 there was a 1½ per cent. cap in the area of the roadway which would be considered in the general ventilation, what there is. In 147, I could not find more than 2 per cent. at or below the roof level, but it put light out in cavity about 3 feet above the roof 20 yards back from the face. In 8i heading there is an accumulation showing a 2½ per cent. cap at a point 25 yards back from the face, so I was informed. I did not go beyond this point; both 81 and 147 headings were fenced off as reported. All other places were clear. It is very warm in the workings and roadways comprising this district." Of the above-named places, 24, 81, 147 and 109 were places going to the dip and 37 was a level. Such places, in the ordinary course, would be much more easily kept free from gas than a place driven to the rise such as 24's heading. They were not being kept free at the date of Mr. Shaw's inspection, 31st May, 1932, and it is material to add that Mr. Shaw commented in his report on this aspect of the matter as follows :— "Ventilation. — All the working beyond the downthrow fault are headings, forming pillars approximately 66 by 66 yards; no means such as air pipes or bratticing is provided to ventilate any of these headings, some are more or less level and others to the dip; there is none to the rise and this appears to be the factor on which they depend for the places keeping clear of gas. The headings are cul-de-sacs, and consequently, the ventilation is more or less stagnant, and gas in several places." "The same remarks apply to the workings inspected to-day as to those inspected yesterday relative to the volume of ventilation in the district, viz. :— that it is feeble and that there is a large amount of leakage before it arrives in the district." "Conditions as a whole. — The ventilation is feeble, and consequently the workings and roadways are very warm, out of a total of eight headings, two are fenced off for gas, and gas to the extent of 1½ per cent. is showing in three others, and no provision in the shape of air pipes or brattice to conduct the ventilation to the face of the headings." Mr. Shaw continued his inspection on 2nd June, 1932, visiting on that day the workings in the Crank Seam and at the end of his report on those workings he made a note in reference to that part of 109's district on which he had reported on 31st May, as follows:— "The management are taking the ventilation of these districts in hand and No. 147 heading is now reported clear of gas. I understand that they are also bratticing in towards the face in No. 81 heading, and the Manager, so far as I understand, was going into this district this morning with the object of getting the gas cleared from 81 heading and also from the other places." Reverting to more recent times, Parry said he had never had any complaint from the men about the ventilation in the district and he had not said, as was later in the Inquiry alleged by some witnesses, that the ventilation would not be right until a new road was put through the fault. He denied that a new road (105's) which it was intended to put through the fault to hole into 24's heading and was touching the fault on the high side, was for the purpose of improving the ventilation, although the Manager, in evidence, had already said that was its purpose. On the low side of the fault 24's heading was approaching the fault but it had not quite reached it. He agreed that that was a likely place for gas to come off. The condition of 95's district, in the opinion of Edwards, afternoon shift deputy, "both on the coal face where coal was produced, in the return and intake airways, and on the transport roads" was such that no complaint could be made about it at all. That, in brief, was the evidence of the officials chiefly responsible as to the adequacy of the ventilation of 95's district. In certain respects which I have indicated, I am unable to accept it as accurate and it is necessary therefore to consider how far in other respects it was corroborated, and how far contradicted, by the evidence of other witnesses. The evidence which tends to corroborate may be briefly summarised as follows:— Edward William Williams, repairer and spare fireman, said that when in 95's district he found everything in satisfactory order. He wore a Welsh flannel singlet and a waistcoat and did not find the temperature unbearable. During August, the last time he was there, 24's heading was standing and there was no gas in it then. He had never found gas in 95's district. Thomas Henry Williams, shotfirer and spare fireman, said that he had not been in 95's district for about nine months, and that he did not find it any hotter there than in any other part of the mine. He, however, added to this statement on further examination that 95's and 20's top end were as warm as 14's; they were the warmest places in the mine. Thomas Henry Lewis, also a shotfirer and spare fireman, said he had worked in 109's district, which included 95's, on 1st January and for three weeks in March; the ventilation was good and he never had to report gas. Osborne Jones, collier, whose working place was 187's, that is, the place on the right side of 142's Deep immediately below 95's road, said the ventilation there was good but "a bit warm". He tested for gas in his place every morning, but he never found any there. He knew the opening into 24's airway because "there were some sleepers there and we took a couple of sleepers from there"; the sleepers were "like a kind of fence". Edward Arthur, collier, who worked in the same place as Osborne Jones, said "considering how far it was in . . . we could not grumble at the heat down there." He had never found gas in his place. I come now to certain evidence which, in the main, I believe to be evidence of truth, to the effect that in certain respects the ventilation of this district was gravely inadequate. John Taylor, ripper and contractor, some of whose evidence has already been referred to, said that the mouth of 24's airway got blocked up about a fortnight before the explosion and it remained blocked up until the early hours of Wednesday, 19th September, when he knocked a hole through over an old strap about two yards from the mouth; on going to put his lamp down to have a look, the light was immediately put out and he could feel the heat on his face. It was firedamp which put his light out; he saw "the blue flash of the flame shooting up into the shield." The night shift deputy, Sam Matthias, who was killed in the explosion, came down shortly afterwards and he (Taylor) told him what had happened. Matthias said he would send down some brattice from 8i ‘s but he failed to do so; Taylor therefore, on his own initiative, "covered the hole up with sleepers and put dirt on it." Taylor said he was not at work on the Wednesday night, but on the Thursday night he was and he gave in evidence a description of events which he said occurred during that night as follows :— By Sir Stafford Cripps — Q. On the Thursday night were you again working in the same place? A. Yes, same spot. Q. Were you given instructions on that night to bore a hole for the purpose of firing a shot there? A. The hole wanted to be enlarged according to official orders, and the fireman asked me to put a hole in that with a banjack. I mentioned in conversation to him it might be a little dangerous, and suggested that I put the hole higher up. He said, "Why?" I said, "You know what is coming out, Sam." He said, "Well, do just as you like, Jack," so I put the hole higher up. Q. What was the depth of the hole you put in? A. About 18 inches. Q. And after you put the hole in did Matthias come along and fire? A. Not just then. He didn't come till half-past two. Q. At half-past two he came along to fire. Was that a sort of normal time he came to your part? A. Yes, we usually used to bore first. We were pushed in 81's, and he would come along about that time to this ripping. Q. Did you see him charge the hole? A. Yes. Q. Do you know what charge he put in? A. 4 ozs. Q. Then did you clear and he fired? A. I went inside, and my mate and the fireman went up hill. Q. Then he fired the shot? A. He fired the shot. Q. After he had fired the shot what happened? A. I remained for about ten minutes for the smoke to clear. It is the usual custom. Q. Which way did the smoke clear? A. Straight down the main road. Q. Straight down 95's? A. Split by 95's. Q. After that did you come back, after that time? A. Yes, I came back. Q. And what happened then? Was Matthias there too? A. He was just finishing rolling his cable up, and was coming down, and I was right at the hole. He said, "How is it done, Jack?" I said, "Well, Sam, I don't like the smell coming out of here. Neither do I like the heat." He said, "I always said I could ventilate it." I said, "Aye, but look what is coming out." He put his lamp down, and it went out. He said, "Aye, there's something too there, Jack," and he shouted up to Jack Daniels — John D. Jones his name is by right, but he is known as Jack Daniels — and he asked him to send Jim down with a lamp. Q. Because he was in the dark? A. He had lost his own light. Q. He asked Jim to send another lamp down? A. No, he shouted to Jack Daniels to send his mate down and a lamp, so that he could go out for a lamp. His words to me was, "Stand on one side, Jack. I shall be coming back to you. Q. You stood off and waited for him to come back from 81's? A. Yes. Q. What happened when he came back? A. He never came back till 4 o'clock in the morning. Q. And you were standing off waiting till then? A. Standing till 4 o'clock. Q. What happened when he did come back? A. He asked me to do him a favour. He said, "Will you and your mate go and clean manholes out from 81's to 41's North?" He said, "The Inspector of Mines is coming down owing to that lad having his leg broke in 81's," so I took it on Friday the Inspector of Mines should have been there. This last matter was a side issue. In fact, a lad (George Smith) had had an accident but it was not reported to the Divisional Inspector and therefore an Inspector would not be coming to inquire about it as Matthias had expected. It was not for Matthias to know that the accident had not been reported to the Inspector and the incident merely serves to afford a point of confirmation to the accuracy of Taylor's memory. When Norman Parry, the day shift deputy, was being examined some days before Taylor gave his evidence, he had said that he went down the pit on the morning of 21st September at 5.20 and that he met the night shift deputy, Sam Matthias, at their station in 81's level. He there discussed with Matthias the conditions in the district and saw the report that Matthias had made. Asked by Mr. Charlton if Matthias had anything of importance to tell him, Parry replied "No, nothing particular, only the places were in good condition." On this matter, Parry was questioned by Sir Stafford Cripps as follows :— Q. Let me now come to the date when you went in that you have given the account of to Mr. Charlton. You met Matthias coming out on that morning? A. No. In the station. Q. I meant, you changed places with him. I did not mean at any particular point. That was on the early morning of Friday, 21st September? A. Yes. Q. Did he tell you of an incident which had occurred on 24's, where 24's met 142's Deep, that night? A. No. Q. Did he tell you that he fired a shot in the mouth of 24's that night? A. No. Q. And that gas came out in large quantities from the old road? A. No. Q. And that when he put his lamp down to inspect the hole, his lamp went out? A. No. That is the first I have heard of it. Q. That is the sort of event you would expect to be reported to you, is it? A. Yes, if that occurred. Answering Mr. A. T. Miller, Parry said that on this occasion, in accordance with his usual practice, he saw the report which Matthias had made and, in reference to gas, it read :—" Free except a little on 179's and 183's road," neither of which were in 95's district, and that was the only gas referred to in writing. Asked "Was any other gas referred to in conversation" Parry replied, "None whatever." To continue with Taylor's evidence. He said that, notwithstanding the block in 24's airway, air continued to come through on to 142's Deep until he plugged the hole up, after which he suggested it was going in at 95's road, up 95's face and; there being no brattice in 24's road, down that road and across 95's road — the hot air going out passing over the cooler air going in — and continuing straight down over a brattice which was hung a foot from the roof. As, according to his evidence, Taylor was not in 95's or 24's after he had plugged up the hole, his description of the course of the air after that event was not the result of observation. It is doubtful, of course, whether a "plug" consisting of sleepers with dirt on them would prevent air passing. Just as Mr. W. T. Miller said Taylor would have a job to get anybody to accept that a covering of sleepers and small dirt would hold back gas, it would be equally difficult to believe that such a covering would keep back air. Taylor said he realised that the conditions in 95's and 24's were dangerous and he knew men were working in those places. He thought the explosion might have happened earlier "because of what was coming out of that hole in 24's on to the main road," but he had reported that to Matthias. He was not concerned with what happened on the day shift; he had reported the occurrence to Matthias "and it was in the hands of the officials to do their part." Taylor added that when he was in 24's he noticed that there were four lamps all lit on the floor and the haulage-hand (Sam Bond) had his on his belt. He first became concerned about the conditions in the district on 21st January, or, at all events, towards the latter end of that month, "when I was ordered to split the air into 24's top end, that heading going up towards the fault" and on looking to see where to put the brattice, the light of his lamp was put out. It was so hot there he could not go into the heading at all. It will be remembered that, according to the deputies' reports, gas was present in 24's heading from 23rd January to 3rd February, thus confirming Taylor's recollection. His object in covering over the hole which he made into 24's airway was, he said, to prevent gas coming out on to 142's Deep because there had been one or two runaways which had smashed the electric cable down there. This was the first mention during the Inquiry of an electric cable in 95's district and none was shown on the plan. Evidence was given later that there was such a cable but that it had been disconnected on 1st September. Taylor said that if the morning and afternoon firemen said they travelled through 24's airway every shift they would be liars. The sleepers and dirt with which he covered the hole which he had made into 24's airway on the Wednesday morning were still there when he returned on the Thursday night. He had always thought the conditions were dangerous, the most serious being" the effect of heated conditions on health". He had not complained because he was afraid of being victimised by the Colliery Company and "he was not in compliance as a financial member to make a complaint to the Miners' Federation." John Hughes, collier, said that during the week of the explosion he was working in 24's taking off a lift of coal uphill towards the fault. There was no gas in his place during that week and his lamp was not put out. There was gas all the time in 24's heading. Some months before the explosion he had complained to the deputy, Edwards, about gas in 24's face. Edwards tested and told him to fence the place off. It remained fenced off for about six weeks after which he repaired the road up to the face — about 20 yards — but, after working two shifts, gas appeared again and he was sent to work about 30 yards lower down to take a lift off the side to widen the place. To get to 24's he travelled at one time along 24's airway but had not been able to go that way for two or three months because the main road (142's Deep) was being raised and the mouth of the airway was thus becoming closed up. He then had to travel to 24's place by way of 95's and 24's roads. The last time he went through the airway the mouth was about a yard wide and 2 feet 6 inches high. Cross-examination on this last point by Mr. Shawcross was as follows:— Q. The roadway into 24's was completely closed, was it? There was no airway? A. Not completely closed, not quite. Q. About what sort of opening was there in it? A. The last month I never took much notice, because there was timber over it, because they were blowing down there. Q. Blowing the roof down? A. Yes. Q. Did you notice at all what sort of size it was during the last month? A. very small. There was timber over it. You couldn't get down it. Q. I am not suggesting you could get down. What sort of size was it? Was there air going through? A. What air there was was coming up through it, I reckon. Q. There was air coming up? A. There was no air hardly to travel, but that was the way it travelled, to my idea. Q. And it travelled right up to the explosion? A. There was no air travelled there in the last few weeks at all. The witness, Taylor, had said there was no brattice sheet across 24's road when he was there three weeks before the explosion, but Hughes on this point said a brattice was there — he was sure of it" because it used to get ripped off". Hughes also said that when his lamp was put out, he used to get it re-lit and then go back to work in 24's and it then remained alight. For close on a year the gas in 24's had made him feel very heavy and drowsy when he got home "and feel I did not want to go anywhere at all". Edward Ponton said he had worked in 95's district for four years on haulage work. It was very hot there, "like Hell". He thought the air went into 95's and up the face and down 24's road. There was a brattice across 24's road. He and his mates always went in by 95's road. Stephen Lewis, a collier on 95's face, said that at one time, four months before the explosion, he travelled along 24's airway to get to his working place, but latterly "it was practically covered over almost every morning when we went down with timber and one thing and another". It was not possible to get into this airway at the mouth since about two months before the explosion. Lewis, in answer to Mr. Frowen, said if he had wanted to travel out of 24's airway, he could not have got out on to 142's Deep, "but there may have been wind travelling that way". He could not say whether the covering over the mouth of that airway interfered with the ventilation in 24's and 95's. The only air that they used to get was down 95's road and up their (95's) face. He thought the conditions were worse after the sheet across 142's Deep was torn away than they were before. During the two weeks prior to the explosion it was hotter in his place than previously — it was "red-hot". There was no gas in his place after they got through to 24's, but about 12 months before, when 95's face was being opened, gas was there continually and it was there for months. There had been no gas in his place recently. He continually made complaints to the deputies — Thomas Henry Lewis at first and later Norman Parry. He had recently complained to Norman Parry about the ventilation. "We told him it was getting warmer there, and it was getting unbearable there." By Mr. Henderson — Q. What did Parry say? A. He seemed to take no notice; it was useless telling him anything. Q. Was that a week before the accident? A. Yes. Q. Was there a. new road being made about then? A. Yes, going towards 12's road, I call it — 81's road, I believe they call it — off 109's Junction. Q. Did you ever have any conversation with Parry about that new road? A. We have told him that the heat was getting unbearable, and he said it would not be much better until we got that road through. Q. Did you have occasion to speak to the fireman about the lack of air there? A. Yes, because it was so warm there. Bert Jones, collier, said he was working in 24's taking off an 8 yard lift of coal alongside 24's heading and putting on a pack to carry on the wind road to clear the heading out. The temperature in 24's was "red-hot". He had complained to the deputy, who said it would be no better until the road that was coming down to meet them was through. It was hotter during the last week before the explosion — "It was partly unbearable, very near unbearable." There was "half a brattice" at the top end of 24's road, about 3 yards below the airway. In reference to the heading (24's) he said that it had been fenced off just above them during the last few months because of gas and was fenced off at the time of the explosion but on reflection he said that was not so — "Now I come to think, I think the fence was taken down when the pulley was put up" — the pulley being the haulage return wheel in 24's heading — some six or eight weeks before the explosion. His lamp had been put out when he was working in 24's heading six months before the explosion. The last time he was actually in 24's heading was with Mr. Bonsall some three months before the explosion. Mr. Bonsall had an electric lamp but they could not get within 10 yards of the face. His (Jones') lamp was "blazing-up". He had not travelled along 24's airway to his working place for three months. The mouth of the airway was closed up. David Williams, a collier, who also worked in 24's place, said he did not think there was any ventilation. He had complained to Parry many a time but Parry "used to say it would be better when that road came through". He complained to the deputy, Edwards, about gas about six months prior to the explosion, and Edwards fenced off 24's heading and it remained fenced off until the pulley was put up. He and his mates used to travel through the "intake" at one time until it became too bad" because it was a nearer road, a lot". It would be three or four months since he went through it. It is of interest to compare the deputy, Parry's, evidence with that of Jones and Williams in reference to the fence across 24's heading. Parry, questioned by Sir Stafford Cripps, said:— Q. As a matter of fact, was not that heading (24's) right up to the date of the accident, fenced off? A. No. Q. And was it not actually fenced off in the week of the accident? A. No, it had not been fenced off for a considerable time. Q. What do you call a considerable time? A. Months. Q. I suggest to you that it had been fenced off intermittently right up to the time of the accident, and, in fact, during the week prior to the accident was fenced off? A. No, I cannot say it was fenced off. Q. Perhaps you do not remember: is that it? A. No, I do remember it was not fenced off — not actually fenced off. Q. Was there some obstruction to stop people getting there? A. There was some dirt down in there. Q. Was it in such a condition that it could not be penetrated? Let me put it that way. A. No, I could get straight up to the face. In weighing the truth of the foregoing evidence I have been influenced by a study of the accounts which were given by the two deputies, Parry and Edwards, of the extent and character of the inspections which as deputies they made of the district. They were examined at length on the point and I am struck by what they said and by what they left unsaid about the inspection of 24's airway. Parry, in describing the route he followed when making his first inspection (he was not asked about his second) on 21st September, did not mention 24's haulage road — a road which he was required to inspect — but stressed that he travelled along 24's airway — a road which he was not required to inspect. His evidence on this point, when being examined by Mr. Charlton, may be the more easily followed if reference be made to Plan 2. That evidence was as follows — "After that I proceeded back along 81's level and down to 95's drift. Down 95's drift I went in 24's intake side. Into 24's, I examined there, right along 24's face, along the rib to 95's, down 95's face, examining for gas until I came down to 95's road end, and examined the ripping lips there. Then on the bottom side of 95's, came back up 95's, right along 95's road to 142's junction, and there I proceeded back up 142's for a few yards to examine into the 37's place. Examined there ripping lips and where I could examine there on the face, came out of there and proceeded down 142's deep, into 231's, examined inbye 231's on the faces, out from there and down to 147's junction, in along 147's junction and up the return airway of 95's." Q. "You went down 142's, you ‘returned' (should probably read ‘turned') into 24's —" A. "Intake". Q. Why do you say that? A. It was my first call. Q. How do you get from 24's to 95's? A. Down the face, right along the rib. Q. Could you go straight on to 95's face without going into 24's? A. No. Edwards, when describing the route which he followed during his first inspection on the same day, did not mention 24's airway. His evidence on this point was as follows:— Q. What did you do after that? A. Then I went down the hole. Q. What is the hole? A. That is 95's District. Q. Down 142's? A. That's it. 12,796. How did you travel then? A. I travelled down into 37's. 12,797. By which road? A. 142's Deep into 37's. There was only one set working down that Deep on that particular day. 12,798. Where did you go next? A. I went up into 24's and 95's. Then I went into 147's place. Then I came back up the Deep again. Looking at the plan, Edwards would appear to have followed the natural and obvious route, namely — He went down 142's Deep as far as 37's place; into that place and then, into 24's place via 24's road, down 95's face, out by 95's road and on reaching 142's Deep turned down into 147's. Mr. Charlton went over this itinerary with Edwards a second time as follows — Q. Eventually you found your way down this hill? A. Into 95's. Q. How many men had you employed there on the afternoon of the 21st? A. There was only two working on the face and haulage hands. Q. That is three altogether? A. Four. Q. What was the fourth? A. Two haulage hands and two on the face. Q. Which face were those men employed on? A. On 37's. Q. Were they coaling? A. Yes. Q. You would be the last man down there? Did you fire any shots down there? A. No. Q. These two men were getting coal in 37's? A. Yes. Q. On the occasion of that first visit did you go into 24's at all? A. Yes. Q. What did you find when you went into 24's? Anything out of the ordinary? A. No. Q. Did you examine for gas there? A. Yes. Q. And did you find any? A. No. Q. Did you go down 95's face? A. Yes. Q. Did you go into where you were enlarging the return in 147's? A. Yes. Q. I thought there were no men working there at that time? A. Well, the lads were working there, the haulage hands. They were also winding from these two men that were in 37's also emptying the road, so I had to make a visit to see if the haulage was all right up to these points. Q. That is your first inspection? A. That was my first inspection. Edwards then gave the route he followed during his second inspection of 95's district, and it will be seen from his evidence quoted below that in this account also he makes no reference to 24's airway until he is specifically asked if he travelled it. Q. You made a later inspection than that. What time did you start your second inspection? A. Generally start five minutes past eight on my second examination. Q. We are speaking of the specific date, the 21st of September. What lime did you start that night? A. Five minutes past eight. Q. Was your round pretty much the same as you have described? A. No. Q. Will you tell us what it was? A. We went down the hill first, down 95's district, down 142's Deep, down 95's road, into 24's, down into 95's road end and out again, and into 231's and 147's, and up that air course into 14's road. Q. Did you never travel that bit of road off 142's Deep to 24's? A. Yes, Sir. Q. You did not say so, you know. You said you went in by 95's, and we have been told that is where the coal comes out? A. No, it does not come that way, does it? Q. Yes, we have been told that coal comes out on the road known to us as 95's? A. Yes, it comes on 95's. I thought you meant 24's road. Q. I was putting it to you you had not been through that windway off 142's and 24's? A. Yes. Q. Did you do that on this visit we are now on? A. Yes. Q. You did go there? A. I went in that way, didn't I? 12,886. No, you did not say so. A. I went into 24's, through this road into 24's, down into 95's and out on 95's road. Q. You did not say that. You said you went down to 95's and up to 24's and then on to 95's face. Now on this visit what was the size of the hole that you went through when you went down to go to 24's place from 142's? A. The air course? Q. Yes, the opening? A. About 4 feet 01 4 feet 6 inches. Q. You are quite clear about the place, I mean? A. Yes, the air course from the main deep into 24's? Q. Yes? A. Yes, about 4 feet square. Q. And the ripping lip was near there on 142's? A. Yes. Q. About bow far below or above? A. About 4 feet 6 inches or 5 feet of a drop there. Q. But was there not a ripping lip going on in 142's? A. Oh, yes. Q. Where was that ripping relative to this air course? A. About three yards lower down, I should think two or three yards lower down. Q. As far as your knowledge went, were they going to put some holes above where the air hole was, to blast that down? A. No, I do not think so. Q. So that when the night men came on where would you expect that they would be working on that ripping, on that canch? A. Yes. Q. Straight on, on 142s? A. Yes. It will have been noticed that after Mr. Charlton had specifically asked Edwards if he ever travelled "that bit of road off 142's Deep to 24's", in other words, 24's airway, Edwards replied "Yes, Sir" and in his answer to question No. 12,886, he said — "I went into 24's, through this road into 24's down into 95's, and out on 95's road", thus omitting, as Parry had omitted, 24's haulage road — a road, as has been said, he was required to inspect. Mr. Charlton's examination proceeded — Q. Will you then just proceed with it? This is your last inspection, you see, before the night shift? A. Yes. There were men working in the air course, the top air course, on that particular night. Q. At the top air course of 147's? A. Yes. Q. And you passed them? A. No, the top air course of 147's, the top of 23's face, on that return airway. Q. But we have not got there yet. The Commissioner: I think you had better start again, and let the man tell you where he went. Mr. Charlton: I am sure he has had every opportunity, Sir. The Commissioner: He has, but he did not seem to take hold of it all. Then followed questions by myself, as follows:— Q. I want you to go through the second inspection just as you made it. A. I went down 142's deep, went through 24's air course into 24's place; from there to 95's. Q. By the face, along the face? A. By the face. Q. Which is 6 feet high? A. Yes. Q. And the width from the gob to the face is about what? A. Six feet. Q. It is 6 feet square there, then? A. Yes. Q. Then you went down 95's place? A. Yes, and came out along 95's road, but first of all, I went into 37's place. Q. That was the first inspection, was it not? A. No, the second, too. We are on the second now? Q. Yes. First of all you went down to 37's? A. Yes. Q. And had a look at that? A. Yes. Q. Then what happened after that? A. I went through the air course into 24's. Q. You came up the hole again? A. Yes, and down 95's place and up 95's road. Then I went along 147's road, up the air course. Q. You must be a bit more specific if you are going to do justice to yourself. You are out now at the end of 95's road. Where exactly did you go then? A. Then I went down 147's road. Q. Did you never go into 231's? A. Yes, I passed that. Q. Yes, you passed it. Do you mean you passed it. A. No, I called there. Q. Did you go in to see it? A. Yes. Then I worked myself down 147's road and straight up the air course there. Q. Right up to 14's? A. Yes. Q. I think you had better say now exactly where on that round you made inspections for gas, if you made any at all? A. I did inspect for gas as I went around. Q. Where? A. All lips. Q. Tell me where exactly. A. There are three lips on 142's deep. Q. You examined on each lip? A. Yes. Q. What did you find there? A. Nothing. I went into 24's. Q. Anything in there? A. No. I went along 24's then, and I examined as I went along? Q. How do you mean, you examined as you went along? A. I examined for gas every place I went to, wherever I thought it was necessary. Q. Where you did think it was necessary at all? A. Yes. Q. What did you find up in 24's? A. I found nothing. It was clear. Q. You do not seem to have travelled that road they call 24's road at all? A. Yes, I did do. Q. You did not say so. A. Oh, you mean the haulage road? Q. Yes. A. Yes, I went into that. Q. You did not say so. A. Out of it again and down 95's face. Q. You did not say at any time you had ever been in 24's road. A. But you do do that, you see. You have got to come back. Q. Why didn't you say so? A. And up from 95's, up to 37's. I did that. We have got to do those in some cases where we cannot reach them. Q. What do you mean? From 95's turn to 37 you cannot reach it? A. I went to 37's, then I went back through the air course into 24's; therefore there was a portion of that road not examined, from 95's turn to 37. Q. Yes, I noticed that. A. That was done also. That has to be done on several occasions. Well, that was done. Q. Is there a block in there of some sort? A. In where? Q. In 142's, between 95's and where the third lot of men are ripping. Is the road blocked? A. No. Q. Quite open? You could not walk straight down if you wanted to, could you? A. Down to 95's road? Q. No, down 142's? A. Yes, up to 147's road. Q. Yes, I see. You could not go any further than that? A. No, it is blocked lower down than that. Again, looking at the plan, it is not likely that a deputy would go first to 37's place, then come back up 142's Deep and through the airway into 24's, as Edwards said he did, even if 24's aircourse had been travellable. Was not the natural and obvious route for him to take the one described in the answers to questions 12796-12798? It will be noticed that in this second account of his route, in including 24's airway he omitted 24's haulage road, as he had done in answer to question 12886. The evidence of these two deputies, on this point, does not ring true and I do not accept it as true. I do not believe that 24's airway — which as I have already said I believe to have been a return and not an intake — was inspected by either of them on 21st September and I do not believe that it was sufficiently open for inspection on that date. In conclusion, it is of interest to refer to a similar case where the ventilation was actually moving in a direction contrary to that intended. In the *Report of the Divisional Inspector for Yorkshire for the year 1932, Mr. E. H. Frazer gives a sketch of the workings in the Silkstone Seam at Cortonwood Colliery and he shows how, in conditions less favourable to natural ventilation than existed in 95's district, the ventilation there travelled in to a face, along that face and out again on to the main intake. And in that district at Cortonwood Colliery there was an explosion. The position on the left side of 95's district, in my opinion, was precarious, and, whilst it would have been eased if the drift (105's) which was being driven to the dip from 81's haulage road had been holed into 24's heading, work having been stopped in 24's in the meantime, it would not even then have been satisfactory and would not be until a separate main return airway on the left side of 142's Deep and of the Dennis main haulage road had been made. Add to the position in regard to the ventilation of 95's district, the firing of shots at the mouth of 24's airway, and the whole situation becomes one of great danger. * Report of H.M. Inspector of Mines for the year 1932, Yorkshire Division
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||