Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

3. Ventilation.

Ventilation of the mine was produced by a double inlet Walker fan placed at the surface and steam driven.

There was no proper air-lock at the top of the upcast (the Martin) shaft, platforms (butterfly boards or policemen), raised by each of the two cages as it came to bank, being relied upon to prevent air flowing direct from the surface to the fan.

(a) Air measurements. — The air measurements, said to have been made monthly, as required by Section 29 (2) of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, were entered in the prescribed book, Mines and Quarries Form No. 37, to 3oth June; the measurements said to have been made in July and August were found in the note-book of the Assistant Surveyor (William Idris Cuffin), who said he made the measurements. Some 18 months later — in June, 1936 — Mr. Cuffin, when giving further evidence, said that on the instructions of the Manager he had not in fact made any measurements since June, 1934 that the figures in the note-book for July and August were imaginary and that he had concocted them because the Manager had told him to do so a day or two after the disaster.

The quantities in cubic feet per minute, measured in the fan drift, the main intakes and, included in the latter, the main intake to the Dennis Section of the mine, were for the first six months of 1934, according to the figures entered in the prescribed book, as follows —

 Volume in cubic feet per minute.
Date
1934.
 Fan Drift.   Main Intakes.   Main Intake
Dennis Section
M1
. 
26th January   151,590 127,928 35,353
24th February  157,836 127,505 37,970
26th March   155,746 138,611 46,840
28th April   153,267 138,406 47,834
28th May   145,938 125,738 45,508
30th June   142,970 117,284 43,065

The intake and return airways in the Dennis Section of the mine are shown on Plan 1. The point of measurement in the Dennis Main intake airway is shown at M1 and the points of measurement of such splits as were measured are shown at M3 and M7. Contrary to the requirements of Section 29 of the Coal Mines Act, 1911 (and No. 77 of the General Regulations dated 10th July, 1913) the quantity of air was never measured in certain splits, namely those coursing along 81's and 14's levels.

In regard to measurements required to be made in each ventilating district at or as near as practicable to a point 100 yards back from the first working place at the working face which the air enters, the only such measurement said to have been made was at M6 in 61 ‘s district. Another similar measurement should have been made in 109's district. The measurement said to have been made at M7 in 95's district was not strictly in compliance with this requirement; if the air had in fact entered 24's airway from 142's Deep, it should have been measured actually in the airway.

Whether measurements 100 yards back from the first working place in the other districts are required by the Regulation is not at all clear.

The measurements in cubic feet per minute applying to the Dennis Section for the first six months of 1934 (according to the figures entered in the prescribed book), were:

 Point of measurement — See Plan 1.
Date
1934
M1
Main
Intake
M3.M4.M6.M7.M5
Main
Returns
M2
Main
Returns
26th January   35,353 19,320 12,432 7,214 3,510 33,476 22,182
24th February  37,970 19,840 11,985 7,546 3,072 34,818 20,017
26th March   46,840 23,490 18,006 7,940 4,811 35,638 23,974
28th April   47,834 21,264 14,719 7,392 4,607 36,430 24,073
28th May   45,508 14,006 12,933 7,560 5,173 28,166 21,896
30th June   43,065 11,692 10,465 6,907 4,760 22,464 20,176
27th July*   43,103 11,699 10,062 6,720 4,356 23,382 20,513
25th August*   42,557 11,845 10,304 6,864 4,769 21,870 11,843
* The fictitious figures from the note-book, not entered in the prescribed report book.

I do not believe that many of the measurements recorded even in the prescribed book were ever made. I have in my possession Mr. Cuffin's note-book in which were entered the velocities and areas at the various measuring points for November, 1933, January, April and June, 1934. But for November, 1933, there is only one entry in this note-book referring to the Dennis Section, namely a measurement at M1; in January, and again in April there are only two such entries, namely measurements at M2 and M5; and in June there are five entries, namely, measurements at M1, M2, M3, M4 and M5.

On 8th June, 1936, during the sitting when he confessed that the figures for July and August were fictitious, Mr. Cuffin was asked by me where the calculations not appearing in the note-book were. He replied that he did not always use a notebook but used foolscap.

I do not accept that explanation. I think Mr. Cuffin was given more work than he could overtake and that in consequence he scamped the work of air measurement.

When examining the figures in the note-book, I found that there were errors in the calculations — in some cases the entries in the prescribed record being 10,000 cubic feet per minute too little, and in the prescribed book itself there were errors in simple addition.

Some of these figures cannot be accurate; for example, in January they represent that 26,305 cubic feet per minute or 57 per cent. more air was coming out than was going in, whilst in June 425 cubic feet more were going in than were coming out.

It was sought at the Inquiry by Counsel for the North Wales Miners' Association to draw important inferences from a series of carefully prepared graphs, which he put before the Court, showing since January, 1933, in relation to the water gauge and the speed of the fan, the rise and fall in the quantity of air recorded at different measuring points. The chief of these inferences was that the graphs indicated progressive and serious reductions in the quantities of air reaching the faces of the districts furthest inbye, namely, 109's, 95's and 14's and that these reductions could only be accounted for by excessive leakages arising from deterioration in the return airways due to neglect of repairs.

Had the evidence substantiated the accuracy of the figures themselves, and had due precaution been taken month by month to measure the quantities of air under conditions sufficiently like to ensure their full comparability over a lengthy period of time, I think the arguments based upon the graphs would, in the main, be sound; but, as it is, I feel that the figures are quite unreliable and that they give little or no guidance in themselves in regard to the actual state of the ventilation or of the return airways.

(b) Deputies Reports. — Turning then to the more specific evidence afforded by the statutory reports of the deputies, it was regrettable that the evidence available did not include all the reports made by the deputies from the beginning of 1934. Some of these reports could not be produced, the books in which they had been made, or copies of them, not having been kept in the office at the mine, contrary to the provisions of Section 24 (1) of the Coal Mines Act, 1911. The missing books were said to be in the cabin near the bottom of the Martin Shaft and, except for those books which were in use and presumably had been taken into the districts and that in use during the first fortnight in January in 29's district, this was proved to be correct when that cabin was first entered during the recovery operations. The books were taken from the cabin and put in evidence on 31st March, 1936.

The following summary gives the names of the Districts and the days for which a report is still not available, over the period 1st January, 1934, to 21st September, 1934 :—

20's District. — August 5, 28, 29, 30, 31. September 1, 2, 5, 11, 12, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19.

61's District. — September 1, 2, 5, 10, 11, 12, 15, 16, 17, 20, 21.

109's District. — September 21.

14's District. — September 21.

29's District. — January 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9, 10, 11, 12, 13.

September 5, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 15, 16, 17, 21.

Martin's Deep. etc. — None.

Taking each district of the Dennis Section in turn, the evidence during the Inquiry in respect of the ventilation was to the following effect:—

(c) Ventilation of No. 4 North Section. — This section of the mine comprised two districts — 20's and 61's.

The quantity of air entering the section was said to be measured at the point marked M3 on Plan 1 and the measurement required to be taken about 100 yards from the first working place at the working face which the air entered, at M6.

20's District. — The deputy on the day shift in 20's district (which did not include 37's and 231's places) was Richard Owen, and his evidence was :— He was always satisfied with the amount of air in his district; it varied very little; there was a very good current along the face; the roadways were warmer than the face, but were not hot; he had never found any gas measurable by a cap in the rippings; there were no cloths at the rippings; the last time he was through before the explosion (the Friday morning), the ventilation in his district was very good; he had not seen gas in his district for two years.

The evidence of the afternoon shift deputy, Thomas Brammer Tune, of 20's district, which on that shift included 37's and 231's places, was that in 20's district proper he had not seen gas for two years; there had been gas at the face of 37's heading, but he had not seen it there since 1st May.

On the night shift there was one deputy, William Salisbury, for the 20's and 61's districts. He was killed in the explosion. The last report before the explosion which was available was made by him; it referred to an examination made between 4.50 a.m. and 5.30 a.m. on 21st September and was to the effect that these districts were free from inflammable and noxious gases.

None of the workmen who gave evidence had seen gas in the district.

On 21st March, Mr. P. G. Dominy, H.M. Junior Inspector of Mines, made an inspection in reference to an accident. He visited the last three places at the return end of the district; he found no gas.

61's District. — According to the deputies' reports, the only place in which gas had been found was adjacent to a fault in the North West corner of the district. The morning and afternoon shift deputies, Josiah Thomas Jones and Walter Swinnerton, agreed that gas had been persistent in these places for some time; that what they found was 1½ to 2 per cent. of gas when the lamp was held close to the roof at the face; the places were at first kept clear by erecting brattice cloth and, eventually, by cutting a hole through the fault and so circulating the air right round. This hole was enlarged the day before the explosion and on 21st September no gas was found.

The night shift deputy was killed in the explosion.

Three workmen witnesses spoke of the gas referred to above and to making the hole through the fault for ventilation purposes. They described the ventilation generally as good, and one, who worked on the afternoon shift, said he left his working place — 122's, one of those in which gas had been persistent — about 9.45 p.m. on 21st September and no gas was there then.

On this evidence it would appear that the ventilation in the No. 4 North Section of the mine complied with the crucial requirement of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, namely, that the ventilation shall be constantly of an amount sufficient to dilute and render harmless inflammable and noxious gases.

109's Section. — This section of the mine comprised two separate sets of workings, namely, 109's and 95‘s; both were assigned to one deputy on each shift.

The air entering 109's district was not measured notwithstanding that it was a split, nor was the air measured at a point about 100 yards back from the first working place which it entered. That entering 95's district was said to be measured at the point marked M7 on Plan 1.

(d) Ventilation of 109's District. — The deputy on the day shift, Norman Parry, said in evidence that he was satisfied with the ventilation. Gas had been seen in 81's road and had been reported regularly from 9th April onwards. Parry said this was a feeder in a cavity some 6 feet long, 2 feet wide and 18 inches to 2 feet deep; the percentage of gas in this cavity varied from 1½ to 2 and was seen when the lamp was held against the roof. Air was turned into the cavity by means of a hurdle sheet and the presence of gas could not be detected in the general body of the air. He also found and reported gas in 80's road during his inspection on the morning of 21st September. This gas also was in a cavity some 15 inches deep, 7 feet long and 2 to 2½ feet wide. There was 1½ per cent. to be seen with the bonnet of the lamp touching the roof; with the lamp below the normal level of the roof, the gas could not be seen. A hurdle sheet was set to turn the air into the cavity. No complaint had even been made of the ventilation and he had never under any circumstances used compressed air for brushing away gas. The gas in this cavity was also reported by the night shift deputy, S. Matthias, in the report of the inspection made by him at the end of his shift on 21st September.

The evidence of the afternoon shift deputy, Robert Thomas Edwards, was similar to that of Parry. He had seen the gas in the two cavities. The night shift deputy, S. Matthias, was killed in the explosion.

The Undermanager said he was through 109's district on 4th September. He went inbye by way of the return airway and examined the face throughout; he found no gas except in the cavity on 81's road. He was also in this district on 20th September and made an inspection of 23's face; there was good ventilation; he examined for gas in several places including the wastes but found none. He did not visit 81's or 80's faces on this latter date, but he saw the gas in the cavity on 81's road; it was a slight trace — one per cent. — and could not be detected on the inbye side of the hurdle sheet set beneath the cavity.

Mr. Dominy inspected 109's face on 5th September, 1933, and found a feeder of gas in the ripping of the return airway which was being diluted about 6 feet from the point of issue. That was the only gas he had ever found in the Colliery. He made another inspection of this face on 20th December, 1933; he found no defects. He did not visit 81's road to see the gas which was there, but its occurrence, he said, was explained to him by the Manager.

The description of the ventilation given by the workmen witnesses who had worked in 109's part of 109's section varied, many saying it was "very good", others that it was "not so bad" and one that it was "very poor". This last witness also described how during the afternoon shift of the Tuesday before the explosion, the deputy Edwards had used compressed air to blow gas out of 80's face and how, when that was being done, five safety lamps had been extinguished.

This alleged occurrence was put to Edwards in cross examination as having taken place about three weeks prior to the explosion but Edwards said he did not remember any such happening and that if it had occurred he would have remembered it. The man, who was said to have taken the five extinguished lamps to be relighted, said that he was not working on 80's face and he did not take any lamps out to be relighted. Another witness said compressed air could not have been used on 80's face on the Tuesday afternoon shift before the explosion because he had the hose pipe in 23's face where he was using the "banjack".

Where the truth lies amongst such diverse statements, it is difficult to say, but having regard to the practice, referred to later, of using compressed air to blow gas out of cavities in 14's district, it would not be surprising to find a similar method practised in this district.

On the evidence as a whole, the crucial requirement of the Act in reference to ventilation was complied with.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z