Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

Recent History

24. The most significant events at the colliery in recent months having a bearing on the fire in September were a heating in the Loader Mine on 24th July, and a fire in the Dysart Dip No. 1 Section on 6th August, 1967.

The Heating of 24th July

Discovery

25. During the morning of 24th July, J. T. Brown, deputy engaged on special duties, looking up the Loader Mine from its junction with the Loco Level, saw smoke coming from a point on the right-hand side which later proved to be about 40 yards from the junction. He then investigated more closely and, finding smoke was issuing from the top of the girders, telephoned D. Wilson, the under-manager in charge of reconstruction, at the pit bottom. Wilson had actually passed through the Loader Mine three quarters of an hour earlier but had noticed nothing untoward.

Dealing with the July heating

26. D. Wilson who received the telephone call between 9.30 a.m. and 10.00 a.m. at once recognising the serious potential of the heating ordered the immediate withdrawal of all men likely to be affected by it and informed the manager. The conveyor belt in the roadway was withdrawn from the affected area and hoses run out from a hydrant in the Loco Level near the Old Pumphouse. This presented no difficulty because the hydrant was at the time on the intake side of the Loader Mine, the direction of ventilation being along the Loco Level from Tilson's Alley. That the air was moving in this direction was largely a matter of chance because this changed from time to time according to the temperature on the surface. After the reconstruction of the No. 3 Pit Bottom during the summer holidays of 1967, this variability ceased and there was a greater flow of air into the Four Feet Section with the result that the air in the Loco Level settled down to flow constantly from the Loader Mine towards Tilson's Alley.

27. The point where the fire had occurred was in an old fall area; when the fireboards between the RSJ webs were removed, three feet of packing timber and the coal above it were found to be burning. The burning material was dug out for quenching and the work continued during the remainder of the day and on into the succeeding night. Ultimately a cavity about eight feet high and ten feet long was excavated. The area was cooled down from about 150 degrees fahrenheit to about 70 degrees fahrenheit and Wilson was convinced that the fire was "definitely out" before packing of the cavity was commenced.

28. A. H. Barker, H.M. District Inspector of Mines and Quarries, visited the area soon after the incident was discovered and agreed with the immediate measures being taken to deal with the situation. He then travelled the return airways and detected carbon monoxide at the stopping on the high side of the No. 3 Heading, but found none in the return itself. D. Wilson also made an inspection of the return airway in the vicinity of the place where it crossed the Loader Mine. He neither saw nor smelt anything unusual, but he did notice that the concrete raft at the crossing had heaved up. He thereupon arranged for the cracks so disclosed to be filled in and this was done on the following day.

29. Later that day Barker attended a meeting of the management at which the general lines of removing the burning material and of sealing the cavity were agreed. The discussion also took in the need to eliminate any air leakage between intake and return airways in the triangular area bounded by the Loader Mine, No. 3 Heading and the Dysart Main Return. An essential feature of this reinforcement was to be the treatment of a length of the Loader Mine with polyurethane foam. Another was to breach the stopping in the return at the entrance to No. 3 Heading and to fill any voids found.

30. The cavity in the Loader Mine was filled with sandbags built up on the RSJ's with plaster puddled between the bags and the coal sides. Both the inbye and outbye sides of the cavity were treated in this way, leaving a narrow shaft up the middle and this was similarly treated using fireboards as supports for the sandbags. Temperature tests were taken throughout the filling operation and at no time did it exceed 70 degrees fahrenheit. D. Wilson was satisfied that "a sound and efficient job" had been made of the filling.

Treatment of the Loader Mine

Application of polyurethane foam

31. As soon as the immediate danger was passed, the management turned its attention to longer term measures. It was decided that the lining of the Loader Mine with polyurethane foam should extend over a length of some 150 feet between the Loco Level and the Cable Belt Road. Verbal arrangements were made immediately with the Caledonian Mining Company to carry out the work. On 28th July, colliery workers, under the general supervision of company representatives, started to prepare the site and on 30th July machinery and material required for applying the foam were taken underground. J. Simpson, an under-manager, exercised control over the work when he returned from holiday on 31st July. Preparation of the site included the making of four recesses each about four feet wide and two feet deep cut into the sides of the roadway to provide adequate sealing for the foam lining. Simpson Found no signs of heating but decided to play safe and have the four recesses treated with polyurethane foam immediately. With the resumption of production at the colliery following the annual holiday, however, the actual work of spraying the foam had to be restricted to the night shift from 31st July, because the application of polyurethane foam constituted a hazard to health while spraying was in progress.

32. C. V. Peake, deputy managing director of the Caledonian Mining Company, explained that the work of foam application in the Loader Mine was carried out in accordance with the requirements of the National Coal Board Production Department Information Bulletin No. 65/253. The polyurethane used had been ordered from the manufacturers by reference to the Board's specification; this included a provision requiring a flame inhibitor to be incorporated in the polyurethane mix. The foam was applied in two coats, giving a total thickness of about one inch, In the first instance no mention was apparently made by any of those concerned about the need for the applied foam to be treated with a coating of a fire-retardant material as indicated in para. 5(ii)(c) of the Bulletin. On 3rd August, however, the management arranged with the Caledonian Mining Company for the coating to be applied as soon as the foam work was complete. The material necessary for this was delivered to the colliery, but, for reasons which I shall explain later, it was never used.

Subsequent Inspections

33. The work of applying the foam was completed on the night shift of 5th-6th August. Shortly after this, Barker inspected the polyurethane foam lining and found it satisfactory; there were in fact one or two very small holes around some cable hangers but these he took to be of no consequence. A few days earlier he had travelled the return airway in the vicinity of the Loader Mine with J. S. Wilson, production manager. They inspected the stopping at the junction of the return airway and No. 3 Heading and found no carbon monoxide. At that time the stopping had not been breached with a view to filling any voids but some pipes and pumps had nevertheless been installed to facilitate the performance of this work as soon as it could be started. At about 1.30 p.m. on 8th September, M. R. Bottomley, H.M. Inspector of Mines and Quarries, in the course of an inspection for another purpose, travelled through the Loader Mine, had a quick look at the foam, passed his hand over parts of the surface and considered it to be satisfactory. He did not see, smell, or feel anything indicative of spontaneous combustion. There was no fire-retardant coating on the surface but it was his understanding that this was to be applied when other foam work in the Dysart Dip No. 1 Section, to which I shall refer later, had been completed.

Contract arrangements

34. The decision having been taken that the work of lining the Loader Mine with foam should be carried out quickly, the parties concerned — the management and the Caledonian Mining Company — agreed to dispense with the normal formalities of obtaining a quotation and drawing up formal contract documents. Instead, they agreed that the work should be carried out under a verbal contract based on the N.C.B. Information Bulletin mentioned above. Later there was an exchange of letters to this effect. A. Cairns, mining engineer, special duties, measured the work for payment on 17th August.

35. The parties to this verbal contract considered that the Information Bulletin did not specifically require the surface, to which the polyurethane foam was to be applied, should be treated with a lining of fire-retardant material. For this reason, it was explained that the work ordered to be done in the first instance was restricted simply to the application of foam. By omitting any reference to an application of fire-retardant material beneath the foam, the management had already settled by implication that this was not necessary, because the Loader Mine was already lined with concrete slabs and fire-resistant boards. It was arranged on the 3rd August that the work to be undertaken by the Caledonian Mining Company of applying a coating of fire-retardant material on the polyurethane when foam spraying of the latter was complete, should be the subject of another verbal contract.

The Fire in the Dysart Dip No. 1 Section

36. On 6th August, the day after the completion of the foam treatment of the Loader Mine, a fire occurred in the Dysart Dip No. 1 Section. The management considered this to be a greater risk to the safety of the mine than the Loader Mine, which was now treated with polyurethane foam, and decided to have the Dysart Dip No. 1 Section main gate treated in the same way. They deferred the work of lining the foam in the Loader Mine in accordance with the arrangements which had been made three days before, concentrated their efforts on applying polyurethane foam in the Dysart Dip No. 1 Section and completed this early on the night shift of 8th-9th September.

The Night Shift of 8th-9th September

37. Following the fire in the Dysart Dip No. 1 Section, an increased number of air samples were taken daily under special arrangements designed to give information about the effectiveness of the fire-fighting measures taken there. On 8th September, a carbon monoxide analysing and recording device installed in the Section was tested satisfactorily and, as a result, the special arrangements for sampling were discontinued in favour of the normal sampling pattern. To avoid the misleading effects of carbon monoxide produced by shot firing, the usual practice was for samples to be taken daily at the end of the night shift. D. C. Dryburgh, a deputy engaged on special duties, was instructed to this effect when he went on night shift on the evening of 8th September, and he planned to coiled his samples at about 5.00 a.m.

38. At about midnight, Dryburgh travelled along the Loco Level and went through the No. 6 Heading into the main return. Walking along the return, he passed the stopping to No. 3 Heading, and came out through the No. 2 Heading. He had some experience of spontaneous heating, but, in the course of his inspection in the vicinity of the Loader Mine, he neither smelt nor saw anything which gave him cause for concern.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z