|
VI. — General Conclusions.Point of Origin and Cause of Ignition. — I am of opinion that this explosion originated in No. 13 level somewhere between Nos. 1 and 2 topholes, and that it was caused by the flame of an open acetylene lamp coming in contact with an explosive mixture of firedamp and air that had accumulated at the rise side of the level which was thickly timbered. The volume of the explosive mixture was probably small, but lying on the timber there must have been much very fine, and practically pure, coal dust with which the gas was closely in contact and this dust was the cause of the explosion spreading both along the level and into the No. 2 tophole. Coal Dust. — No precautions were taken against the dangers of coal dust. Some parts of the mine were undoubtedly extremely wet and on this ground, according to the evidence given by the mine officials, they did not consider it was necessary to take precautions against coal dust. In my opinion, the levels and the crossings between the topholes should have been treated with stone dust, in accordance with the provisions of the General Regulations of July 30th, 1920, as amended November 20th, 1924. It is probable that had this been done the explosion would have been confined to narrower limits and fewer lives have been lost as a result of it. Ventilation by Compressed Air. — The method of ventilating the faces of the levels and the immediately adjacent topholes by compressed air is no doubt much more convenient than the use of either bratticing or air pipes for this purpose. But, although there is nothing in the Coal Mines Act to preclude its use and, apparently, until the day of the explosion it had proved to be an adequate means of ventilation, in my opinion, it is not to be recommended. The supply, especially where, as in this case, quite a number of machines depend upon it for their motive power, is apt to be irregular and spasmodic. For this reason it is unreliable and if, as I consider was the fact here, firedamp is being emitted constantly, even if only slowly, a temporary cessation or interruption of the normal supply of compressed air is likely to result sooner or later in contamination of the atmosphere. The use of Acetylene Lamps in Naked Light Mines. — I have already discussed (page 17) the possibility of the ignition of coal dust directly at the flame of an acetylene lamp and given my reasons for thinking that such an occurrence is extremely unlikely under mining conditions. At an early stage of the investigation of the explosion the Miners’ Agents, Messrs. S. O. and D. L. Davies, raised also the question of the possibility of the explosion having been initiated by the ignition of an explosive mixture of acetylene and air, produced by the escape of acetylene from the burner of an extinguished lamp or from a defective generator coming in contact with the flame of another lamp. Apparently, suspicion was aroused by a damaged lamp which was said to have been found attached to the clothing on the body of Thomas Hughes at the foot of No. 2 tophole. A seam of the generator of this lamp had split open part of the way round and the carbide inside was exposed. It is of course not known when or how the defect in the lamp developed, but there is little doubt that Hughes came hurriedly down the tophole probably in the dark after the explosion and if, which is not at all certain, he was carrying this lamp it is not unlikely it was damaged in the descent or by falling from the chute on to the floor of the level. In Section IV of this report I have definitely stated that in my opinion the explosion was initiated by firedamp, and I do not think that acetylene had anything to do with it. There remains, however, the general question of possible danger arising from the use of acetylene lamps in mines. The report by Dr. Wheeler (Appendix IV) includes data in respect of these acetylene lamps which, in my opinion, should allay any suspicion in regard to them. Whilst a full charge of carbide could produce 2.5 cubic feet of acetylene if all the gas were emitted instantaneously, normally, the gas is produced in the lamp at the rate of no more than about 1/8 to 1/5 cubic foot per hour, the latter being the consumption by a "flaring" flame. The gas is only emitted from carbide when it is in contact with water, and since the water supply is carefully regulated, it is evident that the possibility of an escape of gas in dangerous quantity is so remote as to be negligible. It may be of interest also to note that acetylene has no toxic effects on the human system. In conclusion, I have gratefully to acknowledge the courtesy extended to me by the able representatives of the interested parties throughout the Inquiry. My thanks are also due to Mr. T. Ashley, His Majesty’s Divisional Inspector of Mines, and to his Assistants, whose investigations and evidence did so much to aid me in arriving at a conclusion as to the cause of the explosion; to Dr. R. V. Wheeler who gave valuable evidence at the Inquiry and later kindly undertook the tests of the density of the dust clouds produced in the workings; to the Colliery Officials and to the representatives of the Workmen whose evidence, too, was most useful in helping to arrive at the cause of the disaster. I have the honour to be, Sir, Your obedient Servant, F. H. Wynne, His Majesty’s Deputy Chief Inspector of Mines.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||