II. — Narrative Of The Accident.
The explosion occurred in No. 13 level of the West District at about 7 p.m. on Thursday, 28th November.
Up to this time work on the afternoon shift had proceeded quite normally. The day fireman, John Henry Daniel, had examined the workings within two hours of the afternoon shift, commencing work at 3 p.m. and had reported everything to be in order. The afternoon fireman, Henry Rees, had completed his first round of inspection of the West District at about 4.30 p.m., and had met with nothing to cause him concern. Further, the shotfirer, Stephen John, had been round the district and had inspected the face of 13 level where he fired a shot at about 5.30 p.m., and he too found everything in order.
The effects of the explosion were confined to the small area of workings lying between Nos. 12 and 13 levels of the West -District. Plan 2 is a plan on an enlarged scale of this area. The plan shows details of the effects of the explosion as observed the day after the occurrence. It also shows (a) the positions of the bodies of the seven men killed as they lay when they were recovered; and (b) the supposed disposition of the men employed in No. 13 level and Nos. 1 and 2 topholes immediately or shortly before the explosion.
Of the eight men employed in No. 13 level, of whom six were colliers and two were trammers, six were killed. The seventh man killed was Thomas Jones, a collier whose working place was at the face of the main west slant but who was in No. 13 level seeking timber when he was overtaken by the blast. The two men who escaped were Arthur Williams, one of the two trammers engaged in filling coal at the foot of the topholes and the face of the level and tramming it thence to the double parting at the slant, and David John Lewis, one of the, colliers ordinarily working at the face of the level. Lewis escaped the main effects of the explosion by a fortuitous circumstance which had caused him at the critical time to be away from his post. From these men, and others engaged in the slant both above and below No. 13 level and in the workings of No. 12 level, it has been possible to obtain information regarding the effects of the explosion on the borders of the area to which its more serious effects were confined. Arthur P. Williams was standing in the double parting in No. 13 level about seven yards inbye from the slant, and Lewis was in the slant a few yards above this level, at a valve in the compressed air main, when there was a "tremendous blast of wind" which put out their lights and knocked both of them over. Williams stated that he also noticed a small flame over his head and he was burned on the back, shoulders and arms and his hair was singed. Lewis, in the slant, felt nothing but the blast. The experiences of others rather further afield were similar; they felt a rush of wind and their lights were extinguished by the concussion.
The four persons working in the slant below No. 13 level made their way out as soon as they had recovered from the temporary shock. As has already been stated their lights were extinguished and they had to grope their way up the incline in the dark. One of them, the filler Andrew Gwyther, had been injured by falling in the slant when the blast struck him, and required some assistance. On reaching No. 13 level shouts were heard and one of the party, John Sambrook, went in to the parting and assisted Arthur Williams out.
David John Lewis, to whom I have already referred, was in the slant a little higher up, where he had gone to turn on more air at the stopcock in the compressed air main which served No. 13 level. He felt a blast of air which put his light out and he was thrown down. When Sambrook and the others reached him, he joined them and they all proceeded up the slant and finally without much difficulty reached No. 11 level where in due course, as will be described below, they were met by the fireman, Henry Rees, coming from the East District.
At the moment of the explosion a set of full trains was being drawn up the slant in charge of a rider, Trevor Guy, who was riding on the haulage rope at the front of the set. Guy stated that the set had reached a point about 15 or 20 yards from the landing at the top of the slant and had stopped momentarily for want of pressure at the haulage engine, as was not unusual at this point where the gradient slightly increases, when he felt a gust of wind and his light was put out; he heard no noise and saw no flame. He relighted his lamp and went to the back of the set to see if anything had happened to it. Finding nothing wrong he walked up the slant to No. 11 level and there met the haulier, John William Hughes, with whom he was having a conversation when they saw lights down the slant. Proceeding down the slant Guy and Hughes at No. 12 level met Sambrook and the others coming up.
Further light is thrown on the subject by Daniel Davies, the engineman in charge of the Main West Slant haulage engine, situated in a recess at the rise-side of No. 9 level, see plan 1. He corroborated the statement of Guy that the set had stopped a short distance below the landing at the top of the slant and that the reason for this was a shortage of air. The engine was still standing when he heard a little noise which at first he thought was caused by a fall. He restarted the engine but stopped it again at once on receiving a signal. He waited some time for a signal to go on, but as none came he went out of the engineroom to investigate. He then found that the separation door in the slant just below No. 9 level (see plan 1) was open and concluded the noise he had heard was caused by the door being blown open. He closed the door and returned to his engine. After a further wait he became anxious and was going down to the door again when he met Trevor Guy coming up the slant to him.
In No. 12 level apparently the effects of the explosion were less manifest than in the lower parts of the district. The extinction of lights caused momentary concern only, for after relighting them the men there proceeded to get their mid-shift meal and only became alarmed when smoke appeared in the air current. They immediately made their way out through topholes to No. 11 level and thence outbye to the Main West Slant.
It is as well at this stage to consider the movements of the fireman, Henry Rees, the only official normally in the mine during the afternoon shift. Rees, at the moment of the explosion, was on his way round the workings of the East District. While engaged with two colliers there he felt a peculiar sensation in his ears. He said in evidence "My ears felt blocked". He remarked to the colliers, "It must have fallen in the rippings". He went out, however, to see what had happened and eventually reached No. 11 level at the bottom of the No. 2 slant where he met Andrew Gwyther. Further West in No. 11 level he met some more men and was informed by them that something had happened in No. 13 level and that the men from there were "behind" (meaning apparently that they had not come out). He passed on and at the Main West Slant encountered Sambrook and others who were putting Arthur Williams into a tram. He gave instructions for Williams to be looked after and sent up to the surface. He tried first to go down the slant, but afterdamp prevented him from going as far as No. 12 level. Returning to the top he tried to go along No. 11 level to the fan, but here too bad air barred his progress. He came back to the slant, and gave orders to telephone for the manager (it would have been better to have done this earlier and before attempting the exploration described above), a rescue party and some lamps. He then sent a party of men to put a sheet in the East level so as to force as much as possible of the intake air into the West District. Accompanied by two workmen, he then proceeded up the slant to No. 9 level and along that level to the tophole which was the return airway for the West District. The air here was good, so he returned to the slant and renewed his effort to get down to No. 12 level, but could not do so.
A further attempt to get to the fan in No. 11 level was also unsuccessful. Returning again to the slant he met the manager, Mr. Phillips, and other helpers who had arrived in response to the telephone message. With some difficulty the fan was reached and was found to be ineffective on account of some obstruction to the motor. The obstruction having been removed, the ventilation of the workings below No. 11 level was partially restored and a party led by the manager proceeded down the slant to No. 13 level where the bodies of two persons lying in the parting were recovered. Afterdamp which was still hanging in the level prevented further progress, until the Rescue Brigade arrived. Wearing rescue apparatus the Brigade recovered the remaining five bodies without any difficulty.
Death in every case was due to poisoning by carbon monoxide.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.