II. Character Of The Seam And Method Of Working It.
Past experience has shown that the Seven Feet seam, of which a typical section is shown in Plate 1, as well as the Eight Feet and Bullhurst seams, are particularly prone to spontaneous combustion, heatings having occurred both in the pillars before any drifting was commenced and also in the wastes. Records kept during the past 28 years show that during this period no less than 21 districts have been sealed off in consequence of spontaneous combustion. Of these 4 were in the Bullhurst, 5 in the Eight Feet and 12 in the Seven Feet.
With the exception of the present instance no explosion has made itself manifest, nor has any life been lost in connection with a gob fire in this mine.
The figures above indicate that of the three seams the Seven Feet is the most liable to this trouble, and the management appear to have been fully alive to the danger. The seam is thick (10 feet excluding one foot of coal next the floor), the roof is strong and the pavement weak with the result that the floor readily lifts with much disintegration of the coal and fireclay composing it, thus exposing a considerable area of coal surface to the oxidising action of the air.
The seam is gassy but not excessively so, and with a normal current of fresh air no serious difficulty has been experienced in the past in keeping the working places in a proper condition for work to be carried on in them.
The workings are dry and dusty, as is almost inevitable in a thick seam at such a depth, and at an inclination which entails much transport by self acting inclines and much breakage of the coal in the process of getting and loading.
From time to time three methods of working this seam have been practised, viz.,
(1) A modified Longwall system,
(2) The Breasting system, and
(3) The Heading and Drifting or "Rearer" System.
At the time of the explosion the seam in Wakefield's Dip District was being worked on the Heading and Drifting or "Rearer" system. Plate 1 illustrates clearly the application of the system in both its stages, namely, the heading stage as shown in the lower panel called the "Bottom Shunt" section, and the drifting stage as shown in the upper panel or "Top Shunt" section. The first or heading stage consists essentially of driving out to the boundary, barrier or some arbitrary distance a pair of opening out Levels from 10 to 15 yards apart, the lower one being the main level and the upper one the top or air-heading. From these roadways or levels, at distances varying from 80 to 120 yards apart, pairs of dips are driven up to a boundary, a barrier, upper levels or goaf, as the case may be, so as to form panels of workings. By means of level headings driven from these dips the panel is split up into pillars, from 10 to 12 yards in thickness, which are afterwards worked out by drifting, commencing at the top of the panel and working downwards to the main level.
This system of working highly inclined thick seams has been in vogue many years and was originally developed merely as a safe and economical method of extracting the coal.
As time went on and the seams — exhausted at shallower — came to be worked at greater depths the additional difficulty of spontaneous combustion in the goaf cropped up. The exercise of reason, together with practical experience, suggested that if an atmosphere sufficiently deficient in oxygen could be maintained in the goaf the danger from heating and gob-fire would be materially minimised. A further development of the "Rearer" system of working was then evolved, having in view the maintenance of a more or less inert atmosphere, consisting mainly of firedamp, in the goaf. To attain this end, the dips from which the pillars were to be formed were terminated not at the lower level of the old panel next above, but at some distance therefrom, so that a substantial barrier of coal was left at the rise side of the new panel. And the new panel had leading into it only two roads which were situated at the lowest outbye corner of it. This system was departed from to some extent in Wakefield's Dip District in that the upper or "Top Shunt" section was pierced by two old roadways, which had been sealed with stoppings, near the top right hand corner of it. This is evident on reference to Plate 2. The departure from the usually accepted procedure is referred to later (page 20).
The "Rearer" system of working has a further advantage, it affords facilities for rapidly isolating a fire should one threaten or actually break out in a panel, for only two stoppings require to be erected to effect this purpose, and the isolation can be completed with a minimum of loss of workable coal since only the single panel is affected by the isolation.
It is usual at an early stage in the development of a panel to erect in the two opening out levels preparatory stoppings which are in effect partially completed stoppings in which an aperture is left no larger than is necessary to permit the passage of tubs. Materials for the immediate completion of these stoppings are kept constantly close at hand. In any event, the stoppings are completed without delay upon the exhaustion of the coal in the panel.
Of the two sections of Wakefield's Dip District it will be observed that the upper or "Top Shunt" panel was rapidly approaching complete exhaustion. Only six small pillars remained to be worked above the air heading and three larger ones along the head side of the main level. One jig or self acting incline, known as Kelsall's Dip, was in use and the output from the working places, of which there were but three, all came down it. Operations in the "Bottom Shunt" panel were confined to heading out. The stage of the extraction of pillars had not yet been reached. Above and inbye of the pillars being worked to Kelsall's dip, there existed goaf or waste covering an area of about five acres.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.