|
III. Narrative Of Events Leading Up To The Explosion.The explosion occurred on the afternoon shift at about 4.15 p.m. on 18th December, 1925, somewhere in the neighbourhood of Kelsall's Dip in the "Top Shunt" panel. The number of miners (colliers) at work in Kelsall's Dip on the Friday afternoon was five and they were allocated to three places. See Plate ? — Nos. 1, 10, 11, 12 and 13. Two colliers were also engaged in repairing the air heading near to Wakefield's back dip. See Plate ? — Nos. 14 and 15. During the morning shift no indications of heating had been observed, work had proceeded normally in every respect, and nothing had happened to cause serious anxiety in the working places. Towards the end of this shift, however, something happened which it is necessary and desirable should be described at some length. At about 1 p.m. Gerrard Harris Forrester, an assistant surveyor, who during the morning had been engaged at a survey in another part of the pit, decided, before ascending the shaft, to go down the West Winpenny Back Slant to see how some repair work was going on at the bottom thereof. Passing through the main separation doors near No. 18 Pit bottom he noticed an unusual smell in the return air. His replies to questions in chief on this point were as follows :— 557. Q. The Coroner: Did you notice anything? — A. I noticed a different sort of smell in the air; it was different from what it usually is. 558. Q. Was it gob stink? — A. I could not exactly explain it. It was different from the usual smell in that return and as a matter of fact I put it down then to oil on the haulage rope. 559. Q. Did you say anything about it to anybody? — A. No, not then. 560. Q. And where did you go afterwards? — A. I went down the Return Slant to the bottom. 561. Q. Did you notice any smell there? — A. No 562. Q. Did you notice a different smell anywhere else ? — A. No, not then. I went down there to see the man who was working at the bottom — Albert Hughes — and when I got down there the telephone rang, and I answered it, and the pump man who had gone up on the journey that I came down on asked me if I would go. out into the intake at the bottom of the Main Slant and ask them to start the pump there. So I went to ask them to start the pump, and they did so. Then I came back again up into the Return. 563. Q. What time would that be ? — A. 1.20 to 1.30. I noticed a smell then when I came out of the intake into the Return. 564. Q. What did you put that down to? — A. It was the same smell I had smelt up at the top. 565. Q. Did you put it down to the same reason? — A. No. because I was on the in-bye side of the rope. I did not know what it was so I followed it. And in reply to Mr. Boydell 602. Q. You got to the bottom of the West Winpenny Slant and there you found Albert Hughes ? — A. Yes. NOTE. — Albert Hughes was a spare fireman temporarily engaged as a repairer in the slant, and at Forrester's request he took part in an examination of the airway to the top of the dirt jig in the return from Wakefield's District, see Plates 1 and 2. 603. Q. And after you had been through the separation doors into the Main Intake Airway where you washed your lungs out, so to speak, you returned to the Return? — A. Yes. 604. Q. And you got a smell which arrested your thoughts, and you compared it with a smell which you had got at the top of the dip through the first separation doors nearer the pit bottom ? — A. Yes. 605. Q. The smell at the bottom of the dip was more intense than that which you got through the doors nearer the pit bottom ? — A. No, I think it was about the same. 606. Q. But it was such that you called upon Albert Hughes to come to you and confirm your suspicions ? — A. Yes, I asked Albert Hughes to come with his safety lamp as I had not got one. 607. Q. Did Albert Hughes then go through the separation doors to wash his lungs out, so to speak ? — A. Yes. 608. Q. And when he came back did you ask him what he thought the smell was like ? — A. I asked him if he smelt anything, and he said he did. 609. Q. What did he say it was like? — A. He said he thought it was gob stink. * * * * * 620. Q. And what did Hughes say at that point? — A. I asked Albert to test there, but we got nothing; I tested with the lamp there. 621. Q. On the West side? — A. Yes. 622. Q. The smell was there? — A. Yes. 623. Q. And did Hughes say it was much stronger at this point or words to that effect ? — A. I think he did. 624. Q. He thought the smell was more persistent at that point? — A. Yes. 625. Q. Did he suggest to you that you should waste no time in getting out and reporting to some higher official such as the Under Manager ? — A. No. Hughes' account of his experience is interesting for comparison with that of Forrester. His replies to questions in chief are quoted as follows :— 919. Q. Where did you see Forrester ? — A. Bottom of the riding dip — the big slant. 920. Q. Tell us in his own words, what did he say to you? — A. He went past me in the first place, and came back in a short time and said "Albert, do you mind coming back with me with your safety lamp?" I said I would, and as we were going down he said, Can you smell anything different in the air"? I said, "No." He said, "Go through those three doors and get a mouth of fresh air." I did so, and came back. He said, "Now can you smell anything"? I said, "Yes, I can smell something different now." Of course, we went farther on then, tracing the smell. 921. Q. What sort of smell was it ? — A. A sulphury smell. 922. Q. What did you put it down to ? — A. I did not put it down to anything particular, only something wrong, something unusual. 923. Q. Did you put it down to gob stink ? — A. No, I did not. 924. Q. You proceeded where; how far did you get down ? — A. We went to the Bullhurst. We tested to see whether we could find any gas or anything there. We could not. Of course, we lost the smell in that heading and came back again to the Eight Feet. We picked it up as we were going on the Eight Feet stopping, and lost it again there. We tried for gas again. It was clear. We came back and picked the smell up again at the Seven Feet junction; went in the east side, lost it again. Then we proceeded and picked it up again on the junction, went into the west side past the dip, the short jig, to the stopping. We lost it there, and came back again to the dip, the short jig, and picked it up again Forrester and Hughes then discussed the position and finally it was agreed between them that Forrester should find the undermanager and make a report to him. As it happened the first responsible official he came in touch with was an overman, George Wilcox, who had in the course of his duties during the morning been round all the places, including the back dip in Wakefield's district and who described his itinerary in these words 1515. Q. The Coroner: You were in on that fatal Friday? — A. Yes. 1516. Q. What time? — A. I started from the pit level at nine o'clock and travelled by way of the separation doors at the top of the seven feet slant down the return to Wakefield's Dip. After visiting a place on the west side level I measured up the work done by Simms and Brayford. They were working in the back dip posting up and flitching.* From there I went along the top heading to Kelsall's Place. I measured the work done there, and went across the landing to Isaac Ball's Place. I measured the work done there. From there I went to Owen's Place. The left-hand side, of course I visited first. That is not working. It is standing temporarily. After examining the brake landing across to Owen's drift I went further on past Owen's drift, 35 yards I went into the goaf. 1517. Q. Upwards? — A. Straight along the level. 1518. Q. Did you notice any gob stink ? — A. None whatever, Sir. 1519. Q. Did you notice anything abnormal in any shape or way ? — A. Nothing unusual; quite normal, Sir. Wilcox received Forrester's report. He told Forrester to go and inform the undermanager, George William Lowe, while he himself proceeded to explore the return airway. Retracing his steps he met Lowe at the top of the West Slant and without any delay Lowe and Wilcox, taking Forrester with them, proceeded together to the West Slant return. The time was then about 2.5 p.m. On reaching the top of the West Slant return the party found the day shift, including the day fireman, just getting out of the train in which they had ridden up the incline. Lowe asked the fireman if everything was all right in the district and received a reply in the affirmative. Neither the fireman nor any of the men with him made any complaint of any unusual smell, which, if any existed, one would have expected them to have noticed, seeing that they had come outbye in the return from the bottom of the slant. Apparently, at this time the unusual smell, which barely an hour previously had alarmed Forrester and Hughes, had now disappeared. Nevertheless, a further examination of the return was made by Lowe, Wilcox and Forrester. They retraced the path already followed by Forrester and Hughes but noticed nothing to cause them any anxiety. At the conclusion of the investigation, i.e., when they had reached the top of Wakefield's back dip, Forrester apologised for raising a false alarm, being now convinced that there was no unusual smell. Accordingly, it was not deemed necessary to prevent the afternoon shift from proceeding to their work. All these witnesses were quite frank and straightforward and there is no reason for casting doubt on their veracity. At the same time, it is impossible to dissociate the smell which Forrester experienced, roughly from 1 p.m. to 1.30 p.m. and the explosion which occurred 2½ or 3 hours later. The afternoon fireman, Amos Whalley, was informed by the undermanager of the inspections that had been made and undertook specially to look round for anything wrong in connection with the brattice cloths, or with the ventilation or the gas. * i.e. widening the roadway.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||