|
5. Arrangements For Ventilating Points Where Sealing Off Operations Were In Progress.Plan I shows how the ventilating currents were conducted into the various districts of the mine and what the volumes of air were when last measured on July 13th, 1923; I think it may be assumed that the figures on the plan are fairly representative of the quantities of air passing up to the 16th July when the ordinary working of the Colliery was suspended. I have already recorded that on the 18th July, with a view to reducing the volume of fresh air passing into the fire area, the Ventilating Fan was slowed and the water gauge thereby reduced first from 4.5 to 2.5 and later in the day to 1.5. After this reduction had been made, an inspection revealed a considerable body of firedamp accumulating in the North West District. I have already described how, in order to dispel this gas without increasing the volume of air travelling into the fire district, a regulator or block was put in the East return airway, and the speed of the fan was increased gradually, over a period of an hour and a half, from 12½ to 50 revolutions. This regulator naturally reduced the quantity of air passing through the ventilating district in which it had been placed, and, the agent considering that the air had been too much reduced, the regulator was eased by a brick or two being taken out each side of it to enable more air to circulate. The quantity of air then passing into the fire area was not measured. The air current which travelled in by the East Plane as far as No. 11's was split there. One portion of the split passed into the South East District; the other portion of the split passed along the face between 95's and 53's crossgates into the fire area in the Middle East and Low East districts, and thence into 21's return airway or out by the North East intake airway which, by reason of the fire, had again become a return. This was the course of the air when the preparations for erecting the stoppings Al and A2 were commenced. During the joint inspection on Sunday, 22nd Jury, and at the joint conference afterwards, when a decision was come to as to the future steps to be taken, the question of ventilating the places in which stoppings were to be erected was discussed, although at first Mr. Pickering when examined by Mr. Wynne had no recollection of the discussion. Q. Mr. Pickering, have you no recollection at all of any discussion as to means of ventilating all those places at that meeting on Sunday night ? — A. No I have not, sir. Q. Of course we realise you had gone through a lot before that in the pit, but I will try if I can to refresh your memory. Can you remember anything being said with regard to the facilities we had at 21's for getting more air up? — A. Yes, I do remember some discussions on that point, that it would be quite easy for us to bring fresh air up to 21's stopping. Q. That was part of the discussion, I think. Again, with regard to 7's stopping and the possibility of bringing plenty of fresh air up the converted intake? — A. Yes, from 5's. Q. Those two seemed to be simple matters ? — A. Quite. Q. Can you not recollect any reference to the possible difficulties arising at 53's and 37's and being dealt with by bratticing ? — A. I cannot, sir; I am sorry, but I cannot. On this same point Mr. Ross said that he remembered "very vividly" that, when Mr. Herbert Smith made some remarks about the ventilation, Mr. Butler described how he would take the ventilation up 95's crossgate and down along the face. Mr. Ross also stated that he remembered Mr. Herbert Smith saying that, as far as the Mines Act was concerned, it was to be carried out and every precaution taken for safety. Mr. Butler, however, had no recollection of this. When cross-examined by Mr. Herbert Smith the manager was questioned as under. Q. Do you think that at that conference there was anything suggested about great care and safety being taken with these men because we had an enemy in front of us that we knew about ? — A. Well that was the object of the conference. Q. Did you hear anything from me in that respect? — A. I did. I cannot remember word for word what it was. Q. And do you remember this, that I said — Before there is going to be any agreement about men going to work on behalf of our side we are going to have an understanding that every care is going to be taken and the Mines Act strictly carried out? — A. I remember that. Mr. Dunn during his examination stated that he raised the question of ventilation during the joint inspection and remembered Mr. Herbert Smith's remark that: "The ventilation had been somewhat disturbed in consequence of the explosions between the 17th and 19th July, and was like a lot of sheep — uncontrolled and unharnessed round that district." Mr. Jackson, the General Manager, when cross examined by Mr. H. Smith, could not remember anything he (Mr. Smith) had said at the conference on the 22nd with regard to the ventilation. In my opinion it was proved that, during the conference at which it was agreed to bring back men for the purpose of erecting stoppings, it was stated that attention was required and would be given to those places where work would have to be carried out, so that the operations could be performed "in as little danger as possible." These were the words used in the note issued by the Miners' Representatives after the termination of the Conference. As shown by the instructions issued to the officials by Mr. Pickering (see pages 15 to 17), the method adopted for carrying ventilation into the affected area was to lay an 8-inch steel pipe throughout the whole length of the stopping A1. There were, in addition, through this stopping two 2-inch pipes and a ½-inch pipe: the former intended for use ultimately for the purpose of introducing inert gas into the fire area, and the latter for the purpose of taking gas samples. On the return side an 8-inch pipe was inserted in the stopping C, in addition to a 2-inch and a ½-inch pipe. These three pipes were practically the only outlet for any air which, as operations progressed, could pass the region in which A1 and A2 stoppings were being erected. This was the position of the ventilation at A1 and A2 on the day, of the disaster; for on the Thursday the stoppings had been made up to the roof, and although, as I have already related, the door in 95's crossgate was finally opened and kept open, and screens were erected elsewhere to force as much air as was possible under that system up 95's face, I do not see how these measures could materially improve the ventilation at the stoppings, since there was no passage for the air in that direction except the limited area provided by the openings through the 8-inch air pipe, the two 2-inch inert gas pipes and the ½-inch air sampling pipe. On the other hand, these measures were likely to cause firedamp to accumulate in the rear of the point where the men were working; indeed 4 per cent. of firedamp was found on the low side of 95's, and the place was fenced off to prevent persons from inadvertently travelling in that direction. On the morning of the explosion, a very short time before the explosion occurred, steps were taken to conduct more ventilation up 95's crossgate and down the face by putting a sheet across the East Main Plane; but no steps were taken or contemplated, even at that time, to conduct any more air beyond 95's crossgate. The emergency which arose as regards the ventilation was in fact not anticipated by the management, and no plans or preparations for meeting such an emergency adequately were made. On this point Mr. George Watkins, overman, was examined by Mr. Wynne as follows :— Q. Now, Mr. Watkins, previous to the commencement of work on these stoppings, you and your colleagues, I presume, would talk things over amongst yourselves? — A. Yes, sir. Q. Did you discuss at all the difficulties that were likely to arise, in. 53's and 37's in regard to ventilation? — A. Yes, sir, we had them over. Q. Did you discuss amongst yourselves what steps might be necessary to keep those places ventilated ? — A. Well, those, had been taken by the 8-inch pipe being put through the stopping. Q. That proved sufficient up to a point, apparently ? — Yes, sir. Q. But it failed on Friday afternoon? — A. Must have done, sir. Q. And you had to take some further steps? — A. Yes, sir, we had, yes. Q. Which you have related — the door in 95's and the sheets. Those steps failed apparently ? — A. Not for the time being; they were quite efficient. Q. Not for the time being, I quite agree. From the reports apparently they failed towards Saturday morning ? — A. Yes. Q. Do you think when these steps had failed like that the proceedings should have been stopped until other steps were taken ? — A. Yes, sir, when it got to that. Q. What other steps might have been taken, in your opinion ? — A. What other steps might have been taken? Well, as long as there was too much gas, for anybody to work in easy and safe, the men should have been withdrawn. That is, when it got to the 6 per cent. at which I understand they were withdrawn. Q. We will take it at the extremes, if we can. Supposing it had been found impossible to reduce that percentage of gas. What would the position have been then ? — A. Well, of course, we do not look at things as impossible. We have to try methods to remedy them, and we should have had, to try to adopt some methods. Q. We will go back to that point, then. What other measures could have been adopted to remove it. You had already had your pipe in the stopping; you had taken your door out at 95's, you had put sheets on the gates in 95's crossgate. What could you do in addition ? — A. Well, of course, the quantity might be such that we should have tried to remove the gas; it would have to be piped out. Q. That is a practical suggestion? — A. Yes. Q. Will you just describe to us how such a suggestion could have been carried out ? — A. Well, we should have had to get length of pipe enough to reach from 95's crossgate right into the stoppings. Q. Had such a policy been considered, as far as you know, until this moment, by you or anybody else ? — A. Oh, I do not know, sir. Of course, up to this, as far as things had progressed, the ventilation had been fairly reasonable under those circumstances. That is, with the 8-inch pipe and the two 2-inch pipes, carrying decent ventilation through the stoppings; so, therefore, the occasion had not arisen not up to that point. Q. No. Of course, I am not asking you exactly the facts at the present. We are discussing pros and cons, you see. It is more or less theory; it is not quite theory, but it is approaching it. You suggested piping might have been a feasible means of reducing the gas up there ? — A. Yes, sir. Q. It had not occurred to you, previous at any rate to the shift you last worked on, that such a course might be necessary ? — A. No. You see, that was my first shift in going on to 53's crossgate. I had not been in the area before, not since the commencement of the stoppings. So, therefore, it had not arisen to put this problem to me previous to that; not up to then. The difficulties encountered and the methods adopted as regards ventilation at the sites of the stoppings on the return side of the fire area have already been indicated (page 19).
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 25 Aug 2023
|
Search |
|
|||