Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

I.M.E. Previous Return to Index Next I.M.E.
/   \

Volume 12 (XII), 1896-1897, published 1897

Mr. W. N. Atkinson (H. M. Inspector of Mines, Newcastle-under-Lyme) wrote that the essential part of Mr. Stuart's paper was the evolution of a theory concerning the manner in which coal-dust explosions were propagated. He had read Mr. Stuart's book on the Camerton explosion, where the evidence on which this theory was based was more fully set forth, but he was entirely unconvinced that any such mode of propagation as Mr. Stuart described actually took place, nor did he see the necessity of such a theory to account for all that was observed after a coal-dust explosion. He had investigated a great number of explosions both of fire-damp and coal-dust, some very minutely and others in a more cursory way, amongst the latter class being the explosions at Camerton and Timsbury. In no explosion had he seen indications which, in his opinion, lent any support to the idea that a coal-dust explosion "comprises numerous local explosions, separate in time and space, at irregular intervals." 14 It was easy to understand that differences in the quality of coal-dust, in chemical composition, fineness, purity, and dryness, would cause differences in the violence produced by its explosive combustion in air ; and also that the propagation of a dust explosion might be almost arrested by local lack or impurity of dust, and be then resumed with full force under more favourable conditions.

Nothing was more difficult to gauge than the absolute or relative force developed in a mine explosion, and Mr. Stuart seemed to have gone on the principle of attributing every striking evidence of violence, such as a broken door or tub, or a big fall of stone, to a local explosion. Such striking evidences of force were at once observed, but to prove the absence of force in the intervening portions of road was a much more difficult matter, and on this essential feature of the theory the observations cited by Mr. Stuart in his account of the Camerton explosion were far from sufficient to maintain the theory. He (Mr. W. N. Atkinson) had heard it stated after an explosion that there had been no force on a certain section of road, and on examination found that this conclusion had been drawn because of the absence of evidence of force, the observer having forgotten to consider that there was nothing there to leave traces of violence. The mere fact that timber remained in position was not a criterion that great force had not traversed the road ; much depended on how the timber was set. For instance, at Camerton, he observed, in the case of some of the timber which remained in position, that the posts were set in small recesses cut into the wall-sides, which would effectually preserve them from the force of a blast. When timber was once displaced, the amount of stone which fell bore no relation to the force of the explosion, as Mr. Stuart seemed to imagine, but depended on the nature of the roof. Uninjured full tubs, were not evidence of the absence of a force great enough to completely smash empty tubs. Neither Mr. Stuart's account of the Camerton explosion nor his own observations conveyed to his mind the conviction that there was any satisfactory evidence of the absence of force between the points described as the sites of local explosions, except at the point of origin of the explosion ; and the absence of force for some distance on each side of the point of origin of several previous explosions, initiated in the same way as that at Camerton, had been observed and described in a number of cases.

No estimate was made by Mr. Stuart of the time required for the slow propagation of the flame through the spaces separating the numerous supposed local explosions, if such separate explosions were usual in coal-dust explosions, they could not fail to have been observed in the large number of cases where men had escaped and described what they saw and heard of the explosions. At Camerton, the onsetter observed but one reversal of the air. The progress of the flame was supposed to be "comparatively slow" between the various local explosions, and this was supported by a curious observation on a tram of coal, between Nos. 5 and 6 explosions, at Camerton, from which it was said that about 60 lbs. of coal had disappeared in lumps of ¼lb. to 4 or 5 lbs. each, and as the fragments could not be found, Mr. Stuart concluded that they had been transformed into coke and fine carbon, the coke being deposited on two bars almost immediately above the tram from which the coal had disappeared. To effect this phenomenon the explosion must surely have halted altogether at this point, because lumps of coal weighing 4 or 5 lbs. would require quite an appreciable time to be converted into coke and fine carbon. It is difficult to understand how coke so produced could be deposited on bars in the position described, but it may be noted that while this was going on Mr. Stuart supposed there was still an incoming air-current. 15

He would not now attempt to follow Mr. Stuart in the description of the chemical processes which were described as resulting in the intermittent explosions, but on this part of the subject it would be interesting to have the opinion of chemists. He was at a loss to understand, however, why it was thought necessary to place "an explosive gas at disposal for disruptive action, without the production of carbon monoxide or carbon dioxide, and which did not yield these gases as products." 16

It appeared to be Mr. Stuart's opinion that carbon monoxide and dioxide were not formed by coal-dust explosions ; but according to Dr. Haldane's report on The Causes of Death in Colliery Explosions and Underground Fires, carbon monoxide was the most usual cause of death, and he had no doubt that this statement was correct.

He did not subscribe to Mr. Stuart's opinion that coal-dust explosions were arrested for want of oxygen, on roads containing sufficient oxygen for working purposes. Experiments made by Dr, Haldane and himself showed that, in the case of fire-damp, explosions easily occurred in atmospheres containing far less oxygen than was required to keep a lamp alight and until the contrary was proved, it appeared probable that such would also be the case with coal-dust. No doubt, the arrest of explosions on dry roads was a different question, and one requiring further investigation. It was usually difficult to locate the exact place where the flame of the explosion ceased, and it was reasonable to suppose that a considerable amount of dust would be carried by the rush of air or gases beyond that point, both of which considerations were disturbing factors in determining the nature of the dust where the flame ceased. Mr. Stuart said, "propagation of the explosions was observed to have been abruptly arrested in roads where dry coal-dust abounded." 17 He (Mr. Atkinson) had paid considerable attention to this point, and believed that in those cases where such a conclusion at first sight appeared probable, that the real cause of the stoppage of the explosion lay in the impure nature of the dust at such places. A case in point occurred at Timsbury. He was told that in certain districts the explosion had stopped on roads where there was much coal-dust, and went to see one of these places. After locating the place where it appeared most probable that the flame had ceased, he examined the dust, which at that place was practically confined to the floor. It appeared black and dry, and by a cursory examination would pass as coal-dust and small pieces of coal ; but a closer examination showed it to be largely mixed with shale. Examined in daylight, it was greyish-black in colour, and the majority of the particles large enough to show their composition were of a dark coloured shale. It was possible that there were other conditions which might determine the arrest of a coal-dust explosion on a dusty road, but it appeared very improbable that lack of oxygen should be the cause in an ordinary mine roadway, whether an intake or a return air-way.

In treating of the Camerton explosion, Mr. Stuart took up the subject as if that explosion was the first in which coal-dust had been the only agent. He said "fire-damp was an acknowledged danger ; but a large experience had failed to establish such a character for coal-dust, and the non-gaseous mines possessing a historical freedom from explosions, no opportunity had arisen to investigate the phenomena of an explosion in which coal-dust was the exclusive agent ;" and a few lines below, coal-dust was referred to as a "hidden danger in coal mining." 18 So far from being hidden, the danger of coal-dust had been widely acknowledged for some years previously, chiefly through the valuable researches of Mr. W. Galloway ; and since 1880 it had been contended, and was still maintained by himself and others, that some of the most disastrous modern mine explosions were due solely to coal-dust. Then as now, there were dissentients from that opinion, and so recently as 1892, when the possibility of an explosion in some of the non-gaseous mines in Somersetshire 19 was suggested, it was said to be "putting theory against the facts." 20 It was true that the explosion at Camerton was the first to be recorded in this county, as occurring in a mine reputed to be absolutely free from fire-damp, but in the United States of America it had previously been reported that more than one severe explosion had occurred in mines where fire-damp had never been detected. Since the explosion at Timsbury, the absolute freedom from fire-damp of the Somersetshire mines had been questioned.

Mr. M. Deacon (Alfreton) thought that the members of the Institution were indebted to Mr. Stuart for the trouble that he had taken in preparing such a valuable paper ; it raised several points which would be new to the minds of many of the members. The theory of separate explosions set up by Mr. Stuart was not clearly substantiated by the arguments, the principal of which were the intervals of disruption and the absence of mechanical effect upon the intervening roadways of the mine. Doubtless a variation in the constituents of the gases in the mine at different points would have the effect of varying the intensity of the explosion (or perhaps more correctly, in the case of coal-dust, "inflammation"), as it followed its course through the mine ; but without a continuation of the flame it was difficult to understand how Mr. Stuart accounted for the separate ignition of the successive explosions.

Mr. Stuart said that the records of the Camerton and Timsbury explosions had this value, that they demonstrated that explosions were produced in some cases by coal dust, and the processes were originated under ordinary conditions and operations. He (Mr. Deacon) did not quite agree with Mr. Stuart in these deductions, as he thought that coal-dust explosions were probably initiated by the firing of the resultant gases from the explosion. Certain qualities of blasting powder had been proved to yield a very large percentage of carbon monoxide, amounting in some cases to nearly 20 per cent. of the total of the resultant gases. This gas, if collected in a vessel, could be easily ignited by a lighted match being dropped into it, and if a little coal-dust were sprinkled into the vessel at the same time, a long extension of flame might be obtained. He would like to know whether the blasting powder used in the shots which were supposed to have created the Camerton and Timsbury explosions had been tested for resultant gases, and if so with what result?

With regard to the absence of evidence of mechanical force in certain portions of the mine, he (Mr. Deacon) thought that this, in many cases, might be due to the natural conditions of the mine, and to the absence of timber or any other substance forming a resistance to the force of the explosion. At Blackwell colliery, this was found to be the case, but the evidence of heat, which was apparent more or less along the whole length of roadways covered by the explosion, satisfied him in this case, at any rate, the flame was continuous throughout the whole extent of the roadways affected. There was no apparent evidence of separate explosions. Similar results were found at Blackwell to those at Camerton and Timsbury, in the small amount of damage done in the near proximity of the shot which was supposed to have caused the explosion. Three men and a horse, and some tubs of coal, were found about 90 feet distant from the point of the explosion on the out-bye side, none of which gave evidence of special mechanical disturbance ; but there was no satisfactory evidence that the gaseous movement was not as rapid at that point as at any point of the explosion. The men and the horse were all slightly burned.

He (Mr. Deacon) only agreed with Mr. Stuart in his theory of separate explosions in so far as "separate explosions" might be taken to mean a greater development of force at one point in the travel of the flame than at another.


14 Trans. Fed. Inst., vol. Xii., page 381.
15 Trans. Fed. Inst., vol. xii., pages 375 and 376.
16 Trans. Fed. Inst., vol. xii., page 378.
17 Ibid., vol. xii., page 379.
18 Coal-dust an Explosive agent, page viii.
19 First Report of the Royal Commission on Explosions from Coal-dust, page 176.
20 Transactions of the National Association of Colliery Managers, vol. iv., page 80.

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print