|
Volume 12 (XII), 1896-1897, published 1897
The phenomena of colliery explosions. Mr. G. E. J. McMurtrie (Cinderford) wrote that there were one or two points not explained by Mr. Stuart's theory of a coal-dust explosion, as exemplified at Camerton and Timsbury. According to Mr. Stuart, while the coal-dust on the floor was fused, that on the props, and on the crown-trees, or caps, appeared not to have been touched. Now, the latter was generally considered the most inflammable portion of the dust, and yet according to Mr. Stuart's statement was not touched, while the dust on the floor, which in thin-seam districts was very largely composed of under-earth and horse-dung, was fused. Surely, too, if the speed of these propagated explosions was not great, the gases whilst traversing such lengths as 1,030 feet must have greatly cooled down ; if so Mr. Stuart's theory did not explain the successive propagated explosions. What, too, became of the oxygen in those lengths ? Was it absorbed by the heated gases in their progress, or not ? Mr. Stuart's statement that "propagation of the explosions was observed to have been abruptly stopped in roads where coal-dust abounded," was strange and contrary to what was generally received. Prof. H. Louis (Newcastle-upon-Tyne) wrote that Mr. Stuart's theory, as far as he could follow it, seemed designed to account for the absence of carbonic acid and carbon monoxide in the after-damp. As it had been most conclusively proved that both of these gases did exist in after-damp, the application of this theory seemed to him to present some difficulties. The theory appeared to be that "the products of the mining powder . . . Projected through the planes of ruptured strata" 11 still retained sufficient heat to distil marsh gas from the coal-dust on the floor of the workings and to dissociate this gas into carbon and hydrogen. The temperature of such dissociation was not exactly known, but it was certainly higher than that of the interior of a gas retort or above a bright red-heat. But Mr. Stuart's theory demanded that even after their heat had been absorbed in dissociating the gas, "the products of the mining powder" should still retain enough heat to ignite the hydrogen thus generated. It was not quite clear whence this additional quantity of heat was to come, the gas should not ignite at this very elevated temperature, of which it need only be said that if the "products of the mining powder" were hot enough to perform these operations, they would be quite hot enough to dissociate water into its elements, or to fuse the strata through which they were projected. He (Prof. Louis) saw no reason for any such complicated theory. It was well known that very finely divided particles of solid carbon suspended in air could be readily and instantaneously burnt, the difference between the mode of combustion of a gas and a very finely divided solid being one of degree, rather than of kind. Mr. James Ashworth (Derby) wrote that Mr. Stuart's paper on "The Phenomena of Colliery Explosions" appeared to be devoted to a consideration of the phenomena of two explosions as diagnosed from the observations of the author, and not a consideration of the phenomena observed in connexion with other explosions. These phenomena appear to be capable of being summarized under the following heads, viz. :— (a) that an explosion when once initiated from any cause has not the character of a single or simple explosion, but has that of an uncertain number of explosions; (b) that the length of roadway traversed by these explosions is of uncertain length; (c) that the theory of the author is built up on the basis of dissociation of hydrogen gas from the products of distilled coal-dust, which first distillation is effected by the heat of the originating cause, and afterwards by the heat developed in each succeeding explosion; (d) that the product of each explosion is steam, and not carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide; (e) that the evidence of the point where an explosion has originated is to be found at the place where most damage is produced; (f) that the afterdamp at Camerton and Timsbury collieries disclosed the absence of the small percentages of carbon dioxide and of the inflammable gases that are appreciable by the ordinary tests, but the open lights burned brightly and the explorers suffered physiological sensations that ended in unconsciousness; (g) that air saturated with water vapour must be a valuable contributory precaution in stopping the progress of an explosion; and (h) that the effects, propagation, and after-damp of the explosions at the Camerton and Timsbury collieries were entirely different from those of any other recorded explosions. The first consideration which suggests itself under the (a) paragraph of this summary is, that this conclusion of the author is not in accord with the observations of any other author who has dealt with the explosion of gases, or with the vibratory action of explosions in gases, or with the velocity of the flame developed by such explosions, nor with the effect of the condensation of the steam on the third and all succeeding explosions, excepting the last one. With respect to this he says :— "The external stratum of the product coming in contact with the cold wet surfaces would be instantly condensed, leaving a vacuous space into which another stratum would fall and be condensed, and the process would be repeated so rapidly during the slow gaseous movement as to make condensation practically instantaneous. The product being liquefied by surrender of heat, the temperature would fall below the distilling-point, and the chemical actions come to an end." 12 Now, as the effect of condensation was continuously at work from the time that the originating explosion took place, and until the termination of the author's series of explosions, and as the "gaseous movement" is said to be "slow," it is clear that the theory set cannot be complete in its argument without the effect of the successive condensations being also taken into account. The author's theory depended at the outset on their being sufficient heat produced by the products of a blown-out or over-powdered shot, not only to distil gas from the coal-dust, but also to dissociate the hydrogen from the other products. This dissociation depended entirely on the heat of the evolved gases, and the author assumed this to have been 2,896 degs. Cent. ; but as the powder had already expended a large proportion of its heat in breaking its way out of the shot-hole, it was not possible that this degree could remain, and it must also be remembered that such a great heat could only exist so long as the products of the powder were confined, and, further, that if some of the powder-grains were driven out into the roadway, either unburnt or only partially burnt, the temperature could not approach that suggested by the theorist. Moreover, we had ample evidence that no heat of such exalted temperature was produced, because (taking the case of Camerton), the man and boy who were killed were able to escape out of the refuge-hole (105 feet from the shot) and run 57 feet after they had been burned in the refuge-hole. This latter circumstance, coupled with the fact that their bodies showed no signs of any secondary burns, would seem to be conclusive evidence that there was such temperature then existing in the roadway as would dissociate hydrogen gas from the products of coal distillation. To further show that the author had immensely over-estimated the residual heat that was available for the working-out of his theory, it must be noted that at Camerton the initial points of his gaseous ignitions were placed at points 828 feet apart, and at Timsbury 573 feet apart, and that the men found in the incline at Camerton were within 258 feet of one point of ignition, and therefore exposed to its force as well as its heat, and yet neither of them showed any traces of these effects. The value of these facts in practically considering the author's theory is further shown by noting that the volume of hydrogen-gas estimated to have been exploded at this point was 1,000 cubic feet. This volume of hydrogen would represent not more than 5 per cent. of the cubic contents of the road, if evenly distributed, and as its ignition would be a detonating effect, and not a simple explosion, it was possible to assert, on the authority of Prof. Berthelot and Prof. H. B. Dixon, that the length of time occupied in traversing the whole length of the affected roadway at Camerton would occupy something less than one second of time. Until the facts of this first explosion were cleared up, it was not worth while to consider each succeeding explosion in detail ; but there was one other fact in connexion with the author's theory, which also affected the basis on which it was built up, viz., the indications (e) which he had accepted as proof of the points where one or more of the ignitions took place. The first disproof of this acceptance lay in the fact that the men at Camerton were not blown to pieces, and that in every case where an explosion had been traced to its real point of origin, the men close to the point of ignition had been very little injured, and in many cases very little burnt. To instance a few cases :— Bardsley colliery, March 30th, 1875, two men were burnt, of whom one survived ; Higham colliery, Barnsley, October, 1857, gas fired at the furnace, the furnace-men got out alive, but all the horses in the pit were killed ; Woodend pit, Leigh, August 13th, 1886, the gas fired at a lamp, but the man using it was scarcely singed, and a man close by got out alive, while 38 men further away were killed ; Micklefield, and many more cases, might be quoted. To prove that the product of explosion was steam (d), and not carbon monoxide and dioxide, the author said that at Camerton as well as at Timsbury collieries the ordinary tests disclosed the absence of small percentages of carbon dioxide and of inflammable gases ; but it must be noted that he did not mention carbon monoxide, the presence of which was very strongly suggested by the fact that open lights burned brightly, and the explorers suffered physiological sensations which ended in unconsciousness. The doctor's report on the cause of death unfortunately did not state whether the characteristic pink coloration due to carbon monoxide poisoning was or was not present, but the position of the man's body at Camerton suggested that his death was not instantaneous. With regard to the best means of arresting the propagation of an explosion, the author advocated the saturation of the ventilating-current with water vapour (g). This point was not new, but as he (Mr. Ashworth) had often pointed out in communications on the subject of coal-dust, its value as a preventive measure to localize, or in any way prevent, an explosion was entirely illusory, because the safety-point of saturation could not be obtained. When considering this matter we have to bear in mind that the percentage of watery vapour which any current of air could carry was in direct proportion to its heat, that is, the greater its heat the more water it could carry; and as the effect of sprays was to lower the temperature, we cannot be surprised to find that the figures given by Mr. H. W. Martin, in his evidence before the Coal-dust Commissioners, proved that sprays gave a reduction of 2 degrees of heat, but no increase of aqueous vapour. Thus there were 7.3 grains of aqueous vapour in every cubic foot of air at the working face when the sprays were at work, and exactly the same when the sprays were not at work, proving that the warmer air took this weight of vapour from the natural evaporation of the miner and from the men, animals and lights. At the Maybach colliery, Saarbruck, the temperature was only lowered 1 deg. Cent. by spraying, and the humidity of the coal-dust at the working faces varied between 2.05 and 3.65 per. Cent. Now, as this is under the percentage (5 per. Cent.) which Prof. Dixon, in his paper on the "Rate of Explosions in Gases" stated to give the highest explosive results when present in the air, it must be evident that spraying added directly to the risk of the propagation of a coal-dust explosion, and also indirectly by the possible production of water-gas, which would enhance the deadliness of the after-damp. He (Mr. Ashworth) whilst thus showing the insufficiency of water-sprays, would, as he had always done, strongly advocate wet lengths of roadway, particularly the application of sprays placed at short distances apart, and so applied that the water would first wet the roof and timbering, and that the surplus would fall on the floor and keep it saturated to the extent of 50 per. Cent. over a distance of 200 feet as a minimum. A wet floor was not in itself a sufficient protective, neither was it a sufficient protective when assisted by water-sprays as ordinarily applied. His reasons for so strongly treating this part of the subject arose from observed phenomena not referred to by any other writer on the subject of coal-dust and other colliery explosions, viz., that the explosive flame when rushing through the galleries of a mine did not, as a rule, fill the area of the road but only a certain depth from the roof, and that the passage of the flame in this manner was frequently accompanied by an after-blast of air. As an example of these phenomena, he would quote a recent case which from the published data seemed to fulfil the conditions, viz., that of Nos. 15 and 16 bodies on the main west level of No. 8 pit and No. 56 in No. 1 district at Tylorstown colliery. Nos. 15 and 16 bodies were severely burned on the face and hands, to which caked dust adhered, and were superficially burned on the upper portions of the chest and forearms, and their clothes were ripped off. The burning effects he attributed to the explosive flame, which might fill about half the height of the level, the ripping off of the clothes to the after-blast, and the scorching to the residual heat of the explosion. In the case of No. 56 body, the evidence indicated these dual and consecutive effects even more clearly, because only the head and the front of the chest were burned, whilst the back was clean and unburned, although the clothes were ripped off and the head legs, and arms torn from the body. The tearing off of the clothes and the mutilation of the body, he (Mr. Ashworth) attributed to the after-blast. Perhaps it would be as well at this point to explain what he meant by the after-blast ; it was the motion of air in mass caused by displacement. It might be seen when blank cartridge was fired from heavy ordnance by the effect on the grass in front of the muzzle. Its effect was also practically demonstrated when the s.s. "Cabo Machichaco" was accidentally blown up by dynamite in 1894, at the quayside, at Santander, when several persons in the town had their clothes torn off, and great damage was done both by concussion and displacement of the air. There were many more phenomena disclosed by colliery explosions, but time would not permit him (Mr. Ashworth) to do ,more than refer to some of them very briefly. First, then, as to the quantity of coal-dust which took part in an explosion, the writer had been and still was of opinion that only such coal-dust as was in suspension in the air at the time when an explosion was initiated took part in the actual explosion. And that coal-dust which was, as a matter of course, disturbed by the blast itself, or by the after-blast already referred to, was only affected by the residual heat of the explosion. Also that the coke which was oftentimes deposited on the opposite side of props, etc., to that exposed to the original blast, was so deposited by a "return current of air" caused by the condensation of the products of the original explosion, or by a |"return flame," which was often in evidence after an explosion and was caused by the burning of the carbon monoxide gas in the presence of unconsumed oxygen or of oxygen supplied from the adjacent roads. To be brief, excellent examples of the effects of a return current caused by condensation were recorded in Messrs. J. B. and W. N. Atkinson's account of the Usworth explosion 13, and of the return flame in Mr. William Galloway's account of the Pen-y-graig explosion. In conclusion, and for the sole object of drawing attention to other phenomena, he would ask for an expression of opinion on the question, why a level or working-face ventilated by a current of air travelling from east to west should be more subject to disaster than one ventilated by a west to east current of air? Also why, when an explosive flame extended through the shaft to another mine or seam of coal, the west side was again preferred by the devastating flame? And lastly, whether a great deal of most valuable information might not be obtained by, firstly, a microscopical examination of coal-dust obtained from the ventilating-current or upper timbers, or ledges in the neighbourhood of the point of origin of all recent explosions, on lines similar to the microscopic examination of the Altofts dust made by Mr. W. E. Garforth ; and secondly, by an exhaustive examination of each dust on lines similar to those pursued by Dr. P. P. Bedson when experimenting on the occluded gases of coal-dust, but without first drying the coal-dust.
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||