Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

I.M.E. Previous Return to Index Next I.M.E.
/   \

Volume 12 (XII), 1896-1897, published 1897

Mr. W. C. Blackett (Durham) said that one doubtless obtained from Mr. Stuart's paper a very closely-reasoned mind-picture of what that gentleman considered might occur in an explosion of coal-dust. But, except in some points of what were really sub-details of the main issue, the theory advanced differed in no important particular from others which had been promulgated by various persons over a considerable period of years. By the main issue, he (Mr. Blackett) meant the one broad fact that coal-dust could be fired in a mine, and the resulting phenomena attended by a consecution of explosive violence throughout those passages of the mine where the conditions lent themselves to the event. Mr. Stuart must, forgive those who cannot follow and acquiesce in all his views of these details.

For instance, it was impossible to agree with the statement that "the phenomena of explosive violence at distinct points along the paths of the explosions, and the positive absence of such phenomena in the intervening spaces, demand for their explanation distinct modes of energy." 21 From the observations which he (Mr. Blackett) had had the opportunity of making at several explosions in the County of Durham, he disagreed with the premises involved in this statement. It did not seem to him that there were any of these very distinct points of violence, or that there was any such positive absence of violence, in intervening spaces.

He (Mr. Blackett) had quite fresh in his mind the state of the Brancepeth mine after the recent disaster, and he thought that the thesis might be put more accurately by saying that the propagation of a coal-dust explosion through the galleries of a mine was distinguished by phases of increased violence occurring at successive stages in the path which had been prepared by what he had termed "pioneering phenomena." 22 The principal difference, therefore, between Mr. Stuart and himself, was that where Mr. Stuart maintained a succession of distinct explosions, he (Mr. Blackett) upheld one continuous action, having phases showing from stage to stage increments of greater violence.

At no point, in the paths of the explosion at Brancepeth, was there to be seen a positive absence of expansive violence. It was true that there were points where, by comparison, there was very little violence ; but in no case was this ever so small as to allow of the impunity of the stoppings, which in every instance were blown into the returns. A close examination of what Mr. Stuart called "local disturbances," but which he (Mr. Blackett) preferred to name "localities of increased disturbance," showed that of two moving forces which had been at work, there were always evidences of one being stronger than the other, and the former was always in a direction away from the initiatory point of the explosion. Thus there were few, if any, points in Brancepeth where (without tracing it ab initio) one could not definitely say from which direction the blast had come ; but, in order to do this, it was necessary to eliminate as guidances the position of most of the lighter articles which had got adrift or were loose. Very heavy articles, and those which were difficult to move had remained attached, were invariable in the certainty of their monition.

Now he (Mr. Blackett) thought that if Mr. Stuart were suddenly placed in the centre of one of his "local disturbances" situated between two "intervening spaces" of positive repose, he would be unable to say in which direction lay the initiating point of the originating explosion and if he was right he ought not to be so able, because each distinct explosion should show radiating force equal on all sides. But he (Mr. Blackett) ventured to say that there was not one single locality in Brancepeth where there was not some quite convincing sign which stood out pre-eminently over all its fellows. The "opposite directions" shown, to his Mr. Blackett's) mind, simply conveyed an impression that the blast had originally loosened and carried away a number of articles which had returned with the back-draught of gases on their way to fill up the void caused by the condensation and cooling of the heated resultants, and they doubtless give a similitude to the "exertion of explosive force from a common centre" of "local disruptions."

In the length of road in which the men were found, who had been using the blasting powder which originated the explosion at Brancepeth, all the stoppings had been almost dissipated while within 100 feet of the shot, and within 60 feet of the powder-canister, which had also exploded, were displaced timbers and a heavy fall. Notwithstanding these indications, the road comparatively speaking was not generally disturbed, although the water-tub which had been used by the men was smashed to pieces. Instead, therefore, of 400 or 500 feet mentioned by Mr. Stuart in this case, great violence had occurred well within 100 feet.

This central space should, according to Mr. Stuart, have been quiescent and devoted by the liberated heat solely to distillatory purposes, but within 60 feet of the fired blasting-powder, was a stopping of which barely two or three bricks remained together, and of which almost every brick had been blown away as far as possible and buried deep in dust and rubbish. Surely, and order of repose which could admit of the forcible ejectment of a solidly built brick-stopping was of a somewhat violent nature, and could scarcely be properly described as showing an "absence of appreciable mechanical force in the movement of the atmosphere."

It should also be remembered that this state of things prevailed throughout the Brancepeth pit wherever the explosion had travelled. He could not recall a single stopping which had remained. If Mr. Stuart's idea on the subject was correct, one would certainly expect to find in those generating-spaces, which he said were so little influenced by any moving force, that even small particles of coke were enabled to ascend and settle on timbers under the roof, immediately over the point where the lumps of coal from which he supposed they were distilled, that the brick-stoppings, which at any rate cannot float in the air, would at least remain standing in their site, and those only be removed which happened to coincide with the centre of one of the "loci of disruptions."

But nothing of the kind was to be seen, and if it could so easily be shown that everywhere there was sufficient motive power to cause the disappearance of the stoppings, it must also follow that there was at least sufficient power to raise a heavy cloud of dust, which, becoming intimately mixed with the oxygen of the air, was in exactly the same favourable condition to suffer combustion as was the cloud of dust which an ordinary light ignited in the Brancepeth hopper some years ago.

It is quite natural to conceive that a rush of such phenomena through a mine would not maintain uniform characteristics. It would, indeed, be extraordinary if it maintained laboratory precision, and it was this continuous change in the conditions which had deceived Mr. Stuart. If a mine were suddenly overrun with fire-damp, and an explosion occurred before diffusion had been completed, similar phenomena would be experienced. When the mixture with air was more favourable, there would be much violence, and where the proportions were excessive or otherwise, there would be less.

Mr. Stuart emphasized the violent injuries suffered by some men as compared with the immunity of others. But it was unnecessary to assume a detonation to account for such injuries. It was not difficult to assume that, where a phase of increased violence had severely developed itself, it was possible for the atmosphere to have reached a speed of 5 or 6 times that of one of the most rapid air currents. Such a speed would be at least 100 miles per hour, and if imparted to a man's body would in its course account for all such injuries. An eastern typhoon would probably furnish among its hundreds of victims many such cases.

Reverting to the disappearance of 60 lbs, of coal, "in lumps of ¼lb. to 4 or 5 lbs. each," did Mr. Stuart really expect anyone to believe that any heat there ever was available during a mine explosion could distil such lumps so as to deposit the carbon immediately overhead, merely because Mr. Stuart was unable to find the lost coal ? The disappearance of articles in a pit after an explosion, such as bricks from stoppings, and the like, was often very perplexing, but one did not generally jump to the conclusion that they had been volatilized. It was much more reasonable to conclude that one's power of discovery had failed. However great might be the absolute temperature reached by any of the products during a mine explosion, the time of contact was so brief as to preclude the idea that "lumps" of coal would be distilled. Why did particles of coke ascend to the roof from one tram, and descend to the floor from another, as mentioned by Mr. Stuart ? It was impossible to establish any relation between coked dust, found after an explosion, and coal in the neighbourhood.

Probably one of the most striking features of Mr. Stuart's theory was that which allowed the specific heat of the gases to distribute a kindling temperature over such various lengths of road. Thus in one of his tables23 :— No. 3 explosion, which only covered in its limits of destruction a distance of 18 feet, developed a temperature sufficient to distil gases and ignite No. 4 explosion at a distance of 390 feet ; while No. 7 explosion, which covered 357 feet, had only a generating space of 198 feet for No. 8 explosion. Suppose, therefore, the whole of the first 18 feet were filled with gases at a temperature of 2,000 degs. Cent. (which was not likely), this heat spread over a length of 390 feet would be reduced by admixture alone to about 145 degs. Cent. How then could No. 4 explosion be started unless combustion was continuous ?

Mr. Stuart also utterly ignored the possible importance of the physical properties of dust. Everyone must remember the interesting experiments made by Sir Frederick Abel on dust at the time of the Seaham explosion, in which it was found that magnesia even helped to explode an otherwise non-explosive compound of fire-damp and air, owing to the peculiar action of such dust. It was more than possible that this peculiarity was exercised by dust in the violent combustion of its own products.

He (Mr. Blackett) would like Mr. Stuart to enlighten the members as to what really did take place in the Brancepeth hopper and in such similar instances. If it was not combustion, with more or less violence, of dust and air, what was it ? And if it was combustion, why should not the same phenomena be produced in a mine as well as in a hopper ? And if more confined, and the air more dense, why should such combustion not be increasingly violent ?

To answer such questions, Mr. Stuart was obliged to deny the existence of the "pioneering phenomena," which alone could produce sufficient clouds of dust. He (Mr. Blackett) would like to remind Mr. Stuart that this term of "pioneering phenomena" did not occur in the Report of the Royal Commission. 24 There were very few mining engineers who would agree with Mr. Stuart in this statement, and there was definite evidence of the occurrence at Brancepeth. The rush of wind knocked down an elderly man, who was working near the shaft-bottom, and rendered him for a time unconscious. Upon recovery, one of the first things this man noticed was the sneezing of the horses in the stables (due to dust), and clouds of dust were seen to ascend out of the downcast shaft, were deposited on the surface, and penetrated into the winding-engine house. The engineman said that he heard a rushing noise, and knew that an explosion had taken place.

Violence also had been exerted within the south way, for some considerable distance, and the two boys working therein (who subsequently came out alive) felt a rush of air, which extinguished their lights, but they attributed it to a fall of stone. In such places, as the working-faces were approached, the propagation of the explosion ceased, because the air had no longer sufficient freedom, and therefore the "pioneering phenomena" ceased. Again, if there were such "an inadequate horizontal movement in the gaseous body which attacked the coal," as Mr. Stuart suggested, was it not difficult to account for the perfect ease with which one distinct explosion communicated itself against a very rapid air-current to another ?

He (Mr. Blackett) found that his most searching observations failed to discover any dust completely coked. Quantities were intumesced, and much had a very soot-like appearance, but still, under the microscope, it seemed quite distinct from ordinary soot.

Mr. Stuart alleged the "practical absence of carbon monoxide" in the gaseous product of an explosion. He (Mr. Blackett) had closely examined scores of bodies killed by after-damp at Seaham, Tudhoe, Trimdon Grange, and Brancepeth. He had also felt the effects of breathing after-damp himself, and anyone who had seen the former and felt the deadly sickness and excruciating headache of the latter, was most unlikely to state that there was a "practical absence of carbon monoxide." Nothing could be more conclusive than the bright pink appearance of certain parts of bodies killed by this gas. The head and chest were so brightly coloured at times as to give a like-like appearance, such as was sometimes seen after violent and over-heating exercise, and, not unusually, effusion of blood had occurred from the ears and nostrils. He (Mr. Blackett) was also inclined to think that the bodies did not soon assume rigor mortis. In fact, the blood was no longer blood proper, but another chemical compound of the red corpuscle with carbon monoxide, and that only. Dr. Haldane's report to the Home Office, and his paper, 25 were the first clear medical evidence which had appeared on this subject, and they should be carefully read, when little further evidence would be needed to disprove Mr. Stuart's statement. It was not exaggeration to say that nearly all the bodies in a mine were killed by carbon monoxide, even many of those who would otherwise have died from terrible injuries.

He (Mr. Blackett) thought that the amount of labour and thought given to the matter by Mr. Stuart deserved considerate treatment, but, at the same time, he could not agree with Mr. Stuart's views, and he trusted that he had discussed the matter with all propriety.

Mr. Stuart wrote, in reply to the discussion, thanking the members for the attention which they had given to his paper. It was difficult to condense the results of his investigations within the limits of a paper, and he thought that some of the misapprehensions in the discussion might have been due to this circumstance. He suggested that a further examination of the paper would remove many of the difficulties that had been felt ; and observed that it contained the answers to several of the questions raised, e.g., Mr. G. E. J. McMurtrie spoke of the coal-dust on the floor being coked, but, referring to the coal-dust on the timber, remarked — "According to Mr. Stuart's statement it was not touched ;" whereas the paper stated — "The coal-dust on the sides and the upper parts of the timber is no doubt attacked by the hot educts." 26 Apart from this statement, the theory of chemical actions in the path of the coal-dust involved the distillation of the coal-dust on the timber. Mr. McMurtrie continued — "If the speed of these propagated explosions was not great, the gases while traversing such lengths as 1,030 feet must have greatly cooled down ; if so, Mr. Stuart's theory did not explain the successive propagated explosions," showing that he had overlooked the theory of the paper, particularly the hypothesis of a constant regeneration of heat along the path of the coal-dust — which was as essential for the production of explosive gas from coal-dust by distillation, as heat was necessary to distil gas from coal in a gas-retort ; without this theory successive propagated explosions were impossible.

Prof. Louis remarked that "Mr. Stuart's theory, so far as he could follow it, seemed designed to account for the absence of carbonic acid and carbon monoxide in the after-damp ;" but in the final paragraph of his paper, it would be found that the theory was designed to account for a variety of phenomena, of which the practical absence of carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide formed but one element ; and that all the phenomena must necessarily find an explanation in the theory. Prof. Louis continued that "it had been most conclusively proved that both of these gases did exist in after-damp." Upon this question, Mr. W. N. Atkinson observed that "it appeared to be Mr. Stuart's opinion that carbon monoxide and dioxide were not formed by coal-dust explosions ; but according to Dr. Haldane's report on The Causes of Death in Colliery Explosions and Underground Fires, carbon monoxide was the most usual cause of death, and he had no doubt that this statement was correct ; and Mr. W. C. Blackett remarked that "Dr. Haldane's report to the Home Office and his paper(r) were the first clear medical evidence which had appeared on this subject, and they should be carefully read, when little further evidence would be needed to disprove Mr. Stuart's statement." The statement made in his paper was respecting "the absence of the small percentages of carbon dioxide and of the inflammable gases, that are appreciable by the ordinary tests." 27 The facts recorded were, that the lights burned brightly in the after-damp, which was the ordinary test to prove the absence of more than 2 per cent. of carbon dioxide ; and the exploring parties suffered faintness and unconsciousness only after long exposure to the after-damp ; indicating that the carbon monoxide was considerably less than 1 per cent. of the gaseous mixture. If the hydrocarbons of the coal-dust had been burned in the explosions, large quantities of carbon dioxide, and appreciable quantities of carbon monoxide, would have been gaseous products forming a considerable portion of the after-damp. In such circumstances, the lights would have been extinguished, and all the exploring parties must have been rendered almost immediately unconscious. The contrary was the case ; and the carbon constituent of the hydrocarbons was not entirely oxidized, but almost wholly separated out, and disseminated in the after-damp ; consequently, the quantities of carbon dioxide and carbon monoxide that would be necessarily produced in the conditions set out in the paper were less than the small percentages named.

The appeal made by Mr. Atkinson and Mr. Blackett to Dr. Haldane's report upon The Causes of Death in Colliery Explosions called for notice. The fact that deaths had been largely due to carbon monoxide poisoning had long been known and accepted, and the supposition made by Mr. Atkinson and Mr. Blackett, that it was opposed in the paper, was imaginary. They would find it stated therein that members of the exploring parties "suffered physiological sensations that ended in unconsciousness," the well-known effects produced by carbon monoxide in the after-damp.

The properties of carbon monoxide were known to mining students more than thirty years ago, when Sir Lowthian Bell proved its explosive character ; and Dr. Thomas Richardson, of Durham University, brought the researches of Dr. Le Blanc to the notice of mining engineers, which showed that the fatal effects of after-damp were due to the presence of carbon monoxide ; this, when forming only 0·54 per cent. of the gaseous mixture, caused faintness, feelings of suffocation, stupefaction, and death. Mining engineers had not been so long ignorant as to the poisonous properties of after-damp, or the cause of death due to the presence of carbon monoxide in the atmosphere, as some gentlemen have recently seemed to suppose.

Prof. Louis further observed :—

The theory appeared to be that "the products of the mining powder . . . projected through the planes of ruptured strata," still retained sufficient heat to distil marsh gas from the coal-dust on the floor of the workings, and to dissociate this gas into carbon and hydrogen. . . . Mr. Stuart's theory demanded that, even after their heat had been absorbed in dissociating the gas, "the products of the mining powder" would still retain enough heat to ignite the hydrogen thus generated. It was not quite clear whence this additional quantity of heat was to come, nor why the gas should not ignite at this very elevated temperature. . . . He saw no reason for any such complicated theory.

By reference to the paper, the theory will be found stated in the following terms :—

The products of the ignition of the mining powder, with their unexpended heat . . . striking the coal-dust . . . setting up destructive distillation. The educts flowed into the atmosphere of the mine, but could not go explosive combustion, although an ignition-temperature was at command, because the atmospheric oxygen was inadequate or not within reach. . . . In the loose dust and debris, and in interstitial spaces, there was necessarily some oxygen, which would be seized by the free hydrogen, and by the hydrogen constituent of gaseous hydrocarbons in the educts . . . its oxidation . . . The temperature reached by the oxidation of hydrogen being about 2,000 degs. Cent., and there being a large quantity of heat generated in that process, the remaining hydrocarbons that had not previously undergone change would, at that temperature . . . undergo dissociation, placing free hydrogen at disposal for disruptive action where oxygen could be obtained. . . .

Prof. Louis was therefore under a misconception in supposing the theory demanded that the heat in the products of the powder should, after initiating distillation, effect dissociation of the educts, and subsequently provide an ignition temperature ; also in suggesting that the theory failed to indicate the source of the supplementary heat, or to explain why the educts were not burned. The theory had its illustration in the process for the production of lamp and diamond black, which were not complicated.

Mr. James Ashworth referred to the phenomena recorded in the paper, and gave what he supposed to be a summary, under eight heads - for which there was little justification. The statement marked (h) had not been suggested by the author of the paper, and it was contrary to his views. The statement (e) "that the evidence of the point where an explosion has originated is to be found at the place where most damage is produced," is also directly opposed to his (Mr. Stuart's) theory. The paper stated that between the points of origin and the first explosions, as well as in the intervals between succeeding explosions, the roads were undisturbed, and the evidence was given ; "The men had suffered no violence, not a bone was broken, nor their clothing disturbed, the food-bags were still hanging by cotton-tapes, the loaded and empty trams were alike undisturbed, and the timber standing in its ordinary position." 28 Mr. Ashworth would find his criticisms upon "temperature, heat, distillation, and dissociation" answered in the paper ; and in regard to his supposition that the explosion was instantaneous throughout the field of disaster, disallowing time for local explosions, and his appeal to the researches of Prof. Berthelot to sustain that idea, it would be found by reference to these researches that the conditions of propagation of explosions in gaseous mixtures confirmed his (Mr. Stuart's) theory of explosions at intervals along the path of the coal-dust.

There were other statements made in the discussion as representing his (Mr. Stuart's) theory, which were contrary to it ; and with the replies already made to many misconceptions, he referred the members to his paper, feeling that its further perusal would remove the difficulties they had expressed ; and he would now deal with only one of the remaining remarks upon this question.

Mr. W. N. Atkinson remarked that "in treating the Camerton explosion, Mr. Stuart took up the subject as if that explosion was the first in which coal-dust had been the only agent," and made him (Mr. Stuart) say that coal-dust was a "hidden danger in coal-mining." Mr. Atkinson complained that he (Mr. Stuart) had therefore done injustice to Mr. W. Galloway and others, whose investigations had shown the dangers of coal-dust some years previously. The words quoted will be found in the preface of Coal-dust an Explosive Agent, in the following connexion :—

Fire-damp was an acknowledged danger ; but a large experience had failed to establish such a character for coal-dust, and the non-gaseous mines possessing an historical freedom from explosions, no opportunity had arisen to investigate the phenomena of an explosion in which coal-dust was the exclusive agent. In November last, an explosion occurred at the Camerton collieries, Somersetshire, a non-gaseous mine, which afforded the occasion for studying the features of an explosion produced by an agent other than fire-damp, and of elucidating a hidden danger in coal-mining. 29

It would be seen that the author's remarks were, that the Camerton explosion was the first occasion upon which coal-dust had been the only agent in a non-gaseous mine — which was a fact ; and the task that he had set himself was to elucidate a hidden danger — hidden in the sense that a large number of mining engineers could not recognise it as an exclusive danger, though everyone accepted fire-damp as such. Mr. Atkinson's separation of his (Mr. Stuart's) words from their qualification, and the prejudicial construction which he had offered upon the partial extract, appeared to be wanting in correctness.

He could have read earlier in the preface the remark that for some time previously coal-dust had been suggested as a danger ; and observed that the researches of Prof. Galloway, Mr. Hall, himself, and others were referred to in the introduction to the volume, as antecedent to the author's investigations.

Mr. W. N. Atkinson has suggested a doubt as to the absolute freedom from fire-damp of the Camerton and Timsbury collieries, but offered no evidence for the statement. He referred to the Timsbury explosion, when some men stated that from forty to fifty years previously, when they were boys twelve years of age, they had lighted gas at a neighbouring mine. Mr. J. S. Martin, H.M. Inspector of Mines, heard the evidence, and disposed of the matter in his report as unworthy of serious attention. If Mr. Atkinson had known the facts as they were known to Mr. Martin and others, doubtless he would not have made the suggestion referred to.

In reply to the doubts suggested by Mr. Atkinson upon his cursory examination of the Camerton and Timsbury mines, and by Mr. Blackett as to the correctness of his (Mr. Stuart's) observations of the phenomena of the explosions, he had to state that he was engaged for five days in the Camerton and three days in the Timsbury collieries ; and pursued the exact methods of observation and measurement acquired during several years' studies in physical and chemical laboratories. As the suggested doubts affected the value of fundamental observations, he felt it necessary to state that his records could not be questioned by any gentleman who had made equally exhaustive investigations with the advantage of the preceding experience in the methods of research referred to.

Referring to Mr. Maurice Deacon's remark, that "without a continuation of the flame it was difficult to understand how Mr. Stuart accounted for the separate ignition of the successive explosions," he (Mr. Stuart) replied that he relied upon the heat in the continuous oxidation of the hydrogen to ignite the explosive mixture at each locus of explosion ; and in response to Mr. Deacon's desire to know the "resultant gases" of the mining powder used at Camerton and Timsbury collieries, he (Mr. Stuart) regretted that he had not the information to offer, as no experiment had been made.

Upon the important question of explosions at intervals along the path of the coal-dust, he (Mr. Stuart) observed that Mr. Deacon and Mr. Blackett appeared to accept the principle. Mr. Deacon said that "he only agreed with Mr. Stuart in his theory of separate explosions, in so far as 'separate explosions' might be taken to mean a greater development of force at one point in the travel of the flame than at another;" and Mr. Blackett observed that "the principle difference, therefore, between Mr. Stuart and himself, was that where Mr. Stuart maintained a succession of distinct explosions, he (Mr. Blackett) upheld one continuous action, having phases showing from stage to stage increments of greater violence."

The phenomenon to be explained was the exhibition of explosive violence in abnormally large sectional areas of road. The kinetic energy in Mr. Deacon's travelling "flame," and in Mr. Blackett's "continuous action," when emerging from normal sectional areas into larger spaces, must suffer a diminution of power to exert disruptive action. The failure of this kinetic energy to effect disruption in the antecedent small area would, therefore, be more pronounced in the large space. The disruptive effects in the larger area consequently demanded for their explanation the exertion of potential energy disruptive in nature, and exhibited a mode of energy only known in the ignition of highly explosive bodies.

In estimating the value of the absence of disturbance of roof and timber in the intervals between the explosions, the natural strength of the roof formed a factor as suggested by Mr. Atkinson and Mr. Deacon, which was considered and recorded in his (Mr. Stuart's) investigations. The observations at the Camerton collieries upon this question were summed up in the following words :— "In the sections of violent energy, the roof was broken down, alike in friable strata requiring double timbering, and in firm strata needing only occasional props," which covered every description of roof between the explosions.

Mr. Atkinson carried the question further, saying :— "When timber was once displaced, the amount of stone which fell bore no relation to the force of the explosion, as Mr. Stuart seemed to imagine, but depended on the nature of the roof. Uninjured full tubs, again, were not evidence of the absence of a force great enough to smash empty tubs." Mr. Atkinson might equally say, that the effect of an explosion in military or submarine mines, bore no relation to the force of the explosion ! and his conflict upon this question was not with the writer (Mr. Stuart), but with an established principle in mechanics, viz., the relation of energy to work.

The absence of mechanical force between the explosions was a fact of observation. When considerable lengths of road with roof of the same nature, demanding timber uniform in strength and quantity, presented the phenomena of disruption at intervals in which the timber was displaced, sometimes fractured ; and the roof, whether of shale, faulted stone, or strong bedded cliff, was broken down, while the timber and roof in the intervening spaces were not disturbed, there could be no question that disruptive energy had been exerted in the disruptions, and not in the intervals. When wooden structures, air-pipes, loaded and empty trams, were found at numerous points in the field of the explosions, undamaged and undisturbed ; while in the spaces between them, corresponding structures were broken to pieces, air-pipes rent into parts, full and empty trams alike thrown off the rails, the woodwork broken up, the ironwork fractured and contorted, and the contents scattered abroad ; the effects of mechanical violence at the loci of destruction, and of its absence in the intervals, had their demonstration. When the bodies of the men were found distributed over the field of the explosions, many at separate points, simply burnt, but not otherwise injured, while in the intervals between them other bodies were found blown to pieces ; phenomena were exhibited that demanded for their explanation explosions at the loci of the mutilations, and their absence at the adjoining loci of unmutilated men.

Mr. Blackett ventured the remark that the mutilation of bodies would be produced by the air-current travelling at the velocity of "100 miles per hour," and referred to the Brancepeth explosion in which a case of mutilation was reported as follows :— "At first, an arm was found, and about 30 feet distant the remains of the body," which the manager described as follows :— "It was like a lump of flesh, we could not tell what it was." Mr. Blackett suggested that this mutilation was produced by a current of air at a speed of 100 miles an hour. He had to consider the force represented by a current of that velocity, to understand its impotence to effect such results. The human body sustains normally a pressure of 14.7 lbs. per square inch, and retained its structure and form under pressures of over 40 lbs. per square inch. The velocity of 100 miles an hour represented a pressure of 0.34 lbs. per square inch ; and this added to the normal pressure of 14.70 lbs., made Mr. Blackett's mutilating force 15.04 lbs. per square inch ; or one third of the resistance the body had successfully sustained in working operations. The teachings of mechanics would show Mr. Blackett, that when disruptive effects were to be produced by energy stored up in an elastic medium like a mass of air, the velocity of that mass to effect disruption by its impact, must be equal to the immense velocity reached in the ignition of highly explosive gaseous mixtures ; and nothing less than a violent local explosion at the spot where the unfortunate man in the Brancepeth colliery stood, could have imparted to the air a velocity capable of exerting the disruptive energy exhibited in his mutilation.

A short distance from these mutilated remains, another man was found in the path of the explosions, who had suffered no mutilation, indicating the local character of the explosion, and illustrating the principle enunciated by Prof. Berthelot, that the velocity of the explosive wave rapidly diminished in the conditions external to the exploded gaseous body.

The absence of disruptive energy in the intervals between the explosions was not only an observed fact, but must be so in the nature of the case from what was known of the behaviour of explosive gaseous mixtures upon ignition.

Mr. Atkinson declined to accept his (Mr. Stuart's) remark that the arrest of propagation in dry and dusty roads was due to the want of oxygen, but that question was governed by the teachings of chemistry. He continued to say that "he would not attempt to follow Mr. Stuart in the description of the chemical processes which were described as resulting in the intermittent explosions, but on this part of the subject it would be interesting to have the opinion of chemists. He (Mr. Stuart) would be pleased to hear that Mr. Atkinson had taken the opinion of chemists experienced in the treatment and explosion of gaseous mixtures and the destructive distillation of coal. Mr. Atkinson was probably not aware that his (Mr. Stuart's) investigations had been examined by a distinguished chemist, who had recorded the results in the Chemical News 30 in the following words :— "On a careful perusal of Mr. Stuart's book, we are convinced that he interprets the phenomena in strict accord with the facts observed, and with well-known chemical and physical laws."

In conclusion, he (Mr. Stuart) observed that the importance of the subject of colliery explosions and the interest that must attach to new suggestions which propounded a rationale of the calamities fundamentally different from the prevailing opinion, appeared to call for the lengthy reply he had made to the discussion. He hoped that many of the objections to his theory had been removed by the further remarks now made, and that the Institution would continue to promote the elucidation of the subject.


21 Trans. Fed. Inst., vol. xii., page 372.
22 Ibid., vol. vii., page 54.
23 Coal-dust an Explosive Agent, page 30.
24 Coal-dust an Explosive Agent, page xiv.
25 Trans. Fed. Inst., vol. xi., page 502
26 Ibid., vol. xii., page 375.
27 Ibid., vol. Xii., page 376.
28 Trans. Fed. Inst., vol. xii., page 372.
29 Page viii.
30 1894, vol. lxx., page 84.

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print