Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

I.M.E. Previous Return to Index Next I.M.E.
/   \

Volume 12 (XII), 1896-1897, published 1897

The exploring parties frequently advanced into the stagnant atmosphere more rapidly than diffusion was effected, to make apertures through the falls ; and had favourable opportunities of observing the effects of this atmosphere. Their open lights burned brightly, and disclosed the absence of the small percentages of carbon dioxide and of the inflammable gases, that are appreciable by the ordinary tests ; but they suffered physiological sensations that ended in unconsciousness. They observed the atmosphere laden with particles of soot, and compared it to the condition produced by "turning a bed-tick inside out and shaking it in the air." The author observed that this suspended matter had been universally deposited upon the walls and timber of the road throughout the fields of disaster ; and, upon examination, found it to be amorphous carbon, such a may be obtained by burning hydrocarbons in limited quantities of air. The carbon obtained by holding a glass rod in an illuminated gas flame, and the compact form of the deposit, are well known ; the carbon at the Camerton and Timsbury collieries proved, upon investigation, to be the same in substance, but differed in the form of deposition. In numerous places in the mines, the carbon upon the timber and strata was in gossamer-like form, and gave the surfaces a veined appearance. 8 The author collected these striated filaments upon paper ; but, however carefully preserved, they broke down into powder under the slightest pressure. The general deposit was a loosely built up and dilated stratum, which, when touched with a flat surface, shrank to a fraction of its original thickness. It was obviously the accumulation of successive settlements of particles originally in atmospheric suspension ; and that condition of the atmosphere in the mines immediately after the disasters is a fact of observation. These depositions of carbon were, therefore, distinct in structure from the deposition that arises from the impingement of a hydrocarbon flame upon a cold surface. The origin of this carbon is not far to seek ; the residues of coked coal already referred to, are the evidence of distillation, showing that hydrogen and gaseous hydrocarbons flowed into the atmosphere of the workings ; and these hydrocarbons provided the amorphous carbon, of which it formed the solid constituent.

The separation of this carbon of the educts involves questions in thermo-chemistry which cannot be dealt with in this paper, beyond saying that the processes that caused its separation were the sources of heat upon which the explosive phenomena depended.

The author suggests the following theory to explain the phenomena now recorded. The products of the ignition of the mining powder, with their unexpended heat, were projected through the planes of ruptured strata, in fan-like sheets, striking the coal-dust on the floor, and setting up destructive distillation. The educts flowed into the atmosphere of the mine, but could not undergo explosive combustion, although an ignition-temperature was at command, because the atmospheric oxygen was inadequate or not within reach to make an explosive mixture. In the loose dust and debris and in the interstitial spaces, there was necessarily some oxygen, which would be seized by the free hydrogen and by the hydrogen constituent of gaseous hydrocarbons in the educts, its oxidation liberating the carbon of the latter in solid form to float in the atmosphere. The temperature reached by the oxidation of hydrogen being about 2,000 degs. cent., and there being a large quantity of heat generated in the process, the remaining hydrocarbons that had not previously undergone change would, at that temperature and in the absence of atmospheric oxygen, undergo dissociation, placing free hydrogen at disposal for disruptive action where oxygen could be obtained, and leaving more of the fine carbon in atmospheric suspension.

A series of chemical actions of constant sequence was, therefore, established in the immediate vicinity of the shot, in which there was the partial oxidation of hydrogen referred to, generating heat, which instituted a series of chemical changes identical to those which the heat supplied by the products of the mining powder had originated ; and these regenerative activities were of constant and similar reproduction along the path of the coal-dust, free hydrogen undergoing constant accumulation, until a place was reached in the workings where the available quantity of air was greatly increased, and there being an ignition-temperature at command in the partial combustion taking place, the accumulated hydrogen was oxidized with explosive violence, causing the disruptive effects observed at the loci of the initial local explosions.

The quantities of heat generated in the initial local explosions greatly exceeded the total quantity of heat in the products of the mining powder, and it will be readily understood that an advancing series of similar changes to those described was again established in the coal-dust beyond, producing secondary explosions at points farther away, where the conditions of the oxidation of the accumulated hydrogen were fulfilled ; consequently, the explosions would be propagated along every path of the coal-dust, so long as atmospheric oxygen was available, and there were no wet spaces to bring down the temperature.

This theory satisfies the demand for chemical changes causing a constant regeneration of heat, and places an explosive gas at disposal for disruptive action, without the production of carbon monoxide or carbon dioxide, and which did not yield these gases as products. It accounts for the practical absence of carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide from the atmosphere in the fields of disaster, with the fact that the carbon constituent of the hydrocarbons was not oxidized, but disseminated in the atmosphere, where it was found in copious suspension by the exploring parties, and from which it had been deposited upon the vertical faces of the enclosing walls in dilated layers and in striae, giving the faces of stone and timber the veined appearance already referred to.

It is not difficult to understand why there was an absence of mechanical effect upon the ventilating-power at the Camerton collieries, when it is remembered that the gaseous hydrocarbons that were being constantly added to the atmosphere of the mine, were almost immediately eliminated by the oxidation of the hydrocarbon constituent ; and that the volume of the incoming air was being constantly diminished by the removal of its oxygen forming one-fifth of that volume, for the oxidation of the hydrogen in the explosions and the antecedent actions in successive productions of steam, undergoing eventual liquefaction by the surrender of heat ; and that by means of this exhaustion, the mechanical equilibrium of the air-current was maintained.

The terminations of the explosive phenomena admit of explanation. Propagation of the explosions was observed to have been abruptly arrested in roads where dry coal-dust abounded, and at these places observations disclosed the presence either of coked coal-dust or amorphous carbon, indicating chemical activity that supplied heat and ignition-temperature. The absent factor in the explosive cycle was therefore atmospheric oxygen, and the condition of the air-currents confirmed the conclusion. Propagation failed, because the chemical actions languished to extinction, due to an inadequate supply of atmospheric oxygen for the oxidation which yielded heat to carry on the distillation and other chemical changes. The fundamental difference between the path of propagation and the path in which propagation failed was in the condition of the air-currents. In one very small split of the air-current, and in return air impoverished of its oxygen, the chemical processes were observed to have been arrested.

Propagation was also arrested in wet places, and is explained by the fact that the production of the oxidation of hydrogen would by its contact with wet surfaces undergo a change corresponding to what takes place in the condenser of a steam-engine. The external stratum of the product coming in contact with the cold wet surfaces would be instantly condensed, leaving a vacuous space into which another stratum would fall and be condensed, and the process would be repeated so rapidly during the slow gaseous movement as to make condensation practically instantaneous. The product being liquefied by surrender of heat, the temperature would fall below the distilling-point, and the chemical actions come to an end.

The disaster at the Timsbury collieries originated in the main intake-airway ; and while the disastrous effects that are identified with a colliery explosion were produced from the shot to the upcast shaft on one side, there were no such effects from the shot in the opposite direction towards the downcast shaft. Observations, therefore, show that had the condition of the airway from the shot towards the downcast shaft also prevailed from the shot towards the upcast shaft, the disaster would not have happened. The difference between the two portions of the airway was as follows :— On the upcast side, it contained the full circulating current of air, which at the time of the disaster was about 13,000 cubic feet per minute, and the coal-dust was dry. On the downcast side, it contained the same circulating current for a distance of 150 feet ; at that point the ventilation entered the intake from a side road, and the air between the side road and the door was a still atmosphere. The coal-dust was more or less damp or wet at the side road and wet up to the door ; the still atmosphere was laden with water vapour to saturation. 9

At the Camerton collieries, the coal-dust was equally dry on both sides of the shot, and disastrous effects were produced in both directions. The propagation against the intake air-current after being active for 3,714 feet, causing great destruction, was abruptly arrested at 2,838 feet from the downcast shaft. The atmosphere at this point was the main intake air-current in which the 3,714 feet of propagation had occurred, and the author made the following observations of the condition of the road where the propagation was arrested, commencing in the vicinity of the last or No. 10 explosion 10 :—

 feetfeet
Archway and fall ; floor and sides dry and dusty ... 90
Water and mud on floor ; no dust 66 ...
Floor damp between the rails, damp dust outside of rails 24 ...
Last fall, floor and sides damp ; no dust 21 ...
Water and mud on floor, sides wet ; no dust 48 ...
 159 
Floor damp between rails, intermittent wet spots ; dust outside of rails damp to dry 234 ...
Floor and sides damp and muddy 24 ...
Floor and sides dry and dusty to horse-gug 261 ...
  519

The effectiveness of wet lengths of road in stopping the propagation of an explosion, is a fact of observation ; and air saturated with water-vapour must, in the nature of the case, be a valuable contributory precaution.

The arrest of propagation is consequently brought about by atmospheric conditions in which heat cannot be generated for the reproduction of the distillatory and other chemical actions, because the supplies of atmospheric oxygen are inadequate ; also by wet surfaces, which demand the surrender of the heat for the evaporation of their moisture.

Most of the principal phenomena of the disasters at the Camerton and Timsbury collieries have now been referred to, and the theory which the author has advanced upon his records and investigations, may be shortly stated as follows :—

A colliery explosion, in which coal-dust is the pricipal agent, comprises numerous local explosions, separate in time and in space, at irregular intervals, where the available supplies of atmospheric oxygen are greatly increased, and caused by the explosive combustion of hydrogen derived from the coal-dust in the antecedent spaces, by a series of chemical actions, of constant sequence, which produce heat for regeneration without auxiliary intervention, and are consequently reproduced along the path of the coal-dust under the conditions named.

This theory accounts for the coked residues of coal, and the positions in which they were found ; explains the presence of amorphous carbon in atmospheric suspension, and its characteristic deposition upon the enclosing walls throughout the fields of disaster ; accounts for the practical absence of carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide in the gaseous products ; supplies the heat for the distillatory action, for dissociation, for raising the air of the gaseous mixture to ignition-temperature, for supplementing the losses due to the contact of the products of combustion with cold surfaces ; allows time for the distillation of coal, and the chemical changes in the series of actions ; provides the explosive gas for producing the disruptions ; explains the occurrence of the disruptions at intervals, the absence of mechanical effects in the intervening spaces, the conditions under which propagation proceeds or is arrested, the maintenance of the mechanical equilibrium of the air-current at Camerton collieries, and excludes no coal — except that which yields no combustible gases when subjected to the temperature of destructive distillation.


8 Coal-dust an Explosive Agent, pages 54 and 55. The Origin and Rationale of Colliery Explosions, page 34.
9 The Origin and Rationale of Colliery Explosions, pages 45, 48, and 49.
10 Coal-dust an Explosive Agent, page 28.

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print