Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

I.M.E. Previous Return to Index Next I.M.E.
/   \

Volume 9 (IX), 1860-1861, published 1861

The Inquest.

Edward Wailes Hall — I am master shifter for the three pits at Hetton Colliery. On Thursday night last, about half-past eight o'clock, the head keeper came to me and informed me something serious had happened at the East and West Minor Pits. I went to the pits, and found there was no means of getting down. I then proceeded to the Downs Pit, and went down it, and proceeded in a westerly direction to the East Minor Pit. When I came to the wagonway, I found the timber all blown out, and several falls from the roof in the way. I got over a very large fall, but the after-damp prevented me going further. The paper writing now given in by me is a correct list of all the men who have been killed in the pit. (See list on plan No. I.)

George Lowden — I am overman of the West Minor Pit, in which, on the 20th December last, the explosion took place. It is my duty to examine the workings before the men go in to their work. I went down on that day at twenty minutes past two o'clock in the morning. It is my duty to fix the places where the men coming down were to work. I had charge of the men and boys in the south way and at its extremity. They commenced working about half-past five o'clock, and the explosion took place between eight and nine o'clock in the evening. They were all killed. They were found in the main way. I left the pit that morning at eight o'clock, and was in my own house at the time of the explosion. Before I placed the men, I examined their places about half-past three o'clock that morning, and found no gas. I came out by the return to the furnace, and found the return free from gas. I had no charge of any other part of the mine. I have been down since the explosion, and my opinion is, that it has gone from the flues. I think so, because the injury done spreads from that place both north and south. I have had charge of the West Minor Pit for the last thirteen years. I have not seen any gas where these men were working for three or four months. It might be some time before that I saw gas, but it was in the west way from the furnace. The ventilation was going all right when I left that morning. If the ventilation was all right when the explosion took place, I do not think it possible for gas to have come from these places and explode where it did. I could tell by passing along that the ventilation was all right. When I came up, the portion of the pit that I had charge of would be taken charge of by Robert Young. That is the whole of the West Minor Pit. When I saw the gas some months ago, it was in the west of the south way, in the pillar workings. The return from that portion of the workings does not go near the flues I have named; it goes to the two furnaces. There has been no explosion in that part of the pit where the gas was seen. There has been no gas seen by me in the neighbourhood of the flues. The gas which I saw was north of the places where the men were working, and if the ventilation was perfect there could be no communication between that place and where the men were working. The men worked with locked Davy-lamps. I had no fear of their working with naked candles when I left. I found five of the bodies on the 22nd day of December last. I found Robert Hall, James Box, and William Richardson in the return on the south side of the main way. They had not been injured by the force of the explosion, hut had died from the effects of after-damp. I also found the bodies of Anthony Young and John Ferguson in the main way, rather beyond the bottom of the new bank from the shaft. They had been killed by the force of the explosion, I think near 600 yards from the furnaces. These five men were nearly all together. On the morning of the explosion I came out along the return, about 500 yards from the shaft, and when I came to the furnace I went into the north-west retain of the two furnaces, and found no gas whatever. I found no tail or cap upon the flame of my lamp, nor any indications of gas in the places I examined. It was my duty to examine, and I did so, and found no indication whatever of gas. From the time I went in until the men came down, I was employed in examining the workings, and had sufficient time to examine them carefully, which I did.

Robert Young, back-overman — I was down the West Minor Pit at nine o'clock in the morning of the day on which the explosion took place. The pit was in my charge until five o'clock in the afternoon. There was good ventilation the whole of the time. I cannot tell the quantity of air circulating, I considered there was sufficient for the safety of the men. I examined the water gauge, which tells the strength of the ventilation; it was standing at one inch and six-tenths at twenty minutes before five o'clock. There was no accumulation of gas or foulness in any part of the pit whilst in my charge. The ventilation was perfect up to the time when I left. I examined the goaves as I went round, and found they were not giving off any gas. Between the time I left and the time of the explosion I do not think gas could have accumulated and been carried to the flues. If there had been gas, whilst the ventilation was perfect it was not possible for it to have got to the flues. I have been down the pit every day since, and have seen the damage done, and I think the explosion took place in the flues, but cannot say what was the cause of it. I should say gas had caused it. I cannot form any opinion how the gas got there. The last time I saw gas at the edges of the goaves will be some months since, but I cannot say exactly. There has never lately been any cap or tail on my lamp in any portion of the workings. When the furnace was out there was a great difference in the ventilation, but there was no gas. There was a little fire in the two west furnaces when the other was not in use. No gas could have come from the Low Main to cause this explosion as there was so much air in the pit it would destroy it.

Thomas Smith — I am master shifter under Hall. On the 20th of December last, I went down the East Minor Pit at half-past five o'clock at night, to examine the lamps, lock them, and place the men. I examined the lamp of every man working in the pit that night whom I had under my care, and found their lamps all right. Lowden had five of the men in his charge. I placed four men, viz., Thomas Sandilands and Thomas Wright on the north way, about 500 or 600 yards from the downcast shaft, and John Jopling and John Gibbon, also on the same way, about 200 yards further in. I placed no more men in that district. I placed three men and a boy, viz., William Smith, Robert Gardiner, William Gardner, and William Newman, in the east way, about 800 yards from the shaft. They got out alive. I placed George Gleghorn, and Bond, William Anderson, Joseph Scott, and Richard Proud, a boy, in the same way, further in — 600 or 700 yards further in than the Gardiners. I also placed Ralph Hope and Robert Simpson in the same way, but in a different direction. These were all saved but Joseph Scott. These are all the men I placed in the East Minor Pit. In the West Minor I placed, on the south side, John Ferguson and Anthony Young on the main way, near the bottom of the new bank. I also placed William Richardson, Robert Hall, and James Box, through the separation door into the return. I placed Thomas Mitcheson, John Lowden, and Robert Wilson in the east south way. They would be about 1000 yards from the shaft. I had not examined the workings of the pit previous to setting the men to work. It was not my duty. After I had placed the other men, I went north with the four men that went north. In setting them to work, I had only to pass the downcast shaft. There was no indication of gas in any of the places where I placed the men. I was in the pit when the explosion took place, 800 yards down the east bank. I was blown away by the explosion. It came from the west of where I was. As soon as I gathered myself together, I put up my hand to see how the ventilation was, and which way the air was going, and found it was going west. That was the wrong way. In less than a minute I found the air going in the right direction. I told the men I had placed in the east way to reconcile themselves. I got them all gathered together, and some of them told me they could not get up the engine bank for smoke. We then went up to the north return, and when we came to the tunnel that crosses the east wagon way, I told the men to take hold of jackets, and I went first, and proceeded to the downcast shaft of the East Minor Pit. When I got to the downcast shaft I found the furnaceman, and I then looked about and found the pit all blown to bits about there. I then went round to the West Minor shaft, accompanied by some of the men, and found all was blown to bits there also. Finding this, I then proceeded north, to make my road to Eppleton Pit. We proceeded about 300 yards north of the East Minor Pit, when we found the after-damp. We were obliged to return to the West Minor Pit, and remained there until seven o'clock next morning, when some deputies arrived. We then proceeded down the east way, and so to Eppleton Pit, and were all drawn safe to bank, except Scott and Hope, who had left us, and proceeded in another direction, the former being lost. My cabin is about 100 yards north from the furnaces, and I am down there every night, and near to the furnaces. I had never noticed any gas in the part I had charge of, nor near the furnaces. I cannot tell the quantity of air circulating at the time of the explosion; but the air was good. I had no fear at all of any explosion taking place. I have been down six days since the explosion, working. I have examined about the shaft, and she has gone inbye all over. It would require the explosion of a large quantity of gas to cause the damage I saw. I can form no opinion where that gas came from. I do not think so large a quantity of gas could accumulate from the inbye workings of the pit without my knowledge. Open lights were used at the stables. In my opinion, it was quite safe to use candles. It is the first air from the downcast that goes to the stables. I have no idea where the gas came from that caused the explosion. I cannot say whether so large a quantity of gas could be generated in the boiler fires. There is an upper seam in the shaft, but it is not possible for it to have come from there. I am aware it has come from the neighbourhood of the shaft, but from where I cannot form an opinion. The air currents were as usual when I placed the men. The place I was standing in, when blown down, might be seven feet and a half by ten feet and I was blown with violence about four or five yards. All the men, except three at the south separation door, were in the main intake. The boiler fire was fed with fresh air. If the foul air had come away from the west broken, it could not have got into the engine chimney, and no other foul return could have got from any other part of the pit to the engine chimney. I am quite satisfied that the explosion took place near the shaft. I think there was a sufficient quantity of air circulating through all the ways for the perfect ventilation of the pits, and safety of the men, up to the time of the explosion. The four men on the north rolleyway were working with open oil lamps at the time of the explosion. There were no other naked lights but Gleghorn and Bond's, who were about 900 yards north, and 300 yards east from the downcast shaft. Gleghorn and Bond were saved. The men working upon the north wagonway could not work with any other lamp, the current of air was so strong. The air was coming direct from the shaft to them.

John Curry — I am a furnaceman. On Thursday, the 20th December last, I had charge of the east furnace in the East Minor Pit. At four o'clock in the afternoon I took charge of it, and remained there until the explosion. When I took charge I did not see anything particular or unusual. There was no appearance of gas anywhere about, nor had I observed anything before the explosion took place to lead me to suspect any danger. Between eight and nine o'clock the explosion took place. I was just going in to fire at the time, and the strong wind, from the force of the explosion, met me. The furnace was in a good state before that, the fire was good and a strong air coming to it. By firing I mean supplying the fire with coals. I had supplied the fire with coals about five minutes previously. After I felt the wind of the explosion, I found the air come back from the furnace instead of going to it. As soon as I felt the wind I made my way through the first door coming out to the downcast shaft. The force of the air was very great before I got through the door, but after I had got through I did not feel it so much. I got out by the Eppleton Pit. I thought the air was good when I went in, and it continued so up to the time of the explosion. I can form no opinion where the explosion took place. I have not been down the pit since, but the force of the explosion came from the upcast shaft. The furnace fire had been out a week before that, when the water was coming down the shaft. I think it was out about three days, but I cannot exactly tell. The other two furnaces were at work when mine was out. I never heard of any gas in the pit. My furnace was lighted two or three days before the explosion took place, but am not certain. The furnace was going as usual after it was set away again. I form my opinion by the force of the draught going towards the furnace. I cannot say that the gas did not fire at my furnace. I did not see any of the flame of the explosion. There is only one current of air comes to my furnace. If it had gone down my return I must have seen the flame of the explosion. I saw no fire, and was not burnt. I would be five or six yards from the furnace when I felt the wind. The air that came from the explosion was not hot when it came to me.

Isaac Lowthian Bell, of Washington, said — I am an ironmaster and chemical manufacturer. I have not been accustomed to investigate matters of this sort connected with collieries, but from having between 20,000 and 30,000 cubic feet of gases per minute to deal with as an ironmaster, it has led me to study gases particularly. I went down the downcast shaft of the East and West Minor Pits this morning, and spent two hours in examining the flue in which the explosion is alleged to have taken place. In the first instance, I found a damper within six feet of the boiler, broken in two, the lower portion resting in its place, and the upper portion, as one might have expected from the counterbalance weight, drawn upwards; a jacket close in to the other end of the boiler, burnt; some wood-work nearly opposite to the boiler, charred; and wood-work and stone blown in the direction from the boiler. I found doors blown down, all indicating the direction of the explosion to have been from the boiler. I found thirty feet of the flue between the damper and the upcast shaft blown out. I found the whole of the lateral flues (of the pipe drift) opposite the pipe drift blown outward. From that point for about thirty feet the flues and travelling way were whole, arising, no doubt, from the greater strength of the flue, or less intensity of the explosion; then about fifteen feet of the top of the flue blown outwards, and about ten feet of the covering of the travelling ways also displaced. At the crossing over the way leading to the downcast shafts, the flue being unsupported either on one side or another, was burst. The walls on the north side were blown to the north, and the south walls to the south, and, generally, the indications of the explosion at the crossing were as if the explosion had proceeded from the crossing as a common centre. From there I continued along the flue towards the furnace, going to the upcast shaft. The soot had evidently been displaced from one end to the other. At the bend next to the furnace there was a little displacement of brick-work. At the end of the north furnace a bridge of brick-work was blown over in the direction which an explosion in this flue would render probable. Immediately opposite, there is a furnace drift proceeding from another furnace, in which, where it crosses a road, I found the arch displaced. After seeing all this, the question arose, could a flue of these dimensions contain sufficient gas to cause such an explosion? and, secondly, if it could, where did the gas come from? I conclude the gas could not come from the workings, because the boiler furnace always has been, and is now, exclusively fed by air proceeding direct from the downcast shaft without going into the coal workings, assuming that the ventilation was maintained in a proper way. I find, by computation, that this flue contains 7000 cubic feet, and to fill that flue with light carburetted hydrogen, leaving a sufficient content for the necessary atmospheric air to thoroughly explode the light carburetted hydrogen so contained in the flue, 150 lbs. of fresh coal would furnish the whole gas necessary. The length of time to do that would depend upon the heat applied to the coal. I find, to fill the same flue with another explosive gas, carbonic oxide, leaving space for air, 40 lbs. of coke would be sufficient. Supposing the flue to be filled with either of these gases, together with the necessary atmospheric air required for their explosion, at a time when there was no fire to cause the explosion, that is, no flame in the furnace to cause the ignition of these gases, which might readily occur from damping the coals, then the combustion of the coal at the boiler end or the furnace at the far end, either one or both, could easily supply the flame for setting on fire this inflammable gas. Supposing this to have occurred, is the damage which ensued a probable event? I may state that, in my own experience, I had a wrought iron pipe, three feet in diameter and about 100 yards long, filled with an explosive compound, in which the combustible gas was carbonic oxide — the less explosive gas of the two. It has about half the explosive power of light carburetted hydrogen. That pipe fired at one end at a lamp, blowing the man holding the lamp many yards into the air, breaking every bone in his body, destroying the whole length of the pipe, and splitting the blowing apparatus of metal, which was three-quarters of an inch thick at the far end. My opinion is based upon these facts, and upon philosophical calculation of the power of such a quantity of gas, or much less, and I conceive that the results I have this day seen are easily accounted for. As soon as the contents of the flue took fire, supposing it to be filled with a mixture of light carburetted hydrogen gas and atmospheric air, the 7000 feet contained in it would instantly become about 56,000 feet. Of course, that increased volume would rush in the direction of the least obstruction; and, as I understand, the men, or most of them, were found in the way in a direct line from where the explosion took place, the contents of this flue would be instantly converted into after-damp by the explosion, and being taken up by the natural ventilation of the colliery, would be carried into the workings, and thus cause the death of every man over whom it passed in its way. I think it highly probable that the explosion might set fire to the north stables, which are at a distance of three hundred and fifty yards, not because flame would travel that far, but because particles of inflammable matter, set fire to by the explosion, would be driven in the direction of the stables, and besides the temperature of these exploded gases being about 1500 degrees of Fahrenheit or more, or a very bright red heat, would of itself if coming near hay or straw, immediately set fire to it; and in this way, as far as I have seen, I consider everything can be fully accounted for. It would take seventy-five quarter casks (of 25lbs. each) of gunpowder to produce the force such as the quantity of gas exploded as described is capable of exerting. In these calculations I took a ton of coals to produce 10,000 cubic feet of light carburetted hydrogen, and about 650 feet from 150lbs. of coal, and add about nine and a half times that of atmospheric air, which makes 6835 of explosive mixture. A quantity of soot deposited in the flue, assuming that no steam was present, could not have added to the explosion. Assuming that steam was present, I consider that the explosion might possibly have been increased in intensity. The flue is ascending, and I think it improbable that the gas would have lodged in it, but still it is possible. I think it highly probable the gas might lodge from the boiler fire to and inclusive of the crossing. All calculations based upon the difference of the specific gravity of gases are liable to disturbance by differences of temperature, by which means a cubic foot of heavy gas may be rendered lighter than a cubic foot of lighter gas, according to the temperature. If the gas was only contained in that portion of the flue (I mean between the crossing and the boiler) it would reduce the quantity of the gas to about 3000 cubic feet. The explosion of that quantity would be quite sufficient to account for what I found. I think the only explosion took place in the flue. I think that gas oversaturated, or under-saturated above or under the proportion of nine and a half of air to one of gas might have the effect. After the crossing was blown down, a larger amount of air would be admitted to mix with the hydrogen gas, but I cannot positively say whether it would increase the explosion or not. There is no reason which I can give at present to account for the gas accumulating and exploding on this occasion when it has not done so for so many years. It is one of those occurrences affected, to some extent, by the doctrine of chances; that is, you require inflammable gas, atmospheric air, and fire, contemporaneously; any one of these wanting and no explosion ensues. I do not think the state of the weather affected it at all. If the damper had been hermetically closed, inflammable gas would not have been found there. Its being partly open would add to the generation of gas, and also supply air. It is my opinion the explosion cannot have taken place in any other manner than I have explained, from the direction in which the bricks have been thrown and are lying, and from the other appearances in and about the flue. If a large quantity of fire-damp had come down the downcast shaft, going over, not through, the fire, and filling the flue, a similar explosion might take place, if by any means fired. If no large quantity of gas came down the downcast, nor from the inbye workings, to fill the flue, I do not consider it possible to have taken place from any other gaseous elements from any other place than the boiler fire. If 160,000 cubic feet of air were coming down the downcast shaft per minute, it would have to meet with 16,000 of fire-damp per minute to make it explosive to the extent that I have supposed it may have occurred in the flue; but having to pass two other boiler fires would cause the explosion to be totally different, and the indications also, to what I found them.

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print