On the Explosion at Hetton Colliery, on the 20th day of December, 1860.
By Mr. Nicholas Wood.
On the 20th day of December, 1860, at about half-past 8 o'clock in the evening, an explosion took place in the East and West Minor Pits, which was attended with the most serious results, and by which twenty-two persons, nine horses, and fifty-six ponies were killed, and considerable damage done to the pits. The explosion took place in the immediate vicinity of the downcast pit, and as it was considered quite impossible that any explosive gas could have occurred in that locality, it was at first thought to have occurred by an explosion of one of the steam engine boilers — there being three steam engines, and three high-pressure steam boilers near the bottom of these shafts.
When access was obtained to the bottom of the pit, as will hereafter be explained, it was ascertained that the explosion had taken place in the boiler flues of one of the engines, called Davison's engine; that it had blown the flues to atoms where the explosion had at first occurred; that it had then blown down a crossing or archway over the main wagonway (about eighty yards from the centre of the explosion), and had then spread right and left from such crossing, one current passing to the left along the main west wagonway to the shaft, where it had blown seventeen fathoms of the brattice out of the shaft, and had then proceeded into the west way, where, at a distance of 800 yards from the shaft, it had killed several men; at the same time, the other current had passed along the east wagonway, and, at about the same distance, had killed four men — the effects of the explosion being, however, felt at a distance of upwards of a mile from the centre of the explosion, in both directions. In a north and south direction, the main ways being at right angles to the direction of the explosion from the crossing, though the effects were felt for upwards of 1000 yards, yet the force was much diminished by its passage around the angles of the entrances into the main roads.
A conclusion was soon arrived at by the parties in charge of the mine, that the explosion could not have been occasioned by the ordinary gas of the mine (a conclusion corroborated by subsequent inquiries), but that it had occurred by an explosion of some description of gas generated within the engine flues of Davison's engine in the East Minor Pit.
The circumstances and results of this explosion being of an almost unexampled character, and being likewise of so important a nature regarding the risk attendant upon the employment of fire engines, boilers, and flues underground, render it advisable that every publicity should be given to all the circumstances attending such an event, for the purpose of clearly and unequivocally ascertaining and considering all the facts of the case, that I have thought it of sufficient importance to lay before the Institute the result of all that took place at the coroner's inquest, and any other facts which such inquiry elicited, and which appeared to me to bear upon the investigation of so important an inquiry.
I may premise that, finding the explosion to have been occasioned by causes which were most unprecedented, and so very difficult to he accounted for, and of so mysterious a nature, I suggested that the inquiry before the coroner should be of the most searching character — that all the evidence which could by possibility throw any light upon so intricate a subject should be obtained; and, therefore, besides examining all the witnesses usual on ordinary occasions of explosions, viz., of the workmen in the mine at the time, of the persons in practical charge of the mine when the accident occurred, and of the viewer under whose direction the underground operations were conducted, I called in several professional gentlemen of other collieries, who assisted in recovering the bodies, and who rendered most efficient assistance on so melancholy an occasion, I also obtained the evidence of two of the most scientific and manufacturing chemists of the district, Mr. I. L. Bell and Dr. Richardson, with a view of ascertaining if they could, by their chemical knowledge, satisfactorily account for so extraordinary an explosion.
In soliciting the attention of the Institute to so important an inquiry, it will, perhaps, be the most advisable mode, and that which will promote the most impartial inquiry, if I lay before them the official evidence adduced on oath at the inquest, which I am enabled to do by the kindness of the coroner, T. C. Maynard, Esq., who has forwarded to me a copy of the depositions taken by him on that occasion. In order, however, to make that evidence more intelligible, I have annexed copies of some plans exhibited at the inquest, explanatory of; and showing the situation of the pits, the direction and extent of the different main roads and air courses, and the quantity of air circulating in the different splits of the East and West Minor Pits, which were the pits in which the explosion occurred. I have also added two plans, on a larger scale, showing the underground furnaces, and the different air courses around the downcast and upcast shafts — the position of the different engines near the bottom of the pits — and of the boilers and flues, particularly the flue in which the explosion occurred; showing the state of the flues previously to and at the time of the explosion, and the state in which they were found after the explosion had taken place; together with plans of the damper of the boiler, and the fire place from which it is supposed the explosion originated. These will, I trust, enable the members of the Institute to more clearly understand the evidence, and to investigate the causes which led to such a lamentable accident.
Plan No. I. shows the general ventilation of the two pits in which the explosion occurred, with the main air courses and splits of the air, on which is marked the quantity of air passing along these splits, and into the different districts of workings immediately preceding the explosion. It may be explained, that in this portion of the Hetton Collieries there are two perfectly distinct and independent shafts or pits; one called the East and West Minor Pit, which is marked on the plan as the downcast, and which are denominated the Lyons Pits or Colliery; and the other, which is called the Blossom Pit, marked on the plan as the upcast, the latter pit not being sunk below the furnace drifts (coloured yellow), which, as shown in plans II. and III., enter it on both sides; therefore it crosses the roads from the downcast pits from twenty to thirty feet above them. The reason why the downcast is termed the East and West Minor Pits is, that the shaft is divided by a partition or brattice, on each side of which are drawing apparatus by which the coals of two pits workings — the East Minor Pit workings, and the West Minor Pit workings — are drawn to bank. The airways, or main roads along which the intake currents pass, are shown in black, and the return air courses are shown in red lines, and the quantity of air passing is shown in cubic feet per minute. There are, as shown on the plan, two travelling roads to the Eppleton Pits or Colliery, another division of the colliery, and at which there are separate and independent downcast and upcast shafts. The communication is closed by double doors, and these roads are only used for the purpose of travelling between the two collieries, and which, on this occasion, were found of great utility, as will be seen by the evidence. There is also another section of the colliery, called the Elemore Pits or Colliery, at which there are also separate downcast and upcast pits; but there are no travelling roads or communication between the Elemore, and the Lyons, or Eppleton Pits.
Plan No. II. shows the position of the two Lyons Pits, the downcast or East and West Minor Shafts, and the upcast or Blossom Pit, with the furnaces, viz., the east furnace, and the west furnace, and the drifts leading from them to the upcast shaft having a rise of about thirty feet. The positions of the several engines are also shown, and of the boilers; the direction of the steam pipes leading from the boilers to the engines being shown by black lines, and of the exhaust pipes by red lines. All the boilers are placed upon the level of the Hutton Seam, or of the bottom of the downcast shaft; the flues from Davison's engine passing across the main road near the Albert engine to the two furnaces, where it enters the furnace drift to the upcast shaft. The flue of the two boilers for the active and Victoria engines pass up a staple, shown on the plan, near the boilers into the furnace drift, which is there about twenty feet above the level of the boilers and downcast drifts. The section A, A, shows the inclination of the furnace drifts from the furnaces (which are on a level with the downcast shaft) to the bottom of the upcast shaft. The longitudinal section, on a large scale, showing the inclination from the boiler of Davison's engine to the furnace drift at the junction of the two west furnaces. This plan also shows the position of the stables, which were set on fire by the explosion; and also the route of the ventilation at and immediately preceding the explosion, the black lines showing the ingoing direction of the air from the downcast shaft, and the red lines the return currents from the different districts of workings to the furnaces and upcast shaft. Upon this plan, showing the longitudinal section of the flues from the boiler of Davison's engine to the bottom of the furnace drift at F, is likewise shown cross sections at A, B, and C, D. It will be seen by these that nearly up to the crossing of the main wagonway, at X, the flue is double, with a passage road, c, c, above the flues, a, b, a, along the middle of which the smoke from the boiler passed, and that beyond and at the crossing the centre flue, b, along which such heated air passed, was of a larger area than between the boiler and the crossing. The two smaller flues, a, a, were travelling roads, along which a considerable current passed to prevent the heat of the centre flue from setting fire to the coal.
Plan No. III. shows the state of the flues, crossings, &c., after the explosion, and the direction of the blast or explosion as adduced by the evidence, or shown by the effects of the explosion on the doors and passages around the shaft. It is unnecessary for me to give any detailed description, in this place, as it could only be a repetition of the evidence given at the inquest. I prefer that these particulars, and the effects of the explosion, should be given by the persons examined, than that it should be given by me at second hand; and that any conclusion which may be drawn from the evidence, or other details or particulars, should result from a free and unbiased discussion by the members of the Institute, rather than from any observations of mine, except so far as I may deem it necessary to offer any opinion at such discussion. I shall, therefore, only give such explanation as may be necessary to make the plans clear and intelligible. It will be seen that plan III. is a perfect copy of plan II., except as altered to show the state of things after the explosion, and the addition of the two sections of the flues at E, F, and G, H, to show the effect of the explosion on the flues at these places. It will be seen that the darts on the plan are made to proceed from the red mark through E, F, on the plan, from whence, as a centre, the explosion proceeded in all directions; and the thickness of the lines are made to show, in some degree, approximately, the intensity of the explosion at the several places, and in the different directions.
Plan No. II. shows different plans of the flues and damper. From these it will be seen that the dimensions of the flue next the boiler is three feet by thirteen and a half inches up to the damper, and four feet two inches by sixteen inches beyond the damper. The damper works in a recess in the brick work, not in a metal frame. This recess is three inches in width, and three inches in depth all around the flue, the damper working up and down within such recess, in the usual manner, by a balance weight, working over a pulley, the weight working up and down near the engine fire. The damper was five feet in height and two feet in width, and half an inch in thickness. On the top of the flues, and of the recess in which the damper worked, was an iron plate, leaving an inch in width to steady the damper in working up and down within the recess, as shown in the plan.
It was given in evidence that the damper, when the fire was damped, at five o'clock on the evening of the accident, was left about one and a half inch from being shut, this would give an opening of thirty-six square inches; and supposing only three-eighths of an inch opening into the flue around the damper within the recess would give about forty-four inches opening, making about seventy square inches through which the air would pass into the flue when the fire was damped. I have ascertained, by experiments made recently, that the velocity with which the air passes through the opening of the damper with seventy square inches of area is sixty-six feet per second, consequently, if there were seventy square inches of opening into the flue at the time of the explosion, or during the time whilst the fire was damped, there would be about 2000 cubic feet of air passing into the flue per minute.
I now proceed to give the evidence as adduced at the Inquest, so far as it bears upon the enquiry before the Institute, and leave the investigation to the members without comment.