Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
/   \

V. — THE OPERATION OF AMERICAN MOBILE MACHINERY

(1) The Historical Development of the Use of American Machines. Having regard to the important part played by this machinery in the explosion it will be advisable to give a short description of the types of Joy loader and shuttle car in use at this colliery.

During the War years, with the object of increasing coal output, much of this equipment, including shortwall coal-cutting machines, duckbill loaders, mobile trucks and the like, was imported under Lend-Lease into many mines in this country and installed in seams likely to be suitable for the bord and pillar system of working, for which these types of machines were designed.

The naturally favourable conditions of the Busty Seam at this mine: thickness of seam, strong character of the roof and floor, depth of working, easy gradient, and comparative freedom from firedamp, rendered it a suitable subject for trial.

Joy loaders and shuttle cars were first introduced into 69 District during 1945 and the good results in whole working (advancing formation of pillars) justified further installations, four in all : three in the South Side Busty districts and the most recent one, in April, 1950, in another part of the mine.

Good results continued to be obtained in the whole working but the complete extraction of the majority of the seam remaining in pillars. about 67 per cent. in the case of 69A District, was clearly to be the crux of success of this mechanization as a whole. I imagine the results in this direction were not similarly satisfactory after an experience of some nine months or so in this district. However that may be, this brokens working called for additional care in the use of electrical machinery at the face, bearing in mind the contiguity of the goaf being laid down, and for a high standard of maintenance of the apparatus which unfortunately was lacking.

(2) The Joy Loader (Type 12 B. U.). This machine is mounted on two caterpillar tracks, each driven by a separate 3 h.p. motor, and employs two 3 h.p. motors for the gathering arms which collect loose coal from the face on to a contained scraper conveyor, which in turn delivers the coal to the opposite end of the loader where it is discharged on to the shuttle car. A small electricallydriven pump powers a hydraulic system for raising and lowering the gathered load and the loading jib at its rear end, and for moving this jib horizontally to facilitate the coal being discharged at a specified point.

The electrical controls are situated in a master control box mounted on the frame on the right hand side of the machine facing the gathering head and immediately above the tractor guard. These controls consist of the following switches :-

 (i) 
On the extreme right hand end a SAFE-OFF switch which, when in the OFF position, prevents any of the motors on the machine being run.
 (ii) 
On the same axis of the SAFE-OFF switch, but with the handle to the left, a switch controlling the gathering head motors. This switch has three positions : OFF, RUN and START, and is normally springloaded so that when released the switch returns to the RUN position.
 (ii) 
On the left of the master control box, two switches controlling the traction motors, which are so arranged that the handles operate on a common axis to permit easy control of the machine in a forward direction.

The three controls of the hydraulic system are situated slightly to the left of the master control box and are used for the starting and stopping of the oil pump motor, the lifting and lowering of the gathering head and the loading end, and the horizontal movement of the loader jib.

No provision is made in the American design for electrical interlocking of plugs and sockets and flexible cables to ensure that there is no power on the cable or plug when the latter is detached from the apparatus. The use of such interlocking, or remote control, is now common practice in British mines, and at Eppleton Colliery an additional push/pull switch for an intrinsically safe remote control circuit was fitted on the top cover of the master control box to enable power to be cut off the trailing cable at the gate-end box.

A photographic illustration of the loader is shown on Plate I (C).

The arrangement of cable entry into the master control unit of these machines, as received from America, whereby the main feeder cable passed through a gland which was sealed with asbestos cord packing, was not in line with the accepted British standards, nor was it considered to be suitable by colliery managements generally as it did not allow for inter-changeability of cables and the use of the screened type of British trailing cable. To overcome this defect cable adaptor boxes of different designs were fitted to the master control unit to enable the ordinary B.S. standard type of plug and socket to be used, and in conjunction with this fitting the remote control arrangement described above was incorporated. Although these additions had the effect of invalidating the U.S.A. "Permissible Certificate", they were agreed by H.M. Electrical Inspectors to be an improvement, provided the fittings were flameproof and of suitable mechanical strength and design.

(3) The Shuttle Car (Type 32D). This is a self-contained battery-operated mobile vehicle used for transporting mineral from a mechanical loader at the coal face to a discharging point outbye, in this case on ramps at the return end of a belt conveyor. It is about 22 feet in length, has an overall width of about 7 feet when fitted with side plates, and a maximum height of 4 feet 5 inches. It runs on pneumatic tyres and has a capacity of about three tons of coal.

Power at 96 volts is supplied from a 330 ampere-hour battery at 6-hour rate of discharge, carried in two steel containers, each holding 24 cells and placed one at each side of the car.

All the controls are placed at the driver’s platform and contactor switchgear and hydraulic 4-wheel brakes give effective control of the car. The driver has a choice of two seats at the near side (left hand) of the front or driving end so arranged that he can always face the direction in which the car is going. The steering wheel can be tilted to assist in the steering of the car.

The car is driven by two 5 h.p. motors each driving one rear wheel separately. Its speed is 3½ to 5 miles an hour. On the floor of the chassis is a scraper chain conveyor, driven by a 5 h.p. motor situated at the rear of the car, which can be made to move front-ways for filling the car when receiving from the loader and discharging its load outbye.

A photographic illustration of one of these cars is shown on Plate II (B).

(4) Examination of the Machines after the Explosion. It is appropriate at this stage to describe briefly the condition in which these machines was found after the explosion by H.M. Electrical Inspectors of Mines, Messrs. R. Dobson and B. J. Burkle.

(a) Joy Loader (Serial No. 3405). This machine was in position at the coal face of No. 8 Left. The external push/pull remote control switch for applying power to the loader, the traction motor switches, and the hydraulic levers was in the OFF position. The gathering arms switch was in the RUN position, and the lights and safety switch on the upright ON. The cable adaptor box, normally attached to the master control unit, was detached with its spigot completely free from the engaging hole in this unit. None of the four fixing screws was in position, and two of them had evidently been fractured level with the outside of the control unit on some similar previous occasion. Due to this detachment, an opening existed from the outside atmosphere to the interior of the master control unit in which the contacts are situated. A gap of 0.042 inch also existed at one point in the flange of the control unit top cover. (The position of the detached cable adaptor box is shown on Plate II (A)).

This machine was completely dismantled underground and examined in detail. The interconnecting cables appeared to be undamaged with one exception : that from the main transformer chamber to the jib-end light was found to be completely severed, but no evidence of fusion was found. One of the switch contacts had been so adjusted as to prevent power being switched on to the lighting circuits, and one of the interconnecting cable gland nuts was not securely attached to the gland. The insulation of the motor windings was found on test to be in order.

(b) Joy Loader (Serial No. 3276). This machine was standing on No. 6 Right cross-cut between Nos. 5 and 6 bords. It is unlikely that it was actually being worked at the time the explosion occurred. The cable adaptor box was found to be very loosely attached to the master control unit and all the four fixing screws were broken off in the threaded holes in the unit. The spigot flange was entered in its housing in the master control unit but a wedge-shaped gap ranging from 3/16 to of an inch existed between the side of the adaptor box and the master control unit. Seven of the 11 set screws in the cover of the control unit were loose giving a flange gap of 0.006 to 0.025 of an inch. All interconnecting cables appeared to be undamaged and tests of the insulation of the windings of each of the five motors were satisfactory.

(c) Shuttle Car (Serial No. ET 1028). This car was in position at the outer end of the Joy loader in No. 8 Left. It was almost fully loaded with coal and dirt. The driving side battery was damaged with three of the cell tops shattered, but no internal defect was found when the battery was later dismantled at the surface. Samples of dust removed from the cell tops of the batteries were sent to S.M.R.E. and a microscopic examination revealed signs of carbonizing. A layer of white powder, later identified as the filling powder of a main fuse, was found in the positive fuse chamber of the driving side battery and signs of fusion were seen at the fuse in the negative chamber of the offside battery. Both fuse chambers were afterwards tested at S.M.R.E. but no external inflammable mixture was ignited.

The protecting hoses covering the interconnecting cables of each of the three motors were found to have been drawn out of their respective clamps with the result that the cable was exposed near each motor, but no evidence of any damage to the core insulation was found.

Tests of the left side traction motor revealed an earth fault which was located on an interpole coil winding. On dismantlement at the surface it was seen that the copper of the interpole winding had fused to the iron of the polepiece. This earth fault indicated that another similar fault must have occurred elsewhere on the machine, but no such fault was revealed by a careful examination of all the apparatus. It was therefore presumed that one fault had been repaired at some time prior to the explosion.

(d) Shuttle Car (Serial No. ET 1049). This was standing empty on No. 4 Main Bord opposite the entrance to No. 6 Right Cross-cut. It was afterwards completely dismantled underground and appeared on examination to be in good order except for the cable between the driver’s control box and the front light. The protective hose cover of this cable was punctured and the cable insulation damaged at one point, but no evidence of fusion was visible on the conductors. The clamping glands of the interconnecting cables were all tightly packed but two of them had been packed with spun yarn and one with black adhesive tape instead of the original asbestos cord.

All the other electrical apparatus, including the arcwall cutter and two drilling machines, which were of the British standard of flameproof design, were found in safe working order, apart from consequential damage to one drilling cable.

(5) Maintenance of Cable Entry on Joy Loader Machines. Since the igniting cause of this explosion has been established as being due to an electrical defect at the main cable entry of the Joy loader at work in No. 8 Left at the time, it is necessary to discuss at some length the question of the supervision of these machines at this mine, in particular the maintenance in a flameproof condition of the cable adaptor box connection with the master control unit.

Plate I (B) shows the cable entry arrangement, and the cable adaptor box separated from the master control unit is shown in Figure 1 opposite.

This adaptor box was fitted to each of eight Joy loaders at their inception at this mine to give indirect cable entry and so enable, as I have previously stated, the use of the British type of flexible cable and interchangeability.

The design of the assembly, however, soon manifested itself in practice to be unsatisfactory owing to the fixing set screws frequently becoming sheared or stripped - as a result of vibration, and or the possible sustaining of a blow, together with the drag (at times) of the heavy trailing cable, while the loader was being flitted - causing the flameproof joint to open and the spigot to be drawn out of its housing and thus expose the contacts inside the control unit.

An attempt was then made to overcome this structural weakness by fitting an angle bracket (shown on Figure 1) to strengthen the assembly and to sustain any blow or drag of the kind described above.

This arrangement seems to have been only partially successful and still called for the frequent attention of the electrical staff. The difficulty of maintaining the assembly in a safe condition, however, seems to have increased considerably in 69A District about nine months prior to the explosion. This was not, in my view, a coincidence but was due to the rougher usage received by these machines in pillar extraction work commenced about that time.

From this time onwards the standard of maintenance and repair in respect of the two Joy loaders in 69A District appears to have deteriorated considerably and it is not unlikely that latterly, at least, the cable entry was seldom being used in its designed flameproof condition.

I need only give two instances to illustrate the deplorably low state of repair into which the main cable entry on these two machines was allowed to fall.

A young assistant electrician, Gordon Squires, carried out repairs to these machines on two occasions a few days before the explosion and extracts from his evidence at the Inquest are given below :-

I started work at Eppleton Colliery in 1940 at the age of 14 and I am a fully qualified electrician. I work under the supervision of Mr. Minto, head electrician, and of the shift foremen.

On 26th June, I was sent to make an examination of the electrical apparatus in 69A District, I examined the Right Side Joy loader and found that the cable adaptor box was broken away from the master control chamber, the spigot was broken off the adaptor box and had been left in its housing on the control chamber. The angle bracket which acts as a stiffener between the control chamber and the adaptor box was fractured, with the result that the latter was hanging loose and exposing the leads which ran from it into the chamber. The loader was working at the time; the operator was later killed in the explosion. I ordered the loader to be stopped and pointed out that it should not have been run in this condition. I stripped off the plug housing and then took off the adaptor box in order to get at the spigot and the studs. I sent to the surface for a new adaptor box. The latter is fixed to the control chamber by means of four studs which can only be reached by taking the end plate off the box. I found all four studs broken off. I tried to pick the broken stud ends out of their sockets but found that I could not do this. I then fitted the new adaptor box. The spigot was a driving fit, and I fastened the adaptor box by means of its angle bracket. I had to remove the top cover of the control chamber in order to punch out the broken spigot.

Before replacing the cover. I checked the flameproof gap of the new spigot. I was satisfied that the clearance was fully up to standard and that the apparatus was now flameproof. I cannot remember what the gap was but I am certain that it was less than 10 thousandths. I checked the adaptor box and the pummel housing for movement and found them to be secure. I considered that the machine could safely be used in this condition but that the broken studs should be drilled out and replaced in order to make the fixing more secure. I came to the surface and reported to the shift foreman, I think it was Mr. Avery. I was not sent back to this machine before the explosion and I do not know whether the studs were drilled out or not. This is the only time when I have had to deal with a broken spigot.

On the 29th June I was in the afternoon shift commencing at 3.0 p.m. While I was busy repairing a drill transformer in 69A District, the deputy, George Lumley, asked me to have a look at the Left Side Joy loader. He said that the pummel housing and the adaptor box were loose. The machine was standing when I got to it, but I found that the adaptor box was loose and that shot firing cable had been tied round it to try and secure it. On making an examination I found that the angle bracket was fractured and that the adaptor box was loose but that the spigot was partly entered into the control chamber. I took the end plate off the adaptor box and found all four fixing bolts lying in the bottom of the adaptor box. Two of them were broken in their sockets, a third had stripped the threads of the socket, and a fourth bolt was loose but the socket was alright. I stripped the pummel housing down so as to remove the adaptor box and I tried to remove the broken studs but I was unable to do so. I replaced the adaptor box and fitted one of the 3/8-inch bolts but this was all that I could do at the time. I took the cover off the control chamber, tested the spigot gap and found it satisfactory, but I saw the deputy and told him that the loader must on no account be moved until I had got a new angle bracket. I came to bank to get this and returned to fit it. After doing this I tried the pummel housing for movement but found none and I said the machine could be used. I returned to the surface and reported to the surface foreman, Mr. Avery. I reported what I had done and said that the two broken studs wanted drilling out and the damaged hole re-tapping to take ½-inch stud. I did not get back to this machine.

I have not myself had to deal with defective adaptor boxes on any occasion other than the 26th and 29th June. I am usually in the Maudlin and Main Coal Seams and I do not often go into the mechanization districts in the Busty Seam.

I also give below extracts from the evidence of the Shift Foreman Electrician, J. R. Avery :-

I started at Eppleton Colliery as an electrician in 1935 and I was appointed as a foreman electrician in 1937. At the time of the explosion I was shift foreman working in rotation with G. Rafter and J. T. Robinson on the three shifts commencing at 7.0 a.m., 3.0 p.m. and 11.0 p.m.

Instructions about work requiring to be carried out are given to the shift foreman either by Mr. Minto, head electrician, or by the foreman of the preceding shift. The shift foreman does some of the work personally and he arranges for the other work to be done by the assistant electricians. At the time of the explosion there were eight assistant electricians and six apprentices for the whole mine. There would usually be four electricians on the day shift and two on each of the other shifts. At the end of the shift, the foreman makes out a written report on all work done in that shift, and this report is passed to the head electrician. I consult with the head electrician when on the day shift or the afternoon shift. When on the night shift I see the afternoon foreman before starting my shift and the day foreman when I finish.

I cannot remember the date when the angle brackets were first fitted to stiffen the adaptor box assembly. The adaptor boxes gave no trouble for some time after the Joy loaders were put into use and then we started to get odd cases where examination showed that one or more of the fixing studs had become loose. The angle brackets were then fitted but we continued to get trouble occasionally. Sometimes the studs would be slack and in some cases one of them would be broken. On some examinations the studding would be alright but sometimes there might be one stud slack or two studs slack. It would be very unusual to find more than two studs slack.

From my experience, if there was only one stud in position, the facing between the adaptor box and the control chamber would be flameproof, but I would not consider the fixing to be mechanically strong enough and I would report it as unsatisfactory and requiring immediate attention.

On 26th June, when I came on shift at 11.0 p.m., I heard that Squires was in 69A District fitting a new adaptor box to the Right Side Joy loader. I went into the district and looked over his work. An external examination showed no defect. I tested and found the facing joint flameproof and firm. The machine was working and, as I had a job to attend to elsewhere, I contented myself with an external examination. I did not know at that time there were no stud bolts in the box. I saw Squires later at the surface and he then told me that some of the studs were broken in the holes, but I still expected that there were some studs in and I did not know until now that the fixing of the adaptor box was depending on the angle bracket and that there were no studs in.

On the 29th June, Squires was again working on my shift. He reported to me that he had repaired the adaptor box on the Left Side Joy loader and fitted a new angle bracket. He had tried to pick out two studs which lie could not do. One hole was partly stripped but he got one good bolt put in the other hole and left all secure and flameproof. In my written report I mentioned that the studs needed attention and I also mentioned it to the succeeding foreman, G. Rafter.

It was now the weekend and, as I had been told to concentrate on electrical work elsewhere, I did not follow up to see that the studding had been attended to. We were short of a proper tool to do this job as, owing to the awkward position of the drilling, the standard drill was not suitable. I was taking steps to get the tool.

After his inspection on the night shift on 26th/27th June, following Squire’s repair to the cable entry of the Right Side Joy loader, Mr. Avery reported to the head electrician, Mr. Minto, as follows :-

Busty 69A new plug socket adaptor installed in Joy loader. The studding is broken in and will be to drill out when convenient.

It was, unfortunately, never convenient to fit new fixing bolts in either of these machines and it is clear that both machines were worked without any bolts in position from these dates, at least, right up to the time of the explosion.

It had evidently gradually become accepted practice here that so long as the spigot was made "a driving fit" (to quote Squires) and the cable adaptor box was kept up to the master control box by the angle bracket, it was not necessary to renew any of the fixing bolts. In other words, as suggested by Mr. Sam Watson at the Inquest, the angle bracket gave a false sense of security to the electricians. It may be conceded that even in this condition the assembly would be flameproof for the time being, but it was obviously very susceptible to derangement from a blow and consequently much too precarious to be safe. It is therefore hardly surprising that the cable entries of both machines were found to be in a defective and unsafe condition after the explosion.

It is not difficult to imagine that, having eight of these assemblies to repair frequently in addition to their normal duties, the underground electricians were overworked, and the remedy was clearly to have improved the design of the cable entry arrangement as soon as it became patent it was unsatisfactory. I cannot understand why this step was not taken by the head electrician, Mr. Minto.

Mr. Minto discussed the design with the Group Engineer but the matter got no further than a start being made to increase the size of the fixing screws. There were no entries in the daily log book to indicate any trouble of the kind and he admitted that he had not mentioned the matter either to the manager or the undermanager. Nevertheless, 1 find it difficult to believe that neither of these chief officials had any knowledge of this trouble which must have had an adverse effect on the output. In any event it is to be inferred that little heed had been paid by any of the officials to the safe running of these machines, and that the matter was largely left in the hands of the underground electricians to make improvized repairs according to their own standards of safety and in the time at their disposal during their routine examinations of the electrical apparatus.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print