IV. - THE CAUSE OF THE EXPLOSION
No contraband (matches, cigarettes, or the like) was found in the workings or in the clothing of any of the victims and smoking or the illegal use of a naked light can be discounted as a possible source of ignition.
No shots had been fired during the shift and, although the shot holes in the face of No. 8 Right were being charged at the time of the explosion, the exploder and firing cable were found on No. 4 Main Bord.
All the safety lamps, ten electric and nine flame lamps. in use in the district were examined at the Safety in Mines Research Establishment of this Ministry and passed as safe, except two electric cap lamps. Had the damage to these two lamps - broken outer glasses and envelopes of the inner bulbs - occurred before the explosion, it is possible either of them could have ignited firedamp, but I am satisfied that in each case the damage was consequential and that safety lamps can be dismissed as a likely igniting cause.
There was no indication that frictional heating of any description had entered into the question, and no compressed air was in use in the district.
All the fixed electrical apparatus was found to be in a flameproof condition. Of the portable apparatus in use there, the only machinery at work at the time was the Joy loader and the shuttle car at the face of No. 8 Left, and the arcwall machine (running light) in the return airway at its junction with No. 6 Right.
The course of travel of the explosion indicated that ignition had probably occurred in No. 8 Left and this was supported by the fact that the cable adaptor box was found separated from the master control box of the Joy loader.
The adaptor box had been mounted to the control box by means of a flange and spigot machined joint held by four fixing set screws or studs and a strengthening angle bracket, but none of the studs was found to be in position. Two of them had evidently been broken for some time past, and the spigot joint had opened to create a crescent-shaped gap in the side of the control unit (see Plate II (A)).
The interior of the control box was in a very dirty condition and contained a quantity of coal dust and many small pieces of coal. This indicated there had been open access to the inside switch contacts for a considerable period prior to the explosion.
Tests carried out at the flameproof testing section of the S.M.R.E. at Buxton showed that this gap readily passed flame in an inflammable mixture of methane and air with a spark made to simulate the break flash at the control switch contacts of the traction motors switches of the Joy loader.
Similar tests were witnessed later at Buxton by representatives of the National Coal Board, including Messrs. H. F. Collins, Production Director, and J. L. Baker, No. 2 Area Electrical Engineer, for the Durham Division; of the Durham Area of the National Union of Mineworkers, including Mr. Sam Watson; and of the Mines Inspectorate, including Messrs. T. A. Jones, Divisional Inspector, and J. Cowan, Principal Electrical Inspector, and myself.
A summary report on an examination and test of the cable entry assembly of the Joy loader, made by Mr. J. Haig, Chief Experimental Officer of the S.M.R.E., Buxton, is given in Appendix II.
Damage to, and leakage of the electrolyte from, one of the batteries of the shuttle car in No. 8 Left was investigated to determine whether open sparking, or an explosion of hydrogen, had taken place but no evidence of this could be demonstrated experimentally afterwards.
I discuss these apparatus later in this Report.
I conclude that (a) the explosion had travelled all the working places and roads which were near to the faces ; (b) it was principally one of firedamp and there was little if any propagation by coal dust; and (c) a falling barometer had probably brought about some encroachment of firedamp back in the goaf, and some disturbance of a ventilation brattice or canvas sheet was sufficient to enable firedamp to enter No. 8 Left, where it was ignited at the master control box of the Joy loader and burned back into the goaf until it reached explosive range and there developed violence which swept from the goaf into the return airway.
I am satisfied this is the proper explanation of the igniting source and behaviour of the explosion, and this view is generally accepted by all parties.