II. - THE 69A DISTRICT
(1) General Description and Method of Work. - This district was set off in 1946 from the Main South Plane to work the seam in a trough area, 200 yards wide, lying between two large faults running in a westerly direction, forming pillars 37 yards by 17 yards with headings five yards wide to give 33 per cent. extraction.
A quantity of 7,050 cubic feet of air per minute entered the district, but only 3,080 cubic feet reached the face. The records show these figures to have been consistent over the previous 12 months.
From its inception the district was worked by arcwall cutters, Joy loaders and shuttle cars. The latter transported the coal on to the No. 4 Main Bord where they discharged on to a Huwood 30-inch belt conveyor feeding a short scraper-chain conveyor loading into tubs which were hauled in sets of 30 by main and tail haulage to the pit bottom.
The district had advanced to the working boundary, a distance of about 1 ,300 yards from the Main South Plane. Support had to be left for surface property on the inbye length and the workings were stepped back for extraction of the pillars, by "brokens" working, which commenced in September, 1950. At the time of the explosion about 300 yards had been retreated and some 12 acres of goaf laid down.
The loading point was stationed about 350 yards from the line of extraction at the time of the explosion, and about 400 yards from the Main South Plane or half a mile from the Jane Shaft.
At the face the section of the seam included a top coal 1 foot 8 inches, dirt band and coal 1 foot 1 inch and a bottom coal 2 feet 6 inches, totalling 5 feet 3 inches working height, with a bedded sandstone roof.
The arcwall machine cut normally in the dirt band to a depth of 7 feet. The band was then loaded by a Joy loader into a shuttle car which discharged into stowbords (completed and disused headings), but this practice was rather difficult during extraction working and the dirt was occasionally loaded out on to the belt conveyor. The holed faces were broken down by separate rounds each of four shots in the top and the bottom coal, and the coal was then loaded out and conveyed mechanically.
At the time of the explosion the electric machinery installed at the face consisted of one A.B. Universal arcwall coal-cutter, two Joy loaders, two shuttle cars and two portable drilling machines. Electric power was supplied from a sub-station in the district transforming from 5,500 to 500 volts A.C., and the battery-operated shuttle cars were served at an outbye charging station by two 7.5 K.V.A. rectifiers.
All the electrical equipment was up to British flameproof standards or was intrinsically safe, except the Joy loaders and the shuttle cars which, however, carried the overall "Permissible Certificate" of the U.S.A. Bureau of Mines.
About 150 tons per day were produced on three shifts arranged as follows :-
| | Descent | Ascent |
| First or Fore Shift | 12.22 a.m. | 8.0 a.m. |
| Second or Back Shift | 8.0 a.m. | 3.34 p.m. |
| Third Shift | 3.34 p.m. | 11.24 p.m. |
(2) Organization of the District. Each shift was in charge of a deputy, under the general supervision of an overman for the whole of the South Side Busty.
The deputy in charge of the fore shift at the time of the explosion was N. Holmes, and those on the second and third shifts respectively were J. Burrows and G. Lumley. The overman on duty at the time was M. Brown.
The normal complement of persons employed in the district on each of the three shifts was 12 and a deputy, which included one shot firer, one driller, two cutter-men, two Joy loader operators, two shuttle car drivers and one machinery maintenance man, with one conveyor loader attendant and two haulage hands outbye.
(3) Inspections prior to the Explosion. The deputy on the fore shift made his own pre-shift inspection before passing his men inbye the meeting station, which he could carry out in about half an hour, but those for the other two shifts were made by the deputy on the previous shift.
The deputy, G. Lumley, on the third shift (the one prior to the explosion) made his second and last inspection between 9.0 p.m. and 10.0 p.m. before his shift finished inbye at 11.10 p.m. The various canvas sheets and brattices were then in position and the ventilation was taking its proper course. During his shift he made frequent tests for gas at the goaf edges and in the working places but found none. Both the lift in No. 8 Left and the "jenkin" (bord lift) in No. 8 Right had been cut during the latter part of the shift but in neither face had the band been cleared or the coal drilled. The arcwall coal-cutter had been brought back to the outbye side of No. 8 Right turn, one Joy loader was standing on the outbye side of the coal-cutter and the second Joy loader was back from the face of No. 6 Skirting. Both shuttle cars were back at the charging station ready for the batteries to be changed.
Deputy Lumley met his successor, the now deceased deputy N. Holmes, at the surface at 12.0 midnight and informed him of the position in 69A District. Holmes went underground at 12.22 a.m. with his shift and probably commenced his inspection about 12.45 a.m., the usual time.
The last few pages of the deputies’ report book, which had been blown outbye from the meeting station, were found torn and illegible and showed signs of burning. There was no legible entry for the last pre-shift inspection by deputy Holmes but his inspection for the previous day, 5th July, was timed to commence at 12.45 a.m. and was completed by 1.30 a.m.
The amount of work done by the new shift certainly points to one of two things, (1) that deputy Holmes completed his pre-shift inspection well before 1.30 a.m. or (2) that he admitted his men piece-meal prior to full completion and recording of his inspection. There was, however, visual evidence in the form of his chalked initials and date to indicate that he had in fact inspected all the working places.
According to R. W. Evans, haulage engineman, two shuttle car loads of stone and coal had been discharged on to the belt conveyor: one load by 1.25 a.m., and it can be assumed these loads came from No. 8 Right face which was found cleaned ready for drilling and charging shot holes. A third shuttle car load was being obtained in No. 8 Left face at the time of the explosion.
This means that the one Joy loader had first been taken into No. 8 Right face, then flitted to the face of No. 8 Left, and that both shuttle cars had been flitted from the charging station to these places. No loading had been done with the other Joy loader in No. 6 Skirting, but the coal-cutting machine had been flitted during this shift from the outbye side of No. 8 Right turn to the junction of No. 6 Bord with No. 6 Right Cross-cut.
I mention this to point out that the amount of flitting done by these machines during the fatal shift would entail passing through many canvas sheets and may well have caused undetected derangement of one or more of them and so short-circuited the air current.