|
25th June 1885, Page: 4, Column: 1 The Accident At The Margaret PitThe InquestThe inquiry into the circumstances attending the accident at the Margaret, or "Peggy," Pit, by which 13 lives were lost, on June 3rd, was resumed before Mr. Maynard, coroner, at the Jolly Potters' Inn, Newbottle, yesterday morning. Wm. Lishman, chief viewer at the colliery, having been examined, as reported in our first edition of yesterday, Ralph Blackbird, fore-shift deputy in the New Maudlin Seam, said that he went to work at 2.30 on the morning of the 3rd, and remained till 10.30. He examined the sixth gateway about ten minutes to three a.m., and a second time at twenty minutes to ten. On each occasion he found the place all right, and although he examined 15 or 16 yards all along the face, there was no sign of dampness, nor was there any change in the condition or colour of the coal to indicate the approach to old workings. As witness was coming out he met the deceased deputy overman House, and reported to him that all was right. — Replying to Mr. Atherley Jones, witness said that at the east place of No. 6 gate-way, where Laidler's body was found, he had seen a little water at times. He had noticed it for about three months, and it had not increased during that time. The water was such as was often given off at a "hitch." — Mr. Atherley Jones : Did you ever hear it suggested that the water might have percolated through from the old workings? — Witness: I never heard that. — By Mr. Young: No water was found in the other workings, and very little at the spot indicated. Had there been any water at the face in the sixth gateway witness would have seen it. He did not see any signs of gas that morning either at three or at ten o'clock. Walter Bircham, hewer at the sixth gateway, was in the back shift on June 2nd. He left the place at a quarter to five p.m., and Jos. Carr, one of the deceased men, followed him in. Whilst hewing there witness did not notice any sign of dampness in the place, nor was there anything in the appearance of the coal to lead him to believe that they were getting near old workings. Witness had been told there was some water from the low side of the seventh gateway, but he had not himself seen it. He had not seen any water in east place at No. 6 gateway, but he had been told there was a "sup" there. He had no idea where the water came from. John Unsworth, hewer, examined by Mr. Atherley Jones, said he had worked on both sides of No. 6 gateway, the last time being a fortnight or three weeks ago. It was above the "hitch" that Laidler's body was found, and witness had never worked below the "hitch." Witness had seen water coming out of the top of the dip side of No. 7 gateway. It dropped from the top, and did not come through the floor. — By the Coroner : He did not know that he was working towards the old workings of the Elizabeth Pit. Wm. Laidler, master shifter, said that early on the morning of the 3rd June he was in the face of No. 6 gateway. The coal was quite dry, and he did not notice the least sign in its condition or colour to lead him to suppose they were approaching the old workings. Witness did not notice the least sign of gas. There had been, so far as witness was aware, no apprehensions experienced by the men as to that particular place. He had a relative in the pit. — Mr. Atherley Jones; Have you ever seen water in the east place of number six gateway, where your nephew's body was found ? — Witness: There was a sup there, but very little. It dropped out of the "threads" in the roof. — The Coroner: That is 60 yards away from the point of holing. — Mr. Atherley Jones: That is admitted. (To the witness): Can you tell me whether it was the dip end or the rise end of east place that the water dropped through from ? — Witness : It was the low side of dip place. — Replying to further questions from Mr. Atherley Jones, witness said the Maudlin top stone bled, and dropped through the threads in the roof. — By the Coroner : The water was no more than was found in an ordinary pit working. Some of the water might have come from the hitch in east place, and the other was the result of the bleeding out of the roof, which was higher than the hitch. Witness had been in the pit 30 years, but he could not say how long the water had been coming through the roof. There was sometimes a tubful of water in a day, and at other times there was none for a week. The bleeding from the roof was the same as witness had noticed in this and other Maudlins where he had worked. John Smailes, fore-overman, examined by Mr. Cooper, said he knew the place where Laidler's body was found. He had observed a little water there that "bled" from the top. It was between No. 6 and No. 7 gateways where the "bleeding" took place. There were "hitch threads" in the roof to cause it, and it was not an unusual thing in the Maudlin wherever there were hitch threads, or small breaks, in the roof. There was very, very little water from the roof. It had lasted about fourteen weeks, and got less if anything. It commenced after they had got about three judds from the point. — By Mr. A. Jones: The Maudlin seam was a dry seam. He agreed with the last witness that a little of the water might have come from the hitch, the other was caused by the bleeding through the hitch threads. Witness admitted that there was a little dripping also between No. 3 and No. 4 gateways, but it was just discernible. The driping was not different to what occurred from the Old Maudlin. — By Mr. Young : In fourteen weeks between 15 and 16 tubs of water would be taken out. In the last nine days two tubs of water were taken out. Witness examined the face where the accident took place on the morning of June 2nd, and there were no indications whatever that they were approaching old workings. It was three years since the drift was holed. Mr. W. Lishman, recalled, produced the old working plan, to show that the old workings of the Elizabeth Pit had been correctly transferred to the new plan. They were designed to a slightly different scale, but corresponded in every respect. Between a point on the old plan and the point of holing the plan showed a length of 376 yards, and that was witness' belief. There had been no means of surveying the old workings through the Elizabeth Pit for 55 years, the last chance of such a survey being in 1830. Had any damage taken place on the surface above the old workings from the Elizabeth Pit, that subsidence would have taken place 50 years ago. Witness had done everything to satisfy himself years ago that the old plans were correct. Within a week of the accident witness was talking over the plans with the manager (Mr. Tate), and he remarked that when they got to a certain point they would have to commence and bore. He had not the slightest apprehension that the old workings of the Elizabeth Pit extended further than shown on the plan. Witness's idea was to begin to bore 200 yards from the old workings. He considered that 50 yards was a safe distance, but he had resolved upon 200 yards as an extra precaution, and for no other reason. He never doubted that the plans were correct, but it was a sense of responsibility as regarded the men that made him decide that boring should be commenced 200 yards from the point of joining. The New Maudlin "Peggy" Pit was opened two or three years ago. Under the present Act of Parliament they were bound to make up the plans every six months, but they were made up in their case more often. — Mr. A. Jones ; Do you know as a matter of fact that 60 years ago plans were made up but very seldom ? — Witness : I do not know that. Witness went on to say the plans at that time were kept up well, and might be so in the case of the Elizabeth Pit up to the day on which the old workings were drowned out. That was in 1830. — Mr. A. Jones pointed out that by the Act of Parliament it was provided that where there was danger from an accumulation of water, the working approaching such place ought not to exceed eight feet in width, and a borehole should be made at least five feet in advance. — Replying to further questions, witness said he could not call to mind a single case where the plans had proved inaccurate up to more than one or two feet. — The difference in level between the east place, where Laidler's body was found and the spot where the holing took place, was from 12 to 15 feet. Witness had had his attention called to the dripping in the ten fathom Hutton seam, but the dripping in the spot spoken of by the several witnesses was so slight as to call for no notice. — By Mr. Young : No human being, so far as he was aware, knew of any communication between the old workings of the Elizabeth Pit and the Margaret Pit, nor were there up to the time of the accident any indications of an approach to the old workings into which the holing took place. The inquiry was then adjourned for luncheon, and in order to give Mr. A. Jones time to consult with his clients as to what other evidence should be called on their side. On the resumption of the inquiry, Mr. Atherley Jones said he had two witnesses to call as to matters of fact. The first witness was John Birgin, a hewer at the Margaret Pit. He said that he had worked in the east place of No. 6 gateway two months before the accident. He had seen close on a tub of water there a day, and it was taken away. He felt the coals wet. The water came from the floor, and witness had also seen it come from the roof at the left side of the gateway. John McCulloch, a hewer employed at the Margaret Pit, said he worked in the east place of No. 6 gateway three months since. He saw water there — sufficient to fill five or six tubs per week, and part of it was carried away with the coals. In witness' judgment, the water came from the bottom — that was, it rose through the floor. Witness could not see any other channels of water that ran into it. — By Mr. Cooper : Had water come from the top and wet witness' coals, he would have got an allowance, but he did not in this case, and never asked for it. Mr. Cooper here said that if it were desired by the jury he would call an independent gentleman to give evidence as to the character of the precautions taken by Mr. Lishman. — Mr. Atherley Jones replied that so far as the evidence had gone they did not wish to throw the slightest imputation upon Mr. Lishman. All they had desired was to get at a true history of the case, and he believed they had attained that. He repeated that there was not the slightest desire on their part to cast any imputation upon Mr. Lishman, and the matter was one upon which the jury would have to exercise their judgment. He did not for one moment suggest that Mr. Lishman had been guilty of any negligence at all. — Mr. Cooper remarked that after such an expression of opinion from Mr. Atherley Jones he would not for one moment think of troubling the jury with any further evidence. — The Coroner, addressing the jury, said there was no need for him to say anything further. If the jury were satisfied that there had been no negligence on the part of anyone at the pit, the case would be one of misadventure, and it would be their duty to return a verdict of accidental death. — The Jury then held a short private consultation, at the close of which the foreman said their unanimous verdict was that George Jarvis and others met their death by noxious gases in the New Maudlin seam of the Margaret Pit, caused by holing of the workings of No. 6 gateway into the old workings of the Elizabeth Pit, such holing being due to the inaccuracy of the old working plan of the said Elizabeth Pit. It the case of Rennison Carter, who appeared to have been accidentally drowned in the pit, a verdict was returned to that effect. Replying to the Coroner, the Foreman said the Jury attached no blame or negligence to anyone. — The inquiry, which had lasted about four and a half hours, then terminated.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||