Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

4th June 1885, Page: 3, Column: 2

Flooding Of A Durham Colliery

Loss Of Fourteen Lives

Considerable excitement was caused yesterday at Fence Houses, Pensher, and the surrounding neighbourhood by the alarming report that the Peggy Pit, which is situated about two miles from both these places, had fired, and that there were about 150 men below ground. The people in the immediate locality of the pit, though no sound was heard indicative of an explosion, were themselves for some little time under the impression that such was the nature of the calamity, and telegrams to that effect were sent broadcast over the country. Further enquiries, however, soon dispelled the illusion, and brought out the fact that the disaster, though a very serious one, was by no means so serious as people were led to suppose from the first wild rumours which were set afloat. In brief, it was found out that only 27 men and boys were in peril, and that the cause of the accident was a rush of gas and water in consequence of men in what is called the new Maudlin seam having "holed" into the old workings of the Elizabeth Pit, Walbottle (Newbottle). When the news of the calamity arrived on the surface it spread, as ill news generally does, quickly, and there was a rush to the pit head by many hundreds of people who had relations or friends down below. Though the extent of the disaster was very speedily found to be much more limited than expected at the time, and though the fears of the majority present were soon relieved by the riding to bank of most of the men below, a considerable number of men remained all day in the neighbourhood of the pit anxious to have first information from men, who ever and anon rode, of what was going on underground. The quiet dignity which is so eminently the characteristic of the Northern miner in danger was very conspicuous. Even when the alarm was at its height there was no sign of undue excitement. Men and women alike kept their feelings well curbed, and stood patiently waiting to learn the worst or best as the case might be. Never is manhood more fully vindicated, and never is the virtue of patience more strongly exemplified than on such occasions as that of yesterday. The bulk of the men were got out of the pit between twelve and one o'clock, and all these were unharmed except two, one a deputy-overman named Rennison Carter, who died shortly after arriving to bank, and the other a lad named Thomas Ainsworth, who was, however, little the worse. There were, however, still 25 of the 150 below at the time of the accident underground, and these were reported to be shut in without much hope of rescue in time to save them. When twelve of these men were reached and brought out between five and six o'clock at night, it was pleasant to see the heavy faces of many an onlooker brighten as they recognised a relative or friend, and the quiet thankfulness with which they were welcomed back from the darkness and danger of the pit to the genial sunshine of the surface. When first information of the accident came above ground Mr. Lishman, who is the head viewer for the Lambton collieries, and who at the time was at Biddick, was telegraphed for, and Mr. Peter Tate, manager of the Peggy Pit, who happened to be in the city of Durham, was also wired. Both gentlemen hastened to the pit as speedily as possible, and immediately took command of the operations for curtailing as far as possible the harmful results of the accident. No effort, either physical or mental, was spared to save the lives of their work, people or the property of their employer, and, indeed, their efforts were beyond praise. Amongst others present were Mr. Morton, Lord Durham's agent; Mr. Stokoe, viewer, Houghton; Mr. Baxter, viewer, Lambton; Mr. Wood, Rainton; Mr. V. W. Corbett, the Marquess of Londonderry's chief mining agent; Mr. Barrett, head viewer of the Seaham collieries ; Mr. Bell, Government Inspector of Collieries ; Mr. W. H. Patterson, miners' agent; the Rev. A. J. Blagdon, Vicar of Newbottle ; the Rev. Mr. Pryor, Roman Catholic priest, Houghton le-Spring; Dr. Park, Dr. Tennant, Dr. Lyons, Dr. Dingwall, Superintendent Fairbridge, and others.

The pit in question is the property of The Earl of Durham, and is named the Margaret, after one of the Lambton family, though it is more frequently termed the Peggy Pit. It is one of the group of collieries which are known by the family name of their noble proprietor, and is situate close to Philadelphia, and about two miles from the railway stations at Fence Houses and Pensher, on the line from Newcastle to Durham, via Leamside. It comprises four seams — viz., the Five-quarter, the Main Coal, the Maudlin, and the Hutton, the last mentioned being about 115 fathoms below ground, and the first about 60. The Main Coal has not been worked of late, but the other seams up to the time of the accident still resounded to the strokes of the hardy miner's pick. In the Hutton Seam the way extends south for nearly a mile to the face of the coal. A half a mile from the shaft there is what is called a ten fathom dyke — viz., a place where the seam has fallen about that distance. One hundred and fifty yards further on there is a twenty-five fathom dyke. There are, of course, corresponding subsidences in the other seams, and the Maudlin Seam is worked in the 35 fathom coal, or that part of it which is that distance below the level of the seams as they branch out from the shaft. This part, though, as we have indicated, only a continuation of the Maudlin at a lower level, is called the New Mauldin, to distinguish it from the other part. It was here where the accident took place, and where the twenty-five men were imprisoned. The two falls in the seam of which we have spoken have placed the New Maudlin some distance below the portion of the Hutton Seam which lies between the shaft and the "trouble." It is therefore approached by way of the Hutton Seam as far as the difficulty, and then by a slanting way cut through the drift of stone at such an angle as to make the outlet in the New Maudlin. Between the New Maudlin and the fallen part of the Hutton Seam below there is communication by means of a staple, and there is similar communication between, the New Maudlin and the Main Coal, and between it and the Five-quarter. These were put in for the purposes of ventilation, but it will be seen by our subsequent remarks that they were of great assistance in other ways with reference to the present disaster. The pit works two shifts a day, and employs altogether, above and below ground, about 440 men and boys.

The accident occurred about eleven o'clock in the morning, just as the shifts were changing, and it is estimated that there were down the pit at the time about 150 men and boys. It occurred in the New Maudlin Seam, just before the men there were relieved by the portion of the descending shift detailed off for work in that portion of the mine. It seems that they were boring, and that through inadvertence or ignorance of their precise locality in reference to neighbouring pits they "holed" through into an old pit at Newbottle, named the Elizabeth Pit, which has not been worked for many years. The result of this unfortunate circumstance was a rush of gas and water, which overwhelmed the men working in that neighbourhood, and caused the death of Rennison Carter, a deputy overman, almost immediately. Of this man various reports are given. One is to the effect that while attending to his duties in the New Maudlin he heard that something was wrong further in bye, but had no idea of the nature of the mishap. He ran forward to ascertain what was the matter, and seeing a man drowning, he attempted to save him, but was himself overcome and rendered insensible by choke damp. Another account is that, having heard all was not right, he went forward to the staple door and opened it, upon which a rush of water and gas compelled him to retreat. As we have stated, when the news of the catastrophe was sent to bank telegrams were sent to Mr. Lishman and Mr. Tate, with the result that they took the most speedy means at their command to arrive at the spot. In the meantime, however, measures were taken to remove from the pit the men who were not imprisoned, and who were not required to participate just at that time in the attempts to rescue those who were in peril. There was not the slightest panic amongst the men, and this was quietly and expeditiously done. In addition to that, very shortly after eleven o'clock two persons were brought out of the Maudlin who were not able to effect a retreat unaided. The first was the lad Thomas Ainsworth, who lives at Sunniside, and who, though suffering from gas, was not long in recovering, and is now all right. Rennison Carter, the unfortunate deputy-overman, was the other one. He was quite insensible, and on being conveyed to bank was taken towards Sunniside, where he lives. He was not taken into the house, as the medical gentlemen considered that the fresh air would aid their exertions towards his recovery. All that medical knowledge could suggest was done to save him, but the deadly choke-damp had already got so strong a hold upon him that neither fresh air nor medical treatment could do him any good, and he died within a brief period of his being brought to bank, in the midst of a large number of his mining comrades. There were still 25 men in the New Maudlin, with whom then and for some time afterwards no communication could be effected. At half-past one o'clock Mr. Tate descended in company with Mr. Smailes, overman, and the under-viewer, Mr. Hope, and others, and subsequently Mr. Lishman went down. They made as full an examination of the locality as the circumstances would admit of, but were unable at that time to devise measures which would enable them to get view of the imprisoned men. The way in the New Maudlin seam, it appears, descends for a portion of its distance and then rises, and it was in the ascending portion that the 25 men were employed, and thirteen of that number were on a part still higher than their comrades. As soon as the water rushed in upon them it descended the rising ground and settled in the "dip," or low lying portion, in sufficient quantity to close the passage. The complete flooding of the seam was prevented by the fact that the water escaped down the staple mentioned into the Hutton Seam, but fortunately the men there engaged escaped before there was a sufficient accumulation of water to place them in much jeopardy. Though exertions to get near the men were in nowise relaxed, it was greatly feared that all must have been killed by the gas, if not by the water ; but, as the sequel showed, nearly half of them were alive, though suffering from the effects of gas. After the quantity of gas had been decreased they were reached by means of a kibble and winch down the staple from the Main Coal to the New Maudlin. In order to get to the staple they had to be brought through water knee deep, and on being raised to the Main Coal measures had to be taken to revive them. At last they were sent to bank, and what with the fresh air and medical remedies they soon recovered a certain measure of good spirits, and are now doing well. They were brought up between five end six o'clock, and were warmly, if quietly, welcomed by relatives and friends. Their names will be found below under the head of rescued. The first to reach the open air was Middlemiss. The two men Daglish followed, and the others in quick succession. When the list had been completed many an anxious eye was turned to the shaft to see if any more would follow, but hopes raised by the, at the time, unexpected recovery of the dozen were doomed to disappointment, as the other thirteen men are in such a position that they could not be reached, and their whereabouts could only be guessed at. After this it was found impossible to do much until the water had subsided. At seven o'clock the water was reported to have "eased" considerably, and there was a chance of the influx continuing to decrease. As nothing could be done at that time towards the recovery of the men who, from their situation, were shut in by the water there was a cessation of work until the water had sufficiently run off to allow the explorers to proceed further in and look for their imprisoned comrades, who are almost certainly dead, though there were some sanguine enough to entertain what was something like a forlorn hope. The shift that had been working during the afternoon returned to bank about nine o'clock, but were not able to report much progress. They had, however, seen that it was quite impossible for the imprisoned miners to get out by any other way than the Maudlin Seam, and that they were prevented from doing by the water. The main intake airway was also drowned, so that there was no chance of escape that way, the men being presumed to be at the sixth and seventh gateways, which are turned out of a new cross gate-way, that has been recently put through the hitch. The explorers had been enabled to reach the beginning of the new cross gate-way, but, finding the ventilation defective and the gas coming away strongly, they were compelled to retreat. Before they came to bank it had become evident to them that the water had abated, though very slightly. Shortly after nine o'clock arrangements were made for the descent of a fresh shift of men into the mine to continue the exploring. The shift consisted of twenty-nine men, twelve of whom were selected to work at the face, the others being directed to look after the "gin" by means of which the explorers were lowered into or brought out of the New Maudlin Seam by the 35 fathom staple. The men were under the superintendence of Mr. Tate, manager, and of Mr. Laidler, the master-shifter. It was their intention to proceed down the staple, and, by going through the regulator, try to work into the New Maudlin, where the men are entombed. Their first care was to be to see that the ventilation was complete, and for this purpose the explorers took bratticing with them, in order to direct the current of air into the proper course. As for the water, it was impossible to say whether or not any immediate attempt would be made to prevent the inflow. Everything depended upon the strength of current and depth of water. With this understanding, the shift descended at twenty minutes to ten o'clock. The shift was to remain in the main until six o'clock this morning, when the men were to be relieved by a shift under the charge of Mr. Stokoe, the manager of Houghton Colliery.

A meeting of miners was held last night at the Lambton Castle Inn, Philadelphia. Mr. Miller, check weighman, presided. There was a large attendance. It was resolved to appoint four local inspectors to explore and examine the mine on behalf of the men; one inspector to take charge of each shift. It was further resolved to ask Mr. Lishman to stop the pit on the following day.

Up to eleven this morning the work of endeavouring to reach the thirteen men entombed in the Margaret Pit, Philadelphia, had proceeded satisfactorily, but slowly. The volume of water has now decreased one-half, and the explorers expect to reach the men within twenty-four hours. Experienced miners say that if anyone is found alive it will be little short of a miracle. A lot of fallen coal has been encountered, and the work of exploration is one of great difficulty.

The following list includes the one man killed and those entombed, and those rescued :—

Rennison Carter, deputy-overman, married.
List of the entombed men.
Joseph Adamson, hewer, married; one child.
John Bailes, hewer, married ; two children.
John Callaghan, hewer, married ; two children.
Joseph Carr, hewer, married.
William Davison, hewer, married; one child.
George Lowary, hewer, married ; three children.
James Gray, hewer, married ; five children.
Thos. Sanderson (or Jackson), hewer, married ; three children.
Joseph Robson, hewer, married ; two children.
George Kirtley, driver.
Joseph Laidler, shifter, single.
John Howse, back-overman, married ; no children.
List of the rescued.
Thomas Ainsworth, putter.
John Middlemiss, putter.
John Daglish, hewer.
Thomas Daglish, hewer.
Edward Wheeler, hewer.
John Wheeler, hewer.
George McLaren, hewer.
Henry McLaren, hewer.
Joseph Lewis, hewer.
John Wilkinson, hewer.
John Allison, hewer.
John Williamson Henderson, putter.
Joseph Pattison, hewer.

John Daglish, a hewer, says: The accident occurred about ten o'clock. I was at the third gateway, and the accident occurred at the fifth or sixth gateway. My lamp was blown out owing to the stithe or gas. I and my brother (Thomas Daglish), along with Wilkinson, Lewis, the two Wheelers, the two McLarens, Middlemas, Henderson, Allison, and Brown, made our way down the bank to the edge of the water — a distance of about 100 yards. I persevered into the return way in the old workings, where I was checked by the water. We then went to the staple, where the water again checked us. The water was then about two feet deep and eight feet wide. At the staple we broached a stopping. There was plenty of wind, but the water "bested" us again. The water came up about 4ft. high. We then came back to No. 2 gateway ends, where we remained for five hours. I went round the workings as far as No. 5 gateway, but had to retreat owing to the water. I and my "marra," McLaren, afterwards went about 200 yards, and managed to get the clothes of the men, as up to the time they were almost entirely naked. Every now and then I went so far along the road to see if the water was slackening any ; but there was no sign of it. At last we heard a knocking, and we gave a shout. We saw through the stopping a strange man with a light. We asked who he was, and he said his name was Paget. We knew that he was a stranger, and then, also, that our deliverance was at hand. Soon afterwards we were able to get out. We left the other men in "the hitch."

Thomas Ainsworth, about 16 years of age, says: While in the pit this morning I heard a rush like that of water, and went to see what it was. I met the deputy-overman (Rennison Carter) and another man. They turned back with me, and they fell down. I tried to help Carter, but I became exhausted.

Robert Evans, Raglan-street, Philadelphia, who was drawn from the pit about one o'clock, says: I am a hewer, and work in the New Maudlin Seam of the Peggy Pit. Where the explosion has occurred is in the New Maudlin Seam. I went down the pit this morning, at ten o'clock, being one of the back shift men, and on getting to the bottom proceeded to my work. I had not been at work more than an hour when a putter lad came running in bye, calling of the men to make haste to the bottom of the shaft, as the New Maudlin Seam had fired. All the men in my seam at once made for out bye. On reaching the bottom of the shaft we were all drawn safely to bank by way of the old Maudlin shaft. The Hutton Seam men were also got out by the same means. Some of my marrows said that they felt after-damp in coming out, but I felt nothing unusual in the air neither when I was at work nor when I was travelling out. The Peggy Pit has always been known as a very safe pit, and well looked after. In the New Maudlin the number of men and boys will be about 60. I think there will be no fear but all of them will be got out alive. The New Maudlin shaft is not blocked up in any way that I know of.

Another man who was with Evans agrees with the above narrative in every particular, excepting that he says he felt the effects of stithe before he left the workings.

John Wheeler, hewer, who was at work in the Maudlin Seam, says: Between eleven and twelve o'clock I heard a rush of water, and then a sound of concussion. A "space" (a vacuum) was caused, and in order to reach a place of safety we rushed along the seam, and opening a stopping, got into some old workings, where we remained until we were rescued. Had we not succeeded in removing that old stopping we should have been beyond all reach of rescue. The water, so far as we could see, was about five feet deep, and coming along with tremendous power. The lights were extinguished by the concussion, and we remained in darkness for six hours.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Adamson, Joseph    Hewer  Deceased, Individual Page
Ainsworth, Thomas   16 Putter  Rescued
Allison, John    Hewer  Rescued
Bailes, John   31 Hewer  Deceased, Individual Page
Barrett, Charles Rollo    Viewer  Whos Who Page
Baxter, John    Viewer  Whos Who Page
Bell, Thomas    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Blagdon, A. J., Rev.    Vicar  
Calligan, John   28 Hewer  Deceased, Individual Page
Carr, Joseph   25 Hewer  Deceased, Individual Page
Carter, Rennison   35 Deputy Overman  Deceased, Individual Page
Corbett, Vincent Charles Stuart Wortley    Mine Agent  Whos Who Page
Daglish, John    Hewer  Rescued
Daglish, Thomas    Hewer  Rescued
Davison, William   22 Hewer  Deceased, Individual Page
Dingwall, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Durham, Earl of    Mine Owner  Whos Who Page
Fairbridge, —    Police Superintendent  
Gray, James Wilson   37 Hewer  Deceased, Individual Page
Henderson, John Williamson    Putter  Rescued
Hope, —    Under Viewer  
House, John George   46 Back Overman  Deceased, Individual Page
Jarvis, George    Driver  Deceased, Individual Page
Laidler, —    Master Shifter  
Laidler, Joseph   19 Shifter  Deceased, Individual Page
Lewis, Joseph    Hewer  Rescued
Lishman, William    Viewer  Whos Who Page
Londonderry, Marquess of    Mine Owner  
Lowrey, George    Hewer  Deceased, Individual Page
Lyons, —, Dr.    Doctor  
McLaren, George    Hewer  Rescued
McLaren, Henry    Hewer  Rescued
Middlemiss, John    Putter  Rescued
Miller, —    Check Weighman  
Morton, —    Mine Agent  
Paget, —      
Park, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Patterson, William Hammond    Miners' Agent  Whos Who Page
Pattison, Joseph    Hewer  Rescued
Pryor, —, Rev.    Priest  
Robson, Joseph    Hewer  Deceased, Individual Page
Sanderson, Thomas Jackson   32 Hewer  Deceased, Individual Page
Smailes, —    Overman  
Stokoe, Joseph    Viewer  Whos Who Page
Tate, Peter    Colliery Manager  Whos Who Page
Tennant, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Wheeler, Edward    Hewer  Rescued
Wheeler, John    Hewer  Rescued
Wilkinson, John    Hewer  Rescued
Wood, —      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Margaret Pit  Margaret Pit



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
04 Jun 1885  Colliery Accident (The Times)
04 Jun 1885  Flooding Of A Durham Colliery, Loss Of Fourteen Lives (The Middlesbrough Daily Gazette)
05 Jun 1885  The Colliery Disaster Near Penshaw, Twelve Men Entombed (Sunderland Daily Echo)
06 Jun 1885  The Colliery Accident in Durham (The Times)
08 Jun 1885  The Colliery Disaster In Durham, All The Bodies Recovered (The Middlesbrough Daily Gazette)
08 Jun 1885  The Colliery Accident At Bunker Hill, All The Bodies Recovered, A Singular Custom. — A Sad Case (Sunderland Daily Echo)
09 Jun 1885  The Margaret Pit Accident, Coroner's Inquiry (Sunderland Daily Echo)
10 Jun 1885  The Disaster at Philadelphia, Appeal for Aid (Sunderland Daily Echo)
12 Jun 1885  The Accident At The Margaret Pit, Official Inspection (Sunderland Daily Echo)
17 Jun 1885  The Accident At The Margaret Pit (Sunderland Daily Echo)
24 Jun 1885  The Accident At The Margaret Pit, Inquest This Day (Sunderland Daily Echo)
25 Jun 1885  The Accident At The Margaret Pit, The Inquest (Sunderland Daily Echo)
04 Aug 1885  The Disaster At The Margaret Pit, Official Report (Sunderland Daily Echo)
05 Jun 1886  The Colliery Accident In Durham (The Times)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Margaret Pit, Newbottle
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page
Report Page  Text of the official report into the incident

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 19 Jan 2023

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print