Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mine & Quarry Engineering - Main Index
Mine & Quarry Engineering - Subject Index
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Title Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Title
 
 Mine & Quarry Engineering March, 1955 

These experiences prove that anchoring is obtained by both friction and deformation of the rock. In a very hard rock the anchoring device is not able to deform the rock, a very small contacting surface being obtained in this case. When put under load the steel starts flowing at these places and the anchor yields. From this point of view expansion bolts are more advantageous than the slit and wedge type, as the anchoring body of the former is more effective and can be made from especially hard steel. On the contrary in a somewhat softer rock the anchoring parts penetrate a little into the rock, and the surface of contact increases, both resulting in a better anchoring effect. Expansion bolts have, a toothed anchoring body which serves this purpose perfectly. However, with slit and wedge bolts it might be possible to obtain a better anchoring by reforging the end of the bolt from a circular form to an elliptic one with approximately the same radius as the hole, thus increasing the anchoring surface.

In order to classify the rock with respect to its ability to accept anchoring, its hardness has been determined by a special apparatus. A small steel ball is shot by a spring with constant force against the rock, and the impact leaves a small cavity, the diameter of which can be measured. Repeated tests with the same kind of rock varied only within the limits shown in the graph reproduced in Fig. 6. The diameter, measured in mm., gives an inverse indication of the hardness of the rock. A remarkably accurate classification of the rock with respect to its capacity for anchoring can be obtained in this way, which should be completed by exact petrological descriptions. According to the tensile tests the limits of anchoring in soft rock for expansion bolts was found to be "softness 4." This corresponds petrologically to a shale without sand. For common slit and wedge bolts the limit is somewhat lower. The graph shown as Fig. 6 is not complete over the range of very hard rock.

The yield is, of course, a very important matter in the technique of anchoring. Yield means space for loosening and loosening means increase of load.

Many conclusions may be drawn from these graphs. A bolt of a certain diameter and steel quality should only be given such stress when tightening the nut that there is still a reasonable safety margin before yielding starts. On the other hand, this initial stress, which can be measured with sufficient exactness, should be big enough to exclude yielding caused by the expansion device.

It seems possible to develop this method to the extent of determining what may be termed "bolting data" — this being based on numerous tests and exact petrological descriptions — for any given rock, i.e. the necessary primary stress to be given and the limit of load, the latter being represented by the characteristic point at which the yield curve starts to bend over. In this way characteristic bolting curves can be drawn for the different kinds of rock, a conception of which is given in Fig. 7. In a sound medium hard rock the critical "yield point" as it may be called (y in Fig. 7) is given by the tensile strength of the steel, while the initial stress p is appropriately lower. The necessary number of bolts will have to be based on p. The greatest economy is obtained in this case as the steel is fully utilised. The softer the rock the further y moves down, the steel becomes stressed only to a fraction of its tensile strength, and anchoring becomes the centre of the problem, which also prevails in very hard rock. In these cases economy points to expansion bolts with smaller diameter and high anchoring effect or to changing the material altogether and using reinforced concrete instead of steel, which offers all the features required if anchoring becomes difficult.

Reinforced-concrete anchors have been tried with excellent results in the coal mines of Hausham (Bavaria)12 as well as in the Ruhrgebiet11 in order to prevent floor lift in roadways. In Hausham there was a bituminous marl which gave rise to floor lift and in the Ruhrgebiet there was a seat earth with traces of shales.

The tests made by Dr. Langecker in Hausham were first made with normal cement but this did not give satisfactory results as 60 to 70 hours hardening time was needed to cement the steel sufficiently fast in the holes. This was considered too long with respect to the speed of the squeeze, which started only a few metres behind the face. Straight bars proved to be inferior to bent ones. The best results were obtained by anchors as shown in Fig. 8 using quick-setting cement. Tensile tests made with this kind of anchor showed that the steel of the quality 37 — 11 breaks at the upper end under loads of 6 to 8 tons for 14 min. diameter, and 10 to 14 tons for 19 mm. diameter after 24 hours, In the floor of the roadways in question only single anchors, 1 m. long, were placed on the centreline at distances of 1.50 m. Practically no upward movement could be detected in the anchored portions.

Encouraged by these favourable experiences the engineers of the Ruhr took over the method and concrete-anchored a 180 m. long gallery, the bottom of which was 2.4 m. wide. In this case rows of four anchors, each 1.50 m. long, were placed 0.9 m. apart. in all, 800 anchors were set for 180 m. length. The result of this method was surprisingly good, as in the anchored portion upward movements of up to 10 cm. only were measured, whereas the unanchored portion was squeezed up by 1.40 m. The concrete mixture used in this case consisted of 2 parts Portland cement, I part silicate potassium and 8 parts sand and fine aggregate (by volume). Setting was observed after two hours and sufficient hardening took place after 24 hours, it was found important to follow the advance as closely as possible with anchoring and to concrete the dry-drilled holes immediately in order to prevent closing by squeezing.

While prestressing is of fundamental importance for all-metal anchor bolts in order to avoid loosening of the rock, this is not possible or necessary for reinforced-concrete anchors. The latter need neither a plate nor a thread, the rock being held together by adhesion and friction between concrete and rock. No loosening can happen after the concrete has hardened unless the anchor is destroyed.

The results obtained with reinforced-concrete anchors invite the conclusion that concrete anchoring is the best and most economic method of support for squeezing rock. Up to now tunnelling through this kind of rock has involved technical difficulties as well as high cost. In such cases it is usually possible to excavate a round without any support, the squeezing starting after a couple of hours in bad cases, and in better ones after some days. The enormous forces developed when the rock expands into the open space are usually counteracted by strong steel arches or rings spaced at short distances with a tight lagging behind. In spite of these expensive measures the results are often negative because the idea of this method of support for squeezing rock is fundamentally wrong. The surprisingly good results of concrete anchoring, up to now unequalled by any other method, indicate it, on the contrary, to be the right system. The effect of the anchors can be explained by the formation of multiple arches between the anchors, the latter being held in place by those portions of rock at a greater distance from the cavity, which are not, or only slightly, affected by the movement (see Fig. 10). The necessary length of the anchors and their centre distances will have to be determined empirically for each case in the light of circumstances.

To complete the anchor form of support in squeezing rock a net should be attached to the protruding ends of the bars. This is necessary for the safety of the crew as well as to prevent the loosening movement from progressing towards the interior of the rock.

The tensile stress of a steel bolt can always be controlled by a so-called "torque meter" — an instrument which provides a reading of the torsional moment. In this way the initial stress can be ascertained as well as changes in load caused by the anchor yielding or the rock loosening, but the method supposes that the thread is not rusted or clogged. A rusted thread can show the same torsional moment as an oiled thread stressed only to one-third of the latter11. Thus suitable results can only be obtained by a torque meter if the threads are clean and oiled.

In order to be independent of this condition a kind of spring washer is now being tried in the Ruhr. With this washer inserted between the plate and the bolt the tension of the bolt can be easily found from the compression of the washer, which corresponds to the force exerted, the system acting virtually as a spring balance. In order to give a bolt the desired primary tension a distance ring can be inserted, tightening of the nut being stopped as soon as the distance ring touches the plate (Fig. 9).

Control measurements of bolted areas have been carried out several times in certain mines in the United States, and have shown astonishingly small variations — only plus or minus 10 per cent. — with respect to the initially installed values.2 In really bad rock higher variations must be expected.

Although it is relatively easy to determine the forces in a steel bolt it is impossible to measure forces with a concrete anchor, as in this case the forces act not at a point, but along the whole surface of the anchor.

(To be continued)

References

1. Beyl, Z. S. "Rock Pressure and Roof Support." Colliery Engineering, September 1945 to October 1946.
2. Boman, I. E. "Tillampningar i U.S.A. av Bergfastning 'med bult'," Tryckluft, No. 3, 1952.
3. Editorial article "Diversion Tunnel Driving Without Liners — Keyhole Dam Wyo." Engineering News Record, May 17, 1951.
4. Grundy, C. F. "Notable Water Tunnel." Water Power, January 1953.
5. Perez, Henry T. "Tunnelling Costs Drop down when Bolts hold up Tunnel Roof." Construction Methods and Equipment, March 1952.
6. Pierce, J. C. "Pinning up an Aqueduct Roof." Compressed Air Magazine, May 1953.
7. Rabcewicz, Lv. "The Fortacava Hydro-Electric Scheme." Water Power, September, October, November 1953.
8. Slager, Ted. "Underground Mushroom Farm." Compressed Air Magazine, May 1951.
9. Terzaghi, K.v. "Geological Introduction to Tunnelling with Steel Supports," by Proctor & White, The Commercial Shearing Stamping Company, Youngstown, Ohio. 1946.
10. Huber, W. G. "Complex Excavation Pattern cuts out Underground Power House." Civil Engineering, June 1953.
11. Mildendorf H. and Janssen K. "Erfahrungen mit dem Ankerausbau." Gluckauf H. 33/34 1953.
12. Langecker F. "Versuche zur Verankerung der Gebirgsschichten im Liegenden" Gluckauf H. 45/46 1952.
13. Bengt Erdheim och Sten C.A. Bergman "Dragforsok med Bergbultar" Rapport av Kungl. Fortifikationsforvaltningen Befastningsbyran Forsknings- och Forsokssektionen.
14. Tests made by Kungl. Jarnvagsstyrelsen bantekniska byran (Dir. B. Fellenius.)

Drawings and Photographs accompanying the article

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

Article reproduced from a copy of the magazine held at National Mining Museum Scotland, Newtongrange, Midlothian.

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 17 Jan 2023

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print