|
April, 1955 Bolted Support For TunnelsBy Professor Dr Techn. L. v. RABCEWICZ, StockholmRound mild-steel is the best material for rock bolts. The quality mostly used for this purpose in the States has 0.20 per cent. carbon content, a yield point of 2,400 kg. per sq. cm. and a tensile strength of 4,000 kg. per sq. cm. In Germany, quality 37 steel is that used mostly. "Tor-steel," the elastic limit of which is increased considerably by cold working, is certainly superior for this purpose to steel 37 having regard to both economy and safety. The diameter of slit and wedge bolts should not be smaller than 20 mm. for short bolts, and 25 mm. for bolts longer than 1,500 mm. Bolts that are too thin cannot be driven properly and moreover are too much weakened by the slit. At the outer end the bolts are threaded for a length of 150 to 200 mm. Many different types for each of the anchoring systems shown in Fig. 4 (p. 113 of our March issue) have been developed, but in spite of its smaller anchoring effect the slit-and-wedge anchor is much more used in American mines due to its simple construction and low price. This is not so in Germany and Austria, where the expansion anchor is that most preferred, owing to the fact that rock conditions are generally much worse there than in the States. A further advantage of expansion bolts is that the holes need not be drilled to an exact length, and that steel of smaller diameter and higher quality can be used. In Fig. 4 were shown different types of slit-and-wedge anchors, the most suitable form of which needs to be determined for each case separately.2 The slit is preferably made by gas cutting as the rough surface gives a better hold for the wedge. The bolt transfers its tension to the rock by means of a plate or washer having dimensions of about 200 x 200 x 10 mm. Different types of plates have also been developed, such as square and triangular with flat or joggled surfaces. The latter should provide a better grip on the rock. It very often happens that the rock surface is not perpendicular to the axis of the bolt, and in such cases either hardwood wedges or special angle washers, usually made of cut angle section, are used to obtain better contact between plate and rock. Different inclinations of the plate can be obtained by taking angles of uneven legs. In Germany a plate is used for this purpose, the middle part of which is joggled to a hemisphere with a slit instead of a round hole. This kind of plate gives close contact to the rock up to an angle of 45 deg. In relatively bad rock it is expedient to connect the bolts with each other in order to distribute the load and to prevent relative movement, as well as to support the rock between the bolts. For this purpose steel channels of 120-150 mm. are most suitable. Also ties have been used in some cases. Experience has shown that as a rule it is easier to place them parallel to the tunnel axis as the surface of the tunnel is more even in this direction and practically the same static effect is obtained. Moreover, costly curving of the channels is avoided with longitudinal placing. In most cases the fixing of the channels is simplified by following the traces of the border shotholes. The bolts, provided with wedge, plate and nut, are driven home by stoper machines fitted with a capped headpiece to protect the thread of the bolt. The holes in the channel bars are drilled beforehand. The drilling of holes in the rock, and the application of the bolts and channels proceeds gradually from a suitable point. On tightening the nuts the channels are bent, thus fitting roughly to the configuration of the rock. In the Ruhr steel cables are preferred to the stiffer channels, special washers being inserted to carry them. Cables obviously follow the rock face more smoothly and are easier to fasten, as the bolts are not bound to fixed distances by holes drilled beforehand in the channels; also the lagging can more easily be placed over the cables than over channels. On the other hand, the rigidity of the channels gives rise to a considerably better load distribution. If netting is required, wire meshwork — such as is commonly used for stone mattresses in river constructions — can be recommended. The net, which provides immediate protection for the workers, is best fixed temporarily by a number of short bolts, and not until this has been done should the drilling of the long holes be started (see Figs. 11 and 15)7. In this way the net is gripped between the channels and the rock. The nuts are usually tightened by means of a pneumatically-driven wrench, as are manufactured by, and available from, a number of compressed air firms. Such a wrench is an indispensable tool for the roof-bolting technique, for the nuts are tightened very strongly within a few seconds. The wrench can be adjusted to exert a predetermined torsional moment corresponding to the desired initial bolt tension and functions precisely provided that the thread is oiled. The experience gathered with concrete anchors in soft rock is still insufficient for much more to be said about it. It seems anyhow that steel of smaller diameter can be used for reinforcement than is required for normal steel bolts. The diameter of the hole on the contrary should be greater, probably not less than 40 mm., in order to get a greater surface. Holes in the floor are first filled with mortar, then the bar is thrust in and the hole closed by a prefabricated concrete plug pressed into place. For horizontal and rising holes this system would not do; an easy method would be to insert in the hole a corrugated steel bar with a small deaeration pipe attached to it, to fix at the entrance, which must be drilled sufficiently large, a short grout pipe and to grout the hole with a quick-hardening mortar (see Fig. 18). Alternatively, use may be made of one of the recently developed methods in which the hole is first filled with plastic mortar after which the bar is inserted, as described later. Dry drilling has in any case proved to be considerably superior to wet drilling but especially in softer rock. Historical development and recent experience The first attempts to replace old-fashioned timber supports by roof bolts can be traced back 40 years in European and American mines, but systematic research work on a larger scale was not started until 1948 by the U.S. Bureau of Mines, In a few years bolting has become so indispensable an element in the mining practice in the States that today several millions of bolts are placed monthly. The very deserving experiments with roof bolting of Mr. Z. S. Beyl, a Dutch engineer, carried out during the last war, must also be mentioned here.1 His first trials go back to the year 1912. Mr. Beyl tried later to introduce the system into the English mines, but up to now it has not become as common in Europe as in America, undoubtedly partly due to an extremely cautious attitude on the part of the supervising authorities. Tunnelling engineers were much more reluctant to adopt the method. In 1950 roof bolting was used for the 200 m. long Keyhole diversion tunnel in Wyoming and for a small part — only 60 m. — of the 9 km. long Duchesne tunnel in Utah.3 Later roof bolting was employed on a much larger scale by the New York City Board of Water Supply for its East Delaware tunnel during the years 1950-1952. This 60 km. long tunnel is still under construction. With the first two projects mentioned plates only were used, whereas for the New York water tunnel channels and ties were employed. The flat-bedded shales and sandstones in thin laminations of this tunnel were roof bolted for a length of 20 km., 124,000 bolts having been used (see Figs. 12 and 13)5,6 The most recent example of roof bolting in tunnels is that of the underground work at Kemano, British Columbia.10 In Europe there is a tendency to adopt this method in Sweden, but in most cases the object has not been to consolidate the roof by creating a natural arch capable of bearing, but merely to protect the workers against minor falls of rock, sufficient security being obtained simply by fixing a net to the roof with anchor bolts. Roof bolting was also used in the Bowland water-supply tunnel in England.4 In Sweden much research work has been accomplished resulting in a great increase in knowledge. Nevertheless, in the opinion of the author, the technique of roof bolting is still in its infancy, particularly with regard to tunnelling. The author had the opportunity to make some tests with roof bolting in decomposed gneiss, with various degrees of chemical alteration, at the excavation of the Forcacava underground power plant in Brazil.7 Based on accumulated experiences the method was used for the 420 m. long 42 deg. inclined pressure shaft (sectional area 44 sq. in.) and the 24 m. wide excavated roof of the power house (see Figs. 14 and 15). For the worst part of the pressure shaft, where a large fault zone was crossed by a second joint system, 3 m. long anchor bolts 1 in. in diameter were used, connected by 6 m. long 120 mm. channels and completed with a wire net. The ground was successfully strengthened and secured in this simple and cheap way, but to have supported it by steel arches would not only have been very difficult and dangerous, having regard to the inclination of the tunnel, but also have meant a considerable loss of time and money. Roof bolting in this case was carried out in the following manner. After blasting the round and roughly scaling the section, a heavy steel jumbo was brought forward and the most dangerous portions of the rock were supported by jacks and braced against the jumbo framework. The net was then fixed by a few short bolts, immediately followed by the drilling and the placing of the long bolts and channels. In this case the method was specially advantageous because it did not reduce the cross-sectional area, which made the erection of the heavy steel lining and concreting much easier. A section of the roof of the power house was also roof bolted but unfortunately not until many weeks after excavation, and the nuts were only tightened by hand. When blasting close to the bolted area the layer supported by the bolts disintegrated. The drilling of the holes had obviously initiated very fine cracks in the strata which were at first invisible but caused later disintegration when vibrations were set up by blasting. However, in this instance, the bolting was applied too late and too incorrectly to be effective (see Fig. 16). An exemplary result of support by bolting was obtained with the start of the large discharge tunnels of the hydro electric power plant at Asswan — area 150 sq. m. (tunnel contractor Svenska Entreprenad AB SENTAB, Stockholm). Tunnel 1 had to be started in a closely jointed granite with water-bearing slickensides, unfavourably dipping 40 deg. towards the open cut with a strike about 30 deg. to the axis. The entrance of tunnel 2 had to be made close to the crossing of two more or less vertical faults. The rock cover at this point was only 3 m. at the portal and some metres further in even less. The rock — a fine grained diabase — was heavily jointed in two vertical and one horizontal directions and, moreover, intersected in short distances by clay-filled shear zones. On the author's advice the rock was bolted before blasting the first rounds in the way shown in Figs. 19 and 20. Bolts 3 to 4 m. long were used, connected radially by flat-iron 120/8 mm., the latter anchored at the face and at the top. A net was applied over the whole surface. Open spaces between flat-iron and rock were wedged. After blasting a couple of rounds some grouting was applied to fill open joints thus eliminating the danger of movement. The upper part of the tunnels was started by a top gallery of 16 sq. m. to be enlarged later to both sides and at the bottom to 70 sq. m. The tunnels were then continuously roof bolted and netted inside, using 2 m. long slit and wedge bolts of 1 in. No movement occurred either when blasting the first round or later when widening and deepening the section. Today roof bolting is in process of official acceptance by tunnelling engineers not only in the United States but also in other countries, and has been adopted in the specifications of important tunnelling operations such as Australia's Snowy Mountains hydro-electric scheme and for the water-supply tunnels for Athens. Drawings and Photographs accompanying the article
Article reproduced from a copy of the magazine held at National Mining Museum Scotland, Newtongrange, Midlothian.
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 17 Jan 2023
|
Search |
|
|||