|
March, 1955 Bolted Support for TunnelsProfessor Dr. Techn. L. v. Rabcewicz, Stockholm, describes the technique of roof bolting and recounts its advantages, particularly when driving through unstable rock.Since the last world war American tunnelling methods have come increasingly into use in Europe and other parts of the world. As is well known, these methods aim at excavating the whole tunnel section in a single operation in order to obtain space for the complete mechanisation of the different operations. Where unstable rock is encountered, fullface advance is made possible by supporting the roof and walls of the tunnel with steel arches, which are later embedded in the concrete lining. It is surprising how these methods have been introduced in such a short time in a profession so conservative as tunnelling. The reasons for this are the constant rise in wages as well as the endeavour to reduce the time of construction; and an important factor that has largely, although indirectly, contributed to the development of these methods abroad has been the financial aid granted by the United States to war-ravaged countries. American engineers controlled nearly all the big construction projects of this kind in the countries concerned, and were largely responsible for their design, especially in such countries where there was a lack of engineering staff. A large number of big hydro-electric projects are now being built outside the United States under American management, and this has consequently led to the introduction of American tunnelling methods and to the specification of their use by contractors. The way in which methods and equipment for tunnelling have developed in the last years is revolutionary, due not only to the reasons already given but also to systematic and costly research work carried out not only in the United States but also in Europe, mainly in Sweden. Although the purpose of this article is not to deal with this development but to consider a modern method of tunnel support in unstable rock, it will not be out of place to offer a brief criticism of the steelarch method of support. If we compare the economies of steel-arch supports with the older European tunnelling methods we reach some interesting conclusions. The cost of driving a tunnel through unstable rock is governed principally by the outlay on wages, explosives, steel, wood and cement. A short calculation shows that the steelarch method is certainly economic in the United States where relatively high wages and low costs of material promote such a method, but in countries where the relation between wages and material costs is reversed this method does not prove to be economic. For such cases the modernised European tunnelling methods, which divide the cross section into a sequence of faces, are more advantageous, and they are also faster, especially in long tunnels in really bad rock. But if the rock does not need any temporary support, full-face driving is no doubt the most economical and far superior to the old European methods, even in countries with low wages and high material costs. Recently, however, tunnel engineers have started to introduce a method of support for tunnelling in unstable rock known as "roof bolting" — a method which has been used for many years in mines in the United States. The use of roof bolting there is rapidly increasing. Since the first systematic tests were commenced in one mine in 1947, no less than 50 mines employed bolting by the beginning of 1949; by the end of the same year the number had risen to 150, and in 1951 500 mines had taken over the system, 450 out of which were coal mines. During the year 1951, 75 million tons of coal were mined under bolted roofs.2 Roof bolting follows the simple and ingenious principle of fastening the loose rock near the surface to the solid rock above by means of anchor bolts instead of supporting it from below. This technique not only supports the surface rock but assists it to act as a load-carrying element. The results obtained to date with roof bolting have been so satisfactory, and its technical advantages are so obvious, that in the writer's opinion the method will before long largely replace the use of steel arch supports as well as the older European tunnelling method, as the latter two methods can be considered to be economical only where geological conditions call for forepoling. Theoretical principles of roof bolting Immediately after a tunnel has been driven for the length of one round t (see Fig. 1) the rock in this section expands and settles slightly, developing a double arch effect. In the longitudinal direction of the tunnel the arch rests on the still untouched rock at the front and on the already consolidated portion (see arrows in Fig. 1). The second arch effect, perpendicular to the axis of the tunnel, is given by the form of the roof, which is usually an arch in tunnels. How long this combined arch will stand without support depends on the geological conditions, the length of the round t and of the radius of the tunnel roof, but in most cases, even in badly disintegrated rock, it will be possible to maintain this natural arch for a practicable span t for at least a couple of hours. If necessary, specially dangerous places can be temporarily supported from the drill jumbo. This means that the rock must stand until the blast fumes are removed and the mucking is accomplished. The limits of the method, as regarded from the stability of the surrounding rock, are consequently very close to a geological condition which requires forepoling. If the natural arch is not supported immediately after the mucking, it will continue to sink down slowly until it disintegrates, In the meantime the top of this vault is already behaving as a bridge by forming the next arch. The process will continue until the radius is small enough to reach equilibrium. The portion that is liable to fall is generally parabolic in cross section, having a depth t/2 though the loosening process will never go as deep as this if the movement is stopped by quick support. Nevertheless it will be expedient to make the bolts no shorter than t, i.e., twice the depth of the presumed maximum loosening. The natural surrounding rock of the cavity is in this way transformed into a protective arch the thickness of which is given by the length of the bolts, l > t, where l > b/3 to b/4 as the arch also must have a certain relation to the width of the tunnel. This protective arch will function as long as it remains intact; consequently, also, the rock surface between the bolts must not be allowed to loosen, and this can easily be prevented by means of wire netting or by a layer of gunite. The arch-shaped cross section of a tunnel is of course much more favourable for roof bolting than the flat roof which usually results from the mining of bedded deposits, in which case the bolts have to withstand shear stresses like stirrups in a reinforced concrete beam, and it would be expedient to ensure that the bolts of a beam fitted tightly in the holes, leaving no gap. Unfortunately, this is impossible as the holes are seldom perfectly round and there must moreover, be some space left to insert the somewhat larger portion with the wedge. Consequently the shear forces have to be absorbed by the friction between the rock layers, a condition that can be obtained to a considerable extent by clamping them together by bolts. In addition to the friction a slight unevenness of the surface of the layers, which can always be relied upon, will very much increase the resistance against movements between the surfaces, having the effect of dowels. The rock receives a prestress by bolting and the bolts have consequently to follow the static principles of prestressing in reinforced concrete as much as possible. As it is not possible to place the bolts in the way of stress bars at the lower side of a beam, they should at least be given an oblique position in order to take the place of bent-up bars and stirrups (see Fig. 2). With an arch instead of a beam the shear forces will be greatly reduced by the vault effect, but even in arch-shaped roofs shear forces can be caused by joint systems, especially by systems of parallel layers, e.g., sedimentary formations, schists, etc. Hence it is of greatest importance for every bolt not only to exert a strong prestress to the rock but also to set it in a direction which answers to the static demands of the geological conditions, as shown in the schematic sketches in Fig. 3 for three different joint systems. Just as a static member of reinforced concrete must be prestressed before receiving the load, the rock also has to be prestressed by bolting before the load develops. This means that the space tin Fig. 1 must be bolted immediately after blasting and at the same time as the next round is being drilled. The space between the bolts is chosen in accordance with the length and diameter of the bolts. Assuming, for instance, that a I in. bolt is given a load of 12 tons, taking into consideration a sufficient factor of safety, this would correspond to a rock volume of 4.5 cu. m. at a density of 2.65 tons per cu. m. If the length of the bolt allows a thickness of the protective arch of 2.5 in., each bolt will consequently carry an area of the road of
For special geological conditions — for instance, for the examples shown in Fig. 3 — any increase in the number of bolts will necessarily depend on the thickness of the layers and the nature of the rock. Steel bolts can be divided, according to the method of anchoring, into the common slit and wedge bolts and the so-called "expansion bolts." The first type is anchored by driving the bolt against the bottom of the drilled hole to expand a wedge in the slotted tip of the bolt, whereas the expansion bolt has a device which widens the anchoring portion increasingly with the tension exerted by tightening the nut. With expansion bolts either a cone is used to widen a sleeve or two wedges (see Fig. 4). The limit of the geological quality of the rock in the bolted area in case of an arch virtually depends on the possibility of obtaining a solid anchoring. As there is no space for any deformation, theoretically even a vault of sand would stand and carry a considerable load if bolts could be anchored in it and loss of material towards the open space could be impeded. Anchoring is certainly the principal practical problem connected with this method. The rock, as well as the anchoring part of the bolt, is exposed to shear, and the larger the contact surface between rock and anchor, and the better the anchoring device bites into the rock, the better is the anchoring effect. Experience has shown that the best anchoring effect is obtained with sound — but not too hard — rock as it is known from numerous tensile tests, that a 1 in. bolt, for instance, usually breaks at the thread with forces between 20 and 24 tons before the anchoring gives way. But this is not the case in rock of inferior quality, as the following results of research work will show. In order to establish a scientific foundation for the considerable utilisation of roof bolting in the Ruhrgebiet, which has to deal with quite poor rock conditions, some very interesting tests have recently been made there11. The tensile tests executed with roof bolts in sandstone and schist showed that the bolt slowly glides out under the applied stress. The same phenomenon had been observed by the author in his tests with anchoring in decomposed gneiss. The distance through which the lower end of the bolt moves as a function of the applied load — i.e., the yield — is shown in Fig. 5. The yield of a bolt measured during these tests includes, of course, not only the distance which its anchor moves but also the temporary and the permanent elongation of the bolt. Further, in using expansion bolts the bolt will pull out a short distance, pressing the expanding mechanism more firmly against the rock, if the bolt has not been sufficiently prestressed while setting it. If this is the case, the diagram shows a flat rise at the beginning, becoming abruptly steep as soon as the expansion has finished. (See test 1 in Fig. 5.) The curves of tests 1 and 2, made in a schist containing only little sand, are flatter than the curves 3, 4 and 5 which have been made in sandstone. Wet drilling of the hole in relatively soft rock instead of dry drilling makes the anchor yield easier, which can be seen from test 2, which is considerably flatter than curve I. With test 5, made with a thinner bolt, the steel starts to flow at 11 tons and 15mm. yield. On the other hand, however, neither should the rock be too hard. This is proved by tests, made recently in Sweden, in hard granite with bolts of different types13. These showed relatively low anchoring effects: 6-16 tons for expansion bolts and 3-10 tons for the common slit and wedge bolts. In a quartz, for instance — a specially hard and brittle material — the anchoring force of the 1 in. slit and wedge bolt is reduced to less than 1 ton. Drawings and Photographs accompanying the article
Article reproduced from a copy of the magazine held at National Mining Museum Scotland, Newtongrange, Midlothian.
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 17 Jan 2023
|
Search |
|
|||