Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Inquests Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Inquests
/   \

1858 Page Bank Colliery Disaster

Inquest Report

Page Bank Colliery Inquest

Extracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1858

Mr. William Armstrong, of Wingate Grange, said, — On the morning of the accident I was sent for to Page Bank Colliery. I went first to examine the working pit, and found a very considerable discharge of smoke from it; I was also satisfied from the colour of the smoke and smell that it was the smoke of burning wood and not of coal. I believed also that there had been no explosion, but that it was a fire which had arisen in the shaft of the pit itself I then examined the chimney, and there found a considerable quantity of smoke, and in that smoke I thought there was coal smoke, which showed that the small seam was on fire. I knew the colliery very well, being check viewer. Mr. Atkinson, the Government Inspector, Mr. Johnson, and myself, then had a consultation as .to what was most expedient to be done, and we decided in the first instance that we would endeavour to check the fire in the staple by putting in a stopping at the end of the chimney drift. There was a portion of stopping in before. We left a small aperture in the stopping to get a current to the smoke in the drift, so as to prevent it going back over again into the pit; we were quite clear then that there was a large body of fire in the staple drift, and more particularly in the other shaft. We decided to get down to the drift, if possible, and insert a dam, with a view to extinguish the fire. To enable us to get down to that point, as well as to get more air to the men in the pit, we conducted the water in two or three channels to one side of the pit, and dispersed the water with thorn bushes so as to make a shower down the pit; after this we prepared a cradle and got some air boxes knocked together to assist the sinkers in getting down to the drift end; whilst doing this we began to put canvas brattice in. We succeeded in getting four and a half fathoms of brattice in, when the men declared they could not stand the smoke and heat any longer. After waiting a while to see the effect of it, and finding it did not answer, we took it up again and enlarged the aperture in the chimney drift, so as to give a free vent to get the smoke Out of the drift. Mr. Wood and Mr. Forster had been sent for, and arrived towards night. A consultation took place, the result of which was that we determined to attempt once more to get the brattice put into the pit; it was prosecuted and continued with until we got down to the staple drift; its progress was then arrested by the fire at the blower, and we could carry it no further. At ten o'clock in the morning, by means of the water, a communication was effected with the bottom of the pit, and the men were brought to bank. The spears of the pumping engine had been burnt before this, and all the water we had to extinguish the fire had to be carried. When Jack Nicholson came to bank with the first boy he informed us that all the brattice below the blower was good, and we were then satisfied that the fire had not extended below the drift. No one has been down since the accident. It would be very difficult to account for the way in which the fire originated. There were only two ways whereby it can possibly be accounted for. One of them was a very probable mode; it might have been caused by a spark from the torch which Thomas Bird had used on Saturday morning; sparks from torches were very common, and he knew a fire of considerable magnitude which took place from one at Wingate Grange a few years ago. A detached spark from the torch might be carried through the door, the draught of which would be very strong, rise with the upcast air of the engine shaft, and be lodged in some recess in the plank tubbing, and there it might smoulder and burn until it burnt through the tubbing, which is two and a half or three inches thick, then communicate with the gas which accumulated behind the tub (not to a great extent, but there would be some), produce an explosion, and the fire it would create would in all likelihood cause that rush which Bird had spoken to. The second theory or conjecture which he had was that a spark from the furnace might be carried with the upcast air communicating with the tubbing, and produce the same results as he had before mentioned.

By the Coroner. — It is very common to use torches, but in my own practice I have discarded them altogether. I consider that they ought not to use torches except in extreme cases. It was very probable that a spark from an oil lamp on Saturday might have smouldered until Thursday. The wood would take a considerable time to burn through, as it would be completely saturated with water. In my experience I never knew of a life having been lost by the bratticing of coal pits getting on fire.

By Mr. Atkinson. — I was down Page Bank Pit in August, and noticed the ventilation in the pit ; it was in very good condition. I cannot say whether Mould would have seen a flash of light if there had been an he was in the cage. His not having seen any flash is a presumption that there was no explosion, but it is not conclusive. There was nothing blameable about the construction of the furnace ; it was a good furnace, and there was a very considerable current of air. Long antecedent to Mr. Atkinson seeing Mr. Johnson, and talking to him about a second shaft, such a thing had been suggested, but there were many difficulties which interposed to prevent it being carried out. I consider iron plates, and cast-iron or malleable iron brattice, to be better than wood. There is an objection to the smoke corroding the iron rapidly.

By the Coroner. — I consider that there is no blame to be attached to the management of the colliery generally; I think every vigilance and precaution had been used.

By a Juror. — Two shafts were better than one, but they were not absolutely necessary. The pit is a shallow one, and there was less necessity for two shafts. I know of no law to compel the sinking of two shafts. There is no law to prevent torches being used in pits, but the practice could be forbidden in the colliery regulations. I have known Bird several years, and believe him to be a very steady, worthy servant.

By Mr. Tiplady. — In consequence of the large quantity of water which has been met with, and other difficulties, the sinking of a second shaft has been delayed.

By Mr. Atkinson. — If the fire had occurred in the downcast shaft, and there had been two shafts, not one single life could have been saved, as the whole of the smoke must of necessity have gone in-bye and suffocated them.

Mr. Nicholas Wood said, — I was sent for and arrived at the pit on Thursday evening. I found Mr. Johnson, Mr. Armstrong, and Mr. Atkinson; we examined the pit and the staple, and all the circumstances connected with the fire. It appeared to me to be beyond doubt that the brattice was on fire, and also the wood "tubbing" in the pit and in the staple. I found, as Mr. Armstrong described, an attempt had been made to put sheet brattice in the pit, for the purpose of giving the men air, and in doing so the workmen had been driven out by the intensity of the fire. I found them pouring water down both the pit and the staple. After discussing all the circumstances with those gentlemen, I came to the conclusion that it was advisable to make another attempt to put in the brattice; in order to enable them to do so, the whole of the force of the water was applied to the pit. We considered that the air should not be obstructed in passing up the staple along the drift, and the water should not be used in the staple unless it could be spared from the pit. Putting in the brattice was then commenced; and Mr. Forster arrived, and he concurred in what had been determined upon. Two lengths of timber brattice were put in, and sheeting below that. Mr. Forster and I remained until between twelve and one o'clock, after arranging that the putting in of brattice should be persevered in during the night, and we would visit the colliery in the morning. At that time it was supposed that the fire had originated at the furnace, and that the whole of the brattice had been burnt out. We also thought the fire was confined to the timber tubbing, and portions of the brattice that might be left unconsumed. I returned to the colliery about ten o'clock next morning, and was most agreeably surprised to find one of the boys brought to bank immediately after, the fact having been that 16 or 17 fathoms of the lower portion of the brattice was entirely uninjured. On Monday last I went to the colliery with Mr. Forster, Mr. Atkinson, Mr. Armstrong, and Mr. Johnson, and made a most rigid inquiry of all the men in charge in the different departments, and we found that no lights except safety lamps had been taken down or up the pit. It is very usual for large flakes of burning cotton to be blown off an oil lamp, and the pit being an upcast, if the sparks had blown from Bird's lamp, they might have settled in the woodwork of the pit. It is my opinion that this was the cause of the fire, by setting fire to the timber in the shaft, which, when burnt through, would explode the gas in the cavities of the tubbing; and, in my opinion, accounts for the rush of wind described by Bird, and to the brattice being thrown off which killed Kellet. I think the smoke would immediately follow the explosion. I have considered the other ease alluded to by Mr. Armstrong: and looking at all the circumstances relating to the position and dimensions of the furnace, and the quantity of air passing over it, there being a side drift along which at least one-third of the air passed, I cannot come to the conclusion that the brattice had been set on fire by a spark from the furnace.

By the Coroner, — I think Bird would consider himself justified in using a torch under some circumstances, but I cannot say there would be no risk in it. The risk was its being a case where there is no passage used up and down the shaft. Torches are used in a great many collieries in the trade. I cannot ascertain that there has been any negligence anywhere; and I think the colliery has been managed with great care, and there seems to have been ample ventilation. It seems to me extraordinary that any men should have been lost at all, as there was plenty of air down the pit. I cannot agree with the witness that the lives were lost by fear. It might have been the case with the man Robson, but certainly I don't think it would be so with the boys. I rather think they have been on their knees, putting their faces down to the water, on which, there would be a current of air, and in that position they have fallen asleep, dropped down amongst the water, and so been drowned. in my opinion, if the. shaft had been set fire to by the furnace, the fire would have been immediately opposite the furnace drift, and not at such a distance up the shaft.

Mr. Thomas Emerson Forster corroborated Mr. Wood in the first part of his statement. He said, I concur with Mr. Wood that the cause of the fire was from a spark from the torch used by Bird on Saturday.

By Mr. Atkinson. — I do not know that torches are generally used in engine pits. It is advisable to have two shafts, but I have known many pits with single shafts and brattice, where there has never been any accident. I have known them take fire, but I never knew any lives to be lost before. My opinion is, that in consequence of the smoke Mould would not have been able to see any flash had there been an explosion.

The inquest was adjourned until ten o'clock on Thursday morning, the 14th of October, when the following further proceedings were taken and evidence adduced.

John Mould re-examined, said, — On the morning of the fire I carefully examined the shaft. I was led down slowly. I had a Davy lamp, with which I examined the brattice. I saw that the water was all right. I think if there had been any smouldering I should have smelt it.

By Mr. Atkinson. — If there had been any smouldering in the back-shaft, under the caphead, I should have smelt it.

By the Coroner. — I last examined these places on the Monday previous. I usually examined those parts three or four times a week.

By Mr. Atkinson. — It is not usual at other collieries to examine them oftener. The furnace comes into those parts from the bottom, and there is a straight ascent. I have never seen sparks fly from the furnace up the shaft. If a spark did come from the furnace, it would go that way. The furnace is not nearer the bottom of the shaft than furnaces usually are. There is not so much danger of the downcast shaft taking fire as the upcast. It is left to my own judgment as to when I think it advisable to examine the shaft. The only place where fire could have been smouldering was the engine shaft and under the caphead. All other parts were examined. I don't think any part of the bratticing was on fire on Monday. Water is constantly kept running down the shaft.

By a Juror. — There is no rule connected with the colliery for examining the shaft It is left to our own discretion. Kellet might have examined the shaft between the Tuesday and the Thursday unknown to me.

By Mr. Tiplady. — It is part of my express duty to examine the shaft; it was also a part of Kellet's duty. In other collieries that I have been at the shafts were examined about twice or thrice a week.

By the Coroner. — I consider it is sufficient for the safety of the men if these shafts are examined twice or thrice a week. I did not think it necessary to make a more searching examination after I knew Bird had been down the pit with a lighted torch. I have seen sparks fly up the shaft from torches.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print