1858 Page Bank Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
Page Bank Colliery Inquest
Extracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1858
David Bolam. — I live at Page Bank, and am a deputy in the pit. I went into the pit at two o'clock on Thursday morning with John Mould, John Waller, and George Robson. We had our safety lamps with us. They were lighted, but there were no other lights. When we got into the pit we went in-bye to see whether all was right. That is part of my duty. We found all right. I met Mould at the flat, near the extremity of the workings, where I had been examining, and reported that all was right. The air in the pit was good. There was a good wind going about. We met the men, then examined their lamps, and set them to their places. I then went on with my work. It is part of my duty to see to the safety of the men and the mine. I went to meet the boys about six o'clock, and placed them at their work. Then I went on with my own work. I think it was about nine o'clock when I was going with some timber from the third north headway towards the west drift. I then heard one of the drivers call out the brattice was on fire at the shaft, and I had to bring all the men out-bye. I did so. I had ten men in that berth, and I went round and told them all. I saw them all out-bye. I then was going out-bye myself; when I met some of the men who had gone out, coming in-bye again. They said they could not get to the shaft for the reek and smoke. They said the smoke was coming in-bye. I told them we would have to be through the broken doors into the return. I met George Robson the deputy in the broken flat. I told him we would have to be into the return. We went into the return at the back side of the furnace about 30 yards from the shaft. There were a good many other men there then. There was no reek there; there was none coming from the furnace. The smoke was coming down from the shaft through the separation doors. The smoke went through the shaft doors and returned over the furnace back to the shaft again. We had a consultation. Thomas Horsley, George Pattison, George Robson, and myself consulted among ourselves. Horsley and Pattison were stonemen, Robson and myself deputies. We thought it would be best to put the furnace out; it would give the men a better chance of putting the fire out. We put it out. About an hour after some of the lads grumbled a bit about it. They all seemed very well. About one o'clock on the Thursday afternoon, about an hour after the furnace was put out, something fell down the shaft and threw the smoke back upon us. George Robson then shouted to us to pray. He was very frightened, and said we had all only a quarter of an hour to live. He frightened some of the boys very much by shouting and praying. We retreated then from the furnace about 50 yards. About five minutes afterwards she took a suck, and the smoke went back, and most of us went to the furnace. Some went too near the furnace, and some went in-bye. The last lamps went out about nine or ten o'clock on Thursday night. Then there was no light left in the pit. Some of the men then got scattered away from us. Some of them got back into the broken way and some into the north way. Most of us stayed behind the furnace. I slept behind the stopping a good bit on the Friday. We remained there till we heard the men going about the shaft on the Friday. I was the last one who was got out. I did not know that any of them was dead. Where I was none of them suffered anything but from fear. We could hear the water falling down the shaft the whole time. I could see bits of burning brattice falling from time to time up to the time we were relieved. I did not hear any report or any explosion. If there had been anything of the kind I must have heard it. About one or two o'clock on the Thursday afternoon I and the waggon-way man gave a few shouts up the shaft, but we could not stay any time. When I went down the pit on the Thursday morning at two o'clock I examined the brattice. The water was running down as usual; there was no fire, nor any sign of it. In my opinion the cause of the death of Robson and the boys was chiefly fear, and nothing else.
By Mr. Nicholas Wood. — I did not see Robson and the two boys. I did not see any of them dead in the mine. The ventilation was good all the time. We thought it was rather stronger than usual from the fire burning in the shaft and the water falling down it.
By the Coroner. — I don't think there was anything in the ventilation of the mine to cause death to any one. There was good air all the time where I was, and we begged all to stop about the furnace, but some got frightened and strayed away. I have no idea what set the bratticing on fire. I have worked at this colliery ever since it was started, about two years ago. I never heard any of the men complain that there was not two shafts.
By Mr. Tiplady. — There has never been an accident before this; the deputies usually light their lamps before going down the shaft.
At half-past one the jury adjourned for 20 minutes.
After the jury had re-assembled, Mr. Tiplady said there were several other witnesses who could confirm the evidence of David Bolam, but if the jury were satisfied with the evidence on the points he spoke to, it would only be a waste of time to call them.
The Coroner said it had been suggested to him that they should have one or two witnesses to speak to each particular class of facts.
The foreman said if they had one or two witnesses to speak to each department it would be sufficient.
Thomas Brown, of Brancepeth Row, brakesman at the Page Bank Colliery, said, — On Thursday morning week I went into the pit at six o'clock and released Thomas Watson; the boys had arrived and we set away to draw coals. Three tubs were drawn after Kellet came. At nine o'clock there was a rap to draw the men away; I drew up, and in doing so heard something fall. I had then hold of the handles, but felt nothing; shortly afterwards I saw "reek" coming up out of the shaft. It takes 6¾ strokes to draw up. The smoke was of a darkish colour. I thought I first saw it from the caphead side; it came to the door of the engine house. I heard a shout of "fetch her up" before I got Mould to bank. As far as I saw before I went to work the shaft was in its usual state ; if there had been any fire I must have seen it. I have never seen any one go down the shaft with any sort of lights but Davy lamps; the men generally go down in the dark and light their lamps at the bottom. The fire broke out shortly after Kellet went down; when I did see it there was a great quantity of smoke came up as though the fire had broken out all at once.
Thomas Bird deposed, — I live at Page Bank, and am an enginewright; I was at the colliery at the time this accident happened; I was there about half-past eight o'clock. It is my duty to look after the ropes and machinery connected with the shaft and the colliery generally; I examine the shaft almost every night ; I do not examine it in the morning. On the Saturday before the accident I was busy down at the bottom of the shaft from six o'clock in the morning until between five and six at night; we were changing the low set clack. John Wailer and Charles McGlosty were assisting me; we got it done that Saturday. On Sunday morning we and Waller went down to tighten the high set clack door; in examining the shaft we used Davy lamps we have large Davy lamps for the purpose of performing that duty. We never had any naked light; we are prevented from using naked lights except at the bottom; it is a general rule that no naked light shall go down. No smoking is allowed.
When we were working at the low set clack on Saturday we had a torch, consisting of a vessel with a long tin spout, and a thick cotton wick. The set clack is in the engine upcast shaft. When the wick burns down to the tin, we often knock it to get the wick out; sparks sometimes fly out when that is done. I did not see that done on Saturday. I was down about half an hour on Sunday morning; I went down on the cage top. I had besides the big torch a small oil lamp, holding about a pint of oil, when I went down on Saturday. I don't know that any candles were used. There is a door through the brattice to get to the low set clack. There is a considerable force of wind when these doors are open, which blows up the upcast. When we were down on Saturday we closed it directly we got through. On Monday I was down again to see that the syphons were all right; we had no torch on Monday. I was at the pit every day after until the day of the accident, but I was not down. I was there on Wednesday night. On Thursday morning was beside the shop door when the accident took place; that is about 50 yards from the shaft; I heard a rush, and when I looked the shaft was enveloped in smoke; it was light coloured smoke, and came up both the fore and back shafts. In about a quarter of an hour after I saw flames at the top of the shaft; I believe I saw them when they first reached the surface. I went home about an hour after I saw the flames, having got wet. We were allowed to use torches at the low clack door, but we never used them higher up. The onsetter has his oil lamp always burning there for the purpose of the men to light their Davy lamps.
By a Juror. — It is a common practice to use torches in engine pits.
Mr. Atkinson. — What was the reason for not using candles in the back pit?
Witness. — Because it was so wet we could not keep them in.
By Mr. Atkinson. — The wind is very strong when the doors in the brattice leading to the back pit are open.
By a Juror. — The sound which first attracted my attention was like a rush of rain.
John MacKey examined by Mr. Tiplady. — I live at Spenny Moor, and am a sinker. I went down the shaft on Friday after Nicholson had been done and fetched the first boy lip; I went to examine the pit generally, and assist in fetching the men up. I found the brattice nearly all burnt out down to the staple drift; portions were left hanging here and there; I could not tell where the fire had most prevailed, but at that time it was burning about three fathoms below the staple drift; the fire was mostly on the back side of the engine pit; both the main and quarter brattices were burnt there. There had been no body of fire further down, and from there to the bottom the brattice was all good. The fire appeared to have been the strongest just above where the blower of gas is. The gas was burning when I went down. I did not see the furnace drift that day. I assisted in bringing the men up.
By a Juror. — I cannot say what could have ignited the "blower."
By Mr. Atkinson. — I did not see the furnace drift. If the brattice was set on fire it would burn the plank tubbing through, and so ignite the blower. The brattice was all good down towards the furnace.