Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Inquests Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Inquests
/   \

1858 Page Bank Colliery Disaster

Inquest Report

Page Bank Colliery Inquest

Extracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1858

Thomas Hall, of West Hetton, under-viewer, said, — I was at Page Bank on the day of the accident, and remained until half-past ten o'clock on Friday morning. I went to the bottom with Nicholson. The only man standing at the shaft was Horsley. I asked him where Kellet was, and he said, "he went to bank yesterday." I then took a lamp and found Kellet lying dead about two yards from the bottom of the shaft. We allowed the body to remain until the live persons had been taken out. The body was much mutilated, especially about the head. The shaft was all good at the bottom. A spark from the torch lamp is the most probable cause of the fire.

By a Juror. — I have known sparks smoulder for several days. I have seen sparks fly up 80 yards. I think a spark might have smouldered from Saturday until Thursday.

Matthew Thornton, overman, of Byers Green Colliery, proved finding the body of George Sheraton. He was lying in a tub, and quite dead. There was no water in the tub. The air there was no worse than it was further in-bye. I cannot account for the fire except it originated from a spark from a torch. I think a spark from the furnace could not have gone so high.

Mr. William Robert Hawks, of Spennymoor, said, — I am surgeon to the Page Bank Colliery. I was present when the bodies of George Sheraton, Thomas Lishman, George Robson, Thomas Attey, Robson Reay, William Coates, James Stobart, Dennis Haley, and Simpson Burns were brought to bank. They were all dead. I examined the bodies. I found a cut on Dennis Haley, and a graze on the cheek of Stobart. I think fear, exhaustion, and the smoke caused death. They had all the appearance of persons who had died of asphyxia. The smoke had probably produced drowsiness and insensibility, and in that state they had either fallen or thrown themselves down.

Mr. Henry George Hardy, surgeon, of Byers Green, spoke to the bodies of the nine persons mentioned by Mr. Hawks, and he concurred with that gentleman in the opinion that asphyxia, produced by the inhalation of smoke, was the cause of death.

Mr. Allen, surgeon, Willington, proved having examined the body of Kellet, who was very much bruised about the head and face. In his opinion, he had been killed by a fall. Death had been instantaneous.

Mr. R. S. Johnson was recalled, and produced a copy of the rules of the colliery. One of the rules which he read was to the effect, that it was the duty of the deputy overman to inspect the engine and coal shafts, and superintend all repairs. Thomas Bird is the engineer of the colliery. It was also the duty of John Mould and the deceased, Thomas Kellet, to examine the brattice and the engine and coal shafts generally. I paid Kellet 5s. a week extra for that duty; he had been a master sinker, and was considered a very efficient shaftsman.

By Mr. Tiplady. — I have had 18 years experience in the coal trade. Engine shafts are examined by the engineer only when he changes his buckets and clacks; this may occur once in two or three days, and sometimes perhaps not above once a month. Upcast shafts, not being coal-drawing shafts, it is usual to examine them from the bottom in the travelling ways past the drift, and look up the shaft to see that the water fall is on. Engine shafts are seldom gone up. In Page Bank, owing to there being pumps in the upcast shafts, it was necessary for the engineer, or some one, to go to the pumps frequently, as it being a very heavily watered place, it was necessary to change the buckets frequently.

Mr. Tiplady. — What is your opinion of the cause of the fire? Witness. — It having been proved that the fire originated 20 fathoms up the shaft, I think it not likely to have been caused by a spark from the furnace. Had it been a furnace spark, it would naturally have ignited opposite the furnace drift. It is probable that the fire originated from a spark from a torch; it might have been occasioned by a cinder from the fire-lamp, which is placed from three to five yards from the mouth of the shaft. I think the former inference the most probable. Had a spark been blown from the torch of Bird it would have been carried high up the shaft, as the draught is so great. Nothing but a torch could burn in the upcast shaft. Had there been another shaft it would have been an upcast. Had there been two shafts at Page Bank, it is my opinion, under the circumstances, that it would have been worse for the men, and the probability is that the whole of them would have been killed. The whole of the smoke would have been blown into the mine, supposing the men had acted as in this instance, and not opened the separation doors.

Thomas Bird recalled, said, — I have been employed as engineer 16 years. I have always used torches, and oil lamps in engine shafts. I had previously been employed at Seaham, Wingate, and Castle Eden collieries. I examined the bratticing on the Saturday, Sunday, and Monday previous to the accident. After Monday I was unwell, and did not go into the shaft. I told William Hall I was poorly. I don't know whether he set any one to do my work. I went about my work above bank until Wednesday morning. It was more particularly Kellet's duty to examine the shaft. I don't know whether he examined the shaft during the week the accident took place.

Mr. John Atkinson, of Bowburn, near Durham, Government Inspector, said, — About two years ago I examined the shaft at Page Bank Colliery ; my attention was directed to a blower of gas in the shaft; I thought the arrangements made for carrying it off satisfactory and sufficient. I have examined the shaft since the accident to within a short distance of the drift. It is customary, in first opening out coal mines, to establish a small temporary furnace, to produce ventilation, as near, and, I believe, often much nearer the shaft than that which was in use at Page Bank Colliery at the time of the accident. Shaft brattices do occasionally catch fire, but in most of the cases which have come under my observation it has been at a point opposite the furnace drift, and not, as in this case, at a point many fathoms above the furnace drift. In none of these cases has there, in my experience of more than 22 years, been any life lost in consequence of a fire having occurred in the shaft brattice. I think if the shaft doors had been opened by the men in the pit, all would have been saved, except Kellet, or — in the event of their having been unable to get to the shaft doors for the smoke — if they had broached the stoppings. The fact of Thomas Kellet having smelt burning timber leads me to the conclusion that the fire was not caused by any explosion of gas in the shaft.

The gas might have become ignited from a small aperture, and continued to burn without causing an explosion. I am of the same opinion as Mr. Wood, Mr. Armstrong, Mr. Forster, and others, as to the fire having originated from a spark; but I don't agree with these gentlemen in thinking that the spark was more likely to have come from the torch used by Bird on the Sunday preceding the accident, than from either the surface lamp or from a spark from the furnace being carried in a nearly horizontal direction along the furnace drift, into and then vertically up the shaft by the air passing over the furnace; although the latter might be deemed improbable, I think it just possible, and my opinion is that a spark from either of the sources I have last mentioned might have come in contact with and ignited some small jet of gas in the shaft, which would have continued to burn, and might have ultimately ignited the brattice and other timber in the shaft. From the appearance of the shaft since the accident I am of opinion that the fire originated not less, but probably more, than 60 yards from the furnace. I think if the fire had been smouldering from a spark caused by the torch, the smell of burning timber would have been discovered sooner, and hence I think the spark did not come from the torch. I feel confident the pit was well ventilated. I am of opinion that there was no undue risk in the arrangements, not more than in the practice of the trade generally. If the furnace had been further off the shaft it would have been a less efficient ventilator. Torches are generally used in engine pits in the coal trade, but I think they are dangerous, and a more safe description of light should be used. I consider that the general safety of a mine is much increased by having two shafts, although had this Page Bank pit been the downcast, and there had been a separate upcast shaft, in the event of the downcast shaft having got on fire, I much doubt whether any of the lives could have been saved, supposing the men to have acted as they actually did in this instance.

The Coroner said they might have acted very differently.

Mr. Atkinson said he wished to remove, an erroneous impression which had got abroad, that if there had been two shafts there would have been no danger to the men. Examination continued. — I can corroborate generally the evidence which has been given relative to the operations made to extinguish the fire.

By Mr. Tiplady. — I don't think there is any one to blame for the accident. I think the general arrangements of the pit were proper and efficient, Of course I would have preferred another communication from the surface to the mine, and there was one in course of construction.

Mr. Maynard. — A second shaft was going on?

Mr. Atkinson. — Something that would have been equivalent to a second shaft.

The Coroner then proceeded to sum up. He said, in the first place he must preface his remarks by saying that he was sorry that the serious illness of his father had occasioned his absence from this inquiry. This had been a subject of deep regret to his father, and also to himself, because though he had had some experience in inquests, he had not had much experience in inquests of so much importance as this. He might allude to the serious misunderstanding which now existed between the magistrates of this county and the coroners as to the nature of the cases in which it was necessary to hold inquests. So far as his father was concerned, and so far as he himself was concerned, they had determined to hold inquests in all cases where, they deemed it necessary, utterly irrespective of any question as to the paltry allowance of fees. In colliery accidents it was the duty of the coroner to institute the most searching and strict investigation, because if they went to the mouth of the pit to make an inquiry they would generally find, it stated that the man had been killed by his own neglect. As they were probably aware, the coroner's court was a very ancient one, and one of the highest importance. The coroner was a delegate of the Queen herself, and the jury chosen were her people. The inquiry in a coroner's court was one in which no person was distinctly to blame, and the court from its constitution was and ever had been regarded as particularly the poor man s friend. In all cases like this the owners of collieries were enabled by their wealth to be represented by experienced persons, and it must be a high satisfaction to the people of this country to know that they also were represented, and that from the very constitution of a coroner's court they might be assured of obtaining a full and impartial investigation. This was a case of very considerable importance, as the lives of ten men and boys had been sacrificed and he was quite sure that every disposition had been shown to institute a full investigation into the whole of the circumstances. The duty of the jury would be to ascertain as far as they could how, when, and by what means these persons came by their deaths. On the first point they would have little difficulty in forming an opinion; and with regard to the point as to by what means their deaths had been caused, he thought the evidence they had had must have so convinced them that it would be unnecessary for him to make any observations. The general gist was that the fire originated from some cause in the shaft, and on that there was considerable difference of opinion, some believing that the fire was cause by a spark from the furnace, others that it had been caused by a spark from an oil lamp used by Bird on the previous Saturday, and a third supposition was that it might have been caused by a spark from the lamp at bank. In coming to their conclusion, as to what means the deceased came by their deaths, it would not be necessary for them to say by what identical spark the fire had been produced, but they had to consider whether the shaft had been set on fire by the commission or omission of any person employed at the colliery. If they believed that there had been any neglect, they must next consider whether there had been that negligence which amounted to criminality. It had been laid down that every man must bring to bear on his particular office a reasonable amount of skill and knowledge; as, for instance, if a surgeon by any unskilfulness in his mode of treating a patient caused death, he would be guilty of the crime of manslaughter. The coroner then proceeded to recapitulate the chief points in the evidence, and he read over the whole of the statement made by Mould, and remarked that it was somewhat singular that when be smelt fire he did not at once endeavour to ascertain from whence it proceeded, instead of attempting to go up to bank to put on more water, when he knew that the usual quantity was falling down the pit. It would be for the jury to consider as to whether there had been any negligence or omission of duty on his part; and he might remark generally that if they had any remarks they wished to append to their verdict, it was quite competent for them to do so. They had been favoured with the opinions of some of the most skilled and scientific gentlemen in England connected with the colliery trade, and he would remind them that Mr. Atkinson had spoken in the highest terms of the general management of the mine; it must be very satisfactory to the colliery owners to have such an opinion from the Government inspector. As the question had been much agitated out of doors with respect to the desirability of having two shafts, he wished them particularly to direct their attention to the evidence given on that point. The evidence, generally, was that if there had been two shafts at this pit, the shaft where the fire occurred would have been a downcast shaft, and if there had been an upcast the whole of the smoke from the fire would have been carried into the mine, and in all probability not a life would have been saved.

About ten minutes before three o'clock p.m. the jury were left in consultation, and at half-past three they agreed upon the following verdict :—

"The jury are of opinion that the brattice in the shaft was ignited by a spark, but from what source the spark came from there is no positive evidence to show ; they are further of opinion that the whole of the men, save Kellet, died from fear and suffocation, arising from the fire in the shaft, Kellet being killed by falling down the shaft ; and, further, they are of opinion no blame can be attached to any person whatever ; they therefore find a verdict of accidental death."

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print