1882 West Stanley Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
West Stanley Inquest, Third Day, Saturday, 27th May, 1882 (cont.).
Mr. William Johnson called again, examined by Mr. Edge.
You told us that you went down the pit immediately after the explosion? — Yes.
You have told us that you went into this South Crosscut district? — Yes.
Was that the first exploring party that went into the South Crosscut district? — Yes.
Did you go into the back South Crosscut? — Yes.
Just point out the portions you travelled that night in the South Crosscut, and the portions you have since travelled? — That night we came along the Fore Crosscut, and we recovered those three bodies. We found the brattice opposite the Stenton here burned the in-by side of that burning, the brattice was complete right into the face. Mr. Davison and one of the workmen came through here (pointing to the diagram), and recovered this body here.
That is Hutchinson? — Yes, in the Stenton, and came on ; the canvas in the Back Crosscut was down and I, Turner, and Mr. Davison immediately put it up, the same canvas that had fallen down, and when I got to it they were past this corner end of the canvas, replacing it ; they were up behind the canvas, replacing it from the back there, putting it up and fastening it as best they could ; I kept the other man down here until this canvas was put up. I came back over here and Mr. Davison came back over the door, and we went through and went in the face with them again.
You had to put the canvas up to take the air in with you? — Yes ; the other parties were standing back in the Stenton, and when these men came up, the canvas was in, it had been replaced again.
Mr. Davison was actually in the face of that Back Crosscut before you were? — Mr. Davison and Middlemas were in first nailing the canvas up ; they had some nails in here (pointing to the diagram), and I came back over here again, and by the time I came back over they had got onto the face and come out by the door, and we went in through the door into the face the proper way. Mr. Davison was the first that had been in that face.
When you got in there into the face what did you see? — The stones were lying ; they were some, perhaps, that had been shot down and worked down by a pick. In the east side of the crosscut there are the remains of the top portion of a drilled hole, where the man had evidently, as far as I could judge, been nicking his stone up with this shot, and had worked the west side with the pick and the cracket, and the number of stones lying seemed to have been worked out by the pick. The pick and cracket were immediately on the stones ; in fact, I sat down upon them when I went in there.
Were the pick and cracket on the stones when you went in? — Yes.
The kitty and the touch that you produce, where were they? — In the Fore Crosscut.
Were they in the hole? — They were in the hole.
In the pricker hole? — Yes ; the straw was in the hole ; the touch paper had fallen out, and it was lying immediately below the hole.
The straw was in the hole, and the touch paper was on the floor below? — Yes ; I drew Mr. Atkinson's attention to the straw, and for fear it might be lost we took it out, and Mr. Atkinson laid it upon the cracket.
Mr. Atkinson was there with you then when it was drawn from the hole? — Yes, and after we went back again, for fear the straw might be lost we brought it out of the pit.
That was the straw untouched that you produced here before the jury? — Yes.
Did you explore all this South Crosscut any more that day? — We came back to there (pointing to the diagram).
The innermost west board? — Yes, at this time, because we had some more men.
You knew where these other men were up in this district? — Yes.
Then you said you came back here to the west rolley way? — Yes, stooping this south one off and the west one off, and took the air in here. At that time I was sent for, and I got to bank, and Mr. Baker Forster and Mr. Berkley both arrived.
You did not go in with the first party that found Middlemas and McCabe? — No.
You came down the pit again with Mr. Baker Forster? — Yes, between 6 o'clock and 7 o'clock ; 7 o'clock it might be ; I cannot say which.
Did you go into this district then? — Yes, we came back into this district, knowing we had these men to go, and we met them just in the in-by side in No. 2 crossing bringing the two bodies out, and Mr. Rutherford, Mr. Fairley, and Mr. Davison returned with us into this place.
You knew that there was an old door there? — Yes.
Where had that door been used ; tell us what purpose it had been used for? — It had been used for many months at the main return from the west district immediately on the east side of No. 2 air crossing.
It had been used in there? — Yes ; when this air crossing was put in it was taken off, and it was laid upon the pillar stones, just on the in-by side of the first wall north of the crossing, and it remained there ever since.
(The Coroner.) There would be a heap of stones? — Yes, just a rough heap of stones.
(Mr. Edge.) Did you see where that door was after the explosion? — I saw it, but I could not say that it had been shifted one way or the other, because so many had been there before I saw it ; but it has been lying there ever since that crossing was put in.
How far north of the air crossing? — I cannot say how far it was in-by ; I did not measure the distance because there had been so many at it.
I suppose it would have taken Mr. Rutherford and Mr. Fairley some time to get the air into this place? — Yes.
Then did you travel into Middlemas' and McCabe's place? — Yes.
Did you travel any other part of this East North Crosscuts that night? — Yes.
What part did you travel that night? — Mr. Baker Forster and I travelled both north and south of that district ; that is as far as we could get ; the ventilation was not restored then.
Have you since travelled the rest of that district? — Yes.
Which part of it? — All of it.
We have heard of a fall here north of Middlemas' and McCabe's place ; whereabouts was that fall, can you tell me? — I suppose along this headway course, this east board here (pointing to the diagram).
Where were the falls and airway? — There were various falls here (pointing to the diagram). There is a fall along these narrow boards here that we have not been able to get over yet.
Can you tell me how these stoppings along the north narrow board were blown? — Yes, these were canvas bearing-up stoppings, these were all bearing-up stoppings right round by the face.
I will take you first of all to these stoppings along the north narrow board, how was the first stopping going from the rolley way, from the North Crosscut rolley way? — It was blown to the south, blown to the right side.
(The Coroner.) The first stopping east of the North Crosscut rolley way? — Yes.
(Mr. Edge.) How was the second? — In the same direction.
How was the third? — The same way.
Was it blown to the south also? — Yes.
And the fourth? — That was blown to the north.
And the fifth, do you know how that was? — We have not been able to see that one. We have been able to trace the blast in there to, but we have not found that stopping.
In the case where the blast was going north round towards that you could not get into it? — No.
Have you been in the east boards, east of the third stopping? — Down to this Stenton here (pointing to the diagram).
You have been down to the south side of the fifth Stenton? — Yes, the fifth Stenton from the Fore Crosscuts.
You said the indications were going down there, that the blast had gone north? — Yes.
You were speaking about a bearing-up stopping, is the bearing-up stopping to the south between the third and fourth stoppings on the north narrow boards? — Yes, on the back narrow board, that was blown to the west.
(The Coroner.) What is that stopping? — Blown to the west.
What do you call that?
(Mr. Edge.) There is a stopping in the back narrow boards between the third and fourth stoppings.
(To the witness.) Did you travel along the north narrow boards? — We returned this way, and came out this way (pointing to the diagram) by the back narrow board, and there was no trace of fire of any kind along this back narrow board. We went through here and went down the fore narrow board.
You went from the back narrow board through the Back Crosscut? — Yes.
Into the fore narrow board? — Yes.
And then you went east along the fore narrow board? — Yes, we went as far as we could get, and from the fall all the way up ; the charring is on the east side of the props, and there was timber blocked out and blown to the west.
You are speaking of the fore narrow board? — Yes, going west.
Going west along the fore narrow board did you notice anything when you got into the North Crosscut rolley way? — Yes, there were the brick kibbles and the accumulation of dirt up against the west wall north of the North Crosscut.
Opposite where the fore narrow board came down into the narrow crosscut? — Yes.
Then were there some brick kibbles in the west narrow board? — Yes.
Can you tell me whether you noticed any indications coming out-by from the back narrow board along the North Crosscut? — The indications are really very slight, many of the stoppings are blown both ways, and coming past the east rolley way end, or the east going-board end, the coal is very much charred on the out-by side just at the east here (pointing to the diagram), showing that the blast had come past here and charred this end. There is some place where you can find small canches of coal. You find a little charring on it, but you find very little charring along here (pointing to the diagram).
Along the crosscut way? — Very little.
Now have you travelled this district south? — Yes.
From Middlemas and McCabe's place? — Yes.
How were the stoppings there, I will take you down here. You know where there was a regulating door? — Yes, a regulating stopping.
Between the west district return and the airway from McCabe's place? — Yes.
Where did that stand? — It stood just here (pointing to the diagram), about six or eight yards on the in-by side of that wall.
That regulating stopping stood about six or eight yards in-by from the return? — Yes.
How was that blown? — It was blown into the return.
I suppose there was a stopping first at the East Crosscut? — Yes.
That is the crosscut to the east of the North Crosscut rolley way, had there been a stopping in there? — The stopping was up there (pointing to the diagram).
The stopping was up near the flat of the east-going board, south side? — Yes.
There is another stopping that has been spoken of nearly opposite the end ; it is between where the North Crosscut rolley way joined the west again and where the door and brattice stood? — Yes.
How was that stopping blowing? — It was blowing to the south.
(The Coroner.) What is that called.
(Mr. Bell.) It is the stopping on the south first wall to the left hand of the in-by side of the North Crosscut, is it not? — Yes.
What kind of stopping was that? — A brick stopping.
(The Coroner.) It was blown to the south? — Yes.
(Mr. Edge.) Did you notice, opposite where the North Crosscut rolley way takes off from the west rolley way, any signs there? — On the North Crosscut?
No, opposite to there (pointing to the diagram), where the North Crosscut takes off from the west rolley way? — There is a pillar bit up here directly opposite the North Crosscut, that pillaring is as though it had been plastered a bit, and in which dirt and dust had accumulated directly opposite the North Crosscut ; and directly on the east and west side of the North Crosscut it is free, similar to what it was when first put in, from this hard dust.
Does that lead you to any conclusion with regard to how the blast had come? — Yes, that leads me to the conclusion that she came out south from the North Crosscuts.
Do you know where the door in the west rolley way, the door in the in-by side where the North Crosscut takes off, was blown to? — It was blown to the west.
I ought to have asked you about this door here (pointing to the diagram) ; a door stood at the in-by side of the flat of the east-going board? — Yes.
Did you see where that door had been blown? — One band and a batten that goes across the door was lying in this position, as though it was lying open where a trapper's prop and string hung on. It was lying just in that position and there were other portions of it lying further out. I could not speak very much more about that door, because I was going straight on over this fall (pointing to the diagram), and in the meantime there were more parties behind looking about.
There was a fall in-by of that door? — Yes.
I want to know whether there was any other door set up or lying about in that east-going board? — There was an old door into the flat, but it was not in use.
Have you seen that old door since? — Yes, a portion of it.
Where did you see that old door?
(The Coroner.) Will you tell us first where the door was lying before the explosion? — It was lying at the South Headways end, in the bottom end of the flat.
(Mr. Edge.) It was lying in the in-by end of the east flat? — Yes.
Where did you find the portion that you were speaking of? — There had been so many in here before me, that I would not like to place any reliance upon it. The exploring party had been there before me. The old door opened to the west.
Mr. Bell wants to know how the standing door in the flat opened? — It opened to the west from the north.
In McCabe's place did you notice the props there? — Yes.
What did you notice about them? — I noticed that the props were very much burnt and charred on the east side. In the first place, the first thing we came to was a tub turned into the South Headways here (pointing to the diagram). This tub had been taken off the turn by the west part of that main and put in here to be out of the way. It had been standing this way and then it was put in and came round the opposite turn, and the south end of that tub as it stood when I went down was all charred very much too, and that in its former position had been put directly opposite these boards.
Have you since the explosion, been into this place? — Yes, many a time.
Is Mr. Colquhoun accurate in the description he has given us? — Yes, very accurate.
With reference to the cavities? — Yes, with reference to the hitch and the leader.
Can you tell me this. In going south along the airway from McCabe's place did you see any indications? — Yes, of burning.
How were the indications there? — I found the indications both ways, some props were charred all round, but mainly from the south.
Do you mean going south from McCabe's place? — No, coming south. I found them both ways, but mainly from the south.
You found them mainly charred on the south side? — Yes.
Going north along the airway from McCabe's place, did you notice how the props were there? — They were all burned on the south side, the fire having gone north ; the fire was very intense along here (pointing to the diagram) going north along the airway. Two pillars back from the innermost face the force, or portion of the force, comes back over here (pointing to the diagram).
You say that the force had come south again? — Yes, a portion of it. The main force continued on its course north and you find charring right across here (pointing to the diagram), and coming south, across the East Narrow Board.
You find the charring coming south from that place in a line with where the regulator was? — Yes.
On which side was the charring of the props? — On the north side.
Did you draw any inference from that whether the blast separated, a part of it going north, and part going south to where the regulator was? — No.
Do you know how the two stoppings in the airway to the south of McCabe's place were blown? — No, I could not say that, because there were portions of canvas, there were bearing up stoppings. We found pieces of canvas lying in every direction. The indication of fire ceased here altogether (pointing to the diagram).
Where is that? — That is the first board north of the regulator, and that regulator is driven into the return here (pointing to the diagram).
Have you examined the South Crosscut since the explosion? — Yes.
Have you examined the whole of that South Crosscut district since the explosion, or what part of it have you examined? — The whole of it.
What indications have you seen in this South Crosscut district? — In the South Crosscut district there is not very much indication in the first pillar. What indications you find, you find upon the wall side ; there is no timbering.
We may take it that you could not see much indication in the first pillars going south of the South Crosscut district? — No. What indications you find, you find upon the wall side, indications of the blast going south.
What indications did you see there? — Charring on the canches of faces of coal that were open to the blast going south, and the one open and coming north was free from charring.
Going along in-by from the first pillar what other indications did you see? — I saw similar props charred on the north side ; and fine dust on the south side.
We have heard that some of the bratticing in the Fore Crosscuts had been burnt? — Yes, that was immediately opposite the Stenton.
The innermost hole Stenton? — Yes.
Had there been much of that bratticing burned? — I should say about eight or ten feet ; it was never taken down ; it was burnt across ; there was a hole in it about two feet down or so.
It had not come down? — No, we put a piece of fresh canvas in front of it.
(The Coroner.) Do you mean a piece of two feet wide covering a length of eight or ten feet? — Yes.
(Mr. Edge.) How was the canvas in the Fore Crosscut north of that innermost hole Stenton? — I should say it came out of the storehouse ; no fire had been near it.
Did you notice anything in the innermost hole Stenton? — The charring in this innermost Stenton appeared to me as if the fire had been hanging there, and had gone out there because the charring was on every side right round the props here (pointing to the diagram). The props when we took the charring off them were simply all charring.
Getting to the Back crosscut you have told us that when you went first of all in the Back Crosscut the bratticing was down? — Yes.
Was that bratticing burned? — No, the same brattice is up yet.
Did you see any indications in the Back Crosscut? — There were indications of burning no further than this innermost west unholed board. There was a kibble standing at the west of this board and the out-by side of it was charred and the soles were charred on the north side and were quite clean on the south side as in the first one ; and the other sole was on the other way showing clearly that the blast had gone south there ; but that was about the extent of it.
You did not see any signs of burning south of there? — No.
What is the sole? — It is the frame of the tram.
Going out-by along that Back Crosscut, did you see any indications? — Yes, there was a tub here (pointing to the diagram) with a rail or two, that was driven accross this way, driven out.
Did you see any other indications going on round? — There was a tub against this first wall side (pointing to the diagram), a pillar up, and the wall north. I have no idea where that tub came from. The end of the coal was charred, but what position it had been in I could not say. The early indications round here were on the north side.
From where the tub was all the indications were on the north side going out? — Yes.
Can you say whether you have formed any opinion with regard to the original place of this explosion? — I cannot form but one opinion.
What was the opinion which you formed? — That she exploded in here (pointing to the diagram).
That is in McCabe's place? — Yes, that is the only disturbed place there is , and since the ventilation has been restored, you are not able to detect gas only in that one place.
Is gas still coming off from McCabe's place? — Yes, the cavity is full of gas.
The cavity that Mr. Colquohoun spoke of? — Yes.
Is that the only place in the pit in which you have been able to detect gas since the ventilation was restored? — Yes.
In your judgement it fired that and caused the damage we have heard of? — Yes.
Cross-examined by Mr. Bowey.
I forgot how long you have had the management of this colliery? — For five years past.
Have you the entire charge? — Mr. Greenwell is consulting man.
Do you consult him? — Yes.
Is he the viewer of the colliery? — He is consulting viewer once a month. I refer to Mr. George Greenwell.
When did you last consult him before the explosion? — I think it was just about a fortnight or three weeks before the explosion.
You think he was at the colliery a fortnight or three weeks before the explosion? — Yes.
What was the last time before that occasion on which you had seen him? — A month before that.
As a rule how often do you see him? — He is at the colliery once a month.
Did you consult him about any matter a fortnight before the explosion? — There was nothing very particular to consult him about, but he spoke of this drift that we were driving up this Tilly Seam here (pointing to the diagram).
Did you consult him upon any other matter? — No.
Have you found a certified copy of the rules? — No.
You have never seen them? — No.
These are the rules that are in force, are they not (handing a copy of the rules to the witness)? — Yes.
Have these rules been in force all the time you have been manager? — Yes.
(The Coroner.) Those are the rules of 1874?
(Mr. Bowey.) Yes, sir, those are the rules of 1874.
(Witness.) I explained that they were in different districts.
(Mr. Bowey.) I am told that the rules for the Lamp pit are the rules for this colliery. (To the witness.) You have never seen that certified copy, you say? — No.
These rules have been in force since you have been manager? — Yes, and previous to that time.
Have you any regulations at the colliery with regard to shot firing? — The only regulation we have is enclosed in a portion of the book there. No one is allowed to fire a shot unless appointed by me to do so.
Do you keep a list of the persons whom you appoint to fire the shots? — There are not so many of them that I require to do so.
Do you keep any list? — No.
When you appoint a person to fire shots do you give him anything in writing certifying that? — Nothing.
(The Coroner.) You give him no written appointment? — No.
Or a list of the persons now appointed? — No.
(Mr. Bowey.) How often do you appoint them? — There are only the deputies appointed.
Do you appoint all the deputies to fire shots? — Yes.
Do you give them an appointment when they first come? — I make a man a deputy, and he is given that power, that is with reference to shot firing in his district.
Is anyone else allowed to fire shots besides the deputy? — Not in the day shift.
And in the night shift how is it? — He is probably allowed by the master shifter, if he is present, or Douglass.
Douglass was a shifter? — Yes.
Who had authority to fire shots in the South-west Crosscuts? — Douglass.
Who had authority to fire shots in the east-going board? — In the day shift there were no shots required.
No one had authority to fire a shot in the east-going board that night? — No.
When you went into the South Crosscut did you say Mr. Davison and Middlemas were in before you, into the face? — In the Back Crosscuts.
In the back South Crosscuts? — Yes.
And when you went in you found the cracket where? — On the stones.
You cannot tell whether it had not been moved? — No, I cannot say whether it had been moved or not. I know nothing about it. Mr. Davison and Middlemas put the canvas up in the back side.
(The Coroner.) But they happened to be in before you? — Yes.
(Mr. Bowey.) But you were not together at this point? — No, Mr. Davison went up behind the brattice with Middlemas to assist him in putting the brattice up. I was up behind the brattice too, but I came back to get the nails, and while I was getting the nails they came direct back over from the face to the door, and I went in through the door and went in with them again.
Would they have to pass the cracket before you? — Yes.
Where did you find the cracket? — On the top of the stones.
Where did you find the pick? — Just lying facing the west side of the cracket.
Was it on the stones? — Yes, facing the west side.
(The Coroner.) How do you mean "facing the west side"? — The cracket was on the east side of the crosscut, and the pick was lying on the west side of the cracket.
(Mr. Bowey.) Which of the crosscuts, the fore or the back, was Westgarth working in? — Westgarth would be in the Fore Crosscut.
And Douglass? — In the back one.
The indications from the face of the Back Crosscut to the innermost Stenton were what? — There were no indications of fire south of that west board.
There were no indications of anything of blast or dust? — No.
What are the indications which you speak of particularly at the out-by sides of the innermost Stenton ; that board which you spoke of just now coming down the crosscut out-by? — The charring on the timber there is all on the north side and fine dust on the south side.
One of the indications which you found was a tub? — Yes.
Which was blown east? — Yes, and there was a rail or two.
There would be no indication of the direction of the blast? — The blast had come from the west through that board.
And the next tub you came to you were unable to say anything with reference to it? — I could not say anything about that tub.
And from there to the main in-take what are the particular indications? — The charring is chiefly or nearly all upon the north side. I find some places where the prop is charred nearly all round it ; but where you find one side it is nearly all on the north side.
Are there many props marked on the north side only, or are most of them marked all round? — Most of them are marked on the north side ; there are not many marked all round.
Did you hear the evidence of Anderson the overman? — Yes.
Do not you consider that it is a violation of the rules of the colliery and of the Act that when Anderson saw a blue cap on the lamp he allowed shot firing afterwards? — He never saw it in here (pointing to the diagram), he said he had once seen some the same way in the Back Crosscuts, a little one morning.
About a month ago? — Yes, it was not facing from the face.
He said it showed blue, and he allowed shot firing to go on there in the same way that he had done before ; was that a correct thing? — It was not issuing from the coal.
He saw a blue cap on the lamp, and he allowed shot firing after that in the same way as he had done before ; do you consider that a proper thing ; would you have permitted it if you had known of it? — No.
If it showed a blue cap on the lamp, in your opinion was it a proper course to be followed to allow shot firing to go on at that place without any further precautions? — If it was true what he says, of course it was not.
Have you any reason to doubt it? — I very much doubt it, because I never saw it myself.
Because you have not seen it is that the reason why you dispute his word? — I only say that he ought to have reported it.
Then it was not a proper thing to do? — It was a very improper thing for him to see gas and not report it to me.
Are there any orders at the colliery that if they found gas and got it cleared away they were not to report it? — No.
How do you account for the fact that both Anderson, the overman, and the deputy (I think it was Mosson), both say that when they cleared away the gas they reported "all right," and thought that was quite sufficient? — They said that the report was all right for the men to come into the pit.
They reported the state of the mine and the district that they had examined, on the occasion when they found the gas and cleared it away, as "all right"? — Yes. Certainly if I had been deputy myself and had gone into a place and found a little gas standing in it in that way, and it did not matter how little the work was to remove it, I would certainly have reported it if I had found it.
Then it was not a proper course for them not to report it? — No, it is a very easy matter to do.
What was the exact place for the deputy's chest near the air crossing in the west main way? — It was just in this middle South Headway end west of the North Crosscut there (pointing to the diagram), on the out-by side of the stopping.
Where was it found after the explosion? — There was a good few in before me. I was busy erecting this No. 2 air crossing. I do not know who was in first, But I was in here (pointing to the diagram).
When did you see that first? — I did not see it until late on in the afternoon.
Where did you find it then? — It was just lying near to the corner here (pointing to the diagram).
How far had it been moved? — I do not think it had been moved very far at all.
In what condition was it? — It was partly broken, but many had seen it before me.
You say that there were very few indications up the North Crosscut? — Yes.
Very few indeed? — Yes.
Nothing from which you could give any idea with regard to the direction of the blast? — Where it was found was upon the wall side, on the coal side.
That might be whichever way the blast went? — You always find it on the north side of the canches of the coal, not on the south side.
There was no fall in the place where Middlemas and McCabe were when it was first seen after the explosion? — Yes. These (pointing to the diagram), had only got so far out went we went back again and there was a large stone down. Mr. Baker Forster held the lamp back.
Whereabout was that? — About three feet from the face.
Had that stone fallen after the explosion? — My idea is that that stone would fall immediately with the explosion.
Whose duty was it to examine Middlemas' and McCabe's place? — Hunter's.
He was the deputy? — He was master shifter.
Have you a report of the examination of the place? — When.
Immediately before the explosion? — No, the man is killed.
What are the reports that are supplied to you by the overmen and the deputy, are they all contained in the book which I have before me? — Yes, they are in that book which you have before you.
They are all contained in this book? — Yes.
Have you no separate book in which they specifically say whether they have seen gas or not and whether they have examined certain districts? — That book says they have examined their own districts.
Do you know that it is a customary thing in collieries to have a book in which there are certain printed questions, and which the deputy signs? — Yes, I have seen them and had them.
But you have not them at this colliery? — Some prefer this better than printed forms. In point of fact, it is not long ago that I made inquiries of the inspector, and he felt that this simple form was really the better way.
Who said so? — An inspector.
Who was that? — Mr. Atkinson.
Are you aware whether any of the overmen and deputies have seen gas and never reported it? — No, I have heard of it within the last day or two, but never previous.
Do you believe it? — If I believe that they have done so, I believe that they have gone a long way short of their duty.
Do you believe it? — No.
You do not believe the evidence you have heard on that point? — No. I beg your pardon, I was mistaking you. Yes, I believe these men have spoken the truth, but they came short of their duty in not reporting it.
That is Mossom and Anderson and Middlemas? — Yes.
Have you enforced those special rules at your colliery? — Yes.
Have you ever had any difficulty with Anderson or Mossom, or with Middlemas? — Never.
Of course you have read the special rules? — Yes.
Do you consider it a proper thing to have a man at the colliery who cannot read as deputy? — Yes.
Do you consider it a proper thing to have a man as a deputy at the colliery who cannot write? — Yes.
How is he to makes his reports? — He gives them to his marrow and his marrow makes them for him.
But suppose his marrow could not write, what then? — I would not like to put two together that way, we only have one that cannot write.
Do you consider that the 17th rule under the head of "Overman," which says that he is to enter the results of his observations each day in his Report book and sign the same and forward a copy to the manager or under-viewer is sufficiently complied with by this book? — That is not the overman's book.
This is the deputy's ; but I will read to you the 17th rule, "To enter the result of observations each day in his Report book and sign the same, and forward a copy to the manager or under-viewer." Do you consider that that is sufficiently coupled with by putting in for instance "Busty West Flat all right" and signing it? — Yes.
Where is this book kept? — At the colliery office which is within 150 or 200 yards of the pit.
How can the men see it? — By coming to the office and asking for it.
And the office is open during what hours? — From 8 o'clock till 8 o'clock again ; I dare say, from 8 till 6.
The men are often going down the mine before those hours, are they not, before 8 o'clock? — The fore shift men go down at half-past three o'clock.
Then how are they to get to know the state of the mine? — They meet the deputy at the bottom of the mine.
Then they are not to get it from the deputy's report book? — He has not entered it then.
How could they see the report of the previous day? — They could have seen it if they had come to the office to enquire for it.
The deputy will come out, will he not, on the preceding night about half-past 5 o'clock? — Yes about that time.
And the office closes, you say, about 6 o'clock? — Yes ; the clerk leaves at 6 o'clock, but the office but the office closed until I retire to bed ; the office is at the end of my house.
In point of fact, a hewer would have to come to you to see the book? — Yes, if he came after six is not o'clock, he would see me and get the book.
But supposing you were not there? — Then my son would be there, or Mr. Colquhoun would be there ; some of them might be there.
And some might not? — There is always some of them there.
After 6 o'clock? — Yes, at my house.
Do you mean to say that there are always some of the officials of the colliery at your house after 6 o'clock? — No, but my son is.
Always? — Yes.
What age is he? — 16.
Has he charge of this book? — No, but he is quite able to open the office door and present the book to them.
What is he in the office? — He is assistant clerk.
In the first place about this book, this is a book for a mine with no inflammable gas in it? — Yes.
Is this a correct report book for your mine? — Yes.
But yours is a fiery mine? — It has not been considered a fiery mine till now.
Have you never seen gas? — It never came under that category.
Do you mean to say that this was a mine that could be considered within the words of the Act as not a fiery mine until now? — Yes.
Let me read the second general rule to you. "In every mine in which flammable gas has been found within the preceding 12 months, then once in every 24 hours, if one shift of workmen is employed, and once in every 12 hours if two shifts are employed during any 24 hours, a competent person or competent persons, who shall be appointed for the purpose, shall, before the time for commencing work in any part of the mine, inspect with a safety lamp that part of the mine and the roadways leading thereto, and shall make a true report of the condition thereof so far as ventilation is concerned, and a workman shall not go to work in such part until the same and the roadways leading thereto are stated to be safe. Every such report shall be recorded without delay in a book which shall be kept at the mine for the purpose, and shall be signed by the person making the same"
(Mr. Edge.) I should like to see what the definition of a fiery mine in the Act of Parliament is.
(Mr. Morley.) There is no definition in the Act.
(The Coroner.) Therefore it is open to question, it is a matter of opinion.
(Mr. Bowey.) These are the rules given with Act of Parliament.
(The Coroner.) Are we not entering into a very large question which has troubled the heads of mine inspectors, colliery owners, colliery viewers, engineers, and everybody connected with collieries, with respect to what is or what is not a mine in which inflammable gas is found.
(Mr. Bowey.) I understand that this is a very broad inquiry.
(The Coroner.) It is, but I do not suppose that everybody wishes to be here for a month or six weeks. What I was about to say with regard to that rule is this, that with the view of saving what perhaps will be a very long and fruitless discussion upon this question, because as I understand, it is a matter which has been considered over and over again and without arriving at any proper determination, I think it would be advisable that you should limit yourself to asking the witness the question whether the mine has or has not up to now been dealt with as a fiery mine and so coming within that definition.
(Mr. Bowey.) I will not ask a single question after that preface.
(The Coroner.) I do not want to stop the slightest discussion that is likely to lead to any practical result, but it is a question upon which there is a good deal of difference of opinion with reference to what is a fiery mine or what is not a fiery mine. I would ask the Government Inspector whether I am not correct in that expression of opinion.
(Mr. Bell.) Certainly.
(Mr. Bowey.) I thought if we had the witness' statement first it might have been better.
(The Coroner.) I understood that you had put the question to the witness and he had answered it to the effect that it had not up to now been considered a fiery mine.
(Mr. Bowey.) But surely he could give his reasons, however I shall not ask him another single question. I shall only consider what course I ought to pursue.
(The Coroner.) I do not think there is any reason for any exhibition of feeling about it. Just proceed with the inquiry.
(Mr. Bowey.) I will do so. (To the Witness.) What is your practice with regard to consulting with your overmen and deputies? — Every afternoon.
Do you see them every afternoon? — Yes, I meet them at the office as soon as the pit is done at night.
Did you see them on this day? — Yes.
What report had you from them? — That everything was all right.
That is to say, that you have this entry in this book I suppose? — Yes, and talking the matter over with them.
Did they inform you of anything at all with regard to the condition of the pit? — Nothing, everything was right.
That is to say, you saw this entry in the book, but was there any verbal statement? — Every night I ask them if they have anything to mention, is there anything fresh or anything wanted or anything like that, that is the practice with us every night.
When did you first form an impression or opinion with regard to the seat of this explosion? — I first saw the course from here (pointing to the diagram), that might, but as to where it had gone and that sort of thing I could not tell until I had made a thorough inspection, and, in fact, several inspections with regard to the route it had taken and that sort of thing.
What was it led you to come to the conclusion that night that that was the place where the explosion occurred? — Because it was in such a disturbed state in giving off a quantity of gas.
Had you been in the South Crosscut then? — Yes.
(The Coroner.) Middlemas' and McCabe's place you mean? — Yes.
(Mr. Bowey.) Did you not find that also in a disturbed state. I mean the South Crosscut? — No, everything was quiet there, the seam was regular, but there was no lifting or cracking nor nothing of that kind in here, in the South Crosscut (pointing to the diagram).
Do you mean that you came to a decided opinion from the very first day that Middlemas and McCabe's place was the seat of the explosion? — No, I say that night I went in and saw the gas. I say this place was in a disturbed state.
When did you make up your mind with regard to the seat of the explosion? — After having had a look all round these places (pointing to the diagram).
And after talking the matter over with Mr. Baker Forster? — No.
Did you ever have any conversation with him about it? — I was with him when he was down with several others, but Mr. Forster came back and he and I had a thorough examination of the place.
Was not there some conversation between you and Mr. Baker Forster then with respect to where the explosion had originated? — Not particularly that night because I was too much engaged.
When was there a conversation between you respecting the place where the explosion had originated? — On the Friday night following we came back and made a thorough examination both north and south.
And your opinion did become more decided after having Mr. Baker Forster's view upon the matter? — My opinion was formed before he came. With regard to this crossing here (pointing to the diagram), I may say that after Mr. Baker Forster had got out the out-by side of this No. 2 air crossing he was not quite satisfied.
He was not quite satisfied you say? — He was talking about one of the headways here and he was talking about another one, and in order to thoroughly understand it he went in a second time, that was this second pillar (pointing to the diagram) from the east where the fire crossed the narrow board.
How do you account for the timber being burned on the south side going south from Middlemas' and McCabe's place? — I account for it by this fire coming along here and going along this board (pointing to the diagram).
The same way as Mr. Baker Forster accounted for it? — Yes.
Has the position of the cracket and the pick on the stone anything to do with forming your conclusion, supposing the pick and cracket had been found alongside the stone? — Nothing at all. If the pick and cracket had not been there it would not have affected my mind.
Do you say that there are clear indications of there having been work there after the shot had been fired in the Back Crosscut? — Yes, very clear.
Do you consider it possible for a hewer not to find them when he went in to seek them? — It depends upon what they had been done to if he went at the same time that I went, it would be impossible for him to find it.
If a man went to seek it? — Then he is sure to find it.
Indian says he went and could not find any? — I was not with him when he was in there, but I know that he has been in there.
Would the indications be gone by the 26th of April? — That was a week. It depends upon whether these stones had been much disturbed. There had been very few people on the top of the stones before that time. I did not examine for pick marks myself. I was thoroughly satisfied from the position in which the cracket and the pick were lying that most of the stones were lying on the west side and most of the small stones were worked off by the pick, but it was quite necessary in my mind, in fact I never thought about it.
Cross-examined by Mr. Heaviside.
Was McCabe's place considered a safe one? — Yes, the men came out at 5 o'clock at night.
But sometime previous to that? — Yes.
The roof of the bottom did not heave for any length of time did it? — Some of the east boards do heave a little, and some do not.
But every precaution was taken? — Yes.
What quantity of stone did you notice come from that crevice (pointing to the diagram)? — I crept in that night, and that was the only time I was really in the facing till we got it opened. Mr. Forster asked me to creep in and measure it, and when I measured it it was about 10 inches thick. Of course I did not go from one side of the place to the other, it may be from 2 to 10 inches thick.
Was there any amount of gas coming off? — Yes.
I am asking you with regard to the gas in Middlemas' and McCabe's place? — Yes.
Previous to the explosion was it considered quite free of gas? — Yes, the hewer had left it at 5 o'clock that night.
Two or three weeks before the explosion it was quite free from gas? — Yes.
In the South Crosscut, was that generally considered free from gas? — Yes.
Down the South Headways, was that generally considered free from gas also? — We had three reports of gas having been seen at this trouble here which is now good.
Then we have in Mossom's evidence and Middlemas' evidence that they had instructions from you to clear off the gas and not report it? — No, not from me.
(The Coroner.) This is what was said : "I said we knew we have to report, because Mr. Johnson made me report gas."
(Mr. Heavisidel.) About the end of December do you remember that George Arnold was working in the second west flat of the South Headways? — Yes.
Do you remember any report of gas lighting up there? — I never heard of it.
And that shortly after that Martin was working there at the end of December, and that the place lit up from a shot? — I never heard tell of it.
(The Coroner.) We will call it near Turner and Jobson's place.
(Mr. Heavisidel.) The place was lighted up, and there was a sort of flame of three yards, about the end of December last? — I know nothing about it. I never heard of it.
Do you consider that the most dangerous part of the mine? — No, I do not consider any one part more dangerous than the other.
You generally consider it free from gas? — Yes.
(Mr. Bowey.) I should like now to ask Middlemas a question.
(The Coroner.) With reference to what part of the evidence.
(Mr. Bowey.) He said that he never found gas there. The back overman, Thomas Coulson, and the fore overman, William Anderson, told me not to report gas ; that is two years since.
(The Coroner.) I will read exactly what took place. Beginning with your cross-examination, the witness says, "I do not report gas after I have cleared it away, because I think it is not necessary It is not because I could not get men to go down the pit afterwards. The back and fore overman said I had not to report it. Their names are Thomas Coulson and William Anderson, it is more than a month or two ago before that I never found any gas. I found gas twice, once I spoke of it to Mr. Johnson, the manager, and once to Anderson. The time I told Mr. Johnson I could not clear it away. I told him, and he came down the pit and examined it. I did not put it down in the book. It was about two years ago.
(Mr. Edge.) That was up in the north district.
(Mr. Bowey.) Do you recollect the fact of gas being reported to you, and not entered in the books
It was over four years ago when we were opening this pit out. These workings (pointing to the diagram) had been driven from the Lamp pit so far away. After the new pit was put down, these workings were being opened out, and when he travelled down to here, down below this trouble of the North Headways, through the trouble, that board being foul (pointing to the diagram), he found gas in there, and he was examining the place, the place was not working. He came and told me about it, and I went back with him.
Was it ever entered in his report book? — He was not a deputy then ; he was simply opening the pit out.
(Mr. Edge.) Was he a hewer? — He was a stoneworker.
(The Coroner.) How long is that since? — About four years ago this month. We were getting a small quantity of coal from the south side when we first commenced. When we first got the pit down we were exploring these workings here to get the road made, and get these places done. Four years the present month we were getting about two scores a day. These were old workings, and we were driving these headways south of the shaft. The north side was where the old workings had been, the south side was driven from a new pit, we were driving new coal.
You were driving from the old workings into coal? — The first coal that was worked was about four years ago, and that was in the South Crosscuts, this north coal down this east board had been worked from the Lamp pit before the Busty pit was sunk, and at the time this gas was seen down here (pointing to the diagram) was when we were opening this going board out, which had been driven some years before that.
And that is the gas which was referred to by Middlemas? — Yes.
(Mr. Bowey.) Was that ever reported in any book? — This was not a working seam at that time.
Did you enter it in any book? — No ; we were canvassing the place up and exploring the place.
(The Coroner.) And your reason for not entering it was because you were not working? — We were merely opening it out ; it was my first time in.
(Mr. Heavisidel.) What reason have you for calling this a non-fiery mine? — Because I have found it so free from gas.
But you have no reports of finding gas? — You find gas similar to what they find in mines which are entirely worked with candles. The date when the gas was found is marked upon the plan.
(The Coroner.) The dates are 23rd February 1882, and the 17th and 18th of March 1882? — Yes.
(Mr. Edge.) You said that you would find as much gas in mines where candles are used? — Yes, and more.
(Mr. Heavisidel.) In September last, was it reported to you that there was gas in the North Crosscut first Stenton-in-by-side? — No.
That was not reported to you by Mr. Anderson? — No.
You knew nothing about it? — No, not till I heard it here.
(Mr. Bowey.) Here, on the 21st of November, there is an entry, "Busty South Flat, Thomas Currey ; All right, except first headways ; South Flat off on account of gas"? — Yes ; this place (pointing to the diagram) was standing ; it was a spare kibble ; it was standing at this trouble, the gas was at this trouble.
It was "off on account of gas"? — No, it was a spare place ; if he reported the gas as there (pointing to the diagram) he would see it every day ; and he would report it every day, if he saw it every day.
What is the meaning of that entry, "Off on account of gas"? — That the gas is there.
And that the men are off on account of gas? — There were no men in there.
But what do you understand this "off on account of gas" to mean? — I knew there were no men working in there. There was gas to be seen in there, and had been seen.
You say it does not mean that the men are off on account of the gas? — I never said that.
Do you say that that was so, or that it was not ; does it mean that the men are not working there on account of the gas? — No, it does not.
Then what does it mean? — It means that there is gas there on that day.
What does the term "off on account of gas" entered in this book mean? — It means that the place is off on account of gas, just as it says.
On the next day, the 22nd November, there is again an entry, "off on account of gas;" and on the 23rd November, "Busty South, T. J. Coulson, all right except a little gas in the first headway south;" and then "Busty South Flats, Thomas Currey, all right except a little gas in the first headways south." Then on the 24th November, "Thomas J. Coulson, Busty North flat all right, but South flat off on account of gas"? — Yes.
(The Coroner.) Those entries go from the 21st to the 24th November.
(Mr. Bowey.) Yes, the 21st, 22nd, 23rd, and 24th.
(The Coroner.) It is a continuation of the same report? — Yes.
(Mr. Bowey.) I see here, "South flat off on account of gas," those are four entries on four days in November, and then we have some in February ; and still you say that this is not a fiery mine? — Yes.
Did you ever hear of gas being found in the South Headways about the end of December? — Which South Headways? — These South Crosscuts here (pointing to the diagram).
The second west flat in the South Headways at the end of December ; had you ever any reports from Turner? — Turner was never deputy in there.
Who was deputy at the end of December? — I expect Currey, Currey and Knocks.
At the end of December, I mean, who was deputy over Arnold? — Currey and Knocks would be if they were at their own work.
But you did not know of that? — No. This trouble (pointing to the diagram) is the only place that I know of gas having been seen, and we kept it as a spare place ; it did not matter whether it was working or not. If gas was in it, the deputy reported it, but if not he could not report it.
Did you hear from Mossom, one of the deputies, about 14 weeks ago about a shot being fired in the east-going board, not far from where Middlemas and McCabe were found, and the gas lighting up the place, and setting light to the canvas? — Not at the time. I have a week or two ago, and I sent for them, and they denied any gas being there at all. I sent for both the overman and Mossom, and they said it was a damp shot that set light to the gas.
Have you read the general rules in the Act? — Yes.
And you know the sixth rule, which says that "Every such report," that is to say, where any part of the mine has been closed on account of gas, "shall be recorded in a book which shall be kept at the mine for the purpose, and shall be signed by the person making the same"? — Yes, we have had no places closed for gas.
Do not those reports refer to places off on account of gas? — No ; they were spare places, the men were never taken into them.
Was not the meaning of the reports in that book this ; that the portions referred to in the reports were portions of the mine in which the men were not allowed to go on account of there being gas there, have you made a special report of those places being closed on account of gas? — I have made no further report. When the overman went in and examined them the places were clear. The deputy the first thing in the morning found the gas, and when the overman went in it was clear, and from the overman's report there was no gas seen in his time.
On the 21st November 1881 the report is "All right, except first headways in south flat, off on account of gas" ; does not that mean that that portion of the first headways in the south flat is closed and the workmen not allowed to go there because gas has been found there? — Yes ; but that was an hour before the workmen came to work, and then the overman comes in, and he finds it clear, and being a spare place they do not set the men there, if the overman comes and reports it clear when he sees it, and the overman is my next man.
Does not this report by the deputy that he has found a place with gas in it, and it is closed on account of gas being there, mean that it is dangerous? — But he did not send the men in there that day.
But is not that the effect of his report? — Yes.
Have you got a book in which that report appears, under the sixth general rule? — No ; because the overman's report for the same day says that he found everything right.
Have you got such a book at all in which you make such reports? — Yes.
You have an official book under the sixth rule, but you have no entry in that book at all, neither on those dates, nor on any other dates? — No.
You consider that this report, having been made by the deputy of gas being found and a portion of the mine being closed on account of the gas, does not come within the sixth rule and ought not to be entered in an official book? — The overman reported to me that the place was all right.
Why does not this report in the book come under the sixth rule, and be one which should be reported in the official book kept by you? — It would not, because the overman said in his report that the place was quite clear.
Is there anything in the sixth rule which says that when the overman has gone and removed the gas and made the place clear, that then it shall not be entered in this book? — No, there is not.
If the overman had not come and reported that the gas had been removed and the place was clear, you would have entered it in this book? — Yes, if the overman had reported it I would have entered it in the book.
Now, with regard to the mine being a fiery mine, you say it had not been considered and you have not considered it a fiery mine up to the present time? — Yes.
Then how was it that you were using the rules which were applicable to fiery mines? — These rules were in force when I came into the colliery.
Have they not been in force in the colliery because it was considered a fiery mine? — I should think not.
Why have the rules only applicable to fiery mines been in force at this colliery? — At some mines where they work with candles these rules are adopted.
But candles were not adopted in this mine? — There was no stipulation that either candles or lamps should be used in the Busty.
As a matter of fact were candles used in the Busty? — They have never been used.
Are there not rules in force with regard to locking the lamps? — No. Mr. Bell and I have had that matter talked over and over again.
Where lamps are used they are obliged to be locked under the Act of Parliament, are they not? — Yes.
(Mr. Edge.) There are other seams in the Lamp pit besides this one.
(Mr. Morley.) Is not there a rule in this book which prevents candles or lanterns or naked lights being used anywhere in-by of the caution board? — Yes.
Is not that a rule enforcing the use of locks with reference to lamps? — Yes.
Could you say in the face of that that this seam was being worked as a non-fiery mine? — It never was worked as a non-fiery mine, that is, it has been worked under these rules. But Mr. Bell ask me did I propose to work it with candles or lamps, and I have said that owing to the troubles in the pit had commenced with lamps and we would keep on with lamps.
Do you consider that you could have used candles in this mine? — One of our eminent engineers considered that the seam ought to be worked with candles.
Do you consider that you could have used candles with these rules in force in the mine ; do not these rules prohibit the use of candles? — Yes, north of the caution boards ; but if you have candles in the working faces you have no caution boards.
Who was the engineer you spoke of just now? — Mr. Berkley.
Were not the inspections by the deputies made under the second general rule which requires an inspection every 12 hours? — Yes.
And was not that inspection carried out as if the mine was a fiery mine? — It is carried out in every colliery where there are two shifts of men.
But by the second general rule in the Act of Parliament, if it is a non-fiery mine only one inspection in 24 hours is necessary? — Yes, but there are two made for all that.
You say that in non-fiery mines the custom is to have two inspections although two are not necessary? — Yes.
Is the second inspection reported? — Yes, both by the back shift and the fore shift.
With regard to this overman's book, that is the book in which the overmen make their reports? — Yes.
Is not this a book which is drawn up under the third general rule in the Act of Parliament? — Yes.
Does that third general rule in the Act of Parliament apply to the reports made by the deputies in their examination? — Yes, the third general rule is applicable to non-fiery mines.
But I am speaking of the reports made by the deputies who examine before the shift enter the mine? — I could not speak from memory upon that.
With regard to the third sub-section of rule 76, at the foot of page 17, will you tell me whether the second and third general rules in the Act of Parliament do not apply to the inspection and the reports of the deputies who are to examine before the shift go in to work? — Yes, they apply to the inspection by the deputies.
And not to the examinations made by the overmen and reported by them? — I could not speak from memory on these things.
But you have got the two rules before you, and you must have read these rules carefully over? — Yes ; but although I have read them over many times I have not them in my mind at the present time.
(Mr. Edge.) Why should not an overman be included under the head of "competent person or persons for the purpose"?
(Mr. Morley.) But the inspection is to be made before the shift go into work. (To the witness.) The overman goes down at different times during the day, does he not, as a rule? — They go down the fore shift working.
Take the 21st of January this year, here is a report made by Mark Cowan at 10 o'clock in the morning? — That is when he comes out of the pit.
Here is Anderson the overman's report at 8 o'clock in the morning? — That is when he came out of the pit that day.
Would those two inspections have been made at the same time? — He has to come out of the pit at 10 o'clock when he enters it in there.
When would these two men have gone down? — Anderson would have gone down at 3 o'clock in the morning, and probably the other at 4 o'clock.
Cowan's inspection would not have been an inspection before the shift went down ; it would have been at the same time, would it not? — His man goes down later than the other one ; there is half-an-hour difference ; there is another seam in another pit.
Do the overmen make the investigations as a matter of fact before the shifts go into work? — Yes ; they cannot examine the whole of the pit, but they go down and commence to inspect as soon as they go down.
If they had not finished their examination would the shift go in? — No.
Therefore their examination is not an examination, not under the second and third general rules? — The deputy overmen do that.
The overman's examination is not an examination which is to precede the shift going into work? — No.
Is not this report book made up from the deputy's report under the second and third rules before the shift go in to work. Just read the heading of the rules (handing a book to the witness.) Is not that report to be made under No. 3 general rule by the deputy before the shift go in to work? — Yes.
Is that the proper book for the overmen to enter their reports in? — Yes.
(Mr. Bell.) Does the overman examine the working places and the roadways before the workmen go in to work? — Yes, he examines all the roadways before the workmen go in to work.
(Mr. Edge.) There is nothing there to show that he is to enter his report in the book before the workmen go to work. It says, "a workman shall not go to work in such part until the same and the roadways leading thereto are stated to be safe."
(Mr. Morley.) But the deputy has to make his investigation before the men go in to work, the overman has not. This is a book drawn up under the third rule which is not applicable to the overman's report ; it is a deputy's book and not an overman's book at all.
(Mr. Bell.) The overman's report, you will observe, is under the 17th special rule.
(Mr. Morley, to the witness.) Is this the only book you have got? — Yes.
Where does the overman make his report with regard to the barometer? — In the office.
In what book? — In the office.
But in what book does he enter the report? — It is not in a book ; it is upon a large square almanack dated, it is registered on that.
Can we see that? — Yes, you shall have it. (All the different classes of report book, barometer readings, special rules, and Acts of Parliament since the 1st of January were ordered to be produced.)
(Mr. Morley.) Is there a book for the master wasteman's report? — No, the overman does that.
He acts in both capacities? — Yes.
Do I understand that there is no report book with reports of the men in it under the 30th rule? — There is no proper book kept for it, they simply sign the overman's pocket book.
You have read the 30th rule with regard to the book, I presume? — Yes, but I know that the men generally speaking have a dislike to that kind of thing.
You know that the 30th general rule is in these terms, "and shall make a true report of the result of such inspection, and such report shall be recorded in a book to be kept at the mine for the purpose, and shall be signed by the persons who made the same"? — Yes.
You have no such book at all? — No, the men have a very great objection to it, and I have not enforced it ; in fact, in many cases they do not make any examination.
When the deputies were appointed, you say that they were authorised to carry keys? — Yes.
And to fire shots? — Yes, where shots were allowed to be fired.
Is that in accordance with the special rules? — Yes.
What do you mean by "Where shots are allowed to be fired"? — In some seams you do not fire shots at all, and if anything came across that wanted a shot to be fired the deputy would not dare fire the shot unless he consulted me first about it.
That is the instruction given to him? — Yes.
Do you remember Mossom being appointed a deputy? — Mossom had charge in the sinking pit when I came here, and I think he had been at that sort of thing before I came here ; he had been deputy shiftman, and he was in the pit when I came here, and I saw no reason why he should be changed.
Did you hear what he said, that he had never had the rules read over to him? — Yes, I heard him say that.
But you say that he was there before you came as manager? — Yes.
Have there been other signs of gas besides these reports that have been made to you ; have you ever heard of this singing and bubbling of gas and water? — I have found singing in nearly all seams that I have gone into ; it is very seldom that you find a seam in which there has not been that in it.
Have you heard it in the South Crosscuts? — No, I do not think I have ; but I have heard it in various districts in all seams that I have been in either north or south.
What sort of lamps were used? — Clanney lamps only.
Had none of the men besides the deputies keys? — No.
Was Douglass a deputy? — He was shooting stone there in the night shift.
He was not a master shiftsman? — No, he was appointed to fire shots.
(The Coroner.) And therefore would require to have his lamp open? — Yes.
(Mr. Morley.) Of those four lamps that were found in the South Crosscuts two were unlocked, how do you account for that? — The man had evidently opened the lamp and had not locked it, it was lack of duty not locking it as soon as he was down ; he might have been at the out-by side of the caution board relighting it, but it was only supposition.
(The Coroner.) Westgarth's lamp ought not to have been unlocked? — No, but if Westgarth's light had been out, and Douglass had brought his lamp by the out-by side of the caution board, he might have brought it there to relight it.
(Mr. Morley.) Do not you think that if you had kept a list of the men who were authorised to have keys it would have been a very desirable thing to do? — But there are so few of them, and I know them all so thoroughly well, that I did not think it necessary.
What number of men have you in the pit altogether? — We have not over 100 colliers altogether.
In the various seams? — Yes.
Have you been making some alterations with the lamps with regard to the washer? — No, these lamps were used with washers when I came here.
Were they sent from the manufacturers in such a condition that they would not screw up? — I have never known the makers send them out without washers.
(The Coroner.) Did you know anything about these lamps until you came to the colliery ; had you seen them before you came to the colliery? — No, I had never seen these lamps.
You say that they had been in use before you came? — Yes.
Have you any personal knowledge of what condition they were in when they came from the makers? — No, but I have seen them, dozens, come from the makers, and come without washers.
(Mr. Bell.) Have you had any new lamps since you came here? — Yes, three or four dozen.
Did they screw close up? — Yes, without a washer.
In ordering lamps, do you specify whether they are to have washers or not? — All these new lamps that I am referring to were in stock when I came here ; and Mr. Burn after some trouble that they had had in Wales would have the Museler introduced for protection as an extra precaution, but the men eventually objected to them, they gave a preference to the Clanney lamps.
(The Coroner.) Since then, they have used nothing but the Clanney lamp, which was already in use in the colliery when you came, the old lamp? — Yes.
(Mr. Bell.) You say that you fire the shots by taking off the lamp top? — Yes.
Is not that a violation of the second deputies' rule? — It would be a violation if anybody was doing it but the deputy.
But the deputy is instructed to carry out the instructions of the overman and back overman, and allow "no naked lights or unlocked safety lamps to be carried past a 'caution' board on any pretext whatever, and carefully examine and securely lock every workman's safety lamp before allowing him to proceed beyond the caution board"? — Yes.
Under "any pretext whatever"? — Yes.
Is not it a violation of that law having a lamp unlocked at the face of a board? — I think not. How would you prefer that shot being fired.
(Mr. Bell.) I am not at present under examination.
(The Coroner.) Does not this rule mean carrying an unlocked safety lamp past the caution board ; it says "and allow no naked lights or unlocked safety lamps to be carried past a 'caution' board on any pretext whatever;" it is an unlocked lamp carried past the caution board? — It is locked when it goes past, and I think Mr. Bell will agree with me that a man dare not take his lamp to fire a shot where a shot should not be fired.
(Mr. Bell.) The only thing I want you now to explain is Mr. Greenwell's position. Who is Mr. Greenwell? — He is the late President of the Mining Institution of Newcastle.
And he is consulting viewer here? — Yes.
He would be in some measures responsible for the mode of laying out this mine, would he not? — Yes, everything is talked over between us.
Is Mr. Greenwell here? — He has been here twice.
(Mr. Edge.) I can call my client, who has been to see him during the last two or three days. Mr. Greenwell is now suffering from gout, and he is unable to be present.
(Mr. Johnson.) He is lying at Newcastle ill.
(Mr. Bell.) I thought it was right to ask if Mr. Greenwell took all the responsibility in the general laying out of the mine? — Yes.
Was he perfectly conversant with the mode of ventilation of the mine? — Yes.
Did he approve of this shot firing and of single doors? — These single doors are doubled by a canvas door.
Not all of them, are they? — Yes ; I would not have carried out anything that he had not approved of ; it is not likely.
Could you give us the extent of the workings opened out, or the area of the workings opened out ; all the area of coal worked? — I think there are about 70 acres covered there (pointing to the diagram).
Taking it on this side of the trouble it would be about 70 acres? — Yes.
Part of it is worked from the whole, and part whole and broken? — Yes.
You think that the area altogether would be about 70 acres opened out? — Yes.
(The Coroner.) Do you mean that the royalty covers 70 acres?
(Mr. Bell.) That is worked out now.
(Mr. Morley.) Does that include the unworked coal shown upon the plan? — It includes the worked coal and the broken coal. That is a complete plan of the Busty workings.
You are driving a drift up in to the Tilly seam, are you not? — Yes.
Is that the Tilly seam (pointing to the diagram)? — I have never been into it.
You pass through it in the shaft, do you not? — Yes.
Has there been gas there? — Not to my knowledge.
You were not here when the shafts were sunk? — No ; there was no gas came off of it, because the other shaft was down through it years before that, and if there had been anything that would have tapped it.
Do those two shafts act simply for the Busty seam (pointing to the diagram)? — No, those two shafts act for the whole colliery.
Is the up-cast shaft used for drawing coal from the other seams? — Yes, from the lower main and Shield row ; and the down-cast draws from the Busty and the Hutton seam. The up-cast shaft is from the low main and the Shield row, and the down-cast for the Busty and Hutton.
Do you call this Busty seam a dry or a wet seam? — It is a dry seam.
Do you find much dust in it? — The coal is of a very dusty nature to begin with ; it is a tender coal, and if we had called it "dusty" instead of Busty it would have been more applicable.
It would be very freely scattered about everywhere? — Yes.
Have you read any paper of Professor Abel's on the inflammable nature of coal dust and its explosive character? — I have simply glanced it through.
I see recently he has been delivering an address on the 28th of April, at the Royal Institution of Great Britain ; have you seen anything about that? — No.
The previous papers that you read about coal dust, and which have been communicated from him probably, did they refer to the dangerous nature of coal dust? — Yes.
Did you meet in the previous paper that you read anything to this effect, "It must now be accepted as beyond question that very few, if any, explosions have occurred of which the destructive effects, so far as burning and production of the fatal afterdamp are concerned, have not been more or less considerably increased through the agency of the coal dust raised by the explosion, and that the latter has been in very many cases instrumental in causing the burning effects of the explosion to spread over great areas and to reach to workings which, in the absence of dust, would have escaped the visitation." As far as your judgement leads you to form an opinion do you concur in Professor Abel's view? — I think in an explosion coal dust is a very great agent.
You fully bear out what he says? — Yes.
Then, further on, he says that, "In many instances the occurrence of such outbursts following upon falls of roofs or the firing of shots, or the rapid disengagement of fire-damp from coal or goaves consequent upon sudden changes in atmospheric pressure have been clearly proved to have preceded disastrous explosions ; in others however, the conclusion that an explosion has been connected with the occurrence of a sudden disengagement of gas in considerable volume has been based upon assumptions or conjectures more or less admissible, or upon evidence of doubtful nature collected after the explosion (as in the case of the recent explosion at Seaham Collieries). Under any such circumstances, however, it is, to say the least, extremely difficult to realise how sufficient gas to produce an explosive atmosphere can be conveyed, even by the most powerful ventilation currents which can circulate in mines, from the seat of such a sudden outburst to far distant portions of the mine, to which the actual explosion is proved to have extended within the period which is known or believed to have intervened between the first disengagement of the gas and the firing of the explosive atmosphere produced thereby in the vicinity of the outburst by the firing of a shot, by a defective lamp, or by other means of ignition." Then he says "On the other hand, the character of the effects which in many instances have been produced by the explosion, the evidences of severe burning such as could not be produced by the rapid explosion of a gas mixture only, and the deposition of partially burnt coal or coke dust in very distant and distinct parts of the mine workings, leave no room for doubt that coal dust has played a more or less important part in almost all the explosions which have been of late submitted to investigation. Further, it must be conceded that in some instances coal dust would indeed appear to have been the chief instrument of destruction." Do you agree with that? — Yes, I have no doubt about it.
Then you agree with it? — Yes.
Can you suggest any method by which in a dry, dusty seam, such as, for instance, the Busty, which is very extensively worked in this locality, it can be rendered safer by preventing the accumulation of dust ; could it be treated in some way or other to render it less harmful in the event of an explosion taking place? — We try watering the ways, and there have been various modes suggested such, for instance, as sending steam down pits, and having water drops here and there.
Have you tried any of those things? — No. I am only speaking of various things that have been suggested.
But have you adopted anything of the kind? — We have watered the ways, that is all.
But still that does not affect the dust that may be deposited either on the walls or the pillar sides, or on the various parts of the timbering? — No.
Now, with regard to the use of gunpowder, do you or do you not admit that that is to a great extent a dangerous mode of getting coal ; for blasting coal? — If I have coal to get, I prefer to work at the coal, if you can do it, without it.
But have you heard of any plans such as this for instance, "Another method of getting coal, which, though not new in itself has been applied in a novel manner and with most promising results by Messrs. Smith and Moore, has the great advantage of dispensing entirely with the use of explosive agents and of any but the most simple mechanical appliances. It consists in applying the force of quick lime will develop if confined and made to combine under that condition with water, whereby it undergoes very considerable expansion, a large amount of heat being at the same time developed. Messrs. Smith and Moore convert the freshly burnt and crushed quicklime into very compact cylindrical masses or cartridges having a small groove on one side, so that when the requisite number of cylinders are inserted symmetrically into the mechanically drilled hole in the coal which they fit accurately, a narrow pipe with perforations along its entire length enclosed in a tight fitting stocking of open webbing and provided with a stop-cock may be inserted into the side of the charge, which is afterwards tamped in the usual manner. The proportion of water necessary to slake the lime, plus an excess of about one sixth, is then forced into the hole through the pipe by means of a simple hand syringe, and the stop-cock of the pipe being closed the operation is complete." Have you read that method of getting coal? — I have seen the account.
Have you seen it tried? — No ; but I have seen an account of it.
Here is the result which he gives : "In a brief space of time sounds, indicative of the cracking of the mass of coal which contains the cartridge show that the expansion of the lime by its union with the water, and the very considerable development of steam within the cartridges are performing their work, and after an interval of time varying with the strength of the part of the seam operated upon, the coal is detached in large blocks. The holes can be charged so rapidly that a considerable number may be put into operation in quick succession by one or two men. As the action of the charge occupies some little time (15 or 20 minutes). they really come into operation together, and in this way large faces of hard coal in long wall workings are brought down with ease and certainty. Whether these compressed lime cartridges can be applied with any success in stone still remains to be determined ; but in point of cost, simplicity, and, above all, safety, this method of detaching coal appears to rank before any other yet tried. Besides entirely avoiding the use and production of flame or fire in the blasting of the coal, the operation is conducted gradually and almost noiselessly, and the raising of dust by the more or less violent concussions which attend the employment of explosives in any form or manner is avoided. It is insisted upon by a great majority of those most competent to judge that the employment of explosives cannot be dispensed with in the profitable working of coal mines. That the use of gunpowder in the ordinary way, even with strict attention to all practicable precautions, is a most prolific source of accident has long been recognised. The development of safe methods of applying explosive agents or of simply effective substitutes for them is therefore of such paramount importance in securing protection to the miner against the dangers of fire-damp and of coal dust, that those who are entrusted with the management of coal mines should spare no exertions to test vigorously but fairly, the merits of any proposals which afford promise of success in this direction." Do you think, after hearing that, that it could be applied to the Busty seam. Of course it is too late to prevent what has already happened ; but, in order to avoid anything like this occurring again, do you think it would be attended with great expense or a great deal of trouble to see whether such a method would answer? — We are making experiments to try it, just as we can manage it ourselves, with lime.
You are adopting the same principle, are you? — Yes.
You are going to put it into operation? — Yes. Instead of having the water set in the tap, we have got some very thin tin, so as just to have this tin to fit the hole and have it filled with water, with something very slender at the in-by end ; they drive this plug in for stemming, and that forces the water upon the lime.
Hunter was the master shifter? — Yes.
Was he a competent man and a careful man? — Yes, a very careful man.
We have heard from one of the men who were saved up in this North Headway that he was a careful man, and examined the lamps? — Yes.
Was Douglass a careful man? — Yes, a very careful man.
Did you ever appoint a deputy, or keep a man acting as a deputy, unless you were satisfied the he was a careful and a proper man? — Not at all.