1882 West Stanley Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
West Stanley Inquest, Third Day, Saturday, 27th May, 1882 (cont.).
The names of the jury were called over, and all answered their names.
Mr. William Henry Hedley sworn, examined by Mr. Edge.
You are a viewer of the Consett Collieries? — Yes.
How many years experience have you had in mining matters? — Nearly 27 years now.
Did you go on the afternoon of the explosion with Mr. Baker Forster down the pit? — Yes, and Mr. Berkley and Mr. Johnson and others accompanied us.
Did you accompany Mr. Baker Forster in the inspection which he told us yesterday he made on that afternoon? — Yes.
Have you been in other parts of the pit as well as the South Crosscut district and the North Crosscuts? — No, only to the north side of the pit.
That is the North Headway? — Yes, not in the South Headways.
Did you look for indications when you were down? — Yes.
Did you come to a conclusion in your judgment with reference to where the site of the explosion was, and the cause of it? — Yes, I did. I came to the conclusion that the site of the explosion was at the face of the east-going board ; McCabe's and Middlemas' place.
Then I take it from that, that in your judgment the explosion did not take place in the South Crosscut district? — I do not think so.
You heard Mr. Baker Forster give his evidence yesterday? — Yes.
Do you agree in the view he expressed? — Yes, I agree fully in all that Mr. Baker Forster stated with reference to the facts observed, and in his opinion also with regard to the seat and cause of the explosion.
With regard to this place here (pointing to the diagram), McCabe's place, did you notice the props there? — Yes, I noticed them carefully in that place.
What did you see? — All that I noticed were charred very markedly on the in-by side.
Just tell me, are you speaking of McCabe's place? — I am speaking of the holing nearest the face, up towards the face.
Is this what you call a holing (pointing to the diagram)? — Yes, from the last headways, up to the face. The sides of the props were very much charred. On the in-by side I noticed that the brattice was blown back over from the face for several yards, and the end of it twisted round the prop, about two yards of it.
Did you notice a stow tub? — Yes, I noticed a stow tub near the face, four yards from the face, and also a coal tub.
Did you notice anything on the stow tub? — Both the stow tub and the coal tub were charred on the in-by side.
Did you notice the indications in the crosscut district ; did the charring there present any peculiar appearance to your mind? — In the Fore Crosscut there was some charring on both sides of the props, but mainly on the north side, the out-by side much more markedly. I also noticed that some of the faces of the coal were charred on that same side.
Did you notice the brattice that was in here (pointing to the diagram) in the Fore Crosscut headway? — Yes, I noticed that it was standing, but very much burnt, very much charred.
It had not been blown out-over? — It was just remaining in the position that it had been originally fixed.
Generally you endorse what Mr. Baker Forster said yesterday? — Yes, I do, fully, so far as the examination of that part of the pit is concerned, and as to his conclusion with reference to the cause of the explosion, I quite agree with him.
Cross-examined by Mr. Bowey.
You have had 27 years experience of mining? — Very nearly.
What experience have you had of fire in mines? — Not very much.
How much? — In recent years I cannot say that I have had any.
In former years, what experience had you of fire in mines? — Some five or six years I was connected to some extent with mines which contained gas, about 16 years back I had the control of a colliery where there was some gas in it, worked with lamps.
Which colliery was that? — Bowden Close Colliery.
How long had you the management of that colliery? — Only about a year.
What other colliery which may be called a fiery mine have you had experience of? — The Rainton Collieries.
What charge had you over those? — I had no special charge excepting some special work that was going on in connexion with some dams putting in there.
What was the length of your experience in those collieries? — About three years.
What was your principal work there? — I was principally going down for the sake of getting experience, and also for about six months I had charge of putting in some dams at Pittington. They are all one concern.
Was Bowden Close Colliery worked with candles and lamps? — Partially candles and partially lamps, chiefly candles.
I may take it that this one here at Bowden Close Colliery and three years at the Rainton Collieries were in the early part of your life? — Yes.
And since that you have had 27 years experience altogether. For about 20 years past you have had no experience whatever with regard to fire in mines? — Practically not.
You went down with Mr. Baker Forster? — Yes.
You have talked over the matter with him? — Yes.
And you have agreed to concur in his theory? — I have agreed with him from my own observation of what I saw in the mine principally.
You talked the matter over and you have come to a conclusion and you endorse all that he has said? — Yes.
Cross-examined by Mr. Heaviside.
With regard to the south Fore Crosscut, were the indications entirely in-over? — I think not ; some of the props were charred slightly on the in-by side, but much more markedly on the out-by side, all that I observed, the charring was deeper on the north side.
Take the first pillar ; was there any difference in that? — All the props I noticed were charred more on the out-by side than the in-by side.
Did you travel south of where Middlemas and McCabe were found? — No, I did not.
Did you travel north from McCabe's place? — No.
You just went down into McCabe's place? — Yes, just down into McCabe's place and saw the headways end of the tubs.
What other part did you go into? — Into the South Crosscut.
Did you go through into the Back Crosscut? — Yes, just into the face.
Did you travel this way through from the south back into this return? — No.
How far did you come to this back headway? — The innermost Stenton.
Did you go into the east board? — I went down two of the east boards so far.
You only made a very casual examination of the mine? — Yes, only one examination.
Do you think you made such an examination as to enable you to speak with any degree of confidence with reference to the direction and cause of the explosion? — I think that the indications in the face of the east board and in the South Crosscut are, at any rate to my mind, very conclusive that the explosion occurred in the east boards. I judge from the evidences of the burning I saw. I do not myself attach very much importance to the way in which the force of the explosion showed itself.
Is not that a very important thing? — I think it might be variable ; it might be very erratic, the way in which the force would show itself.
But taking the force generally, was the examination such as to enable you to say that it came from that point, and that other large area beyond that north, and the other large area west, and the places both east and west of the two crosscuts? — I have heard the evidence of the other witnesses with reference to their examination of the districts you refer to, and I am assisted in my conclusion by hearing that evidence.
I gather that you pay more attention to the burning than to the force? — Yes.
With regard to the indications the other way, you take it from Mr. Baker Forster's point of view? — Yes.
After hearing Mr. Baker Forster's evidence? — Yes.
But not having seen them you cannot speak confidently with regard to the indications? — No.
Did you notice the Back Crosscut here (pointing to the diagram), the back South Crosscut? — To some extent I did.
Did you see any indications of a shot having been fired there? — Yes, I saw there were stones lying and a cracket on the top of them.
Was that stone the result of a shot? — I thought so.
Did you see any signs of a shot hole or anything like that? — No, I did not.
Might it not be a fall? — It is possible.
Did you not see the remains of a shot hole? — No, I cannot say that I did ; I do not remember to have seen it.
Your evidence is so superficial that I think it is scarcely worth while going more into detail, but I will just ask you this, If you take the burning in preference to the force, how do you account for the burning down here in the South Headways? — I take it that the explosion has extended in that direction, and the burning has gone in over from there.
Might it not be as easily or more easily extended to that part ; that part of the pit is nearer than this (pointing to the diagram)? — I think the evidence, taking the west rolley way of the force of the explosion, is very clear with regard to its having gone out-over. It is quite clear to my mind that that had been the direction of the explosion from the west way into the south and north of the shaft.
You are speaking of force down here when you do not admit it? — I think the evidence there of force is perhaps more to be relied upon than in any other part of the pit. There you may rely upon it to a great extent. The way in which the baulks at the top were first of all driven in and then have since been driven out was to my mind conclusive that the force that had driven it out came from the west.
When was it that you examined this back South Crosscut? — On the evening of the explosion.
Had people been in before you were there? — Yes, Mr. Davison, Mr. Johnson, and Mr. Atkinson had been all in before that, I understood.
Had there been an exploring party down there before you went in? — Yes, that party consisting of Mr. Davison and Mr. Johnson, and Mr. Atkinson, I think was also with them.
When you were there the brattice, I suppose, had been put up? — Yes.
So that you really cannot speak with regard to the appearance of the back South Crosscut as it appeared immediately after the explosion? — No, I cannot.
Had you ever been examining a pit after an explosion before that? — No.
This was the first explosion you ever investigated? — Yes.
Admitting the signs of burning are more indicative of where the occurrence took place than the signs of force, could you come to a conclusion without seeing other signs of burning that we know existed in another part of the colliery? — Of course I have heard the evidence with regard to the signs of burning, it being in-over as well as the force being in-over, and that has helped me to my conclusion.
Further examined by Mr. Bowey.
How long have you held this opinion? — From the first night.
From the first night you were in the pit? — Yes.
Do you mean that you formed your opinion without having examined those other parts of the pit. You had not gone north and south of Middlemas and McCabe's place? — No.
And still you formed an opinion on the very evening of the explosion? — Yes, I did.
And you formed that opinion principally upon the burning in preference to the force? — Yes.
You also chose this east-going board as the place, although there was burning in the South Crosscut, and although there was burning down in this district here (pointing to the diagram) Yes, the burning in the South Crosscut that I saw in-over was from the north towards the south.
But you were not down the Back Crosscut? — No.
And you formed an opinion on the very evening of the explosion? — Yes.
Without going either north or south of Middlemas and McCabe's place? — Yes.
Or hearing anyone's opinion? — Yes, and my opinion has been confirmed by all I have heard since
That is to say, that you formed an opinion or theory, and having heard other people say since that they were of the same opinion you are confirmed in yours? — Yes.
But your theory was formed without an examination? — It was formed after an examination of those places.
But without an examination of either north or south of Middlemas and McCabe's place to see which way the blast had gone? — Yes.
And without any practical knowledge of an explosion ; you had never been down a colliery before where there had been an explosion? — No, but it is a matter of common sense and common observation.
And it is 20 years since you have had experience of a fiery mine? — Yes. Any one of the jury would be competent to tell which side of a prop was affected.
But you did not look to see which side of the prop was affected north and south of McCabe's place? — No ; I did in the place itself.
But you did not travel north and south? — No.
You formed your opinion without knowing that? — Yes.
(Mr. Oliver, foreman.) Did you observe the brattice still standing in that South Crosscut? — Yes, in the Fore Crosscut.
Do you think it was likely for the explosion to go in-over and leave the brattice still there? — I think it had been a very quiet effect of the burning in there. I think the force of the explosion had gone mainly down the rolley way board from the shaft, and there had been simply a quiet action that had gone in-over into the face of the South Crosscut.
(Mr. Bates, a juryman.) Would it be possible for the fire to go into that front crosscut and not light that touch that was charged in the front crosscut and fire that shot off? — It seems rather curious, but it has been so evidently ; there has been fire and yet the straw has not been lighted.
Would it be possible to see that as well? — Yes, because it has happened.
A touch would take hold a deal quicker than the brattice, would it not? — (No answer.)
Your theory is that the stopping is in where you think the explosion came through ; did you see the stopping in the innermost holing in the South Crosscut? — No, it was open the innermost holing between the two Crosscuts.
As I understand, you examined this district here, McCabe's district, and you found that these props in-by of that innermost headway's going into the face, were charred at the in-by side? — Yes, very decidedly so.
And there were two tubs there, and you found them also charred? — Yes.
That is a matter if you had not been down a fiery mine you could see for yourself? — Yes, any one of the jury could judge of that for himself.
And I suppose the same thing could have been seen here in the props in the Fore Crosscut? — Yes.