1882 West Stanley Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
West Stanley Inquest, Third Day, Saturday, 27th May, 1882 (cont.).
Mr. Charles Davison, examined by Mr. Edge.
You are a viewer at Cornsay Colliery? — Yes.
Did you form one of the exploring party on the afternoon of the explosion? — Yes.
Did you and Mr. Johnson and Middlemas and some others work your way into the South Crosscut district? — Yes.
You went through the innermost Stenton into the Back Crosscut, did you? — Yes.
What took place after you got in there ; what were you and Mr. Middlemas and Mr. Johnson doing? — After coming up this Stenton we found the brattice down here (pointing to the diagram) ; it had been blown down, and likewise, into the face of the crossing, and Middlemas and myself commenced and erected this brattice, and put it into this position (describing).
How was the brattice blown down? — This was blown round this way and blown into this way (describing) ; there was no brattice in the centre, this was blown down and this was blown into the way, it was loosened from the top.
The brattice opposite the Stenton was blown down? — Yes, it was all blown west.
What did you and Middlemas commence to do? — We commenced to put up the brattice again.
Who was the first person into the face of the South Crosscut? — I was the first person myself.
What did you see when you got into the face? — I went forward towards the face and left Middlemas back at the brattice end, and I found the place was standing at a trouble stoneface instead of coal, and I walked up onto the stones with a lamp to examine it, and I saw a cracket and a pick, and I concluded that a man had been working there.
Where were the pick and cracket when you saw them? — On the top of the stones.
That had come down? — Yes.
What happened then? — I examined the place and I found there was a little gas at the top, and I kept the other parties back until the gas was cleared out and the air got circulated round the brattice ; and after that Mr. Johnson and Mr. Atkinson came in and the others.
I need hardly ask you, you did not put that pick or cracket on the stones? — Oh, no.
There is no doubt that you were the first person there, and when you went in the pick and cracket were on the stones? — Quite so.
Did you subsequently go into where McCabe had been working? — Yes, after that brattice was got we made our way to where McCabe was working, and I got into that part, in fact, I was the first to get to McCabe and the other ; I was the first to go into the east board.
You were one of the exploring party that went intothe east-going board? — Yes.
We have heard of two tubs, or a tub and a kibble that were in there ; where were they standing? — The tub was standing here (pointing to the diagram) at the innermost Stenton. It was a coal tub.
Where were Middlemas and McCabe? — They were behind the tub.
They were lying behind the tub were they? — Yes, both of them.
In-by of that what did you find? — Nearly into the face about 10 yards back there was a stow tub and the tram, that is the kibble or stow tub.
Then further on, did you notice anything? — Yes, I went into the face and found a fall. I found a lamp just behind the kibble, one of the lamps, and I went to the face to search for the other, and we found the other lamp underneath the stones.
Did you form any idea with regard to where the explosion originated and how it had gone? — My candid opinion is that the explosion occurred in the east-going board where McCabe and the other had been working.
I ask you this : could the explosion have occurred where the shot had been fired in the Back Crosscut at the face of the Back Crosscut? — If it had occurred there, I should have expected to have seen stronger symptoms of it than what I did see the symptoms in the Back Crosscut were very small, very light.
Did the fact that the pick and cracket being on the stone there lead you to any inference? — If the explosion occurred there I should expect that they would have been charred.
What I want to know is this : It has been suggested as a theory that the shot that had been fired in that Back Crosscut fired the gas and caused the explosion? — Then I would expect to find the cracket and the pick buried if the shot had been fired, according as the stones were lying.
You would not have found them on the top of the stones? — No.
Cross-examined by Mr. Bowey.
Did you see any indications of there having been pick work at that place where you found the stone? — I did not examine that minutely.
Have you examined it since? — No.
You cannot say how that is? — No.
When did you come to a conclusion with regard to the cause of the explosion? — Before I left the east-going board I came to that conclusion.
That day? — Yes.
Did you examine north and south of the east-going board? — No, just the east-going board.
What was it that led you to form that opinion? — The east side of the timber from the face right away out to the other edge was charred.
The timber was charred on the east side at that particular place? — Yes.
Are there no indicators which justify the opinion that the explosion occurred in the South Crosscut? — No.
None whatever? — I could not form any opinion that it had occurred there.
Are there not any indications that are consistent with the explosion having occurred there? — Not that I saw.
None whatever? — No.
What were the indications from the main in-take going along into the South Crosscut? — In by?
Right away from the in-take? — The indications were in-by.
From the in-take to the first pillar were they in-by? — Yes.
Were the indications as strong from the in-take to the first pillar as they were further in from the first pillar to the face? — To me they were.
You have heard, have you not, that some of the other witnesses have said that they were not so strong? — Only this morning ; but I have not heard all that has been said this morning.
You were not here yesterday? — No.
Nor the day before? — No.
You are quite sure that the pick and cracket were on the stone? — Quite sure.
You say that if the explosion had occurred in the South Crosscut you would have expected to have seen stronger symptoms there? — Yes, just so.
But there are some symptoms of an explosion having occurred there, are there not? — I have not seen any.
Not one? — No.
You are quite clear and confident in your opinion? — Quite clear.
You have not the slightest doubt about it? — Not the slightest.
There is no question about it? — Not at all.
You are perfectly certain? — Quite so.
There cannot be any difference of opinion about it? — I have answered you question, and that is sufficient.
You would not be surprised, would you, if men differ in opinion about that? — No ; but I am surprised at your asking questions like these.
Is it not possible that a back lash of fire might have burnt the props on the east side in McCabe's place? — I do not think it.
Are you equally positive about that? — Quite so ; it would have to go in before ; it could come back.
You are quite certain about that? — Yes.
Positive? — I say I am quite certain about that.
(The Coroner.) You cannot get a back lash till you have a front one? — Yes ; and the front one would be stronger than the back one.
Cross-examined by Mr. Heaviside.
Were you in the South Crosscuts before you went to the east-going board? — Yes.
Have you had much experience in fiery mines? — I have had 25 years experience, and more than that.
In fiery mines? — Yes.
Have you had to examine mines after explosions? — For the last 27 years I have had to examine mines, and I have examined mines after slight explosions.
But never anything of this magnitude? — The first I was at was the Seaham Colliery which was of any magnitude, and I was at Trimdon Grange just after the explosion.
You say that you found gas in this back South Crosscut? — Yes.
Where was it coming from? — It had been caused by the brattice being down. As soon as the brattice was put up and the air sent into the face it was cleared out.
It was off the face? — No, the gas was near the face.
Was there any sound of gas coming off? — I did not hear any.
Was the brattice itself burnt? — No.
Would you call a mine a fiery mine where gas collects so soon because the brattice happened to be down? — The brattice had been down some hours before I had been there ; and when you meet with tubers you must expect to find a little gas either more or less.
Have you been all over the mine? — No, not this mine. I have not been over this mine. I was only in the South Crosscut and in the east-going board.
You see that there are marks of a great number of troubles, especially in the North and South Crosscuts? — Yes.
You would naturally expect a good deal of gas to come off at those troubles, would you not? — It just depends. You may go to mines where you have more troubles and get no gas.
You naturally expect to find gas coming off where you get a trouble, do you not? — No, not with respect to a back trouble. I say where there is a seam with gas you might expect to find a trouble. I know this, that as soon as the brattice was put up it was seen clear.
From your experience upon that occasion would you call this a fiery mine? — I would not call it a fiery mine. I saw no gas but just in that place and in the east board, and I attribute that to the brattice being down.
Do you think that a mine where candles have been used is a fiery mine? — I cannot give an answer to that question.
If you were managing this mine, would you allow it to be worked with candles? — I should prefer to have more experience with the mine. I was only in the mine eight hours, and I could not form an opinion, but I know this far, that the gas was soon cleared away, and I would have no hesitation in using candles in that place.
Anyhow, it is a mine from your experience that might be used with candles? — (No answer).
You would recommend candles to be used in a mine like that? — I have been 39 years engaged in mining, and from what I saw I would not be afeared of it.
If the explosion had killed 13 men you would still consider it a safe mine for candles? — As far as my experience went in the place I did not see anything to prevent it. Perhaps if I had been at work in the place and was there day after day I might have seen something otherwise than that, but I was only eight hours in the place.
You say you saw gas in that place when the brattice was down ; from your experience of fiery mines did you ever know a comparatively fiery mine foul so soon as that? — Yes, I have.
Worked with candles? — Yes.
(Mr. Bowey.) What colliery is it that you are speaking of? — The Hilda Colliery in South Shields.
(Mr. Willis.) Do they work there with candles now? — I do not know.
(Mr. Bowey.) Is that not a fiery mine? — It is some years since I left it, and I do not know. I have not been there for some years.
Do not you know that it is acknowledged to be a fiery mine? — No, I do not.
Do not you know that it is acknowledged to be a fiery mine? — I will not acknowledge that I know it. I have not been told.
You do not know that the Hilda Colliery is one of the most fiery mines in the district? — I do not ; it is not from what I here. I think it is one of the best ventilated mines in the place.
Mr. Edge stated that was all the evidence they proposed to call on behalf of the owner.
(The Coroner.) Have you anything to put in at all in the shape of documentary evidence?
(Mr. Edge.) Only those books that we were speaking of if they have come down.
(Mr. Bell.) There is No. 6 book that we want.
(An almanack showing the reading of the barometer was produced.)
(Mr. Bell.) I want the book with the barometer readings.
(Mr. Edge.) There is no such book.