Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Inquests Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Inquests
/   \

1882 West Stanley Colliery Disaster

Inquest Report

West Stanley Inquest, Second Day, Friday, 26th May, 1882 (cont.).

Mr. Thomas Colquhoun, sworn, examined by Mr. EDGE.

You went down the pit on the day of the explosion? — Yes.

And were you one of the party that got first into the two South Headways? — Yes.

What was the condition of the South Headway when you got there? — The brattice close to the bottom of this Stenton (pointing to the plan) for about three or four yards was burnt out, and the in-by side was standing at the time within two or three yards of the face unburnt. Then in the face here (pointing to the plan) there was a shot, at least there was a hole drilled and it had been stecumed ready to be fired.

Did you see the kitty and touch paper? — Not till afterwards.

Did you examine it afterwards? — Yes.

(The Coroner.) How long afterwards? — It would be when I came out of this place here (pointing to the plan).

Shortly afterwards? — Yes.

(Mr. Edge.) On the same occasion? — Yes.

(The Coroner.) Within half an hour afterwards? — Yes.

(Mr. Edge.) Where did you go from that Fore Headway? — We went from the Fore Headway up this Stenton into the back one.

What did you find in the Back Headways? — The brattice was up then when I went up here and in the face there was a lot of stones lying where they had evidently been shot down, and upon the right-hand side of the place going in there was a pick lying just as it had been dropped, and a cracket on the top of the stones. At the right-hand side of this place there was an appearance as if the man had been dressing the top, because a little bit of coal and greystone was lying on the top of the stone, just as if it had been dressing it down on the right-hand side ; and I may mention that at this board here there was a kibble stand close to the end, and there was charring on the east side and north side of that kibble, and there was a tub found up in the face, and that was charred a bit too.

That is the unholed board? — Yes, in this Stenton here (pointing to the plan), the innermost Stenton. The props, almost the whole of them, were charred upon the east side.

What experience have you had in underground working? — I have been 12 years since I first went to serve my time at Wardley Colliery, that was Mr. Alfred Palmer's. I was with him nearly eight years, and I have been here between three and four years.

"Underground workings" I said? — During that time I was with Mr. Palmer I was altogether underground.

You hold a certificate of compentency as manager? — Yes.

Did you examine all the other districts in the pit? — Yes.

Did you come to any judgement with regard to the seat of the explosion? — Yes, I did, I considered it occurred in the face of this East Board where Middlemas and McCabe were working.

When you went in was the brattice up or not? — Yes, the brattice was up.

Was the brattice up the whole way along or how? — I do not recollect that, it was up to the in-by side of this board here (pointing to the plan).

It was up to the in-by side of that unholed board? — Yes.

(Mr. Morley.) From the face? — No, from the Stenton end.

(Mr. Edge.) You cannot say whether it was up or by the in-by side of that? — No.

You say you came to the conclusion that it was Middlemas and McCabe's place? — Yes.

Have you been in there since the explosion, Immediately after the explosion, have you been there lately? — Yes.

Can you tell me whether any more stones have fallen there? — Yes, the roof and the thill are nearly close together, and about a yard from the face there is a great break, an opening in the strata running up, I should think to judge by the eye, about 15 feet.

Does that represent it (handing a sketch to the witness)? — Yes, that is the position that it is at the present time. Then since the explosion the roof and the thill have come close together, and it has been opened out since, and there is room to get into it, and at where you see the cavities it is about perhaps from 18 inches to 2 feet in width, and it widens out a little and gradually runs up to a point, then it extends right across the whole breadth of the board, and at each side right and left of where the stones have not been taken out there is a slip, and the stones are lying as if they had slipped that crevice and still in that position.

(The Coroner.) What is the height of the colliery there? — It has never been measured, but looking at it it looked about 15 feet, and it may go up to the other seam for anything I know, that is the Tilley Seam, about 36 feet up. It is six fathoms from the Tilley to the Busty, that is 36 feet.

(Mr. Edge.) That map, of course, is not drawn to scale? — No ; it is just a rough sketch just as it has been opened.

When did you examine it last? — I think it was Friday. I was in it yesterday morning or the morning before that, Wednesday morning.

You mean that can be seen there by anyone who goes in? — Yes, quite.

You say that your conclusion was that that (pointing to Middlemas and McCabe's place) was the origin of the explosion? — Yes, I think so.

Cross-examined by Mr. BOWEY.

What time was it that you went down into the South Crosscut? — Some time between 1 o'clock and 2 o'clock in the afternoon.

Who had been in before you? — Mr. Atkinson, Mr. Johnson, and Mr. Davison, of Cornsay, to my recollection, whether any of the men had been in there or not, I cannot say.

You did not see the kitty and touch paper when you first went in there? — No, I did not. I went in in the dark and left my lamp outside here (pointing to the plan).

And you cannot say that the pick and the cracket had been there at the time of the explosion? — I cannot swear that they were there.

You were not the first in? — No.

It may have been moved? — Yes ; but it is hardly likely, I think.

And equally the brattice may have been moved, I mean put up? — Yes, I suppose it might.

Did you notice what the indications were as you entered the South Crosscut? — Yes.

What do you say about the indications at the first pillar? — There was a little charring on the roof here and upon the wall side, the right-hand side, but principally in the middle of the roof.

In-over or out-over? — In-over.

The first pillar? — Yes.

From the first pillar to the innermost Stenton what were the indications? — Very much the same.

In-over? — Yes ; but they were not so marked till you got near this Stenton here (pointing to the plan), except in the East Boards.

From the Stenton into the face were there any indications of any kind of burning? — From the innermost Stenton into the face of the Fore Crosscut the brattice was burnt out and had dropped, I should think it would be three or four yards, and then from there it was standing still, it was cindery, it was burnt, but it was still standing. Perhaps it would be five or six yards there standing up towards the face.

Are we to take it that the portion of the brattice nearest the face was not burnt? — Yes, a little ; but not so much as just opposite the innermost Stenton.

And were there any other indications there from the Stenton into the face? — No. I do not recollect any other except that there was a great deal of charring in the roof, and it was quite cindery.

Did you go round there into the Back Crosscut? — Yes.

What were the indications in the Back Crosscut? — There was not so much as in the Fore Crosscut, the charring here (pointing to the plan) was very trifling as compared with this Stenton here, and it was on both sides of the props to the best of my recollection, but principally inwards.

And as you come out-over? — Yes, the same thing here (pointing to the plan) and then in this board here. That is the innermost air board, the charring was upon the west side.

What would that indicate? — It would indicate as if it had come round here (pointing to the plan).

As if it had gone into the Back Crosscut? — Yes.

And came further down again this way coming out-by from the crosscut? — I may mention here that there was a tub at the bottom of that air board, the innermost air board of the Back Crosscut, and there was a turn laid in like that (describing) up this air board, and it had been knocked right across this way here, and a plate knocked away, also knocked eastward, and there was charring upon the west side of that tub.

What would that indicate? — It would indicate, I should say, that the force had come round to the east.

That it had gone into the Back Crosscut? — That it had come down this West Board, as though the tub had been standing in that West Board.

And as though the blast had come in? — Yes, certainly.

Was not there another tub? — Not here (pointing to the plan).

But further out-by from the Back Crosscut round by the blue line round the corner? — There was no tub there. There was a tub here (pointing to the plan), and it was jammed right on the north wall side and that was here (pointing to the plan), and the charring was upon the north end of it.

What would that indicate? — I cannot tell you, it would indicate as if the blast had gone in there (describing).

As if the blast had gone into the Back Crosscut? — It would depend upon where the tub had been standing. If the tub had been standing in front here and had come round there, I cannot tell what it would indicate ; but I can tell this, that if the tub had been standing in the in-by side, that is to say, to the south of the headway, and the blast had come round that way (describing), it would have charred it there, but then we do not know where it was standing.

And coming further out did you find anything from there? — Yes.

What indications were there? — There was a tub here (pointing to the plan).

Another tub? — Yes, and it was twisted round away in that direction in that corner, it was twisted round in that direction and the charring was upon this end of the tub, and also upon this end upon this side (describing).

Which would indicate what? — It would indicate as if it had been round here.

As if it had gone into the Back Crosscut? — Yes.

Were there any further indications as you came out from the Back Crosscut? — Along here?

Yes. How was the timber? — It was charred principally upon the north side.

The out-by side? — Yes, that is the north side.

You have not mentioned what the indications were along the North Headways upon which you have founded your opinion, you have not given any indications up the North Headways and along there. When were you first in there? — I was in there that evening.

What indications did you see at the air crossing? — Of course that was blown out.

The air crossing was blown out? — Yes.

Which way was it blown? — I should say in all directions, but principally to the west.

That is, the air crossing into the North Headway? — Into the board, it was both ways.

You could not express any opinion with regard to the blast from that? — Oh, dear no.

What other indications did you find as you went further in? — These stoppings were blown out west and east according to their respective positions.

That would indicate nothing with regard to the direction of the blast? — No ; but here where you turn to go to the east board there is charring upon the roof and upon the south side of this board, just at the corner here (pointing to the plan).

At the corner entering into the East Flat? — Yes. Then in the flat itself the place was drawn out and the timber was all lying about there in all directions, and the tubs were also smashed and the tops of them were to the out-by side of the tram wheels.

You cannot tell anything about the bottoms of the tubs, which way they were blown? — From their appearance the tops had been blown to the west.

And the bottoms? — The bottoms must have been just where they were. I think that the tendency would be that the top being the weakest portion would go furthest out.

You are not of the same opinion as the witness who stated that they had been blown both ways? — No.

What did you find in the in-by side of the flat? — I found this door here knocked down, and the batten, the band, and one deal were lying just as if it had been open down between that and the prop where the string was attached to the putter lad for opening and shutting the door. Then there were also several portions of deals in splinters lying at the west side of this door, and in here there was a fall just commencing about these two headways at the in-by side of the door. Then this fall extended for some five or six yards, and on the top of this fall there was one band and some stones underneath. There was another band and some wreckage of door there, and portions of the bricks belonging to this door (pointing to the plan).

Which way had the bricks been blown? — They had been blown in this direction.

In-by? — Yes.

Not out-by? — No.

And going further north what was the next thing you found? — Of course there were some places where the timber was knocked down and stone had fallen.

Was there anything indicating in which direction the blast had gone? — Not till you got down to this pillar where the charring commenced, the charring commenced there (pointing to the plan) and it was generally speaking upon the east side of the timber, and as we got down to where these two men were found there was a tub lying across the way then.

What position was that tub in? — It was lying in that direction (describing), but I think this tub had been removed to get these bodies out when I got down, because I did not go down till after the bodies were got out.

How did you find it? — It was round in this turn here (pointing to the plan).

Was it burnt at all? — I cannot say. I did not examine it.

But you saw the tub, and you would have noticed it if it had been burnt, would you not? — I did not examine it.

But you would have noticed it without expressly examining it? — No, I did not examine the tub for any indications of burning.

You did not notice any indications of burning? — Because I did not examine it.

But you saw the tub? — Yes.

And you did not see that it was burnt? — I did not exactly. I did not examine it. I saw the tub but I did not examine it.

Do you mean to say that you could not see whether it was burnt without examining it? — I mean to say that I did not examine it.

Did you see any indications inside of that tub? — I went down and saw extensive charring, but I only went down to the middle of this face pillar (pointing to the plan), and there the timber and small coals and stones were completely covered with the char and cinders, and the roof as well.

Did you go north from Middlemas and McCabe's place? — Yes.

What indications did you find there? — I saw there was a tub in here at the bottom of the first West Board, it was on the headways, and the charring was very thick upon the south side of the tub. The inside of that end of the tub was quite free from anything of the kind ; and on the other side, the north side, there was charring more at the top and so far down towards the middle, and on the other side it was free.

Was the tub charred on the north side? — No, it was charred on the south side and free on the north side.

And beyond that what were the indications generally? — I did not go any further because it was fallen here (pointing to the plan).

Have you been up this district north, this headways district? — Yes.

When were you up there? — I could not speak to a day or two because I have been down so often.

Did you observe anything up there? — Yes, I think it would be within a week at any rate that I was along here, and they were renewing the stoppings here, and the gas was coming off at this one and that one (pointing to the plan).

Did you observe any indications with regard to the direction of the blast in that district? — With the exception of the stoppings, and each one of them right and left being blown in that direction, east and west, there was no indication that I saw till I got in there (pointing to the plan), that is the face of the crosscut, and here two stone tubs stood right at the extreme end of the headway.

On the west side? — Right in the face of the North Crosscut, they stood there.

What stood there? — These two stone tubs, and they were completely wrecked, and portions of the kibbles or stone tubs, that is the tops of them, were blown to more than half-way along that board. This is the innermost air board (pointing to the plan).

What would that indicate? — It would indicate that the blast had gone up there (pointing to the plan).

Is that consistent with the blast coming either from the South Crosscut or the East Narrow Board? — I think it is quite consistent with its coming from the East Narrow Board.

Is it consistent with its coming from the South Crosscut? — I do not think so, because I think the blast has gone that way (describing).

Is it not consistent with its coming from the South Crosscut? — No, I do not think so.

Why not? — Because of that door here which was blown away to the east.

Supposing it was? — Then I think the indications are that it travelled that way (describing).

Is not that consistent with its coming from the South Crosscut at the north end of the North Headways, the tubs being blown in there. Is not that one indication consistent with either the blast coming from the East Narrow Board or the South Crosscut? — No, I do not think so. I think if it had come from the South Crosscut it would have gone out-by.

You do not agree with the other witnesses that if it did come from the South Crosscut it would have gone up this headway? — No, I do not.

(Mr. Edge.) Who said that?

(Mr. Bowey.) Mr. Rutherford.

(Mr. Edge.) He said that there was nothing to show along this North Crosscut which way it had gone. Mr. Bowey said it would have gone in there from the South Crosscut.

(Mr. Bowey.) I never understood anybody to say that it would not.

(The Witness.) Another thing is that the reason it had gone in there is that that door was blown to the west (pointing to the plan).

(Mr. Bowey.) Are you able to give some reason why, if the explosion had occurred in the South Crosscut, it would not have gone into the headway there? — From all the knowledge I possess it would have gone against the air out of the shaft.

If it had occurred in the South Crosscut it would not have gone into that headway? — No.

Why? — From the fact that in the generality of accidents which have occurred it has gone in that direction.

Which direction? — Towards the best outlet and where the most air is coming.

You think if it had occurred in the South Crosscut it would not have gone in there but have gone out of the shaft? — Yes, it would.

Are there any indications in your opinion in that headways district along the main in-take to show that it did not go in there from the South Crosscut? — No ; I am only speaking of the indications going in there (pointing to the plan).

But I am asking you now whether there are any indications in that headways district along the main in-take, or in other words are not the indications along that in-take quite consistent with its going in there (pointing to the plan)? — No.

Apart from the fact that you think it would have gone to the shaft? — No.

What are the indications against it? — Here (pointing to the plan). Just right opposite to the air crossing upon the fore narrow board there is a stone pillar built right up to the roof about six feet high, the width of this pillar (pointing to the plan). It is chock full of fine coaldust and the dust from the mine. On each side of it there is no trace of it.

On which side is it covered with dust? — It is right opposite where this would come out, here where the air would come out or anything would come out.

Where? — Right opposite where the North Fore Crosscut commences. There is a pillar built there of stone, and this pillar is brought up to a height of about six feet, I could stand upright in it ; but it is choked up with dust.

You say that that was charred on the side which showed that the blast had come from the East Narrow Board? — No. I cannot speak about charring, it is just fine dust, dust from the mine, it indicates, I think, that the blast had carried the fine dust before it, it might be that the blast coming out had acted like a piston, and had driven all this mine dust with it.

You say that that is indicative of its coming from the South Crosscut? — I think it is an indication that it came this way (pointing to the plan) it has come out-by from the North Crosscut. It indicates, I think, that it has come from the north to the south.

In coming to the conclusion as you have done that the explosion did not arise in the South Crosscut have you attached any weight to the fact that you found the pick and cracket upon the stones? — I think that if the pick and cracket were found there the men had left them just as they were working.

Has that been one of the reasons which has brought you to your conclusion? — Yes, I think the men had been working there at the time.

Supposing that the pick and cracket were not first found upon the stones would that alter your opinion? — No, it would not.

I thought that would have been and element in coming to your conclusion? — It is something to help you to a conclusion.

Then if it is the other way, will not it help another way? — No, I think there is a strong indication there of which way it has come, and I think there is another here (pointing to the plan).

If the pick and cracket are upon the stones they help you to your present conclusion ; if they are not upon the stones when they are first found they do not help anything, and they do not tell against your theory? — No.

Cross-examined by Mr. HEAVISIDE.

At the end of the second wall in the back South Crosscut, did you find a shot box? — I am not sure of your locality.

There was one tub blown six yards westward ; did you find a shot box at all down there? — Yes, I found three.

(The Coroner.) In what part is that? — In the furthest west headways, in the back of the South Crosscut. You see where the doors are ; that headway is coloured blue above the westernmost headways. I found two right in the middle of that pillar, that wall, the one nearest to the face, nearest to the south.

(Mr. Edge.) The second pillar from the narrow board? — Yes.

(Mr. Heavisidel.) Was there one lower than that? — Yes, there was one underneath the tub wall here at the junction of that headway and the board to the east.

Had they been blown any distance? — I could not tell you.

You could not tell the position originally? — No. The two that were lying here were evidently where they had been placed.

Did you go south from where Middlemas and McCabe were working? — When.

Immediately after the explosion? — Yes, that same day I went up there.

To the south did you go? — No, I did not go south, not the day of the explosion, but I was there afterwards.

Referring to the fine dust that you say was on the stopping at the bottom of the north headways, might not the second blast have blown it there? — Where is the second blast going to or coming from.

Would not the second blast carry it there ; the return blast? — I do not see how that could be.

Had the force of the explosion been greater on the east-going board than elsewhere ; or where was the greater force, at the east-going board or at the South Crosscut? — Most decidedly here, at the east going board.

There had been greater fire there? — Yes.

(The Coroner.) The greater force of the explosion? — Yes.

(Mr. Heavisidel.) Both the fire and the force? — In the face of the east board and along the wall the charring was as thick and as great as in any part of the pit.

Was it equally as great? — Yes.

Where was it equally as great? — I should say in the face of this east board, the going board, and along the north wall and the south wall.

But you say that it was as great there as in any other part of the mine ; but the force had been greater? — I say the force was greater at this flat than it was at this (pointing to the plan).

(Mr. Edge.) At which flat? — The east flat as indicated ; there was more force there than at the south.

Examined by Mr. BELL.

When you were at the flat what were the indications on the south side wall? — There was a length of tram plates stuck up on end as if they had been driven from the first board to the south to that point, perhaps about the distance of six yards, and they had been wedged into the roof.

Were they driven from south to north? — They were driven from south to north.

With reference to the indications against the props, what were they? — They were, generally speaking, all round in that place in the innermost wall, but, generally speaking, they were towards the south and west.

Were they not as strong on the south side as on the north? — On the south side of the prop?

Were they not as strong on the south side as on the north? — No, scarcely.

But there were strong indications on the south side? — Yes.

And those indications tally with the blowing northward of the length of plates? — They would scarcely do that.

The force must have been in that direction because the indications on the south side have been to drive the plates southward? — But there are indications of the blast having blown the plates here.

But I am speaking of the Stenton? — That is the wall south of the east board?

Yes? — I do not think the indications of the charring are consistent with the plates being found in that position.

If there were indications on the south side of the props there, would that not be an indication that the blast had gone northward? — The indications of the charring are principally in the direction travelling this way (indicating on the plan).

We will finish with the wall first. I am speaking of the innermost south wall ; were there not strong indications on the south side of the props? — Yes, there were.

That is an indication that the blast had gone north from there, is it not? — Yes, it is.

And the plates were also driven in the same direction? — Yes.

Now just go to the South Crosscut, where was the second tub, was it the first pillar up? — It was there (pointing to the diagram).

I understood you to say that the tub had been driven eastward? — No, I said it had been driven northward, and it was charred northward to.

Driven up against the north side? — Yes.

With regard to the other tub in the back Crosscut, in what way was it driven? — It was driven eastward.

Then you make a division of forces here between the two boards? — Yes, it appears so.

Is it not consistent with reason that what forced the one tub one way might force the other one in the same direction? — When the blast had come round this way, and there was a vacuum formed, it might draw that tub out again.

That tub was not broken, was it? — No.

A tub is rather a heavy thing to be drawn out of a vacuum, is it not? — If there was tremendous pressure upon it it would move it.

How could you have any amount of back pressure there when you had such a little space in the Crosscuts?

(The witness hesitated.)

You cannot account for it, I suppose? — No, I can scarcely account for it there.

Just turn to this diagram of yours on the wall ; is this an open cavity right across the whole width of the board? — Yes, right across.

Have you measured it or seen the top of it? — No.

That is purely ideal? — Yes.

How much stuff has been filled out of the bottom of that place? — I could not say, exactly, as to the quantity, but I can give you an idea of the space it has been got through. About three feet wide. Do you mean immediately under it?

There is, apparently, some stuff which has fallen out of that leader, that would fall into the board, would it not? — Yes.

How much stuff has been cleared away? — About three feet in width, and I should think about two feet in thickness.

Then that stuff would be sufficient to fill that cavity up? — Yes.

Has it not been an open cavity? — I cannot tell what it has been, it is an open cavity now.

You do not know what it was before the fall took place? — No ; but there are some stones slipped down in this cavity.

Is it not like any ordinary hitch leader? — No.

Did you never see a hitch leader run out ; did you never know stuff run out of a hitch leader? — Not in that way.

In what respect is it different from any other hitch leader? — It had settled down and gone upon each side of it as a hitch of face as if it went up in a wedge shape, and in the other place it was all like a running sand.

It has come down in a solid lump? — Yes, and it smashed itself as it got down, tumbled down, but it is still lying in a cavity.

If it was lifted up again it would fill the cavity up? — I do not say it would do that.

If you took the stuff away from the bottom it would keep running, I suppose? — A little.

If you did not take away anything it would stop? — Now it would ; all that is lying there is supported with a stone underneath it.

You cannot give us any proof that there has been an open cavity there? — No, I cannot do that.

You say this is simply stuff coming out of the hitch leader? — Yes.

Examined by Mr. WILLIS.

With regard to the South Crosscut going into the last open Stenton into the fore face, you us, I think, that the brattice there of 10 yards opposite the last hole place is burnt down? — No, I only said three or four.

Exactly opposite the hole? — Yes, opposite the holding towards the face.

Would not that indicate to your mind that a volume of flame had poured out through that Stenton upon that brattice? — No.

Eastward, I mean? — No, the charring upon the props is upon the south.

I am asking you about the burnt brattice. If the brattice was set up against there and burnt down to three yards, would it not indicate to your mind that a volume of flame had poured out eastward out of the Stenton? — Yes, it might do that.

And not westward? — It might have gone in through here (pointing to the diagram), but I think the probability is that it would have gone in that way and hung there. I think that it would have come down the innermost Stenton from the west, and where it is so much charred it had hung there sufficiently to burn there, because it is the worst burnt brattice I have seen in the whole pit.

Would not that indicate that a volume of flame had come from the face of the Back Crosscut? — I should have expected that it would have burnt the whole lot if that was burnt.

Would it not burn the whole lot if it came the other way? — I do not know, I am sure. It evidently has not.

Examined by Mr. MORLEY.

Your theory is that it came from the Back Crosscut towards the Fore Crosscut? — I think they met there in the Back Crosscut, that they met about the Back Crosscut and that they hung there ; the fire hung there a sufficient time to burn it.

But you are speaking of the Fore Crosscut, are you not, because you say the brattice in the Back Crosscut was not burnt at all? — Yes.

So that it could not have hung at the Back Crosscut? — I say that they may have met there at the Back Crosscut, and that it hung fire in this Fore Crosscut end and that Stenton.

Can you imagine that two forces would come and meet at the end of the Back Crosscut and leave the brattice there untouched? — It has left the brattice upon the face of the Fore Crosscut untouched ; it may have been burnt at the junction.

Is that the conclusion you have come to, that the forces did come down and met at the point at the end of the Back Crosscut? — It is.

Is that consistent with the position of these tubs which you have described? — Generally speaking it is.

Do you generally expect to find more signs of force in the immediate neighbourhood of an explosion or less signs than at other parts? — I should say there was less force in the neighbourhood.

You said just now that, in your opinion, there were greater signs of force in the neighbourhood of the end of the east-going board than at the South Crosscut? — Yes.

Would not that rather point to the South Crosscut being the origin of the fire ; would not the fact of there having been greater signs of force at the east-going board than at the South Crosscut rather point to what I have indicated? — I say there were greater signs of burning here, and that the force was great at this east flat. I call the flat the whole district here (pointing to the diagram), because the force here intensifies right round. In this first board here it commences with very broken stone ; it was open, but the second was not. It was dangerous to go there. Then here, as you pass round, it still keeps intensifying in its effect till you get to the narrow board and into the fifth pillar from the north Fore Crosscut ; that is upon the back narrow board. The fall commences there, and it extends, I cannot tell you how far, because it closes lower down. In the fore narrow board the fall commences in the third pillar, and it is almost quite close, I think. That is a very strong indication that there has been a great deal stronger force there than anything in here.

My question was, are there greater signs of force at the east-going board than at the South Crosscut ; you say it is in the immediate neighbourhood? — Yes, it is in the immediate neighbourhood, but it is a gradually intensifying force as it goes.

You would not infer much from the greater extent of the fall except that the roof was less secure? — I gather this much, that it had drawn the timber.

But the timber was drawn? — I gather from the greater force that the force of the blast had drawn the timber. I know they were well timbered.

Equally timbered all the way along? — Yes.

What is your opinion with regard to the way in which the blast entered into the south workings, down the main in-take? — I think it came along the main in-take with the air.

Then why do you say, supposing the fire originated in the South Crosscut, it would not have gone up the North Crosscut, but would have gone out? — I think it divided itself here (pointing to the diagram).

Supposing the fire had originated in the South Crosscut, why do you say it would not have gone up the North Crosscut, but would have turned out towards the shaft? — Because here is the fresh air coming out in this direction ; it feeds the supply, the flame as it comes along the way, and the generality of explosions, I believe, travel in that way.

I must point your attention to the south workings. Wherever the fire originated, it originated in the west workings? — Yes.

It must have travelled along towards the shaft, and yet when you got to the end of the junction it did travel down into the south workings? — Yes.

Therefore you cannot draw any conclusion from the fact that it generally goes against the air, to the effect that nit would not be likely to go up the North Crosscut? — I tested the indications at this North Crosscut end.

Apart from that it would be very likely to go up the North Crosscut if it started from the south, would it not? — It is possible, but I should doubt it.

It is the dust at the North Crosscut that you base your opinion upon, is it not? — No, there is another indication at the east flat in the first pillar.

The one you mentioned before? — Yes. There is another indication that it came out in that direction ; and there is another indication in the face of the innermost east board on the North Crosscut where the dust had deposited in considerable quantity against the wall side, and upon the out-by side, that is the south side, there is not that deposit. I should have thought, if it had gone in that way, it would have gone in that direction.

You put the two together in forming your opinion? — Yes.

Re-examined by Mr. EDGE.

As I understand, you found the force increasing gradually away from McCabe's place as it went north against the wind, and up here in the back narrow board, you say that it had been well timbered? — Yes.

And heavy fallen? — Yes.

And you consider from the way it was timbered that those falls would not have been brought about unless the timber had been driven by the force of the blast? — Yes, because at the outside of that fall the timber all shows signs of charring.

Did you notice the third and fourth stoppings? — I noticed this third stopping, and this one there (pointing to the diagram), and it was blown to the north.

As if the blast had gone up against the wind? — Yes.

With reference to the second and third stoppings, how were they blown? — The first and second were blown to the south.

Is that consistent with the blast having taken into that back narrow board, gone along the back narrow board against the wind, and blown those stoppings in its course in towards the workings? — Yes.

Then you came along here you say (pointing to the diagram). There is not much indication down this north crossing? — No.

But here, opposite the North Crosscut, you found the dust blown down across here? — Yes, very strong.

The witness withdrew.

(Mr. Edge.) We should like some directions as to what is to be done with the lamps, as to how they are to be tested. Do you wish to have them cleaned.

(Mr. Willis.) First they must be marked and the number of revolutions taken that it takes to separate the lamp. Each lamp top and each lamp bottom must be kept to themselves, so that the same number of revolutions are put on again in putting it on. Then after they are separated you must clean them without moving any of the parts, except what is just requisite to clean them, and then light them and test them.

(Mr. Bowey.) As Mr. Edge desires it, I will call one of my witnesses now, in order that Mr. Baker Forster may give his evidence to-day.

(The Coroner.) Very well.

A Committee consisting of Mr. Atkinson, on behalf of the Government Inspectors ; Mr. Cowey and Mr. Thomson, on behalf of Mr. Bowey's clients ; and Mr. Berkeley and Mr. Colquhoun for the owners, was appointed at this stage of the proceedings to retire and to clean and test half a dozen lamps belonging to the deceased men. Westgarth, Douglass, Riley, Hutchinson, Middlemas, and McCabe.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print