1882 West Stanley Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
West Stanley Inquest, Second Day, Friday, 26th May, 1882 (cont.).
William Indian sworn, examined by Mr. BOWEY.
You are the check weighman at West Stanley Colliery? — Yes.
Did you go down the mine as one of the party of explorers on the morning of the explosion? — Yes.
About what time was it? — About 9 o'clock in the morning.
Who was with you? — There were 10 workmen went down with me. Mr. Johnson saw me on the pit heap and told me to go get 10 workmen, and of course I got them and went down, and when we got to the bottom we divided ourselves into batches, five each way.
Which way did you go? — Straight south.
As far as where? — To the east flat.
I believe you were only in the North and South Headways that day. You were not away along here (pointing to the diagram)? — Not that day, only in the south-east.
Did you again go down on the 26th? — Yes, along with Mr. Bell, Mr. Willis, Mr. Rutherford, Mr. Fairlie, and others.
That, I believe, was the official inspection? — Yes.
Did you go into this west way on that occasion? — Yes.
Did you go into the fore South Crosscut? — Yes.
What was the first indication which you saw in the fore South Crosscut? — In the first two walls in the fore South Crosscut, there was little timber. I could not see any timber standing, but there was a batch of plates set upon the right-hand side going in, and at the south side of those plates the crevices were filled with dust as if she had come out over there.
Beyond those pillars, going towards the innermost Stenton, what were the indications as you went along? — In-over.
What were they? — Charring on the props.
On which side? — On the north side of the props.
On the second pillar from the innermost Stenton? — From that east board to the innermost Stenton.
That is from the first pillar to the innermost Stenton? — Yes, from the first pillar to the innermost Stenton, the indications of burning were charred coal as on the north side of the wall.
Indicating that it had gone in or out? — In.
Did you go into the face of the Fore Crosscut? — Yes.
Did you find any indications from the innermost Stenton and into the face up to the face? — None
Did you find anything in the face? — Yes, there was a hole drilled and stemmed and the pricker drawn.
Did you find any stone there? — No, no stone.
I think you saw the kitty and the touch? — Not that day.
Did you go from there into the Back Crosscut? — Yes, through the Stenton.
What were the indications there? — I could not give the indications in the Stenton, they seemed to be all round the prop in the innermost Stenton.
Coming along, just tracing it along, what did you find coming along to the Back Crosscut? — Coming through the Stenton do you mean?
What did you find in there. You came through here (pointing to the diagram) and you say the timber was charred all round? — Yes.
Did you go up to the face there? — In the Back Crosscut?
What did you find there? — The result of a shot, that is, the stone as if a shot had been fired, it was lying on the bottom.
What was? — The stone from the shot untouched.
How were the props there? — The brattice cloth was on the props ; the props were behind the brattice cloth.
What condition was the brattice cloth in? — I did not examine it very minutely in the Back Crosscut, it seemed to be pretty fair as far as I could see in the Back Crosscut, but at the end of the brattice cloth there were half a dozen straws tied together placed on the top of this running plank where they run this brattice cloth on, and I took those straws down and they were burnt on the ends.
Did you observe whether there had been any picking at the stone after the shot had been fired? — I made a careful examination of the Back Crosscut and did not see any indication of picking.
None Whatever? — None whatever.
Although you searched for them? — Yes, and examined the place minutely.
Did you see a cracket there? — Mr. Johnson was sitting on a cracket.
Did you see a pick? — I saw a pick standing by the side, the right-hand side.
Was it on the stone? — It was by the side of the stone.
Mr. Johnson had been there before you? — Yes, he was in before me.
In the Back Crosscut, in the west board, did you find anything? — That is the innermost west board. There was a tub in that board (pointing to the plan).
(Mr. Edge.) Was that the first holed board? — No, there was a tub in that board.
(Mr. Bowey.) Was that tub burnt? — Yes.
At which end, the in-by end or the out-by end? — It seemed to have gone all round.
Did you find anything at the second Stenton? — Yes, there was a tub standing there. It had been either choked up or lifted off the way-one end in the crosscut above this west board and that tub was wheeled about.
Was that by the force going in or coming out? — Going down the Back Crosscut out-by. The plates that that tub had been standing on were taken away with the wheels, and that tub was ended about and the charring was on the south end of that tub.
On the south end? — Yes.
Then I believe you did not go any further along the Back Crosscut? — Not that day.
Where did you go to then, to the main west narrow board? — We went into the main west narrow board again.
Then, I believe you went into the north Fore Headways? — Yes.
The North Crosscut? — Yes.
Did you observe any indications in the North Crosscut? — Not till I got to the overcast.
Which overcast? — This one (pointing to the diagram).
When you got to the overcast or air crossing what did you find there? — I found the bricks and part of the woodwork belonging to that air crossing blown in-over in north.
Into the North Crosscut? — Yes.
Did you notice the condition of any of the props there? — I did not see any props standing.
Were there any indications along the North Crosscut till you got to the east flat going towards the east narrow board? — No, nothing.
Were there any indications from the junction to the east flat going along to the east narrow board? — At the junction end the top coal at that part seemed to be charred and burnt, at the junction end going into the east board.
On which side? — On the north side.
Indicating what, that the blast had gone which way, in or out? — That it had taken in.
Did you see any tubs? — Yes.
Where were they? — The tops were one way and the bottoms were another.
Where abouts were they? — In the flat, the out-by side of the flat.
What was the position of the tubs? — The bottoms seemed to be one lying on the top of another ; the wheels and bottoms seemed to have risen up one on the top of another with the force, and there were two tubs, I think, that were lying at the out-by side of this, and I could not account for the two tubs being there, not at the time. It was a mystery to me, so I let the question lie over till another day till I had a fair chance to get through that section, so as to come to an understanding how those tubs were blown in that position.
What conclusion did you come to about them on that day. Who was with you on that day? — Mr. Bell and Mr. Johnson, and Mr. Thompson, and Mr. Colquhoun.
How did you find them on that day? — I found the result, at least in my own mind, in the second headways from the flat end, the indications were on the north side of the prop in the second headways, the second headways away from the flat.
The east flat? — Yes. I think that she had travelled out of this headway, and by the two tubs being light it had shifted them out by the side of the trams when she came out.
Do you mean coming out of the east? — Yes, she recoils.
(The Coroner.) The blast travelled out of the East Headways with the recoil and that took away the tops of the tubs, they being the lightest parts? — Yes.
(Mr. Bell.) Which headway is that? — Is it out of the North Headways.
(Mr. Bowey.) Which way did the recoil come? — This is the east-going board, the recoil came along here (pointing to the diagram) from north to south.
It came from the north into the east-going board? — Yes, into the east-going way again.
(The Coroner.) The recoil blast came from the narrow board to the north? — Yes.
(Mr. Bowey.) Where did the recoil come from? — From the north, travelling east. The recoil came south from the north.
(The Coroner.) From where, do you mean that it had gone round? — Yes.
It had gone round this way (pointing to the diagram) and then round there? — Yes.
(Mr. Bowey.) How do you mean that it had gone round? — I mean that it had gone this way (pointing to the diagram).
Where did the recoil start from? — It started from in here (pointing to the diagram).
And down south? — Yes.
(The Coroner.) Show us the course of the blast and then the recoil with a pen on the map. (The witness did so.)
(Mr. Bowey.) What indications did you find beyond the tubs, in-by of the tubs? — Then we came to where the door had stood, and the door was gone, the brickwork as well, and there was broken wood lying about, but I could not say whether it belonged to tubs or doors ; but about 16 yards from where the door stood in-by going east, I found a portion of the door under a fall there, there was a band attached to it underneath the fall.
Do you mean that the door had been blown in 15 or 16 yards? — Yes.
Blown in towards the east narrow board? — Yes.
(The Coroner.) What portion of the door did you find? — There was on of the hinges on the door.
One of the bands? — Yes.
That was 16 yards in-by? — Yes, I think about that.
You said that it was under something, under a fallen stone? — Yes.
(Mr. Bowey.) Beyond that door where you found that portion of the door up at the place where McCabe and Middlemas were found, what were the indications? — The charring was the only burning on the props that I could see, and that was on the west side of the props.
According to which you think the blast had gone in? — Yes.
I believe you did not get any further that day? — No, the east board away from the wall was found on the north side ; but we went a wall to the south that day of where McCabe was found.
It was down here (pointing to the diagram) that you went? — Yes.
What did you find in the wall to the south? — There was a tub standing in the turn that had been put in.
The day after the explosion? — Yes.
How do you know that? — Because the tub was found across the way when the bodies were being got out, and it was on the way when we went in.
On the 3rd of May you went down again to this part of the east narrow board, with Mr. Bell, Mr. Johnson, and Mr. Colquhoun? — Yes.
I believe on that occasion you went to within a few yards of the face in the east-going board? — Yes.
For the first few yards how were the indications? — I was about five or six yards in the board, and Mr. Bell and Mr. Johnson were before. Mr. Bell says "Let us see how the indications are here." Well I looked where I was and I found the indications on the west side of the prop, six yards into McCabes board.
Was there any fall? — I could see the face. I got up to the kibble that day, I could see the face and there seemed to be a post girder hanging about two or three inches thick, I could see the face and that is all I could see.
Did you go south at all that day? — Yes.
How far? — That day I went right south within a wall of the return.
What indications did you find as you went south of Middlemas and McCabe's place along here (pointing to the diagram), for instance, what place do you call this? — That is south.
What particular spot do you call that? — A wall. There is a wall and a board. The wall is about six yards in and the board was perhaps 15 or 16 yards in.
Did you find any indications along here? — On the 26th of April, when we went in, there were these two end plates set up on end, and there were questions asked as to what was the cause of that. One said one thing and another said another.
Is this when Mr. Bell and Mr. Johnson were with you? — Yes, that was the first indication noticeable. I said force, another said suction, and I examined the props to see the indication on the props and the indication on the props was at the south side.
Did you find any further indications going south till you came within a pillar of the return? — We travelled up the boards a wall south within a pillar of the return, and the indication in those boards was the west side of the prop and the south side of the wall.
All along there (pointing to the diagram)? — Yes, we were prevented from getting into the return by a fall, we had to come back and we came back.
You were prevented from getting beyond this first pillar on the return by a fall? — Yes, we came then straight down the headways on to the main west board, and came away down through the face again and Mr. Johnson and Mr. Bell were sitting in the face of this wall examining a tub that was in the face.
Did you go along the North Headways that day? — Yes.
Up here (pointing to the diagram)? — Yes.
Did you come round here (pointing to the diagram)? — Yes.
What indications did you find travelling north from the east-going board? — Travelling north the indication was on the south on the prop and east in the boards till we got into this second headway away from the flat.
What did you find there (pointing to the diagram)? — The reverse way, that is where I hold there is a recoil.
That is where you hold the recoil started? — Yes.
Did you travel north again from there? — Yes, we were prevented from getting into the back board by a fall there again.
Where was that? — (The witness put his finger upon the spot.)
That is the first wall out of the back narrow board.
There was a fall there? — Yes.
Then what course did you take? — We came back and along this second headways in-by side of the flat and kept on to the North Crosscut again.
Were you up at the head of the headways that day? — Yes.
Up here (pointing to the diagram)? — Yes.
At the crosscut? — Yes.
What indications did you find at this junction from here (pointing to the diagram), the junction where you go into the east narrow board from the crosscut, did you find any indications? — The charring upon the props was on the south side of the props.
All along here (pointing to the diagram)? — Yes.
Were you up here at this extreme west corner? — Yes.
Did you observe any dust there? — I saw two kibbles there.
Was there any indication there from which you could infer the direction of the blast? — According to the way the kibbles were lying I should say she travelled north.
Do you mean by that that she had gone into the crosscut? — Yes.
And not that she had come out here (pointing to the diagram)? — No.
Along this narrow board? — We did not get round there.
But you say you think the blast had not come along this narrow board? — No, I think not.
Having gone over all these portions of the mine have you come to any conclusion with regard to the seat of the explosion? — Yes, I think in my own mind that it originated in the Back Crosscut off the shot.
What reason do you give for its occurring there rather than in the east narrow-going board? — There is a trouble in the Back Crosscut and there is one in the Fore Crosscut, and there is a trouble in the east board out of the Fore Crosscut, and what these three troubles make, the gas they give off, goes into the Back Crosscut, and the brattice according to the Back Crosscut was seven yards back from the face and I think that the place was foul.
Do you think that it did not occur at the east going board? — Not in the slightest.
You have heard the evidence that has been given so far upon that? — Yes.
Have you any reasons which you can give for its occurring in the east-going board, that is taking away what you speak of as being in the South Crosscut, is there anything that you saw in the east-going board which convinced you that the explosion did not occur there? — The indications going into the board are on the west side of the prop, and this crevice in the top is between a yard and a foot from the face, and I hold that as soon as ever that hitch began, or rather as soon as ever the coal was taken out of that gas would come off there, and the fore shift men of the 18th would take that coal off. The back shift man works his shift seven hours, and the shift that went in at 9 o'clock at night worked till 9 o'clock in the morning.
Then you think the indications in the east-going board are against the theory of the explosion arising there? — Yes.
Cross-examined by Mr. EDGE.
So far as I understand you, you say that the seat of the explosion was the Back Crosscut in the South Crosscut District? — Yes.
That is where you say she fired? — Yes.
I want to know what your theory is of how she fired there? — She fired off the shot.
And you think that place was foul before the shot was fired? — Certain, in my own mind.
You think she fired off the shot? — Yes.
Do you know how they fire shots in this pit? — Yes.
She was foul, of course, before the shot was fired? — Yes.
Do you know how they fire the shots? — Yes.
Do not you know that they unscrew the bottom of the lamp and fire the kitty from the flame from the lamp? — They do not.
How do they do it? — With touch. They sit down and take the bottom off the lamp and off the top, they set the lamp on the bottom and light the touch, and unscrew the lamp again and take the touch and light the touch attached to the straw.
If that place was foul how was it that it did not explode when they lighted the lamp? — The gas was lying up at the top.
Your theory was that it was fouled coming off here, some gas had got up to the top and although the lamp was unscrewed it did not fire the explosion? — The lamp was not near the top.
Was not Douglass the man to fire the shot? — I do not know.
Do you mean that Douglass was the man who had to fire shots? — No.
Do you know that he was a competent man for shot firing? — No.
How long have you been connected with this pit? — I have been here about seven years.
How long has Douglass been here? — Two years, perhaps.
You do not know anything at all about him, do you even know that he was a person authorised to fire shots in the pit? — No.
You did not inquire probably into that? — No, I did not.
Have you ever seen them fire shots? — Yes.
In which part of the pit? — In the Busty.
Which part of the Busty? — I have seen shots fired in the North Crosscut. I have worked in the North Crosscut myself and had shots fired for me.
Where was the shot? — The shot was flanked over into the left side.
Was the shot in the roof or where? — It was not in the roof, it was in the band.
How far was the shot hole from the roof? — The shot hole bears into the roof. This is the top and this is the bottom (pointing to the diagram).
(The Coroner.) There was a coal, and band of stone between the coal? — Yes, it is a coal and band altogether that is being shot down.
(Mr. Edge.) As I understand there are six inches of coal at the top, then nine inches of band and then three feet two inches of coal? — Yes.
Will you point out to me whereabout the drill hole had been? — In the top above the coal.
Then they shoot down band and coal together? — Yes.
How was it driven, was the shot-hole straight in? — No, inclined to the left.
Was it driven up like that or horizontally? — It was driven pretty level in.
When he put the lighted touch up there, how was it he did not fire that foul gas that you say was along here in the roof? — The touch would not ignite the gas.
Where had he got the touch before he put it up, where did he light it? — He lighted it in the middle of the rolley way.
He lighted it below and put it up here (pointing to the diagram)? — Yes.
Your idea is that there would be quite enough gas there to show on a lamp? — I think so.
Sufficient at any rate for a man who was accustomed to fire shots and to examine for gas to detect the gas? — If they examine and know the gas.
Your theory is that she went out-by from that right and left along this back narrow board? — Yes.
What did she do here (pointing to the diagram) did she cross over to the innermost Stenton? — Yes, I think she hung fire in the innermost Stenton.
The indications between that innermost Stenton and the end of the first pillar are in-by? — Not in the Stenton.
But between the first innermost Stenton and the first pillar the indications are in-by? — Yes.
How do you account for the blast coming in that way? — She came through here (pointing to the diagram).
She came through the innermost Stenton into the Fore Crosscut? — Yes, she goes against the air here, into these east boards.
(Mr. Bowey.) Which east boards? — These here (pointing to the diagram).
(Mr. Edge.) She goes through here, along here, and into these east boards against the air? — Yes, and on to the main Fore Crosscut.
And out that way (pointing to the diagram)? — No, and in again.
Why did she not go straight down here when she came out of the Stenton? — Because I think the air at that point was stronger than the fire.
You think the air was enough to keep back the force of the explosion? — The force of the fire there.
According to you the fire would not travel against a good sweep of air coming in-by? — It would depend upon the quantity of gas that was lit.
Have you ever been in any explosion before? — No, this was the first one.
I take it according to you she was not able to go out there (pointing to the diagram), she went down this way because the dust was not able to meet the air coming in? — No.
Do you think she got at all from this district into this narrow board, I mean from the Fore Crosscut into the narrow board district? — I could not see any fire between the narrow board and that first east board.
Is it your conclusion then that she did not go from the South Crosscut at all north out of the south Fore Crosscut? — No.
Where did she expend herself? — The indications through the second Stenton, of charring on the props in that Stenton, are on the east side of the props.
Where did she expend herself when she did not go out. The blast divided and cam into this Fore Crosscut and never went into the narrow boards at all? — She recoiled in here through this Stenton of this back headways.
Down the Back Crosscut? — Yes.
Your theory would be that she recoiled and travelled back over the ground she had already come and followed the other blast? — No, I say she recoiled here (pointing to the diagram), and split. The indications are through that Stenton on the east side of the props, and the indications on the back Crosscut are on the south side of the props.
Tell me this, how were those doors blown? — There was no door there when I was first in.
Did you look to see where they had gone to? — I say there was no door there.
But did you look to see where it had gone? — There was no door there to my knowledge.
Did you look to see which way the stopping that is nearly opposite the entrance to the North Crosscut had been blown? — No.
You did not look? — No.
Would it be inconsistent with your theory if that stopping had been blown south? — As I understand it your theory is that the blast had got into the North Crosscut and come along the Back South Crosscut? — Yes.
And travelled into the North Crosscut? — Yes, into the North Crosscut, but not on this point. I did not say she travelled in on this point. That stopping there is taken right to the far side of the return board.
Your theory then is that she came out of this Back Crosscut, crossed over this narrow board here (pointing to the diagram), and drove that stopping into the return? — Yes.
Where did she go from there? — She travelled down the return under the over-cast.
Where did she go then? — The next wall away from that. She travelled to the next wall below that to the back headways ; there was a stopping in that wall, and that wall was driven off.
Do you know that that stopping was blown into the return, that that regulator board was blown into the return? — That is the stopping below. The back headways stopping was blown north. The regulating stopping from that east flat was blown into the return.
Then you have got the blast as far as this, you have got it out-by in the return past the crossing of North Crosscut? — Yes.
Where did it go from there? — Along here up this wall, down that board (pointing to the diagram), east.
And it went east there and up here to McCabe's place? — Yes.
And then out by here (pointing to the diagram)? — No, it went round here (pointing).
And recoiled her (pointing)? — Yes.
It came down here (pointing)? — Yes.
And blew those tubs out in that direction? — The tub tops.
According to your theory it never travelled up the North Crosscut rolley way? — I could not say that she had travelled.
Your theory is that she did not travel, and that she took the returns here (pointing to the diagram) to the east of the North Crosscut, went under this crossing, and went along the first headways board? — Yes.
And travelled up there on pillars and then took over and went along the side into McCabe's place? — Yes.
And did she come out-by from McCabe's place? — Yes, she came out-by along here, and along the second wall, and through the flat and out-by.
Do you think she went at all north up here, up towards the north narrow boards? — I was never up there ; I have seen two walls in there.
Did you see that those westernmost stoppings in the East Crosscut had been blown south? — They were not blowing south, one was blowing north, there was one or two blown north, but I am not positive which of the stoppings it was.
Did you see any bricks here at the crossing blown east and west in the return? — Yes, there were bricks lying all ways.
Where did those bricks come from? — I am not prepared to say where they came from? — Do not you think that the bricks came from that crossing? — I cannot say.
If they came from that crossing, how could they be blown westward, if your theory is correct with reference to the course of the blast? — For the bricks to have been blown west. I cannot give an answer to that question. The bricks were blowing all ways, and I cannot exactly say.
You have spoken of finding a door north of the flat of the east-going board ; did you make any inquiries as to whether an old door had been lying there? — I did not make any inquiries.
(The Coroner.) He only found the band.
(Mr. Edge.) Yes. (To the witness.) Did you make any inquiries as to whether and old door had been lying there. You spoke of the north of the flat of the East Crosscut ; you say there was a fall, and under that you found a hinge? — Part of a door, a hinge.
Had you been in there shortly before the explosion? — No.
Do you know whether, as a fact, a door had been lying about the place of that fire? — I made inquiries about the fire, and they told me there was an old door standing at the out-by side of the door ; it was standing in the flat end.
Who told you that? — Mr. Colquhoun.
You have spoken to the props ; I will draw your attention to this point. According to you, the blast does not go up this North Crosscut here (pointing to the diagram), but it goes along here and travels up this district and recoils down here, and comes out there. Do you think it went north after it had recoiled, and come out-by the east going board? — I think the force had gone up there, north ; it had travelled north.
Then you support that theory by saying that you found burning on the props along up there (pointing to the diagram)? — A slight burning.
How many props did you see the slight burning on, between that east going board and the north narrow boards? — It might be two.
How many props were there in thas district? — Not many, I know that ; I did not count them.
Where were the two props on which you found the charring? — I could not say exactly the place. I did not take that particular notice where the props stood.
Can you say whether it was half way up? — No, I cannot exactly I tell you.
Or close to the east -going board or where? — I cannot exactly tell you about the props.
You were going down to make notes to form a theory with regard to the cause of the explosion? — Yes.
And you did not take any notice of where these two props were? — No.
Did you notice the props that were up at the North Crosscut rolley way? — I noticed the two tubs.
Did you notice a prop there at the innermost east board, did you see a prop there with a crab tree on it? — I cannot say exactly.
Charred on the east end? — I will not swear to seeing a prop there. I can remember the tubs at that point.
You say that you saw a prop in McCabe's board six yards long, and that you saw on the prop indications of burning, on the west side of the prop? — Yes.
Did you pay any attention to the other props in that part? — Yes, further in.
What did you see there? — All round them there was charring.
Do you think it is impossible that gas could have come off there in that hitch on Middlemas and McCabe? — It might be possible.
Do you think that any inference can be drawn from their bait being found up there and one tin open, the cork drawn from one tin and one of their lamps being found there, and the other lamp being found further out? — Yes, they heard the explosion and run out.
How do you account for the stone that was found on the top of the lamp and on the top of the bait? — I did not see the stone on the top of the lamp, and therefore I cannot speak of it.
But we have heard that there was a stone on the top of one of the lamps and on the top of the bait? — I cannot speak for the stone ; I can only speak to what I saw.
Supposing the stone was there, how do you account for its coming there, did it come there after the explosion or when? — I cannot say when.
Just let me understand this almost finally. Your theory is that the blast did not go in along the east-going board but that it came out of the recoil? — It went in as well.
Where did it come from if it went in along the east-going board. I thought your theory was that the blast travelled up here where McCabe was, and came out with the recoil? — The indications are that it travelled that way.
What indications did you see going in-by there? — There are indications of its going into the east board here, that is the blowing of the tubs.
I thought the tops of the tubs were blown out-by? — Yes, and the bottoms in.
How do you know that the bottoms were blown in? — By the way they were set up.
You mean that they were set up one on the top of the other? — Yes.
Do you think the bottoms had been blown and the tops had been left where the tubs had been standing? — No, I think the recoil brought the tubs to the position that I saw them in.
The recoil from this district here, of course, is on the assumption that the explosion did not travel north up this headway into the north narrow board? — I have not been up into that narrow board.
But it is on that assumption? — Yes.
If it did travel north you could not account for the recoil you suggest. If the explosion which passed McCabe and Middlemas had travelled north along the in-take into the north narrow boards, you could not account for your suggested recoil? — Certainly, I could account for it.
How could you account for it? — The recoil would be there.
From what? — Along that headways.
But what would be the cause of the recoil? — I cannot say.
You have given us as the cause of the recoil, that the explosion was not there to face the fresh air ; but that will not answer up here, because if the explosion went along into those north narrow boards how do you account for the recoil? — There was a fall in there. I do not know whether that was after the explosion or before.
Do you suggest that there had been a fall in there before the explosion which prevented the blast going north and that that caused the recoil down here in the east-going board. If there was no fall as you suggest there, how would you produce the recoil? — Everything would be down when she travelled in there.
But how do you suggest the recoil occurred. Would there have been a recoil if that way had been open there, if there had been no fall in this in-take north (pointing to the diagram)? — I am not prepared to say whether there would have been a recoil or not.
Would there have been a recoil if that had been open? — No.
Where did you first hear about recoils? — I have read about them.
Where did you read about them? — I have read about them in Managers' inspections, at the Seaham for one colliery, I have read the Seaham explosion.
And on the Seaham explosion you have formed your theory of this place? — Yes.
Where was the recoil in the Seaham explosion? — I am not prepared to say. I have not got it off by heart.
Where do you make out the recoil in the Seaham explosion. You have got some idea of recoil from the Seaham explosion and you have applied it to this place? — I formed my own idea in this place.
You could not have formed your own idea about recoils ; you say that you have read the Seaham explosion? — I have read different ones.
Have you read any other explosion that enables you to form a judgement upon the theory of recoils? — I formed my own judgement on it in this case.
Re-examined by Mr. BOWEY.
About the crossing which Mr. Edge asked you about ; you said the bricks were blown all ways? — Yes.
And that you think to be quite consistent with the blast going in the direction which you suggest? — Yes.
And with reference to the men in the east-going board running out because they heard the explosion, you mean when they heard the explosion from this part (pointing to the diagram)? — Yes.