1882 West Stanley Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
West Stanley Inquest, Second Day, Friday, 26th May, 1882 (cont.).
Mr. William Johnson called again, further examined by Mr. EDGE.
Did you find these lamps? — Yes.
Where did you find Hutchinson's lamp? — Lying amongst the water in the South Crosscut. It was lying about here (pointing to the plan). This one here and this one here (pointing to the plan).
(Mr. Bell.) Whose lamp is that? — That is Douglass' lamp.
Where was it found? — These two lamps (pointing to Hutchinson's and Douglas's lamps) were lying very near together, not far from each other.
Were they lying close? — Yes.
(The Coroner.) One was next to Douglass' who was the other next to? — Next to Westgarth.
(Mr. Bowey.) Where was Hutchinson's lamp found? — Very near to the South Crosscut near to where Westgarth's lamp was found, they were both lying amongst the water in the South Crosscut.
Hutchinson's and Douglass'? — Yes.
(Mr. Edge.) Where was Riley's lamp found? — Riley's lamp was found just at this corner (pointing to the plan), opposite where this canvas was burnt.
Is that the Fore Crosscut? — Just at the Stenton end of the Fore Crosscut, they were nearly found both together.
Where was Westgarth's lamp found? — It was found here (pointing to the plan).
There were three lamps found there? — No, two were found here (pointing to the plan).
(Mr. Atlkinson.) Were not those two lamps that are so blackened both found at the Stenton? — Yes.
Hutchinson had his lamp close to his hand, had he not? — Yes, he was lying -----
(Mr. Edge.) Do attend to the question. Hutchinson's lamp was found about the Middle Stenton, and he himself was found there (pointing to the plan)? — Yes.
Where was Hutchinson's lamp? — It was lying out here amongst the water.
I thought you said in answer to Mr. Atkinson that it was found almost near his hand? — No, it was lying out by the side of him.
(Mr. Atlkinson.) It was in the Stenton? — Yes, Hutchinson's lamp was found out here, amongst the water.
(Mr. Atlkinson.) But Hutchinson had a lamp in his hand or close to his hand when he was found.
(The Coroner.) Was there a lamp near to Hutchinson when he was found? — It was one of these two. I cannot say which one it was.
(Mr. Edge.) Those two black lamps, where were they both found? — I think they were both found in here (pointing to the plan).
They were found out near the second innermost Stenton?
(Mr. Bell.) The out-by side of the Stenton.
(Mr. Edge.) Yes, between the first and second Stenton.
(Mr. Atlkinson.) My impression is that the lamps were found one out here, and the other was found at the corner of the Stenton in here (pointing to the plan).
(The Witness.) These lamps (indicating them) were found out-by.
Mr. Bell made a sketch and handed it to Mr. Edge.
(Mr. Edge to Mr. Colquhoun.) Can you tell me whereabouts upon Mr. Bell's sketch the lamps were found?
(Mr. Colquhoun.) There was one found close here (pointing to the plan). That is Westgarth's. The two bright ones were found close to the face of this Stenton (pointing to the plan) between here and the face.
(Mr. Atlkinson.) There were two lamps in the face of the Fore Crosscut.
(Mr. Colquhoun.) There was one lying here near to the corner.
(Mr. Bell.) Whom did that belong to?
(Mr. Colquhoun.) I cannot say that. They were the two bright lamps.
(Mr. Bell.) The two cleanest lamps were found in the Fore Headways?
(Mr. Colquhoun.) Yes.
(Mr. Bell.) Where were the two blackened ones found?
(Mr. Colquhoun.) One was found here at the Stenton, near to this man, and the other was further out, that is to say, lying about here (pointing to the plan). One was found here, and the other was found out here. One blackened lamp was found at the innermost Stenton, and the other was found just entering the Fore Crosscut.
(The Coroner.) To whom did the blackened lamps belong?
(Mr. Colquhoun.) "Douglass" is marked on one, and the other is Hutchinson's.
(Mr. Bell.) The other lamp you say was here. Is that anything like it (handing a sketch to Mr. Colquhoun)?
(Mr. Colquhoun.) Yes.
(Mr. Bell.) Where were the bright lamps found?
(Mr. Colquhoun.) In this part here (pointing to the plan) ; when I saw it this lamp was standing here.
(Mr. Bell.) Not right up in the face?
(Mr. Colquhoun.) No ; they were within a yard or two of each other. I think Mr. Atkinson had brought them out in the face and lit them there.
(Mr. Bell to Mr. Atkinson.) Did you find the lamps?
(Mr. Atlkinson.) There were two lamps in the face of the Fore Crosscut when Mr. Johnson and I went in. I do not think I brought them out ; I think Mr. Johnson did.
(The witness.) I think the men behind us found the lamps, and they drew our attention to them as they found them.
(Mr. Bell.) I observe one of the bright lamps is unlocked, it is marked "Riley ;" and one of the blackened lamps is also unlocked ; do you know whether these men carried keys, Riley and the man that the other lamp belongs to? — Douglass did carry a key.
Is Douglass' lamp unlocked? — Yes.
Is Riley's lamp unlocked to? — There are two of them unlocked ; but I think it is Westgarth's lamp that is unlocked.
Did Westgarth carry a key? — No.
(The Coroner.) Were one or two of these men authorised to fire shots? — Douglass fired the shots.
He was the authorised person? — Yes.
(Mr. Morley.) Was a key found on Westgarth? — I do not know. I cannot tell you anything about that ; it would go home with him in his clothes I suppose. I do not know that any of the men examined his pockets for a key or anything like that.