1882 West Stanley Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
West Stanley Inquest, First Day, Thursday, 25th May, 1882 (cont.).
William Middlemas called.
The Coroner read the previous deposition of the witness, which was as follows :—
"I am a deputy employed at the West Stanley Colliery. On the 19th April 1882, after hearing of the explosion I went down to assist in recovering dead bodies. When in East Flat of west district Busty Seam, about 400 yards by the travelling way from the shaft, saw the dead body of my son William Middlemas lying behind a tub on the main road. His bait was about 20 yards on the inside of him. He was burnt on brow, a little on feet, and on the hands, clothing rather singed. The dead body of James McCabe (No. 12) was lying at the same place. One of my son's legs was lying across part of his body. Heads close together. It appeared as if they had been hurrying towards the shaft and tumbled up against the tub that was standing in the main road and had fallen one on the other and laid there."
Is that correct? — Yes.
Did it appear to you as if your son and the other lad had run when they heard the gas coming off? — Yes.
That was what you thought, that they had run when they heard the gas come off? — Yes.
And they tumbled up against this tub and fell down? — Yes.
Were they burnt? — Yes, they were burnt. I did not see much of it but he was burnt on the brow and a little bit of the neck.
They had not been firing shots there? — No, they had not.
Did you notice where his bait can was? — It was about 20 yards further in by him.
Did you notice where his lamp was? — No.
Did you notice the other bait can? — No.
Did you notice that one of the bait cans had got the stopper out, or the cork out? — I cannot say about that. I did not take particular notice because I was that much put about.
You are a deputy in this Busty Seam? — Yes.
Had you been down the fore shift on the 18th? — Yes.
Which district had you been in? — I travelled to the north and east district first.
That was the district in which your son was found? — Yes. Then I travelled from there to the west district.
Did you go into the South Crosscut? — Yes, I travelled into the South Crosscut ; I travelled round the face.
Did you examine for gas in those three districts? — All of them.
Did you find any gas at all there? — Not that morning ; not at all.
Did you hear any hissing? — We heard the hissing in the east-going board.
Have you tried for gas when you have heard the hissing? — Yes, frequently I have tried for it.
Have you ever found gas when you have heard hissing? — No.
You have never been able to find gas coming off, although you have heard the hissing? — Not off the bottom, but I have found gas in the east-going board.
How long ago was that? — About a month before the explosion.
Was there much gas there? — No.
That was before the men went in? — Yes, it was when we were in the fore shift.
Did you get the gas away? — Yes. I tried the place, and I cleared it. I cleared it off with the brattice.
Do you know how the gas came to be there? — No, I cannot say exactly where it came from, but I have found it in the top over and over again.
Were any shots fired on the fore shift on the 18th? — I fired two, one in the east-going board five walls north.
Where did you fire the other? — In the South Crosscut, in the Back Crosscut.
(The Coroner.) What board in the South Crosscut? — The innermost board in the back head, right on at the back head.
(Mr. Bell.) Is that the west board? — Yes.
(Mr. Edge.) How was the air on the 18th? — I found all things right ; nothing wrong that I could explain to anybody.
Was the air going round the face? — Yes, it was ; everything was going right.
It was going well round the face? — Yes.
Did you ever hear any complaints either about gas or the ventilation of the pit? — No one ever made any complaints to me.
Cross-examined by Mr. Bowey.
Did you report that gas which you found in the east flat a month ago? — No, I did not.
Why did not you report it? — Because I did not think it my duty to do so.
What did you think was your duty? — My duty is, when I take the brattice off I call it my duty to report it.
What did you report that day? — We reported "all right."
And you would have reported "all right" if you had found no gas at all? — Certainly.
Have you read the special rules? — Yes, I read the Government rules on the pit heap.
Have you not had a copy of the special rules? — No, I got hold of a copy, but it is many years since I got those rules.
How long have you been at this colliery? — 25 years.
Have you never read the special rules? — Yes, when I got that book, but that is long since ; there has been a fresh lot since that, I expect.
And you think it is not your duty to report gas if you clear it away? — No, I do not think it is.
Do you know the 22nd rules under the head of "Deputy" : "To enter a report of the state of his district each day in the report book and sign the same "? — Yes.
(The Coroner.) The deputies here have only 14 rules to learn, and you have got a lot more ; how is that? — Our deputy rules end with 14 ; where do yours come from, Mr. Bowey.
(Mr. Bowey.) From Mr. Cooper.
(Mr. Johnson.) Those rules were in force five years before my time.
(Mr. Bowey.) Have you got a certified copy, Mr. Cooper?
(Mr. Cooper.) No.
(Mr. Bell.) We must have the rules in force at this colliery.
(The Coroner.) Those, I believe we have. These rules in the book with the orange cover.
(Mr. Bell.) They are wrong, they are not the established rules, they are not in force.
(The Coroner.) Mr. Edge's client, I have no doubt, will be able to prove them by and bye.
(Mr. Edge.) It is pointed out to me that this is the Lamp Pit rule, and the other is for the Clanny Pit ; it is the Lamp Pit that we are dealing with. I have been going on the Clanny Pit rule.
(The Coroner.) Then we had better withdraw these rules in the orange coloured book.
(Mr. Bowey, to the witness.) Do you know this 22nd rule, or have you read the rules at all? — Yes.
Have you read the special rules of the colliery at any time? — I read the special rules that relate to the Lamp Pit, but it is a long time since.
How long a time is it since you read them? — It is that long since than I can hardly tell. I found it in the book you see.
Is it 10 years ago? — I would not like to say.
It may be 15 years ago when you read them? — I would not say that ; it may be.
But you know there have been fresh special rules since you read those? — Yes ; I read a long report of the rules on the pit heap.
Do you know that since you read those rules so many years ago there have been new special rules for this colliery? — I cannot say.
Do you know that? — I have not got anything fresh you know.
Do you know whether there was a rule in the copy which you read which said that the deputy was to enter a report of the state of his district each day in the report book, and sign the same? — I never heard of the fact, but I read them on the pit heap, I tell you.
Did you read them on the pit heap 15 years ago? — No.
Then when did you read them? — Two years ago.
Did you read such a rule as that "to enter a report of the state of his district each day in the report book, and sign the same? — Yes, it may be that I did, but at the same time it is a question.
Did you know that that was one of the rules? — Yes.
Do you think you recorded the state of your district on that on which you found gas by entering "all right"? — Yes, I think I did.
When did you last fire a shot in that district? — Which district.
The east-going board? — About a month ago ; before the explosion. No, I fired one for Watson during the fortnight I was in last.
In that east-going board? — Yes.
When did you last fire a shot before the explosion? — During the fortnight I was last in.
In the fortnight just before the explosion? — Yes, one shot. I only fired one.
And your last shot in the South Crosscut was when? — The morning before the explosion.
Did you ever find gas in the South Crosscuts? — Never.
You have examined for it? — Yes, I have, properly.
You cannot say that there was gas coming off in that district in which you found your son and Middlemas, which caused them to come away? — No, I cannot say that.
Have you any opinion as to where the gas came off? — I cannot say, much. I only have this opinion. I knew gas had been reported in that district, and my own opinion was that it came from some quarter in the south district.
That is down here (pointing to the diagram)? — Yes.
When were there any shots fired there? — A good while back.
How long ago? — Months back.
How many months back? — Ever since the working started.
How many months ago? — Five or six months ; six months since, I would think.
Can you write? — Yes.
Is there any restriction put upon you for shot firing in the colliery during the day time? — It is very seldom we have fired in coal. I have fired them.
If a man wants a shot fired in the colliery during the day time, have you any orders not to fire it? — No.
Have you any orders that it shall not be fired? — We have no orders that it shall not be fired.
Have you orders that it shall be fired? — I ask the overman as regards the shot being fired, or else I must fetch the man out of the place. That is the way we have done it.
Have you a certificate to fire shots? — No, we have no certificate to do it, but Mr. Johnson would give them the privilege to fire a shot if needed, I expect.
To whom does he give the privilege? — He would give the privilege to the men.
If the men wanted a shot fired the deputy is bound to fire it for them, is he not? — Yes.
Before you fire a shot, what do you do? — Examine the place.
How do you examine the place? — When I go into the place I take my lamp, and I put my lamp down, and I try and if I can find it I enlarge my light to see if she will draw any, and if she will not draw then I cannot say if there is any at all.
Did you examine behind the brattice? — Yes.
Did you go right up behind the brattice? — I will not say behind the brattice, but I go yards back into the brattice to see.
Can you travel through behind the brattice? — Not in all places, but still there is plenty of room for you to travel.
Is that the only place you examine before firing a shot? — I examine all places before I fire a shot.
Do you examine the next board? — Yes, if I know a man is going to fire a shot I go to the nearest board first ; I go in there first generally and then I go to the man that wants the shot fired.
Do you go to the back board? — I do not go to the back board, but I go yards back into the face you know.
What is your opinion is the cause of this hissing or singing noise from the bottom? — I say it is through gas working with the water.
Does gas ever cause the bottom to heave? — Yes.
Is there much heaving in the pit? — These east-going boards heave very much.
Generally they heave more than others? — Yes.
Which of your boards heave the most? — These east-going boards.
Take the board north of that (pointing to the diagram) did that heave? — Yes, that is the east-going board ; that heaves very much.
Take the second and third boards north of that, did they heave? — We have sometimes to cut the planks out, and that showed she was heaving.
To come to the south side of that east-going board, did the boards heave there? — Yes, a little bit too, but not so much on the south side of the going board as they did down at the north.
Have you any heaving in the South Crosscuts? — No.
Have you had any singing there? — No.
A hissing noise or singing? — No.
Have you met with any gas when you have met with a fault? — No.
You say you make no entry in the report book when you find gas, if you able to clear it away with the brattice? — Yes.
Do not you think if gas has collected there before, there is danger of its collecting there again, in the same place? — I cannot say how it is.
Cannot you answer that question? — I task the back-overman and the fore-overman, or else I must fetch the men out of the place. — If I report it, I must stop the place altogether if I report gas.
Did you say that you were not to report it under those circumstances? — Yes, just so.
How long before the time you find gas and clear it away with the brattice has it been examined, how long before the previous examination had take place. I mean how long is it since it was previously examined by you? — Till the man that comes in after me.
I am speaking of before the time you find it, 12 hours or 24 hours before you find it? — The night shift man goes round ; that is, the night shifter goes round and examines the place as well as us.
So that it would have been only six hours? — It was only about three or four hours.
And in that three or four hours the gas had collected? — Yes, if he saw anything of the kind he always told us about it.
It must have collected in the three or four hours before you got there? — Yes.
Do not you consider that the gas again collecting there would be dangerous? — When I go in, if I find it, I put the brattice to, to keep it well up, you know.
(Mr. Bell.) What is your rule with regard to the distance of the brattice from the face? — Six feet from the face.
Do you go six feet under the band before you take it down? — From the face?
In that way it should be close up to the band? — Yes.
Would not the blowing down of that be likely to blow the brattice down? — Some blows down and some wedges down.
Cross-examined by Mr. Bowey.
You say the reason why you do not report gas when you find it, and clear it away is that if you report it you will not be able to get a man for the place? — Yes.
And that is the reason why you do not report it? — I reported it if I saw it, because I think it was not fit for a man to go there.
Why did you not report that you had seen gas and cleared it away? — Because I did not think it was necessary to enter it in the book.
Is your reason for not putting it in the book that you would not be able to get a man for the place? — No, that is not it at all.
But if you did enter it you would not get a man for the place? — That makes no odds. If I found it I would not send anyone.
Therefore you did not enter it? — I could not when there was none, when I cleared it away.
If gas could collect in three or four hours from the time when the place had been last examined. Do not you think it was a proper thing for you to enter it in the book in order that that place might be more particularly watched? — Not if I could clear it away.
But it might not be found if you did not report it? — That is the question, the brattice not being duly up.
You did not see that any other precaution was used for that place when you found it? — We are asked that question, if we have a report, and then we clear it away.
Who was it that you said you were not to report it? — The back overman and the fore overman.
What is the name of the back overman? — He is not here. Thomas Coulson.
Who was the fore overman that told you that you were not to report it? — William Anderson.
When did he tell you that? — Long since.
Many years ago? — Not many.
Was it a month or two ago? — It was more than that.
How many years ago was it? — About a couple of years.
Before that, whenever you found gas, did you always report it? — I never had occasion. I never found any.
That was more than two years ago, you say? — Only once.
How long was that ago? — Two years ago.
And that was the time you asked him? — That was the time I asked Mr. Johnson.
When was it that you asked Anderson? — It is just about that time when I found it again, but I cleared it away.
You found it twice? — Yes ; but then this was the time that I could not get the place on.
Once you spoke to Mr. Johnson, the manager, about it, and on the other occasion you spoke to Anderson? — Yes.
Which was the occasion on which you could not get it away? — The time I mentioned it to Mr. Johnson.
What did he say? — He asked me the state the place was in, and I told him, and he went directly down the pit and he see the state I told him, and he examined it himself.
Did you make any report in the book of that? — No ; I left it to he ; he said he would go and see the place himself.
Did you make any report in the book? — No.
Did you not put anything in the book for that day? — Yes, I put it in the book my usual way.
Did you mention that place in the book? — No, I mentioned it to Mr. Johnson.
When was that? — About two years ago.
What place was that? — In the North district.
Do I understand you to say that you only found gas twice? — I found it them two times.
That is all? — Yes.
As I understand you, the reason why you did not report gas in your book was that you got it cleared away? — All that was left. I asked Mr. Johnson about it, and he gave me a statement of the place.
You thought that you were not bound to report gas if you got it cleared off and set the men to work? — No, certainly not ; there is no occasion to report gas where you can clear it away.
If a man wanted a shot fired, would the deputy fire the shot if he did not find the place clear? — Not likely ; no, sir.
Then it is not correct to say that if a man wants a shot fired the deputy is bound to fire it? — No ; if he thinks it is not fit he will not fire it either.
At the time when you did not report this, when you cleared the gas away with the brattice, was there anything wrong with the brattice, or anything of that kind to allow the gas to accumulate? — No, nothing more than the man had not got his band down when I set him up, and then I set him up and up.
The man had not bratticed it up? — No, he was the back shift deputy, because I was the fore shift during that time.
This had not been done the night before? — No.
It allowed the gas to accumulate there? — Yes.
The rules that you read are the rules that are on the pit heap? — That is all the rules on the pit heap.
(Mr. Bell.) Could we have that particular place pointed out on the plan where Mr. Johnson thought it necessary to go and inspect it after Middlemas had made the report.
Mr. Johnson pointed it out on the plan.
(Mr. Bell, to the witness.) Is that the place you were alluding to? — Yes, that is the place where I found it when I stated it to Mr. Johnson, and he went down the pit and looked at it himself.
Before the present pit was sunk? — No.
(Mr. Edge to Mr. Johnson.) The rules that are on the pit heap now are these rules, are they not (handing a book to Mr. Johnson)? — Yes.
They have been on the pit heap more than two years, and they are the same rules as these? — Yes.
They are the rules for the Lamp Pit? — Yes.
(Mr. Bowey.) Have you a certified copy of the pit rules? — No, I have never seen it.
Do you know where it is? — No.
Is it in the office? — No, or I would have found it before this time.
You have searched for it? — Yes.
(The Coroner.) The book of rules published in 1874 we have before us, and Rule No. 14 under the head of "Deputy," and the rule under the same head of "Deputy" No. 22 in the book of 1873 are precisely alike, word for word, "To enter a report of the state of his district each day in the report book and sign the same." As the rules are under consideration at the present moment, it is just as well to draw attention to the fact that they are both the same.
(Mr. Bowey.) Although for different collieries?
(The Coroner.) Yes, but they are word for word the same.