1882 West Stanley Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
West Stanley Inquest, First Day, Thursday, 25th May, 1882 (cont.).
James Knox, sworn, examined by Mr. Edge.
Were you a deputy in the fore shift on the 18th of April in the Busty Seam? — Yes.
How long have you been a deputy? — About a year.
How long have you been working in the pits? — About 14 years.
At what time did you go down on the 18th April? — About half past 2 o'clock in the morning.
At what time did you come to bank? — About 10 o'clock.
Which district were you in on the 18th? — In the north headways of the south flat.
Did you try for gas on that day? — Yes.
Did you find any? — No.
How was the ventilation when you left the pit? — Good.
Did you hear any singing? — No.
Had there been any shots fired in the south flat for a long time? — No, not for a very long time.
Have you ever heard any complaints with regard to gas or ventilation? — No.
Cross-examined by Mr. Bowey.
That is the only district you were in? — Yes.
When did you last find gas in the south district? — About two months previous to the explosion.
Where was it? — In the south.
But whereabout was it? — In the first headways in the south flats.
Did you report it? — Yes.
Have you your report book? — It is before you.
(Mr. Edge.) The 17th and 18th March are the dates of the reports.
(Mr. Bowey.) What book did you report it in? — In the deputy report book at the office.
Is that the book (handing a book to the witness)? — Yes.
You had no other book? — No.
(The Coroner.) You are only speaking of the first headways? — That was the last time I saw it.
Did you see gas in the second headways? — Yes.
(Mr. Bowey.) How long have you been in these districts? — About nine months.
Where were you before? — I was in the west district for about three months.
Did you ever find any gas there? — No, never.
Have you been in the South Crosscut? — Yes, I have been in.
But I mean acting as deputy in that district? — No.
Have you ever been in that district where Middlemas and McCabe were found? — No, not working deputy work.
You never saw gas in there? — No.
Is this what you would call a " fiery " mine? — I would not like to say it is a " fiery " mine. I never see much gas in it.
Have you seen any? — Yes, I have seen gas.
Whereabout have you seen it? — I have seen it in the south district.
Did you ever find any in the north district? — No.
Did you ever find any in the west district? — No, never.
Did you know Purdy's place? — The east going board?
Yes? — Yes, I know it well.
Did you ever see gas in that district? — No.
Did you ever work in that district? — No.
When you see gas, is it your custom to report it in your book? — Yes, if the place is laid off on account of gas, I report it.
If you find gas in the morning when you go round, do you report that? — I have never found any yet, but if it laid the place off, I should report it.
Have you ever found a little gas in the board in the morning? — Never.
The deputy's book you say is kept at the office? — Yes.
Have the men, before going down the shaft, any opportunity of seeing it? — No, they have no opportunity of seeing it without they go to the office.
Before they go down, they have no means of ascertaining what the report of the deputy, who has examined the pit, is? — No.
Have you ever heard any singing, or bubbling, or hissing noise? — Yes, I have heard singing.
Whereabout have you heard it? — I have heard it in different places. I have heard it in the north district.
Where else have you heard it? — I heard it in the west district when I was there.
North or south in the west district? — It was in the north.
Have you found it generally over the colliery? — Not all over it ; just in the end places.
In the north and in the west ; in different places in the North Crosscuts? — Yes.
Have you found it in the east-going board in the North Crosscuts? — No, I have never been there much.
When you heard this singing noise, have you felt sure that there has been gas coming off at that place? — I have never found any gas, but expect it would be gas and water mixed together.
You understand that that noise is caused by gas and water? — Yes.
Have you always tried for gas when you have heard the noise? — Not always, but I have tried for it and never found any gas.
(Mr. Bell.) Do not you know that the hissing or bubbling up is caused by gas? — I expect it is caused by gas.
You think it is? — Yes, I think so.
(The Coroner.) But you have not been able to detect it with your lamp? — I have not.
Although your knowledge tells you that it was caused by gas? — Yes.
But it was not in sufficient quantity for you to detect with your lamp? — No.
(Mr. Bell.) Is not that a sign that the seam is giving off gas? — (No answer.)
(The Coroner.) You admit that that singing or hissing noise is caused by gas? — Yes.
But you say you could not detect it with your lamp? — No.
It was not in sufficient quantity for that? — No.
(Mr. Edge.) Do you happen to know whether you hear that singing noise in non-fiery mines as well as in-fiery mines? — I would not like to say.
(Mr. Bowey.) Are these reports of yours, of the 17th and 18th of March in your own handwriting? — Yes.
I presume if the men had chosen to ask to look at the reports, they could have seen them? — By going to the office.
How far is the office from the shaft? — About 200 yards.
(Mr. Bell.) Is that the colliery office?
(Mr. Edge.) I suppose it is, but I have never been there before.
(Witness.) Yes it is.
(Mr. Bell.) Would that office be open for the fore shift men to enter? — No, it would not be open for the fore shift men. I mean for the back shift men.
Then where would the fore shift men see the report? — They would see it when they read it. They could not see it when they went down.
But they would see it when they came back to bank? — Yes.
(Mr. Edge.) Do the deputies meet the men before they go down in the day shift? — Yes.
Do they tell the men anything about the state of the pit? — Not if the place is all right.
(Mr. Bowey.) For instance, did you tell them that you had found gas on the 17th and 18th of March? — The men knew, because the place was laid off ; they could not get into the place, I stopped them from going in.
On both occasions? — Yes.
You reported it and also stopped the men from going in on the 17th and 18th? — Yes.
That is to say into that portion where the gas was? — Yes.