1882 West Stanley Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
West Stanley Inquest, First Day, Thursday, 25th May, 1882 (cont.).
William Anderson, sworn, examined by Mr. Edge.
You are an overman in the West Stanley Pit? — Yes.
Were you down in the fore shift on the 18th of April? — Yes.
What time did you come out? — At 10 o'clock.
In the morning? — Yes.
Were you in the face in any part of the workings that day? — North and south I was.
Were you in the South Crosscut? — Yes, I was in the South Crosscut with Mr. Johnson.
Were you in the face in the South Crosscut? — Yes.
How was the South Crosscut when you were in? — Standing high well.
Did you see any sign of gas? — Not there .
Was the air good? — Yes.
The last witness, Middlemas, has told us that he mentioned, having found gas to you, and you told him that he need not report it ; do you remember that? — I do not remember saying it.
You do not remember it? — No, I do not.
Was the pit all right when you left on the morning of the 18th? — Quite right.
Cross-examined by Mr. Bowey.
When did you last see gas in the pit? — About seven or eight weeks back.
Where did you find it? — It was in the Back Crosscut.
Seven or eight weeks ago? — Yes.
Seven or eight weeks before the explosion? — Yes.
Did you report it? — I did not ; it was that small that you could just barely ken that it was there. I did not think it was necessary to report it, it was that small.
What did you do about it? — It was out and past, and gone before I left the place.
How long before that had you seen gas? — I really cannot say how long it is.
How did you find the gas ; did it show a blue cap? — Yes.
You are quite sure about it? — Yes.
And it was where, do you say? — In the Narrow Back Crosscut.
And you know that shots had been fired there since? — Yes.
What precautions have been taken in firing shots there? — Orders have been strictly given to the deputies to be careful about firing and examining the places.
Those were the orders they always had? — Yes.
Do you know anything about the clause in the Act of Parliament about firing shots within three months after gas has been found at a place? — I cannot say that I have read the Act.
Do you know that part of it ; have you heard of that? — No.
Do you know this clause which I will read to you, or have you ever heard anything like it, about firing shots within three months after inflammable gas has been found in any mine, "Gunpowder or other explosive or inflammable substance shall only be used in the mine underground as follows :— (a.) It shall not be stored in the mine. (b.) It shall not be taken into the mine except in a case or canister containing not more than four pounds. (c.) A workman shall not have in use at one time in any one place more than one of such cases or canisters. (d.) In charging holes for blasting, an iron or steel picker shall not be used, and a person shall not have in his possession in the mine underground any iron or steel picker, and an iron or steel tamping rod or stemmer shall not be used for ramming either the wadding on the first part of the tamping or stemming on the powder. (e.) A charge of powder which has missed fire shall not be unrammed. (f.) It shall not be taken into or be in the possession of any person in any mine, except in cartridges, and shall not be used, except in accordance with the following regulations during three months after any inflammable gas has been found in any such mine ; namely, (1.) A competent person, who shall be appointed for the purpose, shall, immediately before firing the shot examine the place where it is to be used, and the places contiguous thereto, and shall not allow the shot to be fired unless he finds it safe to do so, and a shot shall not be fired except by or under the direction of a competent person who shall be appointed for the purpose. (2.) If the said inflammable gas issued so freely that it showed a blue cap on the flame of the safety lamp, it shall only be used (a.) Either in those cases of stone drifts, stone work, and sinking of shafts, in which the ventilation is so managed that the return air from the place where the powder is used passes into the main return air course without passing any place in actual course of working ; or (b.) When the persons ordinarily employed in the mine are out of the mine or out of the part of the mine where it is used." Do you know anything about that? — I cannot say that I do.
Have you ever read the special rules of the colliery? — Yes.
Have you ever read the general rules? — The rules belonging to the colliery.
Have you read the general rules? — Yes.
And the abstract of the Act of Parliament? — No.
Have you a copy of this? — Yes.
Is an abstract posted upon the pit heap? — Yes.
Have you read the 8th general rule? — I cannot bear it in mind.
Have you ever seen a copy of the blue rules? — Yes.
(Mr. Edge.) Have you ever read this clause :— "If the said inflammable gas I issued so freely that it showed a blue cap on the flame of the safety lamp, it shall only be used (a.) Either in those cases of stone-drifts, stone work, and sinking of shafts, in which the ventilation is so managed that the return air course without passing any place in actual course of working ; or (b.) when the persons ordinarily employed in the mine are out of the mine, or out of the part of the mine where it is used." Have you ever read this? — I do not remember reading it.
(Mr. Bowey.) But you say that this gas did show a blue cap? — Yes, you could just ken that it did.
But you said that it showed a blue cap? — Yes.
And you did not know that there was anything in the general rules with regard to what you were told to do, or any extra precautions that you were to take when you found that gas showing a blue cap? — Yes.
Did shot firing go on in that place after that gas was found showing a blue cap in the same way that it had been done before? — Yes.
There was no difference made? — The place was properly examined.
It was examined before the gas showed with a blue cap, was it not? — Yes.
And it was properly examined afterwards? — Yes.
It was examined just in the same way as it had been done before? — Yes.
Had you ever found gas in any other part of the mine? — No.
You did not report this, did you? — No.
What did you report that day? — After the place was cleared out, and it was all right I reported all right.
Did you ever mention to anybody that you had seen the gas? — I did not know that I did.
You reported all right? — Yes, because the place was proper and right before I left.
And you would have reported all right if you had never found gas? — Yes.
That is to say, of course if other things had been right? — Yes.
Will you tell us what age you are? — 62 past.
How long have you been an overman? — Between 17 and 18 years.
Where have you been overman chiefly? — The West Stanley Colliery.
All the time? — Yes.
What were you before then? — Deputy.
At the same colliery? — Yes.
You know the system of ventilation of this colliery, I suppose, beginning at the shaft, and coming southward on the south way ; after you get past the turn to the flat you have a door there? — Yes.
What sort of door is that? — It is on the blue line straight in from the shaft (pointing to the plan).
What sort of door is it? — There was a canvas brattice in there.
Was that all the door you had? — There was a wooden doorway previous to the explosion.
What sort of door had you in there? — It was a door to admit a tubful.
A wooden door? — Yes.
Was it single or double? — It was a single door.
Had you a brattice so that you might make a double door of it? — One at each end.
To double that door had you a canvas brattice? — Yes.
Where was the canvas hung? — One by the side of the door, and one in the out-bye side.
Was the door locked? — Yes.
What sort of lock was it? — A long lock.
Who carried the key? — I had it.
Did anyone else have a key? — The back overman had one.
Anyone else? — No.
Now go up west. I see there is a man-hole door through the trouble ; what sort of door was that? — A man-hole door.
It is the second in pillar away ; what sort of door had you in there? — There was none in.
Between the intake and the return, I mean? — Yes.
Had you no door there? — No ; there was a man-hole door.
(Mr. Edge.) Was this at the man-hole door after you got by the trouble? — It was outside.
(Mr. Bell.) What kind of door had you there? — A proper man-hole bricked door.
Was it single? — Yes.
Was it a locked door? — Yes.
You had no double door there? — No.
Where were your next doors on that road? — The next door was the back end, within the East Flat way end.
Had you any door straight up above the North Crosscut? — There was a rolley way door standing inside.
Was that a single door? — Yes, it was a single door just then.
Before the explosion it was a single door? — Yes.
Are you sure about that? — Yes.
That was a door then into the return from the South Crosscuts? — No.
The air from the South Crosscuts returned up that Narrow Board, did it not? — It returned into the Back Board.
And went up the Narrow Board? — Yes.
We will go along the north way to the east going board ; that is where McCabe and Middlemas were found? — Yes.
There is a door marked there, the second pillar down ; what sort of a door was that? — The rolley way door stood in the east-going board by the side of the flat.
What sort of a door was it? — A single door.
Was there a boy to keep it? — Yes.
Now go to the West Flat, that is the wall further in-by, further north ; had you a door there? — Yes.
Was it a single or a double door? — Single.
Where were your caution boards placed? — There was one placed at each door.
We will take the South Way ; where was the caution board on the south side, south of the shaft? — It was in-by the end of the Flat.
Then in the North Way, that is straight north of the pit, where was the door? — It was this side of the Crosscut.
To go up west, where had you the next one? — The next one was within the Fore Crosscut end.
Where was your caution board on the North East Flat? — It was on the door.
And the West Flat? — On the door.
Then all your ventilation was depending upon single doors, from the doors going into the West Flat? — Yes.
All the ventilation was depending upon that single door just on the West Way End before you turn into the North Flat? — Yes.
Or rather beyond the North Flat? — Yes.
Then in the event of anything happening to that door the ventilation of the whole of your north and west district would lie dead? — I do not follow you.
If that door was left open or broken, would not the air escape into the main return ; would it not be a nearer pull to go into the top of the West way and come back down the Back Headway with the shaft than going in the North way and coming east and west, and round that way? — You could walk easier by coming north than by going up west, because she is a heavy hill to climb.
You have a heavy rise? — Yes.
Supposing the east door was broken, what would be the effect upon the west side? — If the east door had been broken we would have had nothing but what came by the west way.
Would any air have gone round to the west side? — Yes.
Although it is to the rise? — Yes.
Would not the same thing prevent the air going up that you told us would prevent the air going up this door where the rise is? — No ; of the current we had going there there was a portion going round that way (pointing to the plan).
What portion would have gone round? — I cannot exactly say.
You had no regulator in here below the one at the crossing (pointing to the plan? — She would have a stiff pull through here to the shaft.
And that is down hill, and she will come down the hill rather than go up? — Yes.
In that way it would lay your West-way dead, would it not? — But she would stand a chance of pulling the other way out.
She would stand a chance of pulling the East way out? — Yes.
I would like to see your report book.
A report book was handed to Mr. Bell.
Have you only one book? — Yes.
Is this book common to all of you? — Yes.
Have you any other pit besides the Busty Pit to attend to? — Shield Row Seam.
You said that you had seen the general rules of the colliery? — Yes.
Which of the general rules do you work under or make your reports under with regard to ventilation? — The first part of the book.
Those are the Special Rules. I am speaking of the General Rules. Take the General Rules in your hand (handing the same to the witness). Which of those rules do you make your reports under? I want to confine your attention to the General Rules. What is the difference between a General Rule and a Special Rule? — The one part belongs to the colliery altogether.
If you will just hand me that little book I will find the place and ask you which rule you make your reports under.
The book was handed to Mr. Bell.
Here we have in the General Rules, Rule No. 76, just follow on there and tell me under which of those rules you make your reports? — (The witness referred to the book.) It is quite right.
The first General Rule says that an adequate amount of ventilation shall be provided ; the second that certain inspections are to be made ; and the third also says that certain inspections are to be made ; under which of those rules do you make your inspection or report, the second or the third? Perhaps I could simplify it a little bit more for you. One rule refers to a fiery mine, and the other to a non-fiery mine ; which do you make your report under? — Under the fiery mine.
Then that is No. 2 rule? — Yes.
You make your report, I see in your printed form, under No. 3 rule, that is with respect to a non-fiery mine. Who gave you this book to report in? — The manager, Mr. Johnson.
Have you ever taken the trouble to compare this certificate here with the rule which you have in your hand, and which you are signing day by day? — I have not.
You simply go on signing this ; it might be under any other rule in the Act for anything you know? — I expect the book to be right.
But have you never taken the trouble to satisfy yourself that it was right? — No, I have not.
(Mr. Edge.) Will you let me look at what it is he does sign.
The book was handed to Mr. Edge.
Do you report, no matter whether it is under head No. 3 or head No. 2, truthfully to the best of your ability the state of the mine? — I do.
When you report that you have examined the mine and found it all right, you mean that? — Yes.
If you had found anything wrong in the mine you would not have reported that it was all right? — Not at all.
You have been asked about a door straight on along the West Narrow Board, that was a single door you told us? — Yes.
Was there any canvas at the back? — Yes, there was canvas at the back.
Behind? — Yes.
That would have the effect practically of making it a double door, would it not? — What I mean is that there were not double wooden doors.
There was a wooden door and then the canvas behind? — Yes.
Now you have been asked if anything happened to the door and the going board up in the East Northcuts working, the air would not have gone in, was there canvas across that going board before you got to the face? — There was canvas across the going board before you got to the face.
How far back from the face? — The out-by side of the innermost holing.
That would have a tendency to drive the air round its regular course? — Yes.
And I see that there were stoppings right along that board? — Yes.
On the day of the explosion was there any one working in this west district of the North Crosscut? — No.
No one was working in that district at all? — No.
When you found the gas down here in the South Crosscut (pointing to the plan), did you wait till you had satisfied yourself that it was all cleared away? — Yes, properly.
There was no danger? — Not the least.
Were you down the pit after the explosion? — Yes.
Whom did you go down with? — I would not like to say exactly just now, Mr. Johnson was one of the people.
When did you go down? — Somewhere about 2 o'clock in the morning as near as I can guess.
What district did you go into? — South and west from the shaft.
Have you been down also since then? — Yes.
Can you tell me this. I think we may take it wherever the explosion occurred, it did not occur in that North Headway? — No.
Have you examined for the indications down in the South Headway? — South from the shaft?
Yes, straight away south from the South Headway down that district? — Yes, I have been up there.
Did you see any indication going in in-by or out-by of that South Headway? — She had gone in-by, I think.
What did you see that made you think that? — From the indications of the timber line.
Do you mean that the timber showed indications of the blast having gone in-by? — Yes.
What did you notice about the timber? — At some places it was blown in-by, and in other places there were charred props in other directions.
Do you know where the Horse Flat is? — Yes.
Did you notice two tubs there? — Yes.
Did you notice how they had been blown? — Yes.
How were they blown? — Both in-by.
They were blown to the east? — Yes.
How does the flat there dip? — She dips to the west, and to the east.
Then the tubs were blown up the bank? — Yes.
Where did you find the tops? — In the contrary way that they should have been in the walls.
Did you notice whether the tubs were charred at all? — They were charred on the out-by end.
Did you notice any timber in the flats charred? — Not particularly.
Going along in-by the travelling way in that district did you notice whether there was any charring on the timber? — There was charring on the timber.
Which side was it charred on? — Some of it one side and some on the other, and some was charred all round.
The seventh East Board was the board next where Turner and Jobson were found? — Yes.
(Mr. Bell.) We think you might leave the North and South Flat Out-take West of the trouble.
(The Coroner.) The jury do not desire to have any further evidence in that direction. Go to the West.
(Mr. Edge.) Very well, sir. (To the witness) Going in-by along the Narrow Band district, what indications did you find there? — There were indications round by the Flat end.
Here is the first crossing and you go right along in here going west (pointing to the plan).
(Mr. Colquhoun.) Here is the crossing going in this way (describing). Here is the siding, and here is the flat end.
(Mr. Edge to the witness.) At the first crossing what did you notice? — A good deal of the bricks blown out-by.
How far were they blown out? — I did not measure the distance.
Coming along in, did you notice any sign till you come to the siding? — When you come tot the siding even the spring switch was blown along. The weights off the siding at both ends were blown eastwards.
Did you examine any of the timbers coming along in that district? — No, I did not.
Were all the stoppings on the north side of that West Narrow Board blown towards the returns? — Yes.
Do you know where the deputy's chest stood? — Yes.
In the second South Headway? — Yes.
(The Coroner.) That would be really just to the east of the double door? — Yes.
(Mr. Edge.) How far was the deputy's chest from the narrow crosscut road? — About 6 yards.
The in-by end of it? — Yes.
Did you notice that chest ; do you remember how that chest was after the explosion ; do you remember whether it had been blown one way or the other? — No, I think not.
Now we will go to the South Crosscut district ; did you see any indications in the South Crosscut district to tell you whether the blast had gone in in-by of the South Crosscut, or come out by the South Crosscut? — It rather puzzled me that.
Do you mean that the baulks were marked all round? — Yes.
You cannot say, can you, whether it went in-by or out-by by that South Crosscut? — I think it went in-by.
(The Coroner.) The baulks in the South Crosscut are charred all round? — Yes.
Which way do you think the blast went? — In-by.
(Mr. Edge.) Were you with Mr. Johnson, Mr. Colquhoun, and Mr. Atkinson when the cracket was found in the back headways? — No.
Where the North Crosscut takes off from the Narrow Board out-by of that, how had the blast gone. I am referring to this district (pointing to the plan), had the explosion gone out-by in that district or had it come in-by?
Mr. Colquhoun explained the direction of the blast to the Court.
(Mr. Edge to the witness.) Did you see any indications going in-by of the North Crosscut? — There was a great deal of the bricks from the over-cast which were blown out-by.
Were they blown into the return? — They were blown along the rolley way out by.
(The Coroner.) Not into the return? — No.
(Mr. Morley.) In the intake? — Yes.
(The Coroner.) Were they blown out-by in the intake? — Yes.
(Mr. Edge.) Did you see any other signs of how the blast had gone going along that North Crosscut? — Not particularly, I think.
Did you go into where McCabe's place had been, the east going board? — Yes.
Did you see any indications in there of how the blast had gone? — I did not make any particular notes down in that quarter, because there had been a great deal of working taken out when I had gone down.
When did you go into that quarter? — I should not like to say ; it would be a few days after.
Was it a week after, or was it four or five days after, or what? — It would be three or four days.
(The Coroner.) That was not the same occasion on which he went along this crosscut before. He has been telling us a great deal before about the condition he found the place in. That was on a former occasion.
(Mr. Edge to the witness.) When you told us about the indications you saw coming along the Narrow Board, did you come along the Narrow Board the same way that you went into the East going Board? — No.
Was that on the previous day? — The same day. I came in at 6 o'clock with a stoneman to go down that east-going board to rescue, and we met them coming out-by, and so we returned with them, so that we did not go into that for some days. I went down, and came right back to the shaft, and we did not examine anything at all.
There was a crosscut where the bricks were in this crossing in the North Crosscut along by the rolley way? — Yes.
Did that give you any reason to think that the explosion had gone in-by or out-by? — I thought she had come out-by there.
Have you been into where Middlemas and Mr. McCabe were working since the explosion? — Yes, I have been in.
Have you seen the fall of stone there? — Yes.
When did you go in there? — It would be the week after the explosion.
Did you notice a hole in the roof that had been left? — Yes, where the stone fell.
What size was the hole in the roof? — The stone fallen might be from 10 inches to a foot thick.
(The Coroner.) And the length and breadth? — Perhaps 2 feet broad.
And what length? — Perhaps 4 yards or 4½ yards or 5 yards long.
(Mr. Edge.) Did you look to ascertain whether you could see for several yards up above? — Not at that time.
Have you looked to see whether you could see up for several yards where the stone had come out? — Yes.
Can you see for several yards right up in the strata? — Yes, you can see a good distance up.
Is it like a big crack, or what is it? — It is a hollow course.
(The Coroner.) The whole extends some distance? — Some distance out.
How far? — I did not measure it.
Up in the roof? — Yes.
(Mr. Edge.) Was that hollow place where this stone had fallen? — Yes.
Is that a place where gas might accumulate? — Certainly it would.
Have you formed any opinion with regard to how this explosion took place? — No, I have not.
Further cross-examined by Mr. Bowey.
About the South Crosscut, did you notice any difference in the indications between the east end of the first pillar and as far as the innermost Stenton in the South Crosscut? — No, I did not.
Did you not notice what the indications were from the east end of the first pillar to the innermost Stenton in the fore South Crosscut ; what were the indications there? — I am sure I cannot exactly say.
Were there any? — There would be sure to be some.
What were they? — I really cannot say.
Was there any timber down? — Yes, there was timber down.
Did it indicate as to the way it had fallen? — As to the timber fallen down, it fell onto the doorway.
Could you tell from the position in which you found it which way the blast had turned? — I could not.
Could you tell anything from the indications as far as the first pillar? — No, nothing that I took notice of.
Did you not notice that the props between that first pillar and as far as the innermost Stenton were burnt on the north side? — There was some charred first on one side and then on the other.
All round? — No, one prop was charred on one side, and the next prop was charred on the other, and the next prop charred all round.
Were you along the Back Crosscut? — Yes.
Did you notice that the indications in the Back Crosscut to the face of the Stenton were out-by? — No.
How were they? — I did not notice anything particular coming along.
Were the props not charred on the south side? — I did not take particular notice of them.
You cannot say? — No.
Did you see that a shot had been fired in the post girdle bearing off at the roll of the stone close into the face? — Yes, I saw a shot had been fired.
Did you notice that there was stone lying there? — Yes.
Which had been blown down by the shot? — Yes.
In your opinion, had that stone been untouched after the shot had been fired? — There was a pick lying on the top of the stone when I went.
Had any of it been cleared away? — None of it had been cleared away.
Did you notice in the West Board in the Back Crosscut that there was a tub? — Yes.
Did you notice whether it was burnt? — The tub would be standing across the Back Headway.
Did you notice whether it was burnt? — No.
Did you see a tub near the second Stenton? — Yes, that would be always standing across the Back Headways, the east course.
Did you notice that that tub had been wheeled away as if the force had come out over? — No.
Did you notice anything about the position of that tub showing which way it had been blown? — The way she was standing was as much as to say that she had been set in to the board and the force had come down the board and driven her straight across the Stenton. She had driven a 4 ft. plate on her.
You saw the point where Mr. Colquhoun has been pointing to? — Yes.
How do you say that it would have been blown? — I suspect she had been blown out of the board across the east course.
Towards the east? — Yes.
You mean that it had been blown out of the West Board into the east? — Yes ; there is strong reason to believe that, because she had driven one of the plates away on her.
Did you notice that the props were not burnt on the outside, and that they were covered with dust on the inside in the fore crosscut? — Not particularly.
Can you say whether it was so? — No.
You do not know whether it was so or not? — No, not to the best of my recollection.
Further examined by Mr. Bell.
How do you account for all the cracking and singeing and burning about McCabe's place, the east-going board. Had you been down that before? — Yes, I had been down.
Did you observe the cracking and the coal stuff against the props there? — Yes.
And in the North Wall? — Yes.
And in the South Wall? — Yes.
How do you account for all the burning down there? — She spied off to that extent as far as she could get north and south there.
She could get to the shaft, either north or south, could she not? — No.
There is a way right through the return to the shaft, is there not? — Yes ; but the innermost holings you are speaking of.
Take the North Wall up the West board. What did you observe there? — I did not observe anything particular in the first board, she seemed as if the fire had gone along that wall (pointing to the plan).
In what direction? — North, because she had catched the out-by end of the tub and whipped over the top of the out-by end, and caught the out-by end of the in-by end of the tub.
Take the south wall. What were the indications there against the props. What were the indications against the props there? — There were several props marked different ways there.
Did you observe two plates standing upon end? — They were not there when I went.
Did you see two plates blown along like that (explaining on the plan)? — No.
When you say the " way " you mean the tramway? — Yes.
Did you see the two plates that were set up so (describing)? — No.
Were you not in that place two days after the explosion? — I think I must not have been in two days after the explosion if they were standing there then, because they were down when I was in.
Were you ever in before I went in? — No.
Are you quite sure about that? — You had been down the night of the explosion.
If you were not in before I went in you would not see them, because I knocked them down myself. Now, to come back again to the South Wall, from what you saw there, did you form any opinion with regard to the direction of the explosion with reference to the cause of it? — I think she had gone south along that way (pointing to the plan).
Then did you examine the West South Board on the south side, that is, the innermost board. Did you examine that board? — Not particularly, I think ; but we examined the board end.
What did the board end tell you from indications? — It indicated as if the air had gone along the out-by wall from the going board.
Where then? — She would have to come down the pillar behind there (pointing to the plan).
Did you examine that back pillar? — I came down the back, but I did not examine anything upon it.
Did you examine the props that were standing in the back pillar? — No.
Did you see which way the loose stuff was blown? — No.
Then altogether you made but a very superficial examination of that part of the district. Do not you think, as overman, you should have been more particular and taken more pains in examining every detail? — I was not much down in that part.
You were the overman in charge of the pit? — Yes.
Do not you think it was your duty to examine every little place when you knew that you had to come here and tell those gentlemen of the jury all you knew about the place, and all the indications and everything? — Yes.
What was the cavity or hole that you spoke of like? — That is in the face of the narrow-going board.
Was it a hitch-leader? — Yes.
Had she fallen out of that hitch-leader? — Yes ; she had come away at the hitch-leader.
By the face of the East Narrow Board she had fallen away at the leader? — Yes.
Did much stuff come out there ; much stone or leader stuff? — She had a heavy fall altogether.
Has she fallen since that piece of stone 10 inches thick fell? — Yes ; that piece of stone that I have been speaking of was found before the fall took place in the face.
From that fallen stone how far had the big fall taken place in-by or out-by? — In-by of the big fall ; it is lying upon it altogether.
Upon this stone? — Yes ; it was at the leader.
With regard to this leader stuff that is lying in the board, did it fall out of this hole or cavity? — Yes.
It was not an open or empty cavity till this stuff fell out of it? — Yes, this stuff that I was asked about first was just stone fallen from the roof, but with regard to the open cavity which you speak of just now you cannot tell what has been in there.
But have you filled much stuff out of that fall? — No.
Is there much stuff lying in the face? — Yes, there is a deal of stuff lying in the face.
How many tubs. Can you get onto the top of it? — No.
How did you see up the cavity without getting up on to the top of it? — We went into the in-by side.
Is it your opinion that there was an open space or an open cavity there previously to this fall taking place? — That open space is there now.
I daresay it is ; but what do you think was about the fall. Did the fall make this open space or was it there previous to the fall? — I do not know.
You cannot form an opinion? — No.
We will just come back to the South Crosscut. Take the Back crosscut where there was this stone lying ; when were you first in that crosscut where the shot had been fired? — I really cannot say what day it was that I was in, it was on the Friday I think.
(Mr. Edge.) You had been ill on the night of the explosion or the night after I think? — I got my knee hurt.
When was your knee hurt? — The day after the explosion.
Who was with you when your knee was hurt? — There was nobody particular. I was standing amongst the stones when I got hurt ; I got my foot fast.
(Mr. Bell.) When were you first in the South Crosscut after the explosion took place? — With Mr. Atkinson.
But I do not know when he was in ; was it the day of the explosion? — No.
The explosion was on the Wednesday? — Yes.
(Mr. Bowey.) Were you not in the South Crosscut on the morning after the explosion? — No.
(Mr. Bell.) Did you see a workman's pick lying on the stone? — Yes.
Did that appear as if it had been used for any purpose? — Yes.
Or had it been blown in there? — It had either been blown in or taken in.
Was there anything else besides the pick? — No, I think not.
Did you observe any marks in the roof as if a man had been hewing stone? — I did not particularly notice for that.
Did you observe the indications along the Back Crosscut from the face three pillars back. Take the face of the Back Crosscut and come three pillars back ; did you examine that place? — I have been through it, but not to examine it.
Have you formed any opinion with regard to what direction the explosion has travelled there? — Not any further than the canvas brattice blown down.
Have you formed any opinion from any marks upon the props or the tubs or anything else? — No.
Examined by Mr. Atkinson.
You spoke of bricks from the second air crossing being blown out-by? — Yes.
Did you see whether any bricks were blown in-by? — There were a few blown in-by.
Were as many blown in-by as there were blown out-by? — I think not.
Then just beyond the air crossing did you see an old mandoor at the in-by side of the air crossing? — Yes.
Do you know where that mandoor had been before the explosion? — Yes.
Where had it been? — It had been lying upon the pillar somewhere near where it is lying at present.
It had been lying on the in-by side? — Yes.
Do you remember telling me that it was on the out-by side? — The frame of the door was lying upon the out-by side of the door being set where the crossing is.
It was the door itself, not the frame of it? — It was lying by the in-by side of the crossing.
Where had the door been before the explosion? — Lying upon the pillars on the in-by side of the crossing.
You told me, did you not, that it was lying by the out-by side of the crossing before the explosion? — The door.
Yes? — Not to my recollection.
Further examined by Mr. Morley.
You know the air crossing in the North crosscut? — Yes.
Do you remember before the explosion a door lying in the North Crosscut near that air crossing? — Yes.
Was it north or south of the air crossing before the explosion? — North.
Are you certain of that? — Certain.
I am speaking now of before the explosion? — Yes.
Do you remember speaking to Mr. Atkinson about where the door had been lying before? — Yes, I know exactly.
Do you remember to Mr. Atkinson about it? — He inquired first about the door, where it had come from and I told him it was on the wallside set where the crossing is.
That it had been set in the crossing? — No, it had not been in the crossing. When we put the air crossing in, we took it out.
It had been used before the crossing was made? — Yes.
But since the crossing was made, where had it been? — The door lay upon the pillar by the rolley way, by the rolley way side of the going in-by.
North of the crossing? — Yes.
Was it in the same place as where it was after the explosion? — I cannot say exactly to a few yards.
You could not say which way it had been moved? — You could see which way it had been moved.
Which way had it been moved? — It had been moved southward. I mean to say this, that I could not say exactly to a yard or two how far it had been moved.
But it had been moved southward? — Yes.
About the bricks in this air crossing, you say that some were lying north and some were lying south? — There was a deal lying south.
And some lying north? — A few lying north.
Were any of the bricks blown into the return? — Yes, some.
Which way were they lying, east or west? — Both ways.
Did you go along the return? — No.
You have not been along there at all? — No.
Going south from the east-going board, did you go along south as far as the return? — Yes.
Was any damage done where the South Board goes into the return? — No damage, only a stopping blown out.
What stopping is that ; the stopping between the return and something? — Under the return board.
Was that blown east or west? — It was in the North and South Wall.
Is there a door at the end of that South Board leading into the return coming south from the east-going board down towards the return? — Yes.
Is there a regulating door in the board before you get to the return? — We build a stopping-up there and leave a hole in the stopping and regulate it with bricks, so that we have to build up every hole we make.
Was that standing there before the explosion? — Yes.
Was that blown away? — Yes.
Where was it blown? — Into the returns. The regulator was blown into the returns.
Going from the West Narrow Board up the North Crosscut you cross one pillar before you come to the air crossing, a Stenton wall? — That is between the rolleyway and the return.
Yes? — Yes.
The door was found after the explosion north of the return? — North of the return.
Was not the door before the explosion lying up against the Stenton wall between the rolleyway and the return? — No, the door was distinct from the frame altogether.
Where was the frame? — The frame was lying at the out-by side of the air crossing and the left-hand side going in-by.
Before the explosion was the frame south of the return? — Yes.
And it was there after the explosion too, was it not? — I cannot say that.
You do not know where it was after the explosion? — I have never seen.
Were the stoppings blown out south of the east-going board? — Yes.
Which way were they blown? — They were blown each way.
As you came south from the east-going board towards the return, were they blown in-by from where you were passing along? — In-by and blown south from the going board.
Can you understand the plan? — Yes.
Here is the east-going board leading up to where Middlemas and McCabe were found. Then going down here (pointing to the plan) towards the return to the south there are crossings on your right? — Yes.
Which way were they blown? — This way (tracing it on the plan).
How were these stoppings blown? — These stoppings were blown out this way (describing the same).
Which way were they blown? — They were blown where they could get into the board end ; they were blown into the board end.
They were blown west? — No, they could get into the West Board end.
When you say that they could not have been blown to the west, which way were they blown then? — Just here (pointing to the plan).
(The Coroner.) This is the in-take going down here, is it not (pointing to the plan)? — Yes.
There are not stoppings there, but there are stoppings here, to prevent the air going that way. Those are the stoppings you are asked about ; were they blown out, and which way were they blown? — Where they could get into the board, and if they had stood up they were blown here, but if not they had a clear course along here (describing the same).
But the direction in which the stoppings were blown was west? — Yes.
(Mr. Bates, a Juryman.) You say you found some gas in the South Crosscut? — Yes.
Did you particularly caution the back overman about that gas? — Yes.
She was close to the tunnel, was she not? — She was quite off the tunnel then.
At the in-by side of the east-going board there is a door? — Yes.
That door was blown down, was it not? — Yes.
Which way was that door blowing? — It was blowing to atoms.
Were the indications in-bye or out-bye? — They were blowing both ways.
Had she fired upon Middlemas and McCabe, or had she fired in the South Crosscut? — That is a question,
But the indications, according to what I understand from you, would rather suggest that? — Your theory is not good enough there.
Your theory is not good enough ; if there is any question put to the point, you do not understand anything about it. I want to understand this. Were the indications where Douglas was found in-over or out-over? — I do not know. I was not there when he was found.
Was Douglas' cap on the in-by side or out-by side? — I do not know. I was not there when it was found.
(The Coroner.) How far from the face was the fall of stone that you have spoken of near Middlemas and McCabe's place ; how far from the face was the fall? — The first time about 3 feet or 4 feet as near as I can tell.
That is the fall in respect of which you have described the space in the roof to be 2 feet broad and 4½ yards or 5 yards along? — Yes.
And that was within 4 feet of the face? — Yes.
That is so? — Yes, within 4 feet of the face.
Have you had any complaints from any of the men about gas in the pit? — No.
Adjourned to to-morrow at 10 o'clock.