Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Inquests Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Inquests
/   \

1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster

Inquest Report

Seaham Colliery Inquest, 12th April 1881 (cont.).

Mr. George Baker Foster sworn.

7,626. (Mr. Edge.) I do not think we need mention it in the County of Durham, but you are a mining engineer of very large experience? — Some experience.

7,627. You formed one of the board of directors? — I did.

7,628. How soon after the explosion did you go down the mine? — The day after the explosion.

7,629. Did you travel to any extent underground? I was in No. 1 Hutton seam and in the Maudlin.

7,630. How far did you get in the No. 1 Hutton? — We got past the travelling way end, and then we returned by the return. I may say we went with a view of seeing whether the returns were safe or not, not with a view of investigating the explosion that day.

7,631. I suppose subsequently you went down again? — Yes, with Mr. Armstrong and Mr. Wood.

7,632. When was that? — On the 12th and 13th October.

7,633. You observed indications, of course, in No. 1 Hutton also? — And in the other seams as well.

7,634. Did you form any opinion as to the probable seats of the explosion? — My opinion was that the balance of probabilities was in favour of the Polka way end.

7,635. That was from the indications that you saw? — Yes.

7,636. You know how this mine is ventilated? — I did not know the mine before.

7,637. Can you offer any suggestion as to how gas could possibly have got into the stone drift? — No, I think it could not have come there.

7,638. Do you imagine it at all probable that gas could have got into the engine plane and the Maudlin seam between the stone drift and the travelling way? — No, I do not.

7,639. I suppose in forming an opinion as to the seat of the explosion you have taken the various indications all over the pit? — Yes, I put the difficulties surrounding each hypothesis and reduced them to the one that had the least difficulty.

7,640. Of course there are difficulties in each case? — Yes.

7,641. It has been suggested by my friend Mr. Jones, that, under some exceptional circumstances, there might have been gas in the slow board; in your judgment, could the gas have accumulated in the slow board unless the ventilation in the whole of No. 3 Hutton had been disorganised? — I think not.

7,642. How can you suggest, as long as there was fresh air going along the main intake up to the Old Hutton incline, an accumulation of gas in the slow board? — I cannot suggest any way in which there could have been an accumulation of gas in the slow board.

7,643. The slow board was between the return to the north and the main intake? — Yes.

7,644. Have you ever heard it suggested before that gas has accumulated there? — Not that I am aware of.

7,645. Can you give me your view as to what would have been the probable result if there had been a shaft up in the north-east or north-west of the Maudlin? — I think if there had been a shaft there the whole face of the workings would have been altered, and it is impossible to say what would have happened then.

7,646. What is the result of your experience as to how an explosion goes? — It makes to the point of least resistance.

7,647. I suppose any larger place or shaft would be a point of least resistance in a mine? — Quite so.

7,648. I suppose there is a time when the explosion going forward compresses the air to a certain extent, the explosion wastes itself away and goes no further? — Yes, I say compressing the air before it till the force of the compression ---

7,649. (Mr. Jones.) Forms a piston? — Not exactly a piston.

7,650. (Mr. Edge.) That is the result of your experience. Now, you have seen of course how this colliery is worked? — Yes.

7,651. I do not think it has been suggested up to the present, but I will ask your opinion, in effect, is not this colliery worked according to the most approved system of working collieries? — Yes.

7,652. And the most perfect system of ventilation? — As far as I have seen, it is.

7,653. The main intakes are large and the returns are large? — The returns are very large.

7,654. So long as you keep up the perfect system or fairly perfect system of ventilation, does the size of the area worked from the shafts make any difference? — No.

7,655. If there had been a shaft up in the northeast Maudlin, could it have had any effect upon the temperature below unless it was a down cast shaft? — I think not.

7,656. Do you in your experience know collieries in which the face of the workings is further from the shaft than the present one? — Yes, nearly twice as far.

7,657. I think in your own experience one colliery is being worked, a Crown royalty, nearly four miles? — I dare say it is more than four miles.

7,658. (The Coroner.) We may as well have the name of it? — The Whitehaven.

7,659. (Mr. Edge.) Do you know in Morton and Haswell collieries the face of the workings is more than three miles? — I do not know by my own knowledge. I am working other collieries myself with the face of the workings twice as far off as this.

7,660. My friend asked Mr. Lindsay Wood whether the existence of a trouble would be an element to be taken into consideration in having additional shafts? — If you knew the troubles beforehand you would naturally seek not to have to cross them.

7,661. In crossing troubles you have to drift up or down? — Yes.

7,662. Sometimes it is more convenient to have a shaft? — It is.

7,668. (Mr. Atherley Jones.) You have had large experience, I suppose, in connection with explosions? — With several.

7,664. In this county? — In this county and Northumberland and Yorkshire.

7,665. I suppose you have on former occasions endeavoured to discover the seat of an explosion? — Yes; we generally did discover the seat of an explosion.

7,666. Have you always been successful hitherto? — I do not think I have ever given evidence before.

7,667. You have never undertaken the duty of endeavouring to discover the seat of an explosion yourself before? — I have been consulted before.

7,668. And I suppose in a vast number of cases there is generally a difference of opinion, and a very wide difference of opinion as to the seat of the explosion? — Not always; sometimes there is.

7,669. As a rule? — I do not think as a rule.

7,670. Is not it the fact, as a rule, that the origin of the explosion is usually destroyed in the explosion itself? — No, I do not think, looking at the cases I have seen, that I can say that.

7,671. You mean to say, in the cases you have seen, it has happened you have been able to put your finger upon the cause? — As many cases one way as the other.

7,672. In this case you recognise there is a reasonable divergence of opinion as to the locality of the explosion? — I am told so.

7,673. (The Coroner.) Do you think so? — Oh, yes.

7,674. (Mr. Atherley Jones.) May I ask you upon what data you have formed your judgment? — Upon the general appearance of the mine after the explosion.

7,675. I suppose you did not form that opinion without some kind of hesitancy? — I formed an opinion immediately that it had come out-bye to No. 1.

7,676. From the general indications? — Yes.

7,677. A decisive opinion? — Very decisive.

7,678. When was that? — The day after the explosion.

7,679. That was the only portion of the pit, except the Maudlin, that you then examined? — Quite

7,680. You did not go into No. 3 Hutton? — No.

7,681. And you did not go down for the purpose of making any investigation? — No.

7,682. Nor was that discussed at all at that time? — No; it shows I went down quite unbiased.

7,683. Nor did you give an expression of opinion at the time? — I do not know; I would not like to say that.

7,684. You cannot point to any particular thing which fixes the explosion as having taken place in the Polka way? — I think all the indications are that the explosion came outwards and inwards, and therefore I assume the explosion was between these two.

7,685. These indications you examined between five and six weeks after the event? — Partly; partly the next day.

7,686. But you did not go to examine them? — I was down.

7,687. I suppose you had other and weightier things on your mind at that time? — Yes.

(Mr. Bell.) Mr. Forster went down first, in consequence of some fires in the pit.

7,688. (Mr. Jones.) With a view of their being extinguished? — To see whether there was any danger.

7,689. Is not it extremely deceptive to form an opinion as to the locality of an explosion, owing to the diversity of way in which the explosions will run, and the effect of what is termed back lash? — Of course you must take all these into consideration.

7,690. These a good deal deduct from the value of a conclusion? — They deduct in the same ratio from the value of all conclusions.

7,691. Do not you also recognise as an element very much against the theory you propound the absence of fire along the leg of the compass, as Mr. Bell very aptly termed it, and its presence on the other leg of the compass? — My idea is you had a good deal of fire on the outside shaft.

7,692. You know, so far as we have seen, there has been no indication of it? — The engine-house was on fire.

7,693. In immediate proximity to the shaft — I mean in No. 3 Hutton? — As far as I could see, there was as much in one as in the other.

7,694. You do not mean to say you saw any indications of fire in proximity to the Polka way, or along No. 1 Hutton travelling-way? — Yes, I think we saw cases of indications of fire on the wall side in the engine plane.

7,695. Did you see it yourself? — Yes.

7,696. Indications of fire on the engine plane? — That is my opinion.

7,697. That, I think, is entirely new ; we have not heard that before? — I am not very strong about it.

7,698. But you know there were the most indubitable indications of fire in No. 3 Hutton that men were burnt? — Yes

7,699. And you know the only man that was in No. 1 travelling-way was not burnt? — But I have known similar cases in explosions. I think when the flame is passing very rapidly it does not burn so much as when it comes to the end.

7,700. The force of the flame must have been very great, as Venner's and Brown were shattered very much? — So were the men on the other side; it is entirely a balance of probabilities.

7,701. I will put it no higher than this: would not you consider that a very strong element, the absence of fire in the No. 1 and the presence of fire in No. 3, a strong element against your theory? — No, I do not think so much about the fire as the force. I think there are points in No. 3 which show it could not have been there in my view. My answer is, I do not place much reliance on the question of fire. I have seen two men, one burnt and the other not burnt, close together.

7,702. I draw attention to this, that there are a series of men and things which are burnt in No. 3 Hutton? — I am not aware that there is a series of men and things.

I think your may take it from me that that is so — there were the Venners.

(The Coroner.) Mr. Baker Foster knows exactly the position of things. He knows that there were strong symptoms of fire at one point; he admits that there were less at the other, and he says he does not place much reliance in forming his judgment upon those points.

7,703. (Mr. A. Jones.) You have told my friend, with regard to the extent of the workings and the employment of other shafts, that in this colliery the distance from the shaft to the face of the workings is not as great as that which you are acquainted with in other collieries? — Yes.

7,704. Do you know any colliery in which the extent of the workings, past and present, is materially greater than in this? — As far as distance from the shaft is concerned.

7,705. I am not saying that? — I could not give you an opinion.

7,706. I do not want to pin you? — My notion is that there are collieries very much bigger.

7,707. Do you know of any in this county? — Not with two shafts alone.

7,708. Do you know of any colliery with two shafts alone which is as large as this? — I do not belong to this county, so that I cannot say.

7,709. Do you know of any colliery anywhere larger than this? — I think so, but I could not say. offhand. I really do not know the extent of this colliery.

7,710. In your judgment would it not be safer that this colliery should have more shafts, or rather that the extent of time workings should he less than it is? I will refer you to an expression you used in a minute, but I wanted to ask you that first? — No, as far as I know.

(The Coroner.) You must take that within Mr. Baker Foster's answer previously, that he does not know the extent of the workings.

7,711. (Mr. A. Jones.) I will try and take you rather upon theoretical grounds. You said, in answer to my friend, the existence of a trouble is an element in favour of working by distinct pits? — If you know of it beforehand.

7,712. Of course you cannot help in if you have got into difficulty, but the existence of a trouble is a factor which is likely to very materially derange the economy of a colliery? — It depends altogether on the circumstances of the trouble. There are some troubles which damage — deep troubles from a shaft.

7,713. I suppose you are aware that this is a deep trouble? — Oh, I thought you meant a much larger trouble; that is not a very big trouble.

7,714. You do not attach much importance to that? — No.

7,715. I think you see the trouble in the plan? — Practically it is not a trouble, because the seams are opposite each other.

7,716. I beg your pardon? — Very nearly so. You pass directly out of the Hutton into the Maudlin.

7,717. The seams have fallen one below the other, but there is a rise? — You have the Maudlin and part of the Hutton seam on the same level.

7,718. You recognise that as a difficulty in the efficient ventilation of the colliery? — No, not in the ventilation.

7,719. Not the slightest difficulty? — I cannot call it the slightest difficulty when it is once got over. It is an expense.

7,720. When once got over, that is to say, when the system under which it is worked has been completed ; is it not a less satisfactory system than would exist supposing there was no trouble? — It would be much more satisfactory if there was no trouble.

7,721. (The Coroner.) Is it the point of safety or expense that you are hooking at? — Of expense.

7,722. (Mr. A. Jones.) I am speaking on the point of safety? — I do not see that it makes much difficulty.

7,723. Let me ask. you this: Do you assign any limit to the extent of workings with two shafts? —

(The Coroner.) For safety.

(The Witness.) No, certainly not, as long as you can get your air.

7,724. (Mr. A. Jones.) Everything is good as long as it does not depend upon an "if," but what I want is this : is not the extent of the workings an additional element of difficulty in working a colliery? — I do not think you begin to feel the difficulty within two miles. I have never experienced it.

7,725. You know in this colliery the extent of the workings is extremely large, you admit that the extent of the workings — not the distance from the shafts — and the ramification of the workings is a very considerable element to take into consideration in the number of shafts? — I was not aware of it.

You say "No," that the workings may be as extensive as possible, and it will make no possible difference to the ventilation.

(The Coroner.) Put it this way. Do you know sufficiently of this colliery to say that the ventilation cannot be taken up to the workings?

7,726. (Mr. A. Jones.) I cannot put it that way. What I have asked is this: is not the difficulty of ventilation increased by the ratio in which the lengths of the returns and the intakes and the extent of the workings is increased? — Increase of length requires increase of science.

(The Coroner.) You are asking the witness an abstract question, and therefore your cannot get any definite answer to it so far as this pit is concerned.

(The Witness.) I think my answer is fair, in this way: as long as you can get your ventilation round the face you are perfectly secure. Some seams are more difficult to ventilate than others; some ventilating powers are different from others; and unless you give me one particular point I cannot give you a direct answer, but I have never seen a colliery of this size.

7,727. (Mr. A. Jones.) My question is a very simple one. It is this : Does not the extent of the workings and of the returns in the intake increase the necessity for additional shaft accommodation? — It cannot increase the necessity until the necessity arises. As long as you have plenty of air, you have no necessity.

7,728. Does not the extent of the workings increase the difficulty of ventilation? — Oh yes, it increases the power required. It does not make the ventilation impossible.

I suppose you would not say you could work the whole of England with two shafts. They are going to work between Calais and Dover, that is, from England to France.

7,729. But there, in the first place, your have only one tunnel; in the second place you have no gas; and in the third place, you are able to pump in air continually. You will admit, I suppose, that there must be some limit to the extent of the workings? — Oh yes, some limit.

7,730. And your do not think the extent of the workings, as far as you know them in this colliery, is too great for safety? — As far as I know them I do not think it is.

7,731. With regard to a trouble, does not a trouble increase the dangers from gas, or I should say perhaps, does it not increase the dangers of gas being brought unto the workings? — Sometimes it does and sometimes it does not.

7,732. You cannot give me a general answer? — We are always very careful for that reason when we do get a trouble.

7,733. Of course the difficulty is your want of knowledge of this particular colliery, but in this case do you look upon it as a danger? — No, not after it is gone through and an arrangement is made. It is only when you first get a trouble that there is danger.

7,734. How do you account for this explosion taking place at the Polka way end? — If it took place there it must have been from gas coming off the coal.

7,735. Do you mean by a sudden outburst? — Yes.

7,736. By a blower? — No, by a bag. A blower generally goes on for some time.

7,737. A blower comes off with great force, and blows out air and water? — Water followed by gas.

7,738. A blower is simply gas escaping from a cavity? — It is called a blower because it generally comes out with water and makes a great noise.

7,739. This might be the same thing, only it did not come off with a noise? — It might be a bag of gas and come off all at once.

7,740. Do not you look upon it as extremely unlikely that, inasmuch as no gas has been detected there for years, it should have come off suddenly in this way? — Of course if I had examined the colliery before the explosion I should have said it was very unlikely.

7,741. (Mr. Bell.) Do not you think it would be rather an improbable thing to have a bag of gas on that fall considering that those fissures run up there? — It is a difficult thing to say.

7,742. I mean having the fissures running up, and a fall coming away 3½ feet deep, you would not expect to find a bag of gas lying there? — It might come.

(The Coroner.) You say it is not at all probable that you would find a bag of gas there, but it is as probable a solution of the difficulty as you can find after thoroughly examining the pit.

7,743. (Mr. Edge.) You told my friend you did not go into No. 3 Hutton. I suppose you mean you did not go in the first day? — Yes; I went in carefully afterwards. It had evidently not been touched when we saw it.

7,744. There were fires in No. 1 engine plane, and also in the main staples? — Yes.

Adjourned till to-morrow, at half-past ten o'clock.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print