1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
Seaham Colliery Inquest, 12th April 1881 (cont.).
Mr. Lindsay Wood sworn.
7,416. (Mr. Edge.) You are a mining engineer and the chairman of the Northumberland and Durham Mine Owners' Coal Trade Association? — The Durham Coal Trade Association.
7,417. I think you have had considerable experience in mining matters and also in explosions? — Yes; in mining matters and partly in explosions.
7,418. I do not want you to give us all the indications, but you heard the indications spoken of by Mr. Armstrong? — Yes.
7,419. Did you notice those indications when you examined the mine? — Yes; all of them. He indicated to me all the indications that he saw at the time he was down the pit during the two days we were there together.
7,420. When did you first examine the pit after the explosion? — The 12th of October.
7,421. About a month after? — Yes.
7,422. I suppose you have formed some opinion as to the probable origin of the seat of the explosion? — I have. I think that, taking the whole of the indications that I saw, all those examinations of the workings point more clearly to the explosion having occurred at the Polka-way doors than at any other points that I saw.
7,423. We see from one of the reports that there were 66,000 cubic feet of air passing along that stone drift? — Yes.
7,424. In your experience can you imagine any gas coming against that drift of air? — Do you mean coming against the current?
7,425. Yes: working against the current? — No, I do not think it is possible.
7,426. Even assuming that there were tubs being drawn along through the drifts? — If the gas had to come out it would have to come out from the workings further in-bye than the point you name, and it would have to back out against a current of 1,000 feet per minute coming against it, and I do not think that gas could have done that for any appreciable distance. If there had been an enormous outburst of gas, it might have backed that current for a short distance, and then gone in again, but that gas must have been given off at some place very near the point your name to back up — it could not have come from any distance.
7,427. Your know the colliery plan, and you know how this colliery was worked? — Yes.
7,428. Is there any place in the neighbourhood of that stone drift from which you could expect gas to come? — I do not think there is any place near the stone drift end that is at all likely from which gas could have escaped on to that waggon-way.
7,429. Have you yourself, in your experience, ever found gas in the intakes where there was less current than the velocity spoken to here? — I do not quite understand.
7,430. Have you, in your experience, ever found gas in a main intake such as that stone drift? — I have seen gas come on a main intake owing to falls.
7,431. Yes, owing to falls, but not from the workings? — Not backing against a current of that quantity. I have seen blowers out from the face back a considerable current of air, but not of that magnitude, and even then not to any great distance.
7,432. Generally, do you corroborate the evidence of Mr. Armstrong as expressed with regard to what has taken place with respect to appliances in the north of England? Have you had experience in any of the explosions in the north of gas coming in contact with the furnace? — No; I have never seen a case of that kind. I have never heard of one at all.
7,433. Do you agree with Mr. Armstrong in what he said about shot firing? — There is a great deal of evidence about the shot firing. I do not know what you mean.
7,434. What do you consider, in your opinion, would be the effect produced by a shot which has done its work — would there be any effect? — I do not think a shot that has done its work would have any effect by way of explosion being created through the dust being in circulation in the place where the shot was fired. I have never seen a shot which has done its work create any flame due to the dust which was in circulation in the place where the shot was fired.
7,435. You saw, I suppose, where Venner's shot and where Brown's shot was fired. It was fired in the stone drift? — That was Simpson's. (The Witness here pointed out where Brown's and Venner's shots were fired.)
7,436. Can you tell me whether these were shots which had done their work? — Yes, they had done there work completely.
7,437. If there had been, as was suggested by my friend Mr. Jones, a shaft in that north-west side of the Maudlin, what, in your judgment, would have been the probable result of that shaft being there at the time of the explosion? — I think that the shaft bottom would have been damaged by the force of the explosion. I think that the force would have gone in there equally as it did in the other ways. The scene of the explosion is somewhere about here (pointing), and the force would have gone in that way (pointing). If there had been a shaft here, the force would have run into it, and most likely damaged the bottom of the shaft and gone out. Very often the force of the explosion runs to where the fresh air is.
7,438. I shall put it to you shortly, Mr. Wood. - I understand you think that the balance is in favour of the explosion having originated somewhere in the Polka-way end? — I think the balance of all the facts which have been under my cognizance show that this is the most likely place for its having occurred.
7,439. Can you suggest anywhere, unless the door was left open, any means by which the gas could have got up or accumulated in the main coal staple? — No, I do not think so. Even if the doors were left open, I have considerable doubt whether any gas could have accumulated; and if it had accumulated, it must have been in the returns.
7,440. There are no workings in the immediate neighbourhood of the stone drift? — No present workings.
7,441. (Mr. Wright.) Do I correctly understand you that you did not go into the pit until the 12th October? — Yes.
7,442. That is six weeks after the explosion? — Yes.
7,443. But you would not say from your personal knowledge of explosions that you would attach much importance to what you saw after the lapse of six weeks? — Certainly. I am speaking of the indications that I saw.
7,444. Six weeks after the explosion? — Yes.
7,445. But you did not know what had been removed and what had been altered in that time? — I do not know what was done; but I do know what I did see, and those indications were such as led me to come to that conclusion that I have mentioned.
7,446. You have had some experience of explosions? — I have been to a great many.
7,447. Generally after the lapse of six weeks the face of the mine is considerably changed? — I cannot say off-hand how long it was after the explosion that I have examined mines. I have examined them a very short time after an explosion, and also some time after it.
7,448. I suppose you went entirely by what you were told? — I went entirely by what I saw. I don't know that there was anything particular pointed out; of course, in general conversation we heard what was said, but the indications I saw were perfectly clear and perfectly distinct.
7,449. And you agree with Mr. Armstrong that there was no reasonable doubt in the matter? — The preponderance of evidence is to that effect, and as to the other theories there are certain circumstances against their having occurred.
7,450. You don't agree with Mr. Stratton? — No.
7,451. I did not put it to Mr. Armstrong because he did not seem to require any one else's opinion; but I would put to you what I put to Mr. Stratton, as to where the explosion occurred. I asked him, "You rather think it occurred in the lower half between No. 1 shaft and the Polka return?" and he answered, "I should be inclined to think it. Of the two opinions I should be inclined to give it that way, but I do not hold either sufficiently strong. I would be very far from giving a confident opinion about it." Is that too week? — I think it is; weaker than I would put it myself.
7,452. Mr. Stratton was there all the six weeks during which you were not there? — I believe he was.
7,453. About shafts. You have been asked a question or two about shafts. I should have thought that you would have preferred to have had twenty shafts rather than one so far as safety is concerned, but it is purely a question of expense? — I am not at all so sure about that.
7,454. I am not putting it against you, but it would be purely a question of expense — whether a reasonable expense should be incurred to make them? — I think that you could have such a number of shafts as to be dangerous.
7,455. In what way would the shafts be a source of danger? — I think that the force of the current of air coming down the different shafts would act against each other in ways that would have the effect of causing small obstructions of the different shafts, and cause the currents to change, and there would not be one coming down and the other up.
7,456. If that were the case the most danger would be in the open air? — No; because there your currents might blow from east to west and not affect any other part.
7,457. With regard to shots ; do you think from your experience that it is right and proper in a mine of this kind that shots should be fired when so great a number of men are in the mine. I am asking you as a gentleman of independence, experience, and skill in mines, whether it is a proper thing to do? — I should like to ask where you refer to.
7,458. Assuming — and it is not disputed — that along there on the curve, 150 to 200 yards, that you fired a shot? — I should say that there is no more danger in that curve and around that way than there was in firing it on the rocks outside the harbour.
7,459. May I ask if there was any kind of danger or any kind of expense involved in having the shots fired only at a time when no more men are in the mine than are necessary for the firing of the shot? — I should think there was.
7,460. Supposing there were three shifts in this mine, and the night shift was the repairing shift, as was the case on the night of the explosion, would there be any difficulty at all in having all the shots prepared by ten o'clock at night, and allowing them half-an-hour's interval before the repairing shift goes down,. and firing all the shots necessary in the half-hour's interval, which could be managed by half-a-dozen men? — Having half-a-dozen men.
7,451. Yes. You might have half-a-dozen men killed, but that would be different from risking 200 men; is there any difficulty about it? Is there any extraordinary difficulty? — Yes, because the men would be carried out of the shift.
7,462. It does not take more than half-an-hour. You might leave the necessary number of men down to fire the shots, and let the men in the return shift come down as soon as they could, and fire them in a short interval. Would there be any difficulty? — I do not think there is any actual difficulty in doing it. Of course the work would have to be done by the repairing men previously to the other men going in, and those men who were drilling would have to remain in the shift, and they would have a sufficient time after the coal work to do that?
7,463. No. Might they not drill holes before the evening shift went up? — They could not do that with the coal wagons going.
7,464. That is what I am anxious to know? — Oh, yes; there is a difficulty with the stone men during the time that the coal work is going on.
7,465. Why? Because they are not working their shifts out of place? — Oh, yes.
7,466. Not here (pointing)? — Not these identical shots. I am taking a general view.
7,467. You are not talking of the shot firing in that place? — No, I am taking a view generally — not in that particular colliery.
7,468. You think that it would impede the travelling-way if they are drilled? — Yes; the ordinary shots that are fired are fired in the main wagon-way and the shooting down to make height for the larger way, the shots would have to be drilled after the coal work was finished.
7,469. Why? — Because they are passing on them; the stone working is at the same place.
7,470. In bringing down the roofs? — Yes.
7,471. And that would be a difficulty to some extent? — Oh yes, if the working had to be done after the coal-work has to be finished and previous to the ordinary shifters going in.
7,472. Would there be any difficulty in drilling the holes one night whilst the repairing shift was down, and leaving the shot to be fired at 10 o'clock the next evening, immediately after the afternoon shift had gone out? — I presume that that could be done.
7,473. There would be no real difficulty about it except in exceptional cases? — I think it is possible to be done. It depends very much upon the locality and the position of those things.
7,474. Would you see any difficulty at all? — Yes; I do really. I don't say an insurmountable difficulty.
7,475. Is there any difficulty? — In firing the two ways.
7,476. Drilling the holes one night and firing them the next evening — is there any difficulty? — The difficulty in that would be that they could only go at half the rate they do at the present time.
7,477. Would it not be more true to say that it would be 24 hours behind? — No; it might be a day behind, because you fire a shot every day.
7,478. A shot every day. A shot would not be fired until 24 hours after it was drilled? — You could not drive when the coal working is going on.
7,479. (The Coroner.) The tubs are passing in and out of the pit? — You can only drill then six hours in the day.
7,480. (Mr. Wright.) Taking the drill during the repairing six hours, why should not that be fired on the next evening at 10 o'clock? — If you do that it would take them six hours and the other six hours to fire one.
7,481. No; I beg your pardon. You would be a day behind-hand. Tuesday in drilling your holes; and the Wednesday night firing and drilling another hole, and Thursday the drilling and firing after the first two. Do you see any difficulty about that? — I think that there would be a delay.
7,482. Of the 24 hours in the whole operation? — I think it would be more than that. You would not get rid of that shot probably.
7,483. There might be cases of a difficulty? — I think so.
7,484. (The Coroner.) What is the nearest return to that stone drift? — (The Witness pointed it out on the map.)
7,484a. Take it that a fall in the Maudlin occurs, would you get foul air down to the stone drift — in the stone drift? — It entirely depends whether the return to the point where the fall took place is double or single; a few yards would make all the difference.
7,485. Could you get any fall to do it? — I don't think any fall would cause gas to come on to the wagon-way.
7,486. Nor to get to the stone drift in any way? — No.
7,487. (Mr. Bell.) Is not there a big trouble? — There is a "trouble" here at the Maudlin way end.
7,488. (The Coroner.) Now, if it gave off gas there, what would be the effect? — In the return it would have gone to the furnace; and if from the wagon-way, it would have gone in there (pointing).
7,489. If the engine plane was stagnant, where would it go to? — I cannot conceive such a state of circumstances that the Maudlin wagon-way or the Maudlin travelling-way could be stagnant.
7,490. (Mr. Jones.) Is there any particular indication which fixed your mind upon choosing the Polka way as the seat of the explosion? — I think the line of force exhibited from that point demonstrated more clearly to my mind that that was the point in which the centre of force had occurred.
7,491. That is a general observation? — An observation of the points and facts that I saw on the way.
7,492. But not an observation of any particular development. There was no particular indication — I should say signal indication — which fixed the Polka way in your mind? — It was the indication I have mentioned.
7,493. General indications? — It was the indication of the line of debris, and the line of force from that point.
7,404. Travelling down the Polka way and the travelling-way? — Travelling from the polka way to No. 1 shaft, and also travelling from the Polka way in-bye.
7,495. But there is no particular one single indication which fixed it upon your mind? — Not one single indication.
7,406. Who were you in company with when you went down the line? — I was in company with Mr. Armstrong, Mr. George Baker Foster, and Mr. Corbett.
7,497. You are aware that Mr. Baker-Foster was not at all confident as to the locality in which the explosion took place? — I was not aware of that fact.
7,498. He did not form any definite opinion? — It was another Mr. Foster, Mr. Richard Foster that you mean.
7,499. Did Mr. Richard Foster, of South Hetton, accompany you on that occasion? — I don't think he did, I would not be certain.
7,500. You said there was a divergence of opinion. There were differences of opinion among you, and the gentlemen and you discussed the locality of the explosion. That is so? — All the different points were discussed. There was an interchange of views, and some held the opinion that it lay in one part of the pit and the others in another part, I don't remember any particular opinion being expressed other than the Polka way ends.
7,501. But still there was that divergence of opinion? — The whole of the points were discussed as independently as they possibly could be.
7,502. You don't mean to suggest that there was any concentaneous opinion that the explosion took place in the way which you prefer? — I think that there was, and all the people who examined the pit at that time thought as I thought.
7,503. Those who accompanied you on that occasion? — Yes, those who accompanied me thought that that was the most likely point.
7,504. Did you know anything about the 1871 explosion? — No; I don't remember. I was at the pit after the explosion.
7,505. And formed no opinion as to the cause of that explosion? — No; I don't think I did.
7,506. Don't you think it strange that in this particular travelling-way there should not have been any development of gas for years — in that main intake over a considerable period of years — don't you think it strange that it should break out in that way? — I think it is a thing that would not have been expected.
7,507. In fact, if it was not for the indications you would favour any other hypothesis rather than that? — I think that the indications were more than at any other place.
7,508. But being free from indications, would you look upon any other hypothesis as more reasonable than that? — On the contrary, I think there is more likely to be gas there than at the other points.
7,509. Why? — Because I cannot conceive in my own mind where gas could have come from if not from Simpson's shot.
7,510. Do you know which is called the stone way, near the main coal way? — I call it stowboard.
7,511. You know that place is not ventilated? — The stowboard
7,512. Yes. Is that the place near the main coal staple? — Yes.
7,513. That is an old way running up to some old workings? — It was a road between the intake of No. 3 Hutton seam and the stowboard. It heads to the return air hole in the No. 3 Hutton seam.
7,514. We have been told that that was not ventilated? — A portion of the stowboard, between where the men were and the doors, I think was not ventilated, excepting by the scale, which was scaling through the place.
7,515. Can you not contemplate the possibility of gas leaking from there? — I cannot think that it could be possible. The pull of the air was clearly the other way.
7,516. Apart from the pull of the air it is not an unreasonable suggestion that gas might be leaked from there? — But you cannot take it apart from the actual facts of the case.
7,517. Pardon me. I will put the question in order. We will come to the air current. Now, apart from any air current, is it not a very reasonable supposition that gas accumulated there? — I think not. I think so because the pull of the air is against it.
7,518. Leave the pull of the air? — I cannot.
7,519. There is no pull in the stowboard? — I think there is more likely to be a pull there.
7,520. But it is not ventilated. Is there any reason why gas should not accumulate in the stowboard? — I think there is no reason why it should.
7,521. But bear in mind that it is unventilated? — It is unventilated to a certain extent.
7,522. We have it in evidence that it is unventilated? — I did not know that.
7,523. What I am asking you is whether gas might accumulate there? — I cannot say that.
7,524. Assuming it to be unventilated and there to be no pull out of it, might gas accumulate there? — I do not think it is likely. I cannot say it is impossible.
7,525. Why not? — Because I think that that place has been driven for many years, and that unless something had occurred to cause it to come off into it, that the natural sides of the place would not have given off gas.
7,526. You know that it goes straight to the goaf? — Yes.
7,527. It will pass into the return? — It passes into the return.
7,528. Then it goes straight off the returns, and the gas might leak off the returns into that? — But there was no gas in the return.
7,529. But assuming there had been in the returns? — Assuming the pit had been foul, would there have been gas in that stowboard?
7,530. Yes? — It is quite possible.
7,531. Assuming that there was a tendency for the air to be stagnant between the main coal staple running along the intake out-bye, it would be a reasonable supposition that the gas should escape into the intake? — I do not quite follow that.
7,532. Assuming that the air in the intake adjoining the main coal staple is stagnant, it will be a very reasonable thing to suppose that the gas would have a tendency to stagnate and to come off into the intake. Is that so? — I don't think so.
7 533. Would not the gas come off into the intake? — No.
7,534. Why not? — It would go into the return.
7,535. We have got it into the stowboard out of the return, and I am assuming that, and would not it become diffused? — If I understand you, you put a hypothetical case, that if that stowboard was full of gas if there is no ventilation going past the pit —
7,536. I don't say no ventilation. but not a strong ventilation? — That the gas might come out of that stowboard and go in ; and I think it is so, as I said before, if the pit had been foul at that part it would have been foul.
7,537. You have heard it in evidence that the fact of this main coal staple being ventilated both from the top and from the bottom would have a tendency to stagnate. That is what Mr. Armstrong said. Do your agree with Mr. Armstrong that the fact of the staple being ventilated from above and below would cause the air in the immediate vicinity to stagnate? — A tendency.
7,538. Do you agree with that? — I don't agree with that.
(The Coroner.) I don't think you got that from Mr. Armstrong.
(The Witness.) Mr. Armstrong did not say so; and I say that it is perfectly impossible that any stagnation should have any effect upon the airways at the staple or between the airways and the stowboard.
7,539. (Mr. Jones.) Not from the fact of there being two opposing currents? — There never were or could be.
7,540. You know that the staple was ventilated from the middle and No. 3 Hutton? — Yes.
7,541. That being so, the gas would have a sort of duplex course of ventilation from the staple, and would not there be a tendency for the air to come and hang? — No ; it is the same thing as a stanton between two wagon ways; and the air will go up and down.
7,542. We had an analogy of two waters meeting each other. They hang, don't they, when they come immediately against each other? — It is like having two streams of water running one way with a canal put between them.
7,543. But then don't you see that that is not a correct illustration, because they are not running parallel or approximately parallel. They are running in a directly contrary direction? — I beg pardon.
7,544. One is coming down and the other up? — Only when the air is going from one to the other.
7,545. One is ascending and the other descending? — I don't see it, the air must go up and down.
7,546. Sometimes it goes one way and sometimes another in the period of change; during the period of the change there would be a certain tendency to stagnation? — I don't think there would.
7,547. That is a matter of opinion. However, we got it from you that if there were a tendency to stagnation the gas would probably become diffused, and shot firing in the immediate vicinity would be extremely dangerous? — I don't think I stated that.
7,548. That if the gas came out into the place on a stagnated atmosphere, the firing of the shot would be extremely dangerous? — If your had a stagnated place and fired a shot it would be very dangerous.
7,549. Mr. Wright asked you a question about shafts. I don't mean that the shafts should be scattered indiscriminately, but what I want to ascertain from you is this. Do you assign any limit to the extent of workings with two shafts? — Oh, yes.
7,550. I ought to say assign any limit to the safety of working? — I think there is undoubtedly a limit.
7,551. Can your formulate to us the limit? — I could not off hand say what the limit should be.
7,552. I suppose it would depend upon the construction of the mine to some extent? — Very much so, and on the nature of the mine.
7,553. Are you aware that this mine shows signs of several varied kinds of construction, that is to say, of several plans of laying out. Is that so? — I don't follow you.
7,554. It is not worked upon one even plan. I suppose fresh viewers or fresh managers have selected different plans? — I don't think so. I think the plan of this colliery is laid out owing to the curves that have been met with in the workings as they have gone on.
7,555. This is a mine which has been worked somewhat irregularly, to say the least? — No, it is not more irregularly worked than any other mine in the country.
7,556. It has been laid out by different people at different times on different plans? — No, sir; the different managers who have had that colliery to manage have laid out the workings at different periods, but I do not know to my knowledge at all that the original plans of the colliery have been altered since the colliery was first worked.
7,557. You don't know of your knowledge, but looking at the plans, and from your observation of the colliery itself, would you say that there had been a different system? You cannot say as to that? — I said before, the general system of the colliery has been altered.
7,558. You mean only in detail? — It has been altered in the detail during the separate management of the different people.
7,559. Having that in your mind, can you suggest to me any limit to which you would allow the working of the colliery to extend with only two shafts, one upcast and one downcast? — In this particular colliery?
7,560. Of any colliery, but take that particular one? — It depends entirely upon the circumstances met with in that particular colliery, and I don't think it could be laid down that any colliery should be limited to any particular area. You may have a colliery at such an area that it may be dangerous to work with two shafts, and another colliery of the same area where it would not be dangerous.
7,561. Would you recognize the difference of a trouble as a factor which would cause you to advocate additional shaft accommodation, or do you think that the existence of a trouble is of no import? — I think that the existence of troubles would to a certain extent influence the question as to the extent of area. It would be one of the elements.
7,562. One of the elements which would guide them in putting additional shaft accommodation would be the extent and area of the colliery? — Determine the area and the principle on which the colliery should be laid out.
7,563. I do not think you have formed any opinion apart from the expense — we know the expense is a serious consideration as to the advisability of there being additional shafts in this colliery, or perhaps I ought not to say additional shafts, but that the workings should be more circumscribed in respect of the existing shafts? — I have never given that subject my consideration at all.
7,564. You could not express any opinion as to the advisability of not working so much area with only two shafts? — No, I could not.
7,565. With regard to the shaft in the Maudlin seam north-east, supposing a shaft had been there, you have no doubt but that the lives of those men would have been spared? — It depends entirely upon where the men were at the time. In the first place, where the shaft was, and where the men were in relation to the shaft.
7,566. I am putting a shaft somewhere outside the scene of the explosion — outside the area of the explosion — putting the shaft in the far north east corner, so far north that the possible access to it by the explosion would not have happened; would it not, in your opinion, have been the means of preserving the lives of those men? — You mean that the shaft should be in such a position that the explosion did not reach, and that the men were working at such a distance that they were not affected by the explosion, and that these men could not get out there (pointing).
7,567. If you formulate it in that way, you must give the answer in the affirmative ; but I was assuming a shaft in the north-east corner under the circumstances which we know to have existed, would those men's lives have been spared? I suppose you understand the circumstances. I suppose you know that these men were alive and lived some hours after the explosion. Is it reasonable to suppose that those men's lives would have been spared? — I think it would have been if the shaft had not been damaged by the explosion, and that they could have got to it. The ventilation would have been different if the shaft had been down. There would have been a different system of ventilation.
7,568. You have heard the evidence of Professor Abel and Mr. Armstrong. What conclusion do you arrive at as to the presence of a shaft? Do you think a shaft would be the conductor of explosive force? — Nearly all my experience is, that where the explosion has taken place the blast has run to fresh air, due very largely to the inclination of the fire taking off the fresh air and so running towards it.
7,569. Putting it in this case, do you believe if a shaft had been placed there it would have caused the explosion to have travelled further than it did? — I think it is very likely.
7,570. And up to the shaft? — I think so; but I think it is very likely that the explosion would have run further than it did.
7,571. You do not think it was a mere case of the explosive force having been exhausted? — Not entirely. Certainly it was exhausted, due to the conditions in which this place was in, but there is no doubt that force going into the compressed air in the way in which it was going would not have gone if there had been no compression.
7,572. But if a shaft had been in connection with the returns instead of being in connection with the intakes, that difficulty would have been obviated? — I am not sure. I am rather of the impression that the explosion had come through the returns.
7,573. Not down the intakes. If the shaft had been in connection with the returns instead of with the intakes, then the difficulty would have been got rid of? — If that explosion did not affect the condition of separating the return from the intake.
7,574. (The Coroner.) Only one question, Mr. Wood. Would this additional shaft that Mr. Jones is speaking of have any effect in reducing the temperature of the mine? — You mean in that particular way?
7,575. Just take the mine as it is, and as he puts the shaft, would it have any appreciable effect in making the temperature cooler? — It could not have affected this part of the mine ; it might have affected No. 2, here (pointing). That is the difference. I do not know what it is. There may be a certain increase of temperature between the bottom of No. 1 pit and the place it is proposed a new shaft should be, and that temperature would have been reduced at that point.
7,576. It would not affect it any further? — But I do not think it would affect this temperature in the face of the workings. I think that the temperature in the face of the workings would come up to the ordinary temperature.
7,577. (Mr. Wright.) As to the shaft being put in the return. I should have thought the shaft in the return would have deranged the ventilation? — Yes.
7,578. You would have had the fan at the top, and that would have been a separate mine? — Yes.
7,579. (Mr. Jones.) But you could put in a regulator? — And stopped the shaft up.
7,580. Not to do that, but to regulate the air? — If you regulate the air, you must have it going either up or down, and either way it would have deranged the existing system of ventilation.
7,581. But you could prevent the air passing in such a way as to interfere with the system of ventilation in existence? — You would have to stop it.
(Mr. Wright.) You might have doors; it would be a mere escaping place.
7,582. (Mr. Jones.) But what I take Mr. Lindsay Wood to say is this: that the best way in your opinion to remedy any defects of shaft accommodation is to work a limited area with two shafts? — To work a certain area. There is a limit; but I do not say what that limit is.
7,583. It is not a number of shafts scattered promiscuously, which would, of course, derange it, but working the mine over a limited area with two shafts? — Over an area.
7,584. Which you would limit? — Which must be limited.
7,585. (The Coroner.) Could you put it this way, that two shafts shall only be placed for so many acres of workings, and three shafts for double the number of acres. Could you put it in that way? — I think it would be excessively difficult to do so, and I do not think that it would be probably any safer. You may have accidents, and we have accidents in all pits where the shafts are very close together, and I think that the statistics throughout England will show that the largest and greatest number of accidents arise in those districts in which there is a multiplicity of shafts.
7,586. (Mr. Wright.) Some of us think this question is important. We should like to have your judgment in this matter. In the case of this mine, would you say whether it was under-shafted or not? — I do not think it is, although I have the management of some close to it, I do not know any in which the air-ways and the quantities of air are better than in this mine.
7,587. (The Coroner.) Right to the face? — Right to the face. I have been into returns, and they are extraordinarily large in comparison with other mines.
7,588. (Mr. Jones.) But still it is an added element of danger, and increases in extent of the workings? — I think that those workings are not exorbitantly distant from the shaft. I take it that they are rather nearer the shaft than a large number of mines in the district.
7,589. Are not the workings in this colliery almost the most extensive in the North of England? — I do not think so — not as to the distance from the shaft.
7,590. Is not the mileage of the workings, and the distance which they have to go — the intakes and the returns — is not that almost as great as any colliery in the United Kingdom? — That may be in the mileage of different ways going up there and there (pointing), but that would not be a fact if you had shafts all over. But what I was speaking of is the extreme distance of any particular point from the actual shafts, and I say that this colliery is not excessive in that respect.
7,591. According to the extent of the workings so the more complicated becomes the intakes and the returns? — I do not think so. Each particular intake and each particular return has a system of itself. There is no complication. You may think that it is complicated by your merely looking at the plan.
7,592. But you say there is no complication of the returns and intakes in the mine? — I do not think there is any great complication. It may require some explanation to an unpractised man, and even to a practised man, to understand the bearings of one with the other.
7,593. If you were laying out the mine afresh you would not lay it out as it is? — I rather think I would not. I have never gone very carefully into the minute consideration of it, but on the face of it I cannot say that I would do differently.
7,594. You are aware that there are two distinct mines? — Yes.
7,595. (Mr. Bell.) Did you observe the divergence of force in the old incline way when you were down? — Yes.
7,596. Were they not precisely similar to those in the Polka way? — Very much similar to what they are here.
7,597. How do you account for the divergence of force in the old inclined way? — I think that the force clearly went in. There is a large indication of force at the end of No. 3, which was hemmed in, so to speak, by an hermetically sealed goaf.
7,598. Would it not account for the appearances in the Polka way in the same manner? — I do not think in the Polka way there is any of the close confinement. It had all the way to expend its force.
7,599. Were there any appearances in the Polka way inconsistent with an explosion having occurred elsewhere? — I think there were. I think the indications at the Polka way end would not have been as they were if the explosion had occurred at Brown's shot. If the explosion had occurred at that shot, it would have divided and come up two ways. The traffic way was very little damaged.
7,600. Supposing you were to allow that an explosion did not take place at the Polka way end, would not you expect to find more indications of fire south coming this way than you observed? — I think the indications of fire were the greatest out over; the fire was catching the fresh air.
7,601. This would be fresh air coming in on the main intake? — It would be fresh air.
7,602. Would you not have expected to find more indications in-bye? — You ask me whether I would not have expected to have found more indications of fire in-bye than the Polka way if the explosion occurred there. I saw throughout the whole of this mine the least indications of fire that I have ever seen in an explosion before, and I think the indications here would not have been very great. As I said before, for the reason I gave, the intensity of the fire would have been greater when against the current of air than it would be going in.
7,603. There are no indications of fire between the Polka turn and the far off way, or the third east way; but there are very strong indications of fire between the shaft and the old inclined way ; would not you have expected to have indications of fire at the nearer point to the seat of the explosion than you would taking it right away to the far point, No. 3, at the old incline? — It might be so and it might not be so. The greatest point of burning was here (pointing), where it came to fresh air.
7,604. You have all your staple fires in the immediate vicinity of the shaft, and the old main coal staple bottom and the stables, and you have no fires on this side of the Polka way? — You have timber scorched between the curve and the Maudlin engine up to the main coal staple and you have none on the timbers on this side of the Polka way.
(Mr. Wright.) The indications of burning resemble a compass with its legs open. Upon the theory that the explosion happened at the curve, the explosion happened at the equidistant point from both feet of the compasses, and if you put it at the Polka turn you put it at one foot of the compasses. You have to account for the fire travelling the whole length of one leg and not the other.
(Mr. Bell.) That is so; then on the other hand you have the air running into the Maudlin.
(The Coroner.) Had not we better get that from your report?
7,605. (Mr. Bell.) There is as long a leg between the curve into the No. 3 incline as you have to the Polka turn? — Yes.
7,606. Having the whole circuit of the compasses it takes one leg and leaves this side entirely untouched? — I do not remember any particular indications of fire till you reach here (pointing) near the Maudlin engine way.
7,607. (The Coroner.) You say the burning in the positions you found them were owing, in your opinion, to the greater access of fresh air to those points? — That is my opinion.
7,608. And that the reason for there not being so much evidence of burning at the Polka way end was on the same ground? — Yes.
7,609. (Mr. Bell.) Then there would be an equal chance of getting access to fresh air on the south side of the Polka turn as there was at the south side of the inclined way? — I said, having the blast going with the air — pushing it in.
7,610. But it went with great force? — I cannot say that I am correct in my theory, but that is my impression.
7,611. I will not press that any further, but I would like to ask if you remember the scorching of the wall side opposite the Maudlin engine? — Near the Maudlin engine there was.
7,612. I believe you pointed that out to Mr. Armstrong and Mr. Stratton, and I think Mr. Foster was there? — I took this coal away with me that I thought was burnt.
7,613. The reason I want to have that clear is, that the Professor has not been able to discover any traces of burning from the samples at that particular point? — I think it is quite possible.
7,614. (Mr. Atherley Jones.) It is suggested to me that you made some experiments yourself with coal dust ; I do not know whether that is so? — It is so.
7,615. You have heard the evidence of Professor Abel ; I do not know whether you have anything which you can add thereto, founded upon your own observations? — I cannot add anything. The results of my experiments had not quite the same results as Professor Abel's, but I must say that they were not conducted with the degree of accuracy that his experiments were conducted.
7,616. That is the reason I ask you that question? — I found it required a larger percentage of gas to cause an explosion with the addition of the coal-dust than Professor Abel has found.
7,617. (Mr. Edge.) When you mentioned to my friend that the existence of a trouble would be a consideration as to whether you should have an additional shaft, you mean the trouble might render it inconvenient to work the shafts? — It might; it might be advisable to detach a piece of that gallery to another set of shafts.
7,618. Not that the question of the trouble would cause an element of danger? — No; but looking to the geological formation, it might be advisable to detach that piece to another set of shafts.
7,619. One seam would be thrown up, and the other down. My friend has asked you about the distances; do you consider that there is any danger in the world in working this particular colliery with the shafts they have? — No, I do not.
7,620. I suppose in all collieries, whether the area is large or small, it depends on the airways being perfect or imperfect — you would have equal danger in a smaller gallery if the airways were imperfect? — Yes.
7,621. My friend did not cross-examine you as to the working of this colliery; you know the airways of this colliery? — Some of them.
7,622. So far as you have seen them are they perfect and according to the best system? — They are; they are very large, both the intakes and returns are exceptionally large.
7,623. As a matter of fact, I do not know whether you know it, the face of the workings furthest off from the shaft are about two miles. Is it not a fact that in Merton and Haswell, and several other collieries in the north, the face of the workings is further from the pit? — I do not know those collieries, but I do know collieries with the face of the workings from one and a-half to two miles from the pits.
7,624. Would not it be a possible source of danger in the future if you sank your shafts nearer the edge of your royalty that when you came to work back you would have your shaft back in the goaf? — If you had a shaft at the edge of the gallery you would have to work the coal over, and it would be really useless.
7,625. Supposing you were to sink a shaft up in the Maudlin, you would be sinking near the edge of your royalty, and when you came to work back you would leave your shaft stuck back in the goaf? — You would have to take the course of stopping that shaft up after you got to the goaf.