Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Inquests Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Inquests
/   \

1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster

Inquest Report

Seaham Colliery Inquest, 13th April 1881.

The Londonderry Institute, Seaham Harbour, 13th April 1881.

Twelth Day.

Present:

Representatives of the Home Office — Mr. R. S. WRIGHT, Barrister; Mr. THOMAS BELL,. Mr. JAMES WILLIS, Government Inspectors; Mr. W. ATKINSON, Assistant Inspector.

Representatives of the Marquis of Londonderry — Mr. JOHN EDGE (instructed by Mr. H. B. Wright).

Representatives of the Durham Miners' Association — Mr. ATHERLEY JONES, Barrister (instructed by Mr. Marshall and Mr. Bowey); and Messrs. CRAWFORD and FORMAN.

Mr. Lindsay Wood recalled.

7,745. (Mr. Wright.) There is some correction you wish to make? — I think I said yesterday, in answer to Mr. Jones, who asked whether I was present at the inquest that was held on the 1871 explosion, that I was not present. I found afterwards that I was examined on that occasion. I had forgotten the circumstance.

7,746. Are your able to remember whether that explosion was coincident in time with the explosion of a shot? — I don't remember. I have forgotten all the facts.

7,747. With regard to the present subject of inquiry? — I did not fully put to you one or two points on which I desire to have the benefit of your judgment. First of all, you did not see the mine very shortly after the accident? — Not until the 12th of October.

7,748. That is about six weeks after? — I think it is.

7,749. But after that time you think that you are able to form a fairly clear judgment as to the cause of the explosion and the course which it took? — Yes.

7,750. But should you not say that in the course of six weeks, owing to the clearing up of the pit, that that circumstance would be of great importance and value in forming a judgment? — I think that it would be important. I think that the signs that I did see were sufficient.

7,751. You come to the conclusion that the Polka way end was the place where the explosion occurred from the appearance and what occurred there? — Yes.

7,752. But the point that I wish specially to direct your attention to is this. If the explosion happened from gas coming off from the falls near the trouble at the Polka way and exploded thereabouts, how, on that theory, can you account for the strong indications of a blast having come in-bye into the No. 1 from the beginning of the downcast pit? — I think that those indications on coming in-bye were nearer to the bottom of the shaft, and I think that the reaction would occur to some extent at that point. I think that the large expansion of air occurred in the engine plane, and that the pulling and collapsing would cause a current.

7,753. I want to follow that out a little. The explosion as it went out, on your theory, from No. 1 would not meet at the shaft or anywhere thereabouts anything to stop it; therefore it could not be accounted for by the back lash, but it may be accounted for by the stoppage of the explosion, by the exhaustion of the explosion leaving a vacuum so that the flame might come back? — Yes; and especially down the shaft.

7,754. But the fact remains that the explosion did travel for a very great distance both into the No. 3 and into the Maudlin, and seeing the fact that it did travel so far, it is rather inconsistent with the idea that it terminated at the shaft? — I did not say terminated, because it did not terminate; but I say that the condensing of the enormous expansion would cause a sudden sucking down through the shaft that must be accounted for as a force which caused the mixing up.

7,755. Do you think that would be sufficient? — That is the only way I can account for it. I think the explosion would account for this force.

7,756. Would that account for the perishing of the lattice work in the pit — that mere atmospheric effect? — The atmospheric effect would not cause the perishing, but something must come against it with weight that would cause it.

7,757. Was there anything? — Yes, I think so.

7,758. Would it account for the tubs which were sheered off their bottoms in the in-bye direction? — It is difficult for me to say that the tubs were sheered by the bottoms; the place was very largely removed previous to my being there.

7,759. Just bring your mind to this. There is another point, and all the evidence points to it, viz., that somewhere about No. 3 west incline, beyond Venner's shot here, were double signs — inward signs and outward signs. Again, take the Maudlin pit; there again, as the evidence shows, there were indications both ways — inwards and outwards? — I did not see the Maudlin.

7,760. But there were double indications. The evidence shows that this is strong?

(Mr. Jones.) Not in the Maudlin.

7,761. (Mr. Wright.) Yes; in the travelling way and in the engine plane. (To the Witness.) Assuming that there are in each of these two cases, be they slight or strong, you think that they are consistent with the case, with the gas in the Maudlin and No. 3 shaft, that the explosion did come out of the Polka? — I cannot say as to the Maudlin, because I did not see that, but I should not apply it to the Maudlin as No. 3. The No. 3 is more likely to be found, and what I saw there is very much like what we would have naturally expected to be found.

7,762. Supposing the gas came out from the fall near the trouble of the Polka, the gas would naturally work down with the ventilation further into No. 1 — the gas that came out of the fall that you suppose? — If the gas came out of the fall it would go in-bye with the current.

7,763. Would not you with all your experience in other cases have expected a much more prolonged ruin and wreckage in No. 1 on that theory than has actually happened? — Well, I cannot very well say; I think myself that if the gas is coming off where the fall was — the firing at Ramshaw's lamp — that the effect of the explosion running into the fresh air would cause a greater damage and greater development of air than coming in with the current.

7,764. We have an extreme case; from the point at which you fix the explosion it only went 100 yards in-bye, and did not do serious damage? — Not much damage, but I do not know that there was much to damage. You must consider the nature of the roof and obstruction to form an idea of damage. You may have a large amount of damage done by a little force; if you have timber all round, the debris produced is very great with a little force, whereas on the hardstone drift out-bye the force might be excessive, and yet there would be no harm done.

7,765. That would equally apply to the very distant falls of No 3 and in the Maudlin? — Yes.

7,766. So that on one side you have only 200 or 300 yards extension of damage in-bye in the fall? — I cannot speak to distance.

7,767. Well, never mind. On the one side your have, say, from 250 to 300 yards — I speak subject to correction; on the other side you have something like a mile extension of the Maudlin? — I suppose it would be.

7,768. And something like three-quarters, or fully a mile, into No. 3 Hutton? — Yes, I think that is so.

7,769. Would not your say that that was a strong argument against its originating near the Polka? — No.

7,770. You take a much stronger view than Mr. Stratton? — Yes, according to the evidence that you read yesterday.

7,771. Would it be correct to say that you have a "slight preponderance of opinion?" — I have more than a slight inclination; I think it is the more likely case of the two.

7,772. One more question about this fall. It is a pure assumption that the fall was the effect, or was accompanied by, any outburst or outcome of gas? — Yes.

7,773. It was a pure assumption? — Clearly. I examined the fall up to the top, and I found no gas at that time.

7,774. Nor any indications that the fall might have been the effect of the explosion? — I think that the effect of the appearance of the stone was this, as if it had fallen previous to the explosion.

7,775. But that might be the back force that produced considerable signs into the No. 1. I might say that the top of the fall was swept in the out-bye direction? — Yes.

7,776. That would equally be accounted for on the theory that the whole explosion had come in, and if this fall was produced by the explosion, it would be equally swept out by the back lash of the explosion from the southern part of No. 1? — Well, I think all the indications at that point were out-bye.

7,777. The explosion passed the fall and came far in, and there must have been a certain amount of back lash? — You presume that the force came in-bye?

7,778. Yes. I want to know whether the signs of sweeping outward that you saw would not be sufficiently accounted for by the fact of some effects of the explosion. They were firstly here (pointing), and secondly coming outward from No. 1? — If the force came in over.

7,779. Come first of all in over, would the back lash account for the sweeping? — I think that it would hardly do so.

7,780. You are aware that there are old cracks quite open. Would these have let out gas? — If they are let out where gas is lodged, but no one can tell how far they go.

(Mr. Edge.) (Mr. Wood.) I see that you are reported to have said yesterday that the Seaham Colliery was under-shafted.

(The Coroner.) I am clear that this is a mistake.

7,781. (Mr. Edge.) You were reported to have said that the Seaham Colliery was undershafted? — It is exactly the reverse.

(Mr. Jones.) We are not responsible for that.

(Mr. Edge.) It is in the Newcastle Daily Journal.

7,782. (Mr. Jones.) I should like to ask a question on what you have just said. I understand you to say that by the exhaustion of the explosion a partial vacuum was created? — The result of an explosion?

7,783. Quite so. And then that the air rushed back again, and would account for those indications in-bye? — The air would rush down No. 1 shaft to fill up the vacuum which was caused.

7,784. Is not there a slight difficulty in the theory that the No. 1 shaft was completely choked up by debris? — I do not think it was sufficiently choked up, because the air went down. It was so much choked up that a man could not pass up and down. The timbers were all thrown down; but I was not aware, nor am I aware, that the shaft was completely choked.

7,785. We have it in evidence that it was practically closed — I wont say hermetically closed — but it was closed to such an extent as would not, in your judgment, materially militate against the proposition which you have put forward? — I did not see the shaft. If the shaft was completely closed, my theory falls to the ground.

7,786. May I ask your attention to the crossing before you get to the Polka — the first crossing. Was your attention directed to that? — Yes.

7,787. You found that completely broken? — I did.

7,788. Would you attribute the possibility of a back lash there — I wont call it a back lash — but would you attribute the possibility of air rushing in and producing such manifestations as you saw? — No; I think that those crossings were damaged by the force of the explosion.

7,789. Would the air rushing in from the returns at that crossing be likely to produce results similar to those which you describe as having resulted from the air rushing in down the shaft? — If I remember rightly, there were some spread about here (pointing), thrown both ways at that crossing.

7,790. But this crossing was completely laid bare so that the return was brought into one with the intake? — That, I think, was done by the force of the explosion.

7,791. Now would the air rushing in from the returns be likely to produce the results that your attribute to air rushing down the shaft? — There is no doubt that if this was the centre of the great expansion the air would also come from the returns as well as any other part of the mine.

7,792. Would it be as likely to produce those in-bye manifestations which your have detailed to us as if it had come down the shaft? — If there was sufficient air to do it matters not where it comes from.

7,793. And you form the opinion that there would be sufficient air? — I do not think that the back lash came from the returns so much as from the shaft. My impression is that there was room in the shaft. I may be wrong in that.

7,794. Supposing there was not room in the shaft, would you be able to attribute the same results to what you describe as the back lash from the returns? — From the returns of the other parts.

7.795. Might I put it in this way. That crossing having been broken, would the air rushing from those returns be likely to produce the in-bye manifestations which you have told us of? — I can hardly answer that. I think that the back lash might be described as coming from this crossing, but whether the air coming from the crossing did occasion the back lash, or whether the air from the other parts of the mine occasioned the back lash it is impossible for me to say.

7,796. Assuming that the back lash from this crossing might produce these results, such as those you describe, assuming that the explosion had travelled from No. 3 down the Polka way, might not the same result arise from the back lash travelling in a different direction? — I cannot tell what the meaning of that is.

(Mr. Wright.) It is mere argument.

7,797. (Mr. Jones.) Suppose the explosion had travelled from number three, you have then in-bye manifestations all the way. But you say there are out-bye manifestations? — Yes.

7,798. Now supposing there had been a back lash from these crossings, would not that account for the out-bye manifestations? — Would you allow me to put the case? I think you mean this, that if the explosion had occurred in number three, and the force of the explosion had come up number one, and the back lash had occurred from that explosion, would that back lash have accounted at all for the appearance of the outward force from the Polka way doors to the shaft? Now I hardly think that it would. It is a matter of opinion.

7,799. That is quite sufficient for me. The crossings were repaired when you went down? — I think they were temporarily repaired.

The witness withdrew.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print