1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
Seaham Colliery Inquest, 12th April 1881 (cont.).
Mr. William Armstrong sworn.
7,225. (Mr. Edge.) I think you are a mining engineer of very considerable experience, not only in the north of England, but all over the mining districts? — Yes.
7,226. You are one of the Board, I think, that took the direction as to the explosion? — I did.
7,227. Did you go down and make an examination subsequent to the explosion? — I think about five weeks after.
7,228. I will assume you are starting from No. 1 pit. Will you go along into No. 1 Hutton, and describe what you saw — anything of importance as showing an indication, in your judgment, as the possible origin of the explosion? — I wanted, first of all, to discover, if I possibly could, if there were any indications that the explosion occurred in the main coal staple; next, if it was possible that the explosion had originated from the shots in the drift ; and thirdly, whether there was any other point north of the No. 1 pit which I possibly could put my finger upon in which the explosion might originate.
7,229. Did you come to any opinion on the matter? Looking at all the circumstances from beginning to end, I have looked into them as closely as I could, and looking to the time at which I was down the pit I think the preponderance of evidence clearly is that the seat of the explosion was at the Polka way end, and that it did not occur either at the shot or at the bottom of the main coal staple.
7,230. What did you find in the neighbourhood of the Polka way end to lead you to the conclusion that that was the possible seat of the explosion? — First of all, I saw a great exhibition of force at the bottom of No. 1 pit, the lattice of the grate was forced into the centre of the pit, and there were marks of explosion of enormous force. The timbers of the pit had been very greatly injured. Going southwards, it was obvious that the blast had travelled towards the No. 1 pit. Props and timbers were lying more or less in that direction. There was some timber lying in the opposite way, but the great bulk was lying towards the pit; there was a good deal of hay also lying about. There were some bricks at the junction of the two ways which had been carried a considerable distance from the point where they originally were put in.
7,231. Going into No. 1 Hutton? — Yes. We then came to the double intake way, and after going a certain distance in that we found that the explosion had travelled but a very short way and then was arrested.
7,232. From the junction of the engine plane to the travelling way? — We went along the travelling way first of all, and after going a very short distance we found that any further exhibition of force was arrested altogether. We then went to the engine plane, almost opposite to where the Polka way end is; we then went still further south in-bye sufficient to show me that the direction of the blast was entirely in-bye from that point. I travelled some few yards so as to show there was a great exhibition of force which had gone the contrary way to what I observed in No. 1. We then came back to the position where I was told the old man Ramshaw was found, and his lamp was found on the in-bye side of him, completely destroyed, and I saw Ramshaw's tub lying covered with stones forced into the sides of the wall, all indicating that the blast had gone in-bye. Having gone that far, I came to a position in which I could see no indications at all, either in-bye or out-bye ; there seemed to be a stop altogether.
7,233. Whereabouts was that? — Just here, where the dyke crosses, there seemed to be a sort of stagnation. I continued my course ; at last I came to a large fault, 16 or 17 yards long, and I think the stones may have been five or six yards thick. I examined the roof minutely, and found there some very large gullets which completely ran across the plane, and these went perpendicularly upwards, and of course they went downwards and in close vicinity to the seven-foot way. I then had no doubt in my own mind that they connected themselves with the dyke they were upon, there seemed to be no difficulty in the way; and I also observed that all the stones in that large fall had been swept by the action of the blast, and very considerable force appeared to have gone up that way.
7,234. You mean on the top of the stones? — On the top of the stones. We had great difficulty in getting over the fall, but of course it was got over, and I then discovered on the out-bye side of the fall there were many indications of dust deposited out of the way of the blast, upon the lee side of the blast, but in the other direction near to where the Polka way was. There was no deposit of dust in the Polka way ; the dust was exclusively on the outside, and on the lee side of the stone, over which, of course, the dust had gone. From thence I went back again and pursued my course straight round the curve to where the shots had been fired, and I examined the shot very closely, and found it had done its work.
7,235. Brown's shot? — Yes, Brown's shot had done its work ; the stones were all lying as they had recently fallen there; it had not been a large shot, and yet the whole of the stone had been detached. There again the blast had swept over the top of these stones, leaving a deposit of dust upon the lee side in the same sort of way, and the other side, where the action of the blast had passed, was swept quite clean.
7,236. Did you notice the rapper rope? — Yes it was coiled up ; there appeared to be marks of great velocity.
7,237. Did the coiling of the rapper rope give you any indication of how the blast had gone? — Most unquestionably, from west to east. First of all, I went into the Maudlin engine plane, and there was a most extraordinary exhibition of force, because the blast had come through the hole by which you enter into the Maudlin junction. The handle for reversing the steam was bent right down in the direction of the blast, and a little further forward there was a small boiler set upon its end; the pressure of the blast had indented the iron completely in ; it had then lashed towards the north, and put a similar pressure upon the back side of it. The force must have been enormous, because it was a piece of ordinary boiler plate, and the collapse inward to a particular point was one of the most curious things we ever saw.
7,238. Does that afford you any indication? — It afforded me an indication that the blast had come from the west to the east, through the hole in the boiler. The engine stands east and west. It had caught the side of the boiler, turned the boiler round, and went forward.
7,239. (Mr. Wright.) Which way through the boiler did the blast go? — There was a hole by which it had got into the engine house; the engine house is parallel with this line; it entered inwards, found no relief there at all, and scattered about in all directions.
7,240. And got to the west? — I do not believe it did. It came out again at the same hole. I think it went from east to west.
(Mr. Wright.) This is common ground; nobody disputes this.
7,241. (The Coroner.) Would Mr. Armstrong distinguish the different aspect which it would have presented if the explosion took place in the Polka way instead of having occurred at the shot — would it make any difference? — Nothing but the enormous force.
7,242. It would not give any strong indication, it might have come from either place? — From either place.
7,243. (Mr. Edge.) Did you see any indication showing that the origin of the explosion was in the neighbourhood of Brown's shot? — Not any.
7,244. It is suggested that Venner's shot may have caused the explosion. In your experience, have you ever known a shot to be fired when a man was in a stow-hole within 20 yards and straight in the line with the shot? — I do not quite understand.
7,245. It is suggested that Venner's shot might have caused the explosion; I do not know whether you are aware that one man was found in the stowhole? — Yes, the position of the man was pointed out to me.
7,246. You saw the place behind the stow-hole about where the man was fired? — Yes.
7,247. In your experience is it at all probable that a man would be there at the time that Venner's shot was fired? — He would have been a great fool if he had been there.
7,248. He was in the direct line of shot? — I cannot conceive anyone being such a fool; nevertheless, he might have been there.
7,249. Going to the main coal staple, what leads you to the conclusion that probably it was not there that the explosion took place? — The blast coming from east to west along here, and in a straight line, would at this particular point ---
7,250. At Venner's shot? — A little afterwards it would have three lines to go up, one would be the old Hutton seam inclined plane, the other the main hole way, and the other the third Hutton seam. You can easily conceive the enormous confusion there would be at the bottom of the pit you must also consider that nothing was seen of the main coal shaft until after the explosion was over. A very extraordinary reaction takes place, an immense volume of cold air sweeps into the pit after the whole explosion has been at an end to fill up the vacuum and we had all this recoil air coming down the incline plane, meeting the cross currents in every direction, and these produced such an impression on the bottom of the main coal shaft as I think I never saw in my whole life-time; it went in all possible directions it took the most erratic course, and I cannot conceive it possible that anything was generated there unless there were some doors which might have been propped open or some stopping. and that the return air might have been foul in that particular place. A combination of all these causes put together might have come out at the precise moment of time — of course it is possible.
7,251. Can you suggest how gas would have got to the immediate neighbourhood of the main coal staple unless one of the return air doors had been propped open or some stopping had been knocked out? — I cannot suggest any other way. The return air could not have been foul, because if it had been foul its course to the furnace was exceedingly short, it would have shown itself upon the furnace; there was no exhibition at all upon the furnace.
7,252. You know the distance of the stone drift from No. 1 shaft — 151 yards? — It will not be more than that.
7,253. From your experience, knowing the workings of this pit, can you conceive that there could have been any gas found in that stone drift? — I cannot conceive such a thing possible.
7,254. Even as small a quantity as 2½ per cent.? — Certainly not, nor any quantity. The explosion took place at night-time, and I believe the air down as far as the No. 1 pit was as pure as it was upon the surface.
7,255. So far as you can see, looking at it from your experience, you can suggest no possible means by which gas could have got to the stone drift? — Certainly I cannot.
7,256. I do not know how long the connection between the No. 3 pit and No. 1 and No. 2 has existed? — No, I do not know.
7,257. I suppose you have known the history of all the explosions in the Durham and Northumberland coalfields for the last 30 or 40 years? — I have been in the pits 50 years; my first attendance at an explosion was in 1830; I have attended different explosions since that time in different parts of the country.
7,258. Have you ever known any suggestion that an explosion could be traced to gas having gone over the furnace in this district? — I never have.
7,259. There have been a large number of shafts ventilated by means of furnaces? — A great many have been; less now than there used to be.
7,260. I has been suggested that if there had been a shaft somewhere — I suppose about the high end of the Maudlin — the men who were there would have been saved? — I think it is very difficult indeed for any person to give an opinion upon a question of that sort. If the men who where there were in the line of travel of the blast, between the top of the engine plane and the position of the shaft you would have put down, they would have inevitably been destroyed.
7,261. According to your experience, if there had been a shaft there, the blast would have gone to the shaft? — Certainly; the blast from the explosion always travels upon the line of the least resistance, and the blast would have gone to the shaft first of all.
7,262. Choke-damp would have followed after the fire-damp, and that would have affected the people who would have been in that district? — Yes; every volume of fire-damp produces ten volumes of chokedamp, and you can easily conceive to what extent that would flow on both sides.
7,263. It has been suggested by Mr. Jones that the explosion wasted itself away when it had travelled half-way up towards the north portion of the Maudlin? — I am not prepared to say that would not have been the case; it is very difficult to say.
7,264. I am assuming a shaft to be there? — If the blast had been sufficiently strong at the top of the incline plane to have gone down that, it would have taken to the shaft; but if so small a quantity of blast had gone down as would scarcely have reached the shaft, it might have been arrested half-way or two thirds of the way down — such a thing might occur.
7,265. (The Coroner.) Would such a power have created so much damage in other shafts? — Of course, if it once went there it would create quite as much damage.
7,266. I mean, considering the explosive force creating the damage at the other shaft that it has done, can you form any idea whether that was such a force as would have stopped before getting to the other shaft? — I cannot really tell.
7,267. (Mr. Edge.) I do not know whether you explored the Maudlin yourself? — No ; it was stopped off.
7,268. What is your experience with regard to shot firing and coal dust? — Well, I may explain first of all, I do not know of my own knowledge of more than three shots which have been blown out during the whole time I have been down the pits — what you may call blown-out shots. Of course I have seen thousands of ordinary shots, but of blown-out shots not more than three altogether
(Mr. Atherley Jones.) It is not suggested by us that they were blown-out shots.
7,269. (Mr. Edge.) What is your experience about a shot that has done its work; what effect would that have? — I never heard of it, and I never saw it, and I never heard of anybody who ever heard of it that it ever had a tendency to ignite small coal dust.
7,270. That is your experience? — Yes; and I have seen hundreds of common ordinary shots.
7,271. (Mr. Wright.) I believe you are consulting engineer to this colliery? — No, I am not.
7,272. Your never have been? — I have been occasionally consulted — formerly.
7,273. And recently? — No.
7,274. Not in Mr. Stratton's time? — No.
7,275. There is nothing to be ashamed of? — I do not feel the slightest sense of shame; but I have not been so. Of course I act as a viewer, and if they call me in I come professionally; but I have not been here more than twice in these last three or four years.
7,276. As a matter of fact, you were called in early after the explosion? — Yes.
7,277. And you expressed your opinion that it probably arose in the Polka way? — I did.
7,278. Very early? — It was some time afterwards.
7,279. And that view has been adopted by the proprietors throughout? — I do not know; I really cannot tell. It is not my view, you must remember, it was suggested to me first of all by Mr. Stratton.
7,280. I am in error in supposing that it was you who suggested it? — You are.
7,281. However, you adopted it at first? — I examined it for myself, and thought Mr. Stratton's suggestion was a very good one.
7,282. Do you say there is a strong preponderance of evidence in favour of it? — Yes.
7,283. Then you go beyond what Mr. Stratton does? — I was not here when he was examined.
7,284. He said that there was great difficulty in forming a judgment, but that he inclined to that view? — I go much further than that, I say there is a great preponderance of evidence.
7,285. An overwhelming preponderance? — I can see no other solution of the question, because the indications are so very strong.
7,286. Nothing to do with where the gas came from, but judging by the indications themselves? — Yes.
7,287. You are quite clear? — Yes.
7,288. You are aware that there is a very great difference of opinion on this subject? — I am told that there is.
7,289. Notwithstanding that, your judgment is quite clear? — Quite clear.
7,290. Now tell me, supposing it took place about the Polka way end — I do not say it did not, I only want to know what the effect is, it is a very difficult case, supposing it did take place there — I understand your view to be that the gas came from the fall which you speak of, somewhere about the Polka turn? — Yes.
7,291. That is a very old way, many years old? — Yes.
7,292. And apparently with a firm roof? — Except, as I told you before, where it came down.
7,293. And you would expect in an old way of that kind, and with that kind of roof, any gas which there might have been in the neighbouring strata would have got drained off? — Yes.
7,294. Have you ever known the existence of an accumulation of gas coming out under similar circumstances in such an air way of that kind? — Yes, I think I can tell you one which occurred ten years ago in this very colliery itself.
7,295. Whereabouts? — In No. 3 Hutton, where the goaf is now.
7,296. It was not the open air way? — Yes.
7,297. Was a trouble there? — There was a trouble; a very large fall had taken place some years ago, and it was very much covered up with timber; it was on the top of the incline, and I found a tremendous fall of stone there, I found indications precisely similar to what I found here.
7,298. What year was it that you found these indications? — Ten years ago.
7,299. Was there an explosion? — Yes, there was one man a little further in-bye than the top of the wheel ; he was killed, his lamp was found on the inside of himself where he lay, his tub was found in-bye, and the blast had travelled until it came to a stable, where it set fire to the hay.
7,300. I do not think we need have details of that? — I wanted to show the very great similarity of the two phenomena.
7,301. After the fall you have just told us of, which produced an explosion in No. 3 Hutton, did you inspect the fall within a few days? — I did.
7,302. Did you notice any gas? — No.
7,303. You would expect, taking a fall such as you have referred to in the Polka way, that if there had been any considerable quantity of gas coming out of these large galleries, there would have been some continuing traces of gas for a day or two? — I do not know about a day or two, but this is characteristic in these large discharges of gas; they come very suddenly, produce an enormous effect, and then they suddenly cease, and then there is no more indication of them at all.
7,304. Is that your experience, that they cease quite suddenly? — I have had a case occurring within six months at one of my own collieries, where a large quantity of coal has been projected a considerable distance from its bed by the force of the gas behind, and not a single soul has ever seen a single trace of that gas.
7,305. Not a day afterwards? — Not six hours afterwards.
7,306. A few hours afterwards? — Perhaps so.
7,307. And here a day or two afterwards there would have been some indications? — I cannot say.
7,308. Have you considered the Maudlin engine plane? — That is quite immaterial, there are two inlets, and unquestionably if there is a double area there will be more air, but there will never be any reverse.
7,309. I am not asking you to alter your opinion, but we still have to consider all these matters ; possibly or probably you are acquainted with that part of the mine? — No, I am not; I have travelled up the two ways you have spoken of.
7,310. Of course, if they were of equal size, it would be impossible that the ventilation should have gone along the Maudlin a engine plane? — You must remember they travel along the in-bye, and before they come back they come over the furnace again, which regulates the quantity.
7,311. That arguing would cease to apply when you once get to the junction? — There are two junctions heading to the same spot, they are both from the intake; if they are both exactly the same size, the friction being the same, the quantity of air would be the same, if you have 20,000 feet of air coming up No. 1, and the two intakes were of identically the same capacity, without any obstruction, each one would contain 10,000 cubic feet of air. If there is any obstruction in the way of No. 1, more air will come up No. 2, and if there is any obstruction in No. 2, more air will come up No. 1.
7,312. Or if one is materially shorter than the other? — I am supposing the friction to be the same.
7,313. (Mr. Bell.) Did you observe any burning at the point M, near the Maudlin? — Yes.
7,314. On the floats or near the coal? — The only indication of any fire whatever was in a piece of timber high up; I cut it off with a knife, it was very small. There was not a mark of charred dust in any portions of the pit from here in any direction whatsoever, and nothing is more common than to find a large quantity of charred dust when any explosion occurs of any importance.
7,815. (Mr. Edge.) Is it possible that there could have been any stagnation of air in the main-coal staple? — The air would pass it, but there would be no stagnation in that sense of the word, I am not prepared to say the direction of the air.
7,316. There would be no stagnation? — No.
7,317. (Mr. Atherley Jones.) I understood you to say it was not until five weeks after the explosion that your made an inspection of the pit? — No.
7,318. That was the first time after the accident that you went down? — It was.
7,319. I also gather the judgment you formed was based partly on the opinion which you had received, partly a pre-conceived theory you had formed? — No; I had no pre-conceived theory at all. I went down for the purpose of ascertaining for myself.
7,320. At any rate, it was based partly upon the opinion which you received and partly on your own observations? — Afterwards.
7,321. Of course, the value of those observations I suppose you will freely admit is very much impaired owing to the lapse of time that had taken place after the explosion? — I do not know, I am an old pitman; I can pretty well judge.
7,322. I suppose there is no difference of opinion upon this point, that they would be to some extent impaired? — I grant you some little difference no doubt.
7,323. I do not know whether you have heard the evidence of the other mining engineers? — I have not.
7,324. But you would agree with them in saying that there were no certain indications, but that things appeared to be blown in all directions, in all parts of the mine where there were indications of force? — The gentlemen whom you have examined have had — I do not say it with any sort of insinuation of any kind — less experience than I have : they have not come in contact with the many cases I have seen ; they have not the illustration I have already given you upon the top of the old Hutton seam bank. Those gentlemen say they were at a loss to conceive how this gas originated, because they have had no experience.
7,325. May I suggest to you that your larger experience might be to some extent counterbalanced by the fact of their earlier opportunity of inspecting? — It might be to a certain extent counterbalanced; I do not wonder at their hesitation, and I do not wonder at my own temerity.
7,326. I think you so far coincide with their opinion, that you would not express any definite conviction as to the seat of the explosion? — I will go so far as to say this : that my conviction upon this point from all that I have known before and all that I have seen here, and what I have learnt from other explosions, is little short of demonstration.
7,327. That being so — your conviction being little short of demonstration, may I ask you to what you attribute the explosion if it took place at the seat which you have indicated? — First of all you must assume the gas discharged — the gas is poured down with enormous force.
7,328. Am I to understand you are referring to a blower? — No, the discharge of gas from a blower is a very different thing from a bag of gas; I have known a blower blow for 30 years consecutively, but a bag of gas comes all at once.
7,329. My question is this: to what do you attribute the presence of gas in the Polka-way or the vicinity of the Polka-way, so as to cause an explosion? — To having been bottled up for years and years in the upper strata, and very likely the lower strata and in the lateral strata in all directions in the different fissures, and this gas gathered up to the highest possible state of pressure to the extent of 450 feet at the least upon the square inch, suddenly bursting down from the top of the floor into the bottom, so coming into contact with that poor man's lamp, blowing up the lamp and causing the explosion.
7,330. Am I to understand that this gas suddenly developed itself from fissures in the roof and became liberated from fissures? — Liberated by the fissures where it was collected.
7,331. Is not it a somewhat remarkable thing in your mind that in this No. 1 way, which is the old way, gas should develop itself in that way? — No, not at all. I have seen it in Lancashire just exactly in the same position, where after a place had been a waggon-way for a considerable number years, the top was forced down, gas came in contact with a naked flame, and there was an explosion.
7,332. Is not it the fact that these gullets of which you have spoken were all open? — After the fall they were all open.
7,333. At any rate, may I put it in this way: is not it certainly a very remarkable thing that gas should have been liberated in the way you suggest in a place of such long standing as No. 1 travelling way? — I will grant you, thank heaven, it is very exceptional.
7,334. Quite so, and it is something which you would consider less likely than a number of other contingencies? — No ; I do not think that.
7,335. You say it is less remarkable than other contingencies? — I do not know what other contingencies you speak of.
7,336. You have heard the evidence of Professor Abel this morning? — I have.
7,337. Do your consider the contingency upon which you base the accident more or less remarkable than that which Professor Abel has suggested? — I should think not so remarkable. The generation of an explosion by a shot in an air course is to my mind infinitely more remarkable than the generation of gas in this particular form.
7,338. Your experience will allow you to admit that the gas is frequently diffused even through the main intakes? — I never heard such a thing before.
7,339. Do I understand you to say you have never found the presence of gas? — I lay this down as a law with regard to this particular colliery; I have travelled the whole of this intake into the extremist district up to that point where it gets into the workings and begins to separate itself, and we found that with a very small degree of pollution the air would be as free as it was in the bottom of the pit.
7,340. I am not asking you so much with regard to this particular colliery, but I am asking you generally with regard to intakes. Do you controvert the suggestion that gas may be found in the intakes, not in such quantities as to cause a blue flame? — I never saw anything of the kind, and I have been in all sorts of collieries.
7,341. I might ask, how would you find out that it was free from gas? — I had my candle with me.
7,342. You are speaking about walking up the main intakes? — I am.
7,343. Had you a candle that would show 2½ per cent.? — It would show anything that could be shown.
7,344. We might conceive you would be able to walk with a naked candle through the main intakes without explosive results? — I think a naked candle is the quickest indication almost of anything.
7,345. I am asking you to bring your mind to bear upon the evidence you have heard to-day as to the addition as to the auxiliary factor of coal-dust? — I do not doubt for one moment what Professor Abel says.
7,346. You say gas would be liberated in some phenomenal way. Would not it be a very reasonable supposition that gas should be liberated by firing a shot? — Where is the gas to come from? These are questions that I cannot answer.
7,347. I have got from you this — according to your opinion in the main intake of No. 1 travelling way, gas suddenly develops itself, although the thing has not been heard of for years, and although, according to your own statement, it is very remarkable? — It is.
7,348. If gas was so generated, might it not, turning your attention to the locality of Venner's and Brown's shots, be more reasonably generated by the fire of those shots? — I do not think so at all.
7,349. Liberated? — The gas which came in at the Polka-way end was an exceptionally large sudden discharge of a most extraordinary character.
7,350. We know nothing about that? — I am indicating that to you. There is no possibility of any gas having got into the main intake at all from the curve.
7,351. If it gets into one intake, in No. 1 Hutton, what is the difficulty of its getting into No. 3 intake in No. 3 Hutton? — If you assume it possible that a large bag of gas would suddenly come down into the intake, I will at once admit the question, but I have no evidence of that, there is no fall that I know of in that part.
7,352. But might not a quantity of gas have been liberated by the firing of the shot? — Certainly not.
7,353. I do not wish to press you? — Most certainly not.
7,354. Why not? — You must tell me where the gas is to come from.
7,355. You have said gas came from the main intake of No. 1; why may it not equally readily ---? — Do you know what the length of a gas shot is — the hole of a shot? it does not extend more than 3½ feet.
7,356. Supposing it found its way into a fissure, you have known cases where your have bored into a fissure where gas is lodged? — I think I have.
7,357. Then there would be nothing impossible — we are dealing entirely with problematical questions — in my case, being equally reasonable with your proposition? — I do not think so ; there is no evidence.
7,358. On the other hand, we have no evidence in your case? — I beg your pardon, there is always a slip dyke which is the generating cause; you have not that in this particular part at all.
7,359. Let me ask you this: — Do not you consider it also a circumstance of very considerable gravity in leading you to the conclusion as to how the accident originated, that the only place in which you found bodies burnt was in No. 3 Hutton? — I do not quite understand you.
7,360. Do not your consider that a matter of considerable gravity? — There is an enormous blast.
7,361. But you know that Ramshaw's body was discovered without any signs of burning, that was in No. 1 Hutton? — Ramshaw was close to the Polka end.
7,362. He was in No. 1 Hutton, and there were no signs of burning upon him? — He was blown to pieces.
7,363. In No. 1 Hutton there were no signs of burning? — I do not know.
7,364. But in No. 3 Hutton there were signs of the bodies of men being burnt; is not that a remarkable circumstance in guiding you to a conclusion? — Not the slightest.
7,365. Why not? — I cannot tell you why it was that a man was not burnt and another man was burnt; I have seen two men lying alongside of each other — one had the whole of his hair burnt off his head, and the other was not affected by fire.
7,366. I do not wish to press you unduly, but would not you anticipate that in the immediate vicinity of the seat of the explosion the blast would be more likely to cause burning than it would to pass over the men in the immediate vicinity of the explosion and burn them at a greater distance? — I cannot follow you at all.
7,367. But you say here in No. 3 Hutton there are several men discovered burnt? — I am not surprised at that.
7,368. In No. 1 Hutton, and also in every other part of the pit, there are no indications of anybody being burnt? — There was very little burnt in the pit at all.
7,369. Do not you consider that as pointing to the greater probability of the explosion? — No, I do not.
7,370. Your remember the explosion of 1870? — I do.
7,371. In that case you gave evidence also? — Yes.
7,372. What conclusion did you arrive at? — Exactly the same as this.
7,373. Did not you consider it a very remarkable coincidence that on that occasion, immediately at the time of the explosion, a shot was being fired, and that this explosion was also immediately on a shot being fired? — It is very curious.
7,374. And also at the same place? — It is not the same place.
7,375. Some little distance off? — Yes.
7,376. I believe upon that occasion there was a great conflict of opinion? — There were two or three gentlemen had one opinion, but all the rest of the world had only one opinion.
7,377. Were you all the rest of the world? — No; I do not represent all the world. Every viewer who was examined upon that occasion, with the exception of one or two — the inspector was one, and Mr. Heccles, who is since dead, was another — everybody else held the opinion that I myself did.
7,378. I think you said on that occasion it was a coincidence that the shot and the explosion were simultaneous; I suppose you would say that this also was a remarkable coincidence? — It is a coincidence, I do not think it is remarkable, but it is a coincidence.
7,379. Then we have two coincidences? — Yes.
7,380. You have been asked about Venner's shot; you did not see the place where Venner was? — I went up the stow-hole, and I was told a man had been found there.
7,381. I wish to ask a question or two with regard to Brown's shot; you say you saw that shot, and your saw indications which to your mind showed that the shot had done its work? — Almost, not quite.
7,382. And you say your thought it was a small shot? — Yes.
7,383. What caused you to form that opinion? — From the aperture that was made.
7,384. You saw the drill-hole? — Yes, and put my finger into it.
7,385. You are aware that there had been no clearance made of the stone of that shot? — I am sure there was not.
7,386. There is about 12 inches of that shot left? — I do not think the shot was 12 inches long to begin with.
7,387. Was any left? — I mean the hole; I should think there was not more than four or five.
7,388. You would not be prepared to say definitely? — No.
7,389. Did you notice Venner's shot and what quantity was left? — No, I did not.
7,390. Are you aware that the main coal staple is indifferently ventilated from the main coal, and also from No. 3 Hutton? — I know that there is an alteration, but I have not had my attention called to it; beyond going to the bottom of the staple, and looking up the staple, I know very little about it.
7,391. Of course I am now drawing upon your very large experience? — You must not be critical as to my experience.
7,392. I will not be hypercritical ; at any rate, drawing upon your large experience, would not you expect a certain tendency on the part of the air at the bottom of the main coal staple to stagnate? — No, I would not.
7,393. Do not you consider that these two returns of air meeting each other would have a tendency to cause stagnation? — I do not see it.
7,394. What would it do? — It would come into collision to a certain extent.
7,395. One would hold the other? — I do not say that.
7,396. Would your say not? — I think it is most unlikely.
7,397. What would you expect? — It would not be affected at all, the current of air up and down the staple.
7,398. But there were two currents? — The collision of the two currents would become nothing at all.
7,399. But there would be a tendency to stagnation? — I will make you a present of the word "tendency."
7,400. That is quite sufficient. Do you know the immediate vicinity of the main coal staple? — I do not know that.
7,401. (Mr. Wright.) It is the fact that the fall is 9 or 10 yards from the fault? — I do not know that it is so ; it must be some distance off.
7,402. Do you mean to say that it is not? — I do not.
7,403. There is another thing I certainly do not understand from your evidence; these gullets that you told us of were perfectly obvious even before the explosion? — I never saw them.
7,404. And others of a similar kind are open on each side of the fall to the present day? — I have never heard such a thing.
7,405. You will not say that it is not so? — No.
7,406. If these gullets were open for years before the explosion, it is in the highest degree probable the gas would have drained off? — I cannot say.
7,407. You will not say that it is probable that the gas would have drained off? — No; whatever gas there was existing would be drained off by the gullet, but where the accumulation of gas was I cannot follow you, and how it got to the condition I cannot tell you.
7,408. A gasometer full of cracks you think would not empty itself in 20 years? — It is not a gasometer full of cracks.
7,409. (The Coroner.) You say, being ten yards away from the slip dyke does not alter your opinion? — Not the slightest in the world, the communication is quite clear.
7,410. Does the man and his lamp being broken all to pieces point either one way or the other? — It points to the source of the explosion. The gas would come down mixed with the pure air, and the first light it would come to would be that man's lamp, it would burst open that man's lamp and explode.
7,411. At the contact of the light, would the force of the explosion be so great as to smash the lamp, or would it be smashed afterwards? — You can certainly smash an ordinary Davy lamp with a current of eight feet in a second at the ignition point. I have burst dozens.
Because there have been cases where the ignition has taken place and has passed over the party and gone behind.
7,412. (Mr. Edge.) I am not quite sure whether I understood you when you say that there were four or five inches of Brown's shot left; you do not mean four or five inches of the actual chamber? — I think there was.
7,413. There may be four or five inches of the upper surface or the drill-hole? — I think there were four or five inches of coal left on.
7,414. That must be a mistake. My friend, Mr. Jones, has asked you about the gas being liberated by firing shots; was there any chamber which could have contained gas either at Venner's shot or Brown's shot? — I never heard of any.
7,415. Of course, if there was any chamber there it is to be seen still? — I should think so.
(Mr. Bell.) Would you see the chamber at the fall as well.
(Mr. Edge.) At the time the shot was fired.
(The Coroner, addressing Professor Abel.) There has been an expression of opinion from some of the jury, as well as from other parties, to the effect that they would like to see you demonstrate the idea of coal-dust firing.
(Professor Abel.) It was merely one particular kind of action of dust that I spoke about. I should be very glad to do so, and probably the best plan, with submission to you, sir, would be at any time when it would take the least time up. It would be rather interrupting your evidence to do it now.
(The Coroner.) We think we might have it now.
(Professor Abel then put some finely divided platinum on asbestos wool and held it over a gas burner; the gas was turned on, and a flame was produced in about a minute.)