Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Inquests Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Inquests
/   \

1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster

Inquest Report

Seaham Colliery Inquest, 12th April 1881 (cont.).

Mr. James Spence re-called.

7,157. (Mr. Wright.) This (pointing to the plan) is the down-cast shaft, and air coming down that shaft comes, some of it down the No. 1 intake, some of it goes straight along to the Maudlin, and some of it goes round that curve and towards No. 3 Hutton. You observe the communications from the northern part of the curve on the left or west side. This is the Maudlin on the east side. It has been suggested that the air in that Maudlin engine plane cross cut is sometimes stagnant — is that ever so? — No.

7,158. You are quite certain of that? — Yes.

7,159. You have often been through it? — Yes.

7,160. You have never found it otherwise than flowing? — Never.

7,161. Have you ever found it flowing except in one direction? — Only in-bye.

7,162. Towards the Maudlin? — Yes.

7,163. How often in the course of a week did you use to pass through it? — Twice or three times.

7,164. Every week? — Yes.

7,165. And always found a ventilation existing of 1,000 feet a minute? — More than 1,000 feet per minute — cubic feet.

7,166. What velocity would it have? — I could not say.

7,167. What is the section, 10 feet by 10 feet? — It is 10 feet by 7 feet.

7,168. That would be something like 700 per minute velocity — about 11 feet per second? — Yes; I have not measured it.

7,169. There would be a strong current? — Yes.

7,170. Always flowing towards the Maudlin? — Yes.

7,171. You have never heard a suggestion of its being slack air there, or the current reversing? — No.

7,172. You are quite positive? — Yes.

(Mr. Jones.) Is not this rather a matter for all of us to form our own conclusions upon?

(Mr. Wright.) It is exactly what we want evidence upon.

7,173. In your evidence previously, I think you did say that there would be sometimes a dullness in the air about that part? — No.

7,174. Perhaps I misunderstood you about that. Did not you put a stopping in just at the east end, or near the east end of the engine plane that we have been speaking of? — On the intake.

7,175. Did you put a regulator on the Maudlin travelling road? — No.

7,176. Neither before nor after the explosion? — No.

7,177. Has one never been placed there? — Not to my knowledge.

7,178. Just look at the arrangement of the place. There would be a pull of air from the down-cast along the travelling road into the Maudlin main intake, and from the other end of the Maudlin plane there would be a strong pull in the other direction towards the No. 3 Hutton? — Yes.

7,179. And the Maudlin plane we have been talking of would be between two pulls? — Yes.

7,180. So that if your recollection is correct, that the current always passes along that plane, it must be that the pull into the Maudlin intake was very much stronger than the pull the other way? — I never knew it pull the other way.

7,181. Where does the air come from into this piece? — Round the curve, it splits there.

7,182. And it is pulled backwards; part goes along into No. 3 Hutton, and this part is pulled backwards at the rate of something like 700 feet per minute towards the Maudlin? — Yes.

7,183. What pulls it back at that rate; what makes it go back; is there anything that makes it go back that way? — It is not on a straight line there; it is a curve, it splits at that point.

7,184. What makes the air go in that direction. The only way for the ventilation to go into the Maudlin would be along the Maudlin travelling way? — Yes.

7,185. That would be the simplest and shortest passage from the downcast? — Yes.

7,186. I want to know what there is that will make the air that has gone round that curve draw back towards the Maudlin along the Maudlin entrance place? — (The witness pointed it out on the plan.)

7,187. You say the travelling way may be choked that it cannot of itself readily supply all the air wanted in the Maudlin, and therefore, it pulls upon the engine plane to complete the supply? — Yes.

7,188. How is that; in point of fact is the area of the travelling way smaller or larger than the section of the engine plane? — It is less.

7,189. Much less? — Considerably less.

7,190. Which is the larger, the area of the No. 3 intake or the area of the Maudlin intake? — I would not like to say which of the two.

7,191. The suction entirely depends upon the suction from the returns; to ascertain how the air was pulled, you would have to go to the upcast shaft and trace the return back. The whole of the air that ultimately goes by the returns to the up-cast, must come to that junction along the in-take; the question would be, whether the pull of the return air is more effective along the travelling plane or along the engine plane; that is so, is not it? — Yes.

7,192. If we could get all the air from the travelling plane, which is the shortest way to the downcast, it would do so? — I do not understand.

7,193. Supposing the travelling plane and the engine plane were both of the same area throughout, the whole of the air would naturally come by the shortest way along the travelling plane? — Yes.

7,194. The reason it does not is because the travelling plane has a smaller section? — Yes.

7,195. Are you positive that in your time no regulation or anything has been put into the travelling plane to increase the draw upon the engine plane? — No.

7,196. Had it been enlarged at all before the explosion? — No.

7,197. You are quite sure? — I am.

7,198. Nothing had been done? — No.

7,199. No door or stopping, or anything? — No.

7,200. You are quite sure the engine plane had not been narrowed or anything done to it before the explosion? — Quite sure.

7,201. No fall? — No.

7,202. No door of any sort put in? — No.

7,203. (The Coroner.) What do you expect would be the effect of a heavy fall about that neighbourhood in the return, where might it force the return air? — It all depends on the nature of the fall.

7,204. Taking a heavy fall occurring there, where would the return air be probably sent to? — If there was no air going in, there would be none coming out.

7,205. But you would have to have some vent; is there any place where you would get from the returns into the intake? — No place.

7,206. Take it in that neighbourhood? — A small portion would get through there if the fall was on the in-bye side.

7,207. In your case your intake might be fouled with return air? — Yes.

7,208. Would that fall have to be to any extent? — It would have to stop the ventilation. It would have to be on this side.

7,209. Totally stop it or only reduce it? — It would have to stop it.

7,210. Stop it entirely? — Yes.

7,211. It could not be such a fall but that it would at once attract the notice of the officials? — It would.

7,212. It would have to be a fall to that extent? — Yes.

7,213. Is this the same portion of the pit that you gave evidence about before? Take question 4,469 "What is the nearest point to the furnace that gas has ever been seen in any of the returns to your knowledge"? Your answer is, "From sixty to seventy feet from the No. 3 furnace I have seen a slight indication." Where is that locality? — Here (pointing to the plan).

7,213a. It is not at the curve? — No.

7,214. (Mr. Wright.) There is a main trouble that crosses that engine plane? — Yes.

7,215. And gas might come from that trouble? — It might.

7,216. And if the air were stagnant there, or if the pull ceased into the Maudlin, that air would pull towards No. 3 Hutton; if the pull towards the Maudlin ceased it would pull towards No. 3 Hutton from the Maudlin engine plane? — I do not see where it could get.

7,217. Suppose you stop off the Maudlin altogether at the junction between the Maudlin engine plane and the Maudlin travelling plane, then all the air in the Maudlin engine plane would pull towards No. 3 Hutton? — The main intake and No. 1 together.

7,218. Partly to the one and partly to the other? — To the two.

7,219. The shortest way would be the No. 3? — Yes.

7,220. And if there was any gas there in that case the gas would pull towards No. 3? — If it had got on the bye side of this.

7,221. That is the shortest way? — Yes.

7,222. Have you ever seen any gas there where the trouble crosses the Maudlin engine plane? — No.

7,223. Nor ever heard of any? — No.

7,224. Nor where it crosses on the north main? — . No.

(Mr. Atherley Jones.) What is the particular spot you are asking about?

(Mr. Wright.) Where the trouble crosses the Maudlin engine plane.

The witness withdrew.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print