Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Inquests Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Inquests
/   \

1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster

Inquest Report

Seaham Colliery Inquest, 12th April 1881.

The Londonderry Institute, Seaham Harbour, 12th April 1881.

Eleventh Day.

Present:

Representatives of the Home Office — Mr. R. S. WRIGHT, Barrister; Mr. THOMAS BELL, Mr. JAMES WILLIS, Government Inspectors; Mr. W. ATKINSON, Assistant Inspector.

Representatives of the Marquis of Londonderry — Mr. JOHN EDGE (instructed by Mr. H. B. Wright).

Representatives of the Durham Miners' Association — Mr. ATHERLEY JONES, Barrister (instructed by Mr. Marshall and Mr. Bowey); and Messrs. CRAWFORD and FORMAN.

(The Coroner.) I want to know, Mr. Atherley Jones, if it is your determination not to call any more of the men?

(Mr. Jones.) What I should say is this: We have endeavoured to afford every possible facility to those men who think that they have any information which would be of value for this inquiry, to come forward and give it ; and I am not as yet apprised of any evidence — I am speaking now of the evidence of men employed at the pit who would speak as to the condition of the pit — that will be given. The men are here. I came down yesterday, in common with Mr. Bowey, for the purpose of inquiring of the men whether they were likely to afford us any information, but so far as I have been able to discover, they do not seem prepared to add to that which has been already given. But if there are any men here who are desirous of giving evidence, or if they know of anybody, I shall be glad if they will communicate with me, and I have no doubt that they will have an opportunity of being heard after luncheon.

(The Coroner.) I should be glad to hear any evidence that would carry the case further than on the previous occasion. If they cannot do that, we do not want one hundred witnesses to prove the same facts, as we had last time.

(Mr. Jones.) That is precisely the view that I take.

(The Coroner.) I shall ask Mr. Abel to give evidence. He has a wish to go down the pit, and if after his examination he sees anything in the pit that will alter the views which he has formed, then he can be recalled to make any further explanation and be further examined. And with reference to Mr. Abel's report, which I have thoroughly gone into, I think for the purpose of this inquiry the portion that we ought to devote our attention to, and which will answer all the purposes of the inquiry, will be the summary of that report. If I went all through the whole of this lengthy report, the jury, I think, would agree with me that it would only tend to confuse them, and I think that we have everything in the summary to enable them to come to a conclusion. I make this proviso in case the counsel on either side wish to draw particular attention to the rest of the report — they are to be at liberty to do so. At the same time, if Mr. Abel says that his summary requires further explanation from his report, we should be glad also to hear that. I think that you will agree with me that this is the best way.

(Mr. Edge.) Oh ! certainly.

(Mr. Atherley Jones.) I assent to that.

Professor Abel sworn.

(The Coroner.) I had better read the summary of Professor Abel's report. (The Coroner then read the summary, and the different points referred to were pointed out on the map by Mr. Barrett, the manager of Seaham Colliery.) [See Appendix.] That is the whole of this summary of Mr. Abel's report. Perhaps Mr. Edge will take Mr. Abel.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) I do not think that any of us will cross-examine Mr. Abel. We will only ask him questions for information.

(Mr. Jones.) I prefer Mr. Edge going on.

7,029. (Mr. Edge) (to Witness.) Mr. Abel, as a matter of fact, assuming that the report of Mr. Bell is correct, which of course I do, as to the temperature of the mine, the coal dust which you experimented upon was dry at a higher temperature than the temperature which existed in the mine? — That is very possible.

7,030. So you dried the coal dust at about 100 degrees? — Yes.

7,031. Whereas the highest temperature on the 17th of November was 67 in the mine? — Yes.

7,032. And the lowest temperature 46? — Quite so. You would like some explanation.

7,033. Would that affect it? — Not in the least, and I will tell you why. If you expose coal dust for a long period to dry air in a low temperature, you will effect as complete a drying of it, so far as the removal of moisture is concerned, as you would by exposing it for a short time to a considerably higher temperature. In other words, if the dust was continually exposed to a very dry atmosphere at the temperature of, say, 60, it would be as dry as if I had dried it at 100 degrees.

7,034. Now taking coal dust in the stone drift, for instance, the only drying power there would be the natural air coming down the shaft number one and two? — Quite so.

7,035. Of course the drying power of the air would depend upon the temperature of the surface so far as the stone drift is concerned? — Not the drying power of the air. It would not depend purely upon the temperature, because it would depend upon the state of dryness more than the temperature a great deal.

7,036. So far, of course, as we know there is nothing to increase the dryness of the air between one and two shaft of the stone drift? — That may be so. Of course, I cannot speak of that.

7,037. I want further information. I think you, by your experiments, have shown that the gas which you experimented upon is explosive when mixed with a greater proportion of air than Davy's experiments have shown? — Yes, that is so with regard to that particular dust.

7,038. I think I am correct in saying that the facts still show that the result of Davy's experiments have been this: that gas is non-explosive after you arrive at 15 volumes of air? — Yes, those were the results that he arrived at.

7,039. And your experiments have shown that the gas on which you have experimented is explosive even when 40 volumes of air mixes with one of gas? — Yes. it would be hardly called explosive, but it does carry flame, and if you have a very large flame an explosion would take place.

(The Coroner.) What percentage would that be? — (Mr. Edge.) It is 2½.

(The Witness.) 2.5 per cent.

7,040. (Mr. Edge.) Can you give any information as to the differences of the results obtained by Davy and yourself? — No; I can only account for it in this way, that probably Davy limited the application of the term "explosive" to the production of very violent mechanical effects upon a small scale.

7,041. I would like to draw your attention to this. Practically what Davy has taught us in his book, and his dicta have always been so held, is this that three volumes of air and one of gas burn without explosion; four volumes of air and one of gas burn the flames ascending in the vessel containing the mixture ; six volumes of air burns with a whistling noise ; eight volumes to one of gas produces the most violent explosion; for those proportions afford sufficient oxygen to convert the hydrogen into water and the carbon into carbonic acid. The explosion gradually diminishes until the air is fourteen volumes to one of gas, and ceases at 15.1. Sir Humphrey Davy would be dealing with a period when it would be non-explosive at all events in his judgment? — Undoubtedly.

7,012. Can a difference have arisen between your experiments and Davy's in the difference of the gas experimented upon?

(The Coroner.) It strikes me that the mode of operating to get that would be to put them together to see which is the most valuable. Sir Humphrey Davy might not have had his attention closely drawn to air as an explosive article, and might not have carried his observations so far.

7,043. (Mr. Edge.) Then I won't pursue the matter further. Could the difference in the gases experimented upon produce different results? — It would affect the result undoubtedly to some extent, and I am not aware what gas Davy may have used, of course, but the gas we have been experimenting with, and which has been derived from the Wigan seam, is a comparatively sensitive gas, and it does more readily form explosive mixtures than other descriptions of fire-damp with which I have experimented. At the same time I may state that I have had occasion to make a few of these experiments at Woolwich, and I there made use of ordinary coal gas, and the results furnished by the ordinary coal gas were not at all different, but were close approximations to those obtained from this particular gas, so that it would hardly appear that the chemical composition of the gas would affect the results very importantly

7,044. I will pass on to another point. You told me that you introduced, the element of coal dust — I wont go into other gases. You then spoke of a thick cloud of dust? — I stated it was so; but I have also stated that I obtained very decided indications of the power of dust to bring about the ignition of very diluted fire-damp mixtures when present in very small quantities.

7,045. Can you suggest how there could have been in the stone drift any proportion of dust mixed with the atmosphere at the time anterior to the shot? — I only know that when I have been in a dusty pit I have found the dust rise in very considerable quantities, and in quantities more considerable than was the case in certain of the experiments which I carried out.

7,046. But that is not important. You are aware that there is no evidence of it between the downcast and the stone drift? — I am not aware of it, but I take it from you.

7,047. You may take it that there is a continuous volume of 104,000 feet per minute, or practically so, passing from the downcast and passing along that stone drift. Under such circumstances would you expect to find there any quantity of coal dust mixing in the air anterior to the shot? — In a large quantity?

7,048. Yes? — No; I should think not.

7,049. Or in a small quantity — where would it come from? — I cannot conceive it possible that the air would be free from dust even under these conditions. I believe the pit is a dry pit, and there are considerable deposits in different parts. I have not seen the pit.

7,050. What I am driving at is this. I take you from the downcast shaft to this stone drift, and there is no working between the downcast and the stone drift. Therefore you would suggest that there should be a deposit or accumulations of deposits? — Are there no accumulations of dust?

7,051. How would you suggest it? I merely ask for information.

(Mr. Edge.) They are very small.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) We have it in evidence there are large accumulations.

(The Witness.) If there be any dust on the floor or on the side of the pit, I cannot imagine that air passing into it at that velocity and the pit be free from dust.

(The Coroner.) You think there must be floating particles?

(The Witness.) Yes ; but my object in using large volumes of dust is not to exaggerate results, but to endeavour to obtain a condition of things similar to those which would occur at the instant of the firing of a blown out shot. There can be no question that on the instant of a large volume of flame from a blown unit shot that an enormous amount of dust will be set in motion, and that the atmosphere will be filled with dust to such an extent as it was filled in my experiments, and it was with that view that I endeavoured to produce that.

7,052. Of course, whether the dust would be in a large quantity would depend upon the dust in the immediate neighbourhood? — Undoubtedly, I assume that.

7,053. May I also ask you this — would you expect that the blown out shot — I am assuming that your suggestion is that the blown out shot would cause the dust to mix in large volumes in volumes of air? Would you expect that blown-out shot would cause the dust to mix, and that an explosion would follow — would not the shot have expended itself before the dust mixed with the air? — I think not. From what I have seen from the blown-out shot on the ground, where a large volume of flame is produced, and the distance and duration of that flame I have found that certainly would not be the case — the flame would be still larger until the flame is thoroughly mixed up with the air by the effect of the shot.

7,054. You can judge whether the shot has been blown out by the results? — Yes. When I say a blown out shot, it is right I should include an overcharged shot, in which a considerable amount of work might be done, and a very large amount of flame projected.

7,055. You have alluded in your report to the experiments at Harton? — I have.

7,056. I don't know whether you know the results of these experiments? — I have witnessed some of them, and, generally, I may say those results have been communicated to me by Mr. Lindsay Wood.

Mr. Lindsay Wood is going to be called. I don't know whether the result of the Harton experiments is that the dust is not carried forward to any extent. I have so stated in my report, and you will find it so stated. At the same time, even there I think there was evidence of a prolongation of flame by dust in the neighbourhood. Speaking of dust pure and simple, free from gas, and, as you will find in the report, I do not insist upon anything more than that. In fact, I have depreciated the idea that in a total absence of gas the dust would carry and flame to more than a limited extent, but that it does so carry flame is undoubted, and it depends entirely upon the relation of the flame to the velocity of the current. You may have a condition of things in which there appears no change at all.

7,057. Just go back to the stone drift. How do you suggest that the gas would have come from there? — I cannot suggest, because I am not acquainted with the locale at all.

7,058. I won't ask you then? — I don't suggest it.

7,059. Now, the temperature I assume is known in that stone drift. If we take the 15th of November as representing what it was fairly at the time of the accident, there would be a difference? — I suppose there would be a difference between the 8th of September and that date.

7,060. What would you suggest is the difference? — A different of 20 degrees or more.

Mr. Bell has given us the temperature of the stone drift.

(Mr. Bell.) Yes, you will see it on the section K.

(Mr. Edge.) That would make a temperature of 66 degrees?

(The Witness.) Probably about that.

7,061. (Mr. Jones.) My friend was asking you, Professor Abel, with regard to some experiments which were made by Davy. I believe these experiments were only made with gas, and not with coal-dust? — Not with coal-dust. It was simply with reference to firedamp.

7,062. And therefore, of course, any significance which those experiments might have with reference to the explosive quantity of gas in common air have no reference to your experiments on coal-dust? — They would have reference to the question of what amount of firedamp in a mixture with air, and produce more or less explosive results, and in that respect they bear upon the coal-dust question, because the point which, I believe, was touched upon by the gentleman who was asking me questions just now was this: — That I found on experiment, in the first instance, with mixtures of fire-damp and air, the fire-damp of the particular description used furnished explosive results, or results bordering on explosive results, with a very much smaller proportions than that found by Davy, and that would influence the result when the dust question come in.

7,063. I take it that 2.5 per cent. which, I think, is the amount of fire-damp which is necessary in conjunction with coal-dust or any dust to form an explosive mixture, that that would not separately from coal-dust cause an explosion? No ; I may point out with reference to those results obtained with mixtures of fire-damp and air the question of operating on currents and still atmospheres is a very important one, and that, no doubt, considerably influences the results. It would be observed that whereas I obtained with 3½ per cent. a mixture which was just explosive — that was the amount, not 2½ — in currents ranging from 600 to 1,000 feet velocity, when I came to operate with only 100 feet velocity it required as much as 4½ per cent. of the fire-damp to produce a result bordering on an explosion, mind when operating in still atmospheres the result was higher still. Davy's results simply bear reference to vessels where no currents of air were passing at the time, and the nature of the current very materially influences the result obtained. That is also the case with regard to the coal-dust question alone, and it is proper that I should call attention to that as I am speaking of the influence of currents. In the case of the coal-dust experiments the results which cannot at all be obtained at low velocities are readily obtained at high velocities. At a velocity of 100 feet per minute I could not obtain any indication of the enlargement of a flame or the taking up of a flame by coal-dust alone when even in considerable quantities by gunpowder and gun cotton in the atmosphere in which the dust was travelling. But when I proceeded to experiment at 1,000 feet per minute then a considerable flame was produced. Therefore the currents must be taken into account in considering the influence of coal-dust.

7,064. Now some reference was made to the chemical condition of the gas in which you made the experiments. Do I gather from what you said that the gas which you used in making your experiments would not have produced any different effect from ordinary gas, which would be found in coal mines? — I would not go so far as positively to maintain that there might not be the slightest difference, due to the composition of the gas, but I don't consider the difference such as would materially affect any practical conclusions to be derived from the results.

7,065. My friend asked a question which you scarcely could be called upon to reply to, and that is, how you could expect gas would be found in the stone drift. Have you been able to express an opinion? I think you were going to express an opinion on the presence of gas in coal mines up to an extent sufficient to cause an explosion in conjunction with suspended coal-dust? — I don't know that I could give any very decided opinion upon that. I can only say this, that looking to the properties of gas, I, myself, cannot conceive a condition of things in the mine in which fire damp is given off from the face of the coal, even with good ventilation, in which you are absolutely certain, except from the pit's mouth, that you have no fire-damp in the mine. I am speaking of quantities of fire-damp that would in any degree operate, or would produce an inflammable mixture in such quantities as might materially influence the behaviour of coal-dust?

7,066. Sufficient, in fact, to produce the results of which you speak? — Yes.

7,067. Putting it in another way — I don't know whether you have it in the summary — that is, in regard to the presence of gas to the extent of 2.5, would that be capable of recognition by workmen in the ordinary way, or by persons making an ordinary inspection in mines, or would it require the very greatest care for detecting its presence? — I am told so. I myself have seen the small proportions of gas examined for by the ordinary means — by the use of Davy lamps — and I have observed that very great difficulty existed, even in the operation of experienced hands, to determine the presence of fire-damp when it existed in such very small proportions as 2½ per cent.; but I am told by those who know in great deal better than myself that it is not possible, except in the hands of the most experienced of men, to detect below or even up to two or three pen cent.

7,068. I think you said that coal-dust, as long as your experiments went, did not give any certain result as to the explosive force in connection with common air alone, but that you had seen indications of the flame being extended by means of the presence of coal-dust with the presence of gas? — Yes, in currents of fair velocity.

7,069. And I suppose that would be materially increased by the character and nature of the dust, and the character of the temperature at the time? — It would, undoubtedly.

7,070. That is to say, according to the measure of heat in the mine and the inflammable nature of the coal-dust, so an explosive force would be increased even without the presence of gas — so that prolongation of the flame would be increased? — I did not say anything in regard to the explosive quantities.

7,071. Yes. Then with regard to the firing of shot. Assuming a shot to have been fired, may I take it that the effect of the shot, either a blown-out or overcharged shot, would that, in your opinion, raise the dust, and, after bringing it into a state of suspension in the air, be likely to cause an explosion, or rather, an ignition of that dust? — Undoubtedly there must be some ignition of the dust.

7,072. It would not be at all unreasonable to suggest that the explosion would arise from the firing of a shot, even if at the time that the shot was fired the dust was not in suspension? — Quite so.

7,073. I do not know whether I might be permitted to ask you a question, Professor Abel, outside of your report upon another matter. If you don't wish me to do so I will refrain from asking it; but I would like to ask you a question of very considerable importance in our view in this inquiry, and that is as to the presence of other shafts in a mine. I don't ask the question as to the value of shafts, but only the question which has reference to what is said by some mining engineers here. I will direct your attention to the north of the pit — the top of the Maudlin seam. Assuming a shaft was placed there (pointing to map) or in any portion of the top (and I made this inquiry of some gentlemen here), whether, inasmuch as there is no question that the men in that part of the pit, to the number of some twenty-eight, having lived there for several hours after the explosion, and were not affected by the explosion, whether these lives would not have been spared if there had been a shaft at that portion which has been indicated. The answer which was given to me was this, that the explosive current acted as it were as a piston, which compressed the air so that it could not travel any further, but it was as it were beaten back by the compressed air — not exhausting itself in the ordinary way — but that if there had been a shaft there that the explosive current would have travelled up to the shaft and found an outlet, and the men would have perished by the force of the explosion; the question that I wish to ask you is whether that is sound in theory? — Well, I confess the question is a novel one to me; I don't know whether there would be any use in my going into the matter. I don't see how the action could take place myself.

7,074. That is to say, may I take it that your opinion is this, that the explosive current would travel quite as well without the presence of the shaft as it would with it? — Whether the explosive force would reach to the end?

7,075. Yes? — Whether, if there were a violent explosion which extended, or might extend, to the end of the shaft — whether the extension to that end would be influenced by the question of a shaft or not? — I should say not at all.

7,076. May I take it that what exhausted the force was the friction — that it died by simple inanition? — There may have been many causes. The flame may have gradually diminished, and it may have died out at that time. That is in all probability the reasonable and common sense explanation of the result.

7,077. Only one other question. You see there is what is called the main coal staple. Now the main coal staple is a short shaft reaching from No. 3 Hutton to the main coal, and it is ventilated indifferently from the intake and No. 3 Hutton, and from the main coal. In view of the fact that shots are fired in close proximity thereto, would there be likely to be a stagnation of the ventilation in the immediate proximity to the bottom of the main coal staple in No. 3 Hutton? — Well, I think that is a question upon which I would not give an opinion, because although I can realise from the plan the arrangements, I certainly don't feel myself competent to pronounce an opinion upon the ventilation arrangements of the pit.

7,078. I quite understand, but I don't press you upon it. My only point was this, that we have in this main coal staple ventilation both from above and below, and the object of my inquiry was this, whether the fact of the two currents, one from above and one from below, meeting, would not cause a certain stagnation? — That might be the case.

7,079. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) So far as your experiments have gone, we understand that the effect of them is that coal dust alone is not explosive when mixed with air, in the total absence of gas? — Perhaps you will allow me to put it, the coal dust in the absence of gas mixed with air will not carry flame to but a very limited extent.

7,080. It will not produce the phenomena commonly described as a colliery explosion? — I cannot conceive it likely that it would.

7,080a. When you say in your summary, for which the whole mining industry must be greatly indebted to you, that the air of a mine in which the coal gives off gas at all can hardly be at any time free from fire-damp; that, of course, would not apply to every part of the mine? — Certainly not.

7,081. Not to the down-cast shaft? — Certainly not.

7,082. Nor would it apply to a few yards from the down-cast shaft? — Certainly not.

7,083. And probably if there was an old intake airway from the down-cast that had existed for many years, and did not pass through coal itself, it would hardly be possible to account for gas in such a case. The question whether it was a travelling road would, of course, very much influence my opinion. I think where you have a circulation of gas which is favoured by mechanical motion of any kind you certainly favour the natural property of gases to diffuse and mix. You can draw no sharp line as to where that gas, even against a return, would leave off diffusing itself.

7,084. When one watches the tide coming rapidly down the Thames there is a back stream along the shores ; is it possible that even with a strong current travelling along the intake air-way, there may be anything in the nature of a back current from the head of gas? — Undoubtedly.

7,085. Even to a considerable distance? — I think your illustration is a very good one. I may point out that what holds good with regard to liquids holds good with regard to gases to a much greater extent — that is, the tendency of gases to mix is very much greater than the tendency of fluids of different characters and specific gravities to mix. This tendency takes place even under what would appear to be very decidedly opposing conditions.

7,086. Am I not right in saying it has been observed, apparently strangely, that if there is an accumulation of gas in a little cavity in the roof, a slow current passing it will sweep it away much more readily than a quick current? — Yes, that is possible.

7,087. Would it be true to say, the more rapid the current going along the intake the more likely it would be that some gas should work its way backward? — It might be so.

7,088. So that one cannot say how the matter is free from difficulty, even at the bottom of the intake shaft? — It is impossible to say that it is.

7,089. If coal dust alone without any gas would do the work, then every colliery in the country would have been blown up long ago? — My great difficulty, before entering into the question at all, was this if coal dust, pure and simple, as believed by some, and as asserted on the results of certain small experiments by others, can give rise to explosions, how is it that every blown-out shot or every over-charged shot, or, at any rate, the majority of such, did not produce explosions? It appears to me an inevitable conclusion that there must be something in addition to coal dust alone which must give rise to such a result, that it should be as exceptional as it is.

7,090. You have told us a very small quantity of gas will do it, and you say that may perhaps diminish in proportion as the temperature is raised? — Yes, it diminishes most importantly with regard to the nature of the dust used. We have spoken of 2½ per cent. as being the quantity which yielded explosive results with the Seaham dusts; but with one of the dusts operated upon we had similar results with as low as 1¾ percent. of gas; and in all my experiments I am confident the quantity of gas present was considerably below one per cent. in which I obtained the carrying along of flame by coal dust to a very considerable distance.

7,091. Taking the 2½ per cent. as what, if I may use the term, might be called the normal minimum, that might be still further reduced either by the nature of the dust, or by the temperature, or by the velocity? — By various conditions.

7,092. None of your experiments seem to have gone to very high velocities? — A large number were made at 1,000 feet.

7,093. There are a great many mines in this country in which the velocity of currents in places reaches to 1,600 or 1,700 feet? — I have not gone beyond 1,000 feet; I consulted with my colleagues on the Royal Commission, and the conclusion I arrived at was that if I made experiments at from 600 to 1,000 feet velocity I should be taking a very fair mean. I may mention only a few of the actual results are given in this report, but the conclusions are based upon upwards of 300 different experiments which have been made with coal dust mixtures.

7,094. I suppose you are aware there are many mines where at portions of the workings the velocities would be even up to 17 or 18 feet a second? — Quite so.

7,095. That would be 1,200 or 1,300 feet a minute? — Yes.

7,096. Have you at all calculated the effect of velocity to an extent that would give any formula? — No; at the present time I have not seen my way to do that; it would require a very large number of experiments, made under varying conditions, to arrive at a formula which one could accept with confidence.

7,097. You propose to carry on the experiments to some extent further? — To a considerable extent, especially with reference to one very important property which dust possesses in favouring the ignition of very dilute coal-gas mixtures quite apart from inflamability of the dust.

7,098. May any indication be given at present of what the nature of that property is? — I think so, although I would give the explanation guardedly. I think I can give what seems to myself, and to some of my colleagues, a satisfactory explanation. We are acquainted with the action of certain solid substances, and have long been so, when in a fine state of diffusion in promoting combination between gases. If a solid body of a particular description — some metals, for example — be presented to gaseous mixtures in a very finely divided state, or a very porous condition, they have the power of collecting and condensing upon their surfaces these gases, and as they are condensed and collected they are brought closely together, and so chemical combination is consequently favoured. If these bodies be slightly warmed when this takes place, that might be, and is, sufficient, in many instances, to establish what speedily becomes a very rapid combination between the gases which are thus operated upon.

7,099. And extended? — And extended, so that there is a reciprocal action or a kind of mutual action going on. In the first place the combination to a very slight extent is started by the contact with this finely divided matter ; that combination develops heat, for chemical combination is always attended by the development of heat, ; the solid body becomes raised at once to a higher and rapidly accelerating temperature; the combination goes on more rapidly, and in a space of time, which cannot be measured by seconds, the solid body may be raised first to red heat and then to white heat — to the heat at which it will inflame the gaseous mixture, and in that way you may bring about an explosion of a mixture which under ordinary circumstances, exposed to the same body, not in that finely divided condition, would not take place. I can give an illustration of that. I have in my bag one of these materials, and if you happen to have a gas jet handy, I could give you proof positive of the action of finely divided bodies in this condition, if it is of any interest as bearing upon this subject, and I believe it will be found to bear very importantly upon it.

7,100. I should think it of the greatest possible interest, but we must leave that in the hands of Mr. Maynard? — What I have said amounts to this, that a finely divided solid, which presents the porosity or the peculiarity of solids may, when brought into contact with a gaseous mixture, a mixture, for example, of fire-damp, and air containing only very small quantities of fire-damp, which would remain in an inactive condition for any length of time, especially if it be slightly warmed or heated as it passes the flame of a lamp, may at once establish an action of this kind; it may bring about an immediate combination between the two that will develop heat; and in this way in a very short space of time the solid body is raised to the temperature at which it will inflame this mixture, and action of this kind has been exhibited by the particular descriptions of various mineral powders with which I have experimented.

7,101. That assumes some artificial heat introduced from without — at the time of the mixture? — Not always necessarily so, but no doubt in the case of a comparatively non-sensitive powder of this description, you would assume that. But that heat exists; it would be furnished by the mixture simply passing through the flame of a Davy lamp.

7,102. (Mr. Atherley Jones.) Or by a shot? — Very much more so.

7,103. (Mr. Wright.) A very small quantity of dust suspended in the air may be sufficient to determine the explosive action of the mixture of gas and air? — Yes.

7,104. Extremely small? — Yes.

7,105. As much as might exist almost continuously in the travelling ways of a mine? — In many of the experiments I have made in a small gallery representing the air-way of a mine, although I made every endeavour to get the sides of it perfectly free from dust there were minute quantities of dust remaining, and then when I worked at the velocity of a thousand feet a minute, this invariably brought about an inflammation of a gas mixture which would not be otherwise inflamed.

7,106. It presents rather a considerable mixture — the air-way. It must have 2 per cent. of gas and also dust, and if it then meets even with a safety lamp, much more with a naked light, danger must be imminent in all such eases? — One would think so

7,107. Or if it passed over a furnace? — Over a furnace, certainly; I believe there are instances existing in which fire has been thought to have been started from the furnace.

7,108. Without throwing the least suspicion of doubt upon the value of the conclusions, does not that carry it a little far, so to speak; as it was pointed out by you that if coal-dust alone would have exploded, every colliery would have been wrecked long ago, may not we say in a less degree something of the same kind as regards this, wherever the return air current loaded with gas and dust, as it must be, passed over to an upcast, ventilated by a furnace, for instance, it is impossible then to understand how they can have escaped explosions? — If the dust were always exactly of the same character, and the conditions were always the same, I think the conclusion would be quite correct, but the dusts vary very greatly within regard to sensitiveness, and the tendency they have to promote the ignition of these explosive mixtures, so that the result, although it may appear to be startling, after all is comparatively exceptional.

7,109. Probably, the actual velocity at the upcast shaft would not be so great as in the narrower parts of the mine? — No.

7,110. And, possibly, the danger would be much greater in the case of shots fired, by reason of the suddenness of their action, than in the case of a lamp? — Yes, and the large quantity of flame developed.

7,111. So far as I have observed in your report there is no mention of any of these mixtures having been fired by a safety lamp? — They are always at naked lights.

7,112. Have you experimented to see the effect of a mixture of air charged with two or three per cent. of gas and coal dust passing the safety lamp? — I made one or two experiments.

7,113. With no difference as compared with the naked light? — No great difference. The experiments were only made at comparatively moderate velocities, and the dust and gas mixture burnt in the flame of the lamp, but no particles were carried beyond the flame, and no ignition occurred outside.

7,114. It did not occur in any case that particles of dust became ignited inside the lamp and were carried out through the gauze? — No; the lamp gave no indication of gas, but when dust was passed the gas mixture was then burnt inside the flame together with the incandescent dust particles.

7,115. Would a shot, if neither blown out nor over-charged, produce the effect which you mentioned in your examination of keeping up a continuance of flame for a sufficient time to be able to raise the dust, and to fire it after it had been raised? — I should say not.

7,116. May one say that in your judgment — assuming the mixtures 2½ per cent, of fire damp in the air, and dust suspended in the air at the same time — an ordinary shot would probably be free from danger? — I think so.

7,117. In other words, the danger under those circumstances of 2½ per cent. of fire damp in the air, in conjunction with coal dust suspended in the air, would not arise, so far as you have observed, by a shot, unless it were either blown out or overcharged? — It is impossible for me to draw a decided line ; it is evident the danger would be very much diminished. In most cases there is little or no flame when a shot does its work properly, and whatever flash there may be is of almost instantaneous description. It is a very different thing from the flame produced by an overcharged hole.

7,118. If the dust were already in the air, and any flame did come out, it would be as dangerous as a blown out shot? — Yes.

7,119. To sum up the whole thing, I gather from your evidence that in your judgment there is danger enough in any mine which gives off inflammable gas, owing to the presence of coal dust, to make it a reasonable and necessary precaution, speaking of the future and not of the time before we had your evidence, either to water or remove the dust? — There is no doubt, if the dust was removed or laid, it would be, in my opinion, a most important diminution of the danger attending blasting in coal mines.

7,120. I am not suggesting that there is any blame attaching in this colliery, because the subject has not had so much attention drawn to it until the present time, but I want to know whether it ought not to be stated, even more strongly; if I am right in the sense in which I understand your evidence, it is not merely that it would be a proper thing to remove or water the dust, but it would be highly improper not to do it when firing shots in a mine? — Quite so.

7,121. (The Coroner.) You say there must be 2 per cent. in the returns ; if the returns are foul to the extent of 2 per cent, of gas, can you form any idea as to what condition the working places would be in order so to foul the returns? — No, I cannot; I do not speak on my own authority.

7,122. I thought it was more a question for a mining engineer? — I would not venture to pronounce an opinion upon that.

7,123. (Mr. Atherley Jones.) I have omitted to ask, you have referred to two samples of dust, Q and R, which you say are calcined or coked? — Two samples that showed more evidence of having been exposed to heat than any of the others.

7,124. Also you found signs of burning in many other samples? — Yes.

7,125. You say you find symptoms of burning in dust taken from widely distant parts of the mine? — Yes.

7,126. In fact, I may say from the extremes? — Yes.

7,127. Much would depend, I suppose, upon the way in which this dust was collected? — Undoubtedly. I have no doubt the greatest care was taken in the collection of these samples, but it is possible, I think, that the importance may not have been sufficiently realised of merely skimming the dust. I cannot say how they were collected, but I should have collected them by very carefully taking with a card the upper surface, from where the dust was collected, for if it were not so collected it is evident that if the dust were either burnt by passing over a flame or afterwards deposited as the result of the explosion or subsequent to the explosion, that it must exist only on the surface, and if the dust were taken in any other way but merely superficially, and very superficially, it must become mixed with a large quantity of dust which could not have been affected by heat; and hence the results furnished by the dust samples are put forward by me with the greatest reserve ; I can only speak of them as the samples arrived, and I do not consider that the indications of burning afford anything like a decided indication as to the extent to which the dust took part or entered into the action of this explosion.

7,128. Nor afford any precise indication as to the seat of the explosion? — Certainly not; because it is conceivable that even for distant portions certain quantities of burnt dust may have been conveyed — not have been produced at these particular parts, but may have been mechanically conveyed by the current of air at the moment or directly after the explosion.

7,129. It must also, I suppose, depend upon the disturbance which the dust has raised subsequent to the explosion? — If there were found encrustations of coked dust upon timbers and stones at different parts, which from their appearance must have been formed there, there would have been no difficulty of speaking to that — that would have been a decided indication that the coked dust had been produced at those places but any other result is rather a doubtful one. Although burnt dust may have been found there, it may not have been produced at that spot.

7,130. (The Coroner.) May I take it, so far as the burning of the dust supplied to you goes, it is no indication of the locality of the explosion? — That is the way in which I state it.

7,131. (Mr. Atherley Jones.) My friend, Mr. Wright, asked you with regard to lamps and experiments which you made with lamps; I believe you did not make any very exhaustive experiments with safety lamps with reference to this particular subject matter in your inquiry? — No; that is a subject which has been very exhaustively entered into by the Royal Commission.

7,132. I do not know whether I might ask you this: Whether you have formed any opinion which would be prepared to divulge as to the merits or demerits of the Clanny lamp? — If you will excuse me I would rather not do that.

7,133. (Mr. Edge.) Professor Abel's results of experiments on the coal-dust prove that the coal-dust taken from the stone drift and the Maudlin engine plane does not appear to have been affected by heat? — That was so.

7,134. The coal-dust most affected by heat was that found in No. 1 engine plane off-side? — And another one, "Q," which was a place affected to about the same extent on the return side of the Polka way end.

7,135. So that the dust which showed the greatest signs of being affected by heat was found in the neighbourhood of the Polka way, and the dust taken from the neighbourhood of the stone drift was found not to have been affected by heat? — Yes.

7,136. Would you expect to find the coke dust pasted up against any projections in the mine? — I should expect to find it there as well as on the floor.

7,137. Would you expect to find it against projections or timber? — Certainly.

7,138. As I gather from your examination by Mr. Wright, you think that water would be an antidote to dust? — I will not pretend to say that my opinion in the matter has the least value. I know that there are considerable practical difficulties connected with the application of water in special instances, and I know also to apply water as a permanent antidote to dust would be by no means a simple thing; at the same time, it is at present to me impossible to suggest any other method of dealing with dust than by water.

7,139. I do not know whether you are acquainted with the history of mining in the Durham and Northumberland coal-field? — Not intimately.

7,140. May I take it, it has never been suggested with regard to any explosions that have occurred here that they have been caused by gas coming in contact within furnace fires? — I have not heard it.

(The Coroner.) I do not know that. It is within my own knowledge, unless I am mistaken, a great many of the mining engineers at Hatton traced it to that cause; I may be incorrect, but I thought my memory served me in that case.

(Mr. Wright.) There were several in South Wales.

7,141. (Mr. Edge.) Can you suggest whether it is possible for gas to work against the current? — Yes.

7,142. Would you assume gas working against a current at a velocity of 1,000 feet per minute? — I hardly know what you mean.

7,143. I mean going against the current; assuming gas coming off the face of the workings, can you understand it travelling up the main intake against a current of a thousand feet per minute? — I do not think it would travel within any great velocity, but it would gradually diffuse itself even in an air travelling with considerable velocity.

7,144. I am taking 1,000 feet per minute, can you assume that it would travel any distance? — No, I think not.

7,145. Do you know that the velocity in the stone drift would work out to over 1,000 feet per minute? — Was there any travelling in the stone drift, any locomotion, because that must materially affect the question? If it is merely a question of a steady uninterrupted current passing at the rate of 1,000 feet per minute, I do not consider that the gas would have very much chance of diffusing itself rapidly against the current, drawing forward the gas to meet it. It might very importantly influence the carrying of the gas through air passing into the mine.

7,146. That is, assuming that there is travelling at the time to a considerable amount? — I do not bind myself to say the quantity.

7,147. Looking at the mechanical explosion it would go where there was least resistance? — Certainly.

7,148. May I not take it you would find less resistance in a coal work area where there is a shaft than where there is no shaft? — Yes.

7,149. (Mr. Wright.) I rather wanted to get it as regards travelling against the current ; supposing you take a long gallery, a thousand yards long, like a closed pipe, with the intake air-current going along at 1,000 feet per minute, would it be possible for any gas to work back from the further end to the top end? — It would be impossible unless the question of travelling along the road enters into the consideration.

7,150. One would not assume a perfectly smooth pipe, but a thing like a colliery gallery, might it not work back either by itself or by some action of the current — creep along, so to speak? — It becomes rather speculative to give an opinion on that point, and I would rather not state whether such a thing would be possible.

7,151. (Mr. Atherley Jones.) My friend asked you whether by seeking for the least amount of resistance the explosive force would travel the more, and he said if there had been a shaft there would have been less resistance than if there had not been a shaft ; I do not quite understand whether you assented to that proposition? — That is entirely regulated by the violence of the explosion. I happen to have in my mind an instance of a very violent explosion occurring in what may be called an air-way corresponding to the shaft, only it happened to be a large gallery of a fortification; there was a shaft at either end, the explosion took place inside one end of the shaft, and after doing great damage there, the wave produced by the explosion travelled to the other end of the gallery; and, although there was a shaft there, the result of the sudden arresting of the wave set up by the explosion and gas in motion produced an effect fully as violent at that end as at the seat of the explosion itself, so that the existence of the shaft had no effect in diminishing it.

7,152. Nor, on the other hand, would it have an effect in increasing it?

(Mr. Wright.) That does not follow.

7,153. (Mr. Jones.) I understood you to say that the fact of there being a shaft at the locality to which I directed your attention would not have had any perceptible effect upon the explosion? — It might not have had; I can hardly say it would not, because it so entirely depends upon the violence of the explosion.

7,154. But the explosion would exhaust itself rather by friction? — By friction or by the want of material necessary to keep up the explosion. It is just as possible that the explosion died out from natural causes as that it was arrested purely by any action of friction.

7,155. But not by being dependent upon the presence or absence of the shaft? — Not necessarily.

7,156. (Mr. Wright.) There is nothing more that Professor Abel would wish to add? — I think the points have all been brought out.

(The Coroner.) I understand that some of the gentlemen are going down the pit and Professor Abel along with them. It may be that that will alter some of your views.

(The Witness.) I do not think it is very likely that those views, as they rather bear upon the general question and not upon the question of locality, will be much affected, but I shall be very glad to go down.

(The Coroner.) We shall be glad to hear any addition you may wish to give to your evidence afterwards. Who is your next witness, Mr. Jones?

(Mr. Jones.) I do not propose to call any more evidence just now. Of course, if any important evidence is forthcoming I shall be compelled to call it, at the same time I shall take good care that my learned friends are not injured.

(Mr. Wright.) Before this subject is quitted I should like to say we are all, I think, very much relieved of a great feeling of responsibility by the fact that the miners are competently and ably represented here, and that any evidence which ought to be brought forward on their behalf either has been or will be brought forward; otherwise possibly the Coroner would have suggested, and we should certainly have suggested, some miscellaneous selection of workmen to come forward and speak ; but we are all certain that nothing of the kind could add to anything that has already been brought forward.

(Mr. Edge.) I have no doubt that has been carefully considered.

(The Coroner.) There is, perhaps, one point ; I do not know whether Mr. Barrett would be the witness to supply it — it is some evidence we require as to the ventilation of the curve.

(Mr. Wright.) That piece between the curve and the Maudlin ; perhaps Mr. Spence can tell us.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print