1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
Seaham Colliery Inquest, 7th January 1881 (cont.).
Mr. Richard Forster sworn.
6,477. (Mr. Edge.) You are a mining engineer, and I believe the South Hetton and Morton Collieries, about the largest collieries in this country, are under your management? — Yes.
6,478. What distance is South Hetton from the Seaham Colliery? — It practically adjoins it; the South Hetton adjoins the Merton further to the west.
6,479. It is practically a portion of the same Continuous coalfield? — We work alongside of each other.
6,480. When did you first come to join the board of directors? — I came here about eight o'clock on the morning of the explosion.
6,481. Did you make several explorations of the mine? — Yes.
6,482. When was the first? — I do not quite recollect the day — I think the Tuesday or Wednesday in the next week.
6,483. What were the indications which you saw in No. 1 pit? — We explored No. 1 pit, and on reaching the bottom of the shaft I was of opinion that the various things were most certainly blown in over from both sides; I could form no definite opinion there. We proceeded along the engine plane as far as the engine house, which had been fired, and then came to these stables.
6,484. Before you came to these stables, did you notice anything between the shaft and that first crossing? — The shaft was in great confusion ; I could come to no conclusion about that; there was an arch in between the crossing and the shaft siding that appeared to have been, so to speak, plastered with pieces of wood and hay coming out, and all the bricks I saw were on the in-bye side of it.
6,485. Did you see any quantity of bricks blown out? — No, to the best of my recollection, it was completely restored when I went in ; we went into the engine house, which had been fired also; a recess behind it, which I understand at one time formed another engine house, had been on fire also.
6,486. The doors leading to the engine house had been blown in? — There were no doors. In going along the engine plane, the sheaves and other projections were all on the in-bye side, plastered with hay, evidently having come out-bye from the way it was lying.
6,487. You know where the travelling way takes off the engine plane; did you notice a pillar there? — Yes, just at the corner there were some bricks lying both ways, some just in the travelling way and some out on the engine plane.
6,488. Was that plastered on the inside? — The inbye side.
6,489. Now, I will take you along the engine plane; going along the engine plane up to the junction, did you come across the fall? — Yes.
6,490. The fall Mr. Stratton has spoken to? — Yes.
6,491, Did you notice the block of coal? — Yes.
6,492. Did you see the place from which the block of coal had come? — I saw the place from which I suppose it had come out.
6,493. Did the coal appear to have come out-bye or in-bye? — Out-bye, certainly.
6,491. The polka way end, did you notice that? — Just at the entrance of the Polka way end, there appeared to have been a stone pillar built, and this was simply turned upside down; in fact you had to climb over it to get in, and when you came to the doors which are marked here, these were blown to fragments against the right hand side of the wall leading into the return.
6,495. In going to the shaft as far as the Polka way, did you notice anything that indicated the force having gone in-bye in the shaft of the Polka way? — Yes, I was rather led to believe there was an indication here some of the timber, I think just inside these stables, evidently appeared to be blown in over.
6,496. Where is that? — I think just somewhere here (pointing).
6,497. What was it? — I cannot tell you what it had been ; I did not know the pit before the explosion.
6,498. Was that the only indication you saw between the shaft and the Polka way? — At this point (pointing) there were indications.
6,499. I mean on the engine plane?
6,499a. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) The junction of the engine plane? — Of the travelling way and the engine plane; I think that was all I saw on the engine plane — what I have indicated.
6,500. (Mr. Edge.) Beyond the Polka way, how were the indications, out-bye or in-bye? — In-bye on the engine-plane, coming in.
6,501. I mean going in-bye to the Polka way, how were the indications? — They were coming in-bye, south.
6,502. Did you see that large winch that was spoken of? — Yes.
6,503. That had been moved in-bye? — Yes, decidedly.
6,504. Did you find coming along the far-off way, that the explosion had been considerable — down almost to the face of the working? — I did not go that far; I satisfied myself that it had gone in there, and came out there (pointing), and went down the third east way.
6,505. How far did you go down the far-off way? — I could not tell, exactly.
6,506. (The Coroner.) Did you go to the fault? — No.
6,507. (Mr. Edge.) Did you go beyond the turning to the third east? — Oh, yes ; I went down far enough to satisfy myself that it had gone in there.
6,508. Now just take the travelling way of the second intake at the junction of the travelling way with the engine plane; did you go into the travelling way from where it joins the engine plane? — Yes, I travelled right through it.
6,509. Did you find any indications in the travelling way of how the force had gone? — Yes, just at the junction of the travelling way with the engine plane, I was of opinion that there were certain indications that it had gone so far in, then it seemed to cease for a time, but near the stables there were distinct indications of it having come there; there seemed to be portions of mangers and other things lying about.
6,510. I think you saw those temporary stables? — Yes.
6,511. They had been blown out? — They were nearly all blown out when I was there ; there were a few temporary stalls put up, I suppose.
6,512. Did you notice the cistern? — Yes.
6,513. Where was it? — It was down these stables.
6,514. Going south along the travelling way from the stables did you still notice indications going in-bye? — Yes, but not very far, they seemed almost to cease. Coming in as far as these doors, I examined those, and all that was done to them was they were simply started a little as if they had received a slight shock, and were no worse.
6,515. (The Coroner.) From which side? — It would be from the in-take side to it that way.
6,516. (Mr. Edge.) I am not asking you to express an opinion, but I am going to question you on an assumption: assume that the explosion took place on the Polka way, is there anything inconsistent in that assumption in what you saw in the travelling way? — Nothing at all.
6,517. The explosion would naturally blow out the temporary stables, it would also go along the engine plane towards the shaft : when it came to the entrance in the travelling way it would blow in there also? — It would fill up every space where it could get ; that is my idea of it.
6,518. Dealing with No. 1 alone, were the indications that you saw there consistent with an explosion taking place at the Polka way? — Yes, there was certainly a direct centre from there, you could trace a direct centre from the Polka way.
6,519. A centre from which the symptoms of explosion radiated? — Certainly.
6,520. Now I will take you to No. 3 pit. I do not know whether you know where Venner's shot was? — I have a recollection where it is.
6,521. Will you tell me what you saw at the main coal staple — what was the state of the main coal staple? — The staple bottom was completely full of the timbers that had been blown out of the staple, the cage guides and other things — a complete wreck.
6,522. There is a place called the crosscut; do you know where that is? — Do you mean close to the main coal staple?
6,523. Yes? — I think that is it (pointing).
6,524. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Just to the west of the crossing? — The west of the crossing ; of course I have not a thorough knowledge — the same knowledge as these other gentlemen, but that is what I take to be the position of it.
6,525. (Mr. Edge.) I will take it from the junction of No. 3 Hutton with the main in-take. Now, going westward from that, what were the indications that you saw going along the intake? — Into the west Hutton seam?
6,526. Yes? — That crossing was out; there was a recess; a cabin stood somewhere in here. I think that had had the copies of the rules and abstract of the Act, and a chest on the left-hand side going in-bye; the chest was not greatly damaged, the rules were still legible, although the glass was broken.
6,527. From that junction we are talking about, up to the commencement of the Hutton incline; were these indications going in-bye or out-bye? — So far up, certainly, in-bye; there was a place which I understand had been made to measure the air at that point where I should say it was decidedly out-bye. A little further up, perhaps 40 or 50 yards, it was decidedly in-bye.
6,528. That is the district running up the Hutton incline? — Yes.
6,520. In that district there were indications both ways? — Yes, certainly.
6,530. Now, coming down to the junction, travelling along eastward, that is along towards the curve, did you notice what state you found the Maudlin dock in? — It was completely wrecked, the end wall started, and the side wall almost tumbled over.
6,531. Could you see in which way the end wall was blown? — My impression was it was blown westward, decidedly.
6,532. The Maudlin engine, did that give any indications? — Yes; the strongest I saw was the reserving lever bent over.
6,533. How was that bent? — It was bent towards the west.
6,534. Going on further towards the curve, did you notice the rapper-rope being round the tail-rope? — Yes.
6,535. Did you find it there as described by Mr. Stratton? — Yes.
6,536. Was the place pointed out to you as Brown's shot? — Yes ; I saw that.
6,537. Did you notice the rapper-rope eastward and westward of Brown's shot? — There were some small sheaves, somewhere here, which appeared to have been driven up the rope, and fastened against either a pillar or a larger sheave.
6,538. What did that indicate? Did that indicate in your judgment which way the blast went? — Westward, I should say there.
6,539. Did you notice the No. 1 furnace doors? — No, I do not recollect that.
6,540. Did you notice any indications at the junction going in towards the Maudlin — at the junction of the Maudlin engine plane and that curve? — There had been a heavy fall here — (pointing) — and when that was got through in travelling down on the engine plane you come to an arching ; in that arching on the right hand side, travelling in-bye, the chain of the rapper-rope was driven right into the joints of the arching.
6,541. Was that in-bye or out-bye? — In-bye, I should say.
6,542. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) You mean going into the Maudlin? — Into the Maudlin, north.
6,543. (Mr. Edge.) What conclusion did you come to with regard to what you found there in the engine plane of the Maudlin? — I say my impression is that it decidedly went in-bye.
6,544. Did you notice any indications of the travelling way of the Maudlin, between the curve and where it joins the engine plane of the Maudlin? — That crossing was out, and generally the travelling way was very heavily fallen.
6,545. Did you see any indications that would lead you to form a judgment which way the blast had gone in the travelling way? — No, I cannot say that I did, I could not say which way.
6,546. Have you had any experience of falls from the roof in old workings? — Do you mean in places that have been driven a long time?
6,547. Yes, old drifts? — Yes, I knew one that occurred a short time ago on the side of a main rolly way that had been driven, I suppose, 25 or 30 years.
6,548. Was that a large fall? — No, the fall was not large.
6,549. About what length? — I should say something like 6 or 8 feet by 3.
6,550. (The Coroner.) Was there any gas from it? — Yes.
6,551. (Mr. Edge.) About how long had that drift been made — the waggon way? — I can speak for 18 years to my knowledge, but it must have been very much longer.
6,552. Had you observed any fissures at that place before the fall? — Yes, there was a leader of a trouble observable.
6,553. Do you know in that instance whether the fall liberated any gas? — Yes, it did.
6,554. You are one of the board of directors in this colliery? — Yes.
6,555. The board, I believe, formed a judgment that it would be dangerous to open up the Maudlin seam at present? — Yes, decidedly.
6,556. I believe, when Mr. Stratton reported the indications of fire in the Maudlin, the board considered what was best to be done? — Yes, the board was called together to consider it.
6,557. Did you gentlemen of experience come to any conclusion as to whether there would be danger in continuing the exploration at that time? — I think there can be no doubt about that; it would have been highly dangerous.
6,558. And would probably have led to the sacrifice of fresh lives? — Certainly.
6,559. Acting on your judgment and experience, you, with the board of directors, directed I think, that the Maudlin seam should be stopped off? — Yes.
6,560. And I believe you have since consulted as to the propriety of opening the Maudlin seam? — Yes.
6,561. What is the judgment the board has come to? — That it would be highly unwise to open the Maudlin seam at present.
6,562. I do not know, of course, whether you could give any limit as to the time for which the Maudlin seam would be closed up, but is it likely to be closed for some considerable time? — Well, as an individual member of the board, I should prefer not to express an opinion, not the opinion of the board, at all events.
6,563. I do not know whether you will object to express your opinion? — I should say it would be very undesirable to open it out for some time to come, at all events.
6,564. One, two, three, or four months? — I should certainly say four months.
6,565. (The Coroner.) You think it would not be desirable, on account of the danger? — I think it would be highly dangerous.
6,566. (Mr. Edge.) It would be dangerous, I assume, to open out the Maudlin seam until the fire was completely out? — Yes.
6,567. If any fire remains when you take the air in, of course you increase the fire? — Of course, we take gas in upon it.
6,568. (The Coroner.) What is your ground or belief that the fire is still burning? — In the first place, the Maudlin and low main down here (pointing) is practically one seam; you get some 9 or 10 feet of coal. We have reason to believe that not only the coal was on fire, but the roof, and in my opinion there is not time to allow that to be so surely out that it would be wise to take the stoppings out.
6,569. I think you and Mr. Hall were called almost directly by Mr. Stratton, on the discovery of the fire? — Yes, a messenger was sent for us.
6,570. I believe, on your own responsibility, you stopped all inspection until the board could be called together? — Yes.
6,571. And then you decided that this should be sealed off? — Yes.
6,572. (Mr. Wright.) Are we to understand your only reason for saying that it would be dangerous at present to open the Maudlin is what in fact you knew at the time it was sealed up, as to thickness of the place where it was on fire? — I think from what we know of the indications of the fire sufficient time has not been allowed to ensure it being burned out.
6,573. That you knew at the time when it was sealed as well as you know it now? — Of course I know nothing more now than I did then.
6,574. No fresh observations of any kind have been made? — Not past the stoppings, of course.
6,575. Is anything more known at this present moment about the state of the fire within than was known when it was sealed up? — No.
6,576. Have you or the board expressed any opinion at the time it was sealed as to the time it would be safe to open it? — I am not aware of any opinion.
6,577. Was not it stated by you or by the board that it would be open in two or three months from the time of the explosion? — I do not think so.
6,578. So far as you know, no opinion has ever been expressed? — No; the only thing we have done is to meet at stated times to consider the matter.
6,579. It was sealed about the 10th of September? — No; it was the 1st October when Mr. Stratton sent for Mr. Hall and myself — the night of the 1st October.
6,580. At that time had you come to the conclusion that it would be six months before it would be safe to open it? — I do not think it was discussed at that time.
6,581. Had you formed any opinion upon the subject then? — I had formed my own.
6,582. That it would take six months? — Certainly, I would not say it would be safe to open it under six months.
6,583. As to the place of the explosion, you did not visit the mine for several days after the explosion? — No.
6,584. When a great deal of the indication had naturally been cleared away? — Oh, yes.
6,585. I may take it that you agree with Mr. Stratton that so far as the indications could be observed, they tell very much both ways? — They tell certainly both ways, and as far as that is concerned, I am totally at a loss to settle any point where the explosion occurred.
6,586. Do you agree the explosion is evidently somewhere about the Polka way as one alternative, and somewhere about the west of the curve as the other? — I should settle it in my own mind between those points.
6,587. In your own mind, have you any preference for the one over the other? — Of course I have thought the matter over in my own mind, but I am totally at a loss to account for the explosion, because I cannot get the first element; I cannot get the gas.
6,588. Judging from what you can see of the indications, the circumstances of the mine, and everything of that sort, supposing we could find gas at both those places, which place should you select? — Of the two, as a mere matter of opinion, I should say that was the most likely.
6,589. The Polka, you think, is rather the more likely? — I think so.
6,590. Do you put it higher than rather more likely, certainly there would be the possibility of gas at both? — I have put it in that way because I think it is a more likely place where there might have been gas.
6,591. Then, because you think it is more likely that gas was there, you think the explosion happened there? — I put it in this way: I cannot understand how there was gas at either, but that is the more likely of the two.
6,592. Your reason of preferring the Polka is because that is the more likely place to get gas? — I think I can get a theory that there might have been gas there.
6,593. Supposing you were told that there had been frequent blowers at both places for the last two years; then, merely judging by the signs found at the two places, would you still say the Polka was the more likely? — No.
6,594. Have you any theory as to where gas can have come from at the Polka way? — I do not wish to lay it down as any guide in this matter, because I am totally at a loss to account for it, but I have tried to see if gas might be accounted for, and I was thinking it was possible, I do not say probable, but I do think it possible, that that fall which we travelled over in coming along the engine plane might give off gas; and gas might become ignited by Ramshaw's lamp; there was a great deal of disturbance, and the lamp was blown to atoms, and if there was a possibility, if there had been any gas reaching there it would get greater force. It is only theory.
6,595. Is the only instance within your knowledge of a fall having taken place in an old in-take, with this kind of roof, that one you have spoken of in the old rolly way? — Yes; that is the only instance.
6,596. Was that a similar roof to the roof at the Polka way? — No; the Polka way is what I would call a sounder roof than our roof was at that part.
6,597. Yours was not so sound a roof as this one? — Not so good a roof as that.
6,598. What was the roof in your place? — Where it came off was the lead of the trouble.
6,599. Was the roof of ordinary post? — Yes, at that point; I should say it was post.
6,600. The gas that came out — was it much or small in your rolly-way? — It was not a blower; it was sufficient to fill the hole where the stone fell out.
6,601. Not to issue? — I have no doubt it issued, but it had the ventilation pressing upon it, and it was carried away.
6,602. Was it anything like enough, in your judgment, to have caused a large explosion? — With the quantity of air that was passing I should rather think that it did not explode, but in my opinion it was not enough to have caused what we have seen here.
6,603. Nor anything like it? — Certainly not,
6,604. Taking it generally, in old ways like the Polka way and your rolly-way, should you expect that there would remain a sufficient quantity of gas undrained to produce any very serious effect after being so many years open? — I should call it a very unusual thing to find a fall giving sufficient gas.
6,605. What was it you said about there being a trouble at the place in your rolly-way where this fell? — This is a trouble marked on here; the trouble ran across and fell out, just at the loose material — we call it the leader of the trouble.
6,606. The trouble here is not in the place where the fall was in the Polka way? — No.
6,607. The actual fall is not at a trouble? — It is at a "slip" or "jack."
6,608. This was an actual trouble? — Yes; at the leader of the trouble.
6,609. Where you would expect some gas? — Most likely.
6,610. Was it an open leader in your case? — Yes.
6,611. Had there been gas seen there before? — I never heard of it. It was found on the Wednesday it was not there on the Monday.
6,612. In your case did the leader communicate with the goaf? — Yes; there was a goaf worked right up against the trouble.
6,613. Pretty much the same as here? — Except that it was only up against one side of it and stopped there; it did not go through like this.
6,614. In your case do you suppose the gas might have come into the trouble through the goaf? — I do not think so.
6,615. Why not? — Because when I examined it it was not what I would call a goaf, because it was what I would expect to find from the leader of the trouble itself.
6,616. In the present case I suppose you do not know what the gas was like? — No.
6,617. You were not there when it was found? — No; I saw no gas in the Polka.
6,618. (Mr. Bell.) If gas had come off at that fall would you expect to find gas in the hole afterwards? — Well, I suppose the question you have put is this: would I expect that there would still be a continuation of gas given off?
6,619. Yes? — With a heavy ventilating current in the way, that fall had fallen it would sweep it, but I should certainly not expect the gas to take off all at once; you would find a trace several days after.
6,620. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Especially if it had come off in the first instance in such a quantity as must have come off here? — Yes.
6,621. Have you any theory about coal dust as a cause of explosion? — I do not believe it will cause any explosion.
6,622. Have you any experience of dust such as accumulated round the curve in this case? — Ours is a dusty mine.
6,623. Are shots fired in the dusty parts of it frequently? — We only fire shots in the main rollyways — not frequently.
6,624. Near a shaft? — Yes.
6,625. Where the dust is of the kind that comes down the shaft? — I think that is a moot point whether it comes down the shaft at all.
6,626. And shots are fired in those parts? — Yes.
6,627. Have you ever had any explosions in your mine? — No.
6,628. Neither of them? — No.
6,629. How often do you suppose shots have been fired in the dusty parts of your mine — once a month? — The manager could tell you better than I can.
6,630. It is a usual occurrence? — Oh, yes, on the main roads.
6,631. In places where there would be dust? — Yes.
6,632. I suppose you have made yourself acquainted with the general management of this mine? I should like to ask, generally, whether, so far as you have seen, or as far as you have heard the evidence in this case, what your opinion is of the general system of management of the Seaham Colliery? — Thoroughly good, I should call it.
6,633. Is the amount of ventilation, in your judgment, sufficient for the extent of the working? — Yes.
6,634. 320,000 feet per minute, about? — Yes.
6,635. You are generally acquainted with the system on which it is worked? — Yes.
6,636. (Mr. A. Jones.) I believe the fire in the Maudlin seam has never been seen as a matter of fact? — Of course I can only speak from the reports; I have not seen it.
6,637. Nor have you heard of it being seen? — I have heard of the indications.
6,638. And I believe there are taps now put in the stopping for the purpose of testing the state of the seam — of the presence of fire or otherwise? — Not the presence of fire.
6,639. A valve, I ought to call it? — That is to relieve the gas.
6,640. What indicators have you to show the state of the Maudlin, if any? — There are none whatever, that I am aware of.
6,641. Is it not practicable to put indicators? — Not as far as I know.
6,642. I mean in the way of tapping into the seam for the purpose of seeing what would be likely to come off? — You might as well take the stoppings out at once.
6,643. But you might put in a tap or pipe for the purpose of testing? — It would not give you any test.
6,644. Not as to the quality of the stuff that came off? — We get that through the valve.
6,645. That is the only indicator that you have? — Yes, as far as I know.
6,646. That does form an indicator? — Yes, as regards gas.
6,647. Does heat come off now from that indicator? — No, it never did ; the valve is close to the shaft.
6,648. What does come off? — I have not seen it myself.
6,649. Since the stoppings there have been no indications whatever as to what the state of the Maudlin is? — There is this valve.
6,650. That only throws off gas? — Yes, you can have no other indications.
6,651. Not as to whether there is fire or not? — Certainly not.
6,652. Do you believe it would be an extremely dangerous thing to remove a portion of the stopping for the purpose of testing? — You might as well take them out altogether.
6,653. You think it would be a dangerous thing to do? — Most certainly.
6,654. How is it you fix the time at four months; is that merely a rough guess — do you expect then that the main fire will exhaust itself and the place cool? — I put it this way: I am not prepared to say I have made up my mind that it would be prudent to open it out even in four months, but certainly that is the shortest time.
6,655. There are no data, I believe, as to the extent to which the fire has got hold of the Maudlin? — We have to come to our conclusions from the condition it was found in.
6,656. No fire was seen, but Mr. Stratton informed us there was extremely hot air, and there was boiling water; those are the only indications? — The stone was on fire.
(The Coroner.) He said the stone was on fire.
6,657. (Mr. A. Jones.) It was not on fire, but there were indications of its having been burnt? — There was every reason to believe that it was.
6,658. For all you know to the contrary, the fire may be extinguished now? — I cannot say ; I can only give an opinion, and I should say not.
6,659. I want to ask with regard to in-take No. 1 Hutton. There were no indications of any fires there — the Polka way? — It is a matter of opinion that; you say none. I am not clear as to that; there had been some, what is called kersey, in between the doors, as I found it on one of the fragments.
6,660. What was that? — Flannel at the joint of the door; I am not satisfied at all that it had not been burnt.
6,661. A piece of flannel? — Yes.
6,662. That is the only indication which you observed? — There was some indication on some of the timber, but the strongest indication of fire that I saw — it perhaps would be best for me to express that — was on the baulks going up the No. 3 pit.
6,663. I am not merely confining attention to the Polka way and its proximity; the only indication you saw there was a suspicion that there might have been fire on a piece of kersey? — Yes.
6,664. You said you did not believe that coal dust could cause an explosion? — Yes.
6,665. Have you ever made any experiments with coal dust, or seen any made? — Practically, I have not made any experiments, but I have known the result of coal dust taking fire.
6,666. Perhaps you will state what you find to be the result of coal dust — are you speaking in the pit? — No, on the bank; I never knew it in the pit.
6,667. I think you were the gentleman who was going to inform us of that. What were your observations with regard to coal dust having taken fire? — It was not my own observation; it is as I had it reported.
6,668. Perhaps you will state what the report was? — It happened to one of the screen men employed at the Merton Colliery. The tub that conveys the small coal to be screened runs from the winding engine in a box over the head of the screen man. The coal is very dusty, and they are continually tipping the coals into the screen; very fine particles of dust arise off the coals, and deposit themselves wherever there is room. This chain, when it broke, came with great violence into the box, and set a cloud of this dust in motion, and it fell on the gas lamp and ignited, as any other material would.
6,669. It lighted on the gas lamp as it fell? — Yes.
6,670. Then it extended? — It extended in itself.
6,671. Where to? — A very short distance. I suppose the man had been standing close by.
6,672. How did the man become burnt — did it flare up? — Yes.
6,673. Falling on the flame, it blazed up? — Yes.
6,674. Did it extend to the top of the shed? — Oh, no.
6,675. With regard to coal dust not causing an explosion, would you tell me whether in your judgment coal dust would intensify an explosion or conduct an explosion — do you agree with Mr. Stratton in that respect? — I believe, in case of an explosion, where there is a lot of very fine dust lying, it will be set in motion, and where the flame comes in contact with it it will burn, as in the case I have just stated.
6,676. Will it act as a conductor? — I won't say that.
6,677. But you say whenever it comes into contact with it it will burn away in the air? — When in very fine particles and set in motion.
6,678. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) You say your mine is very dusty? — Yes.
6,679. Is it more dusty than Seaham? — I can only give you an opinion. I should say Seaham was more dusty than ours. The coals are of a more tender nature.
6,680. Just about the explosion at the Polka. Supposing the explosion had occurred at the Polka, would not you have expected its effects would have penetrated much further into the third east than they did? — No. My idea is wherever it did occur — down here there is an arching separating the in-take from the return. It knocked that arching out, causing a very heavy fall, and opened out a road into the return and relieved itself there; it actually spent off there, and got so much relief that it really had little else to do.
6,681. You do not think it would have killed immediately all the men about in the returns in that part of the mine? — We have evidence that it did not.
6,682. Since we have evidence that it did not, in your view is that consistent with the theory of the explosion having taken place so near to that part of the mine as the Polka? — I can see nothing inconsistent.
6,683. Your experience of coal-dust burning is confined to that one instance? — It is the only instance I have heard of.
6,684. And there it was burnt in an open space and not in a closed gallery? — It was in the open air.
6,685. (Mr. Edge.) We have heard what Mr. Stratton said about the suggestion of a third shaft being sunk to the Maudlin, do you agree with him that if there had been a shaft there these men would have lost their lives sooner than they did? — I think the shaft would have been of no earthly use, unless it happened to have been put down exactly where the men were.
6,686. Why? — Because they would have been cut off from communication with it in all probability in the same way as they were from these other shafts.
6,687. Would it have drawn the after-damp sooner to the men? — That would altogether depend upon the position of the shaft and the result after the explosion.
6,688. Would it have exhausted the magazine in the neighbourhood of the shaft? — That would altogether depend upon whether the air-ways were closed by the result of the explosion. If they were closed, the air in the shaft would simply be stagnant.
6,689. As a matter of fact we find, I think, in this case that where there were any of these openings there was considerable violence? — That is natural ; the explosion is sure to go up the shafts to get relief, and it would have gone to that shaft also.
6,690. The probability is if there had been a shaft there, the explosion would have been carried on further into that region? — It would have found its way to that shaft most certainly, in my opinion.
6,691. Instead of ceasing about the end of the Maudlin? — Without it got relief into other air-ways, without it blew sufficient stoppings and air-crossings out it would certainly have gone to the shaft.
6,692. (Mr. A. Jones.) May I ask you this: you are aware No. 3 Hutton was explored by natural ventilation? — No, I am not aware of that.
6,693. You know when the explorers went down afterwards to remove the bodies there was no furnace? — That was No. 1.
6,694. Oh yes, you are quite right, No. 1. You know that was explored by means of natural ventilation? — Yes.
6,695. Now you are aware in the Maudlin some of the men walked as much as half a mile and lived several hours afterwards? — We have reason to suppose so.
6,696. You are aware also the explosion did not extend very far into the Maudlin? — We have every reason to know where it went to in that district, at all events. This (pointing) has not been gone into yet.
6,697. In that case would there be any reason why the men who were in that portion of the Maudlin which the explosion did not reach should not have been able to escape by means of another shaft? — If there had been another shaft the explosion would have gone to that shaft to get relief the same as to this.
6,698. We know, as a matter of tact, it did not go : do you mean the shaft would act as a conductor? — I mean it is the natural course for an explosion to take to find the shafts to get relief.
6,699. You mean act as a conductor? — Certainly not.
6,700. As an alternative? — Certainly.
6,701. Very well, we know in the Maudlin seam there were men alive within a radius of half a mile or more who were not affected by the explosion. Now if there had been a shaft there would there have been any reason why the men should not have escaped by it? We know the explosion did not reach there? — Possibly it might have escaped by it if there had been a shaft in the prescribed area.
(The Coroner.) Which men might have escaped? — These few men. And you would have to have another shaft for those men (pointing) and another for those.
6,703. (Mr. A. Jones.) That is to say, everywhere out of reach of the explosion. Supposing there had been a shaft, the men within that radius would have escaped? — I put it in this way, that in laying out the colliery if you prescribed that there had to be so many shafts and put six shafts to a certain area, you would still have explosions, and still have men lost for want of a shaft.
6,704. Of course, I am only assuming this, that if the explosion did not reach that district, in that district which it did not reach the men would have been able to escape if there had been another shaft? — I will explain myself in another way. Whatever shafts you may have would not prevent men being lost. You will have to quarry the coal to be sure of getting rid of an explosion. You cannot do it by shafts.
6,705. Do you believe, quite irrespective of the extent of the workings two shafts are sufficient? — The explosion proves that; nothing has happened on the face of the workings.
6,706. But we know the explosion has not come through the whole of the workings? — It has not come from the face of the workings.
6,707. It has not travelled on the whole of the workings? — No, it has not, because it worked itself out.
6,708. (Mr. Edge.) Is it your experience that an explosion seeks the shafts? — Certainly.
Adjourned for a short time.