1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
Seaham Colliery Inquest, 7th January 1881 (cont.).
Mr. T. H. M. Stratton recalled.
5,976. (Mr. A. Jones.) Upon the last occasion we met, you intimated you would give us full details of the lengths of all the in-takes and the lengths of the returns, and I believe also the extent of the workings in the pit? — I believe I have done so.
5,976a. I have not received any copy of it — I made it before I went away.
(Mr. R. S. Wright.) We have got it in a table which is not yet perfectly completed; it will be furnished to you the moment it is.
5,977. (Mr. A. Jones.) I understand you have furnished that? — (Mr. R. S. Wright.) It has been worked out; you shall have it directly it is completed.
5,978. (Mr. A. Jones.) I suppose you have a fair knowledge as to the general extent of the workings in the different seams? — Yes.
5,979. You can give us pretty tolerably accurate information. I will take you to the main coal seam first, and I wish to know what are the lengths of the in-takes in the main coal seam? — I could not possibly give you that information.
If you will let me refer to that table — it has all been measured.
5,980. (Mr. Edge.) I do not know whether that gives the main coal (handing document to the witness)? — No, this does not, but I can give you an idea about it.
5,981. (Mr. A. Jones.) I must ask you to speak as far as your general knowledge will permit you? — The length of the in-take of the main coal would be about 1½ miles.
5,982. The length of the returns? — The average length of the return would possibly be a mile. If you put the aggregate area together they would be much more, but I should say no part of the return was more than a mile on an average.
5,983. You are speaking of the length which any of the air would travel on its return? — Yes.
5,984. That would not give us the absolute length of the returns? — No.
5,698. What I want is the absolute length of the returns? — There are two returns. I will take it about two miles.
5,986. I suppose you can only give me this approximately. What is the total length of the workings? — The actual workings at the time of the explosion do you mean ?
5,987. The actual workings at the explosion I am dealing with now? — They would be about 1,500 or 1,600 yards, including every passage.
5,988. What is the acreage of the workings that are at present in operation at the time of the explosion? — In the main coal ?
5,989. Yes, of course. I am merely dealing with the main coal now, there were parts of the workings ventilated that were not worked.
5,990. I suppose when you say that, you mean they were parts in which the bores had been driven, but they had not proceeded to remove the pillars? — No, there was a district of the main coal seam which was ventilated, but not worked.
5,991. Do you mean the bores were standing ready for work? — Yes.
5,992. I think we had better include that, because that would be a part? — The total workings of the main coal seam would be, roughly — of course, this is very general — about 80 chains by 60 chains — about 480 acres. It is extremely rough.
5,993. I quite know that. You have not got an abstract of that? — I have not even got the plan before me.
5,994. Then, including the goaf, what is the extent of the main coal, taking the goaf and workings together? — That would include everything — the whole of the coal that has been worked at any time.
5,995. 480 acres? — Yes.
5,996. That would include the goaf and everything? — Yes.
5,997. Now, what is the distance in the main coal — I am still dealing with that seam — the distance that the air has to travel from the downcast shaft to get back to the upcast shaft? — It might be about three miles on the average.
5,998. Of course, you are speaking as approximately as you can from memory? — I think it is pretty near that.
5,999. I will proceed to the Maudlin. I think you have there the figures; perhaps it would be better if you would read them off? — They are divided here.
6,000. I did not ask you in what direction from the downcast shaft the Maudlin is worked? — Due north.
6,001. In what direction is the main worked? — West.
6,002. Now, will you tell me, perhaps from the abstract, the same that I asked you with regard to the main coal, and anything additional, of course, that you may have with reference to the Maudlin? — I have not given the in-take, or the return, but the total length of each air-way — that is what we have got here — from the down-cast to the up-cast — each split.
6,003. Each division you mean? — Yes.
6,004. Then I should prefer your taking it as a total, rather than in divisions. I first want the total in-take? — The intakes are duplicated.
6,006. You mean if they are parallel? — Yes.
6,006. You do not mean the same road, but two roads running side by side? — Yes.
6,007. I wish to have that? — Two miles and a half.
6,008. Including the parallels? — Yes.
6,009. Now excluding the parallels? — It would be about 500 yards less — more than 600 yards.
6,010. Then the returns? — The total length of the returns would amount to perhaps 4 miles or 4½ miles.
6,011. Is that including parallels or excluding parallels? — Including everything.
6,012. I suppose there are also parallels in the returns? — No; we never have them.
6,013. You never do in returns? — No.
6,014. Would you tell me again the total mileage of all the workings? — Between 1,500 and 1,600 yards would take it all up.
6,015. The acreage excluding goaf? — Near to about 200 acres excluding goaf.
6,016. Including goaf? — There would be about 50 acres of goaf.
6,017. I understood you to say the Maudlin lay due north? — It is not very far from true north.
6,018. North east? — It would be almost true north.
6,019. How is that compass? — The compass varies from true north.
6,020. Are any of the workings under the main coal seam? — Nowhere.
6,021. Now, will you take the low main, and will you state with regard to the low main what you have told me with regard to the Maudlin? — We have no low main workings at present, the only low main that is ventilated is part of the other pits return ; it is not ventilated as low main, but simply is a return from the other pits. There are no workings in the low main and have not been for many years.
6,022. Is no part of the low main ventilated? — Except by return air as part of the returns.
6,023. As a return from where? — From No. 2 pit; the No. 2 pit return air ventilates the low main.
6,024. Simply for that purpose the low main is used? — It is not used at all, it is simply ventilated in that accidental manner — partly accidental, and partly intentional; it is not used in any shape, form or way.
6,025. To what extent has the low main been worked? — A very small extent. I would not like to speak accurately, but not more perhaps than 30 or 40 acres at the extreme, a very small portion of that is worked? — There is no goaf.
6,026. In what direction does the low main lie in relation to the general east shaft? — North.
6,027. That would be direct under the Maudlin? — The low main, yes, direct under the Maudlin.
6,028. Would you give us the same information with regard to the Hutton? — Which Hutton do you mean? Do you want the area of the whole?
6,029. I want the area of the whole Hutton that is worked ; I am not talking about the other side of the trouble I am simply dealing with the Hutton seam as it is worked? — It is worked on both sides.
6,030. Let us have No. 1 first?
6,031. (The Coroner.) You want the area of each seam with the extent of the in-take and the returns? — I could not possibly give you the area of the Hutton seam off-hand, because that means to give you the area of the whole of the royalties.
(The Coroner.) So far as it may be considered a portion of this working colliery that is what you want to be at.
6,032. (Mr. A. Jones.) So far as it is a portion of this colliery, what is the extent of the Hutton? — Do you wish to include goaf?
6,033. I have asked the same question before; I have first taken the length of the in-takes? — The others are easy, because there is very little goaf.
6,034. You have No. 1 Hutton before you there — can you give me approximately the length of the intakes in No. Hutton? — Yes, I can do that. I should think 4 to 4½ miles total in-takes.
6,035. That is including parallels? — Yes.
6,036. What is it excluding parallels? — About a mile and a quarter less.
6,037. What is the length of the returns? — I should think the total length might be about six miles.
6,038. Not more? — Not exceeding, I should think.
6,039. What is the mileage of the workings? — There might be about a mile of working passages.
6,040. The total acreage excluding goaf — just approximately? — About 200 acres.
6,041. Including goaf? — That is the total goaf (referring to the plan).
There is more goaf than is shown there.
(The Coroner.) We have had the measurements of the goaf.
(Mr. A. Jones.) Yes; I am taking the goaf with the workings.
(The Witness.) I think the best way will be to add all the figures together as I gave them before. They might disagree with what I am giving now.
(Mr. Wright.) It is between 200 and 300 acres; it is obvious on the face of the plan.
(Mr. A. Jones.) The goaf.
(Mr. Wright.) The goaf is about the same size.
(The Witness.) I measured them before.
(Mr. A. Jones.) I am asking you the goaf and the workings together.
(Mr. Wright.) 500 to 600 acres.
(Mr. A. Jones.) Yes I will take it to be that; only I want to have it on the notes from the witness.
(The Witness.) I suppose that would be about it.
6,042-3. About 600? — Yes, I suppose that would be about it.
6,044. Now, No. 3 Hutton? — The total in-takes is about a mile and a-half.
6,045. Is the in-take including or excluding parallels? — Including parallels.
6,046. Then excluding parallels? — There are none there.
(Mr. Wright.) It may save time if I show my friend what has been nearly completed (handing a table to Mr. Jones). You must not take it as complete, but you shall have it complete by and by.
(Mr. A. Jones.) This is near enough for me.
(Mr. Wright.) It is to show to you that you can rely upon having it all. It was arranged that it should be done on paper and not done viva voce. That is the reason why it was not furnished.
6,047. (Mr. A. Jones.) Now the total length of the returns. It would be about double that. It would be about 2½ to 3 miles.
6,048. The mileage of the workings? — Very small indeed.
6,049. (The Coroner.) What are they? — About a couple of hundred yards.
6,050. (Mr. A. Jones.) The acreage including goaf? — 40 acres, I should think.
6,051. Including? — If you include the total goaf in the pit, I could not tell you how much. It goes a very long way.
6,052. There is a great deal of goaf? — There is a great deal of goaf.
6,053. Of course, I only want it approximately? — I am sure I would not like to say. It must be a great number of acres — 700 or 800 acres.
6,054. That, I believe, is the oldest part of the pit? — It has been made into goaf a long time ago, but it is no older than the others. They are all about the same age in this pit. It was worked more rapidly than the others.
6,055. I suppose that will be Brough's royalty, will it not? — There are a great number of royalties there.
6,056. In No. 3 Hutton? — Yes.
6,057. Does that include the Nickynack? — There is not any particular place called the Nickynack.
6,058. What is the place commonly called the Nickynack? — The whole concern goes by the name of Nickynack.
6,059. Is there not a distinction between the Brough royalty, the Nickynack, and the Londonderry? — There is not. I do not know of any.
6,060. You do not know of any? — No.
6,061. (The Coroner.) I will put it in another way. Were not they known as the Seaton Colliery and the Seaham Colliery at one time? — Yes.
(The Coroner.) Now you have as much as you want?
(Mr. A. Jones.) Yes.
6,062. Does it exhaust the whole of the Hutton seam? — No. The No. 2 pit is Hutton seam.
6,663. Yes, of course. There is the West way, is there not? — In which way?
6,064. The Hutton — the old West? — That you had just now — the No. 3 seam.
6,065. You have exhausted the whole of that? — Yes.
6,066. Then, dealing with the other Hutton No. 2, where does that lie — in what direction? — The north of the shaft.
6,067. What is the length of the in-takes?
(Mr. Bell.) It is on that paper that you have there.
(Mr. Wright.) I do protest against all these things being taken viva voce as well as being on a table.
(The Coroner.) The table is not in.
(Mr. A. Jones.) It is not on the notes, and I want to get a general idea on the notes of the works and the lengths.
(Mr. Wright.) It is on the notes that a table to this extent was to be put in, and that is the way in which it is to be dealt with. The moment it is completed my friend shall have it. It is quite enough at present for his information.
(Mr. A. Jones.) I had no idea that this was being prepared.
(Mr. Wright.) On the contrary, you will find on the notes that this was promised.
(Mr. A. Jones.) Certainly; and my cross-examination was based on that promise ; but I had no idea that this had been prepared. What I desire to do, and what I think is the proper course is, to get a general idea of this colliery. I have very nearly exhausted it. I have practically completed it.
(The Coroner.) Yes, you had better complete it now that you have gone so far.
(The Witness.) May I look at this table?
(The Coroner.) If you can get through it quicker by looking at it, do so.
(The Witness, after referring to the table.) This will not do what he wants.
(Mr. A. Jones.) No doubt my friend Mr. Wright is in possession of this knowledge I am not.
6,068. Take the No. 2 Hutton, and tell me the extent of the in takes? — About five miles, I should say.
6,069. Is that including parallels? — Yes.
6,070. Excluding parallels, how much? — About half a mile less.
6,071. Returns? — I think it is hopeless to attempt to measure them in my mind. I should say double that.
(The Coroner.) He does not want you to speak to yards. He wants to get a general idea of the extent. He does not want to pin you down to twenty yards or fifty yards.
6,072. (Mr. A. Jones.) I do not wish to pin you down to what you are going to say. I am simply asking you as to your general knowledge of the mine and its extent. I will not pin you down to anything? — I should about double that, then.
6,073. Double that? — Eight to ten miles.
6,074. The length of the workings? — I should think they would come to about a mile and a half.
6,075. The acreage without goaf? — About 600 or 700 acres.
6,076. Including goaf? — There may be 70 or 80 acres of goaf.
6,077. Not more? — Not more.
6,078. I think the last I have to deal with is the Harvey, is it not? — That is the Harvey.
6,079. Oh, that you call the Harvey. But is there no other seam worked which you call the Harvey below the Hutton? — No, it is not worked. There may be passages driven into the Harvey seam, but there is practically none of the Harvey worked whatever.
6,080. Does that exhaust the whole of the workings present and past of the colliery? — With the single exception of the west Maudlin. You have not alluded to the west Maudlin yet. It is a small district, about a few acres only worked in the west Maudlin, and that exhausts it all.
6,081. Perhaps you had better, for the sake of symmetry, just take the west Maudlin. What is the length of the in-takes in the west Maudlin? — It might be 510 yards.
6,082. No parallels? No.
6,083. Returns? — They might be 300 or 400 yards.
6,084. And the length of the workings? — There are none. That includes everything.
6,085. The acreage, excluding goaf? — Perhaps 20 to 25 acres; no goaf
6,086. No goaf at all? — No goaf at all.
6,087. That exhausts all the colliery? — You have not mentioned the north main coal. The north main coal also appears in that plan, by the way.
6,088. That is only a very small piece — the north main coal? — Yes.
6,089. Perhaps you will tell us the extent of it? — The in-take will be about half a mile; the return about the same.
6,090. And the length of the workings? — None.
6,091. The acreage? — I should think not more than 10 or 15 acres.
6,092. Excluding goaf? — There is no goaf.
6,093. That exhausts the whole of the colliery? — That is the whole of the workings that I recollect at this moment.
6,094. That is the whole of the workings that you recollect at this moment? — There are no other workings.
6,095. And does that exhaust the whole of the colliery that has been worked in the past, so far as you know? — It does.
6,096. I suppose you cannot give me an approximation of the total acreage of all the present workings in the whole colliery? — You could do it by adding those figures.
6,097. I know we can, but you cannot give that to me now in an approximate manner? — No ; it is impossible.
(The Coroner.) Are you going to carry that any further.
(Mr. A. Jones.) Not now. I cannot complete it.
6,098. (The Coroner.) Is the colliery as it is worked now, a combination of the Seaton Colliery and the Seaham? — It is what used to be Seaton and Seaham.
6,099. Do you know when the combination stopped; if it is not within your own knowledge never mind? — I think, to the best of my recollection, 1860.
(Mr. A. Jones.) I was coming to that.
6,100. It is a combination of the Seaton and the Seaham Colliery? — Yes.
6,101. Which is the older of the two collieries? — They are both the same age; you might call them "twins." I think they were sunk together.
6,102. But they were worked separately? — Yes, worked separately.
6,103. There was no communication between the two? — Not for a number of years.
6.104. Of course; and were they each served by one shaft? — They were each served by one shaft.
6,105. And when the Legislature required two shafts to be made, was it about then that the communication was made between the two collieries? — I fancy it was before that — my impression is that it was before that.
6,106. Which was the larger of the two collieries? — They were about equal in magnitude, I should think.
6,107. I do not want to go over the same ground, but I think this pit lies in the basin of the coal-field, does it not? It is one of the deepest pits that there are to be found in the Durham coal-field? — It is one of the deepest.
6,108. I think you stated that the total amount of air sent in averaged about 320,000 to 330,000 feet? — Yes.
6,109. And the measurement a fortnight before the accident showed 316,579? — Yes, 316,000.
6,110. The colliery is ventilated by means of two furnaces? — Yes.
6,111. And two boilers? — Yes.
(The Coroner.) We have all this.
6,112. (Mr. A. Jones.) How long is it since the boilers were put in to aid the ventilation? — I have not an idea; it is a very long time ago.
6,113. Before you were connected with the colliery?
6,114. (Mr. Edge to witness.) Are you following the question. The question was, "How long is it since the boilers were put in to aid the ventilation"? — Oh, to aid the ventilation ! I did not understand that that was the question; they were not put in to aid the ventilation altogether.
6,115. (Mr. A. Jones.) I have it on the notes, if I am not mistaken, that you said that the boilers were placed there to assist the ventilation? — They are by no means essential for the ventilation of the colliery they were not put in for that purpose.
6,116. That was only an inaccurate way of expressing yourself when you said (at least I think you did) that they were placed there to aid the ventilation? — I do not think I said so.
6,117. They do aid it as a matter of fact? — They do aid it as a matter of fact.
6,118. But it was not with that view they were put in? — No, certainly not.
6,119. I know they served another purpose; do you know of any colliery larger than this which is worked solely by furnace? — Yes, I think I do.
6,120. What colliery? — I am under the impression that the Ryhope is worked solely by furnace.
6,121. Solely by furnace? — Yes, the Monkwearmouth, the Silksworth, and the Merton. I believe the furnace is the rule, in fact, in the deep collieries in the east country.
6,122. Do you know deep collieries in the east country where the fan has been introduced or is introduced? — They have introduced it at Boldon, I believe.
6,123. Is the objection to the fan that it would not be able to work so large a colliery as this? — Yes, that is true.
6,124. Do you know of any colliery in this district where they are introducing a fan for the purpose?
(The Coroner.) Are you going to set up that the amount of ventilation sent into the pit was not sufficient for the workings? Because, if you are not going to set up that, and if the mine is properly ventilated, I do not see what difference it makes whether the mine is ventilated by a fan or by anything else.
(Mr. A. Jones.) I think so. I am not going to dwell upon this at any length ; I want simply to get it on the notes.
6,125. Do you know that there is a colliery in this district where they are applying a fan which will send 200,000 feet? — I never knew a fan that would do it.
6,126. Do you mean that the capacity of the fan will not reach such an extent? — I never knew one to do it — that is all I can say.
6,127. After the explosion you said the great difficulty was that you had to go into No. 3 Hutton by means of such natural ventilation as you could get? — Yes.
6,128. Then, if there had been a fan, there would have been no difficulty in restoring ventilation to No. 1 Hutton at once? — I do not know about that. It depends on the extent to which the fan itself got damaged.
6,129. You assume that the fan had got damaged? I think you might necessarily assume that.
6,130. Necessarily? — Yes, if the pit was damaged.
6,131. In the absence of the fan being damaged, ventilation could have been restored to the colliery immediately? — No, I do not think so.
6,132. Why not? — It does not follow at all.
6,133. Of course, I am speaking independently, of where there are such falls as to choke the main air in-takes and where the stoppings were blown out. I mean, independently of that and apart from that, would not a fan have been able to restore ventilation to the colliery? — It all depends on circumstances.
6,134. Certainly; but more rapidly than a furnace? — I have no experience. I cannot say.
(The Coroner.) You have it from him as far as you can get it.
6,135. (Mr. A. Jones.) You decline to express any opinion further than that. You stated, I think, that this is like all mines in this district — it is a very gassy mine? — Did I say "very" gassy.
6,136. Well, perhaps, I am putting it too far. It is a gassy mine? — It produces gas. It is called a gaseous mine under the Act.
6,137. These deep mines on the east coast are all gassy mines — essentially gassy? — They are all worked under the gas rules. They are all more or less gassy, of course.
6,138. Is it not an uncommon thing in this district for large blowers to come off? — They have been known.
6,139. Can you cast back your recollection to the latest large blower of gas? — In 1877.
6,140. Not later? — No.
6,141. Cast back your mind to 1878. Can you tell whether in the year 1878 there was not a large blower? — It was in 1877, I think. If it was in 1878 it was not in 1877, and vice versa. My memory may deceive me about one year. It was in 1877. There has been only one great blower since I came here, and that was in 1877.
6,142. Where was that? — In the face of the third air way, No. 1 Hutton.
6,143. Was that a blower which came off at a very great pressure? — Yes, it did.
6,144. Did it bring off soil, stone, and water with it? — There was water came away with it.
6,145. Did you come off with a very great noise? — It came off with a considerable noise.
6,146. Considerable noise? — Yes.
6,147. So as to be heard at a distance of 300 or 400 yards? — Oh no.
6,148. Are you sure of that? — Quite sure.
6,149. At how great a distance — You could hear it perhaps 80 yards off.
6,150. Are you sure it was not more? — I should say not more.
6,151. Are you sure that the figures I gave would not more nearly approximate to the fact than what you are giving? — Two pillars off you could hear it. That is about 80 yards. You could not hear it more than that.
6,152. And I suppose you allowed it to exhaust itself? — I did.
6,153. That is the ordinary way. You have had a number of smaller blowers since then? — Yes; they are not an uncommon thing.
6,154. In what part of the pit did you find those blowers chiefly? — Mainly in the third east.
6,155. Have you ever known these blowers come off in the making of refuge holes? — No.
6,156. Have you ever known them come off in connection with shot firing? — No.
6,157. You never have? — No.
6,158. Not in firing a shot? — No.
6,159. Under what circumstances do they come off; You told my friend about what you termed a "creeping" of the mine. Would they go off at all in connection with that? — I do not remember having mentioned "creeping."
(The Coroner.) I do not think it was you. Somebody else mentioned "creeping." I think it was Mr. Turnbull.
(Mr. A. Jones.) Mr. Stratton did deal with it in his evidence.
(The Witness.) There is no such thing as "creeping." If I had been asked if there was such a thing I should have said no.
6,160. A heaving of the mine? — Yes. That is a different matter.
6,161. Would they come off at all in connection with a heaving of the mine? — They might come off from the bottom of the mine. I have known them to do it.
6,162. You have known them to come off the bottom of the floor? — Yes.
6,163. Have you ever known them come off the in-takes? — No.
6,164. Never? — You mean where an in-take has been formed? You must put that question more closely, because the great blower I mentioned was in the in-take, in the wagon-place, in the main place.
6,165. Was it in the engine plane? — It was in the engine plane.
6,166. Of the third east? — Of the third east.
6,167. (The Coroner.) You had better show the locality? — It was in the second in-take rather, in that thing (pointing on the plan.)
6,168. (The Coroner.) We have had that from three or four witnesses. It is not in any other place than that? It is not another blower? — It is not another blower. There is no other blower.
6,169. (Mr. A. Jones.) That was in the workings? — Yes, it was in the workings.
6,170. Have you ever known a blower come off actually in the in-take, so that the gas came into the in-take? — No; never. I have not.
6,171. Never on any occasion? — Never on any occasion.
6,172. Have you ever known a blower come out, not in the workings but in the return? — No ; not that I know of.
6,173. You never have known it? — No.
6,174. Can you give us the approximate cause of these blowers coming off? Is it while the coal is being worked? — These blowers come off at the roof of course.
6,175. You spoke about blowers coming off at the floor? — They are very rare. The commonest form is in the roof. They come from fissures. The gas issues through fissures.
6,176. From cavities? — You do not know where the cavity ends, but little narrow fissures; and as soon as the face of the coal is worked off that allows the gas to come off, and that constitutes a blower.
6,177. There will be no reason whatever, so far as your knowledge of the mine is concerned, why a blower should come off during the process of blasting a refuge hole? — As I told you before, I never knew a case. It is improbable.
6,178. Do you use the Clanny lamp in the mine? — Yes.
6,179. Do you believe that is the safest lamp? — No, I do not think it is the safest lamp.
6,180. What lamp do you believe to be the safest? — Well, it is rather a delicate question to ask. There is a battle of the lamps.
6,181. You are an experienced colliery manager. I am only asking your opinion? — If I were to recommend one lamp more than the others, I should be taken as condemning the best. There are several lamps.
6,182. Do you believe that the Clanny is one of the least safe lamps? — The Clanny is not so safe as more than one other lamp.
6,183. Is it the fact that after the explosion in any explorations you made, you discarded the Clanny, and used the Stephenson? — That is so.
6,184. On account of its greater safety? — Well, it was. That was the reason; there was no doubt about it — it was recommended to be done.
6,185. Is it not a common thing — when I say "a common thing," I ought to correct myself — is it not a danger connected with the Clanny that the gas may frequently get between the glass and the brass? — No, not at all, I should say.
6,186. Are you sure of that? — Quite sure.
6,187. Have you never heard of india-rubber rings being used for the purpose of preventing the gas getting in by the junction of the glass and the brass? — We use leather ones.
(The Coroner.) We got that out before.
(The Witness.) It is a necessary part of the lamp; the leather ring is part of the lamp as much as any other part.
6,188. (Mr. A. Jones.) That is part of the lamp you say? — Yes.
6,189. You make it part of the lamp? — It is part of the lamp.
6,190. Do you mean it was part of the lamp when the lamp was purchased? — I do not know; it depends upon different makes.
6,191. Do you uniformly use those leather rings? — Oh, yes ; the leather ring is part of the lamp.
6,192. Do you know at what velocity of gas the Clanny lamp explodes? — About 8 feet.
6,193. You know the Stephenson will not explode under a much greater velocity? — No; I do not agree with that. I do not think the Stephenson is any safer than some others.
(The Coroner.) You are getting into the battle of the lamps, Mr. Jones.
(Mr. Jones.) I think it is very material we should know what kind of lamp is used here, and whether it is the safest. It is not for me to make any observation about it.
(The Witness.) The lamp is, as you must know, in almost universal use.
6,194. Do you know that the Clanny lamp has been uniformly condemned by all persons who have authority to speak upon the question? — I most certainly do not think so.
6,195. I will put my question in another form. Do you know that the Stephenson lamp has always been held to be a much safer lamp than the Clanny lamp? — I do not think so.
(Mr. R. S. Wright.) I should not agree with either proposition.
(Mr. A. Jones.) Mr. Wright is not under examination.
(The Witness.) I do not think that is at all a proper way to put it.
6,196. For what reason did you use the Stephenson lamp after the explosion? — You had better put the committee in evidence. The committee decided upon it. The Clanny went down the pit and was used for 24 hours after the explosion. I carried the Clanny myself. I would not have been afraid with the Clanny. You must ask the committee as to their reason.
(The Coroner.) I think that should satisfy you, Mr. Jones, so far as this witness is concerned, when he went and worked 24 hours himself with the Clanny after the explosion.
(Mr. A. Jones.) Very well.
6,197. As the manager of this mine, are you aware that the Stephenson lamp was taken down the pit for the purpose of exploring, in consequence of its greater safety? — I do not know the reason why it was.
6,198. Can you conceive any other reason? — I admit many people have different opinions about lamps.
6,199. I know that. I do not question that; but can you give me any reason whatever, other than the one I suggest, why the Stephenson lamp was taken down the mine? — No, I cannot give any further reason than that.
(The Coroner.) Mr. Forster and Mr. Hall were on the committee, and they are going to be called as soon as Mr. Stratton is done, and they will give you the reason why they instructed it to be used.
(Mr. R. S. Wright.) We have had the reason as to the Clanny. It depends upon the state of the ventilation.
6,200. (Mr. A. Jones.) I know it does. (To the witness.) I will put the question this way — in a strong ventilating current where there is an explosive mixture, is not the Stephenson a safer lamp than the Clanny? — I am not sure of it.
6,201. Do you mean to say you are not sure of that? — Yes, I am not sure of that by any means.
6,202. Do you know the authorities so declare it? — No; there is no authority which would say it is a very much safer lamp.
6,203. Do you know that the Musler and the Stephenson are both safer lamps? — I do not agree with that as to the Stephenson; the Musler is a safer lamp.
6,204. The Musler is a safer lamp than the Clanny? — Yes.
6,205. Is the Clanny the only lamp used in the Seaham Colliery? — The Clanny and the Davey.
6,206. What Davey is used, is it without glass or with? — It is the ordinary Davey.
6,207. The ordinary Davey without glass? — With a tin sheave; it was in use then.
6,208. Who used that? — Everybody on occasion — boys principally.
6,209. Boy's use it? — Yes.
6,210. Is it a small Davey? — You see there is not so much fear of breaking anything. You cannot give a glass lamp to a boy to be knocking about with it.
6,211. You give the Davey to the boys? — As a rule, yes.
6,212. Is it only for that reason, because of the danger of breaking the glass? — That is all.
6,213. The Clanny you entrust with the men? — Yes, and as a rule the man wants a better light.
6,214. (The Coroner.) The Clanny gives a better light than the other lamps do? — Oh, yes, double the light.
6,215. (Mr. A. Jones.) You have known cases, I suppose, of the glass of the Clanny breaking while men have been working? — No.
6,216. You have never known such a case? — No, not by proper use.
6,217. You have never known a case of its getting hot and splitting through water getting upon it? — Never, not personally, you understand.
6,218. In your judgment, which lamp would you use in a colliery? — I confess I like the Musler.
6,219. You would use the Musler? — I confess I like it, I say.
6,220. You would adopt that in preference to any other? — There are many questions to be considered in the use of lamps. I do not know that it is altogether right to ask me to give you a definite opinion upon this.
6,221. I do not see why I should not. However, I will not press you upon it; I am only asking you as to judgment? — I have told you I consider the Musler a very good lamp.
6,222. You would prefer it. Now the Seaham Colliery is a very dusty colliery, you say? — I do not think I said it.
6,223. A very dry colliery? — Very dry.
I think you said very dusty too.
(The Coroner.) No, not "very."
6,224. (Mr. A. Jones.) I think you said it was a dusty colliery? — Yes; that is the same thing as dry.
6,225. Is that dust confined to certain parts of the pit, or is it found uniformly throughout the pit? I do not mean to say the same quantity, but is it dusty throughout the pit? — It is dusty wherever there is no water.
6,226. I think my friend Mr. Wright asked you the question with regard to this explosion. You see the point of contact here (pointing) with the engine-plane? — Yes.
6,227. In the natural order of things, of course, supposing an explosion in this pit occurred here (pointing), and going up here, it would pass along here? — Yes.
(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Would you mind naming the places to get it on the notes?
(Mr. A. Jones.) Yes, you are quite right.
(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Supposing it occurred where?
(Mr. A. Jones.) Supposing it occurred in the No. 1 Hutton.
(The Coroner.) The Polka turn?
6,228. (Mr. A. Jones.) Yes, the Polka turn; say No. 1 Hutton; it would pass along the curve down No. 3 pit in-take? — Yes, it would go along No. 3 in-take.
6,229. Westward? — Yes, westward.
6,230. And, as a matter of course, it would not travel up the engine-plane leading to the Maudlin? — Not up.
6,231. No, not up the engine-plane, "not down" I ought to say? — I do not think that; you cannot tell where it would go.
6,232. Looking at the plan and seeing the point of contact of the engine-plane with the curve, it could not travel along the engine-plane? — I would not like to say that at all; I do not see why it should not.
6,233. Did you not account for it going up the engine-plane by the fact that it was a coal-dust explosion at its point of contact with the engine-plane? — Me?
6,234. Yes? — When?
6,235. Yesterday? — No, I said it might assist it.
6,236. Do you mean that if this explosion took place in No. 1 Hutton it would be possible for the blast coming here to turn round that corner? — Most unquestionably; it will turn anywhere.
6,237. Would not its natural course be to come up the in-take of No. 3? — It will go anywhere.
6,238. The blast would travel in the most easy direction, I suppose, for it to go, would it not? — It does not follow that. I tell you it is very capricious in its course. If you have been down a pit, you will know you can form no guide as to where it will go — there are places where you would expect not to find it safe, and where it would lie, and places where you would expect to find it safe, where it was all smashed up.
6,239. Do you mean to say this blast from No. 1 Hutton would go round the curve and then turn at a sharp angle into the Maudlin, when it had a straight road before it into No. 3 Hutton? — Yes, I most certainly think it would — unquestionably it would, it goes wherever there is liberty — it is not a question of directions.
6,240. It would go in that direction where liberty was afforded it? — It would get liberty that way.
6,241. Would not its natural course be down No. 3 Hutton? — I do not know what it natural course would be. I cannot tell you anything about these things.
6,242. You are acquainted with the ordinary laws which govern matters of this kind? — I have told you there seems to be no law in this matter, as far as I can judge.
6,243. If an explosive force is travelling at a certain velocity, it would naturally, would it not, follow the most easy outlet for it — would it not follow the easiest course — I assume it has got round the curve? — I decline to be answerable for anything it has done.
6,244. I am only asking your opinion? — It would go anywhere, I think.
6,245. It would be the easiest course up No. 3 pit — the ordinary course coming from No. 1 pit would be to go up the travelling way here (pointing), would it not? — What do you mean by the ordinary course?
6,246. That would be the easiest way for it to go, would it not? — It would be a straighter road to the Maudlin.
You told my friend, Mr. Wright, that you believed that the coal dust would ignite and would convey an explosion, or intensify the explosion.
6,247. (The Coroner.) Yesterday, Mr. Stratton said he believed that in this explosion, wherever dust had collected the explosion had been intensified; that was as far as I got? — Yes, that is exactly it.
6,248. (Mr. A. Jones.) You spoke especially in relation to this engine plane leading into the Maudlin? — No, I was not speaking about that, but about the curve drift in particular. Mr. Wright asked me about the engine plane on account of the tubs. I think that is so, is it not, Mr. Wright?
(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Yes.
(The Witness.) At the time I spoke about dust in the curve drift where I said it was deposited by the air coming down the pit.
(Mr. R. S. Wright.) What I understood Mr. Stratton to say was that the coal dust in the curve and along the engine plane affected it.
(Mr. Jones.) Clearly.
(The Coroner.) That must be taken as one of the points. Mr. Stratton thinks the explosion would be intensified by the coal dust.
6,249. (Mr. A. Jones.) You take it that it travelled down the engine plane because it would be assisted by the coal dust? — I did not say so at all.
6,250. Do you say so now? — No, I cannot see that it has to do with it.
6,251. What influence had the coal dust upon the explosion — will you point out on the plan? — In that curve (pointing), there is a kind of coal dust that we have not got anywhere else on the colliery. That is what I meant to say, there is coal dust which is deposited, not brought down the pit. It is not on the engine plane or in the travelling way, not to the same extent. That was the point.
6,252. I am quite aware of that, but that does not assist me as to the direction which the explosion should take. You were giving us reasons for the explosion having travelled down the engine plane? — Then all I can say is, assuming the explosion to occur in the curve drift, it would go into the Maudlin by either the engine plane or the second in-take — it might be either way.
6,253. What you say now is that the explosion would be assisted into the engine plane leading into the Maudlin by the coal dust? — By that coal dust lying in the curve drift.
6,251. And of course the coal dust at the junction of the curve drift and of the engine plane? — There is coal dust lying in the curve drift which is peculiar to itself almost; you will find it nowhere else.
6,255. Are you of opinion that the effects which were found in the Maudlin might be attributable not to the original explosive current, but to the firing of the coal dust passing along the engine plane? — Oh, no; it is no different from any other part of the pit. The symptoms as we could see them in the Maudlin were precisely the same.
6,256. Then indifferently you would say this, however out of the way it might be, the course of an explosion is so erratic that it would be quite possible for the explosive current to turn round that sharp angle? — I should certainly say so.
6,257. In the same way, supposing the explosion to have taken place at No. 3 Hutton, it would be equally simple to have turned round that (pointing)? — Just the same thing.
6,258. It would have been equally easy for it to have travelled down the travelling away into the Maudlin? — Yes, just the same thing, you cannot depend upon it; you cannot form any idea how it would go.
6,259. Now, I want to take you to this travelling way in No. 1 Hutton. This (pointing) is the travelling way I think you call it? — Yes, that is the travelling way.
6,260. I think there was some confusion in terms yesterday with regard to it, this (pointing) we will call the engine plane, I suppose? — Yes.
(The Coroner.) "The main in-take" will do as well.
6,261. (Mr. A. Jones.) I read the notes of your evidence about it, but could not quite clearly understand how it was. Perhaps it was my own fault. I could not make out what you said as to the indications of the way in which the explosion had travelled down the travelling way? — Well, I told you that at the commencement of the in-take the indications were inwards, in-bye for about 60 yards.
6,262. That I understood, they were in-bye down the travelling way? — Yes.
6,263. That is here (pointing). Let us be perfectly clear about it? — Yes.
Down the travelling way.
(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Into the No. 1.
6,264. (Mr. A. Jones.) Of course, I have said that after the junction of the engine plane with the travelling way, the indications were indications of the explosions having travelled down? — Inwards.
6,265. Down the travelling way? — Yes.
(Mr. Bell.) "Along," it is not "down."
(Mr. A. Jones.) Yes, "along."
(Mr. Bell.) Call it "in-bye."
(Mr. Jones.) Yes, "in-bye," I ought to say.
(The Witness.) I told you the distance yesterday.
6,266. I will not trouble you about the distance particularly, but after proceeding some distance found the indications out-bye? — Outwards.
(The Coroner.) At the temporary stables?
(Mr. A. Jones.) That is so. I am much obliged to you.
6,267. Where do you fix the temporary stables?
(The Coroner.) It is on that plan, is it not (pointing)?
(Mr. A. Jones.) Yes.
6,267a. Then you fix the explosion as far as your judgment allows you. I will put it this way, where would you fix the explosion? — Between or about the Polka.
6,268. The Polka turn? — I have told you I have not fixed the explosion. It is hardly a right way to put it. I have already declined to fix it.
6,269. I mean to say, as far as your judgment goes, you judge it to be somewhere from the indications about the Polka turn? — I would say somewhere about the Polka turn, there might have been an explosion — I will put it that way.
6,270. Will you explain to me how it is, supposing an explosion took place about the Polka turn, that the indications are in-bye down the travelling way? — Very simply I can do that.
6,271. Yes, please do it? — The engine plane and the second in-take were entirely separated by the stoppings — they were completely isolated from one another; assuming the explosion to have originated at the Polka way, the first open place it would come to would be the temporary stables, and opposite those temporary stables there were doors into the return, and an explosion would naturally get vent at those doors, and it did go through the temporary stables and up through the doors into the return, and as these explosions must be almost momentary, it would reach the end of the in-take almost as quickly as it would reach the temporary stables; therefore, for a short distance it would turn up as if to go into those doors again.
6,272. I should be obliged to you if you would point out to me the course upon the plan, with an indicator by which the explosion turned down into the engine plane? — Into the engine plane.
6,273. Into the travelling way? — There (pointing) is the travelling way.
6,274. Please go from the seat of the explosion? — Supposing it was here (pointing).
6,275. About the Polka way? — There is the first place it would be vacant; at all the rest there are stoppings in between.
6,276. Go on, please? — To what next?
6,277. I want you to bring the explosion down the travelling way? — I say there were doors there (pointing) and a shot would naturally go through the doors into the return.
6,278. Clearly? — And assume it to go right and left there (which it did) when it got to the junction here, as I say, the distance is so short, that it might easily partly turn back, or did turn back to go through those very doors.
6,279. Do I misunderstand you correctly as to this. I do not want to pledge you to anything that you do not mean, but do you mean seriously that the explosion, assuming it to take place here (pointing), would travel up the engine plane and would then go to the first opening that was afforded to it across the travelling way? — Yes.
6,280. Go to the stables, come back into the travelling way? — I do not follow you there.
6,281. Then would you show me on this plan where it would go after it had got to the stables? — The shock that went into the stables would remain there and get vent there.
6,282. Just show me on this plan — I have got you as far as the stables? — There are the stables (pointing).
6,283. Now where would it go? — It would go right through the doors into the return, then it would come up here (pointing).
6,284. But how would it come up here (pointing), that is what I want to know? — Because it did.
6,285. You say "because it did," but I want an explanation as to how it did? — I cannot tell you; it is the very thing that is impossible.
6,286. Would you show me your theory as to the way in which the current went? — That is the way.
6,287. Would you follow it on the plan? — I have told you the way the current went.
(The Coroner.) That it would take the very first opening it could get, and that was coming back to the stables.
6,288. (Mr. A. Jones.) I fully understand that, sir; but what I want to know is, how are the indications in-bye in the travelling way?
(The Witness.) The indications in the travelling way are in-bye for about 90 yards.
6,289. How do you get the explosion in-bye? — It will always go wherever there is vent.
6,290. Will you follow it on the plan — there was an open space here (pointing)? — I have followed it.
6,291. We have got the explosion to the stables; I suppose from about the Polka way it comes up here and crosses into the stables. Now, will you please pursue its course? — I do not know why you are fastening me upon this, because I have declined to give an opinion.
6,292. Mr. Stratton, I want to know — and I think my question is an extremely plain one — how it is you account for the indications down the travelling way in-bye?
6,292a. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Would you let Mr. Stratton finish that answer, because you declined to? — I say I have declined to commit myself to any theory whatever, and now you want me to explain the explosion.
6,293. (Mr. A. Jones.) I quite understand that you decline to commit yourself to any theory, but, at the same time, the balance of probabilities, in your judgment, is that the explosion took place about the Polka way. That I understand. Now, I want to learn from you, and I must press you for an answer, how you arrive at the conclusion that this explosive current should get up into the engine plane, and then turn back to go down the travelling way. We have got to the stables, please to go on from there? — I have told you already, from the indications; the fact is, that the indications are so that they prove that it did go that way.
6,294. Will you kindly show me — because it is most important — the indications, you see, are in-bye here (pointing), which would point to the explosion having taken place in quite a different direction to the Polka? — I have told you they were out-bye at the stables.
6,295. But they are in-bye between the stables and the junction of the engine plane? — Yes, there were in-bye indications there, in the travelling way, and out-bye on the engine plane.
6,296. But they are in-bye in the travelling way. Now, what I want to know is, how you get the current if the explosion has taken place near the Polka to send the indications in-bye? — Simply by its desire to get to this course (pointing).
6,297. Follow the course — it must have taken some course? — And so back into the doors. It would go to some place where there is liberty.
That is another theory altogether.
(Mr. R. S. Wright.) It is what he said before.
(The Coroner.) Yes.
6,298. (Mr. A. Jones.) Then do you mean to say it went up here (pointing) and turned back down the travelling way? — I most certainly do believe it did.
6,299. How would it turn down the travelling way, because that would be right round? — Because it was easier to get to these doors than here (pointing).
6,300. Where would be its difficulty in getting vent? — The difficulty is all over — the difficulty is before you get vent.
6,301. I have got the explosion travelled along here (pointing)? — Yes.
6,302. You then say it turns back here (pointing)? What caused it to turn back? — Because that is the easier road to go.
6,303. Easier than what — easier than going up here (pointing)? — Yes.
6,304. What is the difficulty in travelling up here (pointing)? — Because there is an immense open space here (pointing) to the returns. It will go where there is the least compression.
6,305. Where is the compression that takes it not up here (pointing)? — The entrance of the in-take — the narrowness.
6,306. It is like a shot from a cannon's mouth. When the gun has discharged, the explosion, if there is nothing standing in its way, will go straight on. It will shoot through the touchhole as well — just the same thing — it will get vent wherever it is allowed to.
6,307. The natural vent being here (pointing), how do you account for its turning right round? — I will call that (pointing) a touchhole, that is where it got some liberty.
6,308. Where is the difficulty in getting vent here (pointing)? — The fact is that it has a difficulty to go anywhere.
6,309. Where is the difficulty? — In the road.
6,310. Where? — The place.
6,311. Where? — The place itself. I cannot give you any more answer than that.
6,312. But it is a straight clean road; is not the engine plane a straight clean road up to the shaft? — A straight road.
6,313. A clear road? — Yes, a clear road.
6,314. Now its being a straight clear road up to the shaft, will you explain to me how this explosion when it came to the junction with the travelling way, turned back and went down the travelling way? — I have told you it went to go through the doors, and I can give you no more reason than that which I have given you. I say the explosion took up there to go to these doors.
6,315. (The Coroner.) I do not know whether I understand you rightly or not. I will just ask you when it got to this point (pointing), it got power of expansion? — Through those doors.
6,316. And so distributed in a similar way when it got power of expansion, and went into the seams. Yes, that is the same thing.
6,317. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Put in another way it is this — when here at this point, where there is a division, it found this in-take was not wide enough to carry it? — Exactly.
6,318. So that it was violently squeezed by it, and the first part took the back way?
(Mr. A. Jones.) I do not know that.
(The Witness.) But, Mr. Jones, you will find the same thing the other end of the in-take.
6,318a. I accept, Mr. Stratton, as far as I am able, the explanation you afford as to how a force coming up to the clearway could take it into its head, as it seems to have a head, to turn right round and go in the opposite direction to which it was coming? — The same thing would apply to the opposite indications a few yards away, supposing it coming the other way.
6,319. It blew away the overcasts, did it not? — Yes, it blew away the overcasts.
6,320. And it turned here, and you said the indications were from south to north? — It would get to this point (pointing) before it got to the overcast.
6,321. It is really not a question for argument; perhaps I had better not press you any more. I understand this, however, that the explosion having a clear road like a cannon, would go straight along up to the downcast shaft, and would then take whatever direction was the most open to it, there being plenty of directions open to it, your theory being that when it was travelling it came across some obstacles which caused it to reverse the ordinary law of nature and turn back? — No, it did not reverse the ordinary law of nature at all. It did not turn back, it went another road, that is all.
I will not press that further.
6,322. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) That (pointing to a sketch) is the charge of gunpowder? — Yes, that is exactly it, if you will show it to the jury (Mr. R. S. Wright explained the sketch to the Coroner and Counsel)
(Mr. A. Jones.) I am sure, Mr. Wright, I am obliged to you for your explanation of it. It is a matter, of course, upon which each person must form his own opinion; but I think it is a matter indisputable that if a cannon is fired there (pointing), and there is a straight and open course for it along there, it will follow that course.
(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Something comes out there (pointing), and to show that kind of thing is what a pressure gauge is for.
(The Witness.) Yes, of course it is.
(Mr. A. Jones.) I will not press the matter further.
(Mr. R. S. Wright.) It is the way they measure the velocity of shots every time.
6,323. (Mr. A. Jones to the witness.) You have said that there were indications of the explosion being out by No. 1 Hutton engine plane where Dodgin's body was found? — Yes.
6,324. I am not going to trouble you about the pony again very much, but I am going to ask you this: you found Dodgin's body some distance behind the wagons out-bye? — Yes.
6,325. His proper position should be by the side of the pony, I suppose? — Yes.
6,326. Does it not appear to you to be much more reasonable that the wagons, with the pony, should have been driven away from him frontwards, that is to say in-bye, and that he should be left where he was by the force of the explosion, the wagons, with the pony, being carried further on, rather than that the wagons should have been broken up in the way they were, the pony killed, and he blown right away behind his wagons from the front of them? — Do you mean which of the two things I think most likely?
6,327. Which do you think most probable? — That he was blown, most certainly.
6,328. You really think the most reasonable supposition is that Dodgin was blown right away behind the wagons, pony and all, rather than that the wagons were blown away from him? — I will always believe that the lightest bodies blow the furthest.
6,329. There is something in the extent of surface which is afforded, is there not? — The lightest bodies will go furthest.
6,330. How do you account for his getting past his wagons? — He was by the side of them.
6,331. You think he would be blown right along the side of them, right behind, and that the wagons would be left where they were? — It is a double way, I have told you.
6,332. I know you have; there is a double way, that is your theory? — It is.
6,333. I understood you to say yesterday that some of the bricks of the overcast; that would be, I suppose, this overcast, would it not (pointing)? — Yes, that one.
6,334. That some of the bricks of the overcast were blown out-bye, is that so? — Yes, that is so.
6,335. And some were blown in-bye? — No, I did not say that.
6,336. Did you not say that? — No, not one.
6,337. But you said this, that they were lying in every direction? — I said they were blown right and left. It was a brick overcast. They were blown right and left in the returns, and there were bricks lying in every direction, blown out-bye.
6,338. They were blown into the returns? — Yes.
6,339. You found bricks lying in all directions at the junction of the engine plane, did you not? — All out-bye.
6,340. All out-bye? — Yes.
6,341. Not in every direction? — No, there were a few blown in from the engine to the second in-take — to the one side, as it might be.
6,342. You spoke about finding some stones, clean edges, as if the explosion had come in-bye — where do you fix that? — "Out-bye," I think I said.
6,343. Did you not say in-bye? — No.
6,344. Are you sure? — Quite sure.
6,345. Do you say out-bye now? — I am quite sure I said out-bye before.
6,346. Perhaps it is a mistake; you say, of course, very clearly, that it was very difficult to see, because things were lying in all directions? — Yes.
6,347. Of course, when this overcasting was blown away — after the force of the explosion — would the air rush in with great force down the in-take? — I do not understand you.
6,348. I am only asking you for information. I am not suggesting that what I say is correct? — I do not understand what you mean.
6,349. You see the over-casting was all blown away here (pointing)? — Yes.
6,350. And there was the return here (pointing)? — Yes.
6,351. Of course the force of the explosion would create a vacuum here (pointing), would it not ; after the explosion had passed along here, there would be a vacuum I suppose here? — There must be a partial vacuum.
6,352. Would not the air then in that case rush in with great velocity? — It depends upon the amount of vacuum created; if it was a small vacuum it would not.
6,353. An explosion of the magnitude of this one would create a very great vacuum, would it not? — Yes, it would create a tolerable one.
6,354. And of course that would mean great force in the current of air passing in? — Yes. Well, I cannot say — it is a very difficult matter to say, it means considerable.
6,355. Of course, to a man of common sense, that would be so, would it not? — Yes, I think it would.
6,356. Would not that possibly account, to a great extent, for indications in-bye if the air travelled down with great velocity? — No, I do not think it would.
6,357. Why not? — It would not be sufficient.
6,358. You say it would not be sufficient? — No.
6,359. Why not; it would be sufficient for the hay, would it not? — What hay? I do not understand you.
6,360. The hay that was found on the engine plane? — But the hay came out.
6,361. I know it did, but suppose the hay had been blown out-bye, it might be blown back again by the force of the current, according to your own theory? — No, I do not think there is any vacuum, when you come to put the question more minutely; I do not think there is any great vacuum created, for this reason, that just at the seat of any explosion there are returns and the pressure comes back to the seat of the explosion from the returns, and it eases itself in all directions — it gets eased in all directions — there is no great rush afterwards.
6,362. (The Coroner.) You do not place much stress upon where the hay was found — you do not lay stress upon the hay indications? — Yes, that is it.
6,363. The other view supports the other indications? — Yes.
6,361. Do you put it any stronger than that? — Which is that?
6,365. That the hay indications supported the other indications? — They did.
6,366, Do you put it that they supported it stronger than the other indications supported it? — No, not stronger.
6,367. (Mr. A. Jones.) I will just read you your evidence; it may, of course, be an inaccuracy in taking down : — "Mr. R. S. Wright: Do you mean the stone constituting the fall lying on the ground? — Yes, the edges had a clean and brightened-up appearance as though they had been touched up with something. On the in-bye side? — Yes, on the in-bye side?" — Yes, on the in-bye side.
(The Coroner.) That is the edges of the stone.
6,368. (Mr. A. Jones.) On the in-bye side? — Yes, of the stone.
6,369. "I found nothing on the out-bye?" — Yes, that is right.
6,370. What "in-bye would that be?
(The Coroner.) The in-bye side of the stone.
(The Witness.) The in-bye side of the stone.
6,370a. (Mr. A. Jones.) What direction would that come from? — From in-bye to out.
6,371. On the in-bye side of the stone? — Yes.
I was taking the indication the other way.
(Mr. R. S. Wright.) It was another witness who said it showed the other thing —
(Mr. A. Jones.) Quite right.
(The Coroner.) Turnbull.
(The Witness.) I do not think he did. If he did it was wrong.
6,372. (Mr. A. Jones.) Just coming up here to the Hutton again, the north of the shaft, the doors were blown south, I think you said, did you not? — Which shaft?
6,373. The downcast shaft? — The downcast. The doors were blown into the furnace, those are the doors nearest; the low main doors were blown to the north.
6,374. The low main doors were blown to the north? — Yes.
6,375. What doors were blown to the south? — None.
6,376. Were no doors here blown south? — No, not near the shaft.
6,377. Where were the doors then that were blown south? — There were many doors blown south.
6,378. I mean, on the in-take here was there any door blown south? — Those doors leading to No. 3 shaft were blown south.
6,379. Leading to No. 3 shaft, here? — No, not exactly those.
6,380. That is what I meant ; I have got it wrong on my note. The doors leading to No. 3 shaft were blown south? — Yes.
6,381. Would not that be more consistent with the explosion having taken place in No. 3 Hutton? — Not at all.
6,382. Why not? — It would just do the same thing coming the other way.
6,383. You mean, owing to the vagaries of the explosive current and where it would wander? — It wanders to the upcast shaft, and it would go that way, wherever it originated.
6,384. It would be a turn, but the doors would be more easy to be blown southward, if the explosion took place in No. 3 Hutton, than it would be if the explosion took place elsewhere? — I should think it quite the reverse under the circumstances.
6,385. Why? — It is a much easier road from No. 1 than from the other pit by that way.
6,386. But supposing the explosion had taken place here (pointing), would it not be more likely that the doors should have been blown down, than if the explosion had taken place elsewhere, and travelled along here? — No; I should not think that at all; it might perfectly, possibly happen by an explosion taking place here (pointing), those doors being blown by. That is a very narrow passage between there (pointing), a very narrow road indeed.
6,387. But there is a turn? — It is a very narrow road indeed; it is not more than four feet wide.
6,388. There is an overcast here, is there not? — There is an overcast.
6,389. What was the condition of things here? — It was blown right and left.
6,390. Blown right and left into the returns? — Yes. What I meant was that it would be an easier road from that shaft to this shaft (pointing).
6,391. Now, I just want to take you to Venner's shot. You said something about there being an appearance of one of the refuge holes in course of operation, the stone having been cleared away? — One was cleared away entirely.
6,392. Which one was that? — I am told it was where Hudson was working.
6,393. What did you find in Venner's place? — I think it had begun to be cleared away too.
6,394. But there was a great deal of stone lying there? — Yes, there was a good deal of stone there.
6,395. Was there an accumulation of coal dust there, by-the-bye? — No; very little I should say.
6,396. Was there coal dust to be found on the rafters? — There were very few there.
6,397. But there was coal dust there? — Well, I do not know. You may assume that there would be a little dust, no doubt.
6.398. Then generally I may take it that the course of the explosion is so eccentric, and the way in which the explosion travelled is so utterly unaccountable, that you are not prepared to give any definite opinion as to where the explosion took place. That is the result? — Yes, that is the result.
6,399. (Mr. Edge.) My friend has suggested to you a difficulty. Assuming for the moment that the explosion came from No. 1 Hutton, he suggested a difficulty to you about its going down the engine plane into the Maudlin seam, and what he calls "turning round a corner," as if it were a horse. There would be the same difficulty, I suppose (if there is one), if the explosion had come from No. 3 Hutton; and if there is any difficulty in it, it would have the same difficulty in getting down the travelling way? — Yes.
6,400. The same point would apply whichever way you get the explosion? — Yes.
6,401. (The Coroner.) This may be on the notes, but I want it for myself. Did the in-bye symptoms at the temporary stable in the travelling way cease, or how far did it progress along the travelling way? — About 90 yards in-bye, and then stopped.
6,402. Stopped 90 yards beyond the stable? — Yes.
6,403. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Is it not rather singular that at the particular place in the mine where you think there was an explosive, there was a particular kind of coal dust, say round the curve (pointing), close to the place where Brown's shot was fired; does it not rather point to some connection between the explosion and the coal dust? — I should think not, because, as I have already said, the indications were all one way past Brown's shot. They all go up; none of them come down as that would have done if that had been the centre.
6,404. You going still upon the indications out of No. 1, instead of into it. If you can remove your mind for a moment from those indications, do so? — From this point (pointing) all the indications point westward, none eastward. We cut this pit off entirely.
6,405. From Brown's shot all the indications point westward? — There is a centre here (pointing) where you have indications both ways from it, in the drift itself.
6,406. Is it not correct to say "from Brown's shot all the indications from the westward and that for a few yards to the east of Brown's shot, you cannot say which way the indications are?" — Yes, all west.
6,407. Then you think the centre of the indications is a spot in the curve? — There is no doubt it is so — in the curve.
6,408. And that is the only place in the mine where this kind of coal dust occurs? — Yes, that is so.
6,409. Does that kind of coal dust extend on at all in the direction of Venner's shot? — No, none of it reached Venner's shot whatever, not an atom.
6,410. About how far along past Brown's shot did that kind extend? — It is a diminishing quantity ; it lessens as the air current deposits it, but then the dust on the engine plane is cleared away; this road (pointing) is not clear.
6,411. Did you observe after the explosion whether the particular sort of coal dust you were mentioning in the curve had been to any extent burnt? — I think it had been burnt as far as my opinion goes, but I have not analysed it.
6,412. Partially burnt? — Yes.
6,413. Were any samples sent to Professor Abel from there? — I do not know; I was not here.
6,414. It is specially dangerous to have dust there, is not it? — It has not been considered dangerous.
6,415. Supposing you were still in the management of the mine, should you think it desirable to alter it? — It would be desirable to have it cleaned up.
6,416. Either cleaned up or watered? — I should think so.
6,417. Judging by what you know now, should you think it dangerous to leave it? — No, I should not think it dangerous — I would take it up as a precaution.
6,418. Supposing there were another shaft put down in the Maudlin? — Where from?
6,419. Suppose there were an Act of Parliament to say you must have another shaft under the circumstances, where would you put the shaft within the Maudlin? — You must consider the question of the surface as well.
6,420. Never mind the precise position ; supposing there were another shaft sunk, would it, as a matter of fact, have enabled the men to escape? — I should say not.
6,421. Will you state your reasons for thinking it would not, if it would not? — The reasons are, we have two shafts here now. The explosion originated in one pit and extended to another one, and we find that the men were lost in all the pits. It must have originated in one of the three, and they were lost in all three.
6,422. You say the mere addition of a shaft would not have enabled them to escape? — No, because the in-takes becoming foul, the men are poisoned. We had proof of that in No. 2 pit. The explosion simply passed the shaft and there was sufficient stythe and after-damp went down to affect the men very much indeed.
6,423. Would it have to be a separate pair of shafts? — It would have to be an entirely different set of workings to do any good.
6,424. (The Coroner.) Take the case of the Maudlin, where you knew men were alive for some time after? — I do not think that would have made any difference.
6,425. Why, if they were alive twenty-four hours afterwards? — The in-takes become poisoned, the air becomes unfit to respire, and, no matter where they are, if that air gets to them they will be killed. They lived so long for the simple fact that the explosion destroyed the ventilating apparatus, and they were living upon the magazine of fresh air that existed in the pit. If the current had got to them they would have been killed in a minute.
6,426. By the force? — By the simple poison.
6,427. The exhaustion of the air? — Yes.
6,428. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Taking the travelling way into the Maudlin, the northern part of that travelling way was choked with falls after the explosion? — Yes.
6,429. The southern part of the curve was not choked? — No.
6,430. In the southern part of the travelling way that was not choked, there were some timbers moved, were there not? — No, there were no timbers.
6,431. I am told that there were some timbers there; are you positive that there were not? — I am not positive that there was no timber; there were bricks. I think I told you about the bricks myself.
6,432. I beg your pardon, it is bricks and not timber; there were some bricks moved in that part? — They were moved a very short distance.
6,433. But such indication as it is, whether worth much or little, it shows those bricks were moved outbye from the Maudlin? — That is true.
6,431. And not as if they had been blown by a blast coming from No. 1 Hutton? — That is quite true.
6,435. (Mr. Jones.) I wish to ask do you know the main coal staple? — Yes.
6,436. How is that ventilated? — It stands on the in-take.
6,437. How is it ventilated? — It is ventilated by the air passing.
6,438. You know the main coal staple goes up to the main coal from No. 3 Hutton? — Yes.
6,439. Is the ventilation from No. 3 Hutton entirely? — No, the ventilation comes from the main coal principally ; it stands in two in-takes ; there is an intake top and bottom of it; it is simply a passage between two in-takes.
6,440. Do you mean to say that it is ventilated at all times both from No. 3 Hutton and from the main coal? — Yes.
6,411. Do you consider that a safe mode of ventilation? — Certainly.
6,442. You do? — It is the same thing as having two in-takes.
6,443. Is it at all times so ventilated? — It is just doubling your in-take, that is all; just like having two parallels with a passage between.
6,444. I am only asking this: is there not a danger when the staple is so ventilated, that the air at the bottom of the staple may stagnate? — Oh, no, not a bit, not the slightest
6,445. Supposing there is a greater velocity of air current, I suppose the same laws govern it to a very large extent as govern water. Supposing there is a greater velocity of air in the main coal than in No. 3 in-take, would it not necessarily follow that the air in No. 3 in-take may stagnate at the bottom? — Oh, no, not at all.
6,446. You answer that definitely and precisely? — Under the circumstances it is impossible.
6,447. What circumstances? — As it was. Of course, you are asking me where it was?
6,448. I am taking this, the position is very clear, the Maudlin staple, the summit of the staple in the main coal in-take, base of the staple, in-take of No. 3 Hutton, velocity of air greater in the main coal in-take than in No. 3 Hutton in-take ; its a necessary consequence, would not the air be likely to stagnate at the base of the staple? — No, very unlikely
6,449. What would be the result of such a condition of things? — The air would either come down or go up, as the case might be. If the air-way in the Maudlin is the larger of the two, the air would come down the staple; if the Hutton seam is the larger of the two the air would go up the staple. To establish a perfect balance is a thing I hardly believe could be done.
6,450. Would it not be that the air would be fighting one against the other? — Oh, no, mutually assist one another.
6,451. One is striking at the top, the point of contact being the top of the staple, and the other the bottom of the staple? — Just the same as two in-takes, the one helps the other.
6,452. If the air is coming down the staple it is meeting the air conning up the staple? — Not at all.
6,453. What is it then? — It is coming down the staple and going away.
6,454. Suppose its meeting another current of air? — How can you make it meet that way?
6,455. I understand from you — I do not want to press you unfairly — that this is on an in-take ; that the air is admitted into the staple indifferently from No. 3 Hutton, and also from the main coal; such being the case, there being this current going towards the staple, and one, as you say, coming down the staple, the other also rising up the staple? — It does not rise up the staple when the other one comes down. You are going back to the first principles of ventilation; the way we ventilate our place is by heating the up-cast shaft, it is by exhausting the air, and the air comes and finds its way; it goes the easiest way to the upcast.
6,456. I quite understand that it is as clear as possible; but the air for all that is travelling in the direction of the staple in No. 3? — Yes.
6,457. It is also in the main coal travelling in the direction of the staple there? — Yes.
6,458. That being the case, the air that is going along No. 3 in-take to the staple would come into contact with the air coming along the main coal down the staple? — Yes, the two currents would coalesce.
6,459. That is all I want; I suppose that would necessarily cause that the air which had the greatest velocity would conquer the other and drive it back? — No, it cannot be done; it is impossible.
6,460. What would be the effect? — They would both go on together in varying proportions.
6,461. Very well, I leave you there? — The two streams meet and go on together.
6,462. One stream would stop, and the other go on? — They go on in equal proportions, as much as will fill the air-way.
6,463. (Mr. Edge.) You know where Simpson's body was found? — Yes.
6,464. How far from that was Brown's shot? — About 20 yards.
6,465. Was there anything between the body and the site of Brown's shot? Was it round a curve? — I suppose he would be standing in the curve, there was nothing between — it was a straight line between.
6,466. Where he was found? — It was a straight line between Brown's shot and him.
6,467. May we take it he would not have been standing within 20 yards of the shot unless there was something between him and the shot? — It would be very unlikely.
6,468. He would only be round the curve, or in some place out of the direct line of the shot? — He would be round the curve for shelter.
6,469. If he were round the curve, of course he might have been blown into the position in which he was found? — I should assume that he had been blown westward.
6,470. That he had been blown from east to west? — Yes, that he had been blown across the curve to the other side of the road, from south to north, rather it is.
6,471. You told us yesterday about finding the rapper-rope round the tail rope against the sheaves: did you find those indications at each side east and west of Brown's shot? — Yes.
6,472. You were asked about the formation of the Seaham and Hutton Collieries: when did you first come to Seaham Colliery? — In the beginning of 1874.
6,473. Then you know nothing about that. My friend Mr. Jones has asked you about the lengths of the in-takes. When you gave the total lengths of the in-takes in No. 1 Hutton at 4½ miles, that included the in-take up to the far-off way, and the in-take up to the worth portion of the No. 3? — Yes, the aggregate in-takes.
6,474. It does not represent that it is actually 4½ miles from the No. 1 shaft to the face of the workings? — No.
6,475. (Mr. Bell.) That includes every separate split as well? — Yes.
6,476. (The Coroner.) Now I will ask the same question as I asked yesterday afternoon: is there anyone in Court who can speak to a man having been found dead, with indications that his lamp had been burning some time after he had fallen? — (No answer.)
(Mr. Edge.) I have got two gentlemen here who are on the board of directors, Mr. Foster and Mr. Hall; if you like I will call them now. In one way they are scientific witnesses, and, of course, I should prefer that we had had Professor Abel's report before we called a scientific witness.
(Mr. R. S. Wright.) We are all of us in a difficulty about that. I think, if you do not very much object, we had better go as far as we can to day; of course any scientific witness who is called can modify his opinion afterwards.
(The Coroner.) He can modify his opinion afterwards, if he should see occasion, when Mr. Abel's report is before the Court.
(Mr. Edge.) There are other scientific witnesses whom I believe we shall be in a position to call, but we shall not be able to call them at present.
(The Coroner.) We will take them as far as you can go.