Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Inquests Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Inquests
/   \

1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster

Inquest Report

Seaham Colliery Inquest, 7th January 1881 (cont.).

Mr. William Fairbairn Hall sworn.

6,709. (Mr. Edge.) Are you a mining engineer? — Yes.

6,710. How many years experience have you had in coal-mining? — 25 years in the management, and working as a boy in the pit.

6,711. You have had Haswell under your management? — Haswell and Ryhope.

6,712. Haswell and Ryhope — How far are they from this Seaham Colliery? — Ryhope adjoins it, and Haswell is about 7 miles from here.

6,713. What seams do you work in the Ryhope? Do you work this Hutton seam? — A little.

6,714. You were one of the board of directors who took the control after the explosion? — I was.

6,715. And did you explore the mine? — In connection with the inspectors and some others, the Tuesday after the explosion.

6,716. I will take you to one or two shafts, and then I intend to go along taking you the same way as I took Mr. Stratton and Mr. Forster; I suppose you agree with them that the bratticing of the shaft seemed to have been blown both ways? — Yes.

6,717. Blown inwards? — From what I saw of them.

6,718. Go along the No. 1 engine plane, did you notice that first crossing? — Yes.

6,719. What did you notice in respect to that? — They were busy repairing it. It had been blown out.

6,720. Did you notice the bricks at the crossing? — The bricks were about 30 yards from the crossing.

6,721. They had been blown out about 30 yards? — Yes; there was an arching there. I noticed the end of the arching where it finished, hay had been driven into the ends of the joints.

6,722. The indication of that hay would be that it was driven with considerable force? — Yes.

6,723. Going along south in-bye, what were the next indications that you saw? — Hay driven in-bye, choked in under the rollers along here (pointing.)

6,724. Did you notice the wall at the junction between the travelling way and the engine plane? — Yes.

6,725. What direction was that in? — It was driven, across the travelling way and also out-bye. A wall was driven over on the opposite side.

6,726. There was a fall beyond that? — If you take me to the travelling way I will tell you what I saw, and then come back here.

6,727. If you like I will do so? — We went in this way, and then worked back.

6,728. I will take you there if you like. We will go along the travelling way to the junction. Did you see any indications along there towards the junction, any distance in? — A little way in over.

6,729. What were those indications? — Going inwards a very short distance, and then we came down to the temporary stables here. Before getting to the temporary stables, we came upon some wood remains and other things, and we came here to the temporary stables, which had been cleared out. At the time, I believe, one stall had been made and the pony put into it, and then we came across the engine plane.

6,730. Going along the travelling way, before you arrived at the stables, did you find any indications coming out-bye? — Yes.

6,731. Then you came to the temporary stables? — Then we turned to the engine plane and examined that very carefully, and then we returned to the travelling-way. There was a cistern, which I understood here (pointing) ; that was blown into the stables.

6,732. Did you go in-bye through the travelling way further? — Yes; there was nothing further until we came down here.

6,733. The indications you saw there were in-bye? — Yes.

I do not know that I need pursue the travelling way further.

6,734. (Mr. Wright.) Except, perhaps, you will just ask him this. The whole way down the travelling way, were the indications on the whole in-bye or out-bye? — There was nothing but for a very short distance inwards on the travelling way until we came down here. When we came here, it was driven in this way.

6,736. Driven in-bye still? — Driven in this way.

6,737. (Mr. Edge.) You got into the plane there? — Yes.

6,738. Nearly opposite the third east? — Nearly opposite the third east.

6,739. How did you go then? — Out-bye. We first of all satisfied ourselves that the blast had gone in this way (pointing).

6,740. (Mr. Wright.) Gone in-bye? — Gone in-bye this way, and then gone here.

6,741. Gone in-bye towards the third east? — Yes; the winch was here and some wheels; and going out by the engine plane, the whole of the timber indicated the blast coming in this way.

6,742. Coming in-bye? — In-bye until we came here to the end.

6,743. (Mr. Edge.) Did the indications between which the winch was and the Polka way end show a great amount of force? — A serious disturbance, a great amount of force.

6,744. When you came to the Polka way end, what were the indications? — The indications were out-bye.

6,745. The indications at the Polka end and towards the No. 1 shaft you found going out-bye? — Yes.

6,746. Did you examine the fall which was between the Polka way end and the junction, where the travelling way takes off from the end of the plane? — Yes, I did.

6,747. Did that to your mind show any indications? — It indicated to my mind that that fall had taken place previously.

6,748. Previous to what? — Previous to an explosion. I do not know that it came from an explosion.

6,749. What was it that suggested to your mind (if there was an explosion there) that the fall had happened before the explosion? — The in-bye edges of the fall were all abraded as if you had shot something at them. They were marked.

6,750. Did you examine the out-bye edges of the fall? — Yes.

6,751. How were they? — They were not so clear. This was entirely clear at this end.

6,752. You mean the in-bye edges of the fall were clear as if something had brushed by them? — Yes.

6,753. And the out-bye edges were not so clear? — Yes.

6,754. Did you find any dust on the out-bye edges of the fall? — Yes; there was some dust on the outbye edges of the fall.

6,755. Do you mean right up to the top? — Not quite up to the top. At the end of it.

6,756. Before we pass away from that place, I merely put this to you as an assumption. If an explosion did take place at or about the Polka way end, did you see anything in that neighbourhood which was inconsistent with the theory of the explosion having taken place there? — The indications all pointed to there, in my opinion.

6,757. To that place? — Yes.

6,758. I will take you now round into No. 3. I do not know whether you know where Venner's shot was? — Somewhere here (pointing.) I am not very certain.

6,759. Just put your finger to the left, just where the stow-hole goes up (the witness did so). Do you agree with Mr. Foster in what he said, that going from that place — going from where Venner's shot was — along the old Hutton incline, that you first found indications out-bye, and then you afterwards found indications in-bye? — Yes, in the old Hutton incline I did.

6,760. Did you go into No. 3 Hutton? — Yes, I did.

6,761. Was it the south part of No. 3? — Down here (pointing).

6,762. Yes; that is the south part of No. 3? — Up to the return wheel; that is where it ended, I think. The side walls of this were blown out.

6,763. There are some figures on that plan showing the names of the men. Will you give us the figure where you say you saw the indications cease? — I do not know where the wheel stood now, but they ceased at the wheel.

6,764. Were those indications in-bye or out-bye? — In-bye.

6,765. We will go to the place where Venner's shot was. I will travel along eastwards from that. Did you see any material indications between that and where the No. 3 road turns off the main intake? — Here (pointing). They were blown into No. 3, the timbers. There was great confusion.

6,766. Still travelling along, you come to the Maudlin dock. Did you see any indications at the Maudlin dock? — Yes; the indications were that this wall was driven this way, and this wall was driven to the west.

6,767. The side wall of the Maudlin was driven southward, and the end wall westward? — The side wall was driven southward, and the end wall westward.

6,768. Then travelling eastward still along the intake, you come to the Maudlin? — Yes.

6,769. Do you agree with Mr. Foster that the indications of the Maudlin were that the force was from east to west? — The force was from east to west.

6,770. Then, travelling along down towards the curve, did you notice any indications there? — There was not any indication going down here, down to the curve, except the rapper-rope.

6,771. About the neighbourhood of the in-take to the north main coal, until you got down to the engine plane of the Maudlin, you say there were not many indications? — No, except the rapper-rope.

6,772. Was the place pointed out to you where it was said Brown's shot had been fired? — Yes.

6,773. Tell me what indications you found with regard to the rapper-rope? — It was twisted on the tail-rope. It had been doubled round in-bye over, and as it came to the sheave it was twisted round.

6,774. It was twisted round and driven forward until it met the sheave? — Yes.

6,775. Were those indications going eastward or westward? — Westward.

6,776. Did you find those indications on the rapper-rope at each side of where Brown's shot was? — Yes, going the same way.

6,777. If the explosion had taken place at Brown's shot, in your judgment would you have found such indications as you did find on the rapper-rope to the eastward of Brown's shot? — I do not think we would. They would have been blown westward.

6,778. We come to the engine plane of the Maudlin, where it takes off that main in-take; did you examine that? — Yes.

6,779. Did you notice the sheaves that were there just at the corner? — Yes, I did.

6,780. How were they? — They were driven westward, and the box that held the sheaves for the tail-rope were driven westward.

6,781. Just take that as the in-take (holding up a rough sketch), and take this as the engine plane of the Maudlin, and I want you to tell me about what position those sheaves were in? — The sheaves here (pointing)?

6,782. Yes? — They were driven that way.

6,783. You do not apprehend my question. I want to know about where was the actual position of the sheaves that you saw blown; were they at that corner, or were they up there?

(Mr. Wright.) We cannot tell on the note where that corner is ; we do not know what it means.

(Mr. Edge.) We will define it presently.

6,784. (Mr. Wright.) Were they at the corner, at the end, at the junction of the Maudlin plane to the curve? — Yes.

6,785. (Mr. Edge.) Exactly at the junction? — Yes.

6,786. The left-hand side? — The right-hand side going in, the left-hand side going out-the right-hand side as I went to No. 3 pit, the left hand side as I went to No. 1 pit.

6,787. Did you examine further down the engine plane? — To the Maudlin?

6,788. Yes? — Yes.

6,789. Did you notice the iron chain? — The chain on the rapper-rope was driven into the joints of the bricks about 16 inches.

6,790. Did that give you any indication as to how the explosion had gone in that place, wherever it came from? — Into the Maudlin.

6,791. Did you find any indications between where that Maudlin plane joins the main in-take and the travelling way down the Maudlin main in-take? — I did not see any indications until I came here (pointing).

6,792. What indications did you find there? — There was a large fall here.

6,793. (Mr. Wright.) At the junction of the Maudlin travelling plane with the curve? — Yes, there was a large fall here.

6,794. Between the junction and the shaft? — Yes, between the junction and the shaft. These doors were blown that way.

6,795. Towards the Maudlin? — Yes; and these doors were blown towards the furnace.

6,706. (Mr. Edge.) The furnace doors were blown towards the furnace? — Yes, these doors were blown towards the furnace.

6,797. Did you find all three of the upward openings damaged — I mean at Nos. 1 and 2 shafts, at No. 3 shaft, and at the manhole staple. Did you find considerable damage done by the explosion? — Yes.

6,798. Did that show that the explosion had been severe in the neighbourhood of all those places? — Yes.

6,799. It has been suggested that a shaft in the Maudlin might have been the means of saving the lives of the men who were in there? — I should think it might have been the means of having them dead before they were.

6,800. What is your experience of explosions, or the effects of shafts on explosions? — The explosion always makes its way to the shaft for relief. Supposing there had been a shaft down here (pointing), and if the ventilation had been entirely different, nobody can say what the result would have been. In my opinion those men would all have been killed.

6,801. Those men who were up there would all have been killed? — Yes.

6,802. Killed by force? — Killed by force and by after-damp.

6,803. That is your experience in these number of years? — Yes.

6,804. The explosions are drawn towards the shafts? — Yes.

6,805. You were one of the board of directors. I believe you and Mr. Foster received the report of Mr. Stratton of his discovery of fire in the Maudlin? — Yes, we were sent for.

6,806. That was on the Friday? — Yes, on the Friday night.

6,807. And I think you directed that all exploration should be stopped until the board was called together? — Yes.

6,808. I believe Mr. Stratton made a further exploration? — Yes.

6,809. And made a further report to you? — Yes.

6,810. On the Sunday night, was it not? — On the Sunday night.

6,811. What was the conclusion that you came to, as a practical man and a man of experience, with regard to there being a fire or not in the Maudlin seam? — From the report given to us by Mr. Stratton and Mr. Leasham, it was a fire of considerable magnitude, and that the safest thing to do was to have a consultation with other gentlemen, who perhaps had more experience than we had, and to see whether it was desirable to explore further or not. It was the unanimous opinion of the committee to seal the thing up, as it was highly dangerous and attended with imminent risk to explore further.

6,812. You mean there was no dissentient voice about it? — No.

6,813. It was the unanimous opinion? — Yes, it was the unanimous opinion.

6,814. Who were present when you decided to seal it up? — Mr. --------- Mr. Boyd, Mr. Johnson, Mr. Baker Foster, Mr. Lindsay Wood, Mr. Richard Foster, Mr. Leasham, myself, Mr. Stratton, Mr. Tomlinson, Mr. Corbett, and the inspectors.

6,815. Were the inspectors there? — Yes.

6,816. In the unanimous judgment of the committee, it would have been imminently dangerous to carry on the exploration? — Yes.

6,817. Imminently dangerous to the lives of the explorers? — Yes. I may say the inspectors were in the room, but they did not take any part in the discussion.

6,818. Acting on the best of your judgment, did you come to the conclusion that that must be sealed up? — Yes.

It has been suggested to my friend, Mr. Jones, that it might be practicable to open up the stopping some way, and send someone in.

(Mr. A. Jones.) I did not say to send someone in.

(Mr. Edge.) To open up the stopping?

(Mr. A. Jones.) To open up the stopping. It makes a very material difference.

6,819. (Mr. Edge.) What, in your judgment, would be the effect of opening up the stopping? — It would be very highly dangerous to do so.

6,820. If there was any fire smouldering there, I presume it would only fan the flame? — I suppose so.

6,821. And at the time you did seal it up, if the explorations had been carried on, the explorations would have been bound to carry air with them? — Yes.

6,822. And the more air you carry in the more you fan the flame, and the greater difficulty you would have in putting an end to it? — Yes.

6,823. I do not take the general opinion of the committee, but have you formed a judgment as to whether it would be dangerous at present to open out that stopping? — I should think it would be highly dangerous to open it out at present. We had a meeting about it some few weeks ago, and it was fixed to examine the whole place, and the low main workings as well. It was found there was a communication between the low main and the Maudlin. Consequently, by that time the thing had been getting some fresh air, and there have been some seals put in since to effectually seal it up.

6,824. You mean you have learned within the last three or four weeks or so that there had been an access of fresh air to a portion of it? — Yes.

6,825. And you sealed it up finally? — Yes.

6,826. And, of course, the object of sealing it up finally is to shut off the air, and exhaust the air? — Yes.

6,827. As the result of your experience, when do you say it would be safe to open out the Maudlin seam? I think it would be highly dangerous to open it under four or five months since the last seals were put in.

6,828. That is another four or five months from this time? — Yes.

6,829. The Maudlin seam was sealed off, I think, on the 3rd October? — It was sealed off on the 3rd October.

6,830. Was it possible for any man to be alive in the Maudlin seam at that time? — Not one.

(Mr. Atkinson.) It is three weeks. They would all have died of starvation.

6,831. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Have you had much personal experience in observing the effects of explosions in coal mines? — No, fortunately not.

6,832. Is this the first one on which you have formed an opinion? — This is the first explosion that I have been in.

6,833. In this case you did not go down until a week after the explosion? — Yes, a week after.

6,834. When most of what one may call the lighter indications had been removed? — I do not think so. I do not think anything had been removed.

6,835. That is your impression? — Yes. I am not aware of it.

6,836. You are not aware that any of the ways had been cleared in the interval? — I do not think any of the ways had been cleared in the interval; they were busy clearing them, but they had not cleared them.

6,837. You are not aware that any timbers had been removed? — I do not think they had.

6,838. You are not aware that any bricks had been removed? — Yes, bricks had been removed from this crossing.

6,839. You are not aware that any hay had been removed? — No.

6,840. In fact, I may take it that your knowledge is extremely slight as to what the state of the mine was immediately after the explosion? — Immediately after the explosion it was very slight indeed until I went down.

6,841. You have had no previous experience of any such explosion? — Not such an explosion as this.

6,842. Your mind being a blank as to what the state of the mine was immediately after the explosion, do you undertake to say that the explosion was from the direction of No. 1 Hutton pit — the Polka? — From the indications I have seen, the balance of the indications was in favour of that.

6,843. I do not ask you that. I ask you, do you undertake to say, balancing what you did not see and what you did not know against what you did see of the indications, that the blast came out from No. 1 Hutton? — According to the indications I saw there, my opinion is so ; but I will not undertake to fix the seat.

6,844. Taking into account all that you did see, that is your opinion? — I have taken every indication I have seen into consideration, and thought over it, and I cannot find any place more likely than that.

6,845. I think I can understand you now. Merely judging from what you saw, the balance of your opinion is in favour of the Polka, but you cannot undertake to give any opinion on the subject? — No.

6,846. So much for that. You said if a shaft had been put down in the Maudlin it would rather have increased the men's danger than otherwise? — That is so.

6,847. What do you mean; do you mean an upcast or a downcast shaft? — It would depend on what it was.

6,848. Which do you say? — Either.

6,849. Supposing there is a staple into the Harvey, right at the top; there is a staple into the Hutton, it is what you call the Harvey? — I have not been there.

6,850. Assume there was a downcast there, will you explain how the downcast there would increase the danger to the men shut up in the Maudlin? — Directly an explosion took place it would go to that shaft to relieve itself.

6,851. Whether it was a downcast or an upcast? — Yes, whether it was a downcast or an upcast.

6,852. Supposing there was a downcast there, how would the ventilation have been arranged? — The pit perhaps would not have been worked in that way.

6,853. You say in any way that it could have been worked the danger would have been increased? — Yes.

6,854. If there had been an upcast, do you say in whatever way the ventilation could have been arranged it would have increased the danger? — In my opinion it would be so.

6,855. You say that nothing but making the Maudlin a separate pit with an additional pair of shafts would have diminished the danger? — It is one of the best managed collieries I have seen in my time.

6,856. I am not putting that to you, but I say, in your opinion, nothing short of making the Maudlin a separate pit with two separate shafts would have diminished the danger? — Quite so.

That is a fair answer.

6,857-8. (Mr. Edge.) That is of course on the assumption that there was no communication between the two? — Yes.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Quite so ; making it a separate colliery really. That is his answer. That is the only thing which would have diminished the danger.

6,859. Where was the Clanny lamp, or where was the body found that had the Clanny lamp? — Just about here (pointing).

6,860. Is it figure 32?

(Mr. Edge.) It is No. 32.

6,861. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) At any rate, that is a good bit in-bye of the fall at which you suggest the gas came up? — No.

6,862. What is your suggestion, then, as to how the gas got there? — I cannot tell.

6,863. You have not any opinion as to how the gas got there? — Oh, yes, I have; it is possible it may have got to that hole.

6,864. What is your theory; where did it come from? — That is what I cannot exactly find out — to fix that seat of the explosion.

6,865. You quite follow the importance of following the two questions — first, at what place the indications show the explosion happened at; and, secondly, how the gas got there, if it was there? — I cannot tell you that.

6,866. You have no opinion? — No.

6,867. Do you think it is at all probable that the explosion came from such a fall as that? — It is possible.

6,868. Probable, I ask you. Will you answer that question? — It is possible; I will not say it is probable.

6,869. You will not say it is probable? — No.

6,870. What is the conclusion or the inference that you derive from the fact that one side of the fall had been brightened, I think it was? — I did not say brightened. I said abraded as if it had been shot at. It was marked on the edges as if something had struck it.

6,871. What do you think could have struck it? — It must have been some small stones.

6,872. Was it generally abraded in that way? — It is some time ago since I examined it, therefore I cannot carry my memory back, but it was a considerable abrasion.

6,873. Can you at all account for a considerable number of small stones having been run against it? — If the force came out that way it might do so.

6,874. Might not the explanation be that the outbye edges had been blackened? — It might be.

6,875. Have you ever seen a fall of stone brightened up on one side by an explosion? — Seeing this was the first explosion, I have not.

6,876. I think we may take it as a matter of conjecture on this point, may we not? — Yes.

6,877. I am not questioning your experience as a colliery manager, but on this point it maybe so taken? — Just so.

6,878. From the position of the rapper rope, and no other indication that you mentioned, you draw a conclusion, as I gather it, that the explosion could not, or probably did not occur at the point of Brown's shot. Am I correct in stating that? — Yes, I think so.

6,879. Will you explain why you draw that conclusion from the mere fact of the twisting of the rapper rope — if the explosion had occurred at Brown's shot what would you have expected — how would it have affected it? — The probabilities are that it would have gone to the No. 1 or the No. 3.

6,880. What would have gone? — The force of the explosion.

6,881. But the rapper rope — how would that have affected the rapper rope? — You would not have seen it; it would not have been there probably.

6,882. Would not that equally apply if the explosion had been 50 yards away to the east of Brown's shot? — That I cannot say.

6,883. I am only asking you to speak from the indications you saw? — I saw the indications going from east to west.

6,884. You infer from the fact that the rapper rope was twisted on both sides of the sheave, that the explosion could not have been at Brown's shot? — Twisted in the same way.

6,885. Twisted in the same direction? — Yes.

6,886. You infer from that that it could not have happened at Brown's shot? — Yes.

6,887. It would have come out further in the Maudlin direction? — It would have come out further in the Maudlin direction, and in this direction (pointing).

6,888. From what other direction? — Round here.

6,889. From round the curve? — Yes.

6,890. If it had come round the curve it would have struck the rapper rope just by Brown's shot? — Yes.

6,891. Just by the curve; it would have struck it there? — Yes.

6,892. At the junction of the curve and the engine plane? — Yes.

6,893. Was not the rapper rope twisted in the same direction both sides at that point? — No. I say it was twisted over towards the Maudlin engine plane.

6,894. Was it not twisted over in the same direction at the curve where it joined the engine plane? — I could not say to a yard or two, but I say I saw it twisted up this way by Brown's shot.

6,895. Was not the same kind of twist continued on further east than Brown's shot? — Here is Brown's shot (pointing). I could not tell you to a few yards one way or the other; but what I did see was twisted up this way.

6,896. How far east do you think beyond Brown's shot the same twisting of the rapper rope continued? — I could not tell you.

6,897. It did not continue at all here (pointing)? — Yes, it did.

6,898. How far did you observe the rapper rope east of Brown's shot, do you think? — As I did not measure it I could not tell.

6,899. How far about? — I should say half way between the two places, if not more.

6,900. Do you mean half way between Brown's shot and the junction, or half way between Brown's shot and something else? — Yes.

6,901. You say that such twisting of the rapper rope could not have happened if the explosion had taken place at Brown's shot? — I do not think it could have been done so regular from where it commenced.

6,902. We may take that in conjunction with your previous happy inexperience of explosions? — Just so, of course.

6,903. Apart from your knowledge of explosions, you have had great experience as an engineer or colliery manager? — I have a little.

6,904. I will ask you from your experience, which is a very long one, I believe, and considerable? — 25 years.

6,905. And from your knowledge of this colliery and what you have heard in this room, have you formed a favourable or an unfavourable opinion of the management of the colliery as a whole? — I think the management of the colliery is very efficient indeed.

6,906. And the discipline of the men? — The discipline of the officials?

6,907. No, the men? — All that I can say of the men is this: I had a great deal to do with them from the 8th, and for three weeks after that, and never one of them said "no" to any question, asking them to go down the pit, they were always very willing to do anything; that is all I can say of them.

6,908. Have you got the Hutton vein in the Haswell and Ryhope collieries? — Yes.

6,909. Are they dusty collieries? — Not very much so.

6,910. Have you any views yourself about coal dust, either as a cause or an aggravation of an explosion of gas? — I believe it will aggravate one, but that it will not itself explode.

6,911. You never heard of its causing an explosion itself? — No.

6,912. You have never heard of it? — No. I saw some experiments attempted with it the other day, but they could not get it to explode.

6,913. (Mr. Edge.) Just tell us about those experiments? — It was at Harton.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) It is getting rather wide to go into that.

(Mr. Edge.) We shall have it on Professor Abel's report, no doubt.

6,914. (Mr. R. S. Wright to the witness.) Are you aware where the cabin-man Laverick was found? — I am aware where the cabin was.

6,915. Supposing the explosion had come out of No. 1 shaft, would it not have blown straight into his cabin? — I should think it did.

6,916. Would it not do so? — It did.

6,917. Then I will say "it did," if you like, Mr. Hall; as it did go in, would you not have expected him to be blown to pieces by it? — It would depend upon where he was.

6,918. If it went straight in, would you expect it where he was? — Yes; he might have been lying down.

6,919. Is it not conjecture? — No, no conjecture at all; the iron doors were driven 25 yards through. I think a piece 2 feet square went through an 18 inch one like as though it were brown paper; I saw it, so there is no conjecture about it.

6,920. Do you think Laverick could have stood what the iron doors could not? — Well, his position was everything.

6,921. (Mr. A. Jones.) Just let me understand; you said in answer to my friend, Mr. Edge, that a shaft in the Maudlin might have men die before they did? — Yes.

6,922. What do you mean by that? — The explosion in getting to the shaft would have come upon these men in all probability.

6,923. Why should the explosion have got to the shaft? — Because the explosion would make to the shaft to get relieved.

6,924. Then you disagree with what was stated by a former witness, you mean that the shaft would act as a conductor to the explosion? — No; I do not know what sort of conductor it would be, but it would make to the place where it would be relieved.

6,925. Let me clearly understand. What you mean is this, that the fact of the shaft being there would cause the explosion to travel further? — It would travel to where it could get relief.

6,926. Do you mean that? — I mean that it would travel to where it could get relief, and that would be at the shaft.

6,927. Answer my question? — That is an answer.

6,928. Do you mean that the fact of the shaft being there would cause the explosion to travel further than it otherwise would? — Yes.

6,920. Then it would act as a conductor? — I do not say it would act as a conductor ; it would go to where it would be relieved.

6,930. Are you aware of the fact that the explosion did not extend further than the turn in the in-take — you see the turn in the in-take at the Maudlin seam? — Which seam are you at?

6,931. I am taking the Maudlin, of course; you see the turn of the in-take? — It extended to here (pointing).

6,932. You are aware, at any rate, that it did not reach further than that? — No, it did not.

6,933. Supposing you had put a shaft north of that, as far as the extreme limit of the workings would allow it to be put, would the effect of that shaft having been there have been such as to have caused the explosion to have travelled further? — If the shaft had been there it would have gone up that shaft, and these unfortunate men would have been killed earlier, before it got to the shaft.

6,934. I do not think you understand my question, perhaps it is my fault? — Yes, I do.

6,935. Here (pointing) is the turn in the Maudlin? — Yes.

6,936. The main in-take? — Yes.

6,937. I put the shaft there (pointing)? — Yes.

6,938. Would the effect of the shaft being there — having in view the present working of the colliery (I just arbitrarily place it there) — have caused the explosion to travel further? — The ventilation would have been entirely differently arranged, and it would have gone entirely up the shaft, and if these men had been where they were, it would have gone over them.

6,939. What you mean by the ventilation being differently arranged, I understand to be this — you would continue the in-take up to the shaft's base? — Most certainly.

6,940. Supposing the in-take was not continued up to the shaft's base, but that the in-take remained as it was, and this shaft was there, having no communication with the in-take — would there then have been any reason why it should have travelled further? — What would have been the use of your shaft?

6,941. As a natural air way? — Then you have no in-take to it.

6,942. I quite assume that? — But you want it.

6,943. I quite assume that also. You are aware, upon the evidence that has been given, that No. 1 Hutton was explored by means of the natural air? — What do you call the "natural air?"

6,944. By no artificial means; no fictitious cause; no furnaces at work? — I beg your pardon, there was an artificial cause.

6,945. What was it? — There was the heat of the shaft, which would have continued for weeks after, or we would not have been able to have gone into the pit.

6,946. Do you really mean that the heat of the shaft for some weeks after enabled you to descend the pit? — Yes, I do.

6,947. I am not questioning that; I will not question any of your statements. But, apart from the heat of the shaft, do you mean that there might not be a natural current of air into the colliery without the heat of the shaft? — There might have been if the shafts were cool, but they were not; one shaft was hot and the other was cold.

6,948. Do you mean to say this — that without any heat in the up-cast shaft ---?

(Mr. Willis.) But there was heat.

6,949. (Mr. A. Jones.) Assuming there to be no heat, do you mean to say there would not be a natural current of air? — There might be from the heat given off by the coal being worked, but it would be very trifling.

6,950. As far as the ventilation is concerned, do you mean to say the shaft would have been of no value? — It would be of no value if you had an in-take to it.

6,951. Suppose I take it away from the in-take, and supposing I admit that the shaft gives no ventilation whatever, either natural or otherwise. You are aware that the men lived in this portion of the Maudlin for some time afterwards? — Yes.

6,952. Upon the air that remained in it? — Yes, they did.

6,953. If there had been a shaft here (pointing), those men who were in this part of the Maudlin would have been able to have escaped by that shaft? — I do not think they would.

6,954. Why not? — I tell you they would have been killed by the explosion going up that shaft, that is if there had been an in-take to it, you know.

6,955. You do not follow my question. My question was this: Assuming there was no in-take to it, that you simply had a shaft merely as an outlet? — Then what is the use of your shaft — tell me, what is the use of your shaft?

6,956. Will you listen to the question? Assuming there was a shaft merely as an outlet for the men to escape by — as a sort of staple — in that case would not the men who were imprisoned here have been able to escape by it? — There would have been no communication.

6,957. There would have been no communication with what? — With the shaft.

6,958. No communication between what? — You say "assume that there is no in-take and no nothing."

6,959. No, not "no nothing." I am simply supposing a shaft there in communication with the returns and working places. I say suppose there was a shaft, simply in communication with the returns and working places, would not the men so have been able to escape? — No.

6,960. Why not? — The men would have been killed because the force of the explosion would have gone to that shaft, and in all probability killed then there sooner than they were.

6,961. You misunderstand me? — I am not misunderstanding; I am trying to understand you, Mr. Jones, but I have great difficulty in doing so.

6,962. The explosion, you admitted a few minutes ago, would only have travelled there by means of the in-take? — My admission is only so far as now is concerned ; put the pit shaft there and it is then entirely different.

6,963. I am not putting the fresh shaft in communication with the in-take; I am putting the fresh shaft there totally independent of the in-take? — You are putting it on the returns. Is that what you want to be at?

6,964. Yes, putting it on to the returns? — Very well ; now let us see.

6,965. If the explosive current was to come along here (pointing), would not the men — the explosive current having stayed here at this turn in the in-take? — It would not do that.

6,966. But it did? — But the circumstances would be entirely different with a shaft.

6,967. Why? — It would knock out the stoppings and disarrange everything at once.

6,968. Why? — You could get to the shaft without making communications with that, and it would knock out the stoppings immediately.

6,969. You are begging the whole question? — I am not begging the whole question at all; I am only telling you the result of the practical pit working.

6,970. I say sinking a shaft there — independently of all the in-takes — only having connection with the returns and working places — assuming that the intakes were in precisely the same position, and that the air was fed from this shaft down here — No. 1 and No. 2? — Very well.

6,971. Now I say, what would there have been under those circumstances to prevent the men who were safe on this side of the curve escaping up that shaft? — You are assuming that there is to be a communication with that by the returns.

6,972. By the returns? — It would have blown out the stoppings and killed those men.

6,973. I quite understand what you mean; you say this, that it would have passed from the in-take into the returns and proceeded to the shaft? — It would have knocked the stoppings out, as it did in this case knocked the doors out, &c.

6,974. Do you pledge yourself to the position? — I give it as my opinion, and I believe it.

6,975. Are you aware that the up-cast shaft was not much damaged? — The up-cast shaft was very much damaged.

6,976. The ventilation was never stopped in it, was it? — No, it was not; it was not blocked up.

6,977. And you are aware the men went down the up-cast the day of the accident? — Yes, seeing that I am one of those who instructed them in getting the men out.

6,978. Therefore you have the fullest means of knowledge? — Yes.

6,979. That shaft, of course, was in very close proximity to the source of the explosion, wherever it was? — I do not know that.

6,980. I mean so far as the theories which you have heard with regard to the explosion are concerned, that shaft was comparatively near? — It might have been; I do not know.

6,981. Having that in view you would still adhere to the opinion that a shaft in the Maudlin would be an additional source of danger? — Yes.

6,982. What limit do you draw to the extent of the in-takes, having reference to the extent of in-takes and returns, that the colliery should be worked with only one up-cast and one down-cast shaft? — Three to four thousand acres if the shafts are efficient.

6,983. I may take it, I suppose, that the difficulty of ventilation will increase with the extent of the workings above a certain area? — Not a great deal, if you attend to them properly.

6,984. Is there not a difficulty with regard to bringing the returns over such a wide area? — No ; all you have to do is to make them large enough.

6,985. You say from 3,000 to 4,000 acres is the limit? — Well, I put it roughly in that way. I would not pledge myself to an acre or two — or twenty either.

6,986. (Mr. Bowey.) Or a thousand? — Nor a thousand.

6,987. (Mr. A. Jones.) I understand you to say three or four thousand acres? — Yes, roughly.

6,988. That is including all the seams? — Including all the seams. Not, if you please, if you are going to put them in three here and three there (pointing), and make them six and nine. I mean the area of the whole thing.

6,989. Supposing there are six seams, and an area of 3,000 or 4,000 acres to each seam, you would say that was safe colliery working? — I think so.

6,990. And you think that no additional security would be afforded to the men by having any additional shafts, either for the purpose of ventilation, or merely for the purpose of escape? — Certainly not, not in a properly conducted colliery.

6,991. Are you aware that in some collieries they do have shafts or staples merely for the sake of escape? — No.

6,992. Without regard to ventilation? — No.

6,993. You are not aware of that? — No.

6,994. You never heard of it? — No.

(Mr. Edge.) Would you suggest where you put a question which is based on the supposition that such a thing exists, will you suggest where it exists?

(Mr. A. Jones.) I am not giving evidence.

(The Coroner.) You are not going to carry it any further, I suppose?

(Mr. A. Jones.) No, it is a fair enough question.

(Mr. Edge.) It is based upon the suggestion that such a thing exists.

6,995. (Mr. A. Jones.) Now with regard to the Maudlin, my friend asked you somewhat facetiously about going into the Maudlin; have you got any means of knowing now whether there is a fire existent in the Maudlin or not? — We have no means but experience of these things and opinion of the whole thing. The seams are very friable seams, the roof is a very friable roof, and the thill is a coal thill.

6,996. Very possible there is no fire there now? — It is possible that there is a fire there now.

6,997. It is possible either way? — I would not like to say, but I believe there is a fire.

6,998. Is it possible (as far as there is any means) to ascertain? — As far as there is any means, you cannot ascertain, it is only a question of time.

6,999. What I asked a former witness was this: I merely ask for the information of the men and for the information of the public generally — would it be a matter of very imminent danger to make any opening into these stoppings for the purpose of discovering whether or not a fire existed? — Do you mean for someone to go through the stoppings?

7,000. No, I do not say go through, but to make an opening into it? — Inasmuch as you would immediately afford a vent, and the only vent to that Maudlin seam in the event of its being opened, there would be danger.

7,001. If there was a fire there a great amount of heat would come out would it not? — There would be some heat, it might be a mile or three-quarters of a mile in-bye.

7,002. No heat at the commencement? — Not immediately behind the stoppings.

7,003. What would you find immediately behind the stoppings if they were opened? — The gas.

7,004. I ask you this, as a skilled engineer, there being no heat as you say ---? — I did not say there was no heat.

7,005. Not any amount, in contiguity to the stoppings? — Yes.

7,006. Would there be imminent danger in opening the stoppings to a sufficient extent to ascertain whether there was fire there or not? — I do not see what good you could get by opening the stoppings; you could not see the fire at all, and there would be the imminent danger of driving the air into the fire.

7,007. That would be the danger? — That would be it.

7,008. That is to say, by opening the stoppings there would be the danger of increasing the fire? — Yes, and very probably causing a much greater explosion than there has been.

We want that for the sake of information upon the point, for the satisfaction of all. I am not attaching any blame to anyone. We only want to ascertain what the true state of facts is.

(Mr. Bell.) By doing it you would admit a sufficient quantity of air to quicken up the fire, and create another explosion.

7,009. (Mr. Edge.) Have you known the case of fire existing at the Heugh Hall Colliery for two or three years? — I believe it is existing at the present day.

7,010. Is that a place where it was stopped off? — Yes, 25 years ago. It is a very similar roof to the Maudlin seam here.

7,011. You have heard, I think, the evidence, that there is an average of 316,050 cubic feet of air, per minute, going into this mine? — Yes.

7,012. In your judgment is that sufficient to give ample ventilation to the mine? — Ample ventilation to the mine, and it is one of the best ventilated mines in the kingdom, I should think.

7,013. Of course in coming to your conclusion, as a practical man, as to where this explosion took place, there is difficulty on all sides of finding where the gas came from? — Yes, that is so, that is the difficulty I found when I went into it.

7,014. That is the difficulty in your mind anyhow? — Yes.

7,015. Assume, for instance, for a moment, that the gas exploded down towards No. 3, the main coal staple, would you have the same difficulty in finding out where the gas came from? — Yes.

7,016. (Mr. A. Jones.) Granted a certain fixed diameter of the shaft, by which the air descends, the larger the extent of the workings, the greater the velocity which would have to be introduced into the air current for the purpose of ventilating the increased workings? — Yes, it is all a question of power.

7,017. And I take it also that the danger of a colliery is increased to no small extent according to the velocity of the ventilating current? — I do not quite understand that question.

7,018. A powerful ventilating current is more dangerous than a weaker ventilating current? — Not that I am aware of. I will always try to get as much as I can.

7,019. Certainly as much volume, but is not there a difference between volume and velocity? — I do not know that there is.

7,020. If the velocity is increased by a choke then the danger would be increased? — Then it would be inefficient, you would not get the current.

7,021. As I put my question it is this, according to the area of the extent of the workings having a given diameter you have to increase the velocity? — Increase the size of your returns to get the volume and velocity.

7,022. You have to increase the volume of air, have you not? — Yes, by an increased power of furnace or something else.

7,023. That is, increased velocity? — Yes.

7,024. That increased velocity would mean increased danger? — No, certainly not; it would mean increased safety, I should think, if you could get the velocity.

7,025. There would be greater pressure put upon the workings? — Yes.

7,026. And greater friction? — Greater pressure.

7,027. And greater friction? — No, you would lessen your friction by making your workings large enough out-bye.

7,028. Then you would have to increase the size of your returns according to the additional velocity you put in? — Not at all. All you want to do is to increase the velocity of the air in the place you want to ventilate. Make that according to the Mines Regulation Act, and then you are all right.

We will deal with that hereafter.

(The Coroner.) I suppose, now we have exhausted the witnesses produced up to the present time, it is necessary to consider what time I ought to adjourn to, in order to receive Mr. Abel's report, and finish the three witnesses that Mr. Edge proposes to call, and any more witnesses that Mr. Jones may choose to call. I will make that adjournment to suit the bar as far as I possibly can. I should have liked myself to have finished at the present time without any adjournment, but as Mr. Abel's report is not ready, I cannot do that; therefore I do not think it very material whether we adjourn for a fortnight or a month. I would wish to say in reference to the opening of the Maudlin, that considering the expression of opinion of the mining engineers, I should certainly not take any responsibility upon myself as to ordering any examination or opening out of the Maudlin. The course I intend to adopt is to finish with the witnesses I have already spoken of, and conclude the enquiry before the Maudlin is opened — if it has not been opened before we again sit — with this view, that as soon as ever, after the Maudlin has been opened, the bodies are brought out, I will open a new enquiry to ascertain what was the condition of that portion of the mine beyond the sealed up portion. Then if anything arises to throw a different light upon the whole of the circumstances, and which might lead to a result other than what we arrive at on the present occasion, it might be all gone over again, but if it shows that nothing had occurred which was likely to be the cause of the explosion in this instance behind that sealed up portion, then it would only assume the nature of a formal enquiry, which might be closed as soon as the parties were satisfied.

Now, with reference to the adjournment, having spoken to Mr. Jones and Mr. Edge, we thought about the 9th of February would be the best time to adjourn to, taking all things into consideration, and to that time we will adjourn if it meets with your approval.

(Mr. A. Jones.) I think so, if it will suit the gentlemen of the jury.

(The Coroner.) Will that do, Mr. Wright?

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) I do not interfere, sir; if I can come, I will.

(Mr. Edge.) Then 9th February would suit me, and an earlier day would not suit me, and if we adjourn to a much earlier day there is a possibility of Professor Abel's report not being ready.

(The Coroner.) I cannot get any information as to that at present, except that it is not ready yet.

Adjourned till Wednesday the 9th February, at half-past ten o'clock.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print