Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Inquests Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Inquests
/   \

1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster

Inquest Report

Seaham Colliery Inquest, 6th January 1881.

The Londonderry Institute, Seaham Harbour, 6th January 1881.

Eighth Day.

Present:

Mr. R. S. WRIGHT, Barrister; Mr. BELL, Mr. WILLIS, and Mr. ATKINSON, representing the Home Office.

Mr. ATHERLEY JONES (instructed by Messrs. Bowey and Brewis) for the Miners' Union.

Mr. EDGE (instructed by Mr. H. B. WRIGHT) for the Marquis of Londonderry.

Mr. Thomas Henry Marshall Stratton sworn.

4,857. (Mr. Edge.) The exploration of the mine practically commenced on the 15th of September? — Yes.

4,858. Previous to that time you had been trying to get the men out and getting the pit shaft in order, to get the cage down? — Yes.

(The Coroner.) We had better have what he did on the 7th as shortly as you can give it.

(Mr. Edge.) I spoke to my friend, Mr. Wright, about it, and we thought we might leave that out.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) I agree that it is not necessary unless Mr. Jones wishes to enter into any detail.

(The Coroner.) Generally I would like to have it.

4,859. (Mr. Edge.) What time in the morning were you called on the 8th? — About 25 minutes past 2.

4,860. You went to the pit immediately? — Immediately.

4,861. To which pit did you go? — No. 1.

4,862. What was the condition of No. 1 pit at the surface when you got there? — There was a large quantity of dust ; the rappers were out of order ; they were what we term "cocks" in the local phrase.

4,863. You directed the engineman to put on steam, and you found the cage of No. 1 pit fast? — Yes.

4,864. Did you also find the cage in No. 2 pit fast? — Yes.

4,865. You say the rapper ropes were broken? — Yes.

4,866. I think you then sent a messenger for Copeland, the head viewer? — Yes.

4,867. From No. 2 pit did you go to No. 3? — Yes.

4,868. You sent for the engineman there? — he was not there at the time ; there was no engineman there in the night time.

4,869. Shortly after he came you brought the cage of No. 3 pit to bank? — Yes.

4,870. Did you find anything attached to the cage? — One of the guides was brought up with it. 4,871. Did you go back to Nos. 1 and 2 pits? — Yes.

4,872. And you got the engine ready? — As soon as we could.

4,873. You went down No. 2 shaft, I think, in a loop? — Yes.

4,874. Along with Copeland? — Along with Copeland.

4,875. Copeland went down in another loop along with you? — Yes.

4,876. When you had got down about half way you found that you could not make yourselves heard? — Yes, that is so.

4,877. You came to bank, and did you then get Wetherall and another man to descend? — Yes, Wetherall and Frank Bowston, the other shaft man.

4,878. I think you left a man about mid-way down the shaft for the purpose of communication with the surface? — Yes.

4,879. Did you and Wetherall get to the main coal? — Yes, we got to the main coal.

4,880. You got off there, and you found your men standing about? — We found some of the men there.

4,881. Were those the men who had been working the main coal seam? — Yes, they were all there.

4,882. Did you and Wetherall then go further down the shaft? — Yes, we went down as far as we could.

4,883. About how far had you gone down when you were stopped? — We must have got down to within a few yards of the cage top ; we got down to where the debris was collected upon the cage top.

4,884. Was the cage at the bottom of the shaft? — No, the cage was where it usually is ; it would be a stroke and a half of the engine from the baulk — about 33 yards from the bottom; that would be, I should say, 50 yards from the bottom.

4,885. Did you find the shaft blocked, and that you could not get down further? — It was blocked by the cage being there; all the stuff had collected on the top of the cage.

4,886. What did you do? — We came back.

4,887. You shouted? — We called repeatedly.

4,888. You got no answer? — No answer that we heard.

4,889. Then you came to the bank? — Yes.

4,890. After that did you the same morning go down with Mr. Atkinson, the assistant Government inspector? — Yes, and some other gentlemen — Mr. Leashman and Mr. Bailes.

4,891. You went down No. 2 shaft as far as the main coal? — Yes.

4,892. You left Copeland on the top of the cage about 70 fathoms from the bank? — Yes.

4,803. What was that for? — To communicate with the bank. I think the particular reason was we were going down two in a loop, and we did not care to go any further; we were in the same loop.

4,894. Did you and Mr. Atkinson, Mr. Leashman and Mr. Bailes go along the main coal to the main coal staple? — We did.

4,895. Did you see at the main coal, when you got there, any signs of damage? — Yes, we found everything in disorder in the main coal, the tubs thrown about, and one tub was thrown into the pit.

4,896. When you got to the main coal staple you found disorder? — It was all disorder.

4,897. In what state was the staple itself? — As far as we could judge from the top, there was nothing left to tell; it was completely gone away from the top; all the woodwork had sunk; one rope was still there, and the tub was still in the cage — a full tub — standing in the cage at the top.

4,898. Did you then go to No. 3 shaft? — Yes.

4,899. And then, I think, you came back in No. 2 shaft and returned to bank? — Yes.

4,900. You then arranged to get a kibble sent down No. 3? — Yes, that was when the guides were taken out. They took out the broken guides, and put a kibble in as soon as the broken guides were out.

4,901. And then, I think, you and Mr. Atkinson and Mr. Bailes went down in the kibble? — Yes.

4,902. How far did you go down? — We got into the kibble at the main coal and went in the kibble from the main coal to the bottom.

4,903. You went down in the kibble to the Hutton seam. Did you find some men in the bottom shaft No. 3? — Yes.

4,904. Men who were alive? — Yes.

4,905. Those were the men who had been working in No. 3 Hutton? — There were some of the Harvey men there, I think. I am not quite sure. I do not know who the men were at this moment. I did not ask them their names.

4,906. In what condition was the bottom of No. 3 shaft when you got there? — It was a complete wreck: all the woodwork was destroyed, and the rapper ropes were broken.

4,907. From the bottom of No. 3 shaft I think you went along by the Maudlin pit in that direction? — Yes.

4,908. There are some doors near the Maudlin entrance: just point out the course you took: start at No. 3 shaft? — We went in this direction (pointing).

4,909. Then you came to the Maudlin pit? — Yes, those are the doors.

4,910. In what direction were those doors blown? — Towards No. 3 shaft.

4,911. Did you find a fall of the roof close to the doors? — Yes, there was a heavy fall close there.

4,912. (The Coroner.) In-bye or out-bye side? — When you are dealing with two shafts it is awkward to say "in-bye" or "out-bye." The fall was to the direction of No. 1 shaft, on the No. 1 side of the doors.

4,913. From No. 1 shaft? — It was on No. 1 side of those doors.

4,914. (Mr. Edge.) Did you find Brown's body? — We found him lying on the side of the road.

4,915. In what position? — On his back, with his head towards No. 1 pit, about a foot and a half from the road.

4,916. Was he near a refuge hole? — Just in front of it.

4,917. I what direction were his feet? — He was lying parallel with the rails.

4,918. His feet in the direction of No. 3. pit and his head towards No. 1? — Yes.

4,919. Where were his tools? Did you see them? — Yes.

4,920. Where were they? — To the best of my recollection they were about 8 or 10 yards on the No. 1 side, the place he had been working at.

4,921. How close to what may be called Brown's shot was Brown's body? — About 20 yards on the No. 3 side.

4,921a. Were the tools standing against the wall? — They were all standing against the wall.

4,922. Were Brown's clothes on fire at the time? — Oh, no, they were not on fire then.

4,923. What condition was he in? — He was much burned.

4,923a. Did his clothes show traces of fire? — Yes, I should say they did; his clothes were burned, and his beard burned off.

4,924. Did you at the time examine Brown's shot? — No.

4,925. Then I will take you to that at a subsequent period. You proceeded on from where you found Brown in the direction of No. 1 shaft? — Yes.

4,926. A little further along, at the junction of the Maudlin engine-plane on the curve, did you notice anything there? — We found the body of a man there.

4,927. That was Simpson, I think? — Yes.

4,928. He was Brown's marrow? — Yes.

4,929. He was assisting Brown preparing for the shot? — Yes.

4,930. Just describe the position in which you found Simpson's body? — Just at the mouth of that curve. There are two sheaves to guide the rope round the curve, and he was lying upon the lower of them, with his head towards the Maudlin, and his feet up the bank.

4,931. On which side of the road as you went towards No. 1 pit was Simpson's body? — On the left side of the road.

4,932. Was he lying at all in the engine-plane of the Maudlin seam? — Yes; his feet were beyond the rails. He looked as though he had been driven up against the leg that supports the sheave. The sheaves have vertical legs from the bottom to the roof, and he appeared to have been driven against it.

4,933. Was that wheel in the engine-plane against the side of the engine-plane? — It was within a few inches of the side of the rail.

4,934. Was it on the left-hand side or the right-hand side of the Maudlin engine-plane? — The left-hand side as you go down.

4,935. From that you then went towards No. 1. Did you examine, on your way, No. 1 furnace? — Yes.

4,936. Point out No. 2 boilers? — (The witness pointed them out on the plan.)

4,937. How were the fires in the boiler? — The fires had been damped up, and they were still alight.

4,938. That is the boiler? — Yes.

4,939. And the furnace fires? — The furnace was out. There were no coals to be seen, or very few, upon the bars; the bars looked clean.

4,940. Did you there find Hunter, the furnaceman? — Yes, we found him lying before the furnace.

4,941. He was a good deal burnt? — Very much burnt.

4,942. Did you see at that time how the doors had been blown leading into the furnace? — They were blown into the furnace.

4,943. Towards the furnace? — From the in-take into the return.

4,944. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Would you point towards which return? — There was the in-take (pointing), they were blown in that direction.

4,945. (Mr. Edge.) You went on to No. 1 shaft, and you there found Laverick in his cabin? — He was outside the cabin.

4,946. Did you find some bodies in the neighbourhood of No. 1 shaft? — Not in the immediate neighbourhood.

4,947. In what condition was No. 1 shaft? — It was completely destroyed. All the timber work was completely scattered and destroyed.

4,948. Did you go from that to No. 1 boiler? — Yes.

4,949. Point out the position of No. 1 boiler? — It was there (pointing).

4,950. I think at No. 1 boiler you found that there was a fire? — There was a fire.

4,951. In what? — In the place where the donkey engine used to stand.

4,952. The coal was on fire? — The coal was on fire.

4,953. I believe it was a serious fire, and you had to take immediate steps? — Oh, yes, the coal had a very strong hold.

4,954. Did you then return to No. 3 to get means to put out these fires? — Yes.

4,955. And you took Laverick along with you? — I found him at No. 3 shaft. I went up in the same kibble with him.

4,956. After you had brought Laverick to bank, did you go down No. 3 again? — Yes.

4,957. Did you remain below until three o'clock on the following morning? — I suppose it would be, off and on. I daresay I was up and down, I cannot remember exactly.

4,958. I think you got a good deal of assistance, very great assistance, from other mining engineers and gentlemen who volunteered their services? — Yes, we had the greatest assistance given us.

4,959. During this time had you men employed in putting out the fires at No. 1 boiler-house, and at No. 1 engine-house? — Yes.

4,960. Was there also a fire at No. 1 stables? — Yes.

4,961. Where are No. 1 stables? — Here (pointing). There had been a fire there.

(Mr. Edge.) I do not know whether I am travelling too fast, or whether you would like me to go more into detail.

(The Coroner.) Oh, no.

4,962. (Mr. Edge.) During the time they were extinguishing the fires, I think you were exploring the mine as far as you could? — Yes.

4,963. You found, with the exception of the men that were got out, four men got out from No. 3 Hutton, and Laverick, I think all the men who had been in those seams were dead? — Yes, the whole of them.

4,964. And the horses and ponies in No. 1 stables? — They were all dead.

4,965. I think, on the morning of the 9th, you came to bank and attended a consultation of the consultation board? — Yes.

4,966. That is a board composed of several of the distinguished mining engineers of the district? — Yes.

4,967. Did you go down again, about 6 o'clock on the morning of the 9th, No. 3 shaft; and I think you remained below until 5 o'clock on that day? — Yes.

4,968. During nearly the whole of that day, I think, you were altogether taken up in extinguishing fires? — That was our main difficulty. No. 1 engine-house fire was very strong at that time.

4,969. Of course, a fire below is most dangerous to the explorers? — Yes.

4,970. I think on Friday, the 10th, it was decided by the board of consultation that there should be no more in-bye explorations until the down-cast shaft was cleared? — Yes; we only had one shaft, and it was unsafe because the gas was accumulating.

4,971. You were only able to work the No. 3 shaft, and the gas was becoming dangerous? — Yes.

4,972. By what time had you got out all the bodies of the men known to be in the immediate neighbourhood of the shafts? — We got more out on the 9th and 10th.

4,973. I think from that time your chief attention was directed to clearing No. 1 shaft? — Yes.

4,974. Then from that time up to the time that the fire was discovered, I think you proceeded with your investigations and got men out from the whole of No. 1? — No. 3; we got all the men out.

4,975. And all the men out from No. 1 Hutton? — No, sir; there were very few at No. 1.

4,976. But you got all the men that were in No. 1; ultimately, I believe, before the Maudlin was closed, you got all the men out of No. 1? — Yes.

4,977. And before the Maudlin was closed, you also got all the men who were in the north-west of the Maudlin? — Yes, we got them all who were here (pointing to the plan).

4,978. (The Coroner.) Could you get which were burnt and which were killed by after-damp?

4,979. (Mr. Edge.) I will ask that in a moment. (To witness.) Of course, you had this difficulty to contend with, that you had to take your air in with you? — Yes.

4,980. And that, of course, delayed the exploration of time mine to a certain extent? — It did.

4,981. When did you discover that there was a fire in the east Maudlin? — On Friday night, I think it was the 2nd or 3rd of October.

4,982. Just point out the place where you found the fire? — It was about here (pointing) where we got to it.

4,983. Is that in the neighbourhood of the stables? — About 60 yards the out-bye side of the stables.

4,984. Did you find the roof and stone was so hot that you could not proceed further in? — There was a very heavy fall there, and there was a small passage through about 1½ feet square ; a man could have got through; and looking through that you could see that the cold air was rushing past and condensing into steam, and if you put your hand in it was scalding hot; the drops of water dropping from it were scalding hot, and the stone was burnt.

4,985. You reported that to the board of consultation, and they decided that the Maudlin seam should be walled off? — We first went round to see whether the fire was in the return, and we got further evidence of the fire there before the report to the board.

4,986. Had you from time to time examined the returns of that east Maudlin? — Oh, yes, we had repeatedly.

4,987. You had not discovered in your examination any traces of fire from the return? — Not the slightest.

4,988. It was ultimately walled off, and I believe is still in that condition? — Yes.

4,989. Now there was no relaxation of the explorations for the recovery of the men for some 60 hours after the explosion? — No, sir, not the slightest.

4,989a. I suppose by that time it was practically evident from the state below, and from the after-damp, that any men in the mine must be dead? — Yes.

4,989b. Can you point out to us the positions in which you found them? (To the Coroner.) I do not know whether you would like the number of the men given at the same time?

(The Coroner.) I think I have got all the men; we should like to have the position of the burnt men and the men killed by after-damp.

(Mr. A. Jones.) Were not we to have a little chart? (Mr. Edge.) I think the numbers are marked on the plan?

(The Witness.) The numbers are on the plan, but positively the only two men that I know were burnt were Brown and the furnaceman.

4,989c. (The Coroner.) And Laverick? — Yes; he was alive.

4,990. (Mr. Edge.) Brown and the furnaceman and Laverick, you say, were burnt? — They might have been burnt — many of them; I do not speak as to that, because there were a very great number of men very much shattered, and almost destroyed by the explosion.

4,991. (The Coroner.) What was the locality in which these men were found? — I can tell you all of them.

4,992. (Mr. Edge.) Give us the number of the men and the names? — Simpson was found here (pointing) he was very much broken ; then coming along here (pointing), there was a man found at the end of the Maudlin pit; that was Lowry. I believe he was very much destroyed — in many fragments. Further along here were the two Venners ; I believe one much broken, but I did not see them. Coming along towards here (pointing) was where Hindson was found, very much damaged, and all the men in the main coal staple were knocked about tremendously. Smith, Rawlins, and Potter — that was all in that pit who suffered from the explosion. The furnaceman died from after-damp, and I believe the whole of those bodies there did also.

4,993. I think there were 11 or 13 bodies found there? — There was one, Hindson, damaged, and the rest were not.

4,994. Hindson was the man about whose identity a mistake was made? — Yes. The man in the stall-board had been killed by the shock, and did not die from after-damp; he was not burnt nor shattered; he was lying with his face on the board as if he was killed by concussion.

4,995. (Mr. A. Jones.) What was his name? — Robert Rawlins, I believe.

4,996. (The Coroner.) What was the condition of the men — we do not care about the names?

(The Witness.) Then going back to No. 1 pit, this furnaceman was burnt, but whether by the explosion or by being blown underneath the furnace bars is a point I could not say; he was blown into the furnace. The fireman here (pointing) was very much knocked about; so was this man. Then we come all the way up here (pointing), and we found the three deputies here, all very much broken ; the horse-keeper found there (pointing) died from after-damp.

4,997. Was the horse-keeper in the second in-take or the engine-plane? — He was close to where the three deputies were. The three deputies were very much damaged indeed, and there were mistakes made in their identity. I have no doubt, in fact, I know it.

4,998. Then point out the next place? — This man (pointing) was also torn to pieces.

4,999. That was Ramshaw? — Yes.

5,000. Working close to the Polka way end? — Yes.

5,001. (Mr. A. Jones.) Was he damaged? — Yes.

5,002. (Mr. Edge.) I think one of his feet was blown in one way. This would come in more naturally when I am asking the indications? — He was found lying on his back against a pillar; I believe his foot was in one direction, one of his boots in another, and his stockings were in many places ; his hat was knocked all to pieces — we have never found the whole of it yet.

5,003. Then I will just take you generally; I shall have to deal with these matters subsequently; travelling along, going towards the far-off way were there any men down between the Polka way end and the far-off way? — There were two little boys found on the face of the far-off way, very much knocked about, I did not see them myself. Then coming down here (pointing) the third east, there were either two or three men close to where a large fall was who had been much broken.

5,004. Then I think you found Dawson's body? — Some four or five men in one of the returns of the third east died from after-damp; the whole of the men, with the exception of those three, died from after-damp in the third east; there was one boy very much knocked about.

5,005. Were there any men further in-bye in the third east? — They were found all the way down here in the return, they had evidently come out and gone up to the large fall, and some of them had gone back, and they had gone to where these doors were, and some were found here (pointing). And some had gone down the return and were found there (pointing).

5,006. For purpose of reference, hereafter, you have marked all that plan by numbers, the positions in which the men were found and the numbers represent the men in the book? — That is so.

5,007. You have the book here? — Yes. I was going to say that this man who was found in the Maudlin seam was very much broken — Vickers.

5,008. (The Coroner.) That is the in-take you speak of? — That is the in-take, and that man at the stables, Gray, he died from shock; it was not from after-damp.

5,009. (Mr. Edge.) Were any of the men on the returns shattered? — There were no men in any return that I know of.

5,010. Any men I mean that were found in the returns? — No, none of them found in the returns were shattered ; most certainly not.

5,011. Then you assume that they died from after-damp? — Yes.

5,012. That applies to the whole mine? — Yes, when I say that, there was one, Welch, he was in the return, and he was knocked about, but the other three were not. Two died from after damp, and two might have died from shock. I could not say which, but two certainly from after-damp.

5,013. With the exception of the man you have mentioned in the stables, in the Maudlin east, did you find any other man damaged by the explosion? — No, the men all about here (points) were injured by afterdamp.

(Mr. Edge.) Now I propose to take Mr. Stratton to the indications.

(The Coroner.) By all means.

5,014. (Mr. Edge.) Of course, what you are going to tell us about the indications are the result of a continuous exploration? — Yes.

5,015. At present I will not ask you to express any opinion as to the seat of the explosion, but merely take you to the indications all over the mine, showing that persons might form their own judgment. We will start, if you please, from No. 1 shaft, and go right along the engine plane to the far-off way? — Yes.

5,016. What indications did you find, if any, at No. 1 shaft? — Commencing at the south side of the shaft, that is the No. 1 side, we found the lattice work between the upright girders that forms the outside and the bottom was bulged in that direction from south to north, and we found that the rappers had been bent in a manner which could not have been done in any other way than from south to north, the rapper levers. Then there was a wheel that stood this side of the shaft; it had a cover upon it, and this cover was bent out, evidently from south to north.

5,017. Were those things you have spoken of — those levers and that brattice between the shaft and No. 1? — No, they are exactly in the shaft itself.

5,018. I mean were they on the No. 1 side of the shaft? — The rapper levers and wheel cover would be, you might say, mid-way from the centre point of the girder work ; the lattice work of the girders was at the No. 1 side entirely.

5,019. What appearance did the levers present? — One lever was bent up as though it had had a blow and doubled it; the iron had buckled under the strain applied to it.

5,020. In which direction had the end of that lever bent? — It was the north lever that was bent ; that is to say the lever on the Maudlin side that was bent ; it could not happen the other way. I mean a shock from north to south could not have bent that lever, because the iron handle had it fast ; it must have been bent the other way.

5,021. It must have been bent by a shock going from south to north? — Yes, it must have been.

5,022. What other indications did you find in the neighbourhood of No. 1 shaft south side? — The first thing, of course, we came across was the tubs.

5,023. Where were the tubs? — Lying in the No. 1 shaft siding.

5,024. How close is that No. 1 shaft siding to the bottom of the shaft? — It extends from the bottom of the shaft to about 100 yards away from it.

5,025. In what direction? — From this direction towards the south ; it is part of No. 1 engine plane.

5,026. The No. 1 extends along the engine plane? — It is the end of the plane.

5,027. What indications did you find there ; what condition did you find the tubs in? — The tubs were all knocked about ; they were scattered in every direction. Some were knocked this way, some that way.

5,028. Some of the tubs, I assume, were broken? — They were all broken that I saw.

5,029. From what you could see, was there anything to give an indication as to from what direction the fore had come that had knocked those tubs about? — My impartial opinions would be that they were as if they had been knocked both ways. They had every appearance of being knocked and scattered in every direction.

5,030. Was there anything else at that No. 1 side that attracted your attention? — Yes, we found Dodgin there, he had been (at least, so we supposed) driving his pony with a set of trucks up the bank. We found his pony some 25 or 30 yards away, still attached to the trucks.

5,031. Where were Dodgin's tubs? — About 25 or 30 yards to the south of him.

5,032. That is in-bye where you found Dodgin? — Yes, in-bye.

5,032a. (The Coroner.) Knocked to pieces? — Dodgin was knocked all to pieces.

5,033. (Mr. Edge.) Taking the same question over again, as a matter of fact, you found Dodgin about 20 yards out-bye from his pony and tubs? — Yes.

5,034. Was he much damaged? — He was much the worst damaged of anybody in the pit. He was knocked all to pieces literally.

5,035. With regard to the usual course of the horseman, I suppose usually he would be alongside his pony? — Almost certain.

5,036. Were these tubs coming out-bye or going in-bye? — They were going in-bye.

5,037. Then, if he was alongside his pony he must have been blown out-bye past the tubs? — I should take it to be so.

(Mr. A. Jones.) That is an argumentative question.

(The Coroner.) Well, I do not know ; there is nothing vital in it, Mr. Jones.

(Mr. Edge.) It is only to get the thing on the reporter's notes.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Either that or the tubs must have been blown in-bye from him.

(Mr. Edge.) Yes, either one or the other.

5,038. How many tubs were after the pony? — I think to the best of my recollection there were five or six.

5,039. Were they empty tubs, do you know? — Empty tubs.

5,040. How is the incline — is there any incline there? — A little rise to the south, about, I should think, one in 18 to one in 20.

5,041. Was the pony within the tubs on this incline? — Yes, she was going up the incline.

5,042. We will pass on from that. What was the next indication you saw? — Just above where Dodgin was found, or where Dodgin's pony was found rather, there is the termination of an arch which presents a face in this direction. You see the end of the arch and the spaces between were filled with stones, and bricks, and straw, and dust — filled up.

5,043. The arch led in-bye for what distance? — The ends face the south, and the ends of those bricks were filled up with small sticks and stones and hay.

5,044. About how far from the bottom of the shaft was that? — That would be just about 100 yards, to the best of my recollection. It was just at the end of the shaft siding, 120 at the outside.

5,045. When you speak of the arch, did you find these traces of wood, sticks, and other materials, round the top of the arch? — Yes, round the door of the arch, driven so forcibly and so tightly in that it took some trouble to get them out.

5,046. It was an unfinished arch, I believe, was it not? — Yes, it stopped there.

5,047. It was a rough-ended arch? Yes, just the end of the arch.

5,048. (The Coroner.) Was it on both sides of the arch? — No, the arch ended there — that arch did not go any further in.

5,049. (Mr. Edge.) You found these things at the in-bye end of the arch? — Yes.

5,050. Did you find anything else there? — Yes, we went a little further on, and came to the overcast, which is this (pointing.)

5,051. In what condition was the overcast — The overcast was destroyed in as far as it was blown completely out, and there were bricks in between here, and many bricks had been blown out here (pointing.)

5,052. Was that a brick overcast? — Yes, a brick arch .

5,053. I understand you to say you found bricks blown right and left in the return? — Yes.

5,054. The bricks of the overcast? — Yes.

5,055. And found some of the bricks blown out-bye from the overcast? — Yes, I am sure they were blown out-bye.

5,056. How far did you find them blown out-bye? — The main body of bricks were lying about 20 yards from the overcast. They were lying where the arch had been broken on the top, and some of those bricks had fallen out as well, and there was a considerable heap of bricks at that point.

5,057. About how far was that from the overcast? — About 20 to 25 yards.

5,058. As you proceeded in-bye did you find any other traces? — From that point upwards we commenced at the overcast to find hay lying on the road — the road began to be covered with hay more or less.

5,059. Did you find it in any other place except on the floor of the road? — We found it, as I have described in the end of the arch.

5,060. I mean going in — as you were travelling in? — We found it lying on the one side of the road going in.

5,061. Where was the nearest place in the No. 1 that the hay could have come from? — There were 3 or 4 "hay boards," as they are called; one for these stables, just where my pointer is, and one for the one which was there, and a third for one which was here. Now, the hay in that hay board was all burnt, and the hay in that hay board was there until the stables were cleaned out; but this hay was not burnt where it was.

5,062. That was not burnt? — No, and it was not where it was; it was blown away, and there was a line of hay which was continuous, from there down to the over-cast.

5,063. That is what you call, I think, a temporary stable between the second return and the engine plane? — Yes, they are made of wood.

5,064. That stable was blown out altogether? — Yes, the hay board was there.

5,065. As I understand, you can only account for the hay you found in the spaces, on the supposition that it came from the temporary stable? — I could not account for it in any other way than that.

5,066. Your reason for that being, as I understand you, that the hay in one of the stables, the first stable to the left as you come in, had been burnt, and the hay in the first stable to the right as you come in was still there when the stable was burnt down? — Yes.

5,067. As you went along did you come to the pillars of the engine house? — Yes, the engine house was here.

5,068. About how far is the turning into the engine house from that first over-cast? — It would be about 40 yards or 50 yards.

5,069. How were the doors of the engine house? — The doors of the engine house were blown from the engine house into the return.

5,070. I do not know, but are there any doors? I think there is a door between the engine plane and that engine house, is there not? — No.

5,071. We will travel along the engine plane. What was the next indication you noticed? — We noticed nothing very particularly — at least I did not myself — until we came to this junction of the travelling way in the engine plane; between the engine house and that junction there was a great deal of damage done, but there was very little to show which way it was done. It was all turned upside down, and you might have said either way. Some things looked this way and some things looked that way — you could not make anything of it.

5,072. There was no plain indication? — There was no plain indication ; certainly not, to my mind, but when you got to here there was a wheel which stood between the two roads, which we call a coin wheel.

5,073. Where the two roads branch off to the engine plane? — Yes, that wheel was knocked down, and the bricks were lying about in a continuous line from south to north.

5,074. (The Coroner.) The reverse way? — This way (pointing.)

5,075. (Mr. Edge.) You found the bricks of that corner wall blown out-bye? — Yes, out-bye.

5,076. (The Coroner.) Would you just kindly indicate where that is? — There it is at the junction (pointing.)

5,076a. It is in the same direction?

5,077. (Mr. Edge.) How far out bye from the place where that wall was did you find the bricks? — I believe I may say the further brick I found to be close on 23 yards.

5,078. Out-bye from that corner? — Yes.

5,079. Had there been a notice board there, do you know? — That was in the travelling way.

5,080. I will just continue this, and take you to the travelling way afterwards. Proceeding along the engine plane I think you came to a large fall? — There was a large fall here (pointing.)

5,081. How far from the junction of the second intake of the engine plane was the fall? — It would be about 25 yards.

5,082. What was the length of the fall? — The extreme length was 15 yards.

5,083. Did it cover the whole of the floor of the engine plane? — Not entirely ; it was thicker at one place than the other — more to one side than the other.

5,084. About what depth was it; what was the greatest depth of the fall? — The maximum 3 feet 6 inches or 4 feet — the greatest depth.

5,085. Of course you saw where it came from, but did you notice anything in the roof from where this stone came down. I do not quite know what it is you call it, a "jack," I think?

(Mr. Bell.) A slip.

(The Witness.) Yes, the fall itself had come away at a "jack," or a "slip," as it is termed; but there were others further in-bye.

5,086. Did you notice anything on the in-bye or out-bye edges of that fall — I mean of the stone? — Yes, I should have said that the stone at the in-bye side had a very different appearance to that stone at the other.

5,087. Just tell us what the difference in the appearance of the in-bye and out-bye edges was? As I looked at the stones, the first time I saw them, the appearance gave me the impression that they had received a shock from south to north.

5,088. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Do you mean the stone constituting the fall, lying on the ground? — Yes; their edges had a cleaned and brightened-up appearance, as though they had been touched up with something.

5,089. On the in-bye side? — Yes, on the in-bye side. I found nothing on the out-bye.

5,090. (Mr. Edge.) Did you see any material mixed up with that fall, or in any of the crevices of the fall? — No, there was very little to see upon the fall itself, because it was a perfectly smooth roof.

5,091. Going in-bye from the fall did you notice any other indications? — Yes, going in-bye from that — between there and the temporary stables — we found the hay lying on the right side going in, which had been blown from south to north, in my opinion.

5,092. Did you notice anything in the dust, and how the dust was lying? — The dust generally gave you the same impression, that it had been going in that direction, but it is a very unreliable test or guide.

5,093. I know it is. As you proceeded in-bye did you come across a block of coal? — Yes.

5,094. Point out where and tell us about how far from the fall that block of coal was? — It would be about 80 yards the in-bye side of the temporary stables.

5,095. About 80 yards, do you say? — Yes.

5,090. What was the size of the block of coal? — I think it was 30 inches long and perhaps 18 inches high, and about eight or nine inches thick. I would not like to be sure.

5,097. In what part of the engine plane did you find that? — We found it in a refuge hole.

5,098. Did you search to see where it had come from? — Yes, it was not far to search; the place where it came from was close to it.

5,099. As a matter of fact, did you put that piece of coal into the place where you assume it had come from? — Yes.

5,100. And did you find that it fitted it? — Yes, it fitted it.

5,101. Was the place where it fitted on the in-bye or the out-bye side of where you found the block of coal? — It was on the in-bye side we found it.

5,102. And was part of a refuge hole? — It was just the edge of a refuge hole, just the corner.

5,103. About how far from the place into which the block of coal fitted did you find the block of coal itself? — Four feet.

5,104. Then we will go along further; what was the next indication you found? — The next place we came to, to give any guide, was the Polka way end; all that engine plane was very much turned upside down. Everything was knocked out, but there was nothing to guide you very accurately; it was a disturbed place; when we came to the Polka way end we found that the doors in the Polka way had been blown inwards.

5,105. That is blown in which direction? — Blown in towards the return.

5,106. In towards the return on the left, of course? — Yes, in towards the east return.

5,107. What else did you notice there? — I was telling you when we came to look for Ramshaw's lamp, and found his foot, and that sort of thing, we found he had been blown in different directions.

5,108. I will just come to that. The first thing I think you found of Ramshaw was the tile and pole of the safety lamp? — The first thing we found when we began to look for it.

5,109. Where did you find that, starting from the Polka end? — About 10 yards from the in-bye side of the end of the way in 10 to 12 yards.

5,110. Where did you find any portion of Ramshaw himself? — — We found his foot at the out-bye side of him.

5,111. At the out-bye side of Ramshaw himself or of the pole? — Ramshaw himself.

5,112. Then did you find the foot between where the pole and the lamp was and Ramshaw's body? — Ramshaw was between them; the pole was at the in-bye side of the lamp and his foot was at the out-bye side.

I misunderstood the position.

5,113. (Mr. H. Jones.) Would you just kindly indicate exactly where Ramshaw was? — The exact part where he was there (pointing).

5,114. Where are the Polka doors? — There are the doors (pointing).

5,115. And you say Ramshaw's foot was on the in-bye side? — The out-bye side.

(Mr. Edge.) It was my mistake.

5,116. Going from the Polka way end, what was the first thing connected with Ramshaw that you found, either of his body, or lamp, or anything else? — Coming from the Polka way end we found him.

5,117. You found him first? — Yes.

5,118. How far from the Polka way end was Ramshaw lying? — About 10 yards.

5,119. How was he lying? — I never saw him, but I believe he was lying on his back, as though he was seated against a pillar.

5,120. He was a good deal blown about, I believe? — I never saw him.

5,121. Who saw him? Can you tell me? — I think Mr. Atkinson found him and he was taken out.

5,122. What was the next thing that you found? — We found his lamp after that.

5,123. How far from Ramshaw did you find his lamp? — The lamp was in many pieces; there were no two pieces found together.

5,124. I know that, but just describe? — For instance, we found one pole and the tile in a refuge hole; about two yards away from Ramshaw we found it in a corner — a refuge hole.

5,125. Was that in-bye Ramshaw's body? — Yes, in-bye.

5,126. Did you find the cap on the lamp? — Yes.

5,127. Where was that found? — I am sure I do not remember that exactly at this moment.

5,128. Did you find a portion of one of the stockings in-bye of the body? — Yes, one was found about 20 yards in-bye.

5,129. I think one of his boots and his waistcoat was found where the lamp was? — Yes, on the opposite side of the way, but close to him.

5,130. One of his feet was found — where was that found? — It was found at the out-bye side, to the best of my recollection.

5,131. The out-bye side of the body? — Yes, the out-bye side of him.

5,132. Passing along from where Ramshaw was found, did you find any fall of roof? — There were several falls at the in-bye side of Ramshaw, and the roof was fallen for a considerable distance there, more or less.

5,133. Did you find Ramshaw's tub near where Ramshaw's body was found? — About 25 yards away; the tub was found exactly at the curve.

5,134. Was that on the in-bye side? — On the in-bye side of him.

5,135. And you found the tub; was it partly covered by the fall? — It was completely covered by it; it was a long time before we did find it.

5,136. The tub, I suppose, was in the engine plane, but covered by this fall? — Yes.

5,137. We will go straight along the engine plane. You have told us that for a considerable distance there was a fall along there ; about what distance along the engine plane did you find the falls continue? — The last fall was just at the innermost curve; the curve is divided into three curves now, and it was the innermost curve.

5,138. About how far from the place where you found Ramshaw's body was the last fall of the engine-plane? — It would be nearly a hundred yards, I should think — 80 to 100 yards.

5,139. We may take it about 80 yards from where you found Ramshaw's body the fall ceased? — Yes.

5,140. Going along the engine-plane towards the far-off way, did you sea any other indications? — There was just the same thing over again; things were knocked all to pieces, and things were knocked in all directions ; the way was made almost impassable.

5,141. There were some wheels — two 3-feet wheels? — Yes ; they were at the out-bye side of the fall you were speaking of.

5,142. Were they between Ramshaw's body and the fall? — Yes.

5,143. Where were they? — One of those wheels was where the tub was found; the tub had been evidently knocked right up against it, because it had carried away one of the uprights. Knocking the upright away brought the fall away, and the whole thing was covered up by the fall.

5,144. Which way was that upright? — It was leaning in-bye.

5,145. The upright was leaning in-bye, you say? — The upright was leaning in-bye ; there were several of them ; they were all leaning in-bye.

5,146. At that place? — Yes.

5,147. I probably ought to have asked you this earlier — up to that time had you seen any timber leaning over going in-bye from the foot of the shaft? — Yes, there was timber leaning in-bye; two props were leaning in-bye opposite the temporary stables at the man's cabin ; there were two leaning in-bye there, the only two I can remember.

5,148. Was that in the engine plane? — Yes, just here (pointing). There were two leaning in-bye there; that is the only two I remember.

5,149. Then we will pass on beyond those falls. I think I may take it (there will be no dispute about it) that at any rate beyond the furthest of the falls, any indications there were were in-bye indications? — Yes, certainly, they were in-bye indications.

5,150. Was there much damage done beyond the furthest of those falls and the far-off way? — Yes. The shock here (pointing) had been very violent just by the third air way. It had shifted some very heavy articles.

5,151. It had shifted them? — It had shifted them all in-bye.

5,152. Had the shock been very severe where you told us the two boys were? — Yes, it had been very severe here (pointing). A very great deal had fallen. The timber was knocked off. There was a very heavy fall here, very heavy indeed.

5,153. After you had passed the falls beyond Ramshaw, there were no indications of damage so far as you could see? — No.

5,154. (Mr. A. Jones.) Just beyond the tub? — No. The tub was not at the last one at all. There were several; there were four or five.

5,155. What I mean is, when did you get the last out-bye indications? — The last out-bye indication that I could safely say was that piece of coal.

5,156. (Mr. Edge.) You have told us there was considerable damage done turning to the third east travelling way? — Yes.

5,157. Tell us what you found going along the third east travelling way? — Coming along the third east this way (describing)?

5,158. Yes? — We found those doors blown out into the return, and we found a pony and the tubs, and a boy had been very much damaged there, and then the shock had come down this way, and knocked this over-cast out. It was a brick over-cast. It had gone right and left, and we came down to this point, and there the return was over the top of the in-take there, and so destroyed the communication; it destroyed the barrier between them — it made a very big fall here (pointing).

5,159. How many pillars would that be — about 200 yards, would it not be? — About 220 yards.

5,160. On returning to the third east, what did you find? — A very heavy fall there. It took us two or three days to go through — something like that.

5,161. Then further in what did you find? — It had damaged the arching. There, there is a drift arch timber. It knocked over the piece of timber that there was there, and the roof had fallen down, I think, without a single exception, until you came down here, and then those doors were knocked out.

5,162. Were those the doors to the return? — The return, and a certain amount of shock had gone into that in-take there (pointing.)

5,168. The doors had gone into the goafs? — Yes, and beyond that point there was a fall, where there was a hitch crossing the road — crossing the line.

5,164. How many yards — about 70 or 80 yards? — Not so much as that — about 30 or 40 yards.

5,165. There was no damage beyond that 30 or 40 yards in that travelling way into the goafs? — Not a trace of it.

5,166. You have spoken of all the indications between the bottom of No. 1 shaft in the far-off way, and between the take-off along the engine plane into the take-off of No. 3 east? — Yes.

5,167. Now we will go to the travelling way, where that second in-take goes off to the engine plane. What did you find along there? — A notice board was fixed to a prop at that point.

5,168. Where was it — in the travelling way? — In the travelling way. There were directions on it for people travelling on engine planes and so forth, and I found ---

5,169. How far up the travelling way was it? — It would be just within it. It is difficult to say from memory where it stood exactly.

5,170. Where did you find the board? — I think I found it 15 or 20 yards up in this direction (pointing). I found it on the south side of where it stood.

5,171. That is to say, you found it in-bye of the place where it stood 20 yards? — In-bye.

5,172. Going along that travelling way, what was the next indication you found? — There was a gate stood there, too, perhaps about 15 yards from the junction. It was a gate intended to prevent people going on to the road.

5,173. In what condition did you find that? — That was blown south.

5,174. That was still blown in-bye? — Yes. It was found about 37 yards, I believe. One of the uprights that carried the gate and the crook of the hinge. It was found about 38 yards from the junction, I think, speaking off-hand.

5,175. Go further along in-bye — along that travelling way in the second intake? — Of course all along the way, along here (pointing), there was hay.

I am asking you to travel along the in-take back to the shaft.

(Mr. Bell.) Travel south?

5,176. (Mr. Edge.) Yes, travel south. The first thing I saw was close to here (describing), about 13 yards to the temporary stables. I found a portion of the stables — the cribs, the mangers — were blown south to north.

5,177. That is about 13 yards on the junction side of the temporary stables; you found some of the cribs that had been in the stables? — Yes; they were on the north of the stables about 13 yards. They were driven north.

5,178. In the travelling way? — In the travelling way.

(Mr. A. Jones.) Just let me understand this. Was that beyond the gate?

(Mr. Edge.) No; it was in the direction of the gate.

5,179. (Mr. A. Jones.) Was that before you reached the gate? — No; after you reached the gate.

5,180. After you had passed the gate? — Yes; after I had passed the gate.

5,181. (Mr. Edge.) Did you find any other indications between that and the temporary stables? — Nothing but the hay. The hay was continuous. Those were the principal things. We found the hay.

5,182. The temporary stables are the stables which are found on that plan, between the second in-take and the engine plane and the travelling way? — Yes; they were temporary stables, and were disused.

5,183. Did you find those blown out altogether? — They were completely stripped out.

5,184. In what condition were the stables on the other side of the travelling way — the temporary ones? — A portion had been driven up of those stables — a considerable portion. There was a cistern which stood in the travelling way there between the second in-take and the engine plane. That cistern was blown straight up across the travelling way into the stables, and into the top of them.

5,185. Then, passing on beyond the stables, did you find any further indications? — There was hay blown inwards in this direction (pointing).

5,186. There was hay blown inwards? — Yes.

5,187. When you passed the stables? — When I passed the stables.

5,188. Blown inwards on the travelling way? — Blown inwards on the travelling way, and there was a water tub stood there (pointing). That tub was knocked into three pieces; the main body of the tub was lying about 40 yards from the stables, and the end was lying about 80 — I should say 80 or 90.

5,189. About how far from the temporary stables did the indications of force exist, so far as you can say? — About 80 or 90 yards, I should say.

5,190. In by the stables? — Yes, 90 yards.

5,191. Do you remember some doors leading into the return, and going along the travelling way? — Yes.

5,192. Where were they? — Here (pointing).

5,193. What distance were they from the temporary stables — it would be 400 yards or 500 yards? — It would be 450 yards or so; yes.

5,194. In what condition were those doors? — They were locked doors, and when I got through I found the locks were sprung; the locks were damaged.

5,195. Had they been damaged by force? — Yes.

5,196. Those were doors leading to the travelling way? — The bolt was no longer free ; that is all you can say. There was no damage done to the doors, but the lock was sprung.

5,197. Beyond that place did you find along that travelling way any indications of damage? — Not for a long way until you came to that point (pointing).

5,198. I do not know how you fix that? — I was fixing it about four pillars from here.

5,199. That is four pillars from the winch? — Yes, above the second in-take.

5,200. What indications did you find there? — I found the timber knocked out there.

5,201. In what direction? — It was knocked out from south to north.

5,202. That is to say, it was lying out over? — It was lying outwards.

5,203. (Mr. A. Jones.) How do you fix that? — Four pillars above the second in-take — third east.

5,204. (Mr. Edge.) Have you given now briefly all the indications that you saw in the No. 1 pit? — The indications from this point went in-bye (pointing).

5,205. Do you mean the indications south of these timbers? — Yes; it went in-bye for a short distance; and there was a door stood here and the other end of this in-take, a similar gate to this one, and that was blown in this direction.

5,206. That was blown in-bye? — And then props were knocked out here, and they were blown in that direction.

5,207. There were signs in fact there that they were blown in both directions to a certain extent? — Yes.

5,208. That is to say, in the travelling way where you take off the third in-take? — Yes.

5,209. (The Coroner.) Could you make out where the greatest force had been expended, at the one end of the travelling way or the other? — This gate had not been so badly damaged as that. That is a fair criterion to go by.

5,210. That is where the greatest force had been, so far as you could make out? — Yes. That gate had been knocked into a greater number of pieces than this.

5,211. (Mr. Edge.) Then the result of what you have told us is, that so far as you could judge, the explosion seems to have exercised more force towards the junction of the engine plane and the travelling way than down towards east? — I should not like to say that. I should say one gate was more knocked about than the other ; but I should say the force of the explosion was here (pointing) because the winch, a very heavy article, was moved eight or ten yards. It is one of the heaviest articles used in the pit.

5,212. In what direction was it moved? — It was moved from north to south.

5,213. Then it was moved in-bye? — It stood on the engine plane; it was moved in-bye.

5,214. (Mr. Wright.) How many yards? ten yards? — Eight or ten yards.

5,215. What is the weight of it? — I should not like to say.

5,216. (Mr. Edge.) About? — Besides the weight it is fixed to the roof very securely. This winch is used to haul weights, and as a matter of fact it must be fixed very tightly. It was a ton, I should think.

5,217. Was it a ton weight? — Yes, it would be, I should think.

5,218. Is there any other indication that you saw in No. 1 Hutton? — No, I think that will exhaust the main of them at any rate.

5,219. You have told us what were the principal indications that you saw? — Yes, I have; the principal ones certainly.

(Mr. Edge.) Now I propose to take you into No. 3.

5,220. (The Coroner.) Was there any damage done in this return towards the travelling way? — Those two doors were blown out and the doors were knocked down in that direction (pointing), and those two doors were blown out and knocked about here; and there was no damage done to the returns. There were four men working here, and they walked along to that point.

5,221. I mean in this return towards the travelling way? — This (pointing)?

5,222. Yes? — There was damage done here.

5,223. But beyond that point? — There was no damage done there — not a trace.

5,224. (Mr. Edge.) There was no trace of damage in the west returns of No. 1 Hutton, is that it? — Nowhere, except where there were communications by means of doors. When the doors were knocked out the returns were damaged, but nowhere else.

5,225. The course of the returns was not damaged? — No.

5,226. I will take you now to No. 3 pit. I will take you to the foot of the up-cast. What indications did you see there? — Going north —

5,227. But how was the shaft bottom? — The shaft bottom was blown from north to south. The materials were all carried away that way, in this direction.

5,228. How were the flat sheets? — The flat sheets were lifted up; but first the indication was from north to south.

5,229. Further south was there much damage? — Going here, there were these doors. This door was knocked off its hinges, but the lock was not broken. The second door was carried away; but that third door was unhurt, and coming in there was the road to the furnace, and there are two doors in there, and those two doors were knocked out.

5,230. In which direction were they knocked? — In the direction of No. 3 furnace.

5,231. Knocked towards the furnace? — Yes, there was no mistake about them, because these doors were very much broken; they were carried bodily about 10 yards ; and there were two doors coming into here, leading into the staple way. They were blown in towards the staple — those two doors.

5,232. In what condition did you find the furnace? — That furnace there was no damage done to whatever, not worth speaking of.

5,233. Where was the furnace-man found? — He was between the two doors, just at the entrance of the furnace staple.

5,234. Did he show any signs of damage by force? — It was after-damp, I should say, from the way he had fallen. I could not have any doubt about that. He had fallen on his face.

5,235. He showed no signs of damage at all? — Not at all.

5,236. Did you find that furnace alight for any considerable time after the explosion? — It was alight at 7 o'clock on Friday morning.

5,237. That is some 54 hours after the explosion? — Yes. It had been omitted to be examined so minutely, and it was found to be smouldering at that time, 54 hours after, 7 o'clock.

5,238. Then that shows the explosion had not been very severe at that furnace? — Well, it had not been severe there at all. A lot of the things which the furnace-men had there were still there, these little windmills and things.

5,239. Those little toys? — Yes; they had a lot of little toys, and those toys are there still, and are going at this moment, I believe.

5,240. That shows that the explosion had not been severe enough there to drive the coal off the furnace bars? — Yes, quite so.

5,241. Going from that furnace in-bye to the return, did you see any signs of violence at all? — Not a trace.

5,242. Now we will go back from that furnace to No. 3 pit shaft bottom. There are two roads there? — Yes. There is one (pointing) and here is the other.

5,243. There is one that leads up to the foot of the Maudlin kip, and the other is the one by which you lead in the coal from the No. 3 Hutton? — Yes. That is where the Hutton coal goes, and this is where the Maudlin coal goes (pointing).

5,244. Did you see any indications between that and the main in-take? — Yes; we found that five very long props had been set at the side of the dock, and they were blown away, and their heads were blown towards the shaft.

5,245. How far from the shaft? — About 25 or 30 yards from the shaft.

5,246. Was there a door in that road? — Yes; the first door you came to stood just there (pointing).

5,247. How was that door blown? — It was blown just towards the shaft.

5,248. Was there another door along there? — Yes; it was along there.

5,249. How was that? — It was blown towards the shaft too.

5,250. Is there an overcast close to where you get into the main in-take? — Here it is (pointing).

5,251. What condition was that in? — It was knocked all to pieces — blown to right and left. It is a wood over-cast.

5,252. Did you find any of the timber of that in the intake? — A lot of timber was in the in-take, lying on the floor.

5,253. It was blown right and left? — It was blown right and left in the returns.

5,254. But it was not blown in-bye? — Well, you could not have told it, because there was such a mass of timber and wreckage there, that you could not tell anything about it. It was a most extraordinary wreck.

5,255. Was there much wreckage there? — A very great deal.

5,256. What distance along the main road staple did the wreckage continue? — Until you came to the junction here (pointing) it was worst, there was a good deal of timber at the sides — that sort of thing — which made a good deal of wreck, and there were tubs standing there, and there was a landing.

5,257. Where was that? — Between this point and that, there was a landing for the main coal.

5,258. That is between the over-cast and the turning in to the main coal staple? — Yes. It was a very wide place indeed, and a deal of timber about it.

5,259. Did you find any indications of the way in which the force had gone then? — Yes; there were indications there, I might say, both ways. There were objects driven in both directions.

5,260. There was a sheave which used to stand in the road leading to the main coal staple — Yes ; there was a sheave in the road there.

(The Coroner.) You can lead to this as shortly as you like.

5,261. (Mr. Edge.) Were there two small wheels at each side of the sheave? — There were two small ones.

5,262. At each side? — At each side. They were found close up against the sheave — the wheels.

5,263. At what distance had they been before? — About 10 inches from the sheave.

5,264. In your judgment, generally, from that point to the main coal staple were the indications inbye? — Yes, they were in-bye there.

5,265. (The Coroner.) To No. 3? — No.

5,266. (Mr. Edge.) From the sheave? — They were in-bye there. There was a wheel stood there, and the cover of that was blown towards the staple.

5,267. What condition was the staple in? I think you have told us that already? — Yes; it was clean out.

5,268. There is a road which leads from the staple into the returns, is there? — We found that two doors were blown into the return there.

5,269. Blown into the return? — Yes.

5,270. I will take it generally that the indications there shown, led you to the conclusion that wherever the explosion came from originally, it had gone into No. 3? — Yes, it had gone in there.

(Mr. Wright.) Starting from the main coal staple shall we say?

(Mr. A. Jones.) A little to the east of the main coal staple.

(Mr. Wright.) How far to the east?

(Mr. A. Jones.) We will take in the old Hutton, with a yard of the old Hutton way.

5,271. (The Coroner.) Which is the old Hutton way? — Here is the old Hutton way (pointing).

(The Coroner.) That is the point that we fixed. That is the point which we considered might be taken.

(Mr. Edge.) That may be taken as common ground.

(Mr. Wright.) Yes.

(The Witness.) I may as well say that I have heard more than one person say that between that point and the main coal staple the tubs had come out.

5,272. There were indications there going up that old Hutton incline of force coming out, and when you went further in, there were indications of force coming in? — What I was referring to was, between the main coal staple and that short piece. There were tubs standing there, and it was a very confused place too between the point Mr. Jones speaks of and the main coal staple. It was a very confused place too.

5,273. (Mr. Wright.) How would you define it? Supposing you take this point? — The in-bye end of the Hutton seam back bottom.

(Mr. Wright.) From that, inwards into No. 3, I take it his opinion is clear.

5,274. (Mr. Edge.) Yes; and with regard to the old Hutton? — That is the Old Hutton which Mr. Wright is referring to.

5,275. There are indications there at the foot of the old Hutton incline, at the eastern end, of the force coming out-bye? — Yes, very clear indications.

5,276. And further in there are equally strong indications of force coming in? — Yes.

(Mr. Edge.) Mr. Wright, we need not trouble ourselves with that Hutton incline.

(Mr. Wright.) So far as I know, you need not, unless Mr. Jones has anything to ask about it.

(Mr. A. Jones.) No, I have not.

5,277. (Mr. Edge.) I will take you along the travelling way, to where the travelling way to the main coal staple joins the main in-take? — That is here (pointing).

5,278. No. Further along than that I want you to go? — There (pointing).

5,279. Yes? — There is the main coal staple.

5,280. Just there, a man called Venner fired a shot? — Oh, that is here (pointing).

5,281. (Mr. A. Jones.) By the old Hutton way? — He had fired a shot lately — he had fired a shot not long before.

5,282. (Mr. Edge.) You do not know, of course, when he did fire the shot? — No.

5,283. Where was he firing the shot? was it in a refuge hole? — In a refuge hole.

5,284. In a refuge hole on the right-hand side as you came out-bye? — On the right-hand side coming out.

5,285. Did you notice the stuff that had come down from the shot — whether it had been removed or not? — There was a good deal of stone lying there, but that might have been the stones on the west side had been removed.

5,286. In your judgment a portion of the stones from that shot had been removed? — Yes.

5,287. Venner's son was his marrow? — Yes.

5,288. Do you know where Venner and his son were found? — Close to the refuge hole.

5,289. Close to the place? — Close together in front of the hole.

5,290. What distance from the hole? — I did not see exactly — so far as I can ascertain, they were close to that hole.

5,291. Can you tell me the name of anyone who will tell us the name of the person who got them out — who can tell us? — Thomas Wetherall got them out.

5,292. Opposite the place where Venner's shot was, is there a stow hole? — Yes.

5,293. Point it out? — It is up there (pointing) in a slanting direction.

5,294. That is a place where you stow away rubbish and refuse? — Yes.

5,295. Rawlings was found there? — Robert Rawlings was found in there.

5,296. About how far from the place where Venner's shot was fired? — About 18 yards.

5,297. Can you tell us what direction the jumper hole bore, with regard to the place where Rawlings was found? — You mean the drill hole.

5,298. Yes? — The hole was exactly opposite his, and it was almost exactly in the same line.

5,299. May I take it, if a shot was going to be fired, a man would not remain there? — It is very unlikely.

5,300. He would be in the direct line that the shot was blown out? — He would have been in the line the shot was blown.

5,301. Or any stones blown might go up that stow-hole? — He would have been in a dangerous place.

5,302. Was his stow-cart found along with him? — Yes.

5,303. About 18 yards from where the shot was fired? — 18 yards from where the shot was fired.

5,304. Who was Rawlings the marrow of? — Thomas Hindson.

5,305. Now, we will come back to the place where Venner's shot was fired, and we will travel along the road, the travelling way. What indications did you find going along the travelling way and going east? — Just opposite the stow board we found a chest that had stood there had been removed in this direction towards the shaft.

5,306. Had been blown east? — Yes. Coming further along here we found a fence that had stood there was blown in the same direction; there was a fence to prevent the horses coming in there, and it was blown in this direction from west to east, and then at this point stands the Maudlin return wheel. The rope goes down that wheel, and that wheel was broken, and the broken portions were carried about four feet from east to west.

5,307. The broken portions were carried in-bye towards the third Hutton up in that direction? — Yes.

5,308. (Mr. A. Jones.) Will you fix that place? — That wheel stands just there (pointing).

(Mr. Edge.) Close to where the Hutton road leading to No. 3 shaft takes off from the in-take.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Twenty yards to the east of the over-cast.

(The Witness.) It is rather more than that; there is an old over-cast there ; it is about 10 yards on the in-bye side of that, 40 yards from the over-cast of the return wheel.

5,309. (Mr. A. Jones.) Would you mind just marking it on my plan? — It is midway in that little triangle (pointing).

5,310. Just before you come to the over-cast? — About 30 yards from the over-cast — about 30 yards from the junction and the upper seam way.

5,311. (Mr. Edge.) Travelling eastward from that point, what was the next indication you found? — The next thing you come to is the Maudlin docks.

5,312. What did you find there? — I found the end wall had been started away from the side wall, and that end wall had gone from east to west.

5,313. The end wall of the Maudlin dock had gone from east to west? — Yes.

5,314. Did you find any tubs in the dock? — The tubs were in the dock.

5,315. Did they give you any indication as to the direction of the force? — Not very well. The wall was blown into the dock — the side wall on the top of the tubs; it was all a heap of confusion.

5,316. Then going along from the Maudlin docks eastwards, what did you meet next? — The next thing we came to particularly is the Maudlin engine.

5,317. What appearance did the Maudlin engine present ; just point it out on the plan? — There it is (pointing). Well, looking at the engine from east to west as you enter the house, the fire-box faces you, and the reversing gear stands at the side ; that reversing lever was turned round, and bent in that direction from east to west; and above the fire-box there stands the pressure-gauge. That pressure-gauge was knocked about six inches against the dome and completely flattened, from east to west. Then when you come to the far end of the engine-house, that had a hot water cistern there, and that hot-water cistern was completely crushed in at the far side. We found there was a place in the arch at the back of the engine-house very much damaged. We found that the iron tube that conveys the smoke into this drift had been driven in here (pointing), and then again we found that the back lash — the force of the explosion — had knocked the end of the smoke-box in from west to east.

5,318. At the far end of the engine-house? — Yes; and damaged the back of the hot water cistern in the same direction.

5,319. Where the Maudlin engine is, the north main coal takes off? — That is the north main coal.

5,320. And in that are the No. 3 Hutton seam stables? — There they are (pointing).

5,321. Did the stables afford you any intimation as to how the force had come? — They were very clear. The stables had the end wall here, next to the north main coal road. The end wall was carried bodily from east to west.

5,322. The stables were on the left side of the north main coal in-take? — Yes ; and the wall was driven bodily from east to west.

(Mr. A. Jones.) That is after you have passed the Maudlin engine.

5,323. (Mr. Bell.) On the east side of the Maudlin engine? — There was a stop at the end of the stable, which was driven in the same direction, from east to west.

5,324. (Mr. Edge.) Further along, did you also find indications in the north main coal? — We found damage down here (pointing) — these doors blown out.

5,325. What indications that you found in the north main coal show that the blast had gone in there? — Had gone in-bye.

5,326. Now, you say a stopping was blown out — was that blown in the direction of the standage? — Yes ; that was blown in the direction of the standage.

5,327. Where is the standage? — Here (pointing).

5,328. Did you examine the standage? — Yes.

5,329. Did you find anything there — any indication in the standage? — Nothing of any damage having been done.

5,330. Now we come to the passage leading to the main in-take? — A short crooked passage (pointing).

5,331. Between the end of the turning to the north main coal, travelling along the road, what further indications did you find going along the main in-take? — We found the props and baulks had been on fire, and the coals had been on fire.

5,332. That is some 20 or 30 yards eastward of the north main coal in-take? — No ; right opposite the main coal.

5,333. The coal had been on fire? — Yes, exactly opposite there.

5,334. In what condition did you find the timber? — The timber was unmistakeably charred.

5,335. Had it gone in any particular direction? — No; there was a big fall there which covered all evidence of that sort; you could not tell which way it went.

5,336. Going along eastward from that, what did you next find beyond the place where you say the fire was? — Well, about this point we found the sheave of the roof which had been driven from east to west, that was where the curve was.

5,337. Did you find a stopping near that curve? — Yes.

5,338. That had been blown towards No. 3 shaft? — Yes.

5,339. From that until you came to the curved drift was there much evidence of damage? — Not so much there; there was very little damage done; the timber was all standing.

5,340. From that last point down to where the curve commenced, was there anything to indicate in your judgment which way the force had gone? — Yes, there were several things — the rapper rope, the way it was curled up and laid against the sheaves.

5,341. Show us the position where the rapper rope was? — The rapper rope generally ran along the side parallel with the tail rope.

5,342. There was a tail rope that ran into the Maudlin seam from the Maudlin engine? — Yes, the rapper rope ran alongside.

5,343. The tail rope was along the roof? — Yes.

5,344. Will you describe to the Coroner the condition in which you found the rapper rope, the rapper rope was a thinner rope? — It was a thinner rope. It had the appearance of having been swung round and round until it had coiled itself as far as it could together, and then it was drawn up in that direction until it came to the hard knot, and then the hard knot terminated at the sheave; wherever there was anything to stop it, it went into a knot.

5,345. In one place was the rapper rope coiled eight or nine times round the tail rope? — A great many more times than that — it was coiled a great number of times ; it seemed to be driven up against the sheave and stopped there.

5,346. In which direction? — From east to west.

5,347. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Which side of Brown's shot was that? — Both above and below, both at the east side of Brown's shot, and at the west side.

5,348. Was there no indication? — Yes, the same direction, or both sides of Brown's shot.

5,349. (Mr. Edge.) Where you have told us these coils of the rapper rope were round the tail rope, were the coils going in the same direction? — Yes.

5,350. They were going until stopped by the sheaves? — And these sheaves always laid the west side of the coil.

5,351. Did you find anything further until you come to Brown's shot? — No, there was nothing further than that.

5,352. Just point out where Brown's shot was? — Just here (pointing.)

5,353. You examined Brown's shot, I suppose? — He was firing a shot at the refuge hole? — Yes, he was enlarging the refuge hole.

5,354. Did you find the shot had taken effect — that is, that it had brought down the stone? — It had brought down all the stone it had intended to bring.

5,355. Of course, if the shot had been blown out it would not have brought down the stone? — No, there would have been a portion of the hole left on.

5,356. You found it had done its work? — Yes.

5,357. Well now, in addition, can you tell me how did the drill hole incline — was it horizontal, or did it incline up or down? — It was nearly horizontal, but slightly inclined to point downwards, in the same way it was drilled.

5,358. The outside of the hole would point rather up to the roof? — Slightly, it did so at any rate.

5,359. Beyond Brown's shot, still going westward, what did you next see? — There was a rapper rope I spoke of about a minute ago. At the place where Simpson was found, there were two sets of sheaves to guide the rope round the curve.

5,360. That is to guide the rope in the Maudlin seam? — Yes; there were four uprights for the two sheaves, and upon the top of each of those uprights there was a cross-piece, and laid upon that cross-piece were fixed little wheels to keep the rope up to the tail-rope. Two of those cross-pieces were blown out, and two were left standing. The two that were blown out were pointing up the hole — blown from east to west.

5,361. Where the Maudlin engine plane goes up, there were cross-pieces blown from east to west? — Yes.

5,362. That was chose to where Simpson's body was found? — Yes.

5,363. How was Simpson lying when you found him? — As I described before, he was lying against one of these uprights with his head towards the Maudlin seam, his feet towards No. 3 shaft.

Lying on his face?

(The Coroner.) I think we have already got the position Simpson was lying in.

(The Witness.) He had his face towards the wall. I am almost certain about it.

5,364. (Mr. Edge.) Going along the curve westward to the down-cast, did you notice anything else? There was nothing to see there whatever.

5,365. Did you find any indication where the Maudlin travelling way leaves the curve? — I found the floor had been broken down there, and a communication established between the curve drifts and the road leading into the furnace.

5,366. What other indications did you find there? — There was nothing particular there.

5,367. Was there any fall along there? — There were two large falls; there was a very large fall just at that point where you go down to the furnace.

5,368. How far did that fall continue? — Eight or ten yards perhaps, at the outside.

5,369. Was there anything on that fall to give you any indication as to how the force had come? — Not much, it was bad to tell. I am inclined to think that it fell after the explosion, from what the witnesses said.

5,370. Then we will go along from the fall on back to the bottom of the shaft No. 1 pit; were there any indications between that fall and No. 1 pit shaft? — No, there was not much there; there was not much to see there at all; there were four tubs stood there on the right-hand side of the road as you go to the shaft; they were unharmed.

5,371. Do you mean they were between the entrance to the Maudlin travelling way and the No. 1 shaft? — Yes; I do not know what to draw from that.

5,372. I do not ask you to draw anything? — They were unharmed. When you got to the shaft you found the same thing repeated as on the other side, the iron work was driven into the shaft, the iron lattice-work protecting No. 2 pit to prevent men or tubs and things falling down, that was driven into the pit too.

5,373. (Mr. A. Jones.) Driven into the shaft, you mean? — Yes.

5,374. Driven south? — Yes.

5,375. (Mr. Edge.) Did you see any timber between the Maudlin travelling way and the shaft which gave you any indication? — I cannot recall anything at this moment.

(Mr. Edge.) With regard to the cabin, I do not think I need go into that.

(Mr. A. Jones.) No. Perhaps I might say it will save my covering this ground again; do you take it that the cabin top was blown from the Maudlin side?

(Mr. Edge.) It is blown from the cabin into those drifts; but how it was blown of course cannot be agreed upon; it was blown by the force of the explosion, no doubt.

(Mr. A. Jones.) Very good.

5,376. (Mr. Edge.) Now go to the boilers of No. 1 and No. 2? — These are No. 1 boilers (pointing to the plan.)

5,377. Is there any door between No. 1 in-take engine plane and that No. 1 boiler? — Blown from the in-take to the boilers.

5,378. Did you find one of the bars that had been somewhere before the boiler; one of the rails — you remember a rail being found driven into the coal? — Oh, yes, it was through another door; there is another door at the end.

5,379. Could you say where the rail came from? — Yes, it came from the tramway laid down to carry the coals to the fires.

5,380. Did that tramway lead in from No. 1 engine plane to the boilers? — Yes.

5,381. Did you find one of the rails of that tramway lifted up, and driven into the coal? — Into the rubbish.

5,382. About three feet? — Three or four feet.

5,383. Opposite that boiler there was a wall, I think? — Yes, a wall divided the in-take from the return.

5,384. That wall was blown into the return? — Yes.

5,385. What appearance did the machinery connected with the boiler and the boiler present? How were the flues, for instance? — The tubes of the boiler had their dampers up, the fireman was in there getting his steam up for the morning; one damper was shut; of course there was no damage done to the two dampers that were up, the damper that was down was blown into the flue towards the up-cast.

5,386. No. 1 pit? — It was towards No. 1 pit.

5,387. Was there anything else you noticed at those No. 1 boilers? — Nothing much except that the stopping at the back of the boilers was injured, there was an air leak through there after the explosion.

5,388. Was that blown in any direction, or only injured? — I could not tell; it was just shattered.

5,389. Well, now, I think I will take you down to the Maudlin seam, I believe there was a heavy fall; we will go in on the engine plane, there was a heavy fall right along that engine plane? — A close fall, quite close.

5,390. You could not get through? — Not at all.

5,391. How far did that extend? — I should think the fall would be 30 or 40 yards long.

5,392. How did you get into the Maudlin? — By the travelling way.

5,393. Were there any falls in the travelling way? — There was a very large fall.

5,394. Did you find any indications in the Maudlin seam of how the force had gone? — They were not so plain in the Maudlin as in the other seams on account of the continual fall ; but in the travelling way there was a place in which there was a wall built at each side of the road; those bricks were knocked and lying on the ground, and if they were moved at all, they were moved from the Maudlin towards the shaft; they were not moved very much, but they were moved. Further in-bye in the Maudlin there were indications.

5,395. What was your conclusion from any indications you found in the Maudlin? — No doubt it went down the engine plane into the Maudlin; there was some arching there, about 40 yards of arching, and there were wheels to carry the tail ropes spiked into the sides of the wall, two of those wheels were knocked out and driven by each about five yards, the others that were not knocked out were knocked over as if they had received a blow in that direction.

5,396. (Mr. A. Jones.) You are, speaking of the engine plane now? — Yes.

5,397. (Mr. Edge.) As far as you could judge it, the blast had gone in-bye there? — There is no doubt. We come now to a point where the blast ceases, and those men were living unfortunately for a long time.

5,398. (The Coroner.) What point is that where the men were alive? — Here, sir (pointing).

5,399. Have you any means of knowing they were alive? — We have written records.

5,400. (Mr. Edge.) I think they wrote something on a board? — On a board and other things, and other articles; we have a great many writings on boards and doors.

5,401. Is there anything to indicate how long these men had lived after the explosion? — The last record we had was dated six o'clock; we know there were three men got in between these two doors (pointing), and two men wrote about six o'clock that they were getting very weak; there was no more writing after that.

5,402. That is the latest in date of the records, so far as you can tell? — Yes.

5,403. As a matter of fact, how long did it take you before you were able to get in to where these men were? — We did not get in to these until the 28th or 30th of September; I suppose about that time.

5,404. Of course you could not get in without carrying the air in with you? — We could not get in there at all at first, there was no room for anything; they were close falls all over.

5,405. You had to clear the falls and take your air in with you? — Yes.

5,406. Could you, as a matter of fact, have got there any sooner than you did? — Not unless we had taken that No. 1 out of its turn. We had to take the pits in their turn; of course we could not work these any sooner.

5,407. Tell me why you could not have worked another at the same time you were getting into No. 1? — Because we only had the wheel for the one pit.

5,408. You only had air power to carry you into one pit at a time? — We were depending upon that for the whole time, and we could not possibly explore two pits with safety.

5,409. As a matter of fact you took No. 1 before you took that Maudlin seam? — Yes.

5,410. When you found fire in the east Maudlin, I suppose you reported to the board? — Yes.

5,411. (The Coroner.) What was that? — The first Friday in October.

5,412. (Mr. Edge.) Where you discovered the fire there was a fall between you and the fire? — A fall all the way down here, and there was a fall between us and the fire; that fall was a very large one no doubt.

5,413. What size was the opening through that fall? — It was a very small opening; a man could get through.

(The Coroner.) That has been given before.

5,414. (Mr. Edge.) Did you report the facts fully to the Board of advisers? — Most certainly.

5,415. And I think they decided unanimously that it would not be safe to continue the explorations until that fire was put out? — Yes, that was so.

5,416. Was it on their advice that the Maudlin seam was sealed up? — Entirely under the advice of the board of consultation.

5,417. I take it you did everything, you and the inspectors, and that Mr. Atkinson and that Mr. Leasham, and Mr. Hall, and Mr. Forster, and the other gentlemen — everything you could to get the men out as expeditiously as possible? — I think everybody must admit we did everything that could be done to get them out.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) We have the fullest recognition of that on the notes of the last meeting.

5,418. (Mr. Edge.) You have told us in the north Maudlin the blast seemed to have stopped at that landing? — Yes.

5,419. Going in the east Maudlin, were there any indications of how far the blast had gone there? — There was very little as to which way it had gone; as I say, there is a fall from this turn, in fact, up here it is a long fall, but there are one or two places where there are props standing at the corners of the refuge holes, and my own opinion is that there were two or three props and one or two baulks of the roof which led me to believe that it had gone in, but that is all I can say. There was nothing by which anybody could form a positive opinion.

5,420. There was nothing to afford a strong indication? — Nothing, but I most certainly saw nothing that came out.

5,421. Was there anything at the crossing going into the entrances? — The crossing was blown right and left.

5,422. It was blown into the return? — It was blown into the return.

5,423. What was that — a wood or brick crossing? — A brick crossing.

5,424. Did you find any of the bricks thrown towards the east Maudlin? — They were just standing there.

5,425. You have practically told us all the indications you found in the Maudlin seam? — Yes, all the principal ones.

5,426. Was there any damage done to the return, so far as you could say, except where these crossings were damaged in the Maudlin? — Except where the doors were damaged, there were a pair of doors blown out there, and at that point there was no damage to the return.

5,427. You know where the Geordie bank is? — Yes.

5,428. That lies east of the No. 1 Hutton? — Yes.

5,429. Between the shaft and the first in-take? — It goes direct up the shaft to the east.

5,430. In your judgment, could any accumulation of gas take place there? — I should say not, certainly.

5,431. Where does the return lead to? — No. 1 return comes down here, and that is the proper return ; but the air takes that road (pointing) and goes out through there (pointing), and goes up back here again (pointing) A portion of that No. 1 Hutton air circulates down there, and then there is another portion of No. 2 pit air comes in here, and comes along No. 3 pit again (pointing).

5,432. Which furnace does that lead to? — No. 3; the air travels towards No. 3.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) May I suggest that the question was whether the air did not sometimes slacken so much as to reverse.

5,433. (Mr. Edge.) Have you ever known, either from one of the furnaces being damped down or from any other cause, any slackening in the air, causing the air practically to reverse or stagnate in the Geordie bank? — No, it goes constantly towards No. 3 furnace. It may go less at one time than another; but there is a constant current travelling from the Geordie bank to No. 3.

5,434. That has been your experience? — I should say so.

5,435. (Mr. Bell.) Could you get through from the top of the Geordie bank round the No. 1 furnace — is there any communication? — Oh yes, the No. 2 return is a double one ; the return comes along there at that point — (pointing) — another comes here; of course that road is open; there are ever so many roads the air can take.

5,436. The air from the Geordie bank could either get to No. 1 or No. 3 furnace? — Yes.

5,437. Did you ever see any gas in the roads between the two places? — I never saw any myself, and I never heard of any.

5,438. Not in that drift? — No, I never heard of any other at all. That is the No. 2 return.

5,439. (Mr. Edge.) Do you remember a chain leading into the Maudlin — the rapper rope chain, and going into the Maudlin? — That is the same place I spoke of where the chain wheels were spiked into the walls ; the rapper chain was driven into the arching.

5,440. In which direction? — It appeared to be driven in-bye as far as I could see; it was just buried in the wall.

5,441. (The Coroner.) About as far as the east Maudlin did you see the extent to it? — We have a very good idea of the extent of it from this, and we came as far as it was possible for men to go without further means, and we knew we were 60 yards from the stables, and at the point where we were the stone was burnt ; therefore, I roughly conclude, the fire had more or less extended 60 yards in this direction. How far it had gone the other way I could not say.

5,442. You were of opinion it was absolutely necessary to wall up the seam? — To put the fire out.

5,443. You considered that that was the only thing to be done? — Yes, it was the only way we could do it without risk.

5,444. Now, about unsealing it again. What is the opinion with reference to that? — I have not formed any opinion upon it, because I have not been there.

5,445. You could not form any opinion unless you had been there? — I should not like to form an opinion unless I knew the circumstances since I left the place.

5,446. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Supposing an explosion of the magnitude we know did take place in this colliery had commenced in the east Maudlin and from thence spread throughout the whole mine so as to produce the effects we know were produced, would you expect or not that there would be much greater wreck and ruin immediately outside the Maudlin? — One reason why I do not believe it originated there is that at this point there is a very bad place, full of timber, and that is still standing; it is not burnt at all ; it is the only part left secure.

5,447. If it had come out of the Maudlin you would have expected that to be touched? — Yes.

5,448. (The Coroner.) And also fired? — I will not say fired; I should have expected to have found that gone.

5,449. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Then taking that crossing which you say was blown north and south, is not the very fact of the absence of any decided indication which way the blast came rather in itself some evidence that it did not come out of the Maudlin? — I should say so, and we find it stopped there ; it has made no great destruction there where it stopped.

5,450. On what principle did you determine that you would relieve the men in No. 1 Hutton? You had to choose between two. On what principle did you select No. 1 Hutton to be relieved? — The reason was, the only hole to the Maudlin at that time was just where a man could squeeze through. We could have got into No. 1 pit very much sooner than into the Maudlin — in fact, there was some chance — enormously more chance — of success.

5,451. (The Coroner.) Have you heard of any man found dead having his lamp burning? — No.

5,452. As far as you know there was no man found dead, with his lamp still burning? — We did not get to the lower level until six o'clock.

(The Coroner.) If there is any man in court who can speak to any man being found dead with his lamp burning, I would ask him to offer himself as a witness.

5,453. (Mr. Edge.) What kind of lamp was Ramshaw's? — A Clanny lamp.

5,454. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) It is suggested that some man might have been found fallen upon his lamp with marks of burning on his clothes, showing that his lamp continued to burn after he had fallen upon it? — I have just heard of it. The Coroner asked me the question just now. I have been asked if it was true before, but that is all I know of it.

5,455. You cannot help us to find the person who has stated such a thing? — I could not. I have been asked the question myself — Did such a thing happen? and I have just given the same reply.

(The Coroner.) If there is anyone who has knowledge of it, we should be glad to examine him.

Adjourned for a short time.

5,456. (Mr. Edge.) It was mentioned yesterday that you had discharged a deputy for allowing men to work in the Belcher flat, where there was gas? — That is true.

5,457. Give your own description of what occurred? — The fact was, one day I went into the place, and there were two men working where there was gas. I examined the brattice way, and found it was so that I could not travel up and down it, and I found fault with the deputy, and discharged him in consequence. The gas was there, because there was no wind road. We made a wind road, and the gas disappeared.

5,458. In your judgment you blamed the deputy for allowing the men to work there at the time, and discharged him? — Yes.

5,459. Had there been any complaint to you about the place previously? — No.

5,460. We have been told, I think by Spence, yesterday, that some five or six years ago gas was found within some 60 yards of one of the furnaces? — Yes; that is a long time since; that was in 1874, the 23rd October.

5,461. What furnace was that? — No. 3.

5,462. Did you take any steps? — The fact was there was a most extraordinary fall of the barometer that day; everybody knows in that neighbourhood it was a most extraordinary fall of the barometer, and gas did show there, but we have taken steps since to cure it.

5,463. As a matter of fact there has been something like £2,000. spent to prevent such a thing occurring here? — Yes.

5,464. And these steps were taken, I suppose, immediately? — Immediately.

5,465. Since that time I think there has been no trace of gas in that neighbourhood? — Nothing.

5,466. (Mr. Wright.) I understand your opinion to be, taking the things bodily, that the explosion cannot have commenced at any of the working places? — Yes, that is my opinion.

5,467. Neither in the No. 1 Hutton far-off nor east end working place, nor in No. 3 working place, nor in the Maudlin north west or east working place? — That is my opinion.

5,468. I am not talking about its coming out of these pits, but as regards the working places? — That is my opinion.

5,469. Am I right also in supposing that it is your opinion, judging from what you have observed, that the explosion did not take place in any of the returns? — Yes, I am decidedly of that opinion.

5,470. It must have taken place in some in-take or other? — Yes.

5,471. Before going further, answer this question generally, if you can ; it is peculiarly within your notice. According to the manner in which the colliery has been laid out and worked, is it in your judgment possible that gas can have got from any of the returns into any of the in-takes before the explosion? — I should say not.

5,472. Is there any part of the workings of the colliery as to which you can suggest that such a thing could, in a sufficient extent, have happened? — I should certainly say not.

5,473. So that we get this problem: that the explosion clearly happened in some in-take or other, and that no gas can be traced into any in-take? — That is my opinion.

5,474. Can you suggest any way in which the apparent contradiction happened? — I daresay there would be difference of opinion as to how it happened, and will be to the end of time.

5,475. You have not at present formed any distinct opinion? — I have not formed any sufficiently definite opinion that I could give as a positive fact.

5,476. Then, if you please, I will take you shortly through the main points. First of all we want to come to the place where the explosion happened. Your opinion is that it did not come out of any part — I am now talking only of the workings — it did not come out of any part of No. 3 Hutton? — I do not think it did.

5,477. Where do you mean No. 3 Hutton ends; was it in the part westward of Venner's shot? — Well, we have indications about 250 yards westward of Venner's shot.

5,478. Taking the whole of the indications in No. 3 Hutton, I understand your opinion to be that it did not originate? I will put it in this form — that it did not originate in No. 3 Hutton less than 250 yards from Venner's shot? — No, I do not think it did.

5,479. Is that a fair way of putting it? — I think so, if I understand your question.

5,480. I do not wish to lead you into any admission; I only want to narrow the field of inquiry as much as possible. Substantially, you do not think it came out of No. 3 Hutton? — I do not think it did.

5,481. And substantially, in the same way, I gather you do not think it came out of either part of the Maudlin? — I do not think it did.

5,482. And shall I be right in saying the real question, in your judgment, is between No. 1 Hutton, somewhere in the region of the Polka return, on the one hand, as one alternative, and the region between Venner's shot and we will say Brown's shot as the other alternative? — Yes, those are the most likely; there are two regions.

5,483. Do you agree that these are practically the two regions between which we have to narrow the Inquiry so far as we can tell at present? — I should say so.

5,484. In your judgment is there any reason to suppose that the explosion can have originated at the furnace? — I should think decidedly the contrary. In neither case has any injury gone inwards from the furnace; the returns are intact within 10 yards from the furnace.

5,485. The furnaces were in the returns? — Yes.

5,486. If the explosion occurred in any in-take, that is the same thing as saying it did not occur at either of the furnaces? — Yes, that is so.

5,487. Your view as to the place where the explosion occurred has been clearly enough conveyed as being somewhere between No. 1 shaft and the Polka return? — Yes.

5,488. Have you formed any more precise conclusion in your own mind as to the exact point where the explosion occurred than that? — The region first pointed out, namely, between the main coal staple and the Polka return, would take, in my mind, all the possibilities.

5,489. I am taking the lower half, which you prefer. You say it may have occurred in the upper half of that region, between the main coal staple and No. 1 shaft; but you rather think it occurred in the lower half, between No. 1 shaft and the Polka return? — I should be inclined to think it. Of the two opinions I should be inclined to give it that way, but I do not hold either sufficiently strong.

5,490. Do you think, from your own observation of the indications and from what you have heard, you could give any definite opinion as to which of these two regions it happened in? — I would be very far from giving a confident opinion about it.

5,491. I do not ask you to pin yourself; but is there a clear preponderance in your own mind in favour of one place as the region of the explosion rather than the other? — I would certainly say, in my own mind, the preponderance with the Polka.

5,492. Not a strong preponderance? — Not strong enough to make me assert the thing.

5,493. We are very anxious to know exactly how far the opinion you have expressed is an opinion which you think ought to guide us in our judgment upon this matter, or whether you think it is a matter still open, so far as your judgment is concerned, to be determined in another way? — I think it is a matter still open to be decided.

5,494. In your judgment, what point near the Polka turn should you select as the place where most probably the explosion occurred? — If I were to select, I should select a point at the Polka turn.

5,495. Exactly at the Polka turn? — Yes.

5,496. Supposing the explosion had happened at the Polka turn, how far is that from the cabin where Laverick was? — About half a mile.

5,497. Going half a mile in the other direction, to the southward, the effects of the explosion were enormously strong; it lifted a half-ton wheel? — It was very strong.

5,498. Would not you have expected Laverick to have been blown to pieces if the blast had gone straight out of No. 1 into his cabin? — No, it does not follow. In the first place, it would have to pass the shaft; the shaft gives it enormous liberty, and then the shaft siding is very large. There is a great open space, and you see in the Maudlin seam it had ample open space to expand itself. That would ease the shock passing the shaft.

5,499. There are other places also where the blast would get very much ease in the direction of the other shaft? — Yes, in the same way.

5,500. First of all there is the No. 1 shaft, where it would get enormously eased? — Yes.

5,501. Then travelling towards the Maudlin, what is the next place where it would get eased? — The furnace, which has a direct communication to the upcast pit; it would go right through the furnace to this pit.

5,502. Is there no other place where it would get very much eased before it would get into No. 3 Hutton? — Yes.

5,503. Looking at all these opportunities for that blast getting ease before it got to No. 3 Hutton, does not it strike you the evidence is to the effect on No. 3 Hutton is rather stronger than you would expect if it had come out of No. 1 Hutton? — They are no stronger than the reverse case, an explosion happening in No. 3 Hutton seam affecting No. 1 pit.

5,504. You mean they are equal difficulties; but I thought you had disposed of the question of all this coming out of No. 3 Hutton? — But supposing it did come anywhere here — anywhere about this No. 3 pit — there are the two places where the shock has reached, at the two extreme faces of the mine (pointing).

5,505. You do not think your theory of the place of the origin is at all shaken by the fact that in order to get to No. 3 Hutton and do the damage it did there it would have to pass three or four places where it would be so much eased? — I could account for it by an explosion passing No. 1 shaft and being increased on its road.

5,506. Supposing the explosion originated at the Polka, having all these places to ease itself at besides the Maudlin, would not it strike you as rather improbable that it still had the power to exercise the force it did in No. 3 Hutton? — No, I do not think it would.

5,507. Do you happen to know that there was a wheel weighing 10 cwt. on the incline in No. 3 Hutton blown about 30 yards? — It was blown 33 yards.

5,508. That is something like a mile and a half from the Polka turn, according to the road, the old Hutton incline? — There is where it is.

5,509. That would be something like one and a half miles from the Polka turn by the road it would have to travel? — Not quite a mile and a half.

5,510. A mile and a quarter, if you like. It would have to pass all these places, the road into the Maudlin and shafts, and all the rest of it. Would it be likely? Do you think that is quite consistent with having begun at the Polka turn? — I do not think it is inconsistent you could account for it on that theory.

5,511. I am told that about half a mile south of the Polka turn in-bye into the No. 1 Hutton there was a similar wheel, weighing about half a ton, blown 1 foot in-bye? — I am quite sure there is no truth in that; there was not a single thing in No. 1.

5,512. But a wheel about the same weight? — No, a wheel that was shifted here was a much heavier article than the wheel-bye in here, and much more solidly fixed.

5,513. I do not know if you are able to tell me what the prospect would be of diminution of force; from the Polka turn to where the winch was up was something about half a mile, from the Polka turn to where the other wheel was, something like 1¼ miles. The distance would be very much more than accounted for the difference in weight between the two, the difference in distance would show it? — The fact of the matter is it is a very peculiar thing altogether. There have been things shifted which you would not expect, and things left which you would not have expected to be left. At that particular point where you are talking about — Venner's shot — there were two chests, a large and a small; it shifted the large chest a very great way, and left the small chest intact, never moved it at all.

5,514. In fact, that is so in all these explosions? — They are very capricious.

5,515. It is extremely difficult to tell by the indication of which way things are blown where explosives come from? — I have no other guide.

5,516. You have back lash to account for? — That can only exist under peculiar circumstances.

5,517. Do you include in back lash the effect of air compressed by the advancing blast into the corners of the workings, and which, when the blast has cooled, rushes out again? — That is what I call after blast ; it can only happen in places where it reaches the face.

5,518. If the explosion is very powerful it would always do it? — If it reached every corner of the place it would, but not otherwise.

5,519. How soon would the compressed air regain its normal state of tension? — Take No. 1 seam, where it goes no further in than here (pointing), it would have all the chambers in here to compress.

5,520. But still they would re-assert themselves? — There are more of them, and there are so many roads out.

5,521. That is your view, that the back lash or whatever it is called, is not sufficient in this case to account for the out-bye symptoms I have mentioned in No. 1 Hutton? — I should not say it was.

5,522. You do not think it is enough for that? — No.

5,523. Turn for a moment to where there is the engine-plane into the Maudlin, and the travelling road into the Maudlin on the curve of No. 1 shaft. I think you told us that there was great wreck and ruin in the engine plane, and that there was no wreck or ruin in the travelling plane? — Oh, yes, it was completely ruined.

5,524. You told us you could not get along the engine-plane? — You could not get along, and you could hardly get along the other one.

5,525. You could get along? — But it was all destroyed.

5,526. That certainly was not the impression you made on me. I understood you to say it was impossible to get along the engine plane, but there was no particular difficulty in getting along the travelling way? — There was a great difficulty; in fact the hole was not big enough to admit a bag of sawdust.

5,527. You did not mean to say that there was any very great difference between them? — There was not a pin to choose between them for falling.

5,528. I am afraid I cannot accept that, because you have said you could get through one, but you could not get through the other? — A place may be equally bad for fall and not closed — it is a mere accident, the closing. A fall ten yards long may close a place, and a fall a mile long may not close it.

5,529. Is it your opinion that they were equally damaged? — I should say so as a matter of fact. They commenced to open this road out at the same time as that, and they were down there three days before this, if that is any test.

5,530. Supposing that they, were equally damaged ; just follow this blast coming out of No. 1 Hutton. I suppose it is pretty easy to see on the plan the way it would get into the travelling road; it would go straight into it; no obstacle whatever? — None.

5,531. Supposing it was to get from No. 1 Hutton into the engine plane, what road would it have to take? — It would have to go that way (pointing).

5,532. Does it seem to you that it is very likely that if it had to get round in that way, it would do as much damage to the engine plane as if it had gone straight in? — I think that would account for it. This is how I account for it. There is a curved drift about 100 yards long. In that drift there was a quantity of dust flying. It is my belief you could see the fire ignite that dust by means of the cloud raised by the explosion itself, and that would cause another explosion.

5,533. In order to get the same amount of damage in the engine plane as we had in the travelling plane, you think it proper to call in aid, the supposition that the explosion was intensified by dust? — Certainly.

5,534. Without that you do not think it is likely to have happened? — I do not think it would.

5,535. Have you taken into consideration as to whether it could do as much damage in that engine plane as in the travelling plane; have you taken into consideration that the blast in coming out of the No. 1 Hutton would be very much eased at the shaft? — Yes.

5,536. Is that the only part of the mine where you suppose an explosion of coal dust would have intensified an explosion of gas? — I do not think so.

5,537. What other part of the mine do you think it took place in? — Everywhere where dust existed in any quantity.

5,538. You think in all parts of the in-take it has been burnt where it existed? — As far as it existed.

5,539. Was there no dust in the travelling road in the Maudlin? — There would not be to the same extent.

5,540. Why not? — It was dust of a different description.

5,541. In what way different? — The current is not so great; there is less wind goes down the travelling way, therefore there may not be the same amount of dust deposited.

5,542. What does dust arise from? — From the shaft, from the surface.

5,543. Does not it come from the tubs? — No, it comes from the surface.

5,544. I do not ask you where the dust near the shaft alone comes from? — The dust here (pointing) comes from the surface.

5,545. Take dust a mile off, where does that come from? — That would come from the trituration of the coal particles.

5,546. Does anything that carries coal pass along the engine plane into the Maudlin? — Yes, it has to pass along there.

5,547. Regularly? — Yes.

5,548. Do they also pass along the travelling way? — No.

5,549. Therefore there would naturally be more dust on the engine plane, even apart from what came to bank, than on the travelling way? — I think it would be.

5,550. I have no other points on that part to put to you. Having had your attention pointedly called to what seems to me an objection of some weight to your theory as to where the blast came from, do you think your opinion is at all modified by that? — I have had that very objection called to my mind months ago.

5,551. It does not in any way modify your judgment in that matter? — It modifies it to this extent, that I have not formed any positive judgment whatever.

5,552. I really do not think I am justified in pressing you any further. Your judgment is, it came out of the Polka so far as we have gone on with it? — I do not think anybody can give a theory, that is not beset with difficulties at every turn.

5,553. I will go no further on that point, but will put to you one or two things that were not asked, and that you happened not to mention, with reference to No. 1. The first point suggested either by you, or to you, as a sign that the blast had come out of the No. 1 Hutton, and not gone into it, was that the lattice-work was bulged on the south side of the shaft from south to north? — Yes.

5,554. You told us afterwards, but I think hardly in a way that would show the significance of it, that it was also bulged from the north side, south towards the shaft? — Yes.

5,555. One balances the other entirely? — Yes.

5,566. You cannot use, as you did, the bulging from the south side to the north as any argument greater than the argument that would have followed, stating that it bulged also from north to south? — Mr. Edge, in my examination did not ask me for any argument at all; he asked me for facts.

5,557. I mean it cannot be used as an argument? — You can argue as you like, it is open to everybody to argue.

5,558. Is it not fair for me to say you can draw no greater inference from one than from the other? — That may be fair to say so.

5,559. The lattice-work I have dealt with, the tubs between the shafts and the air crossing; the bodies of some of these had been sheared off the bottoms, had not they? — Yes, I daresay they were.

5,560. In-bye? — There might be some in-bye, and there might be some out-bye.

5,561. There were two cabins near the in-bye stables. The wreckage of these had been struck on the out-bye side? — One cabin near the stables that I spoke of; I have told you already there were two props there which pointed inwards, but I do not think anything was blown in-bye on the other cabin, I cannot admit that.

5,562. One cabin was one way, and one the other? — The other cabin was blown in that direction, east to west, along a passage; that cabin was situated in a passage, and was blown from east to west.

5,563. There is the cover of the wheel of No. 1 engine, that was blown in-bye? — I never saw it; I have heard that it was, but I never saw it.

5,564. In the same drift there is some brickwork above a door frame, that was partly blown in over? — That is in the return, it is the east stables.

5,565. That would not show anything? — There was nothing in that.

5,566. The last point I will put to you is on the road between the shaft and the first stables; there were three fires? — Yes, there were three fires.

5,567. Were there any parts on fire except the fires you have mentioned? Were there any parts that had been fired by the blast in that part of the road? — Not that I know of.

5,568. (The Coroner.) Would there be any large accumulation of dust at those points? — Yes ; the fires in the boiler-house was where there had been a large donkey-house; I have no doubt it was full of grease and cotton waste, — very apt to fire ; the engine-house would be apt to fire from precisely the same reason, — it was an extremely dry place, it would be like tinder, and would fire readily. In this place, the stables, the hay had fired; those are all things you would expect to fire.

5,569. Then the hay was blown about No. 1 Hutton, about the intake, south of the northern stables? — Between the two stables.

5,570. Was there any hay blown about north of the out-bye stables? Take it in this way ; all the hay blown about the No. 1 in-take was unburnt? — Yes.

5,571. Does it occur to you as probable if that hay had been blown about by the first fiery blast coming from the Polka turn that that hay could have remained unburnt? — I do not see any reason to dispute it. If the blast did come out there it would go straight.

5,572. The hay would be sucked out afterwards? — Yes; there have been known cases of explosion where two men have been lying dead side by side, one man burnt to an ash and the other man not touched.

5,573. That again is consistent with either view? — Yes.

5,574. Supposing the blast had come in to No. 1 Hutton, it might have sucked the hay out after it, and the back lash might have scattered the hay where it was? — It might be so.

5,575. (Mr. Wright.) We have dealt with the place where the explosion happened; I shall not be so long on the other points. Now I want to ask you how you think the gas got there? — Well, that is a very difficult point.

5,576. First of all I will ask you again if you think that you fix the Polka turn as the probable place at which the gas was fired or originated? — If we could always account for gas coming from different places there would never be any explosion.

5,577. You do think the Polka turn was where it came from? — If it so fired.

5,578. No, not where it was fired, but where it came from? — It is not necessary to know where it originated if you know where it fired.

5,579. I must proceed by steps. I simply ask you whether you adhere to what I understood you to say just now, or rather what I apprehended you to say, that is that you thought the explosion originated somewhere about the Polka turn? — I would say the balance of opinion is that way.

5,580. That is the point you fixed? — Yes.

5,581. Is not it a fact that the whole of the in-take there is very old working? — Yes.

5,582. Very old? — Yes.

5,583. How many years old? — 18 or 20.

5,584. Have you ever known any fall of roof, producing gas, to occur in that part of the in-take? — No, I cannot say I have, but after the explosion happened there was gas on the in-take there on the day after the explosion.

5,585. I suppose there was gas all over the pit after the explosion, the artificial ventilation had entirely disappeared? — Oh, no, this second in-take was travelled down to about this point (pointing).

5,586. The furnaces were just out, were not they? — I was going to tell you; this in-take was travelled down to here (pointing). It was travelled back from where the gas was seen.

5,587. Whereabouts was the gas seen? — About four pillars up from this point.

5,588. That is not the Polka turn? — No; but the current of air, the draft coming in it, would bring it from the Polka turn. The air would be coming along the engine plane as along the in-take.

5,589. Point out where the gas was seen, will you? — I did not see it myself; it was reported as being seen; it is in the report book.

5,590. We will take it so far as you can tell us? — I should say about four pillars from the third east way end as far as I have been told, and by the report book.

5,591. What is there to show it did not come from No. 3 east? — Because No. 3 east was clear.

5,592. Or from the goaf close by these — what is there to show that it did not come from that goaf? — The simple fact that it did not come from the goaf was that this (pointing) was clean; I can speak to that mine (pointing).

5,593. The crossing was gone at the in-take or at the very point where this gas was seen? — How do you mean?

5,594. Far down where the gas was seen? — There was fresh air coming in here (pointing).

5,595. There (pointing to the plan) is where the gas was seen? — About here.

5,596. That crossing was gone, was it not? — Yes.

5,597. If the crossing was gone, and gas coming out of the goaf into the return, would not that account for the gas being seen there? — Most certainly not.

5,598. I have no doubt you are perfectly right; I only want to get at it. Is there anything else to account for it in your judgment, besides its coming from the direction of the Polka? — If there are two in-takes and both in-takes come in here, then the air certainly was travelling in here and going round by return. That return was clear, and there was a current of air going along it.

5,599. I am quite in your hands, Mr. Stratton, because I do not know what was happening — I simply ask, in your judgment, as far as you know, whether there was any other way in which, at the time it was reported, gas could have got to that point except by coming from the Polka. I only want to know whether there was any other way? — I do not see any other way of getting it there.

5,600. That is a fair answer? — I do not know that anybody else has ever seen gas in that goaf since I came to the colliery.

5,601. Whereabouts from the Polka did it come, in your judgment? — That is just the point; I cannot tell you.

5,602. You do not know? — I do not know.

5,603. Is there anything to show that it did not come from much further out-bye than the Polka turn? — It did not come from here, that return was clear at the time.

5,604. Point out the limits within which it could have started? — It could have started from anywhere about here (pointing).

5,605. That is where the south-west stables are? — Yes.

5,606. It might have started from anywhere about there? — People have explored along here also.

5,607. Were there not bits of gas all over that mine at that time? — Not on the in-takes.

5,608. There were in the returns? — There were in the returns.

5,609. Was there no gas in the in-takes into No. 3 Hutton during the process of exploration? — There was not the first day.

5,610. Was there the second or third day? — It did afterwards accumulate simply because that is a different pit, that is to the rise.

5,611. That old goaf is to the rise where the gas was found, it is from the rise to the Polka, is it not? — Which?

5,612. From that old goaf, you know the goaf I mean, the Polka is to the rise of that, is it not? — Yes, the Polka is to the rise of that.

5,613. To the rise of that goaf? — Yes, it is.

5,614. And the place where gas was seen is to the rise of that goaf? — No, I cannot admit that.

If it is not so I do not want you to admit it.

5,615. (Mr. Bell.) Would not the circulation be cut off if the far crossing was destroyed? — Yes, there was no circulation here, the circulation might get in by air going in here.

5,616. That is on the other side? — Yes, these doors were blown out. As a matter of fact there was air coming in, because people got down to here (pointing).

5,617. If the circulation of air was cut off in that east side return, would not that allow the gas to come from that goaf and get down where the Polka doors were blown out into the main in-take, which would account for that gas that you speak of? — No, I do not think it would ; the gas was cleared next day, and we had not renewed that crossing; the gas was cleared away before that crossing was renewed, and the circulation restored.

5,618. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Your answer is that until the explosion you had never known gas to come off that part of the in-take? — I had not.

5,618a. Have you ever known any falls? — No.

5,619. For how many years before? — I have been there seven years.

5,620. Take the other part, what I am going to call "the region of shots," from Venner's shot to Brown's shot ; that is very old, is it not, also? — That will be much older than this.

5,621. Did you ever, in the whole of your seven years, know gas come off in that region of shots? — Not on the in-take.

5,622. The in-take I am speaking of? — No.

5,623. Nor any fall of roof? — No.

5.624. Therefore this occurs equally in both places? — Yes.

5,625. It is a very unlikely place for gas to form in? — Yes.

5,626. And very unlikely for gas to come off; if it did form in either of them? — Very.

5,627. Have you ever known any blowers in the Hutton seam, except some insignificant things? — We have known some very bad blowers.

5,628. In this colliery? Yes.

5,629. Whereabouts? — That (pointing to the plan) would not be nearly so old, I suppose, as the part we have been speaking of? — No; that is not so old as the part we have been speaking of.

5,630. There you have an in-take like the in-take of the Polka turn or the in-take between those shots; standing for a good many years it gets drained of gas probably? — I do not know that at all.

5,631. That is the reason you do not get gas or falls at such old places? — The reason in the Hutton seam is that it is a rock roof, it is a sandstone which rarely falls, it is a good roof.

5,632. Is not the reason that you do not gas partly because it has been standing so long that any gas there may have found its way out? — No, I do not think that is so with a rock roof.

5,633. How do you account for it in old places like the Polka turn, and between Venner's and Brown's shots there had been no gas seen at that time? — I account for it by the fact that there had been no falls for one reason.

5,634. If there had been falls you think there would have been gas? — I do not say that either.

5,636. I will put it in this way — is it not an entirely gratuitous assumption, and one of which there was no probability beforehand, to say that there was a fall or any escape of gas at any time before the explosion? — There is no reason why gas should not come from the roof.

5,636. Is there any reason why it should? — There is reason.

5,637. What reason? — The reason that blowers in the Hutton seam do come from the roof.

5,638. I am not talking of coming from the roof but at these parts (pointing). You know perfectly what I am asking you about. Can any sort of reason be given for its being probable that a fall should take place at these two points, or that gas should come off at these two points? — There was no probability, of course.

5,639. It would be more likely in a new in-take, I suppose? — You would more naturally expect it in a new place.

5,640. Why — I thought you said just now you would not? — The reason I would more naturally expect it in a new place is, that in the course of working in a new place you are opening out new strata that you have never seen in your life before, and do not know what you are coming to.

5,641. If it has been standing, for a great many years before that it is not so? — Not in its normal condition.

5,642. Not unless something happens to shake it down? — Yes.

5,643. I do not know whether you are accustomed to consider these questions at all, but considering what you have told me as to the condition of the ground — the Polka turn on the one hand, and the other places on the other — if you do not like to answer the question do not, but I was going to ask you whether you do not think it is not extremely improbable that a fall of roof, accompanied by an outburst of gas, took place at either of those two points until after the explosion? — Well, I do not know; you have falls of roof; you know.

5,644. If you do not like to answer the question you need not? — I do not quite understand the scope of it.

5,645. Is it not extremely improbable, from your knowledge of the mine, that the first gas that caused the explosion — (I will put it in that form if you like), came (before any other explosion, you know) from the roof at either of those two points, and so caused the mischief.

(The Coroner.) By a natural fall?

5,645a. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Yes, I will take it in the way the Coroner puts it — by a natural fall? — I should not think it more improbable than any of the other suggestions offered to me.

5,646. That is not the question. The question is is it not extremely improbable? — I should think so; "improbable," certainly.

5,647. I will put it in this form if you like. Before the explosion, was it not extremely improbable that there should be either a fall of roof or an escape of gas at either of those two places? — Yes, very improbable. Everybody thought it very improbable to have an explosion.

5,648. Now we pass to a totally distinct point. We have got where you rather think the explosion happened, but without any confidence as to the exact point. I suppose that is the only answer you can give as to how the gas got there? — Yes.

5,649. If it started at the Polka, it must have been a fall or a blower? — Yes, a fall of roof.

5,650. There are a lot of little "cracks" and "jacks," which have been there ever since you have been there? — There are cracks and jacks. I do not say they are old ones.

5,661. Have they not been there ever since you have been there? — I do not say that.

5,662. Do you mean to say that you do not know that there have been such things there all that time which you could put your hand into all along? — I did not know it.

5,663. You know it now? — I know it now, certainly.

5,664. There were? — I did not know that there were then.

5,666. I do not want you to admit anything further than you mean to admit. Do you know that there were before the explosion several cracks and jacks about the Polka? — No; I do not understand that to be so at all.

5,666. All you mean is, that since the explosion you have become aware that there are some, but as to their previous existence there you cannot speak; is that it? — That is it.

5,667. We will ask somebody else about that. How do you think the gas lighted at the Polka? — If it lighted there at all it would light at the lamp.

5,668. What lamp? — The Clanny.

5,669. There was but one lamp there, was there? — Yes.

5,660. What was the rate per second of the ventilation at the Polka turn? — Between 10 and 11 feet.

5,661. Is that dangerous? — To use a Clanny?

5,662. To use a Clanny under those circumstances? — The probability is, that most people would use a naked light.

5,663. Does not that go to strengthen the force of my former question as to the improbability of a fall of roof, accompanied by gas, at that point? — I do not deny that it is improbable.

5,664. That is the only theory you can give. If the explosion happened there, it must have happened by the gas coming out of a fall. If it went off at either, and that was the place, then it must have been lighted by the Clanny? — Yes, that is it.

5,665. Putting all those "ifs" together, you think it more likely than any other theory that can be Suggested? — I cannot give an opinion.

5,666. It is the most likely theory you can suggest? — I think it is.

5,667. Now let me ask a few questions about dust. You told me what, it strikes me, is very much as an answer that may throw a light upon the whole thing. As I understand you, you say there was dust in all parts of the mine, where the mine was burning or where the explosion extended? — What I did say about the burning was, that it burnt things which were likely to be burnt.

5,668. Without referring to what you said, is it the fact, so far as you observed, that the most destructive effects of the blast were exactly in those parts of the mine in which there was dust? — No, that does not exactly follow.

5,669. I mean in the natural way, is it not so? — Of course it is, because it has followed the in-take.

(The Coroner.) Three points the witness cleared up by saying there was grease and that sort of thing.

(The Witness.) It must have followed the dust to some extent, because it followed the in-takes, and that is the most dusty part.

5,670. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) You do not mean to put it any further than that? — No.

5,671. That the explosion was in the in-takes, and the in-takes are the dusty places? — As a rule they are.

5,672. You do not carry it further than that in your own judgment, you do not carry it to a closer connection than simply that the explosion was in the in-takes? No, I do not think I do.

5,673. Mr. Bell suggests that the velocity would be less than 10 at the Polka turn? — No, I think not.

(Mr. Bell.) Two roads?

(The Witness.) There is about 62,000 feet.

5,674-5. You give 45,000 in your statement, and take 25 off? — Why 25 off.

5,676. For the second road? — Yes, but the second road was no bigger than the other. There is no more reason for assuming that take-off than the other.

5,677. That would reduce it, you know? — Why ?

5,678. Because 25 is more than a half? — 25 on the in-take, you mean.

5,679. Yes? — The waggon way?

5,680. Yes; 25 on the waggon way would give it with the area that was there? — What area? I do not think there would be 30 feet.

5,681. Not 30 feet? — No, not on that particular point. It was rather a narrower place than ordinary just at the turn.

5,682. Is not the area more like 60 feet? — Oh, no, I beg your pardon; you can easily test that yet.

5,683. I think it has been measured? — It has.

Yes — —

(The Coroner.) You can have it tested if you think it worth while afterwards.

(Mr. Bell.) It is not worth while, but I and Mr. Willis measured it over 60, and, taking it at 60, it gives 10 feet per second.

5,684. (Mr. R. S. Wright to the witness.) You think the average was 30 feet? — I do not think it was more.

5,685. You are acquainted with the effects of carbonic oxide? — I am glad to say I am not acquainted with that.

5,686. Personally, you are not acquainted with that? — No, I am very glad to say.

5,687. Were there not symptoms of carbonic oxide about some parts of the mine while you were examining it, shortly after the explosion? — I could not say ; you could not tell much —

5,688. I will put it in another form. Were there not parts of the mine in which there was considerable after-damp, but in which, nevertheless, your lamps were not affected? — No.

5,689. You do not think so? — No.

5,690. Did you notice, during the progress of the explorations, that the heads or spirits of any of the party seemed affected? — I can speak for myself.

5,691. You will quite understand me; I am not making any foolish joke? — No, I was going to tell you; most of the exploration done in the after-damp, I may say, without any boasting, was done by myself.

5,692. I quite understand that, Mr. Stratton? — My lamp was the only one used, therefore I know more about it.

5,693. That is why I am asking you? — And I do not think it is so.

5,694. You, if anyone, could state what was the condition of things in the most dangerous part of the mine? — I do not believe I could have lived if there had been what you suggest; the lamp and the man go together; when the lamp became affected, the man became affected.

5,695. So far as you observed? — So far as I observed — quite so. I saw no place where the lamp was affected where I was not affected.

5,696. The last thing I have to ask you is this — If you can bring your mind for a moment to assume that the explosion did not come out of No. 1 Hutton, but went into it, where, in your judgment, did it originate? — We have already fixed upon a sort of two points — either two or three — what we might term a "centre of disturbance;" you have one here (pointing to plan), where it might be, which goes down to the Maudlin, and one from which it comes out to No. 3 Hutton seam, and you come here, in opposite ways, on the same ground, and there are two places at which possibly an explosion might originate; if it originated there, it might have those effects.

5,697. Can you put it any closer than that. In your judgment, if it did not come out of No. 1 Hutton, would it or would it not be fair to say that it probably came from the region between Venner and Brown's shots, or within a few yards either side? — I would certainly limit it to three ; if it did not come out of No. 1, I would limit it to three.

5,698. You would limit it to the region comprised by the curve — the No. 1 shaft and eastward to Venner's shot? — Yes, I think I would.

5,699. Westward of Venner's shot? — Yes, I think I should.

5,700. South of the Polka turn, did you see any indication of a burning — anything whatever? — No, I did not ; there was little there to burn; there was no hay there.

5,701. (The Coroner.) Give the answer first, and then an explanation afterwards? — I said, "No."

5,702. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Perhaps to get that clear on the note, I ought to ask another supplementary question. Assuming the Polka turn to have been the centre from which the explosion radiated, the result then is that on the southward radius there was no burning whatever; on the whole of the northward radius, for a long distance, there was burning? — Yes; because there were things there to burn.

The witness withdrew.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print