1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
Seaham Colliery Inquest, 6th January 1881 (cont.).
Mr. George Turnbull sworn.
5,703. (Mr. Edge.) How many years have you acted as underviewer at Seaham colliery? — Five years.
5,704. What are your duties as underviewer? — To see that the instructions of the manager are carried out.
5,706. On the morning of the 7th of September, I think, you went down No. 3 pit? — I did.
5,706. What time? — About six o'clock.
5,707. Did you meet Weatherley, the overman then? — Yes.
5,708. What did you and he do? — We went round the south way of the Hutton seam in No. 3 pit.
5,709. Just point out on the plan where No. 3 is. (The witness pointed out the place on the plan). Did you and Weatherley examine all the workings round that district and the edges of the goaf? — Yes.
5,710. Did you find any signs of gas there? — Not a little bit.
5,711. Or anything wrong with the ventilation? — Nothing wrong at all.
5,712. How did you come out from that district? — We come out the west side of the return along the goaf edges.
5,713. And then came to the coal staple? — To the coal staple again.
5,714. And went to bank? — And went to bank after that.
5,715. What time did you come up in the morning? — Nine o'clock, I believe.
5,716. Is it part of your duty to see the overman of the mine, and the master wasteman, and the engineer every day? — Yes.
5,717. And to receive their reports? — Yes.
5,718. On that afternoon of the 7th September did you meet the overman, and master wasteman? — Yes.
5,719. And you received their reports? — Yes.
5,720. Was there anything in either of their reports which would lead you think there was anything wrong in the ventilation of the mine? — Nothing.
5,721. Or any accumulation of gas? — No.
(Mr. R. S. Wright.) It is not suggested.
5,722. (Mr. Edge.) I think on the night of the explosion you went down No. 3 shaft? — I did.
5,723. And you were engaged with other men in the exploration of the mine? — Yes.
(Mr. Edge.) I do not propose to take him over what was done to recover the bodies.
(The Coroner.) No, unless Mr. Jones wishes to go through it.
5,724. (Mr. Edge to the witness.) I will take you to the No. 1 and No. 2 shaft bottoms, and I will start with you in there, along No. 1 Hutton engine plane. What indications did you see at the bottom of the shafts? — Beginning at No. 1, the lattice work at the pit bottom was blown to the north — the south side of No. 1 shaft.
5,725. I will take you on up the engine plane. What happened at the pit's mouth might not be much indication, so we will get along into the engine plane. Did you notice where the dock is, as they call it? — The Maudlin dock, do you mean?
5,726. No, between the shaft and the over-cast? — Yes, here (pointing).
5,727. Did you notice anything in connection with the wagons? — There were some blown all to pieces.
5,728. Did you find anything connected with the wagons which would tell you which way the force had come? — My opinion is that it came "out over," with the force it came to the shaft.
5,729. Did you see Dodgin? — I cannot say I saw him, but I knew where he was lying.
5,730. You did not see him? — I did not see him exactly, I only saw a portion of him.
5,731. Do you know where the arch ends? — Yes.
5,732. Did you notice anything there? — I know things were blown away.
5,733. Did you notice which way they were blown? — Yes, the air-crossing was blown out-bye; bricks were blown out-bye from this place (pointing).
5,734. Do you know where they were blown? — Blown out-bye, and right and left too.
5,736. They were blown right and left of the return and out-bye? — Yes.
5,736. What was the next indication you saw — Here (pointing), on the road.
(The Coroner.) Do you not think if he went along the road himself and pointed out what he did see, and what it indicated, you would get through faster?
5,737. (Mr. Edge.) Very well. (To Witness.) You go through that road and describe what you saw as you go along? — These boards had been on fire, between 40 and 50 yards on, some were lying there. Coming down to the Polka, there was a fall here, and my opinion is of that fall, that the indications were out-bye, because the in-bye was clean, and a little blast had gone against it. Then, coming from that fall, I fell in with a block of coal near a refuge hole, which had been blown from the innermost corner of the refuge hole.
5,738. How was that blown in? — That was blown to the north out-bye. Then coming into the Polka, there was a division there again, and round this curve, three feet of a wheel was shifted in-bye.
5,739. (The Coroner.) How far beyond the Polka turn? — That is the Polka turn.
5,740. It is on the Polka turn? — Yes, it is on the polka turn. Then I come here (pointing). There was a great deal of eruption there — tubs were blown out, and the winch shifted eight or ten yards, and a wheel blown fifteen yards, I think.
5,741. (Mr. Edge.) Did you notice what happened to the winch? — The winch was broken.
5,742. How was that fastened? — Fastened to the roof with a prop.
5,743. Was that blown away from the place where it had been? — It was blown away.
5,744. (The Coroner.) In-bye or out-bye? — In-bye.
5,745. (Mr. Edge.) Have you any opinion what weight that winch was? — I would not like to say the weight. The pressure of the bottom and the tub on it would make it heavier you could not calculate on the weight of that, it was fixed in the roof and the bottom.
5,746. How was that fastened — was it fastened firmly? — It was fastened firmly in the top and the bottom — it was upright.
5,747. And was blown out of those fastenings? — Blown away.
5,748. There is one point you passed over, that is where the second in-take takes off from the engine plane ; did you notice anything there — there was a wall? — There was a wall — an air gate. That air gate was blown the west side into the in-take and outwards, and the east side one was blown outwards.
5,749. Blown out-bye? — Yes.
5,760. Is there any other indication that strikes your mind that you saw there in that region? — In No. 1?
5,761. Yes, in No. 1? — No; my opinion is that it started there somehow or other, but I do not know how.
5,762. Then we will go round the place to Venner's shot; do you know where Venner's shot was — did you see that refuge hole that Venner had been working at? — Yes.
5,753. I mean after the explosion? — After the explosion.
5,764. What state was it in — had any of the stuff been taken out or removed? — I believe there had been some taken away, but not much.
5,756. Do you know where Rawlings' body was found? — Robert Rawlings?
5,756. Yes? — There (pointing), opposite Venner's shot.
5,757. Opposite that stow-hole? — Yes; that stow hole.
5,758. Is that the place where Rawlings would have been if they were about to fire a shot? — I think not.
5,759. (The Coroner.) If he had been there when a shot was fired, what would have been the result? — He would have been shot.
(The Coroner.) Was he knocked to pieces or not?
(Mr. Edge.) No.
(The Witness.) He would not stop in there if it was going to be fired.
5,760. Coming towards Nos. 1 and 2 shafts from Venner's, go along the main intake, there, and describe to us what indications you saw? — That air working there was blown right and left and to the west. There was a confusion here again of tubs of some kind or other ; I do not know what it was, but there was a complete confusion there of tubs blown out.
5,761. Where is that? — Between the crossing and this junction here.
We want to get a name for that junction ; that is where the road goes into No. 3 pit.
(Mr. R. S. Wright.) The first junction to the east of the crossing.
(The Witness.) The in-take, and the standage, and the air-crossing.
5,762. (Mr. Edge.) The tubs were there? — Yes; all up together. Then the Maudlin return wheel stood there (pointing), and a portion of that was blown in-bye over about three feet or something of that; three or four feet of wheel was blown away. Coming out-bye to the Maudlin dock, it appeared to me as if the force had gone westward and blown the wheel in a westerly direction and gone against the tubs, and the tubs were blown westward of the dock.
5,763. The tubs that stood in the dock and the Maudlin wheel were blown westward? — Yes; the hot water receiver was blown westward, bulged in from the east side.
5,764. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) The pressure gauge, do you mean? — No ; the cistern that the water was in.
5,765. (Mr. Edge.) What else did you see there? Coming down here to the curve a single rope was blown upon the frail rope.
5,766. That is the rapper rope? — The rapper rope.
5,767. Did you notice whether these coils had been stopped by the tail rope? — When they came in contact with the tail rope sheave they stopped these.
5,768. Did you find that eastward as well as westward, and where Brown's shot was? — Below Brown's shot.
5,769. On No. 1 side or No. 3 side? — No. 1 side, going westward; the indications that I saw there were all westward from the curve to the Maudlin engine.
5,770. Did you notice sheaves where the engine plane of the Maudlin is? — Yes.
5,771. What did you notice about them? — The timber of that sheave was blown westwards. I think the blast came round the curve and caught the timber, and it was blown that way as it came out of the curve.
5,772. In the Maudlin did you notice the staples and chains? — The staples?
5,773. Yes? — I know the staples were blown in-bye.
5,774. What was the condition of that road in the engine plane between the curve and the Maudlin travelling way? — From there (pointing) nearly all the way was clear — about 40 yards.
5,776. What was the condition of the travelling way of the Maudlin the other end of the Maudlin curve? — From there (pointing) there was no fall.
5,776. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) About half way from the curve along the travelling way you say was clear, do you? — Yes.
5,777. That is in the travelling way into the Maudlin? — Yes.
5,778. (Mr. Edge.) That portion which had not fallen was a stone roof, was it not? — An arch.
5,779. I mean on the travelling way? — Stone.
5,780. And the other half that had fallen? — It was going through the hitch, and the strata was very bad there.
5,781. Was there timber? — Yes, timber was blown out.
5,782. Would that lead you to the conclusion that the blast had gone into the Maudlin? — Yes.
5,783. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) I rather gather (if I am wrong you will tell me) that your impression is that the blast came into the No. 1 Hutton and not out of it? — No.
5,784. Which do you think? — It came in from the Polka, but not from the shaft.
5,785. You think so? — Yes.
5,786. If it did not begin there, the most likely place, according to your evidence, at any rate, is that it was somewhere about where Brown's shot is — is that so? — Yes.
5,787. You said all the way from the curve westward was blown in that direction westward? — Yes.
5,788. And that from the curve towards Maudlin was all blown towards the Maudlin? — Yes; that is the way along this curve. I say it was down this curve in No. 1.
5,789. And then, if it did not begin in the No. 1, do you think it began about the Brown's shot, or where? — No.
5,790. (The Coroner.) You pointed to a place where it was? — I would take it to be at that one (pointing).
5,790a. What place is that?
5,791. (Mr. Wright.) Venner's shot? — Yes; they were the two most likely places that I know.
(Mr. Edge.) Does he mean the actual position of Venner's shot?
(Mr. Wright.) He does not pin himself to that; he means somewhere about Venner's shot.
(The Witness.) Yes.
(Mr. Wright.) He does not mean exactly at the place where Venner's shot was.
5,792. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) I do not ask you anything more than this. I will ask you generally if there is anything that you have not been asked that you can tell me about that will throw any light upon this? — I think you have got to know everything that I know about.
5,793. I am sure we have got to know everything we ought to know. Who is the oldest person who knows most about this colliery? Who is the person who has been longest acquainted with the colliery in the neighbourhood of the shafts? — there is an old man I saw yesterday; he knows as much about it as any man. There is another old man called Richard Turnbull ; I think he knows most about it.
5,794. What is he? — He is working shift work.
5,795. (Mr. Bell.) Just go to the Geordie bank there. The air passes backwards and forwards between the two points there, as I understand, from the No. 1 and No. 3 furnaces? — Yes.
5,796. It can either go from the east away to the No. 1 furnace, or from the Maudlin way. It can pass that way and go to No. 3 furnace? — No; the No. 2 Hutton here.
5,797. The No. 2 Hutton — it can pass either way there? — Yes.
5,798. Have you ever seen any bit of gas there? — No.
5,799. Not in the Geordie bank? — No.
5,800. Or in that drift passing towards the large fault? — No.
5,801. Has there ever been any gas seen in that? — Never to my knowledge, and I have known it for many years.
5,802. (The Coroner.) Have you ever seen it blowing there? — No.
5,803. (Mr. A. Jones.) You went down No. 1 intake, and you came across a tub drawn by a pony? — Yes; away from the No. 1 shaft, about 50 yards or 60 yards, I think.
5,804. How far down the in-take was that? — It was 60 yards.
5,805. Sixty yards? — Yes; somewhere about that.
5,806. Which way was it travelling, or was it travelling? — Well, it ought to be travelling in-bye. I do not know which way it was travelling at the time.
5,807. It ought to have been travelling? — It ought to have been travelling. It was hung on for that purpose.
5,808. It was hung on in-bye? — Yes.
5,809. What did you come across first? — After that?
5,810. No; I am speaking of the tub and the pony. What did you come across first? — The tub and the pony.
5,811. No; did you come across the tub first? — Certainly. The tub was before the pony on going in, and the pony was lying there, and the tub was outside of it.
5,812. Was the tub broken? — Well, I expect it was. I dare not swear it was broken, and I dare not swear it was not.
5,813. You mean to say you cannot swear whether it was or not? — No.
5,814. I am speaking of the tub to which the pony was attached? — That particular tub I cannot say.
5,815. Did you see where the pony was? — Yes.
5,816. Where was he lying — how far off the tub? — Two or three yards off.
5,817. Away? — Northwards.
5,818. Northward? — Well in-bye.
5,819. Southward? — Yes, southward in-bye.
5,820. It was lying two or three yards in-bye off the tub? — Off the tub.
5,821. Did you see the gearing on the pony? — I believe the gears were on him.
5,822. And how had the pony been taken away from the tub? — That I cannot tell you.
5,823. Were the traces broken, or what? — How was it fastened, by a chain? — I cannot say. They were not together; that is all I can say.
5,824. Did you notice the condition of the pony, whether it was mangled at all? — It was lying parallel with the road, I think.
5,825. But was it mangled or torn? — No.
5,826. It was not? — No.
5,827. How do you suppose the explosion came from the Polka way? How do you account for the pony being in that position? — I cannot tell that.
5,828. Would not that to your mind indicate that the blast had come in-bye? — No.
5,829. Why not? — It would not do that either.
5,830; Why not? — Because there are several things while the blast is going by.
5,831. I am wishing you to direct your attention to the pony and tub alone? — Well, I cannot say that.
5,832. Apart from anything else, what would that indicate to your mind? — I know the tubs were blown out.
5,833. Apart from anything to which you may have had your attention directed, what would the fact of the pony being separated from the tub some distance inbye indicate to your mind? — It would indicate that tub had been disconnected from the pony by the blast, and blown up. The blast coming out-bye would dash the pony from the tub.
5,834. Would dash the pony from the tub? — Yes, coming out-bye it would do that.
5,835. But would that remove the pony from the tub some distance? — It might do. The tub might go from the pony.
5,836. The tub might go from the pony? — Yes, I think that would be more likely, and I believe it did do that too.
5,837. Do you really mean that the blast travelling out-bye would blow the tub away from the pony, and not blow the pony along? Do you really mean that Mr. Turnbull? — It might possibly be.
5,838. Very well. That is your explanation? — The pony is standing facing the blast.
5,839. You believe it would remove the tub and break the traces and connections, and at the same time not move the pony? — I do not say it would not move the pony. I do not know where the pony was standing, you know.
5,840. Did you notice the timbers in No. 2 Hutton? — Yes.
5,840a. Intake? — Yes.
5,841. As you went down? — Yes.
5,842. You noticed them? — Yes.
5,843. Particularly? — Yes.
5,844. Did you notice in what direction they were lying? — Out-bye over.
5,845. What timbers are you referring to now when you say they were blown out-bye? — The timber belonging to the tail rope sheaves.
(The Coroner.) Was there any timber standing?
(Mr. A. Jones.) I was not referring to that.
5,846. I thought you would understand what I meant by "timbers." I meant the timbers, of course, that supported the roof? — There were two blown out.
5,847. You saw those blown out? — Yes, I saw those blown out.
5,848. Of course, we have heard what others have said, but will you state in what direction, according to your judgment, they were lying? — Out-bye over.
5,849. Are you sure of that? — Yes, that is my opinion.
5,850. Your opinion! But did you notice or did you not notice? — Certainly. If I had not noticed the thing how could I have got the opinion.
5,851. A fact is not a question of opinion. I was asking you whether you could speak as a fact or not as to the direction? — I am coming here to speak to nothing but facts, so far as I know. I am not come here to tell a lie.
5,852. Just answer the question, and tell me this definitely, as far as your memory serves you, in what direction were these timbers lying — these two props, which you say you saw blown out? — Two props. I never mentioned two props yet.
5,863. What timbers did you mention? — I never mentioned two props.
5,854. You decidedly said two. But let us have what you said? — Sheaves standing.
5,855. That was first? — And timber afterwards.
5,856. I ask you whether you ever saw any timber supports or props blown out by the force of the explosion? — Yes, I did.
5,857. How many? — That I cannot remember.
5,858. Did you not say two? — No, I did not.
5,859. (The Coroner.) A good many more than two, were not there? — Never mind how many.
5,860. (Mr. A. Jones.) Never mind how many. In what direction were they lying? — Out-bye over.
5,861. That you are sure of? — Yes.
5,862. Before you come to the Polka turn, after you pass the stables, did you come to a fall? — Yes.
5,863. Did you find the timber there? — I found timber underneath the fall.
5,864. Did you see any props there? — There were props there to be seen.
5,865. Did you see them? — I did.
5,866. You did? — Yes.
5,867. Can you tell me in what direction, according to the best of your judgement, those props were blown? — No, I cannot.
5,868. You can form no opinion? — No, I do not believe any one can, as to how they were blown.
5,869. On the in-bye side of this large fall, did you see a baulk of timber — a large baulk of timber? — There were several baulks of timber. I cannot point out one.
5,870. Did you notice one particularly large baulk of timber? — There is large timber, and I have not made a mark of one particular one. I know there is large timber, but I am not going to swear I made a mark as to any particular one.
5,871. I mean a baulk of timber which was lying clear of the fall? — There was none whatever.
5,872. Did you see one baulk of timber which was lying clear of the fall? — I saw one.
5,873. Did you see several lying together? — Yes.
5,874. Several lying there? — Yes.
5,875. Did they afford any indication as to the way in which they had been blown? — They did not afford much.
5,876. You say not much? — No.
5,877. Did you draw any inference? — No, not by them.
5,878. Which way did they appear to have been blown? — I cannot say.
5,879. Do you say you are totally without the means of forming any judgment? — Yes. I could not tell.
5,880. (The Coroner.) In going in-bye there would be no timber standing? — Yes, there would be the sheave beams.
5,881. Did you notice whether there was dust upon the timber? — Well, there was. I do not say there was not dust, because there was dust upon all the timber.
5,882. Had there been any clearance of the dust upon this standing timber when you were going along? — When I was going along, the timber was lying —
5,883. I am talking of the standing timbers? — The timbers were standing there. It was clean on this side and soot on this (describing).
5,884. Which side is this? Is this next the side? — Next the pit.
5,885. Is it on the out-bye side? — On the out-bye side.
5,886. There was soot on the out-bye side? — Yes, and clean on the in-bye side.
5,887. To what distance was that the case? — (The witness pointed on the plan).
5,888. The timber standing was clean and the dust on the outside? — No, the other way.
5,889. Clean on the in-bye? — Yes.
5,890. And the dust still remaining on the out-bye side? — Yes.
5,891. (Mr. A. Jones.) You heard what Mr. Stratton said with regard to the engine plane, leading from No. 3 Hutton to the Maudlin. Do you agree with what Mr. Stratton said with regard to the coal dust having operated as a conductor up the engine plane? — Yes, I believe it will do.
5,892. Do you believe it will do? — I believe it will do.
5,893. Do you believe it did? — Yes, I believe it did, and I believe it will do.
5,894. Did you ever in your experience know coal dust to act in that way? — No, I have not.
5,895. But why do you draw that conclusion? — Because it will burn — the dust.
5,896. But why do you believe that it will act as a conductor in the way Mr. Stratton suggested? — I have heard that it has caught alight at bank on the screens, and that it burnt one of the men on the pit heap.
5,897. (The Coroner.) You say the dust had caught alight — where? — At bank, on the screens.
5,898. (Mr. A. Jones.) What did it do? — It caught alight at the gas and burnt one of the men on the pit heap; and I believe it would burn down in the pit.
5,899. (The Coroner.) Where did it catch alight? — It caught at the gas.
5,900. Was that flying dust? — Yes.
5,901. It lighted at the gas? — Yes.
5,902. And then burnt one of the men who was standing on the pit heap? — Yes.
5,903. (Mr. Bell.) Did you notice in what way the doors were blown going into the No. 1 furnace? — Into the furnace.
5,904. They were blown into the furnace? — Yes, they were blown right up to the furnace.
5,905. (Mr. Edge.) You do not know whether the pony had been untackled from the tubs or not, I suppose? — I cannot swear to that; I only think he was.
(Mr. Edge.) I might ask Mr. Stratton that question here at once.
(The Coroner.) Is it so important?
(Mr. Edge.) I should hike to know what he says about it.